18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
1/XX
CESI Research
Centre
D.E.A. Università degli studi di Brescia
Mobility and Environmental
Agency of Milan
Toulouse, 18-19/11/2004
Guido Pirovano - Environmental Studies, CESI [email protected]
D.S.T.A.Università degli studi
Amedeo Avogadro
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
2/XX
Model intercomparison
with regard to:
• JNO2
• JO3
• O3 deposition velocity
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
3/XX
Photolysis rates - MethodologyPhotolysis rates - Methodology
“Reference state”:
25th June 2001 - Hour 12.00 UTC - 10 m agl
Comparisons concerning:
- Different models: CAMx, MOCAGE 1, AZUR, CHIMERE 1, RAMS-CHIMIE 1/2
- Different hours: 9.00, 12.00, 15.00 UTC
- Different heights: 10, 500, 4000 m agl
- Different IOP: IOP2a, IOP2b (IOP1,IOP3)
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
4/XX
Photolysis rates - CAMx approachPhotolysis rates - CAMx approach
Jclear = f(, h, O3 Col, Albedo, Haze)
J = Jclear[1+Fc(Ac-1)]
Ac > 1 above cloud layer
Ac < 1 below/inside cloud layer
Ac = f(Lw, z,
for the 22nd and 25th June Ac = 1.
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
5/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
6/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 09.0009.00 - 10 m agl - 10 m agl
CAMx MOCAGE
AZUR
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
7/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 15.0015.00 - 10 m agl - 10 m agl
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
8/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - CAMx profilesCAMx profiles
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
SEA
PLAIN
HILLS
JNO2 -- HILLS - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JNO2 -- SEA - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JNO2 -- PLAIN - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
9/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 500500 m agl m agl
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
10/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 40004000 m agl m agl
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
11/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 - - 25 June 2001 - 22 June 22 June CAMx CAMx
JNO2 -- SEA - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JNO2 -- PLAIN - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JNO2 -- SEA - 22/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JNO2 -- SEA - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JNO2 -- PLAIN - 22/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4[s-1 E-2]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
12/XX
JNOJNO22 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
13/XX
JNOJNO22 - - 2222 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
14/XX
JNOJNO22 - H 12.00 - - H 12.00 - O3 H 15.00O3 H 15.0022 June15 June 25 June 2 July
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
15/XX
JJOO33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl
CAMx R-CHIMIE 2
MOCAGE
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
16/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 09.0009.00 - 10 m agl - 10 m agl
CAMx R-CHIMIE 2
AZUR
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
17/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 15.0015.00 - 10 m agl - 10 m agl
CAMx
R-CHIMIE 1
AZUR
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
18/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - CAMx profilesCAMx profiles
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
SEA
PLAIN
HILLS
JO3 -- SEA - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JO3 -- PLAIN - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JO3 -- HILLS - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
19/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 500500 m agl m agl
CAMx
MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
20/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 40004000 m agl m agl
CAMx
MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
21/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 - - 25 June 2001 - 22 June 22 June CAMx CAMx
JO3 -- SEA - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JO3 -- PLAIN - 25/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JO3 -- SEA - 22/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
JO3 -- PLAIN - 22/06/2004
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6[s-1 E-5]
[m a
gl]
9
12
15
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
22/XX
JOJO33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl
CAMx R-CHIMIE 2
MOCAGE
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
23/XX
JOJO33 - - 2222 June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl June 2001 H 12.00 - 10 m agl
CAMx
MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
24/XX
JOJO33 and JNO and JNO22 - H 12.00 ---- O3 - H 15.00 - H 12.00 ---- O3 - H 15.0022 June15 June 25 June 2 July
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
25/XX
JNOJNO22 - - SummarySummary
25/6- 9.00
0.8
[s-1 1E-2]630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
25/6-12.00
25/6-15.00
22/6-12.00CX
1.3
MO
0.6
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
1.0
MO
0.8
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
1.3
MO
0.85
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
1.4
MO
1.1
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
1.4
MO10 m 500 m 4000 m
0.7
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
1.0
MO
Range of variability
± 12% - ± 25%
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
26/XX
JOJO33 - - SummarySummary
25/6- 9.00
3.25
[s-1 1E-5]630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
1.001.251.501.752.002.252.502.753.003.253.503.754.004.254.504.755.00
[s-1 E-5]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
25/6-12.00
25/6-15.00
22/6-12.00CX/MO
4.5
RC2
2.0
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
AZ
3.25
RC2
3.25
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
4.25
RC2
3.75
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
5.0
RC2
4.25
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
MO
5.0
RC1/210 m
500 m 4000 m
1.75
630 650 670 690 710 730 750U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
CX
2.75
AZ
Range of variability
± 8% - ± 24%
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
27/XX
Ozone Dry deposition velocity - MethodologyOzone Dry deposition velocity - Methodology
“Reference state”:
25th June 2001 - Hour 12.00 UTC
Comparisons concerning:
- Different models: CAMx, MOCAGE 1, AZUR, CHIMERE 1, RAMS-CHIMIE 1/2
- Different hours: 0.00, 6.00, 12.00, 18.00 UTC
- Different IOP: IOP2a, IOP2b (IOP1,IOP3)
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
28/XX
O3 dry deposition velocity - Models approachO3 dry deposition velocity - Models approach
All considered models implement
a “resistance approach” (Wesely)
sbad rrrv
1
Resistances are functions mainly of:
- Turbulence intensity
- Land use features
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
29/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
30/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 00.0000.00
CAMxAll Models
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
31/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 06.0006.00
CAMx
R-CHIMIE 1/2AZUR
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
MOCAGE
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
32/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - 25 June 2001 H - 25 June 2001 H 18.0018.00
CAMx
MOCAGE
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
AZUR
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
33/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00 - 25 June 2001 H 12.00
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
34/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - - 2222 June 2001 H 12.00 June 2001 H 12.00
CAMx MOCAGE
R-CHIMIE 1/2
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
35/XX
Vdep OVdep O33 - H 12.00 - H 12.00
22 June15 June 25 June 2 July
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
36/XX
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s -1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s -1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s-1 E -2]
630 650 670 690 710 730 750UTM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870
UT
M k
m
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
0.4
00
.50
0.6
00
.70
0.8
00
.90
1.0
01
.10
1.2
01
.30
1.4
01
.50
1.6
01
.70
1.8
01
.90
[s -1 E -2]
Vdep OVdep O33 - - Summary of Maximum valuesSummary of Maximum values
0.6
[cm s-1]
25/6
22/6RC1/2
1.8
MO
0.2
All
0.6
RC1/2
1.0
MO
0.6
RC1/2
1.8
MO
H 0.00
Range of variability
± 25% - ± 50%
0.6
MO
1.0
AZ
630 650 670 690 710 730 750
U TM km
4730
4750
4770
4790
4810
4830
4850
4870U
TM
km
Marseille
Aix en ProvenceSaint Chamas
Toulon
Port de Bouc
Avignon
[cm /s] 0.0
00
.20
0.4
00
.60
0.8
01
.00
1.2
01
.40
1.6
01
.80
2.0
02
.20
2.4
02
.60
H 18.00H 12.00H 6.00
18-19 November 2004
Guido Pirovano - CESI
37/XX
ConclusionsConclusions
• J clearly depends on hour and height, but to a lesser extent on IOP and horizontal coordinate (except for MOCAGE)
• Models usually have shown a coherent behaviour, more for JNO2 than JO3
• O3 concentrations are not directly linked to J values
• Models have highlighted a range of variability of 12% to 25% for both rates
• Vdep is function of both time and space (turbulence and Land use)
• Models estimations have shown a quite coherent behaviour
• Range of variability among models spans from 25% to 50% (for the maximum value over the domain)