8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

1/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

2/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

3/33

ii

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

4/33

iii

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

5/33

iv

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

6/33

v

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

7/33

vi

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

8/33

vii

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

9/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

10/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

11/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

12/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

13/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

14/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

15/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

16/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

17/33

According to the Massachusetts court that first consideredwhether the First Amendment protected this speech,[t]hechant, repeated four times, was used during a single ten-second time period in a demonstration which lasted morethan half an hour. When those words were uttered, somemembers of the group were smiling or laughing, and policeofficers stood nearby, seemingly unconcerned. Id . The factthat the Massachusetts court found the chant protected underthe First Amendment underlines the need for guidance here.

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

18/33

format

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

19/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

20/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

21/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

22/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

23/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

24/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

25/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

26/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

27/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

28/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

29/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

30/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

31/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

32/33

8/7/2019 CCR Amicus in Support of SHAC 7 Petition for Cert

33/33