-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.684 Page
1 of 14
.1
•
•
l
5
4
~
' Un',te.d ShJes distf'lc.t CoW'i-
to.,st~tn U\st~~l,) u S"'Pr~AH~~{i% AJ.O,J.,) ll. Cht1 ~ +o
ph~J' k ~ t1 VI ~h y ) 13 O()..i'('U\ P~ B\~ 1 \~ tlv.t(lrio M.
Cwn~o~.)
's Jtlt~-t. M lk.Cj o..v\1/v) lh lv.K-t. A. De-\a-110~ ) \1
Dru.:~~ 1J ~ ne.~)
t1 S~u..wn R. \-i~lYloY\ \
\~ C.hrM'\-e.§i>
R~'«11 M&M'ttm >
CLASS AG T.I..ON
RECEIVED
APR 0 2 2015 CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT
RICHLAND, WASHINGTON
SeLIA~ Pcui-y/ G~t\oi' 0&\ ~!NfV..~CA\ Se.tv\C-eh lli..
~u_orc). Du:m~r
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.685 Page
2 of 14
•
•
•
t P~W:C Po\\ e-t- ~pos~nt) a. \Je.~toFCo~~of\S) 1
~\'~&-.f'o-.\11&.f1 ~,'D\r;_., K\oqCo\ C.\.e.rK) ct
D\\-otN\J. R, \i~\brt>Cl\1 s\A\)•0~ &JSP1 S ~" M'rl
UJ~-roof, Sec... of DOC E. ~on Ml~l.>o\~,o-., ®.~\\\\~ (p.r~t..
l ~~lhA~~1 ~.\),f1-..f'tvJ\~\\I\ U>l ~~ f Sw\te.n'\~t.f 1
Ct>m~ of-f.r~\i(l G>. :t-1 \ ~ K\~1 (o. G:>v..r\-ho\kbe,)
!b Po-\m« ~o\)1 r\St>f\ 1 o\.\o,o,., \\in1 (b.~> 11 ~1heny P.
I,Voi\o·\~1 fuMU' \\\~ (b, !~e J 1~ G,rr\"(.. ¥1v.Wj(;1 ~.'{).~.
f((~n~\tnu>~ !~w\~-e.o'f-t-h~FcW\-s Md.+h~rof~vif\~
s+-J.e.tr~enls o..te 14 T~, Co.s~l Ov~ GcMp\-d--{..1 f\0,_
~·,JecJ;V\
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.686 Page
3 of 14
.1
•
•
3 Fro..nK\i" Coo.n1y !o.l\· UH~ ~h~ It~~~ W~ "1'\10 \ l t~hel"'\
~t>-t4~Vl \1\~fs offi'c.W.\ ~ (M\~ t;'"~ ~~ Fe>~th~c.n~ Qt
tnd.l~ cU\a ~\+\~ \ t\ K\G.j\~p·~~ • F~ 1nptl~lllllntnt1 ~ Sl ...
ver'l> ~e.o~11t~~\~·~n~~fUtTr~tJ~1 Ac.i{~\n Ccwtrltoettori-~ b
~~\)\j \fiCo~ihJib1\(S))~ho\cl.\~ ~Ma uf\~ f~01,mttt\\ ~~\~ cuw..s
tc 1 ~ ~ • ~~'~ ~\c:ol 1 QiscAmu~·\nct ~~+he-6~\~ ~•(~~ Bro•1~ 1
~\ow)1 ~\n,Ovt$\k~"Ofll en~~t\C\ 13~l~;nV'ao\oi\onof~p~\ q
hN\bft:\~ \t\tn4ebv\s\t\~ f....,\\~1tl;c., 4~ 1 5th,n+h A-moJ,
().~S·Go*'1 ~~-h~uJ, ;o
II ho.f\\\\\t\ f.oUJ\ty Cou..tb\D~-l~l' tJ,~ 1(1~ P..-, b)~
•l\36\)'•s~RA\S~~~w~JJ.Ih (,h(;Uftt,lf I United s~~
Coosl-i1Vu1-toV) IS A..tavl-e-1, ~ 10; '\)o ~+o-.1-e.- s~v..\\ I
ma.Y..-e.. Mythlil\~ blA.t 96\d DJI\d. silvec en·,n t>v twa-a iA
Po.~~~ It o'f-rJ
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.687 Page
4 of 14
•
•
•
1 (Jflpwrtmexi\- t>F- ~~-\)oV\S- ·~.b. ~o¥:41\\~}
0\~mpi~l!Di\ ki-i\)4\ ~>i ~ M\~ th-e.- \J~e-? n po-ferW'I\(.d.
by"" S"u.petlw w'\- d-e.t\\, ~1 5f~ 1 ~+h1 nfh1 Al>W1d.. L\..S ~
c:o,J., l4
IS t:Jooo.lc\. t. \to\~-roo\()W)erttJ AssGWv\\-1 lf~ftick~~~~ \~
\A (b~~\tl~ UJnfh1 ~) viohtiortofLt.S.Cllnst~1Ji~~J~IV 1 f ~~
~llfal~6i'IC) I~ GtJt~-h'f\P~\)._b~~r ft~) sto.l{~ I Peo~e..)
~-ltSfVliW.;'IJ dq,rwJ-IDn~f NalwrJ RicJn'k, ll> Ab~c:-efPowu1 ~
'ru, 1 \3t\-, 1 Stk1 ~,u,.~\~i-. iM
a.1. Bun~ ~nu-1 &~~.Ov~SeuJ-o..tyel!--\\rt.
{kpMt~of~rred\a;..':l~- P.ovBe>x4·1H~ 1 Olympia..> ~1
WA~'D£C>t~lti~.)\s!W~suathticio'ul ~~~ Off:.lciJ ~PiiVtde.-~1y
fut~ ~4 cii~ at- Ald.!~ d.VIdA-hd+tiiOj If\ K1dVIC!.f~i~\c7J
Fo.\s-t-lmprhMm~ S~uy 1 PWMift ~~ 1~ T~ickiMJti\ Cow~~~
TroJ.dJoJY~e,s > 4-J-u~~s,c~ ~ l't \Vlttt~u\~ witnohliqcdlo'l\
of:.Coi\~~ 1 k~\J wn.c1 ~lMd.ti' i ~h,. ~ti, 1 1~th~. J.l
~ Gxnttcf\ H:t~\d,.~.Ovl F.r~~tfn Coi.U')+y J~) ID\b.l\1~ tl-h
~) ~C\5(1) I wft (\~'30 IIi~ bcill~ d.~ ~l.l.eAhtc~.t
fo,.'h'Y\~1'111 CM.Ot!Fic,et-a-~.fht-~1 Md..violcd-i~
+h-e),lnikASk:b~~fu.~~n 3~ Mc.k1II 1 ~J.1 clt~) Mic.klii:1 ~l)
AN-'ivk1J~l0 '> W\C\+n~ ~w~tuf\Sk\e~Mt~+
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.688 Page
5 of 14
•
•
•
1 Ar{.i~k 11 StJ~s~ d-. 1 1-ht-~~Ap~lo..o.J c>·&:-~l~d
~sihe,lhliMs~CPnsiHv.t\al"l J p~W>J>,{. a ·\u th(.,
X\V~A-meb1~U)t-~:,l s~!
\\Nopus~t't')~J\bt-o..Sen~oll'-~t.fl~trN41vdfl 3 CoYLl)l'e-6~ t
t>f ~e>tot: Pl'ef.>\11-e.ui Mdo V)U0 P~\clwd· 1 or ~\rrl.
cmy o~H~1 C:IVI l Oif' 4 m\Htcmy l tl\v)~fht; LV~Ited S+J"CJs, or
~nd;r,f MV stJ~) w~l.hcw~\f\~ p{'e.V\~\AO~t~ s ~Y\ OcJh ~ ~ ()..
munb-u- of Cenqli'U.S l C>f (}..f., a.vt e fFi in&v± m
i:h-c..em.m.i~~. q
IO BrL\..Ot..A ~Spo..nnu-, d.h..ovc f!I'WlkJ.iV\ CoUNt~ Tw!cte,
~M& 1\).~ Ave..) Po.bGC>, WACJ
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.689 Page
6 of 14
•
•
•
1 An+hM~ P. W~ik} Furn'XA!'Kifl~ ~Mty !w4e,- 5\b 3u-J..Ave.) ~~
LJI\-C}'Dioi t ·l'~ bi1~ s~ a hWC\ ~~~Is. O~ic.,o.\ ~tAPi,v-Jt_~
for Aiclti~Q/..J~~·,(l_ kl~t>i~oF~vLhiL~ 3 T~iwt
Gilfin·e}rUt.J,~ KidMN~l~ I rJ~e.,.lMpti~on~i, Sto.lf(Jtj) 'P-ro~ I
Msa.w\t l Tv-a,lfic.k\1'19 4 \f\ ~~m~J\-1~hlo..Meh 1
1ltJ\pe4"!>t>~l~ ,.fll8i=Fioot-& F-the,Co~J
vio\~\Vl.C[~t- W~r4\v4eYI 5 $kk,Ct>n4:1-~un AvlkkJ.\~J..,~.h~')
~1-k fL,S, ~~~iJ-Ic.n~{ 1
141 S 1 b 1 1 1 )31 i1~3)
b Ark:1c.-m}d.1 (J\.1..) ~~
l
1 Wt\-e., ?wu'\¥-1 ci~~.o.)l't\n.K\ivltJMtyJ~-
~Oit.~h4thAve.../~ 1 WI\ tt~301 1 ~s bunq s~~'fl ~ 'n htt- OOficiBl
~ Privti-"(; ~·\'Y for \ mpUSo~ Mt 4\-11\ 0~ vet of-+h'CJU9~ ~
\I)DkJ.JVl£1 th-e.. W~\~1'\ ID sw.e_&m~\itJ.Ie'f\~ci~11 §a 1
~:h~.1 Md.~U.)I\iteds~ Ce~~M!-t>VJ M1~§~1 cl.a1 e*>~·> II
CM"\d, ~IAI~M fu th~ '/.~ V th Am~mtJ.i\- ~e.dloll\ $
1 CM hollll),o c fHa,,
I~
n Bti M H&~1V't.n 1 O.,b '0..' f.ru.r.~\i\1\ Co~NY\\y
~to$wAot -lD~b 1\), ~til\ A~) P~M.c.t> 1 l>)~'\'1"{.0 111 ';)
hi\il~ 14 su.W. he..rV-'4\ ~""his Df-F-iiitt\ o..Y)c\, ~tivJ-1:.-~~
fc;il violJJI""'l tht--L0a..~\~'\twl S+c.dtAA:mstitUJ~O'II IS
Att.i,§a 1 §~ 1 §71 §laj M~~ ~itfAs-h.bu,~tSHhtHO(l M.m.1 ~il 1
J.i1«~·, ~y pro~n11he- . lb ~~,., ~l.t-·\~ S~~~ c.o~s tJw,~ ~ h~no
ri~\s
1 ~ue:t'5 no 1\ii-n\161-t wn~1 ~
17 Y\o~ne..pW~t~~.J·ai~ F«..-~ H.o~Joitt\'Pyt-.. wht\,oa,
l~d..!Wlt-~ 1 }1~1 ~ If
l"l Shi.Wltl r. So.tyt, cl.'b.o... fw-Q.V\\
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.690 Page
7 of 14
•
•
•
1
a 3
't
3l ~t.O.~ei- Gi~Mf@Crtj £fpct t>f C\~m
s t-:0 ~~()()t=- or C.l.-AlM- \hrN\ th-t. u."''ho. shl~\~
livC-bll'~f'o-..\\~fl M\~ ;V\ d..?l u.\~)\ c., b s 300d.. (\~
U.V'\\ttA Stol~ "('()-eoJ~':)'J (A) A f~t\~ Co"~etJ\cn) o..nb. \~
Ob~ ~ tct»)c\, 7
~ ~) ~OOf Of-tW\tMY Tho.* t\\-t.STPt\t.nF ~A5t\ll\GTON \~ "-
uropofo;.\'IOVI ottlmd\f\ tht ~ \J~h\'f\~~'i\
S·hr'J\-e...Co~stlt~\ttl Miv\t.- xn, ~lGf\ 1.
Co"'petJ-\t>~\'>1 ht)w tvrYfleJ., lo C~:~rpoG'....l'\cn? ovr~
fermul. b'/ \llW G\fhc\ Jot. not-tilt;t' And. ero .. wt\bt be, c-.
~\o-.)i\htf tfl.:t. U'\miY\oo.l ll AJ1o1\ 11.)\~bwt~>-.. CD\'\~\
j),jW'\6. ~ro\f'l~ -tv th{...ilt'l\hd. S·hdl:6 ~?tl~ti()ll) All'tkk
ml ~ •a a, J.;w,s{..a i WVleN\ Cl. s to-..\-e, ht~ Csv ~4 I
th~c;~u1\~ Co~ sW \ 'IM..\J!... of\ ql ~~~ x~.~ sc\\ rtiof\} I~
·\ht.tt;\~ no mMti~n ofav Sv.~ei\ofCo~.
14 ' ,
IS (i) f~OOf:- Or C\...AI.M- Th~ ~ p-tb~\t, £kin~ bws-,W\""1 to
the, ~\teA St,Jtu, ums+ltvJ\on Mick 1, 1l i tD :\ No S~tt.-
s\v~~..\\) m~tt ~t\rl\~~ hv-.\ ~otc1 ~~~av-\e., o.J-{; ~fo~~-tt
~l-o~ tb1e.- Cov.A 1 ~\t\j o.k-'lf\ "S\AfG.GIJ'V\ \wr'J
Sli\p~\'U'I'\~to-1 (JDVV\pl~~ Ylt f.~.c-~. ~vk..\'l-\i
s~ rcJJ+y/ ~~+o~ U;Sf\- Pc.tto.\~~ ~leek Ltk Rt-cbii'O.
DtDntr
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.691 Page
8 of 14
•
•
•
1 rrD~i"" c.w.~~ooth i hMcl~ ~\~~h~ ll.)ltUcX\ \s exe:t6s\ve-
fr>~(/1 1>.6 wti\ o-~ u~ I~
Mc\.M~>..&wJ.y>AA141l·ne.4- 1 0J,·,\-e,v)~:,t\'N1 w\~
fl,-en~~l fo.m\\)',d-c. . I' 11 (~) ~1\00f. nf cwtlM ~ TlnO'I-t
#!{., f\f~'o'\\\.\\'l\ CoW\~) To..\\ ~fflplcy~ ~ V}Ol v)oht1flq_
th-t 11 i~t- ~m-en~ U1S. eeY\~tvt1m'\ b~ d.myi'J\~ 111\mot--e-~
m~\~hN\ ~s to H•-t 11 brtt;, b'i pJ-t>\1\ c\\~ no
bco'uo.,~h\~\\)\1) ')t0~ Cow+~~~~ f«k."a\ RJ~ cf C'0\ i}.() ?rot
~\1-t. ~-tv
~1 \h-e, t£~.l0 ~\~Mt~ ~~«'~\Us\ ~s the.. C»mp~J:e.IPMih\ftttlm
Skd·eA:~msci-iMiont blN\-M ~!.lee l~lA.V b~A. '1 ~·\~cc~~rpk~-t 1
so·\~~ R(;l)) 7. si>~ s~\~ ~voreea\f\.~s ~{.~ON$ ~ (&fpVJ?
\~ \~c..oVI\'(l\Ac._ 1 avncl tint-- ~wrb ~'~~'~ w~ \\ r1t.,~~'l
ys\11. OJA;ehS 1u ~-c, \o-W 1 uJ~I~ l1 \\- shl·V;~ ,If\
Svf\,~>.i"(. ... ');-. ~\,\.'v
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.692 Page
9 of 14
•
•
•
:1 Afn"") v.n~ 'S~ Fwnwd.W)UittC>~{, u.~ sl Coo~H-~·hDV\ b'Y
o.s\~ a. 1etfof\.:;-\\~c,s o'l'\ ~vpwpk.'oe;\'fl~ b~'o""''\1\'\- +v
~t-~~ \ 1 ~o oJt.. C.OV1\~ta\ +o q"IV-t. 3 ~.Ut tl~iiV'I~s ~p)t;~~
1 s~«t-t.c\ +o ~-t-\f\~ h~ "')) 1 pet~ spto.>.JM 1 fotoec:\ 1 tD
~ 5tnbc}\.1s l \~ \-n b.- hol(...11'UI'oh.\ ~~) \\j\'1\'1 1
c.w\1.\f\~ ~~k:i\a.mt-S1 1 u:p\-\c,\~\n~ tlf~~-t ~~t\~,~~~s ~ot
a..f-e.,\V\ v\e>\cJ.ioV\ ~~-t.\cw:ISAAd Gms+lh.i\ofl1\ ~
1\e>'\- ~V\tn~)\~ +Int.- \C-\.w AAcll,\.~''n 1
f.o.J'Ut_o.~c\.o.Nnc, b-Y\ yov\ l.Uht>A ya.v.. U-St...-~e..ltwJ
i V\. ~ t. ~ cPw*s '~A.-s\'l\e6S !'AS r~, a,nd C&~rl-Appein~ n
~'fn~1t> 1 Ui~not pl'e;.$~-{.. +h-(,.peopk wh-ut fu-e... GoW"t
t~s S\.\ . .J'\7~dion 1 ().VI.d 'So.t\S
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.693 Page
10 of 14
1
d..
~ Tht..e~,...4Jiff~_nwrtGJ hu-e-in ~f..\f(Jl"jo~£J~t.- h01.~tL~
d.~~~~~~lfMl ~s __ _ -_4 ro#l:e.-.~i?
1cM1~~~{-yje>~~~~AA~hy_fu~tt.~itJ.~~~:Mi_~-
~ ~ fut ~1[~\\-n Col)Jh*y J'o.ilwhe'~ Lo.,0 h~ ~roJy
ChW\p~~.._WLSb+s gt- tlt.. W~~-~~ -b ~~~p~' M'li\~Je... A.c,l.0
f:.M, LL~i~tr\ ~yi(}~J~ ,_vAki'\bS ~--
l tM01
H'\ fur, SM-c.- 6().1f\ l()comp~e.- RC.~A> 1~~b4-s~~~·~s
~~YI~fllht~vJ. _'& oij'IU' RG!.d~ 1hoi tlt't.~~'V
MtifflWll'~~s'ln help''*"'l ¥"'\).-• ~e.-JO.:,isv-.p~\\!?h no
\:oj::s) q Wo.,~+n~~~~~~~D;~c$~)Lto~~~hCor.~hmo~vit\Jt\~~ \b _
Su.pfuocJ!41~~ ~~> f~R~of C.v•\~~t.,er
B~irf~~~a.rrc.\.W-LL~w,
\\ ·fu(;JOv\ l dt:seJ~ ¥\~ :su;ply ~a-\ ~iols
t·ycl-'.~fHlld'\D\6e.{)} el\~~ pel"~~ \),_ ~N\~® i'~ of-~)
wv~~m~~tuJ f>£L~~~ yo~J,.~o~t ~~~ yolllr'(\~\
_ \') M~cvbt.\1\,e.-J~Li),p~to dmy :~~IJ\-~1
ti! ~j~ yCt>.tft&rn"-jj)~~Liutt>:y.~v.h_haJt(/ik~f __
_
\ ~ t()lo1 M~ ft-is notl\C\ ~~t'rt,tms+ fG~ ~ov. to_ wot,t. ~
l&i\ftrh~~_efi}_~~t- ~~ _ __ _ _ _ I b Caw+ p~o~twqs .e,very~
it\ tl,;\s :r~ \ \, ~o\~ th~~ olt-'S~' ldnAtl\lo«:111-~~t n ~t~
Ct>~rh~1 tJI'\ do~ ~~ ~, G.iOc\ yc t>. ha,v{,~ tl~~~ t
FVvt~lli\t)tt.: ~v [.owt\:_b~} i~ :r~\~d.~o\-\of\~t-PY~tr&bs
~~~k\n~W·F, u.~it~S~ ~~ttuliot~Attir.kli}
\ ~ !a, ckU#-;1..1 s~~ ~ ''c ... nJ +h~e-\n whkh ()..
S~sht>.~\ ~&v POJty I~ 5~p~t- (A~ s \t)o..\\ hOilf:t ~
o.rlqi~\ !ut\s~doo~
1
, · ~J, by ~c. F~\il\~~/ ~\ hcwi~ ~v.tk!U\ 1\~~CJ lM0
~ l~b~Coi1lp~_ 1 nohod(s1 no LlnS. Cod~Mioi\} the.-
Pe.opk\1\.J~\ O.Ctt..-4.it.\-l'l.e..~"F .. ».. \he;~""*~tJ ~~~
ll#ome~is ~p.Jc.-compeJAtd_-bl'l_t.,4 . _ -· . i}.5
-()..~ D\'\l,t. ycv.. ~'1/) ... .c.e-r-Jc..- K'll.ow~~eJ. ~tJ~
OIV\~ ~~-\-e .. :1~ cpeA Co,~i~ t,~ ~)s ~u.cl' l~'S
~~ !ui\.s~~d\en 1 lt•S~ Celt.frtu..fH~1'1Amc.i-e.- \n1 ~~~ c,~~a
1 ~~~ Q...tt~1 -Htlt.-.STJ\'tEOF
)~if~ \
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.694 Page
11 of 14II -i j l i
------------ ~-
1j W"Srll).l
1
iS l11Aff>c~ -6 ~the. su.p~e;~~v.\ o"f-'lk kvJ. 1 IIJL;t~
skow-:, Coo'S pi 'frwy U\~ \'3 .tiuv;tc.~ ~'i~s& 1 10;~
~~llbu>~e>F-the..l.w 1 ~-td-. U/J·G~ ~~~b 1 o..s uxllt>.~
vlc~/1)1/\ \~~ c:>'t- CJ~of J~\A~ \0[).,s\\~~'fl ~t~~st\Miof\
Afl-i~~ W1 Scd1of\d-f Wf\S~6~~ I l 5~\WW/\~\ ~\)\eMf\~ I f )l\, ti
\l Rv.\~\'6 -\ ~ l
\AS~~~~\)\.\ ~\"'V> tAl
~-eM>~'O\ ~\))f\~
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.695 Page
12 of 14
1 \s~V..~u..?t\ ~;'\~\the., ww*~ (J(W\Y\~d-e.o.\ wl~ ~-~k
lbuo,\1.hf):be.~~~t~ f\0 ~ _ ~iJ(\~ ~ ~o\c1e'~ ~ rfo.i'li\~ ~ ....
~\t-v~~~ ~k ~t~»~ b'i 'Hrt ~ \\~~ ?o\\~J~~W\e-1\t, to ~~~~ea.J, ~
'7\~ t-ln_v\clo.:Vi~">Y\ ~t-"\~ B~ ~dj
\ O.IJ\~toc.w.,-Uo.~ t}i\1>$,~?\fvi\\J.\\'cY)~t, ~H'q
~'\O..rt~itf-e,O\ ~Dto.~\n~ l),)\"''lk\t~ -lb
1t) o-.nt> c:or,h..v\- \:>cer\\ t\.1~ \~-fr'\\~ w'h~\v
V)~\\-\11\~ h~~e\c,}fo.,~,\-../ 1 -e.,\c,, t cNI _ \\ %"fu_~,tV'i
\1 \(},\ion w'n\~ ~(}.;':> hD..~~-1\t~~ to Jr.\.~ t\cM'~m t
tt~fh\-\c..A\.\~\9b{,INt \d.. . be).1\_~~~~tl ~t-a.m~ 1 ~~~\""~ 1
£-~-k~\~ M~ ~'~
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.696 Page
13 of 1411
I 1
1 !W~~t·\ SOY\ \'1\\ M \Jn ~ b-)l\-h ~ ~~MU\~ AN-A~~~~
~rj-1\C)Jflec, (!::6tot.) I ~\i)t~ ~ ~MJt~l... to.~ 'l)t> f~"J
bJ~f~CW\\ 0'~ ~fA~\\~ 1 M tcm\9 hoJ, lflUVJ' ~ GoW\WY\\ \k\ ~
~{>{in~ ~fll\\-of U>tte.v-\:lc~s ~ ui'IID ho..v-e-hd~ A~w$
ttppu-o~\ mJ.J.'Y \'\ yws , 4jA-n~~1~be\U\"l held.\vv F~~~)>t\,
Cou.t1~ ~U:)\ tV\V)o\tc*-'m ~t~~ ~m~-t) \V\ "S fN n~ ~oG mcJe._ 'tn
dJJC-t t ~IJ'l ~Oe.. i) no PvJolil- i2te£Dv-cl 'ff)l}' ALif\H M
\ttt{ t Md
b -\-he., ~Rc«.A~sl;v~tJc1 \t--l-~t>5'M-~, ~~h-yl~to
COMpel
l JU\J.,_~~fAt~ ~Fvt>J~'\-~e,; -b ~~\1/)t ~ hGWt,:\~o..t~~
·iV\ vio1~{ro~ i
1 o-f- ~IJ ?-II 'I Vt ~~~" /H~ @> 1~ ho-b6v C.OP'f\~~~,
AlW~h~s C\. ~Cov-p~ \i\ Cttse-~, Ltli-d---S0?.7l~-d-. \~ iJ\i c.h
+h~ Adw-) V\ a...~~ BV'UL:e.- A J ~Vl-t:r 1 Kl'l(:)tN~ ~-t
A&m~~ Grat~ ot-t~ ~\)~\~~ l\~h\ tlui\11'\W,~e..1 ~;r__hth-e.
Ccl~A.mb\~~~evl ~\c..-e.S. Jc....;M -\ha--+-~y \') -,ttv\ts I
~~Y1>·N~ .. , 1.\){;r;J-t, Y\tlt ~'W1 tlh-c, ~pk\'1\~b~ ~) ~\"'1
oYI. tt> ~\-\-Cbtv\~\rl-~~ Md ~0 cAM ~PJV\';,,Ibk.~~+\~S •
d..\
'd-.~ ~ th-i ~tCA.\'-~ofts re~;,e.N-t-~ r~1"''- \-o ~ ~CNf\1-e.s
w ~tlf\'t th\~\~~\)v~~\e--t. ~o
)l.l~\v~~\ ~~~~\i'\t
fr-~,t. v' \\v.\t. \~ -\' SCLW'¢ f wAy/ ~~tot
'u.,~
-
Case 4:14-cv-05083-SAB ECF No. 50 filed 04/02/15 PageID.697 Page
14 of 14
· ~\1\·e,U'\c).t o,nc\.to ~kmeA\J.e-\'1 R~ec.\ rvui/Y\ this
\\\~Q.\a-n~i~moii'J.!\11\~~ .. ,soflm~\, _
-~ ~~~·\rtU... ~\~\o...~~~v·,
