8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

1/21

ANNEXE

CONSULTATION COMMENTS

Page

269

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

2/21

Emails

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr Wilkinson Herne Bay Oppose Loss of sleep, impact on children and educational achievement, causes of anxiety andstress

Loss of jobs in domestic tourism negative impact on local businesses

Will not create many jobs

Airport proposals Thames Estuary makes Manston less viable

Miss Gilhooly Herne Bay Oppose Loss of sleep, impact on children and educational achievement,

Impact on health - causes anxiety and stress

Loss of jobs in domestic tourism negative impact on local businesses

Will not create many jobs

Airport proposals Thames Estuary makes Manston less viable

Dr Dean Rural Oppose Noise would be intolerable at night

Annonymous Cannot identify Oppose No to Cargo planes at night

No real economic benefit

Mr Chenery Herne Bay Oppose Noise and disruption of sleep

Mrs Blackmore Rural Unclear Reinstate Edinburgh route

Mr Hodges Herne Bay Oppose Manston can only attract noisy cargo planes

Visions of large scale international airport are unrealistic due to location

Limited economic benefits do not justify disruption at night

Why does the flight path come over Herne Bay should come in from the East

Lloyd Herne Bay Oppose Airport doesnt control routes properly nowNot full to capacity in the day so cant justify night flights

Sceptical about economic benefits

Disruption to sleep

Mr Williams Herne Bay Oppose Everyone entitled to a good night sleep

Negative impact on children to learn and health of residents

Page

270

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

3/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr Rainsbury Herne Bay Oppose Sceptical that proposal in help local economy

Thames Estuary proposal better located for international Airport

Sleep is a human right

Mrs Moss Rural Oppose Extension to night time flying would be intolerable

Lewis Herne Bay Oppose Economic benefits exaggerated

Noise pollution underestimated

Sleep a basic human right

Concerned that online consultation excludes older residents

Mr and Mrs Ward Herne Bay Oppose Sleep deprivation

Mrs Cook Herne Bay Oppose Disruption to sleep

Mr and Mrs Clark Herne Bay Oppose Occasional night flights disturb sleep now

Several flights a night would be intolerable

Should fill available day slotsCan only attract old cargo planes

Do not believe economic benefits

Wells Herne Bay Oppose Health and well-being concerns

Sleep issues

Cheesman Herne Bay Oppose Noise pollution

Impact on sleep- concerns with performance at school

Servadei Herne Bay Oppose Impact on sleep and health

Mr Kelly Herne Bay Oppose Noise

No new jobs

Mrs Cooney Whitstable Oppose Noise

Mr and Mrs Cawley Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Greenleaf Herne Bay Support More employment

Manklow Herne Bay Oppose Level of noise pollution

Sleep issues

Page

271

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

4/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr and Mrs Andrews Herne Bay Oppose Chemical and noise pollution

Dr Meyer Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Lewis Herne Bay Oppose No economic benefitsNoise

Sleep issues

Mr Martin Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep issues

Pollution

Not enough eceomic value added

Brett Herne Bay Oppose

Mr Dawson Cannot identify Support Job prospects

Jones Herne Bay Oppose Noise

No increase in the economyMr and Mrs Akbar Herne Bay Oppose

Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels will increase

Clubb Herne Bay Oppose Health

Spare capacity during day so this should be used first

Cargo planes are noisier

Night flights will not create more jobs

Staley Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Taylor Whitstable Support Boost to economy

Parry Whitstable Support Boost to economy

Miss Jarrett Herne Bay Oppose Spare capacity during daytime

No major increase in jobs

Noise

Health issues

Mrs Pay Herne Bay Support Boost to job oportunities

Page

272

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

5/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr and Mrs Flack Herne Bay Oppose Disturbed sleep

Mr Rowden Herne Bay Oppose Increase in noise levels

No true evidence for increase in employmentMr Judson Rural Support More jobs

More passenger flights

Mr Brooks Herne Bay Oppose Noise disruption

Mr and Mrs Neale Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Spare capacity during daytime

No evidence of increase in job opportunities

Mr Cribbett Herne Bay Oppose Increase in noise levels

Sleep issues

Rhodes Herne Bay Oppose

JohnsonMr Cooke Whitstable Support Currently not being used enough

Economic growth

Cllr Peter

Vickery Jones

after

consultation

with

Canterbury

City Council

Members

Cannot identify Oppose

However they represent the extremes, of those who replied a big majority had the

view that although they broadly support a thriving Manston which would offer

convenience of travel and also much needed job opportunities, they do not support

night flights.

Mr and Mrs Martin Herne Bay Oppose

Woollett Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep disturbance

Page

273

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

6/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Passenger and employment projections misleading

Mr Nordin Whitstable Oppose No economic prosperity

Brookfield Herne Bay Oppose Increased noise levelsHealth issues

Mr Cox Herne Bay Oppose Increased noise levels

Watley Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Disturbed sleep

Vacant daytime slots

No increase on job prosperity

Mr Allen Rural Support More choice to fly from

Economic growth

More jobs

Mr Power Cannot identify Support Encourage investmentIncrease employment

Wilkinson Herne Bay Oppose Increased noise levels

Hopper Herne Bay Oppose

Lloyd Herne Bay Oppose Too many different in bound routes

Day time slots available

Assumptions of increased employment not true

Disturbed sleep

No economic growth

Whiteley Herne Bay Oppose Increased noise

Mrs Mott Herne Bay Oppose Increase in flight traffic overnight

Mr Holton Herne Bay Unclear Disturbed sleep

Health issues

Mr Clements Herne Bay Oppose Disturbed sleep

Mr Smith Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Page

274

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

7/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Lacking in evidence to benefits

Mr Spencer Herne Bay Oppose Quality of life will be ruined

Sleep disturbance

Airport is on wrong place

Bayfield Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Only in it for a profit

Procter Herne Bay Oppose Disturbed sleep

Enough spare slots during the day

Green Canterbury Support Employment prospects

Regeneration of the area

Waller Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Quality of Life

Disturbed sleepFee Rural Support Kent needs jobs

Goodwin Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disruption

Rogers Herne Bay Oppose Noise nuisance

Sleep disturbance

Price Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Health issues

Pollution

Flawed infromation about job creation

Walsh Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Need to encourage people to the area, not drive them away

Mr and Mrs Young Herne Bay Oppose Infratils predictions are flawed and exaggerated

Increased noise levels and pollution

Increase in cargo flights will increase "onward" traffic, including noise and pollution

Support daytime flights

Page

275

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

8/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Dr Marsh Herne Bay Oppose Sleep deprivation

Noise

Pollution

Stress

Mr Pearce Canterbury Support Boost economy

Mrs Pearce More jobs created

Mr Pearce

Master Pearce

Master Pearce

Wilkins Herne Bay Oppose Increase in noise

Vibrations

Hudson Herne Bay Oppose Noise maps inaccurate

Impact on H/Bay understatedNoise levels

Sleep deprivation

Negative impact of night flights on the economy of East Kent not enumerated

Economic case not proved

Leonard Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Mrs Howe Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Airport not used to full capacity during the day

Quality of life

Mrs Mann Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Smith Herne Bay OpposeMiss Robinson Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Mr Matthews Herne Bay Support More jobs

Economy growth

Mr Cloke Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Page

276

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

9/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Langford Herne Bay Oppose Increased vibrations

Quality of life decreased

Dr Douglas Herne Bay Oppose Sleep deprivation

Health risks

Effects on children

Information misleading regarding job creation

Mrs Harding Herne Bay Oppose Sleep deprivation

Misleading flight path information

Job creation information misleading

Mr Harding Herne Bay Oppose Sleep deprivation

Misleading flight path information

Job creation information misleading

Mrs Morris Herne Bay Oppose Increased noiseSleep disturbance

Willows Herne Bay Oppose Affect sleep and health

Payne Whitstable Oppose Increased noise levels

Sleep disturbance

Mason Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Mason Herne Bay Oppose Noise pollution

Mayland Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels increased

Mrs Rhodes Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Mr and Mrs Boulter Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disruption

Noise levels

Mr White Rural Support Encourage additional capacity

Thanet needs jobs

Growth of the economy

Mrs Riley Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Page

277

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

10/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr Pettman Whitstable Support Thanet needs jobs

Limit night flights

Mr Davey Herne Bay Oppose Small gain in jobs

Adverse impact on those in flight path

Mr and Mrs Bowley Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Physical health and wellbeing

Hours are too long for "night flights"

Day time slots not full

No more jobs created

Noise levels

Mr Maillardet Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Mr and Mrs Furneaux Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Benefit to community does not stand upJob creation over estimated

Health concerns

Environment issues

Howes Herne Bay Oppose Sound pollution

Vibrations

Mr Jones Herne Bay Oppose Increase in noise levels

Devaluation of house values

Environmental impact

Mr Pratt Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Loss of sleepPollution - noise and air

Will not bring that many jobs

Newton Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Parish Herne Bay Oppose Level of discomfort?

Page

278

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

11/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Bassett

Mr Cross Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep disturbacne

Quality of life

Blackman Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep disruption

Not an ideal location

Richardson Herne Bay Support Economic regeneration

Creat business and employment opportunities

Shepherd Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Maling Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Not many new jobs created

Utilise daytime flying firstMr and Mrs Emery Whitstable Support Hopefully encourage new routes abroad for holidaymakers

Mrs Ridley Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Connors Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Vibrations to hosue

Health issues

Mr Rood Herne Bay Oppose Not using daytime availability enough

Job estimates exaggerated

Noisy

Safety issues

Mr Bennett Herne Bay Unclear MIA needs to challenge Independent Assessors Report

Blyth Rural Support Needs economic growth

Barnett More flights for local people

Brown Herne Bay Support Hope to bring in more airlines

Boost to economy

Page

279

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

12/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Charlesworth Herne Bay Oppose Report shows up exaggerations

Most other airports have minimal night time flights

Allows unlimited night flights

Sleep deprivation

Job increases are fictional

Would kill tourism

Noise

Lack of care for environment

Mr and Mrs Pool Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Mrs Gambrill Herne Bay Oppose

Miss Round Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Noise

The daytime slots are not filledWon't creat 3000 jobs

Mr Taylor Whitstable Support Increase in jobs

Stimulate the economy

Mr Parry Whitstable Support Major boost to the loacl area

Miss Jarrett Herne Bay Oppose Daytime slots not being used to full capacity

Job estimates exaggerated

Health

Safety

Sleep disturbance

Mrs Pay Herne Bay Support Need more airlines using ManstonMr and Mrs Flack Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep disturbance

Mr Rowden Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Job creation figures flawed

Page

280

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

13/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr Judson Rural Support Support job creation

More passenger flights

Mr Brooks Herne Bay Oppose Flights into Manston do not have same restrictions as those taking off

Sleep disturbance

Mr and Mrs Neale Herne Bay Oppose Quality of Life

Noise levels

Airport not used enough during the day

Not enough jobs provided

Blake Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Bosier Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Noisy

Vibrations to the house

Rowbotham Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbanceTuck Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Noise pollution

Property decrease in value

Mr Kent Herne Bay Support Noise not an issue

More holiday destinations?

Mr Howe Herne Bay Oppose Not enough enw jobs

Sleep deprivation

Slater Herne Bay Oppose Sleep deprivation

Mr Lockwood Herne Bay Oppose Disturbed sleep

Deterioration of air qualityNo economic benefits

Mr Clark Rural Oppose Disturbed sleep

Pollution

Mr Skull Herne Bay Support Increase economy

Page

281

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

14/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mrs Dawkins Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Brearly Whitstable Support Growth in business

Mr Jones Herne Bay Oppose Only attacts low cost, noisy cargo planes

Mr Quarterman Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Donnithorne Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep disturbance

Quarterman Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Quarterman Herne Bay Oppose

Lockwood Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbane

Not 1000 jobs created!!

Wildon Herne Bay Oppose Not uitlising all the daytime slots

Mr Upson Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

NoiseMrs Donnithorne Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Lee Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Small economic benefits

Mr Wheatley Canterbury Oppose Increased noise levels

Economic benefit very small

Kitney Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Disturbed sleep

Mr Brocklehurst Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Sleep disturbance

Not enough jobs benig created

Mr Peakall Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Mr Rose Herne Bay Oppose Costs outweigh benefits

Failed to provide credible forecast for eceonomic benefits

Not enough people living in area to justfy passenger terminal

Page

282

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

15/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

House prices will fall

Mr Hutt Whitstable Oppose No extra jobs

Smell fo fuel permanently

Mr Thompson Herne Bay Support Minimal noise

Mr Harris Herne Bay Oppose Lose sleep

Value of property decrease

Mr Davenport Whitstable Unclear

Mr Cronin-Hill Whitstable Support Good for economy

Hill

Mr Conabeer Herne Bay Oppose Noise

In favour of more daytime flights

Mr Betteridge Herne Bay Oppose No market for passenger travel

No substantial evidence for job/tourism increaseNoise pollution

Mr and Mrs Smith Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disruption

Noise

Myers Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Need to fill daytime slots first

Sleep deprivation

Quality of life

Doubt that 3000 jobs will be created

Airport in wrong place

Mr Merrywest Canterbury Support Extra number of flights are minimalMrs Wells Rural Support Needs jobs

Mrs Heath Whitstable Support Create more jobs

Edwards Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Briant Herne Bay Oppose Overwhelming noise

Pa

ge

283

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

16/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Pollution

Reduction in house value

Cannot see that enough jobs are likely

Mr Padgham Whitstable Support has to be moderm, quiet planes

rather in bound than outbound

Mr Mills Canterbury Oppose Noise levels will increase

claims about essential viability and jobs are baseless.

Doyle Rural Oppose health dangers

Noise pollution

No justification of employment opportunities or well being

Mr Mitchell Herne Bay Oppose Quality of life

Noise

Mr Lockwood Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbancehealth impact

Devaluation of property

Environmental pollution

Safety

Mr Goggin Rural Support Improved air services

Need to encourage nationally based carriers

Parkway station at Manston

Mr and Mrs Moroney Whitstable Support Airport is under used currently

Hougham Herne Bay Support More employment

Ryan Herne Bay Oppose NoiseRendell Herne Bay Support Potential disturbance is small

Potential of new jobs

Good road links

Page

284

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

17/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr Davies Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Not persuaded by economic benefits

Mr and Mrs Fooks Herne Bay Support Creation of jobs

Mr Walkling Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Not used enough during daytime

Mr Thompson Rural Support

Savage Herne Bay Oppose House vibrates

Noise levels

Mr and Mrs Butcher Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Detrimental to wellbeing

Location is severely restricted

Mr Bates Herne Bay Oppose Quality of life would decrease

Smith Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbanceMinimal new jobs created

Mrs Jackson Herne Bay Oppose

Mrs Hedges Herne Bay Oppose Hosue vibrates

Noise

Pollution

Mrs Palmer Herne Bay Oppose

Mr and Mrs Robinson Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

affect health

Ms McIntyre Herne Bay Oppose Sleep disturbance

Health implicationsNo credible evidence it will create many jobs

hasn't created a viable daytime business

Mr Bloodworth Herne Bay Oppose Impact on quality of life

Sleep disturbance

Pa

ge

285

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

18/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mr and Mrs Algar Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Mr Brockhurst Herne Bay OpposeWill be excercising our rights under article 8 of the European Convention on Human

Rights.

Mr Lowe Rural Oppose Noise

Disturbed sleep

Climate change

Mr Eason Herne Bay Support More employment

O'Doherty Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Pollution

Kitney Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Disturbed sleep

Rodriguez-Diaz Rural Oppose Noise

Pollution

Mr and Mrs Mill Herne Bay Oppose Not enough economic benefits

Noise levels unnaceptable

Sleep disturbance

Mrs Joyce Herne Bay Oppose Noise

Sleep disturbance

Mr Cleveland Herne Bay Oppose

Mr Bell Canterbury Support Boost to economy

More jobs

Szymczak Rural Support Creat more jobs

Mr Cordell Herne Bay Oppose Intolerable noise levelsNonense about loads of jobs being created

Woods Herne Bay Oppose Interrupted sleep

Over estimated economic impact

Pollution

Page

286

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

19/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

House prices will fall

Gurr family Cannot identify Support

Pa

ge

287

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

20/21

Letters

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

Mrs Jolly Herne Bay Oppose Noise levels

Disturbed sleep, stress, health impacts

Accept daytime flights inevitable but not night flights

Negative impact on tourism if visitors cannot sleep due to night flights

Economy will not benefit

Mrs Forecast Herne Bay Oppose Noise concerns

Will council improve roof/wall insulation and double glazing to help eliminate noise?

Disturbed sleep and health problems

Mr Taylor Herne Bay Oppose Disturbed sleep and anxiety

Noise screaming/thundering

House vibratesMr Taylor Herne Bay Oppose Noise pollution

Disturbed sleep

Quality of life would be blighted

Air pollution

Smith Herne Bay Oppose No business case for allowing night flights

Ill health, pollution, reduced property values

Negatives outweigh positives

Smith Herne Bay Oppose Independent consultants' report demolishes business case

Should not trade wealth for health

Mr Cross Herne Bay Oppose Low flying aircraftNoise

Benefits overstated

Mrs Surgison Herne Bay Oppose Low flying aircraft

Noise

Page

288

8/2/2019 CCC Executive - Consultation Responses

21/21

Title Surname AreaOverall view of

proposalsKey issues

French Herne Bay Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Speed Herne Bay Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

French Herne Bay Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Baker Herne Bay Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Jeer Rural Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Bird Herne Bay Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Monks Herne Bay Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Gardner Whitstable Oppose Impacts on sleep, health and wellbeing

Pa

ge

289