Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document 30 Filed 07/21/17 Page 1 of 2 · Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document...

Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document 30 Filed 07/21/17 Page 1 of 2

Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document 30 Filed 07/21/17 Page 2 of 2

EXHIBIT A

Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document 30-1 Filed 07/21/17 Page 1 of 5

7/21/2017 The New York Times Editorial Board - Interactive Feature - NYTimes.com

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/opinion/editorialboard.html 1/4

Search All NYTimes.com

The New York Times Editorial BoardThe editorial board is composed of 16 journalists with wide-ranging areas of expertise. Their

primary responsibility is to write The Times’s editorials, which represent the voice of the board, its

editor and the publisher. The board is part of The Times’s editorial department, which is operated

separately from The Times’s newsroom, and includes the Letters to the Editor and Op-Ed

sections.

TAKING NOTE »The Editorial Board’s Blog

FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ EMAIL SHAREUPDATED June 12, 2017

HOME PAGE TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR

WORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTATE AUTOS

@JBennet

James Bennet, Editorial Page Editor

James Bennet, the editorial page editor of The New York Times, is in charge of theOpinion department. He oversees the editorial board and the Letters and Op-Edsections.

Mr. Bennet became editorial page editor in May 2016. Before this role, Mr. Bennetwas the president and editor in chief of The Atlantic. Under Mr. Bennet, who wasnamed editor in 2006, The Atlantic substantially increased its editorial reach andimpact while returning to profitability for the first time in recent history. Adweeknamed Mr. Bennet editor of the year in 2012 and Ad Age did the same in 2009.The Atlantic was honored with the National Magazine Award four times duringhis tenure, including Magazine of the Year and best website, for TheAtlantic.com.

Before joining The Atlantic, Mr. Bennet worked for The Times for 15 years inseveral roles, including Detroit bureau chief, White House correspondent andJerusalem bureau chief. He also served as a staff writer for The Sunday Magazine.Before joining the Times, Mr. Bennet was an editor with The WashingtonMonthly. He and his wife have two sons.

Robert B. Semple Jr., Associate Editor

Robert Semple joined the Washington Bureau of The Times in the fall of 1963. Hecovered housing and civil rights during the Johnson administration, spent a yearcovering President Johnson himself, and served as White House correspondentduring Richard Nixon's first term. He served thereafter as deputy national editor(1973-75), London bureau chief (1975-77), foreign editor (1977-82), editor of theOp-Ed Page (1982-88) and associate editor of the Editorial Page (1988 topresent). He received the Pulitzer Prize in 1996 for his editorials onenvironmental issues.

Mr. Semple was born in St. Louis, raised in Michigan and educated at Andover,Yale and the University of California, where he received a master's degree inhistory in 1961.

James Bennet

Editorial Page Editor

Robert B. Semple Jr.

Associate Editor

Linda Cohn

Editor

Nick Fox

Editor

Vikas Bajaj

Business, International

Economics

Francis X. Clines

National Politics, Congress,

Campaign Finance

Lawrence Downes

New York City, Immigration

Carol Giacomo

Foreign Affairs

Mira Kamdar

International Affairs

Serge Schmemann

International Affairs

Brent Staples

Education, Criminal Justice,

Economics

Teresa Tritch

Economic Issues, Tax Policy

Jesse Wegman

The Supreme Court, Legal

Affairs

Elizabeth Williamson

Congress, National Politics

Log In Register Now HelpU.S. Edition




Linda Cohn, Editor

Linda Cohn has been an editor at the Times editorial page since 1988, beating thearrival of the Internet by years. She has worked with Op-Ed columnists, mostrecently Paul Krugman and Ross Douthat but also William Safire, Tom Wickerand Anthony Lewis. She has also been an editor for the Sunday Business section. Linda grew up in Belleville, Ill., and graduated from Washington University in St.Louis.

Nick Fox, Editor

Nick Fox has been an editor at The Times since 1995, having previously worked asthe assignment editor on the National desk, in the Dining section and with theonline opinion forum Room for Debate. He previously worked for Newsday andThe Bergen Record. He has a B.A. from Binghamton University and an M.A. fromthe Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism.

@vikasbajaj

Vikas Bajaj, Business, International Economics

Vikas Bajaj has worked at The New York Times since 2005. Before joining theeditorial board in 2012, he was a correspondent based in Mumbai, India. Hepreviously covered housing and financial markets for the Business section in NewYork. Born in Mumbai, Mr. Bajaj grew up there and in Bangkok, and he received abachelor’s in journalism from Michigan State University. He came to The Timesfrom The Dallas Morning News.

Francis X. Clines, National Politics, Congress, Campaign Finance

Before joining the editorial board in 2002, Francis X. Clines spent 40 years as areporter for The Times on the city, national and foreign news staffs. Hisassignments ranged from City Hall to Appalachia, from Ireland to Uzbekistan,from the Reagan White House to Communism's last stand in the Kremlin. Born inBrooklyn, N.Y., he won the Meyer Berger Award for his "About New York"columns, as well as a Polk Award for coverage of the collapse of the Soviet Union.

@lawrencedownes

Lawrence Downes, New York City, Immigration

Lawrence Downes, who joined the editorial board in 2004, has worked for TheNew York Times since 1993. He served on the National desk as enterprise editorand as deputy political editor during the 2000 presidential campaign. From 1998to 2000, Mr. Downes was a weekend editor on the Metro desk and, before that,deputy weekend editor and copy editor. Mr. Downes was a copy editor at Newsdayfrom 1992 to 1993 and at the Chicago Sun-Times from 1989 to 1992. Mr. Downesreceived a B.A. degree in English from Fordham University in 1986. He alsoattended the University of Missouri School of Journalism from 1987 to 1989.




@giacomonyt

Carol Giacomo, Foreign Affairs

Carol Giacomo, a former diplomatic correspondent for Reuters in Washington,covered foreign policy for the international wire service for more than twodecades before joining The Times editorial board in August 2007. In her previousposition, she traveled over 1 million miles to more than 100 countries with eightsecretaries of state and various other senior U.S. officials. In 2009, she won theGeorgetown University Weintal Prize for diplomatic reporting. She is a member ofthe Council on Foreign Relations. In 1999-2000, she was a senior fellow at theU.S. Institute of Peace, researching U.S. economic and foreign policy decision-making during the Asian financial crisis. She was a Ferris professor of journalismat Princeton University in 2013 and has been a guest lecturer at the U.S. NationalWar College, among other academic institutions. Born and raised in Connecticut,she holds a B.A. in English Literature from Regis College, Weston, Mass. Shebegan her professional journalism career at the Lowell Sun in Lowell, Mass., andlater worked for the Hartford Courant in the city hall, state capitol andWashington bureaus.

@mirakamdar

Mira Kamdar, International Affairs

Mira Kamdar lives in Paris and is a faculty member at the École de Journalisme atSciences Po. She teaches in the master's program jointly managed with the ParisSchool of International Affairs. She is the author of "Planet India: the TurbulentRise of the Largest Democracy" and "Motiba’s Tattoos: A Granddaughter’sJourney Into her Indian Family’s Past." She has been a senior fellow at the WorldPolicy Institute and an associate fellow at the Asia Society in New York. Ms.Kamdar has written for many publications, including The Washington Post,Foreign Affairs, Foreign Policy, The Caravan (New Delhi), Le MondeDiplomatique, Courrier International and The New York Times's India Ink blog.She has a bachelor's degree from Reed College in Portland, Ore., and a Ph.D. inFrench literature from the University of California, Berkeley.

Serge Schmemann, International Affairs

Serge Schmemann joined the Times in 1980. He served as the editorial pageeditor of the International Herald Tribune in Paris from 2003 to 2013. He hasbeen a Times correspondent and bureau chief in Moscow, Bonn, Jerusalem andthe United Nations. He served as the deputy foreign editor in New York from 1999to 2001. Mr. Schmemann received the Pulitzer Prize in 1991 for coverage of thereunification of Germany, and an Emmy in 2003 for his work on a televisiondocumentary about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He was previously a reporterwith the Associated Press. Mr. Schmemann is a graduate of Harvard College andholds an M.A. from Columbia University, as well as an honorary doctorate fromMiddlebury College. He was born in Paris, is married and has three children.

@BrentNYT

Brent Staples, Education, Criminal Justice, Economics

Brent Staples joined The Times editorial board in 1990. His editorials and essaysare included in dozens of college readers throughout the United States andabroad. Before joining the editorial page, he served as an editor of The New YorkTimes Book Review and an assistant editor for metropolitan news. Mr. Staplesholds a Ph.D. in psychology from the University of Chicago and is author of




All photos by Fred R. Conrad/The New York Times

© 2017 The New York Times Company Site Map Privacy Your Ad Choices Advertise Terms of Sale Terms of Service Work With Us RSS Help Contact Us Site Feedback

"Parallel Time," a memoir, which was a finalist for the Los Angeles Times BookPrize and winner of the Anisfield-Wolf Book Award.

Teresa Tritch, Economic Issues, Tax Policy

Before joining the editorial board in 2004, Teresa Tritch spent 12 years at Moneymagazine, as a staff writer, Washington, D.C., bureau chief and senior editor,covering politics, finance and taxes. She has also been a contributing editor for theStanford Social Innovation Review, covering nonprofits, and for the GallupManagement Journal, covering workplace issues, as well as co-editor of a book onIraq, "America at War," a joint project of CBS and Simon and Schuster. Ms.Tritch, a Los Angeles native, holds a B.A. in German from UCLA and an M.S. inJournalism from Columbia University. In 2000, she was a Knight-Bagehot fellowin Business and Economics Journalism at Columbia.

@jessewegman

Jesse Wegman, The Supreme Court, Legal Affairs

Jesse Wegman joined the editorial board in 2013. He was previously a senioreditor at The Daily Beast and Newsweek, a legal news editor at Reuters, and themanaging editor of The New York Observer. In 2010, he received a Soros JusticeFellowship to write a book about jailhouse lawyers. He graduated from New YorkUniversity School of Law in 2005. Before that, he was a producer and reporter forseveral National Public Radio programs.

@NYTLiz

Elizabeth Williamson, Congress, National Politics

Before joining The New York Times, Elizabeth Williamson was a reporter on TheWall Street Journal’s Washington, D.C.-based special projects team, writingfeatures about national politics and the culture of Washington. At the beginning ofthe Obama administration she covered the White House, focusing on theadministration’s relationship with the business community. She also has coveredseveral congressional and presidential races, writing newsmaker profiles; featuresthat shed light on how U.S. politics have evolved, for better and worse; and storiesabout the odd but illuminating quirks of modern campaigns and candidates.Before joining The Journal in February 2008, Ms. Williamson worked for TheWashington Post from 2003. She has covered the federal government, Congress,consumer product safety as well as the response to Hurricane Katrina and federalgovernment contracting problems. Ms. Williamson began her journalism career asa foreign correspondent in 1994. From 1994 to 2003 she worked as a freelancejournalist from the Balkans, Russia, the Baltic nations and broader EasternEurope. Her work appeared in The Wall Street Journal, International HeraldTribune, Chicago Tribune, Miami Herald and other publications. In 2000 she washired by The Wall Street Journal as its Warsaw bureau chief, covering Poland andsurrounding countries. Ms. Williamson received a bachelor’s degree in journalismfrom Marquette University. She was born in Chicago and resides in Washington,D.C.


EXHIBIT B


EXHIBIT 3


Q

(~ _________ s_Jg_n_u_P __________ ~) ( Login ) ------------------------~

NYT Politics . @nvtpol!tics

Fact Check: Partisans falsely blamed Loretta Lynch, Tim Kaine,

Bernie Sanders for Wednesday's Virginia shooting.

nytuns/2subsd9

11:00 PM· J m15, 2017

19 Retwee• , 20 Likes

0 t.1

GAB Am•rican lilli. @.GuardArnerican 4!1

Replying to .§>nytpohtics

Ahem:

0

Wns this attack C\~dencc of how vicious American politics has become? Probably. In 2011, when Jared Lee Loughner opened fire in a supermarket parking lot, grievously wounding Representative Gabby Giffords nnd killing six people including a 9-rcar-old stir! the link to political incitcmrot was

clear. Before the shooting, Sarah Palin's political action cummittce ~a map of targeted clcctoral district9 that put Ms. Giffords and 19

other DelllOCI".J.Is wulcr 6tylized cross hairs.

Conservatives and right-wing media were quick on ·wednesday to •icmand forceful condl'mnatlon of hate speech and crimes by anti-Trump liberals.

Tbctre right. Though there's no sign of incitement as direct as in the Glffords anaclc, blleral~ ~hould of course hold themselves to the same standard of dcccnC)' that they ask of the right.

U3

matt_s_pip @matt_s_pip 4h

Reply1rg to @nytpolttics

Blamed? ... o r pointed out inflammatory rhetoric and fund raising off a false narrative about Tucson shooting?

01 t.12 Q4

The Barbarian @Barbana lllnSF 1 h

v

v

In Lynch's case, we have her call for blood and death on the streets on VIDEO.

Ql U 1 \? 3

Document title: NYT Politics on Twitter: "Fact Check: Partisans falsely blamed Loretta Lynch, Tim Kaine, Bernie Sanders for Wednesday's Virginia shooting .. ..

Capture URL: https://mobile.twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304

Capture timestamp (UTC): Fri, 16 Jun 2017 17:17:44 GMT Page 1 of 8


Q

( ___________ s_,g_n_u_P ___________ ) /-\. __________ L_og __ in ___________ )

0 U4

1 more reply

VK @vjeannelc. 3h

Replytng to @nytpoltt iLs

\? 29

David Burge @l!oW<:thawkblog · 43m

The hardest part of working at the NYTimes and WaPo is having to hit yourself in the head with a hammer every morning to induce amnesia

0

t.+ ' .J

Patrick Moore @padd!mor

U 1 \?7

• . l

TRUMPLICAN!!!~ @HighRawMama 17h

Rep:yir.g to @nytpohtics Don't blame them as much as Madona, Griffin, Play in the park and media. Many liberals have said things they shouldn"t as well

Q n \?8

Dissident Biker @ DtssidentBtker ·t?h

Replytng to @nytpohttcs NYTimes fact checks are meaningless.

Q D \?4

Alamo Nation 'wAhm· _Natton lh Replytng to @nytpohtics

v

I'm blaming NYT, WaPo. CNN, MSNBC for the daily attemp1s at delegitimizing an administration just because their candida:e loss. It's on you.

Q D

Todd @TCttbby 4h

Replying to @nytpohtics

\?3

They a called for violence. Not a stretch at all.

Q n \?4

Scurrilous Dog @Scottymcmahon22 4h

Replymg to @nytpohtics Flip to your editorial page corrections

0 n Q3

v

Ender Wiggin @Sam_A_vtto 14h v

Replymg to @nytpoht ics Fact Check: @nyttmes simply makes shit up now. Sad from something that used to be a respected news source, now fi lled with Dem hacks.

Q n \?4

Burrrton @SeahawkBurrrton 17h

Replymg to @nytpohtics Who wants to link them to thetr Palin arttcle7

Q n \?4

Roy Platz <Yro;biken 23 18h

Replying to @nytpo htics Liberal like to think of themselves as a tolerant group ... they certainly i!rP not

Document title: NYT Politics on Twitter: "Fact Check: Partisans falsely blamed Loretta Lynch, Tim Kaine, Bernie Sanders for Wednesday's Virginia shooting ....

Capture URL: https:/ /mobile. twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304



Q (.-------------- ... \ Log in )

Liberal like to think of themselves as a tolerant group .•• they certainly are not.

0 n \74

Mama Kylee @: MdmaKylee 18h

Replymg to @ln~ttpohtics

Call me stupid but... l'd say it was the shooter's fault. ...

01 n \72

Deborah Gayou @1deserthottle

OK, ... Stupid!

n

SLGTexas @SLGTexas 1811

Replymg to @nytpohtics

Well I b lame ttump

01 n

\71

17h

Deborah Gayou @ 1 deserthott1e 17h

REALLY?! 70 is fa irly young for senility you display. POTUS has NOT ONCE called for DEATH of any1! NOT called for BEHEADING, STABBING any1 .

0 n \73

BucklnTennessee @BucklnTenne~see 2h


NY t1mes thinks all of Twitter has short term memory loss Jusi Yesterday' NYTimes b lamed Giffords shooting on Sarah Palin Whoops?

0 0.1 \72

Chris lillchnr.fndav1d 4h

Replyrng to @nytpolitics

v

v

v

You need a fact check your facts checkers there's evidence .JII-over the Internet of them inciting violence against the right. FAKE NEWS

0 n

Craig @KC11A18A 18h

Replymg to @n~ttpohtiCS

\72

don't forget Obama's ''they bring a knife we bring a gun"

0 n \72

TANSTAAFL @fANS1AAFL24 1h


The Virginia shooting was caused by climate of hate whipped up by reactionary left- fascist Democra sand the M SM.

Including YOU, @nyt1m es

n

DotG <~MoWm16 111 ~~t Replying to <Ynytpohtics

~ Fact Check: NYT is only usefu l in the bottom of a cat litter pan. TRUE

0 n \71

SwampCrazyElaine @Erunner11 0 4tl

0 n

CB @TexasCB 4h

Replying to '§.' nytpohtics

v

Document title: NYT Politics on Twitter: "Fact Check: Partisans falsely blamed Loretta Lynch, Tim Kaine , Bernie Sanders for Wednesday's Virginia shooting ....

Capture URL: https://mobile. twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304



Q

( ___________ s_•g_n_u_P ___________ ) /'-------------·-, \ Login j

.. 1i\ !!"'• ,,_ ., s

I:..D lg'IE'Xa$1...t' · "HI

Reply1ng to @nytpohtics

Do you read yam ovm editorial page? Because · false blaming" is what it does bes !

0

0 n

Craig @KC11A18A 4h


0 1 ... 4h

C/1

you don't read your own paper?

0 u C/1

r-

Archimedes Watts @arch!me>deswatts 17h


8 -!~

Fact check: partisans falsely cla im cheeseburgers taste better than pizza

(It's an opinion, clowns)

0

Antonio @Antonro9847 18h

R~i·:ing to @nytpolitics You forgot Pa lin too you d1shonest hacks.

Q ·n Q

Black Voices Muted :\jldog884 1 h

Replying to @nytpolit ics

Is America's under fund ing of public schools, and privat izin9 college for decades, contributing to extremism?

01 n

v

TANSTAAFL @.>TANSTAAFL24 1 h

Ummmmmmmmm .....

v

Well, that made no sense at a ll .

But keep trying, ok?

0 u (JI

Tall Man Short Hair (<ilTaiiManShort Bm

Replymg 10 @nytpohtics Shorter @NYTimes: ' We don't report the t ruth. we create it '

Q n Q

fossilady @Don na83529215 15m


it' s time the NYT became a cooking newsletter. All they do well is stir the pot.

0 n

, / RightWingHockeyCoach @DroppmThet,lins 29m

• • Replying to ~nytpohtic~ ...... ../ '\. Name one non-employee (or mom) that has ever accused even one of

your employees of having honor. honesty and integrity. You can't.

0 n

bob rod @a1bobbyr 30m

Rep lying to @nytpohtics

the NYT fact checking anything is a joke

0 t1 El


Capture U RL: https://mobile. twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304



Q

( SJgn up ) '--------- ----------~--i_n _________ )

e •

the NYT fact checking anyth ing is a joke

0 n

Ree Fungorio <llRe.:>Fungono 37m

Rep .ymg to @nytpolitics Fo r anyone wondering how this could be real: Yes, the @nytimes IS that goddamned ignorant.

0 n Q

Fred Nicolaysen @phred47 46m

Repljring to @nytpohtics

v

@clifflevy @deanbaqLJet What a shame you dropped Liz Spayd your public editor. Otherwise you wouldn't publish t his shit and I would subscribe

0

BBUTOPIA • MAGA~ @FormerFanatic · 56m

Replying to @nytpolitics This writer fo rgets we all have eyes and ears to witness this hateful retoric!

0 n

Class 10/06 ·~ aroleakwilson 111

Replymg to @nytpo htics

v

#yep sou nds about right they railed agamst guns and promoted hate

0 n

Suresh Karanam @sureshkaran 111 v

Replying to @nytpo lr t ics I don"t blame democrats for the shooting of GOP Reps. I blame the media 100%. Dems a re pretty helpless at this point. Media driving Dems

0 n

Rich Algeni, Jr. @nchalqenl 1 h

Replying to @nytpolitics

Asswipes at nyslimes have the gall to talk about blame?

0 n

Jim G>Wont!ornply 1h

Replying to @' nytpolitics

<-media with blood on its hands and lies in print. The toilet paper of record speaks.

0 n Q

Aaron Henager ~ AaronHenagerl 1h v

Rep!,'mg to <a: nytpo l: tic~

If you think this is bad, you should read the complete BS your editorial board wrote about the :tale andnashootmg

0 n

Ben Crystal a; Bennettruth

Replying to @nytpolitics

You guys are just sad now.

0 n

Big Ed ·§.: Fa!c~"'neddie 1 1 h

Repiymg to @nytpolitics

C? t::l

1t1

C?

For real? This coming from NYT? You people have ZERO self awareness.

n C?

v

~ "--....!--- a.t-L-..1 .. . .J .t • • -, ,


Capture U RL: https://mobile. twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304

Capture timestamp (UTC}: Fri, 16 Jun 2017 17:17:44 GMT Page 5 of 8


Q

( Stgn up ) ( '-------------------------~ -------------------------~

Log in

e •

American Nobody @ljaydakota76 1 h

Replytng to @.'nytpolitics @cnn called you n:fakenev.s You're in deeper than you realize.

0 n

lpsoPhakto @Mcsch;veety 1h

ReplyiPg to CYnytpohtics Fact: The NYT should be renamed to the Potemkin Village Voice You're a sewer-pit of lefty feces.

0 u

Black Voices Muted @dog884 1 h

Replying to @nytpohtics Have Americans been ·primed' for another civil war since Reagan's take back America, and Trump's make America great aga in messaging?

0 u

v

lpsoPhakto @Mc.schweety 1h v

Replying to @nytpolitics Fact: Many Democrats condo ne and enable violence to capture and retain power. Democrats are fascists.

0 u

Dino ~~drnok 1975 1 h

Rep:,,:ir•g to @nytpohtics this proves tht the NY Times has no shame.

0 n

Dino @dinok1975 1h

Repl•tin to @ n tpohtics

v

after t!)'ing to link Palin to Giffords this JUSt proves how pathtetic and hypocrital the NY Times is U all should b ahamed

Q

Kirk Massey @Knktv asseylL U 2h

Replying to G>nytpo ht ics Hilarious, you guys trot out some psycho with zero credibility to find the equ ivalent of the NYT editorial staff.

Q

gasmd @doclounz 411 v

Replytng to @nytpoht JCs Well that's not too biased .... "falsely," how do know either w<ty?'

Q n

Me. @RtckRol hn_ 411

Replymg to @ny1:pohtics Fact Check from NYT, is this parody?

0 n

Donald Jett @Jett_Donald51 6h

Replyirg to @nytpohtics

t.::l

Funny you can report and use falsely blamed when all you report 1s fake news. Nice job. But not sure it was falsely blamed.

0 t:

Michael Oliver @Michael93068797 15h

Replying to @nytpoltt ics Damn conservatives, starting to act like left wingers.

Document title: NYT Politics on Twitter: "Fact Check: Partisans falsely blamed Loretta Lynch, Tim Kaine, Bernie Sanders for Wednesday's Virginia shooting ... .

Capture URL: https://mobile. twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304



Q

/ ' \. _____ Log __ '" _____ )

Repiy1ng to @nytpohtKs

Damn co nservat ives, starting t o act like left wingers.

0 n

OfficialApplebees @TreySummerhn 16h

Repiying to @n. t pohtics

Were any of those id iots blaming Sand e rs you?

n

Thoughtsandprayers @tl oughtsnprayer 17h


I blame the attached list of Cuntos ame1 iranthinker com/ blog /2017 / OfJ/ a

0 n

NO TRUMP @samgebre 17h

Re!Jl~ing to @1nytpohtics @nytlmes tweeted same yesterday

0 n

v

v

Peter Principle @PetetPn 11ciple2. 1711 v

Replying to @nytpoht ics

Gee, you th ink they'd be happy to see their · second Amendment solutions" doctrine being put into action!

0 n

Gunpowder & Vanilla @Tr lstAirtshGirl 17h

Rep \~· ing to @.'n~ tpohtics If the shoe fi ts!!.. ..

0 t.l

18h

Re lying to @nvtpolit ics

and the times blamed Sarah Palin for Giffords

n . .. ~ 18h

Reply1ng to @nytpoh ics

Amazing!

0 n

Liam Alden Smith @Liam_A_Smith 18h


Fucking loretta lynch? What?

o n C?

Beth Midan La @BethMJdanla 18h

Replyirg to @nytpoht ics

Yeah, who knows what bernie meant.

0 u

Jacquie Turner @turner_Jacqlll"' 18h

1\epl)·m~ to @n)'tpohtics

Surprised ...

0 n

Olga @AReaiP•mcesa 1811

Reply1119 to @nytpohtics

;:TheyOw•lt

0 n

..tt:::. - _,. _ J - ' •·~-- ..._t_.. _ I L ... .a..

v

v

v

v

Document title: NYT Politics on Twitter: "Fact Check: Partisans falsely blamed Loretta Lynch, Tim Kaine, Bernie Sanders for Wednesday's Virginia shooting .... Capture URL: https://mobile.twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304



Q g 0

~---------~---in ___________ ) Hn

Repl)•mg to @nytpolltics @ny1imes tweeted same yesterday

0 n

Peter Principle @Pete•Pm1Clple2 17h

Replymg to @nytpolitic<: Gee, you think they'd be happy to see the1r ·Second Amendment solutions' doctrine being put into action!

0 u B

Gunpowder & Vanilla @TrustAinshGi!l 17h

"' Replying to @' nytpolitics If the shoe fits!! ....

Q t..l.

Craig @KC11A18A 18h

R.eplymg to @n]ttpolitics and the times blamed Sarah Palin for Giffords

0 u

Paix @HiPatx 18h

Replying to @nytpohtics Amazing!

0 n

Liam Alden Smith '~ L1am A Sm1th 18h

Rep lying to @nytpohtics Fucking l oretta lynch? What?

Q n

Beth Midan La @B<:rhMJdanla 1811

Replying to @nytpohtics Yeah, who knows what bernie mean

0 n

Jacquie Turner @turnt:r_j<"~lquie 18h

Replymg to ''@nytpol1tics Surprised ...

0 n

Olga (jJAReaiPnncesa 1811

Reply111g to @nytpohtic <: ~rTheyOwnlt

0 n

Re 1'/1119 to @nytpolitics

1h

B

B

B

Pa111sans on your ed1torial board falsely blamed Palm yesterday.

n I •

G 8 @harteychop 1 h

Replying to @nytpohtics Fact Check: Partisan NYT false y blamed Sarah Palin for the Gabb G1fforcls shooting yet again

0 n

v

v

v

v

v


Capture URL: https://mobile.twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/875488162730082304



EXHIBIT C


Document title: Systemic Change Needed After Faulty Times Article - The New York Times

Capture URL: https://publiceditor.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/12/18/new-york-times-san-bernardino-correction-margaret-sullivan-public-editor/















EXHIBIT D


Document title: The Public Editor Signs Off - The New York Times

Capture URL: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/02/public-editor/liz-spayd-final-public-editor-column.html











EXHIBIT E


Document title: Jared Lee Loughner - The New York Times

Capture URL: https://www.nytimes.com/topic/person/jared-lee-loughner

Capture timestamp (UTC): Tue, 11 Jul 2017 19:38:36 GMT Page 1 of 15


























































Date post:	25-Jul-2020
Category:	Documents
Upload:	others
View:	0 times
Download:	0 times

Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document 30 Filed 07/21/17 Page 1 of 2 · Case 1:17-cv-04853-JSR Document...

Documents