15/01/56
1
1
Operating Exposure
• Operating exposure, also called economic exposure, competitive exposure, and even strategic exposure on occasion, measures any change in the present value of a firm resulting from changes in future operating cash flows caused by an unexpected change in exchange rates.
2
Attributes of Operating Exposure• Measuring the operating exposure of a firm requires
forecasting and analyzing all the firm’s future individual transaction exposures together with the future exposures of all the firm’s competitors and potential competitors worldwide.
• From a broader perspective, operating exposure is not just the sensitivity of a firm’s future cash flows to unexpected changes in foreign exchange rates, but also to its sensitivity to other key macroeconomic variables.
• This factor has been labeled macroeconomic uncertainty.
15/01/56
2
3
Attributes of Operating Exposure
• The cash flows of the MNE can be divided into operating cash flows and financing cash flows.
• Operating cash flows arise from intercompany (between unrelated companies) and intracompany(between units of the same company) receivables and payables, rent and lease payments, royalty and license fees and assorted management fees.
• Financing cash flows are payments for loans (principal and interest), equity injections and dividends of an inter and intracompany nature.
4
Financial & Operating Cash Flows Between Parent & Subsidiary
Subsidiary
Financial Cash Flows
Operational Cash Flows
Payment for goods & servicesRent and lease paymentsRoyalties and license fees
Management fees & distributed overhead
Dividend paid to parentParent invested equity capitalInterest on intrafirm lendingIntrafirm principal payments
Parent
15/01/56
3
5
Attributes of Operating Exposure
• Operating exposure is far more important for the long-run health of a business than changes caused by transaction or accounting exposure.
• Operating exposure is inevitably subjective, because it depends on estimates of future cash flow changes over an arbitrary time horizon.
• Planning for operating exposure is a total management responsibility because it depends on the interaction of strategies in finance, marketing, purchasing, and production.
6
Measuring the Impact of Operating ExposureA. Short Run (1Year)
B. Medium Run: Equilibrium Case (2 to 5 Years)
Assume Parity Conditions Hold (FX, I, i)
• The firm should be able to adjust prices and factor costs over time.
• If equilibrium exists continuously, the operating exposure may be zero.
C. Medium Run: Disequilibrium Case
Realized cash flows will differ from expected cash flow the firm’s market value may change.
D. Long Run (> 5 Years)
All firms subject to international competition are exposed to long run operating exposure.
15/01/56
4
• The following slide presents the dilemma facingCarlton, Inc. as a result of an unexpected change in the value of the euro, the currency of economicconsequence for the German subsidiary.
• There is concern over how the subsidiaries revenues (price and volumes in euro terms), costs (input costsin euro terms), and competitive landscape will change with a fall in the value of the euro.
7
Measuring the Impact of Operating Exposure
8
Exhibit 12.2 Trident Corporation and Its European Subsidiary: Operating Exposure of the Parent and Its Subsidiary
15/01/56
5
• Carlton Germany:- Case 1: Devaluation, no change in any
variable.
- Case 2: Increase in sales volume; other
variables remain constant.
- Case 3: Increase in sales price; other
variables remain constant.
9
Measuring the Impact of Operating Exposure
10
Exhibit 12.3 Trident Europe
15/01/56
6
11
Exhibit 12.3 Trident Europe
12
Managing Operating Exposure
1. The Strategic Level Through Diversification A. Diversifying Operations:
• Diversifying sales, location of production facilities and raw material sources to reduce the variability of cash flows
B. Diversifying Financing:
• Take advantage of temporary deviations from the international fisher effect (FX, id - if )
• Lower the cost of capital by switching financing sourcesC. Constraints:
• Some industries require large economies of scale; limit the diversifying production locations
15/01/56
7
13
2. Changing Operating Policies
Adopting operating policies that deviate from normal domestic-oriented policies.
A. Using Leads and Lags
• To Lead: Use soft currency to pay hard currency debt early
• To Lag: Is to pay soft currency debt lateB. Risk Sharing
• Buyer and seller agree to split currency movement impacts on payments.
C. Reinvoicing Center
• Manages, in one location, all transaction exposures from intracompany trade
• Leads and Lags: Retiming the transfer of funds
- Firms can reduce both operating and transaction exposures by accelerating or decelerating the timing of payments that must be made or received in foreign currencies.
- Intracompany leads and lags is more feasible as related companies presumably embrace a common set of goals for the consolidated group.
- Intercompany leads and lags requires the time preference of one independent firm to be imposed on another. 14
Changing Operating Policies
15/01/56
8
• Risk-Sharing:
- An alternate method for managing a long-term cash flow exposure between firms is risk sharing.
- This is a contractual arrangement in which the buyer and seller agree to “share” or split currency movement impacts on payments between them.
- This agreement is intended to smooth the impact on both parties of volatile and unpredictable exchange rate movements.
15
Changing Operating Policies
• Reinvoicing Centers: There are three basic benefits arising from the creation of a reinvoicing center:
- Managing foreign exchange exposure in one
place
- Guaranteeing the exchange rate for future orders
- Managing intrasubsidiary cash flows
16
Changing Operating Policies
15/01/56
9
17
Changing Operating Policies
3. Changing Financing Policies
A. Natural Hedging:
Matching currency cash flows
• Acquire debt denominated in the same currency
• Seek out potential suppliers in foreign country
B. Back-to-Back Loans:
Two firms in separate countries arrange to borrow each other’s currency for a specific period of time.
At terminal date, they return the borrowed currencies
• Difficult to find a counterparty 18
15/01/56
10
In this example, a US firm has continuing export
sales to Canada.
• In order to compete effectively in Canadian
markets, the firm invoices all export sales in
Canadian dollars.
• This policy results in a continuing receipt of
Canadian dollars month after month.
• This endless series of transaction exposures could
be continually hedged with forwards or othercontractual agreements. 19
Changing Financing Policies
20
Changing Financing PoliciesCanadian
Corporation(buyer of goods) Exports
goods toCanada
CanadianBank
(loans funds)
US Corp borrowsCanadian dollar debtfrom Canadian Bank
Payment for goodsin Canadian dollars
Principal and interestpayments on debtin Canadian dollars
U.S.Corporation
Exposure: The sale of goods to Canada creates a foreign currency exposure from the inflow of Canadian dollars
Hedge: The Canadian dollar debt payments act as a financialhedge by requiring debt service, an outflow of Canadian dollars
15/01/56
11
• Matching currency cash flows.
- One way to offset an anticipated continuous long
exposure to a particular company is to acquire debt
denominated in that currency (matching).
- Another alternative would be for the US firm to
seek out potential suppliers of raw materials or
components in Canada as a substitute for US or
other foreign firms.
- In addition, the company could engage in currency
switching, in which the company would pay foreignsuppliers with Canadian dollars.
21
Changing Financing Policies
• Back-to-Back Loans:
- A back-to-back loan, also referred to as a parallel
loan or credit swap, occurs when two business
firms in separate countries arrange to borrow each
other’s currency for a specific period of time.
- At an agreed terminal date they return the
borrowed currencies.
- Such a swap creates a covered hedge against
exchange loss, since each company, on its ownbooks, borrows the same currency it repays. 22
Changing Financing Policies
15/01/56
12
23
Changing Financing Policies1. British firm wishes to invest funds
in its Dutch subsidiary2. British firm identifies a Dutch firm wishing
to invest funds in its British subsidiary
British parentfirm
Dutch parentfirm
IndirectFinancing
Direct loanin pounds
Direct loanin euros
Dutch firm’sBritish subsidiary
British firm’sDutch subsidiary
3. British firm loans British poundsdirectly to the Dutch firm’s Britishsubsidiary
4. British firm’s Dutch subsidiary loanseuros to the Dutch parent
The back-to-back loan provides a method for parent-subsidiary cross-border financingwithout incurring direct currency exposure.
• There are two fundamental impediments to
widespread use of the back-to-back loan:
- It is difficult for a firm to find a partner, termed
a counterparty for the currency amount and
timing desired.
- A risk exists that one of the parties will fail to
return the borrowed funds at the designated
maturity – although each party has 100%collateral (denominated in a different currency).
24
Changing Financing Policies
15/01/56
13
25
C. Currency Swap (Off-Balance Sheet)
Two parties agree to exchange a given amount of one currency for another and, after a period of time, to give back the original amounts swapped.
Requires two firms to borrow funds in the markets and currencies in which they are best known.
26
Both the Japanese corporation and the U.S. corporation would like to enter into a cross currency swap which would allow them to use foreign currency cash inflows to service debt.
JapaneseCorporation
United StatesCorporation
Assets Liabilities & Equity Assets Liabilities & Equity
Inflow
of US$
Receive yen
Payyen
ReceivedollarsSwap Dealer
Wishes to enter into a swap to“pay yen” and “receive dollars”
Wishes to enter into a swap to“pay dollars” and “receive yen”
Sales to US Debt in yen Sales to Japan Debt in US$
Paydollars
Inflow
of yen