Prepared by:
Dragan Stojanovic, CARotman School of Management, University of Toronto
Chapter Chapter 1919
Pensions and Other Employee Future Pensions and Other Employee Future BenefitsBenefits
2
Pensions and Other Pensions and Other Employee Future BenefitsEmployee Future Benefits
Introduction Introduction and Benefit and Benefit Plan BasicsPlan Basics•Introduction
•Defined contribution plans
•Defined benefit plans
•Nature of pension plans
Presentation, Presentation, Disclosure, and Disclosure, and AnalysisAnalysis•Presentation
•Disclosures
•Illustration
•Analysis
Defined Benefit Defined Benefit Pension PlansPension Plans•The employer’s obligation
•Plan assets
•Funded status
•Benefit cost components
•Immediate recognition approach
•Deferral and amortization approach
•Other considerations
•Comparison of results
•Other defined benefit plans
IFRS / Private IFRS / Private Enterprise Enterprise GAAP GAAP ComparisonComparison•Comparison of IFRS and private enterprise GAAP
•Looking ahead
3
Pensions and Other Pensions and Other Employee Future BenefitsEmployee Future Benefits
Introduction Introduction and Benefit and Benefit Plan BasicsPlan Basics•Introduction
•Defined contribution plans
•Defined benefit plans
•Nature of pension plans
Presentation, Presentation, Disclosure, and Disclosure, and AnalysisAnalysis•Presentation
•Disclosures
•Illustration
•Analysis
Defined Benefit Defined Benefit Pension PlansPension Plans•The employer’s obligation
•Plan assets
•Funded status
•Benefit cost components
•Immediate recognition approach
•Deferral and amortization approach
•Other considerations
•Comparison of results
•Other defined benefit plans
IFRS / Private IFRS / Private Enterprise Enterprise GAAP GAAP ComparisonComparison•Comparison of IFRS and private enterprise GAAP
•Looking ahead
4
Benefit PlansBenefit Plans
• Three examples of benefit plans:1. Pension and other post-retirement plans
(e.g. health care and life insurance)2. Post-employment benefit plans (e.g.
severance benefits and long-term disability benefits)
3. Compensated absences (e.g. parental leaves, unrestricted sabbatical leaves)
5
Benefit PlansBenefit Plans• Employee future-benefit plans can be:
1. Defined contribution (DC) plans• Specifies the contributions or payments into the
plan• Does not specify the benefits the employees will
receive or method used to determine benefits2. Defined benefit (DB) plans
• These are any benefit plans that are not a defined contribution plan
• Further subdivided as:a. Benefits that vest or accumulateb. Benefits that do not vest or accumulate
6
• Employer contributes a defined sum (either a fixed sum or related to salary) to a third party– Ownership of plan assets assumed by
plan trustee– Trustee is responsible for investment and
distribution of plan assets• Employee assumes the economic risk
– No guarantee made by employer as to benefits paid
• Cost of the plan in the current year is known with certainty
Defined Contribution PlansDefined Contribution Plans
7
Defined Contribution PlansDefined Contribution Plans• Liability reported if contribution (funding) is less than
required• Asset reported if the amount contributed is more
than required for the period• When plan is first established or when there is an
amendment to the plan, the employer may be obligated to make contributions for previous employee services (called prior or past service cost)
8
Defined Contribution Plans:Defined Contribution Plans:Employers’ Journal EntriesEmployers’ Journal Entries
Contribution madeContribution madeis less thanis less than
the pension expensethe pension expense
Pension Expense DrPension Expense Dr Cash CrCash Cr Accrued PensionAccrued Pension Liability CrLiability Cr
LiabilityLiability
Contribution madeContribution madeis moreis more
than pension expensethan pension expense
Pension Expense DrPension Expense DrAccrued PensionAccrued PensionAsset DrAsset Dr Cash CrCash Cr
AssetAsset
9
Pension PlansPension Plans
• A pension plan provides benefits (payments) to retirees for services provided during employment
• Employer sponsors and contributes to fund, and incurs the cost of the pension plan– Accounting for the employer
• Pension plan receives the contributions, administers pension assets, and makes pension payments to the beneficiaries– Accounting for the pension plan
10
COMPANYCOMPANY TRUSTTRUST
Pension Fund Stream Pension Fund Stream
Pension ExpensePension Expense
Cash paid to pension Cash paid to pension plan (funding)plan (funding)
Accrued pension Accrued pension asset/liabilityasset/liability
$$PlanPlan
AssetsAssets
Retirees (pension benefits)Retirees (pension benefits)
11
• Contributory– Employee and employer make contributions to the
plan • Non-contributory
– Employers bear the full cost of the pension plan– No contributions made by employee
• Vested– Amounts in the plan become the legal property of
the employee• Employee is entitled to receive benefits even
after leaving the employ of the corporation
Pension TerminologyPension Terminology
12
Defined Benefit Pension Defined Benefit Pension PlansPlans
• It is a benefit plan that pension benefits to be received by employee after retiring
• The trust’s main goal is to ensure there will be enough pension assets to pay employer’s obligation to employees when they retire
• Example: employee will receive an annual pension benefit on retirement equal to 2% of average best three years of salary multiplied by years of service
• Pension benefits are based on a formula:– Employee’s years of service and expected salary
level at retirement are usually key variables
13
Defined Benefit Pension PlansDefined Benefit Pension Plans
• Employer is the beneficiary of a defined benefit trust • Pension obligations belong to the employer• The employer remains liable to ensure benefit
payments, no matter what happens in the trust• Employer assumes economic risks• Cost of plan not known with certainty, as it depends
on uncertain future variables (e.g. employee turnover, mortality, inflation)
• The pension expense is not same as cash funding contribution
• Actuarial assumptions used extensively in accounting for defined benefit plans
14
Pensions and Other Pensions and Other Employee Future BenefitsEmployee Future Benefits
Introduction Introduction and Benefit and Benefit Plan BasicsPlan Basics•Introduction
•Defined contribution plans
•Defined benefit plans
•Nature of pension plans
Presentation, Presentation, Disclosure, and Disclosure, and AnalysisAnalysis•Presentation
•Disclosures
•Illustration
•Analysis
Defined Benefit Defined Benefit Pension PlansPension Plans•The employer’s obligation
•Plan assets
•Funded status
•Benefit cost components
•Immediate recognition approach
•Deferral and amortization approach
•Other considerations
•Comparison of results
•Other defined benefit plans
IFRS / Private IFRS / Private Enterprise Enterprise GAAP GAAP ComparisonComparison•Comparison of IFRS and private enterprise GAAP
•Looking ahead
15
Defined Benefit Pension Defined Benefit Pension PlansPlans
• Three methods of measuring the pension obligation valuation
1. Vested benefit obligation– Based on current salary levels– Includes only vested benefits
2. Accumulated benefit obligation– Based on current salary levels– Includes both vested and non-vested service
3. Projected benefit obligation– Based on future salary levels– Includes both vested and non-vested service
16
Defined Benefit Pension Defined Benefit Pension PlansPlans
• Projected benefit obligation is considered the best measure for accounting purposes
• Present value of vested and non-vested benefits earned as at reporting date (using future salary levels) is called accrued benefit obligation (ABO) for accounting purposes.
• Accrued benefit obligation (ABO) for funding purposes may be based on different variables.
17
Pension Liability Pension Liability MeasurementMeasurement
Vested benefit obligation
Accumulated benefitobligation
Projected benefit obligation
Pro-rated on servicePro-rated on salaries
Pension obligation
Present value of the estimated future benefits to be paid to employees
18
Projected Benefit ObligationProjected Benefit Obligation
• Pro-rated on salaries–Annual expense based on percentage of
total estimated compensation earned by the employees over their career
• Pro-rated on services–Annual expense based on the total
estimated benefit being allocated evenly over the years of service of the employee
–Recommended method
19
Accrued Benefit Obligation Accrued Benefit Obligation (ABO)(ABO)
Accrued benefit obligation, beginning+ Current service cost+ Interest cost- Benefits paid to retirees+/- Past service costs of plan amendments
during period+/- Actuarial gains (-) or losses (+) = Accrued benefit obligation, end of period
20
Interest CostsInterest Costs
What rate should be used?• Current market rate
– Determined by reference to current yield on high-quality debt instrument (e.g. corporate bonds)
– IFRS and PE GAAP• Settlement rate
– Implied rate on insurance contract that would effectively settle pension obligation
– Allowed under PE GAAP
21
Plan AssetsPlan Assets Plan assets, fair value at beginning
+ Contributions +/- Actual return *- Benefits paid to retirees
= Plan assets, fair value at end of period
* Actual return = Expected return + actuarial gain on assets
or – actuarial loss on assets
22
Funded StatusFunded Status
Accrued Benefit Obligation (ABO)- Fair Value of plan assets= Funded status
• ABO > Plan assets = underfunded = funded status liability
• ABO < Plan assets = overfunded = funded status asset
23
• Components that change ABO and fund assets (therefore, funded status) include:
1. Current service cost2. Interest cost3. Past service cost4. Return on plan assets5. Actuarial gains and losses
Components ofComponents of Pension Benefit Cost Pension Benefit Cost
24
• Pension cost should be accrued and recognized in accounting periods that benefit from employees’ service
• Two approaches to accounting for pension expense
– Immediate recognition approach• Allowed under PE GAAP
– Deferral and amortization approach• Required under IFRS• Allowed under PE GAAP
Accounting for PensionsAccounting for Pensions
25
Immediate Recognition ApproachImmediate Recognition Approach
Pension Expense
Current servicecost
+
Current interestcost
+
Actual return onPlan Assets
Past Service Costsrecognizedimmediately
Actuarialgains/lossesrecognizedImmediately
+ or + or
Immediate Recognition Immediate Recognition ApproachApproach
• ABO and fund assets are not recognized as separate balance sheet accounts (they are off-balance sheet or memo accounts)
• Accrued pension asset/liability recorded on the balance sheet represents the net position or funded status
• ABO is based on valuation used for funding purposes, not based on projected benefits obligation
• Because all changes are recognized immediately (i.e. actuarial gains/losses and post service costs), pension expense is highly variable from year to year
26
27
• Used to accumulate information needed for the formal journal entries and to keep track of the relevant pension plan items and components reported off-balance sheet
The Pension WorksheetThe Pension Worksheet
28
Immediate Recognition - ExampleImmediate Recognition - ExampleGeneral Journal Entries Memo Record
Items Annual Pension Expense
Cash Accrued Pension
A/L
Accrued Benefit
Obligation
Plan Assets
Bal. Jan 1 2010 0 100,000 Cr. 100,000 Dr.
a) Service cost 9,000 Dr. 9,000 Cr.
b) Interest cost 10,000 Dr 10,000 Cr.
c) Actual return 10,000 Cr. 10,000 Dr.
d) Contributions 8,000 Cr. 8,000 Dr.
e) Benefits paid 7,000 Dr. 7,000 Cr.
Expense entry, 2010 9,000 Dr. 9,000 Cr.Contribution Entry, 2010 8,000 Cr. 8,000 Cr.
Balance Dec. 31, 2010 1,000 Cr. 112,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr.
29
Immediate Recognition - Immediate Recognition - ExampleExample
To record Expense:Pension Expense 9,000 Accrued Pension Asset/Liab 9,000
To record contribution:Accrued Pension Asset/Liab 8,000
Cash 8,000
30
Immediate Recognition - ExampleImmediate Recognition - ExampleGeneral Journal Entries Memo Record
Items Annual Pension Expense
Cash Accrued Pension
A/L
Accrued Benefit
Obligation
Plan Assets
Bal. Dec. 31 2010 1,000 Cr. 112,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr.
f) Past service cost 80,000 Dr. 80,000 Cr.
a) Service cost 9,500 Dr. 9,500 Cr.
b) Interest cost 19,200 Dr 19,200 Cr.
c) Actual return 11,100 Cr. 11,100 Dr.
d) Contributions 20,000 Cr. 20,000 Dr.
e) Benefits paid 8,000 Dr. 8,000 Cr.
Expense entry, 2011 97,600 Dr. 97,600 Cr.Contribution Entry, 2011 20,000 Cr. 20,000 Cr.
Balance Dec. 31, 2011 78,600 Cr. 212,700 Cr. 134,100 Dr.
31
Immediate Recognition - Immediate Recognition - ExampleExample
To record Expense:Pension Expense 97,600 Accrued Pension Asset/Liab 97,600
To record contribution:Accrued Pension Asset/Liab 20,000 Cash 20,000
32
Deferral and Amortization Deferral and Amortization Approach Approach
Pension Expense
Current serviceCost
+
Current interestcost
+
Expected return onPlan Assets
Amortization of Past Service Costs
Amortization of Net Actuarial Gain
or Loss
+ or + or
33
Amortization of Past Service Amortization of Past Service Costs (PSC)Costs (PSC)
• Past service costs arise from either the initial adoption of a pension plan or an amendment to the existing plan
• Under PE GAAP, past service costs are not recognized initially– They are amortized (straight-line) to pension expense
over the expected period of benefit from change in plan
• Under IFRS– Vested benefits are expensed immediately
– Benefits not vested are amortized (straight-line) over average period until benefits become vested
• Unamortized balances remain off-balance sheet and are known as unamortized PSC or unrecognized PSC.
34
• Assets gains and losses– The assets in the pension plan earn income and
this income reduces the cost of the pension to the company
– Since actual returns can vary significantly year to year, the expected rate is used under the defer-and-amortize approach
– Long-term rate of return is applied to fair value of plan assets at the beginning of the year
– Gains and losses occur when actual returns are different from expected returns
Actuarial Gains and LossesActuarial Gains and Losses
35
• Liability gains and losses– Also known as actuarial (experience) gains and
losses– Caused by
• Changes in actuarial assumptions • Actual experience in ABO differing from actuarial
(expected) experience
Actuarial Gains and LossesActuarial Gains and Losses
36
Actuarial Gains and LossesActuarial Gains and Losses
• These gains/losses are not initially recognized• Over time, accumulated effect of the changes
(net gains/losses) may even out• Corridor approach adopted to allow for
circumstances where no accumulating offset occurs
• Amortization used only when the opening unrecognized gains/losses are greater than 10% of the larger of the beginning-of-period balances of the ABO and the fair value of Plan Assets
• If so, amortize excess over expected average remaining service life (EARSL), determined by actuary
• Other amortization approaches are also allowed
37
Corridor Approach - ExampleCorridor Approach - Example
2010 2011 2012
ABO, January 1 $2,100,000 $2,600,000 $2,900,000
FV Plan Assets, Jan. 1 2,600,000 2,800,000 2,700,000
Net Actuarial Loss (gain) 400,000 300,000 (170,000)
Corridor – 10% of the larger of the ABO or PA
260,000 280,000 290,000
Cumulative Net Actuarial Loss (Beginning of Year)
0 400,000 678,182
Excess 0 120,000 388,182
Current Year Amortization 0 21,818 70,579
38
Corridor Approach - Corridor Approach - ExampleExample
• Opening Net Actuarial Loss in 2011 $400,000
Less: Corridor 280,000
Excess over corridor $120,000
– Amortized over 5.5 years – Amount amortized in 2012 = $21,818 (120,000 / 5.5)
• The minimum amortization is the accumulated gain or loss in excess of the corridor amount divided by the expected average remaining service life of employee group (EARSL)
39
Options within Defer-and-Options within Defer-and-Amortize ApproachAmortize Approach
• Both PE GAAP and IFRS allow for option to immediately recognize actuarial gains and losses into income
• IFRS also allows for immediate recognition in other comprehensive income (OCI) rather than net income
40
Valuation of Accrued Valuation of Accrued Benefit AssetBenefit Asset
• Accrued benefit asset cannot exceed expected future benefits (valuation allowance may be necessary to reduce the value on statement of financial position)
• Change in valuation allowance is generally recognized through benefit expense
41
Other Defined Benefit Plans Other Defined Benefit Plans withwith
Benefits that Vest or Benefits that Vest or AccumulateAccumulate• E.g. post-retirement health care benefits
• Accrual accounting is appropriate for post-retirement benefits, post-employment benefits and compensated absences
• Since the right to the benefit is earned by rendering service, the cost and related liability are accrued as employee provides service
• Under PE GAAP, defined benefit plans where benefits vest or accumulate based on service are accounted for in same way as defined benefit pension plans
• IFRS also follows same approach as for pension plans, except that actuarial gains/losses and past service costs are expensed as they occur
42
Defined Benefit Plans with Defined Benefit Plans with Benefits that Do Not Vest or Benefits that Do Not Vest or
AccumulateAccumulate
• E.g. parental leave plans (in excess of what government provides), long-term disability plans
• Use “event accrual” method to accrue full cost• When event occurs that obligates entity:Benefit Expense xx Benefit Liability xx• When the compensated absence is taken:Benefit Liability xx Cash xx
43
Pensions and Other Pensions and Other Employee Future BenefitsEmployee Future Benefits
Introduction Introduction and Benefit and Benefit Plan BasicsPlan Basics•Introduction
•Defined contribution plans
•Defined benefit plans
•Nature of pension plans
Presentation, Presentation, Disclosure, and Disclosure, and AnalysisAnalysis•Presentation
•Disclosures
•Illustration
•Analysis
Defined Benefit Defined Benefit Pension PlansPension Plans•The employer’s obligation
•Plan assets
•Funded status
•Benefit cost components
•Immediate recognition approach
•Deferral and amortization approach
•Other considerations
•Comparison of results
•Other defined benefit plans
IFRS / Private IFRS / Private Enterprise Enterprise GAAP GAAP ComparisonComparison•Comparison of IFRS and private enterprise GAAP
•Looking ahead
44
PresentationPresentation
• Accrued benefit assets/liabilities– Generally reported separately for each
benefit plan (unless all plans result in asset or liability)
– Generally classified as long-term• Benefit costs
– Components of benefit costs may be reported together or separately on the income statement
45
Disclosure RequirementsDisclosure Requirements
• Disclosures under PE GAAP include:– Description of each plan and any major
changes in terms during the year– Information on most recent actuarial
valuation for funding purposes– Funded status at year end, (including FV of
plan assets and ABO)– Explanation of differences between funded
status and amounts recorded on balance sheet
46
Disclosure RequirementsDisclosure Requirements
• Additional disclosure requirements under IFRS include:– Reconciliations:
• Beginning to ending balances of PV of ABO and FV of fund assets
• Funded status to balance sheet benefit liability or asset
– Amount included in periodic net income (and OCI)– Underlying assumptions and sensitivity information– Estimate of following year’s expected funding
contributions
47
AnalysisAnalysis
• Analysis generally focuses on predicting future cash flow obligations
• It is very important to validate the major assumptions underlying the fund status and future cash requirements, especially– Discount rate used to measure ABO– Expected rate of return on fund assets
• Small changes in key variables can have a very significant impact
48
Pensions and Other Pensions and Other Employee Future BenefitsEmployee Future Benefits
Introduction Introduction and Benefit and Benefit Plan BasicsPlan Basics•Introduction
•Defined contribution plans
•Defined benefit plans
•Nature of pension plans
Presentation, Presentation, Disclosure, and Disclosure, and AnalysisAnalysis•Presentation
•Disclosures
•Illustration
•Analysis
Defined Benefit Defined Benefit Pension PlansPension Plans•The employer’s obligation
•Plan assets
•Funded status
•Benefit cost components
•Immediate recognition approach
•Deferral and amortization approach
•Other considerations
•Comparison of results
•Other defined benefit plans
IFRS / Private IFRS / Private Enterprise Enterprise GAAP GAAP ComparisonComparison•Comparison of IFRS and private enterprise GAAP
•Looking ahead
49
Looking AheadLooking Ahead
• IFRS requirements continue to evolve with a new exposure draft expected in 2010, and a new standard in 2011
50
Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons Canada, Ltd. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons Canada, Ltd. All rights reserved. Reproduction or translation of All rights reserved. Reproduction or translation of this work beyond that permitted by Access Copyright this work beyond that permitted by Access Copyright (The Canadian Copyright Licensing Agency) is (The Canadian Copyright Licensing Agency) is unlawful. Requests for further information should be unlawful. Requests for further information should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Canada, Ltd. The purchaser may make Wiley & Sons Canada, Ltd. The purchaser may make back-up copies for his or her own use only and not back-up copies for his or her own use only and not for distribution or resale. The author and the for distribution or resale. The author and the publisher assume no responsibility for errors, publisher assume no responsibility for errors, omissions, or damages caused by the use of these omissions, or damages caused by the use of these programs or from the use of the information programs or from the use of the information contained herein.contained herein.
COPYRIGHTCOPYRIGHT