Making the Water Quality Connection:
Successes and Challenges of the outreach component to the Barnegat Bay Shellfish
Restoration Program
Cara Muscio, Gef Flimlin, and Rick BushnellInternational Conference for Shellfish Restoration
November 18, 2006
Our MissionIntegrating teaching, research, and outreach to anticipate andrespond to issues and challenges in agriculture, food systems,environment and natural resources, and human and communityhealth and development, in order to empower people to improvetheir lives, the lives of others, and the environments on which they depend.
Who We AreA partnership between Rutgers University and NJ Counties
Operating through The New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station
Barnegat Bay Shellfish Restoration Program
Goals of the BBSRP
To educate citizens about the Barnegat Bay, shellfish, water quality, and people – We’re all in this together!
• To grow up lots of shellfish to help improve water quality and clamming opportunities
• To have lots of fun in the process!
Education Program Goals• To establish meaningful connections between
shellfish, water quality, ecology, local culture, and human needs and actions
• To showcase a working model of environmental stewardship and the benefits to the environment and society
• Materials development, visual aides, fact sheets, fun information
• Clam Camp!• Fairs & Festivals• Workshops and field trips• Speakers Bureau – lectures• “What the Bay Hinges on” Minigrant Project
Education and Outreach Activities
Successful Training• 2005 class reported an increase in knowledge of 2
scale points (1-4; 4 high)• 86% of participants said information was valuable• 2006 pre and post tests (n=8) indicate a 25%
increase in score, from 7.69 to 10.31 (of 15 points)• 33% more students attempted answering essay
questions on post tests• 50% more students correctly answered: What is a
watershed? What watershed do you live in?
Challenge• Retaining volunteers/participants….• 79 people signed up in 2005, 70 in 2006• Less than 50% complete course • Less than that are actively participating• Many educators are failing to return….
• Need better communication – volunteers need to feel more involved in planning
Gaining Practical Experience• Volunteers have worked over 2308 hours in
two years • Volunteers have constructed structures,
measured, analyzed, cleaned, and cared for shellfish
• Volunteers have raised 1,200,000 clam seed and 600,000 oyster seed
Challenge• Small percentage of volunteers participating in
education activities– Retired engineers and business people– Lack of confidence in outreach abilities– Perceived lack of adequate expertise– They may be skeptical of an idea– Lack of established program/direction:
• chicken and egg situation
Materials Development• An article written by members• Poster Display at Upwellers• Bumper Stickers• Model Upweller
Challenge• Need more materials to give
out in outreach applications• Water quality education is
the GOAL…– Volunteers focus on clams– “this takes up a lot of room…
can we take it out?”
Clam Camp• Pilot at St. Francis Center on Long Beach
Island• Six one-hour sessions during summer camp• Over 50 kids educated by seven BBSRP’ers• 5-8 year olds (n=20) learned “a lot” (2.6 on 1-3
scale;3 high)• 96% of 5-8 year olds and 56% of 9-13 year
olds indicated they wanted to learn more
Challenge
• TIME INTENSIVE!• Little help in development• Volunteer availability changes• Difficulty getting volunteers to review or
prepare for lessons• Working with 40 kids and two people
1 2 3
4
5
6
7 8
9 10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17 18
Created with EclipseCrossword — www.eclipsecrossword.com
C
SCALLOP
W
A
N
D
O
D
STARFISH
H
U
C
E
H
A
C
O
P
PREDATOR
T
N
R
L
D
D
OYSTER DRILL
A
R
U
Y
F
P
C
M
Q
I
T
L
E
HUMANS
A
A
GREEN
A
H
T
M
U
H
I
L
CONCH
O
L
G
KNOBBED
L U
PRODUCER
Across 2. The powerful muscles that keep bivalve shells closed 4. This common shorebird eats shellfish as well as human food 5. An organism that cannot make its own food, and must eat other organisms for energy 6. An organism that is food for other organisms 7. This blunt headed Ray can make a mess of a clam bed 11. Another name for the Hard clam, from "poquauhock" in Native American 14. Word describing a shelled animal that lives in water, especially if edible 16. A feature of an organism that helps it to survive 17. The most important shellfish species in New Jersey 18. This famous local crab eats shellfish, as well as being an important food source itself
Down 1. Shellfish known by its wavy shell 3. So called because it bores tiny holes into shellfish 4. Major crustacean enemy of shellfish and shellfish growers 8. Predator of Shellfish, radially symmetrical 9. Perhaps the biggest predators of shellfish, harvest in large numbers 10. Another name for the Whelk 12. An organism that lives by eating other organisms 13. An organism that makes its own food 15. This whelk is the state shell of NJ
Fairs and Festivals• Dozens of annual festivals focusing on seafood and the
environment• Repeated attempts to gather crews to exhibit at fairs• Less than 5 people signed up for events, several never returned• Last minute heavy recruitment allowed two displays:
– Chowderfest 2006– Duck and Decoy Show 2006
• Where 4 or 5 volunteers did entire weekends worth of shifts
Other Educational Programs• No formalized “field trip experience” or site
yet developed• However, some Marine Academy (HS)
students are beginning upweller research
• Speakers Bureau not yet developed• Lack of development or lack of interest?
What the Bay HINGES on…• Printed booklet and CD of lessons, activities, and
visual materials• Target grades 4-8, adaptable to all educational
settings, including volunteer use in outreach• Covers: Shellfish biology, ecology and food webs,
water quality and classifications, local maritime history, economics and food production, seafood advisories and nutrition, and environmental stewardship
Goals of the guide• Students should be able to describe how shellfish fit in to the tree of all organisms• Students should be able to identify the parts of a mollusk, and explain how a clam and
snail are different.• Students should be able to understand what place shellfish have in the food chain, and
how they grow, feed and reproduce• Students should be able to label all parts of the water cycle, and understand the way in
which water moves over the earth. • Students should be able to define a watershed, and identify what watershed they live
in.• Students should be able to understand the role of shellfish in water, what kind of water
shellfish live in, and their ecological role.• Students should be able to define point and non point pollution and identify sources.• Students should be able to identify actions that impact their watersheds.• Students should understand how shellfish aquaculture works and why it is necessary.
Visual Aides/Activities
Bioaccumulation F
The Big Ass Clam• Public Art AND education• Tourism map listing all clam locations• An educational fact on each clam• How about a Scavenger Hunt!!!• Log on and take the quiz, sign the guestbook,
tell us what you learned!
•Many volunteers were skeptical of this idea and whether it was good use for our funds…but they are coming around
How do we improve?• Do we require education/outreach participation of
each volunteer?– One 2 hour shift at a festival or fair– Clam Camp/Speakers Bureau/Materials development
• Should we seek out more teachers? – Volunteers VOLUNTEER to do what they enjoy!
• How can we make other volunteers value the outreach component of the program?
Although there are challenges:
• We have the growing pains of any new organization:– Volunteer retention and investment level– Volunteers respond best when its “their” idea– Chicken and Egg situation of development vs.
interest– Need to cultivate interest in education/outreach
aspect of program
The Balance shows…• The BBSRP is a success!!!
– Core group of dedicated volunteers– Great Press– Funding Support– Raising Awareness– People are Learning new ideas and skills
Acknowledgements
Funding provided by:
In the end - we will conserve only what we love,
we will love only what we understand,and we will understand only what we are
taught. - Baba Dioum, Senegelese
Conservationist
