Date post: | 20-Feb-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | safinamandokhail |
View: | 221 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 26
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
1/26
Christopher Dougherty
EC220 - Introduction to econometrics
(chapter 14)
Slideshow !i"ed e!!ects regressions #SD$ method
%riginal citation
Dougherty, C. (2012) EC220 - Introduction to econometrics (chapter 14). [eaching !esource"
# 2012 he $uthor
his %ersion a%ai&a'&e at http&earningresources.&se.ac.u*140
$%ai&a'&e in +E +earning !esources n&ine ay 2012
his /or* is &icensed under a Creati%e Commons $ttri'ution-hare$&i*e .0 +icense. his &icense a&&o/s
the user to remi, t/ea*, and 'ui&d upon the /or* e%en or commercia& purposes, as &ong as the user
credits the author and &icenses their ne/ creations under the identica& terms.
httpcreati%ecommons.org&icenses'y-sa.0
http&&learningresources'lse'ac'u&
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
2/26
In the third ersion o! the !i"ed e!!ects approach* nown as the least s+uares dummy
aria,le (#SD$) method* the uno,sered e!!ect is ,rought e"plicitly into the model'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
1
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
3/26
I! we de!ine a set o! dummy aria,lesAi* whereA
iis e+ual to 1 in the case o! an o,seration
relating to indiidual iand 0 otherwise* the model can ,e rewritten as shown'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
2
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
4/26
ormally* the uno,sered e!!ectis now ,eing treated as the coe!!icient o! the indiidual-
speci!ic dummy aria,le* theiA
iterm representing a !i"ed e!!ect on the dependent aria,le
Yi!or indiidual i (this accounts !or the name gien to the !i"ed e!!ects approach)'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
5/26
aing re-speci!ied the model in this way* it can ,e !itted using %#S'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
4
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
6/26
ote that i! we include a dummy aria,le !or eery indiidual in the sample as well as an
intercept* we will !all into the dummy aria,le trap'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
3
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
7/26
/o aoid this* we can de!ine one indiidual to ,e the re!erence category* so that 1is its
intercept* and then treat theias the shi!ts in the intercept !or the other indiiduals'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
8/26
oweer* the choice o! re!erence category is o!ten ar,itrary and accordingly the
interpretation o! theinot particularly illuminating'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
5
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
9/26
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
5lternatiely* we can drop the 1intercept and de!ine dummy aria,les !or all o! the
indiiduals* as has ,een done here' /heinow ,ecome the intercepts !or each o! the
indiiduals'6
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
10/26
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
ote that* in common with the !irst two ersions o! the !i"ed e!!ects approach* the #SD$
method re+uires panel data'
7
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
11/26
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
6ith cross-sectional data* one would ,e de!ining a dummy aria,le !or eery o,seration*
e"hausting the degrees o! !reedom' /he dummy aria,les on their own would gie a per!ect
,ut meaningless !it'10
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
12/26
I! there are a large num,er o! indiiduals* using the #SD$ method directly is not a practical
proposition* gien the need !or a large num,er o! dummy aria,les'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
11
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
13/26
oweer* it can ,e shown mathematically that the approach is e+uialent to the within-
groups method and there!ore yields precisely the same estimates'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
E+uialent to within-groups method
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
iit
k
jjijitjiit ttXXYY
=
)()(2
12
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
14/26
/hus in practice we always use the within-groups method rather than the #SD$ method'
7ut it may ,e use!ul to now that the within-groups method is e+uialent to modelling the
!i"ed e!!ects with dummy aria,les'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
E+uialent to within-groups method
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
1
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
iit
k
jjijitjiit ttXXYY
=
)()(2
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
15/26
/he only apparent di!!erence ,etween the #SD$ and within-groups methods is in the
num,er o! degrees o! !reedom' It is easy to see !rom the #SD$ speci!ication that there are
nT8 k8 ndegrees o! !reedom i! the panel is ,alanced'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
E+uialent to within-groups method
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
14
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
iit
k
jjijitjiit
ttXXYY
=
)()(2
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
16/26
In the within-groups approach* it seemed at !irst that there were nT8 k' oweer ndegrees
o! !reedom are consumed in the manipulation that eliminate thei* so the num,er o!
degrees o! !reedom is really nT8 k8 n'
i"ed e!!ects estimation (least s+uares dummy aria,le method)
E+uialent to within-groups method
iti
k
j
jitjit tXY
=
2
1
it
n
i
ii
k
j
jitjit AtXY =
12
13
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
iit
k
jjijitjiit
ttXXYY
=
)()(2
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
17/26
/o illustrate the use o! a !i"ed e!!ects model* we return to the e"ample in Section 1 and use
all the aaila,le data !rom 19:0 to 199;* 20*) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
18/26
/he ta,le shows the e"tra hourly earnings o! married men and o! men who are single ,ut
married within the ne"t !our years' /he omitted category in the !irst two columns is single
men who are still single !our years later'15
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
19/26
/he controls (not shown) are the same as in the e"ample in the !irst slideshow on panel
data'
16
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
20/26
/he !irst column gies the estimates o,tained ,y simply pooling the o,serations and using
%#S with ro,ust standard errors' /he estimates are ery similar to those in the wage
e+uation !or 19:: in the e"ample in the !irst slideshow onpanel data'17
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
21/26
/he second column gies the !i"ed e!!ects estimates* using the within-groups method* with
single men as the re!erence category' /he third gies the !i"ed e!!ects estimates with
married men as the re!erence category'20
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
22/26
/he !i"ed e!!ects estimates are considera,ly lower than the %#S estimates* suggesting that
the %#S estimates were in!lated ,y uno,sered heterogeneity' eertheless the pattern is the
same'21
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
23/26
%ur !indings con!irm that married men earn more than single men' @art o! the di!!erential
appears to ,e attri,uta,le to the characteristics o! married men* since men who are soon-
to-marry ,ut still single also enAoy a signi!icant earnings premium'22
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
24/26
oweer i! we mae married men the omitted category* as in the third column* we !ind that
soon-to-,e-married men earn signi!icantly less than married men' /hus part o! the
marriage premium appears to ,e attri,uta,le to the e!!ect o! marriage itsel!'2
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
25/26
ence ,oth hypotheses relating to the marriage premium appear to ,e partly true'
24
I.ED EEC/S EESSI%S #SD$ 3E/%D
#S= 19:08199;
Dependent aria,le logarithm o! hourly earnings
%#S i"ed e!!ects
3arried 0'1:4 0'10; 8
(0'00>) (0'012)
Soon-to-,e- 0'09; 0'04? 80'0;1
married (0'009) (0'010) (0'00:)
Single 8 8 80'10;
(0'012)
R2 0'
7/24/2019 Chapter 14 Fixed Effects Regressions Least Square Dummy Variable Approach (EC220)
26/26
Copyright Christopher Dougherty 2011'
/hese slideshows may ,e downloaded ,y anyone* anywhere !or personal use'
Su,Aect to respect !or copyright and* where appropriate* attri,ution* they may ,e
used as a resource !or teaching an econometrics course' /here is no need to
re!er to the author'
/he content o! this slideshow comes !rom Section 14'2 o! C' Dougherty*
Introduction to Econometrics* !ourth edition 2011* %"!ord Bniersity @ress'
5dditional (!ree) resources !or ,oth students and instructors may ,e
downloaded !rom the %B@ %nline esource Centre
http&&www'oup'com&u&orc&,in&9>:0199?;>0:9&'
Indiiduals studying econometrics on their own and who !eel that they might
,ene!it !rom participation in a !ormal course should consider the #ondon School
o! Economics summer school course
EC212 Introduction to Econometrics
http&&www2'lse'ac'u&study&summerSchools&summerSchool&ome'asp"or the Bniersity o! #ondon International @rogrammes distance learning course
20 Elements o! Econometrics
www'londoninternational'ac'u&lse'
11 0 2