Catering Menu
Papa Joe’s offers catering off-site 6 days a week. Let us help you plan your event.
We offer everything from lunch, dinners, and buffets. We can customize a menu ala cart from our Italian Market Menu, or create a
two or three item buffet all inclusive priced person.
*Prices are subject to change
Call or email Mary at 330.923.7999 x 102 [email protected]
Cold Mini Sandwich TrayChicken Salad, tuna salad, baked ham,
roast turkey, and roast beef served on French rolls with house-made potato chipsMedium (22 sandwiches) $78 Large (42 Sandwiches) $130
Salads by the PoundPapa’s Pasta Salad, Kidney Bean Salad,
Tortellini Salad, Tomato & Mozzarella Salad.Even more salads available from our Italian Market
Local Cheese & Vegetable TrayServed with 5 local cheeses, crackers, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, cucumbers, bell peppers, &
celery, served with our house made ranchSmall $40 • Medium $60 • Large $80
Mediterranean Antipasto TrayRoasted red peppers, marinated artichoke hearts,
pepperonicini, salami, capicola, tomato & mozzarella salad, & a blend of olives, served with crackers
Medium $69 • Large $89
Artichoke DipServed with toasted pita chips, serves 20-24 $45
BruschettaServed with crostini
Medium $45 - Large $65
WingsChoice of barbecue or buffalo style or plain
Small (25 wings) $30 Medium (50 wings) $60
Large ( 75 wings) $90
PierogiesPotato & cheddar pierogies, served with sautéed onions
Small (20 pierogies) $30Medium (40 pierogies) $60
Large ( 60 pierogies) $90
Chicken SatayBaked with ginger soy glaze & served with peanut sauce
$2.99 per skewer
Combination PlatterMozzarella sticks & Fried cheese ravioli served with marinara dipping sauce,
sauerkraut balls served with cocktail sauce, and honey dipped wingsSmall $34 - Medium $64 - Large $98
AppetizersStart off your event with one of our great appetizers!
Chilled Appetizers
Warm Appetizers
Vegetarian Option
Cocktail MeatballsMade in-house with your choice of
barbecue or marinara sauceSmall (20 meatballs) $25
Medium (48 meatballs) $60Large ( 78 meatballs) $98
Italian Sausage & PeppersLocally made Italian sausage tossed with
peppers, onions, & tomatoesSmall $38
Medium $64Large $98
Stuffed Hot Banana PeppersFilled with Italian sausage, ricotta, feta & parmesan cheese, placed on a pool of
marinara sauce $2.99 each
*Prices are subject to change
Hummus & PitaServed with toasted pita chips, serves 20-24 $45
Spinach & Cheese Phyllo BlossomsSpinach & Cheese beautifully
wrapped in buttery phyllo Small (25 pieces) $30
Medium (50 pieces) $60 Large (80 pieces) $90
Mini Beef Wellingtons Tender filet coated in paté and duxelles,
wrapped in puff pastry Small (25 pieces) $75
Medium (50 pieces) $150Large (80 pieces) $240
Goat Cheese & Fresh Strawberry Crostini
$1.50 each
Cheese & Fresh Fruit TraySmall $50.00
Medium $70.00
Large $90.00
Buttery Croissants with your choice of:Chicken or Tuna Salad
25 $75.00
45 $125.00
Small 12 39.99Medium 24 79.99Large 48 159.99
Steamed to perfection for each order. Served with house-made cocktail sauce & lemons
Jumbo Shrimp Tray
Buffalo Chicken Dip Served with toasted pita chips, serves 20-24 $60
Catering MenuServed with a salad and warm Tuscan Bread
Includes our Famous White French, Italian & Ranch DressingsMinimum 20 people
Chaffing dishes included!
Standard Dinner Buffet
2 Main Entrees1 Side Dish
$24 per person
Traditional Dinner Buffet
3 Main Entrees2 Side Dish
$28 per person
Buffet Entree ChoicesOur Famous Lasagna
Noodles layered with Tuscan bechamel & our house made meat sauce, Parmesan
Reggiano & mozzarella cheese
Chicken ParmigianaHand breaded, sauteed, & topped with
marinara & melted cheese. Baked to order!
Crab Stuffed Chickenin a rich champagne cream sauce
Lucca ChickenChicken cutlets lightly breaded, topped with
baby arugula, EVOO, lemon, & Parmesan
Penne with Sausage, Peppers & OnionsPenne pasta with locally made Italian sausage,
tossed with peppers, onions, and tomatoes
Penne PastaServed with your choice of:
Marinara or Meatsauce
Penne PrimaveraPenne with seasonal vegetable with oil &
garlic, & sprinkled with Parmesan
Eggplant Lasagna
Chicken Francaise
Add $1.00A local favorite, tender chicken sauteed in our
butter & lemon sauce
Chicken MarsalaSauteed chicken & mushrooms in our rich
marsala wine sauce
Honey Dijon ChickenGrilled chicken breast, basted with honey
Dijon mustard, & topped with candied pecans
Grilled Chicken BreastGrilled chicken breast, with Italian seasonings
Tuscan Roast Chicken orButtermilk Fried Chicken
Our Famous Baked Mac & Cheese
Side DishesRoasted Potatoes
Italian Style Green BeansPenne Pasta with Marinara
Whipped PotatoesCheesy Whips $1.00 more
Add an additional side for $2.50 per person
Vegetarian Option = Available gluten free by request
*Prices are subject to change
Lunch Buffet2 Main Entrees
1 Side Dish$18 per person
Noodles layered with Tuscan bechamel & Eggplant,and our house made marinara sauce, Parmesan
Reggiano & mozzarella cheese
Sweet EndingsUltimate Dessert Tray
Assorted dessert bars, hand-made cannolis, fresh baked brownies and cookies
Small $32.99 • Medium $59.99 • Large $79.99
Brownie TrayFresh baked brownies
Small (12 brownies) $14.99Medium (25 brownies) $24.99
Large (40 brownies) $40.99
Cookie TrayFresh baked cookies:
Chocolate Truffle, Oatmeal Rasin, Snickerdoodle, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Iced Sugar & Ani’s Lemon
Small (12 cookies) $26 • Medium (25 cookies) $37 • Large (40 co0kies) $52
Hand-made Mini Cannolis Tray$1.75 each