Challenges and Opportunities in Composting Organic Waste
Harold KeenerFood, Agricultural and Biological Engineering
OARDC/The Ohio State UniversityWooster, OH 44691keener.3 @osu.edu
International Symposium on Climate Change and Food Security in South Asia
Dhaka, Bangladash. August 25-30, 2008.
Challenge
• Challenge today is reducing fossil fuel use. Why:– Fossil fuel use leads to CO2 generation– Limited supply –what going do when exhausted– Economic well being of countries
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 2
Reflective Thoughts on Standard of Living (Keener, 2008)
• Food kcal/person gprotein/person• Energy watts/person• Income $/person• Quality m2/person
In all measures two variables. To increase the measure increase numerator, decrease denominator. Comes to CO2 reduction, may have to face up to reducing denominator
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 3
US Policy –mitigate CO2 (HM Keener, 2008)
• Zero Dependence on Foreign Oil within 20-30 years
• Achieve dramatic reductions in net CO2 generation.
1. Renewables- wind & solar (electricity)2. Bio-based economy3. Other Mass transits, etc.
Don’t believe can afford H2 economy. Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 4
Bio-based Economy
• An important solution to reducing fossil fuel consumption
{Solar + CO2 + Nutrients} {Raw Chemical Feedstock}
Chemical feedstock replaces petroleum so don’t increase net CO2 release. (possibly even reduce)
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 5
Wind,Solar,Bio-Mass• Wind - U.S. electrical needs• Solar – Off the grid, homes both rural and urban. (In Ohio
Amish already use for lighting (DC) low investment. ?? What about microwave cooking in country.
• Bio-mass – Waste recovery ->Need to connect city with food
producer, etc. for nutrients– Algae farms –> C20 hydrocarbons as chemical feedstock
for diesels, plastics, also fraction for food, feed– Plants -> food, feed, fiber, chemical feedstock
(Reduction in livestock numbers)
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 6
Composting is important part of Solution
• Aim is to capture nutrients now going to rivers and oceans or atmosphere and reuse these nutrients so we have sustainable system. Avoid new sources of nutrients(N,P,K,…requires excessive energy and cost.)
• Look at what’s happened to fertilizer cost and supply around world. Doubling, trippling cost in United States.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 7
Composting’s Importance• Reduces disease transmission• Stabilizes product-
– eliminates odors & breeding ground for pest• Easy to transport, use, has nutrient value• Provides disease control in plant production
systems• Minimize pollution from runoff, slow
release of nutrients Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 8
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 9
Composting Process
Water Vapor, CO2 , Heat
Microbes
Oxygen
Fresh Organic Material Stabilized Organic Residue
25-75 % less volume
Science of Composting
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 10
Municipal Solid Waste
Manures, Mortality
BioSolids
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 11
• MSW:– Mixed MSW (Number decreasing) 15 facilities– Food Waste 138– Yard Trimmings 3316
• BioSolids 250• Farm Waste/Animal Mortality >5000
* Data for 1997.
Composting In USA*
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 12
U.S. Municipal Solid Waste208,000,000 t/yr
Yard Trim m ings18%
Non-Recyclable Paper25%
Other10%Glass
6%
Metals8%
Plastic11%
Recycleable Paper11%
Food Scraps11%
Currently MSW in U.S.: 23% recycled, 7 % composted, 15% burned, 55% land filled
Compost up to 54%Recycle up
to 36%
Residue
OSU/OARDC
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 13
Challenges in Composting MSW• Need to be source separated Examples: yard
trimmings, food waste. • Food Waste – Need to use bio-degradable
packaging and eating utensils. • Food Waste – Economics of on site versus off
site
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 14Kaufman et al., 2004, USEPA
Composting of Yard Trimmings
• Over 3200 sites in U.S.• Unknown how many mulch operations• Compost value $20-60/t
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 15
Static Pile Composting of Yard Trimmings (PTI, Seattle, Washington)
Compost Systems
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 16
Static Pile Composting of Yard Trimmings(Price Barnes, Delaware, Ohio)
Compost Systems
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 17
New Milford Farms, Inc./Nestlé USA, Inc.
50,000 50,000 t/yt/y of raw materials :of raw materials :••Yard Yard wastes,Agriculturalwastes,Agricultural wasteswastes
““DistressedDistressed”” Food ProductsFood Products••Food manufacturers and grocery Food manufacturers and grocery stores,damagedstores,damaged, recalled, etc., recalled, etc.
Source Separated OrganicsSource Separated Organics••Food Processors, Grocery StoresFood Processors, Grocery Stores
OperationOperation••Aerated static pilesAerated static piles
••SCARAB windrow turnerSCARAB windrow turner
••Bagged product: Bagged product: HamerHamer form, fill form, fill and sealand seal
••BiofilterBiofilter on exhaust airon exhaust air
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 18
Green Mountain System
On Site Food Waste Composting
Earth Tub
• Composting cost per ton high.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 19
Biosolids Use and Disposal 126,000,000 t/yr *
22% Incineration
1% Other
17% Surface Disposal
7% Landfill Cover,
Aggregate 1% Advanced Treatment
52% Land Application
*6,300,000 dt/yr
Ref: USEPA 1999
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 20
Direct Land Application Composting in Vessel
Biosolids
Composting in Aerated or Static Windrow
Methane Production
Gas CH4
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 21
Aerated Static Pile for Composting Biosolids and Woodchips
(Columbus, Ohio, 2004)
Compost Systems
Biofilter
J. Hoff, 2004
Wedge shaped approach with air pulled through the pile then pushed through a biofilter.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 22
“Ag Bag” used for yard and food waste in California.
Operators claim it is effective in a dryer climate.
Compost Systems
Aerated static pile for composting biosolids/ woodchips in “Ag Bag” did not prove effective in Ohio’s high humidity climate.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 23
Regulations in the U.S.• Process to further reduce pathogens (PFRP) - know as
US EPA 503 regulations. Enacted for biosolids.≥ 55 C for 3 days in-vessel≥ 55 C , 5 turns, 15 days for windrow
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 24
Biosolids Issues in USA• Land application lowest cost: $82/dry t (however,
concerns over pathogens, water quality)
• Composting: $173/ dry t (based on cake 22% ds) New separation technology: 30% solids– reduces amendment 38%, reduces cost ???
• Need to lower composting cost. More efficient operations. Static pile versus in-vessel.
• Anaerobic Treatment -> Methane (still by-product generated)
Livestock Waste
• Cattle (Dairy, Beef)• Poultry (Broiler, Caged Layers)• Swine (Sows, Marketing Hogs)
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 25
ManureMillion Head t/yr
Market Hogs 60.4 29,200,000Beef Cows 33.4 509,800,000
Market Cattle 14.9 133,500,000Milk Cows 9.1 212,100,000
Caged Layers 334 14,400,000Broilers 8500 31,300,000Turkeys 283 8,500,000
Totals 938,800,000
Livestock
Poultry
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 26
Agricultural Waste Issues in USA• Land application has lowest cost (however,
concerns over pathogens, air, water quality. • Transportation of liquid manures beyond 10 km
can exceed value of nutrients in manure.• Some new housing/manure management systems
lend themselves to composting manure.• Need to lower composting cost. • Need to find value added markets for compost.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 27
One million birds use system at DayLay Farms. Manure dries on belt from 70% to 50-55% moisture. Manure goes to compost building.
Manure Belt System with Composting for Poultry
New Technology
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 28
Aerated Turned Windrows. (DayLay Farms, Ohio)
Compost Systems
Unamended poultry manure is composted in the first 45 m of the windrow and turned 18 times during the 54-day process.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 29
Turned Windrow Composting of Dairy Manure & Sawdust.
(Sigrist Farms, Ohio)
Using a skid loader to turn manure. The farm has a
turning machine but seldom uses it.
Compost Systems
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 30
Sigrist Farms finds screening is essential for marketing a quality
product. Market as a bagged product (about 18 kg per bag) as
Bull Country Compost.
Compost is stored under roof for curing, approximately 6 months. Material is then bagged for marketing.
Compost Systems
Sigrist Farms, Ohio
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 31
Turned Windrow Composting of Cattle Manure and Yard Trimmings
(Dan Young Farm, Ohio)Dan Young speaking to a group of farmers, agricultural specialists, university persons at August field day.
Compost turner and water are added to tank. Water addition is
often necessary early in the process if starting with materials less than
60% moisture.
Compost Systems
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 32
In-Vessel Forced Aeration System(Paygro, Ohio)
Compost Systems
Composting of cattle manure and food and yard wastes is completed in 21-28 days.
OSU/OARDC Compost 33
Animals placed on absorbing base and being covered over with 2 ft+ of biofilter material.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 34
Windrow after grinding 65 carcasses6-12 in
12 in12 in
15 ft
8ft
Schematic of composting windrow (intact carcass)
2-3' thermometer
Rule of Thumb:• 250'x250' pad will hold
five 15'x200' windrows• 1 windrow will hold ~100
finishing cattleClean sawdust cover
Soiled amendment or used compost
carcass
Grass filtration strips around the perimeterSoil
Lime base
Static Pile Composting of Dead Animalsas an Alternative to Rendering
John Kube, Elanco Animal Health, Greenfield, IN
Compost Systems
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 35
Bio-Research Building
200 L aerated reactor vessels
Instrumentation
Optimization of the Process
Laboratory at OSU/OARDC Used in Controlled Pilot Scale Studies on Process Kinetics
4L BioReactors in Incubator
Windrow Composting Research Site at OARDC
36
OARDC Pad – 20,000 sq. ft. concrete, 1-2 % slope. Aeration fans
OARDC
Composting Research at OARDC
• Optimization studies - Nitrogen, Moisture, Airflow, ........... Send specific questions to: [email protected]
• Survival of pathogens in manure during liquid storage or composting. E.coli survival (rough type), E.coli survival (smooth type), Salmonella, Listeria , Cryptosporidium, Mycobacterium paratuberculosis
• Bio degradable plastics
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 37
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 38
C/N Effect on Decomposition Rate
Study on mixture of paper mill sludge (PS) and broiler litter (BL). Optimum C/N was approximately 35.
Compost temperature = 60 0C.
Ekinci, OARDC, 2001
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
[C/N]b
Dec
ompo
sitio
n R
ate(
k)(1
/day
)
k(from Equation 10 and 11) k(experimental)
k k e b x= − −max ( )1 2μ
kmax = 0.11b=0.002665
μ = 335.R2 072= .
(b)
Optimization of the Process
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 39
Increasing C/N Reduces NH3 Losses
y = -0.0089x + 0.5712= 0.5872
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
20 30 40 50 60 70Initial CN ratio
N loss (% of initial)
N-Losses during composting dairy manure(% lost of initial amount)
Michel et al., 2004
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 40
Effect of Moisture and Operating Temperature on Decomposition Rates
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
30
35
40
45
50
55
40
50
60
Dec
ompo
sitio
n ra
te,k
, (da
y-1)
Tota
l Mois
ture
Con
tent
, wb.
(%)
Tmeperature (oC)
k=0.0917*e -0.5*[((M-44.51)/18.73)2+((T-57.31)/15.81)2]
R2=0.96
Ekinci, OARDC, 2001
Study on mixture of paper mill sludge (PS) and broiler litter (BL) with C/N = 32. Gaussian function used to describe relationship.
Optimization of the Process
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 41
1 m3/ (kgco day) = 22.3 cfm/ (tonco)
Airflow Requirements Control Temperature
Case Study
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 42
Acids Evaluated: Acetic Propionic IsobutyricButyric Isovaleric Valeric
Aerobic, Low Airflow Destroys Volatile Acids, Reduces Odor
Wiles et al., 2004
( )
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450
T im e (h o u rs )
VFA
Em
issi
ons
(mg)
A c e tic A c id
Prop ion ic A c id
Is obuty r ic A c id
Buty r ic A c id
Is ov a ler ic A c id
V aler ic A c id
Intermittent Aeration Run 173-99 Swine/Sawdust Mixture
0
5
1 0
1 5
2 0
2 5
3 0
3 5
4 0
0 1 0 0 2 0 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 5 0 0
VFA
Em
issi
ons
(mg)
A c e t ic A c id
Pr o p io n ic A c id
Is o b u ty r ic A c id
B u ty r ic A c id
Is o v a le r ic A c id
V a le r ic A c id
Continuous Aeration Run 173-99 Swine/Sawdust Mixture
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 43
Dry Matter Loss
• Stir 1 time/week 15.5% dm loss• Stir 3 times/week 18.1% dm loss
• No water added 17.6% dm loss• Add water 36.1% dm loss
Optimization of the Process
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 44
Bioreactor System
Flow restrictor system(air 100 ±3 ml/min)
Data collection computer
Bioreactor incubators
CO2, O2 and temperaturemeasurement, calibration
and data acquisition.
Water condenser and ammonia trap (4° C.)
OARDC/OSU Study on Pathogens
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 45
Mycobacterium paratuberculosisSawdust Compost 55°C
Straw Compost 55°C
Sawdust Pack 25°C
Straw Pack 25°C
Lagoon storage 25°C
0
1
2
3
0 3 7 14 28 56Day
Posi
tive
Rep
licat
es
*
* *
For detailed information contact [email protected]
OARDC/OSU Study on Pathogens
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 46
Mixing Dairy Cattle Manure
For excel spreadsheet go towww.oardc.ohio-state.edu/ocamm/COEC.htm
ITEM Vol Mass Moist C N C/NRatio Ratio wb db db db
MATERIAL dec dec % % %dairy (free stall) 1.00 1.00 81.2 44.6 2.64 16.9sawdust 1.17 0.33 16.0 49.8 0.16 311.0recycle site compost 0.00 0.00 44.6 43.5 1.50 29.0water 0.00 0.00 1.0 0.0 0.00 0.00
Initial Mix 64.9 47.7 1.16 41.2
Using Compost for Growing Plants
• Provides Nutrients• Improves Soil Structure• Provides Pathogen control
– Organic matter must be decomposed “adequately”(prevent N immobilization, pathogen growth)
– Need to control salt levels (EC) in the compost.– Avoid organic acids (anaerobic decomposition)
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 47
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 48
Plant Response versus Age of Composted Plant Response versus Age of Composted Dairy Manure + Straw or SawdustDairy Manure + Straw or Sawdust
Compost Utilization
Natural Disease Suppression in Compost Mixes
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 49Spring et al., 1980, Phytopathology 70:1209-1212
Peat mix Compost Mix
This Phytophthora root rot bioassay helped prove that natural suppression in compost mixes is effective.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 50
Suppressive potting mix used to control root diseases in potted poinsettia plants.
HAJ Hoitink
New Uses for Compost.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 51
Seven-yr-old Taxus crop transplanted at 1-1.5 yr intervals to sustain natural suppression of root rot. Fungicides are not used in spite of its extreme susceptibilty to Phytophthora root rot!!!!
20 gal pots
Compost Utilization
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 52
Rhizoctonia web blight in a mix suppressive
to Phytophthora root rot
What about other diseases?Compost Utilization
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 53
Suppression of Suppression of RhizoctoniaRhizoctonia
More than 80% of 300 different compost-amended potting mixes tested failed to suppress Rhizoctonia damping-off because specific biocontrol agents failed to colonize the compost naturally!!
The solution is to inoculate potting mixes during formulation with biocontrol agents (egTrichoderma spp.) that destroy Rhizoctonia.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 54
CompostCompost--Induced Systemic Resistance Induced Systemic Resistance (ISR)(ISR)
•• Less than 2% of all types and batches of Less than 2% of all types and batches of composts tested naturally induced ISR. composts tested naturally induced ISR.
•• Specific Specific BacillusBacillus strains and strains and TrichodermaTrichodermaisolates are the most ISRisolates are the most ISR--active active microorganisms in composts.microorganisms in composts.
Krause et al, 2003, Phytopathology 93:1292-1300.
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 55Zhang et al., 1998, Phytopath. 88:450-455
Compost-Induced Systemic Resistance (ISR)
Dhaka Bangladesh2008 OSU/OARDC 56
Overall ConclusionsOverall Conclusions•• Compost stability, nitrogen level and absent of Compost stability, nitrogen level and absent of phytotoxicphytotoxic
compounds are important to have quality compost. compounds are important to have quality compost. Valuable nutrient source.Valuable nutrient source.
•• Quality composts can be used to achieveQuality composts can be used to achieve–– Biological control of root diseases Biological control of root diseases -- natural suppression natural suppression
with composts is practiced widely. with composts is practiced widely. –– Specific suppression requires inoculation.Specific suppression requires inoculation.–– Some foliar diseases controllable by ISRSome foliar diseases controllable by ISR--active composts. active composts. –– ISR still is a novel field of science.ISR still is a novel field of science.