SPORTS LAW
CASE STUDY – PROBLEM 2-3
Scenario
• Kathy Mitchell is a student-athlete
• Devoted and active Christian in the church and community
Scenario
• To show her devotion of faith, she wears a cross around her neck on a chain.
• She wears this cross during games as well.
Scenario
• Before the start of the game, archrival asks referee to tell Mitchell to take off the cross
• Mitchell refuses to take the cross off, results in the school forfeiting
1st Amendment
• Protects student-athletes from a state-endorsed religion
• Protects every individual’s right to freedom of belief
• Protects the individual’s freedom to practice his [or her] religion
What Is Her Defense?
• Prevention of expressing her religion
• Does not danger her or others (if taped down)
• Cross is not worn as jewelry, worn as a devotion to religion
• Unenforced rule
References
First amendement to the united states constitution. (2010, October 24). Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution
Thornton, P.K. (Ed.). (2011). Sports law. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
Pictures• http://www.ultimate-youth-basketball-guide.com/images/high-s
chool-basketball-playing-time-and-substitutions-21357933.jpg
• http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3301/3301000606_172ce2e036.jpg• http://www.goldenlaurel.com/images/KTH/Web-Rule-Book-
Cover.gif• http://images.celebrateexpress.com/mgen/merchandiser/35999.
jpg?is=300,300,0xffffff
• http://www.rpgmakerweb.com/img/gameover_xp.jpg• http://passionforcinema.com/wp-content/uploads/the-end-
031.jpg