BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016 Return to: [email protected]. On the following pages, you’ll see a line for the proposal with a grid for feedback. Rationales are always helpful for voters. Don’t worry about pages breaks and header scrolling – just work on this Word document and send it back. Arlene will edit and make pretty. Monograph with comments is available at: http://www.iccsafe.org/codes-tech-support/codes/code-development- process/20152017-code-development-group-b/ The average number of proposals ranges between 47-50 proposals. If you don’t have sufficient time, please send an email to Arlene and Doug W with the numbers you cannot accomplish. We have a few people that we may be able to reach out to for reassignment. Member Expertise Assigned Ashley Ong egress and existing building code IAdmin ADM43 to ADM94 (End) IEBC (all) Stephanie Davis RESIDENTIAL ENERGY, CODE ADMINISTRATION (Start) ADM2-AD42 RE153-RE373 (end) Joseph Crum Energy RE69-RE146 Doug Harvey Any (Start) CE137 Part II (start) – RE63 (Start) CE3-CE29 Arlene Z. Stewart Energy CE31-CE129 Michael Fox Energy/Any CE134 to CE273 Jonathan Bilby Any CE275-CE296 (end) Mike Garrett Fire (Start) IWUIC3-F147 Jeffrey Camden Fire/Building F149-F325 John Barrios Any F326-F401 (end) (Start) RB1-RB96 David Zimmerman in egress, structural, existing building, and property maintenance RB113-RB283 Dennis Stanley Building RB285 to RB372 (end) (Start) FS3-16 – G17 part 1 Joe Belcher IBC Chapters 6, 7, S55-S149
Transcript
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Return to: [email protected]. On the following pages, you’ll see a line for the proposal with a grid for feedback. Rationales are always helpful for voters. Don’t worry about pages breaks and header scrolling – just work on this Word document and send it back. Arlene will edit and make pretty.
The average number of proposals ranges between 47-50 proposals. If you don’t have sufficient time, please send an email to Arlene and Doug W with the numbers you cannot accomplish. We have a few people that we may be able to reach out to for reassignment.
Member Expertise AssignedAshley Ong egress and existing building
codeIAdmin ADM43 to ADM94 (End)IEBC (all)
Stephanie Davis RESIDENTIAL ENERGY, CODE ADMINISTRATION
(Start) ADM2-AD42RE153-RE373 (end)
Joseph Crum Energy RE69-RE146Doug Harvey Any (Start) CE137 Part II (start) – RE63
(Start) CE3-CE29Arlene Z. Stewart Energy CE31-CE129Michael Fox Energy/Any CE134 to CE273Jonathan Bilby Any CE275-CE296 (end)Mike Garrett Fire (Start) IWUIC3-F147Jeffrey Camden Fire/Building F149-F325John Barrios Any F326-F401 (end)
(Start) RB1-RB96David Zimmerman in egress, structural, existing
building, and property maintenance
RB113-RB283
Dennis Stanley Building RB285 to RB372 (end)(Start) FS3-16 – G17 part 1
Joe Belcher IBC Chapters 6, 7, 19, 20, and 21 S55-S149Gregory Young S153-s308 (end)
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 2 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleIADMINStephanie DavisADM2-16 Part IVADM4-16 Part IADM4-16 Part IIADM4-16 Part IIIADM6-16 Part IADM6-16 Part IIADM6-16 Part IIIADM6-16 Part IVADM9-16 Part IADM9-16 Part IIADM9-16 Part IIIADM9-16 Part IVADM10-16 Part IIADM13-16 Part IADM13-16 Part IIADM26-16 Part IADM27-16 Part IADM31-16ADM32-16ADM33-16ADM35-16 Part IIIADM36-16ADM40-16ADM42-16 Part IADM42-16 Part IIAshley OngADM43-16 Part IADM43-16 Part IIADM45-16 Part IADM45-16 Part IIADM46-16 Part IADM46-16 Part IIADM49-16ADM50-16ADM52-16ADM54-16 Part IADM54-16 Part IIADM55-16 Part IADM56-16 Part IIADM57-16 Part I
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 3 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleADM57-16 Part IIADM58-16 Part IVAshley OngADM60-16 Part IADM60-16 Part IIADM60-16 Part IIIADM60-16 Part IVADM66-16 Part IADM66-16 Part IIADM68-16ADM71-16ADM74-16ADM76-16ADM77-16ADM78-16 Part IADM78-16 Part IIADM87-16ADM88-16 Part IADM88-16 Part IIADM94-16
IECC – RESIDENTIAL/IRC – ENERGYDoug HarveyCE137-16 Part IIRE3-16RE6-16G10-16 Part IIIRE10-16RE12-16RE15-16RE17-16RE18-16RE19-16RE22-16RE23-16RE25-16RE26-16RE27-16RE28-16RE30-16RE31-16RE36-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 4 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleRE37-16RE40-16RE47-16RE50-16CE84-16 Part IIRE51-16RE52-16RE56-16RE58-16RE60-16RE63-16Joe CrumRE69-16RE70-16RE72-16RE73-16RE74-16RE76-16RE77-16RE78-16RE79-16RE81-16RE82-16RE85-16RE86-16RE87-16RE89-16RE92-16RE94-16RE96-16RE98-16RE100-16RE101-16RE103-16RE104-16RE106-16RE107-16RE108-16RE109-16RE191-16Mike FoxRE113-16RE114-16RE116-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 5 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleRE120-16RE121-16RE123-16RE127-16RE130-16RE131-16RE134-16RE135-16RE136-16RE137-16RE138-16RE139-16CE18-16 Part IIRE142-16RE145-16RE146-16Stephanie DavisRE153-16RE154-16CE259-16 Part IIRE156-16RE159-16RE161-16RE162-16RE163-16RE164-16RE165-16RE166-16RE167-16RE168-16RE170-16RE173-16RE174-16RE175-16RE177-16RE178-16RE179-16RE181-16RE183-16RE187-16RB373-16
IECC – COMMERCIALDoug Harvey
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 6 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleCE3-16 Part ICE5-16 Part ICE5-16 Part IICE8-16 Part IICE10-16 Part ICE10-16 Part IICE11-16 Part IICE19-16CE21-16 Part ICE21-16 Part IICE23-16 Part ICE23-16 Part IICE24-16 Part ICE25-16 Part ICE25-16 Part IICE27-16 Part ICE28-16 Part ICE28-16 Part IICE29-16 Part IIArlene Z StewartCE31-16 Part ICE31-16 Part IICE37-16CE38-16 Part ICE38-16 Part IICE40-16CE42-16CE43-16CE46-16CE48-16CE50-16CE51-16CE52-16CE54-16CE55-16CE57-16CE60-16 Part ICE60-16 Part IICE61-16CE62-16CE64-16CE66-16CE71-16CE73-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 7 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleCE79-16CE87-16 Part ICE87-16 Part IICE89-16CE91-16CE92-16CE93-16CE96-16CE99-16CE102-16CE105-16CE107-16CE108-16CE109-16CE110-16CE111-16CE112-16CE114-16 Part ICE114-16 Part IICE115-16 Part ICE115-16 Part IICE120-16CE121-16CE124-16CE125-16CE129-16Michael FoxCE134-16 Part ICE134-16 Part IICE135-16 Part ICE135-16 Part IICE138-16CE140-16CE142-16CE144-16CE145-16CE147-16 Part ICE147-16 Part IICE155-16CE171-16CE175-16 Part ICE175-16 Part IICE176-16 Part ICE176-16 Part II
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 8 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleCE183-16CE185-16CE189-16CE192-16CE194-16CE196-16CE200-16CE209-16CE213-16CE215-16CE216-16CE217-16CE218-16CE219-16CE222-16CE224-16CE225-16CE228-16CE229-16CE231-16CE232-16CE233-16CE236-16CE238-16CE239-16CE240-16CE241-16CE244-16CE245-16CE247-16CE249-16CE251-16CE253-16CE256-16CE258-16CE262-16CE263-16CE272-16 Part ICE272-16 Part IICE273-16Jonathan BilbyCE275-16 Part ICE275-16 Part IICE277-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 9 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleCE287-16CE289-16CE290-16CE291-16CE292-16CE293-16CE294-16CE296-16
IWUIC/IFCMike GarrettWUIC3-16WUIC4-16WUIC5-16WUIC6-16WUIC7-16PM7-16F5-16F6-16F7-16F10-16F12-16F19-16F20-16F23-16F29-16F34-16F37-16F42-16F44-16F47-16F50-16F51-16F66-16F69-16F72-16F73-16F74-16G35-16F79-16F80-16F82-16F86-16 Part IF89-16 Part I
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 10 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleF89-16 Part IIF93-16F94-16F95-16F111-16F112-16F103-16F104-16F107-16F113-16F114-16F118-16F119-16F128-16F131-16F134-16F139-16F147-16Jeffrey CamdenF149-16F154-16F157-16F158-16F159-16F166-16F168-16F170-16F172-16F179-16F185-16F194-16F196-16F197-16F198-16F200-16F201-16F205-16F213-16F215-16G16-16F219-16F220-16F221-16F222-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 11 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleF223-16F227-16F228-16F238-16F247-16F250-16F251-16F252-16F258-16F269-16F273-16F275-16F277-16F279-16F280-16F287-16F295-16F18-16F310-16F409-16F325-16John BarriosF326-16F332-16F333-16F336-16F338-16F340-16G26-16F344-16F353-16F359-16F365-16F366-16F75-16F226-16F369-16F372-16F378-16F380-16F386-16F412-16F390-16F399-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 12 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleF401-16
IRC - BUILDINGJohn BarriosRB1-16RB7-16RB10-16RB17-16RB18-16RB19-16RB20-16RB22-16RB25-16RB26-16RB27-16RB29-16RB31-16RB36-16RB41-16RB49-16RB51-16RB52-16RB67-16RB68-16RB69-16RB70-16RB72-16RB375-16RB79-16RB81-16RB89-16RB95-16RB96-16David ZimmermanRB113-16 X This is adequately addressed in the
residential code, as well as in many fire codes and local zoning codes, and may conflict with such existing provisions.
RB114-16 X Ramps are typically for people with physical limitations who cannot reasonably use stairs. This aligns with the purpose of the ADA, which requires that ramps be 36” wide minimum. Also, stairs and hallways are required to be a
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 13 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral Rationaleminimum of 36” in width, as per the residential code. For uniformity and to reduce conflict or confusion in the industry, ramp width requirements should align with the ADA and the other means of egress component requirements of the residential code.
RB119-16 X The technical provisions of the proposed change already exist in the code, but should be consolidated under Section R311.7.10.1.
RB121-16 X Although this issue needs to be addressed, the proposed language is fraught with problems.
RB129-16 XRB140-16 X I take issue with Exception #3, because if
the danger of CO emanating from a newly installed appliance exists, a CO alarm should be installed regardless of prior codes’ failure to require them.
RB147-16 X 23/32 inch wood structural panel should be eliminated from the provision due to its inability to pass thermal barrier fire resistance testing, but calling for heavy timber is overkill.
RB152-16 X Verification that the same foam was not used at locations that require flame retarded foam during inspection would be difficult. The proposed change would expose the public to greater risk than is necessary.
RB157-16 X I don’t think this needs to be addressed because strict requirements are already in place that have demonstrated good performance. Cliché: If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.
RB158-16 XRB159-16 X The change provides increased
clarification with no change in requirements or cost of construction.
RB160-16 X Support with Public Comment 2RB161-16 X Support with Public Comment 1RB162-16 Moved to CARB167-16 Moved to CARB168-16 X The allowance of ladders as compliant
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 14 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral Rationaleescape routes, would allow construction that poses a significant risk to occupants.
RB169-16 XRB170-16 X This should be a universal minimum
requirement, as it is in the IBC, and not an optional appendix.
RB175-16 X I disagree that the minimum slope would create problems with zero lot buildings, and any conflicts with site development plans are easily addressed.
RB190-16 X The live load criteria should be in alignment with the ASCE 7-16.
RB197-16 X The current requirement of 6 mil minimum thickness has been demonstrated as sufficient. Consumers are free to use thicker barriers, but in many areas, the cost would outweigh the benefit.
G6-16 Part II X Support with Public Comment 1, but otherwise oppose.
RB200-16 X Support with Public Comment 1.RB201-16 X Support with Public Comment 1.RB202-16 X Support as modifiedRB209-16 X This helps to allow for new and
innovative designs for materials and fasteners, while maintaining an adequate level of safety.
RB211-16 X This seems to try to supplant the work of a professional engineer with a blanket design, or series thereof, that may or may not provide adequate structural stability in all situations.
RB217-16 XRB223-16 X Support with Public Comment 1.RB232-16 X Support with Public Comment 2.RB235-16 X Support with Public Comment 2.RB242-16 XRB251-16 X This would be difficult to enforce due to
the sealing requirements of the energy code, and I foresee conflicts with existing pre-engineered designs that have been successful.
RB252-16 X Deviation from manufacturer instructions is improper in many
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 15 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral Rationaleinstances, and the change would unnecessarily increase the workload of the building department.
RB253-16 XRB257-16 X The simple requirement to provide a
label specifying the capabilities of the garage door is sound and logical, and would present a small impact only on manufacturers. Most manufacturers already voluntarily label their products, and it is recognized as good practice.
RB259-16 Moved to CARB265-16 X The newly referenced standard appears
to provide the requirements of the multiple currently referenced standards. The change reduces confusion and reduced the likelihood of conflicts.
RB266-16 X The change is intended to clarify current requirements, but it fails to do so, and in fact, it seems to add confusion as written. Needs to be reworked.
RB267-16 withdrawnRB270-16 XRB271-16 Part I X Unnecessarily adds cost and
involvement to builders and building officials without actually modifying the requirements for vapor retarders.
RB271-16 Part II X Smoke testing is obsolete. A flow rate report detailing the system performance is highly beneficial, and provides for a more scientific and reliable approach to ventilation system inspection and approval.
RB272-16 X Support with Public Comment 2.RB273-16 withdrawnRB277-16 XRB278-16 withdrawnRB281-16 XRB282-16 Moved to CARB283-16 XRB285-16 withdrawnRB286-16 X The determination of equivalency to the
benchmark of No. 15 felt is not clear, even in the modified language.
Dennis Stanley
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 16 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleRB287-16RB289-16RB291-16RB295-16RB298-16RB299-16RB300-16RB301-16RB302-16RB303-16RE189-16 Part IIRB304-16RB311-16RB312-16RB322-16RB327-16RB328-16RB331-16RB336-16RB337-16G19-16 Part IIS28-16 Part IIS29-16 Part IIS34-16 Part IIS18-16 Part IIRB345-16S41-16 Part IIS42-16 Part IIRB361-16RB362-16RB363-16RB372-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 17 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleEB41-16EB35-16S5-16 Part IEB48-16EB55-16EB56-16EB57-16EB58-16
IBC – STRUCTURALDennis StanleyFS3-16FS5-16FS6-16S1-16S7-16S12-16S13-16S15-16S16-16S17-16S19-16S20-16S22-16S23-16S37-16S46-16G17-16 Part IS53-16Joe BelcherS55-16S316-16S61-16S63-16S71-16S72-16S314-16S315-16S73-16S74-16G32-16S77-16S78-16S81-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 18 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleS88-16G29-16S91-16S93-16S95-16S98-16S101-16S103-16S105-16S107-16S108-16S109-16S110-16S112-16S113-16S114-16S317-16S116-16S318-16S118-16S120-16S121-16S122-16S125-16S129-16S313-16S136-16S137-16S138-16S145-16S146-16S147-16S149-16Gregory YoungS153-16S154-16S163-16S166-16S169-16S179-16S180-16S189-16S196-16S203-16
BOAF CDC Final Action Hearing assignments Due September 28, 2016Page 19 of 19 return to: [email protected]
Code Support Oppose Neutral RationaleS206-16S209-16S218-16S220-16S225-16S226-16S231-16S232-16S235-16S236-16S238-16S241-16S242-16S245-16 Part IS245-16 Part IIS250-16S252-16S259-16S260-16S263-16 Part IS263-16 Part IIRB313-16S264-16S265-16S267-16S268-16S277-16S278-16S279-16S296-16S299-16S301-16S302-16S303-16S304-16S306-16S308-16
