CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.1 04-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) BUHRMAN LAW FIRM 420 ESTATE OF: ) (John R. Buhrman) ) MOTION TO WITHDRAW AND B. G. NAIK ) APPROVAL OF ATTORNEY FEES ) DISPOSITION: 09-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) JOHN R. MELDORF, III 442 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION OF TRUSTEE FOR ) ANNUAL FEES FLORENCE F. KOBUS ) ) DISPOSITION: 09-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) MILLER & MARTIN 600 ESTATE OF: ) (Donald E. Morton) ) MOTION FOR ORDER MARY FRANCES MARLIN ) EXTENDING TIME ) Mark Kinsman ) Paul Cross ) DISPOSITION: 10-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 391 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION FOR INTERIM ) ATTORNEY FEES JOY S. WRIGHT ) ) DISPOSITION:
Transcript
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.1
04-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) BUHRMAN LAW FIRM 420 ESTATE OF: ) (John R. Buhrman) ) MOTION TO WITHDRAW AND B. G. NAIK ) APPROVAL OF ATTORNEY FEES ) DISPOSITION: 09-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) JOHN R. MELDORF, III 442 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION OF TRUSTEE FOR ) ANNUAL FEES FLORENCE F. KOBUS ) ) DISPOSITION: 09-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) MILLER & MARTIN 600 ESTATE OF: ) (Donald E. Morton) ) MOTION FOR ORDER MARY FRANCES MARLIN ) EXTENDING TIME ) Mark Kinsman ) Paul Cross ) DISPOSITION: 10-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 391 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION FOR INTERIM ) ATTORNEY FEES JOY S. WRIGHT ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.2
11-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) SPEARS MOORE REBMAN & 120 ESTATE OF: ) WILLIAMS (Michael Luhowiak) ) MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF FEES DONALD LOUIS WAMP, SR. ) Paul Cross DISPOSITION: Pass to 8-25-14. (Cassie Rieder) 12-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) HUSCH & BLACKWELL 092 ESTATE OF: ) (Joseph C. Simpson) ) MOTION TO APPROVE SALE CHARLOTTE E. JOHNSON ) OF REAL PROPERTY ) DISPOSITION: 12-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 401 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION TO APPROVE ) ATTORNEY FEES CHARLES LYNN ARCHEY ) ) LISA Z. BOWMAN DISPOSITION: 12-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) SUSAN E. ARNOLD 526 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION FOR SALE OF REAL ) PROPERTY JAMES W. ARNOLD ) Luke Neder ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.3
12-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) WEEMS & RONAN 560 ESTATE OF: ) (Kyle R. Weems) ) MOTION TO EXTEND TIME GARY BENJAMIN FILLERS ) DISPOSITION: 13-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) CHAMBLISS BAHNER & STOPHEL 638 ESTATE OF: ) (Ryan Barry) ) MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF PAUL J. WEBBER ) INTERIM ADMINISTRATOR ) FEES ) DISPOSITION: 13-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) JOHNSON & MULROONY 817 ESTATE OF: ) (Linda Norwood) ) MOTION TO APPROVE ALBERT GEORGE ) AUCTION OF REAL ESTATE WIOLAND ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.4
14-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) PATRICK BEARD SCHULMAN & 021 ESTATE OF: ) JACOWAY (Jonathan Guthrie) ) JOINT MOTION TO APPROVE CHARLES DEWITT REED ) SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT ) Arnold Stulce ) H. Diane Dixon DISPOSITION: 14-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 100 ESTATE OF: ) (1) MOTION TO APPROVE ) ADMINISTRATOR’S EXPENSES WILLIAM KENNETH ) (2) MOTION FOR ATTORNEY FEES PENNEY ) ) Arnold Stulce ) DISPOSITION: 14-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 142 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION FOR INTERIM ATTORNEY ) FEES JOHNNIE S. LAWLEY, JR. ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.5
14-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 222 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION FOR INTERIM ATTORNEY ) FEES JIGGS D. SHAFER ) ) DISPOSITION: 14-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) LYNNE DECHMAN 276 ESTATE OF: ) MOTION FOR INTERIM ATTORNEY ) FEES HERMAN STANLEY ) SPENCER, JR. ) ) DISPOSITION: 10- JOANNE CALECA ) MATTHEW J. FITZHARRIS 0834 SANTERO suing individually ) LEROY AND HURST and Derivatively in the Right ) (James Hurst) and for the benefit of ) MOTION TO WITHDRAW REVIVAL COMPANIES, LLC ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) JOHN SANTERO ) BUDDY PRESLEY ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.6
11- EMMA E. PARKS ) TODD HASTEY 0752 ) MOTION TO SET ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) JASON D. REED ) PRO SE ) DISPOSITION: 13- BUILDING MAINTENANCE ) GEORGE M. DERRYBERRY 0159 CONSULTING SERVICES, ) MOTION TO SET INC. ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) ART CATES, individually and ) CHARLES G. WRIGHT D/b/a C&L FLOORS AND ) JANITORIAL SERVICES ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.7
13- ALMA JANE COOK ) CHARLES C. WRIGHT 0161 ) MOTION TO SET ASIDE ORDER ) DISMISSING CAUSE WITH ) PREJUDICE ) ) VS. ) ) ) PVH CORP. (A.K.A. ) FLEISSNER DAVIS & JOHNSON PHILLIPS-VAN HEUSEN ) (C. Scott Johnson) CORPORATION), and ) LIBERTY MUTUAL ) INSURANCE COMPANY ) ) DISPOSITION: Granted. 13- BRANCH BANKING AND ) BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN 0194 TRUST COMPANY ) CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ ) (John M. Phillips) ) MOTION TO SET ORAL ARGUMENT ) ) VS. ) ) ) MICA DEVELOPMENT, LLC ) MICHAEL L. WEST a Tennessee Limited Liability ) Company, and MICHAEL T. ) WHITENER ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.8
JURY DEMAND 13- NAZARETH SAMUELIAN ) MARKEL & MAJOR 0782 ) Chris Markel) ) (1) MOTION TO QUASH OR ENLARGE ) TIME TO TAKE DEPOSITION VS. ) ) ) COVENANT TRANSPORT, ) LEITNER WILLIAMS DOOLEY & INC. ) NAPOLITAN (Charlie Poss) ) (2) MOTION TO COMPEL ) ) DISPOSITION: 14- JOHN M. MCDONALD ) GRANT KONVALINKA &HARRISON 0060 ) (Harry Cash) ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT ) JUDGMENT AND TO SET ) VS. ) ) ) SAIMA A. HASHMI, her ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORDS heirs and assigns, PHILIP D. ) MYERS, his heirs and assigns, ) JOSEPHINE D. MYERS, her ) heirs and assigns, JESSE O. ) FARR, his heirs and assigns ) and ANY AND ALL ) UNKNOWN CLAIMANTS ) OF ANY RIGHT TITLE, ) AND/OR INTEREST ) IN AND TO THE HEREIN ) DESCRIBED PROPERTY ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.9
14- FEDERAL NATIONAL ) RCO LEGAL 0149 MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION ) (Elizabeth Padgett) ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT ) AND FINAL JUDGMENT ) ) VS. ) ) ) MARY K. CONWAY ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORD ) DISPOSITION: 14- IN RE: TODD LESLIE ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORD 0191 BROSE ) Deceased ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) JAMES METCALF, M.D., As ) HAMILTON COUNTY ATTORNEY MEDICAL EXAMINER for ) (Rheubin M. Taylor) HAMILTON COUNTY, ) MOTION TO SET, FOR DEFAULT TENNESSEE ) AND FOR ORDER DECLARING ) MORTAL REMAINS UNCLAIMED ) AUTHORIZING CREMATION ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.10
14- HAMILTON COUNTY ) LEITNER WILLIAMS DOOLEY & 0231 BOARD OF EDUCATION ) NAPOLITAN (D. Scott Bennett) ) (M. Andrew Pippenger/James Exum) ) JOINT MOTION FOR APPROVAL ) OF COMPROMISE ) ) VS. ) ) ) THE CITY OF ) OFFICE OF CITY ATTORNEY CHATTANOOGA and ) (Wade Hinton/Phillip Noblett) MAYOR ANDREW L. BERKE ) ) DISPOSITION: Order 8-1-14. 14- CHARLES RICHARD DAVIS ) PATRICK BEARD SCHULMAN & 0245 and ANTHONY MACK DAVIS ) JACOWAY (Jonathan Guthrie) ) JOINT MOTION TO APPROVE ) SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT ) VS. ) ) ) ALBERTA M. REDER and ) STULCE & YANTIS AMELIA M. MAILANDER, ) (Arnold Stulce) And ARNOLD STULCE as ) Administrator, CTA of the ) H. DIANE DIXON Estate of Charles Dewitt Reed ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.11
14- WILLIAM TIMOTHY ) DAVID C. NAGLE 0250 LANDRESS ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) JAMES HEWLETT ) SAMPLES JENNINGS RAY & LANDRESS and MAUDE G. ) CLEM (Hoyt Samples) HAMBRIGHT ) MOTION TO REFORM TRUST ) AND/OR APPOINT SUCCESSOR ) TRUSTEE ) DISPOSITION: 14- CORNERSTONE ) BRIAN P. MICKLES 0291 COMMUNITY BANK ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT ) JUDGMENT ) ) VS. ) ) ) BENJAMIN T. BODEY ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORD ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.12
14- J J MACK, LLC ) JOHNNY L. WOODRUFF 0323 ) APPLICATION FOR JUDGMENT ) BY DEFAULT ) VS. ) )
) CHRISTINE JORDAN and ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORD ANY UNKNOWN HEIRS OF ) CHRISTINE JORDAN ) ) DISPOSITION:
14- JAMES GRECO ) ARNOLD & ARNOLD 0338 ) (Prairie Arnold) ) MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT ) ) VS. ) ) ) PERFORMANCE ) WIMBERLY LAWSON WRIGHT CONTRACTING, INC., and ) DAVES & JONES (Gerard Jabaley) ARCH INSURANCE ) MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE COMPANY ) (Ryan Edens) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.13
14- JAMES GRECO ) ARNOLD & ARNOLD 0339 ) (Prairie Arnold) ) MOTION TO SET ) ) VS. ) ) ) PERFORMANCE ) WIMBERLY LAWSON WRIGHT CONTRACTING, INC., and ) DAVES & JONES (Gerard Jabaley) ARCH INSURANCE ) MOORE INGRAM JOHNSON & STEELE COMPANY ) (Ryan Edens) ) DISPOSITION: JURY DEMAND 14- HAMPTON GREEN, LLC ) SPICER RUDSTROM 0368 and ROLF GRIMSTED ) (Robert Uhorchuk) ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT ) JUDGMENT ) ) VS. ) ) ) WHITTESEA FINANCIAL ) MICHAEL L. WEST GROUP, LLC ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.14
14- GREGORY TRENT and ) THE WOLFORD FIRM 0375 VICTORIA TRENT ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT ) JUDGMENT ) ) VS. ) ) ) ROBIN NUTTER ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORD ) DISPOSITION: 07- RUSSELL RAY THOMPSON ) LISA Z. BOWMAN 0716 ) MOTION TO AMEND ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) CAROL ARLENE THOMPSON HABENICHT & JENKINS ) (Daniel Habenicht) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.15
08- MARYAM GHORASHI- ) GRANT KONVALINKA & HARRISON 0098 BAJESTANI ) (John Konvalinka) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) MASOUD BAJESTANI ) JOHN MELDORF ) MOTION TO ALTER, AMEND, ) OR FOR NEW TRIAL ) DISPOSITION: 11- SABRA ELAINE O’DANIEL ) JOHN R. MELDORF 0498 ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) RUSTY WADE O’DANIEL ) GRANT KONVALINKA & HARRISON ) (H. Wayne Grant) ) MOTION FOR ORDER ) COMPELLING DISCOVERY ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.16
13- O. KAREN POOLE ) LEITNER WILLIAMS DOOLEY & 0489 ) NAPOLITAN (Bruce Gill) ) MOTION FOR SUMMARY ) JUDGMENT (filed 7-28-14) ) ) VS. ) ) ) PAMELA A. HARPER ) SAM QUATTROCHI ) DISPOSITION: 13- JULIE STANDEFER ) GRANT KONVALINKA & HARRISON 0900 ) (John P. Konvalinka) ) (1) MOTION FOR TEMPORARY ) ALIMONY AND CHILD SUPPORT ) (2) MOTION TO SET ) VS. ) ) ) CHARLES ALAN ) LAWRENCE & LAWRENCE STANDEFER ) (Jennifer Lawrence) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.17
14- MEGAN MARIE BOZEMAN ) HANZELIK & ASSOCIATES 0383 ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) ) JORDAN TATE BOZEMAN ) NO COUNSEL OF RECORD ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.18
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS 13-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) GRANT KONVALINKA & HARRISON 001 ESTATE OF: ) (John P. Konvalinka) ) (1) MOTION FOR IMMEDIATE EDWARD B. (“BENNY”) ) POSSESSION OF HOME, SANDERS ) INVENTORY AND DIVISION OF ) PROPERTY ) (2) MOTION FOR DISTRIBUTIVE ) SHARE OF ESTATE ) DIETZEN & ATCHLEY ) (Fielding Atchley) ) (3) MOTION TO BE WITHDRAWN ) Mike Luhowiak ) Linda Norwood ) DISPOSITION: 14-P IN THE MATTER OF THE ) GRANT KONVALINKA & HARRISON 092 ESTATE OF: ) (John P. Konvalinka) ) (1) MOTION FOR TESTING JAMES EDWARD ) (2) MOTION TO PRESERVE THE ANDERSON, III ) ESTATE’S PERSONAL PROPERTY ) Terry Cavett ) David Kessler ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.19
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS
97- STEVEN PORRECA ) THORNBURY & MORGAN 1058 ) (Herbert Thornbury) ) MOTION TO SET ) ) VS. ) ) ) CHILI’S INC. AND ) LEITNER WILLIAMS DOOLEY & LIBERTY MUTUAL ) NAPOLITAN INSURANCE COMPANY ) (C. Douglas Dooley) ) DISPOSITION: JURY DEMAND 04- PERRY FLYNN ) BERKE BERKE & BERKE 0319 ) (Ronald Berke) ) (1) MOTION TO QUASH TO BRING ) RECORDS TO DEPOSITION ) (2) MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT ) VS. ) ) ) BROCK BONDING ) HANZELIK & ASSOCIATES ) (Fred T. Hanzelik) ) (3) MOTION TO COMPEL ) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.20
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS 09- STEVE MOSS AND ) MICHAEL E. RICHARDSON 0100 INDIVIDUAL GROUP ) HEALTH PLANS, INC. ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) YELLOW BOOK USA ) PAUL MENDELSON ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT ) AGAINST COUNTER DEFENDANT ) JESSICA MOSS ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.21
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS
09- AVI SUD ) BERKE BERKE & BERKE 0468 ) (Ronald Berke) ) ) VS. ) ) ) BRENTWOOD BUILDERS, ) KRAMER & BARTLETT LLC ) (Beecher A. Bartlett) ) MOTION TO EXCLUDE UNDISCLOSED ) EXPERT OF PLAINTIFF OR ) ALTERNATIVELY TO COMPEL ) DISCLOSURE AND IMPOSE SANCTIONS ) GEARHISER PETERS ELLIOTT & ) CANNON (Wade Cannon) ) BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN ) CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ ) (Cameron Hill) ) TIDWELL & IZELL (G. Tidwell) ) BURNETTE DOBSON & PINCHAK ) (H. Eric Burnette) ) FRANKLIN COOPER & MARCUS ) (Gary Cooper) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.22
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS 14- L. SHAY RICHARDSON ) STEPHEN DUGGINS 0006 and CANDIE M. ) (1) MOTION TO AMEND RICHARDSON ) ) VS. ) ) ) RJK HOMES, LLC ) OFFICE OF TIMOTHY NICHOLS ENGINEERED SERVICES ) (Timothy H. Nichols) CO-OPERATIVE, LLC, ) GEARHISER PEERS ELLIOTT & HUNTS CUSTOM ) CANNON (Robert Lockaby) PAINTING, RJK ) (2) MOTION FOR WITHDRAWAL AND RENOVATIONS, LLC, and ) SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL GREG PADGETT ) TRAMMELL ADKINS & WARD ) (Brian Trammell/A. Lewis) ) JOE MANUEL ) (3) MOTION TO AMEND ) SAMPLES JENNINGS RAY & CLEM ) (J. Christopher Clem) ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.23
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS 14- DIANE KNIGHT and ) BERKE BERKE & BERKE 0043 LINDA J. KNIGHT ) (Jeremy Cothern) ) (1) MOTION FOR DEFAULT ) ) VS. ) ) ) MARK ABBOTT, ) LOGAN-THOMPSON Individually and d/b/a ) (2) (Robert Thompson/Rob Norred) AFFORDABLE ) MOTION TO DISMISS (filed 7-17-14) ROOFING-SIDING- ) GUTTERS and ) AFFORDABLE ROOFING, ) SIDING, AND GUTTERS, ) LLC ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.24
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS 14- HAMILTON COUNTY ) SAMPLES RAY JENNINGS & CLEM 0177 WATER AND WASTE ) (Christopher Clem) WATER TREATMENT ) (2) MOTION TO AMEND FINAL AUTHORITY ) JUDGMENT AND RESPONSE ) TO DEFENDANT’S MOTION VS. ) ) ) RICK CARPENTER and ) PRO SE ANNA GRACE ) (1) MOTION TO ALTER AND AMEND CARPENTER ) THE FINAL JUDGMENT ) (3) AMENDED MOTION TO ALTER ) AND AMEND FINAL JUDGMENT ) (4) MOTION FOR RULE 11 SANCTIONS ) DISPOSITION: 14- LV&HM, INC. fka J S ) WAGNER NELSON & WEEKS 0288 CARE, INC., dba an ) (Michael A. Wagner) Independently Owned and ) MOTION FOR DEFAULT Operated HOME ) JUDGMENT INSTEAD SENIOR CARE ) FRANCHISE ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) ELEANOR BAGAMERY ) DUNCAN HATCHER HIXSON & ) FLEENOR (Everett Hixson) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.25
MOTIONS PASSED FROM PREVIOUS DOCKETS 13- DRAGAN LAZAREVIC and ) PETER ENSIGN 0335 SUZANA LAZAREVIC ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) WELLS FARGO HOME ) BAKER DONELSON BEARMAN MORTGAGE ) CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ ) (Justin Sveadas) ) MOTION FOR SUMMARY ) JUDGMENT (filed 2-5-14) ) DISPOSITION: Set for 8-11-14 @ 2:00 PM 14- STEPHANIE RENEE ) FLEISSNER DAVIS & JOHNSON 0213 HODGES ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) CHARLES GREGORY ) RAMER & HEDRICK HODGES ) (Glenna M. Ramer) ) MOTION TO SET ) DISPOSITION:
CHANCERY COURT PART 2 MOTION DOCKET AUGUST 11, 2014 P.26
RHEA COUNTY CASE 14-CV STEPHEN F. BARNETT, PhD) J. EDWARD NANNEY 10850 and STEVEN F. DeGEORGE, ) Ed.d., ) ) ) ) VS. ) ) ) BRYAN COLLEGE ) CHAMBLISS BAHNER & STOPHEL ) (Rosemarie Hill/Justin Farrow) ) MOTION TO DISSOLVE TRO ) DISPOSITION:
