of 26
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
1/26
Table of Contents
Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 2
Population ................................................................................................................................................. 2
Economic Structure and Major Industries ................................................................................................ 2
Major Firms ............................................................................................................................................... 4
Chinas Stock Market .................................................................................................................................... 6
China Securities Regulatory Commission ...................................................................................................... 7
Legal Enforcement of IFRS ............................................................................................................................ 8
Summary of contents of financial statements .............................................................................................. 9Transition Process of Accounting Standards............................................................................................... 10
Auditing Standards ...................................................................................................................................... 11
Full convergence with International Standards ...................................................................................... 11
Verification of Capital Contribution ........................................................................................................ 13
Comparison of Chinas old GAAP and IFRS ................................................................................................. 14
Accounting Education in China ................................................................................................................... 15
The Chinese Institute of Certified Public Accountants ............................................................................... 16
The CICPA Overview ................................................................................................................................ 16
The CICPA Examination ........................................................................................................................... 16
Accounting Student..................................................................................................................................... 19
Chinas Cultural Influences on Accounting ................................................................................................. 20
Appendix 1. Comparison of CASs and ISAs (As of 2006) ............................................................................. 23
Appendix 2. Accounting Firms in China ...................................................................................................... 25
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
2/26
Introduction
Population
In 2012, China's population amounts to 1.3 billionan increase of 365 million since
1980. Yet, population is growing at a decelerating pace and should reach its peak in less than two
decades. Current methods of population control will be relaxed as the growth of population
slows. The fertility rate is presently 1.6 births per female (below replacement level) and is
expected to remain at that level in the medium term.
The median age is steadily rising and by 2011 it was 35.5years16.9 years greater than
the figure for 1980. In fact, population aging is occurring more quickly in China than in most
other countries. The country's working age population will begin to fall by 2017. By 2040, there
could well be 100 million Chinese over 80 years oldmore than the current worldwide total.
This demographic imbalance will have dramatic and fundamental consequences for the country's
economic and social character. Improvements in social security and healthcare are essential. In
recognition of the extent of China's population ageing, Beijing plans to spend RMB890 billion in
2009-2012 to improve healthcare.
Economic Structure and Major Industries
Industry accounts for about 46.8% of China's GDP (2010 est.). Major industries are
mining and ore processing; iron; steel; aluminum; coal; machinery; textiles and apparel;
armaments; petroleum; cement; chemicals; fertilizers; consumer products including footwear,
toys, and electronics; automobiles and other transportation equipment including rail cars and
locomotives, ships, and aircraft; telecommunications equipment; commercial space launch
vehicles; and satellites. China has become a preferred destination for the relocation of global
manufacturing facilities. Its strength as an export platform has contributed to incomes and
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
3/26
employment in China. The state-owned sector still accounts for about 40% of GDP (2010 est.).
In recent years, authorities have been giving greater attention to the management of state assets--
both in the financial market as well as among state-owned enterprises--and progress has been
noteworthy. (http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/18902.htm)
Agriculture employs 33.8% of the workforce. Farm output grew by 4.6% in 2011. Rice is
the main food crop, but tea, sugar and fibre crops are also important cash earners. In addition,
China is the world's biggest producer and consumer of cotton. Farm output is expected to rise (in
real terms) by more than 25% during the decade but looming water shortages could prove to be a
serious bottleneck. Nationally, the agriculture sector consumes about 70% of China's surface
water but more than one-fifth of water resources are unfit even for farming. The area sown for
grain should increase in 2011 and output will rise by 2.5 billion kg.
Manufacturing accounts for 30.0% of GDP and employs 14.2% of the workforce. In
2009, China became the world's largest car market but annual sales are expected to grow by 8-
10% in 2012. Car penetration in China is still modest, even when compared with countries such
as Brazil or Russia. Beijing announced that in 2012 it will withdraw support for foreign capital in
auto manufacturing in an effort to support the development of domestic auto makers. Many other
manufacturers are trying to move up the value added chain but China's shady reputation on
intellectual property makes foreigners hesitant to transfer technology to Chinese partners.
Domestically, state-owned firms continue to dominate the economy, accounting for an estimated
40% of non-agricultural output.
Services make up 38.6% of GDP. Banks are now more commercially oriented and non-
performing loans remain at modest levels. The regulatory infrastructure of the banking system
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/18902.htmhttp://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/18902.htm7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
4/26
has been significantly improved. The real value of tourist receipts is expected to have risen by
7.4% in 2011
Major Firms
PetroChina-PetroChina Company Limited (PetroChina) is the largest oil and gas producerand distributor, playing a dominant role in the oil and gas industry in China. It is not only one of
the companies with the biggest sales revenue in China, but also one of the largest oil companies
in the world. PetroChina was established as a joint stock company with limited liabilities by
China National Petroleum Corporation under the Company Law and the Special Regulations on
the Overseas Offering and Listing of Shares by Joint Stock Limited Companies on November
5th, 1999. The American Depositary Shares (ADS) and H shares of PetroChina were listed on
the New York Stock Exchange on April 6, 2000 (stock code: PTR) and the Stock Exchange of
Hong Kong Limited on April 7, 2000 (stock code: 857) respectively. It was listed on Shanghai
Stock Exchange on November 5, 2007 (stock code: 601857)
China Construction Bank is a leading commercial bank in China providing a comprehensive
range of commercial banking products and services. Their business consists of three principal
business segments: corporate banking, personal banking, and treasury operations. They are
among the market leaders in China in a number of products and services, including infrastructure
loans, residential mortgage, and bank cards.
They have an extensive customer base, with established banking relationships with many
of the largest business groups and leading companies in industries which are strategically
important to China's economy. They have an extensive network of approximately 13629 branch
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
5/26
outlets. In addition, we maintain overseas branches in Hong Kong, Singapore, Frankfurt,
Johannesburg, Tokyo, Seoul, New York, Ho Chi Minh City and Sydney.
China Petrochemical Corporation (Sinopec Group) is a super-large petroleum and
petrochemical enterprise group established in July 1998 on the basis of the former China
Petrochemical Corporation. Sinopec Group is a state-owned company solely invested by the
State, functioning as a state-authorized investment organization in which the state holds the
controlling share. Headquartered in Beijing, Sinopec Group has a registered capital of RMB 182
billion. China Petroleum & Chemical Company (Sinopec Corp.), controlled by Sinopec Group,
issued H-shares and A-shares at overseas and home respectively in October 2000 and August
2001 and was listed on stock markets in Hong Kong, New York, London and Shanghai.
China Railway Group is a super-large integrated construction group that encompasses
infrastructure construction, survey, design and consulting services, engineering equipment and
component manufacturing, property development and other businesses.
China Railway Group Limited has 46 subsidiaries, including 28 wholly owned
subsidiaries, 15 holding subsidiaries, 4 branch companies and 3 joint venture subsidiaries. In the
year of 2005 and 2006, China Railway was the fourth and third largest construction company in
the world, respectively. In 2007, it was ranked 342nd in the Fortune Global 500 companies, and
listed the 417th in the Worlds 500 Most Influential Brands and the 13th in Chinas Top 500
Enterprises.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
6/26
Chinas Stock Market
The Chinese stock market was established in 1980s. Chinas two stock exchanges, the
Shanghai Stock Exchange and Shenzhen Stock Exchange, were established in November 1990
and December 1990, respectively. Chinese listed firms have multiple classes of shares
outstanding: shares listed in mainland China and traded in RMB (A shares), shares listed in
mainland China and traded in foreign currencies (B shares), and shares listed or cross-listed
overseas (for example, H shares listed on the Hong Kong stock exchange; ADRs if listed in the
US). Since 1996, the stock market has been playing an important role in the national economy as
it was defined as a major source of refinancing the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) sector.
Despite stricter regulations and some improvement in operational efficiency, the Chinese
stock market continues to be tarnished by problems of mismanagement. A Code of Corporate
Governance for Listed Companies was enacted by the China Securities Regulatory Commission
in 2002 as part of an initiative to improve the reporting of inflated profits and the delisting of
loss-making companies. Listed companies are required to undergo supplementary audits by the
major international auditing firms. In general, opportunities for domestic firms and individuals to
hold foreign-currency denominated stocks and bonds (the B share market) remain heavily
circumscribed. Although still constrained, opportunities for foreign firms and individuals to
purchase Chinese-currency denominated assets (the A share market) are gradually increasing.
More than 100 of Chinas 500 largest companies, including China Telecom, Anshan Iron and
Steel Company, and Handan Iron and Steel Company, have been publicly listed, although state
institutions still hold around 60% of shares in such enterprises. Big state corporations, including
the four SOCBs (see above), have also listed their shares in international markets. Chinas other
capital markets remain underdeveloped, although the countrys WTO accession is one factor that
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
7/26
will help enhance bond, insurance and securities markets. Diversification within the interbank
market has strengthened its role as a source of capital for domestic banks. Meanwhile, although
the corporate bond market remains small, the National Financial Work Conference has signaled
that the issue of corporate bonds would play an increasingly important role, as Chinas bond
markets developed.
China Securities Regulatory Commission
The China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) was established in 1992, shortly
after the establishment of Chinas two stock exchanges. The CSRC is under the direct leadership
of the State Council, the highest executive organ of State power and administration in China (1).
The CSRC carries out regulation and supervision of the securities and futures markets
nationwide according to applicable laws and regulations.
The CSRC consists of a chairman, five vice-chairmen, and three assistant chairmen. In
addition to the senior management listed above, the CSRC holds a staff of over 2,500 employees.
The CSRC is headquartered in Beijing, but most of the staff works in the 36 regional offices that
are located in various regions throughout the country. The CRSC comprises 21 functional
departments, 4 affiliated institutions, and 4 special committees.
The CSRC was modeled after two regulatory bodies: the Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC) in the United States and the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) in
Hong Kong. It performs regular reviews and random inspections of companies and securities
firms. It also investigates allegations of company and securities fraud and malpractice. The
allegations come from investors, current and former employees, insiders, newspapers, stock
exchanges, legal proceedings, and police investigations.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
8/26
If the CSRC finds that a wrongdoing has been committed, it will publish the information
in a report that is shown in national newspapers. The CSRC has four different categories for
penalizing companies: public criticism, public condemnation, official warning, and monetary
fines. The CSRC may also suspend trading and withdraw licenses from securities firms. In
regards to individuals, the CSRC can take actions that result in criminal prosecutions with strict
punishments that include the death penalty.
In addition to its supervision and enforcement responsibilities, the CSRC is also
responsible for developing rules and regulations for the securities market that are based on public
law. Also, the CSRC formulates the qualification criteria and codes of conduct for securities
practitioners and fund employees.
Legal Enforcement of IFRS
The Chinese capital market is segmented into two different categories: A-shares and B-
shares. A-shares can only be owned and traded by Chinese citizens while B-shares can be
owned and traded by anyone. The regulations that apply to Chinese firms depend on what type
of security they issue. Companies that issue A-shares must develop financial statements that
comply with Chinese GAAP only, while companies that issue B-shares must develop a set of
financial statements that comply with IFRS and a set that comply with Chinese GAAP. The
companies that issue B shares must also prepare a line-item reconciliation of earnings under the
two standards.
Chinese law states that the financial statements that are issued under the Chinese GAAP
can be audited by a local auditor. However, the financial statements that are issued under IFRS
must be audited by an international reputable auditor, like a Big 4 firm. Also, the CSRC may
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
9/26
require an international auditor to review the Chinese financial statements when a company
applies for new equity offerings in the domestic market.
The audit opinions of international auditors are more highly regarded then those of local
auditors since the independence of Chinese local auditors can be compromised due to the weak
institutional environment in various areas throughout China. Evidence of this occurred in the
early 2000s when the CSRC supported a significant increase in international audit support in
hopes that the quality of auditing in China would improve. From 1999 to 2002, local CPA firms
declined from 106 to 71 due to increased competition from international firms. However,
research shows that the international auditors actually did not outperform the local CPA firms in
increasing IFRS compliance.
In 2001, the CSRC implemented a compulsory policy that is regarded as the most
influential regulatory enforcement effort on IFRS compliance in China. The policy states that
management must choose the same accounting policies for both Chinese GAAP and IFRS, where
possible. Thus, the only differences between the two sets of financial statements would be the
differences in Chinese GAAP and IFRS. The policy was created to increase national
convergence with the international accounting standards. Research shows that the
implementation of the policy led to a clear decline in line-item earning differences between
financial statements based on Chinese GAAP and corresponding financial statements based on
IFRS.
Summary of contents of financial statements
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
10/26
Transition Process of Accounting Standards
In the early 1990s, with the establishment of Chinese stock exchanges, foreign investors
in the stock market had difficulty interpreting the financial statements of Chinese firms and the
restatement of the financial statements into international terms was a costly process (Winkle et
al, 1994). In this sense, the existing socialist accounting model needed to shift to a market
oriented model to attract foreign investors. Since the countrys economic reform, the MOF has
developed Chinese accounting standards that improve the quality of Chinese firms financial
reporting. To achieve this purpose, the MOF made an effort to converge Chinese GAAP with
internationally recognized accounting standards (Chen, Gul, & SU, 1999). In 2005, the MOF
officially clarified its goal of as convergence with IFRS (IASB, 2005).
On February 16, 2006, the MOF announced that it promulgated a new basic accounting
standard and 38 new Chinese Accounting Standards (CASs) that are substantially in line with
IFRS, with a few exceptions. The MOF required all listed companies to start using the new CASs
in their 2007 financial statements. The MOF expanded the use of the new standards to all state-
owned enterprises starting in 2008, and then to all large and medium-sized companies starting in
2009.
Peng et al. (2010) divides this development and convergence progress into four stages.
They consider the first stage (from 1992 to 1997) a revolutionary change in Chinese accounting
because the MOF introduced a market oriented accounting model for the first time. During the
second stage (from 1998 to 2000), the MOF promulgated theAccounting System for Joint Stock
Limited Enterprise and ten specific CASs. The third stage (from 2001 to 2006) is represented by
the issuance of theAccounting System for Business Enterprises, which replaced the 1998
Accounting System, and 16 CASs (6 newly issued, 5 revised, and 5 original standards). The
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
11/26
fourth stage (from 2006) is initiated by the issuance of theAccounting Standards for Business
Enterprises (ASBEs), which consists of a revised Basic Standard and 38 specific standards.
Peng et al. documents that since 1992, the MOF has moved Chinese GAAP toward
convergence with IFRS through the issuance of a series of Chinese GAAP that enhanced the
level of successful convergence, which refers to fully or substantially converged items, with
IFRS (20% in 1992, 35% in 1998, 49% in 2001, and 77% in 2006). The convergence has been
carried out both through the direct import of standards from IFRS (74 of 123 items, 60%) and
through progressive changes to Chinese GAAP (49 of 123 items, 40%).
According toRoadmap for Continuing and Full Convergence of the Chinese Accounting
Standards for Business Enterprises (ASBE) with the IFRS, the MOF targets 2011 as the year for
completion of the convergence program of the ASBE and IFRS, and all large and medium-sized
enterprises are required to use the revised standards as of 2012.
Auditing Standards
Full convergence with International Standards
The development of socialist market economy, privatization, and large inflows of foreign
investment requires the innovation of a Chinese accounting system in harmony with international
practice. To reinforce the confidence of investors, to regulate the performance of audits, and to
harmonize with international practices, China began to issue 10 independent auditing standards
with the first batch being effective from January 1, 1996. The second and third batches of 17
standards, 5 practice pronouncements and 3 related general standards on professional ethics,
Comment [b1]: This is written as thoa year in the future. I realize that is becareference was written before 2011, but I t
will want us to research and find out if th
target last year.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
12/26
quality control and continuing professional education became effective from January 1, 1997,
and July 1, 1999, respectively (Lin and Chan, 2000).
On December 8, 2005, the Chinese Auditing Standards Board (CASB) and the
International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) released a joint statement in
which the CASB indicated that the fundamental principle of drafting Chinese auditing standards
is to improve the Chinese auditing standards system and to accelerate its convergence with the
IAASBs ISAs. As an outgrowth of this joint statement, the CICPA published new 48 Chinese
Auditing Standards (CASs) that adopted nearly all International Standards on Auditing (ISAs) in
2006 (Deloitte, 2006). In China, the CICPA is responsible for publishing auditing guidelines, but
it must seek approval from the MOF before any auditing guidelines can be published.
According to a press release issued on November 10, 2010, the CASB completed the
revision ofCSAsCASs, and achieved full convergence with the clarified ISAs. During the
international convergence process, the CASB made limited additions it considered necessary and
maintained some standards dealing with matters that are not specially covered in ISAs to reflect
Chinas unique circumstances and business requirements, such as standards for the verification
of capital contributions and communications between predecessor and successor auditors. The
IAASB admits that such additions are acceptable if only they dont conflict with ISAs.
Chong (2008) expects that adopting international standards may help streamline the audit
approaches and reporting between the primary and secondary auditors in China. The primary
auditors, based outside China, would have little or no difficulty subcontracting their audit
assignments to the secondary auditors, their Chinese counterparts based in China.
The revised CSAs were officially released in early November 2010, and are effective for audits
of financial statements for period beginning on after January 1, 2011.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
13/26
Verification of Capital Contribution
Verification of capital contribution is peculiar to China. CAS defines verification of
capital contribution as the verification of the truthfulness and legitimacy of the entitys paid-in
capital and its relevant assets and liabilities. In China, verification of capital contribution is a
legal requirement when: (1) a new business is set up that requires each party to pay its
contribution within the times as fixed in the contract; (2) the change of legal person, merger, or
demerger, increases in and assignments of registered capital; and (3) contracting parties wish to
change their registered capital. For instance, equity joint ventures in China are required to have a
registered capital to which all parties must contribute. After each party makes all contributions,
an accounting firm is called upon to verify the contributions and issue a certificate of
verification. The guidelines require the auditor to carry out necessary verification procedures and
obtain sufficient appropriate evidence for the expression of an opinion and the issuance of a
verification report. The verification report should contain two paragraphs: one describing the
scope of the verification and one expressing the auditors opinion on the verification of capital
contribution.
However, there is no equivalent ISA in this area. Verification of capital contribution is
usually not a statutory audit in the developed countries such U.S., U.K., Canada, and Australia,
even though auditors sometimes have to verify capital contributions under various regulatory
requirements.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
14/26
Comparison of Chinas Old GAAP and IFRS
As stated previously, China issued its latest set of accounting standards in February of
2006. Although the standards are very similar to IFRS, certain modifications have been made to
reflect Chinas unique circumstances and environment. Most of the differences between the two
standards come as a result of the Chinese limiting some of the options that are allowed in IFRS.
Therefore, companies that are compliant with the Chinese standards will generally be compliant
with IFRS, as well. A listing of the key differences between the two standards is presented
below.
ASBE 2 only allows the equity method to be used when accounting for jointly controlledentities. IAS 31 allows both the equity method and proportionate consolidation to
account for such entities.
ASBE 3 allows the cost model or the fair value model when measuring land use rightsthat is held for rental property and classified as investment property. Under IAS 40,
enterprises are allowed to classify such land rights as investment property only if the fair
value method is adopted.
ASBE 4 and ASBE 6 require the cost model to be used to measure fixed assets(excluding investment properties) and intangible assets, respectively. However, the
comparable international standards (IAS 16 and IAS 38) allow the use of both the cost
model and the revaluation model.
ASBE 5 requires the cost model to be used to measure biological assets unless there isevidence that the fair value of the assets can be obtained reliably on a consistent basis.
IAS 41 requires that the fair value be used to measure biological assets unless evidence
shows that it cannot be obtained reliably.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
15/26
ASBE 8 prohibits the reversal of all types of types of impairment losses whereas IAS 36only prohibits the reversal of impairment loss for goodwill.
ASBE 17 requires the capitalization of all borrowing costs that meet the criteria forcapitalization. IAS 23 provides an option to expense all borrowing costs.
ASBE 30 states that the expenses of the income statement must be shown by function.IAS 1 allows the same expenses to be presented by function or by nature.
ASBE 31 requires the direct method to be used when reporting cash flows from operatingactivities. An enterprise must also develop a note that shows the reconciliation of profit
to net cash from operating activities. Under IAS 7, an enterprise is only encouraged to
use either the direct method or the indirect method.
ASBE 36 exempts state-controlled entities from being regards as related parties simplybecause they are state-controlled. No such exemption exists under IAS 24.
Accounting Education in ChinaFor bachelors degree, students must take several accounting, management, math, and
finance classes even though the required courses are a bit different depending on colleges. Main
courses of B.A. Accounting at Nanjing Audit University include: Economics, Management,
Statistics, Management Information System, Economic Law, Tax law, Marketing, Monetary and
Banking, Financial Accounting, Intermediate Accounting, Advanced Accounting, Cost
Accounting, Management Accounting, Auditing, International Comparative Accounting,
Accounting Information System, Accounting Statement Analysis, Research of Accounting
Cases, Accounting System Design, Financial Management, etc. (English.nau.edu.).
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
16/26
For master's degree, students should take more theoretical classes including accounting
history and modern accounting theory. Generally, Master of Professional Accounting (MPAcc in
short) programs are more profession-oriented in terms of education objective, admission policy,
course content, educational pattern and quality standard. Whereas, Master in Accountancy
programs are more academic and emphasize more on research.
(http://www.rbs.org.cn/templates/T_eng_new_list/index.aspx?nodeid=280)
The Chinese Institute of Certified Public Accountants
The CICPA Overview
The Chinese Institute of Certified Public Accountants (CICPA) is an organization under
the guidance of the Ministry of Finance and the Council. It was founded in November 1988 in
accordance with The Law of the Peoples Republic of China for Certified Public Accountants
and The Regulations for the Registration and Administration of Social Organizations.
As of October 31, 2010, CICPA has nearly 180,000 individual members, with 95,378 practicing
members and over 83,000 non-practicing members. (CICPA, 2011)
The CICPA Examination
The CPA National Examination Committee of the Ministry of Finance decided to reform
the CPA examination system in early 2007, with a view to support the further implementation of
the professional strategies. In accordance with the MOFs decision and the CICPAs reform
action plan, the new examination system was launched in 2009.
The main characteristic of the new CPA examination system in China is that the
examination consists of two stages:
1) Level 1: Professional stage
http://www.rbs.org.cn/templates/T_eng_new_list/index.aspx?nodeid=280http://www.rbs.org.cn/templates/T_eng_new_list/index.aspx?nodeid=2807/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
17/26
In this level, the examination primarily assesses whether examinees possess a good command of
the professional knowledge as required of a CPA in public practice, as well as the basic skills
and the professional ethics.
The 5 subjects under the old examination system are split, expanded, and combined. Level 1
examination consists of 6 subjects: Accounting, Auditing, Financial Management and Cost
Management, Corporate Strategies and Risk Management, Economic Law, and Taxation Law
2) Level 2: Advanced stage
The Level 2 examination assesses whether examinees can integrate and apply the professional
knowledge in practice, and whether examinees maintain the professional values, ethics and
attitudes, as well as the capability of solving problems. Level 2 exam tests an integrated subject
of all disciplines.
Examinees are only allowed to take up the examination of the advanced stage after he/she has
passed the professional stage. As the advanced stage focuses primarily on examinees
competency, it is suggested that examinees should gain adequate practical work experiences
prior to sitting the second stage examination.
The two levels of examinations are held once a year. The CPA examination in China is a
national unified examination and unlike the AICPA examination, there are no particular
requirements for each province. The examination results of each of the 6 subjects in the
professional stage are valid for 5 years. After successfully passing all the required subjects of the
professional stage examination, the candidate obtains the Certificate for Passing the
Professional Stage Examination. The integrated subject in the advanced stage should be
accomplished within 5 years after obtaining the Certificate for Passing the Professional Stage
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
18/26
Examination. After successfully passing the advanced stage examination, the candidate can
obtain the Certificate for Passing All Subjects.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
19/26
Accounting Student
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
20/26
Chinas Cultural Influences on Accounting
China has had a long and rich history. A large portion of its traditional culture has been
influenced by Buddhism, Confucianism, and Taoism. The culture that has built open over
generations places high value in harmony and moderation. Radical transformations in China are
not perceived favorably. Instead, Chinese culture advocates the importance of harmony and
unity amongst the Chinese people, the environment, and the society.
The government policies that have been places in China over the years have largely been
influenced by the nations culture. In recent years, China has been engaging in gradual
transformation from a planned economy to a market economy. The Ministry of Finance in 2006
implemented new accounting standards. While the government understands the importance of
IFRS in its accounting practices, China has until recently agreed upon a convergence path rather
than completely adopting all standards. This point stresses the importance that the government
places on a harmonious society. Harmony is viewed to incorporate the law in governing society
and bringing about fairness and honesty.
Hofstede (1980) from Holland developed a model of culture as the collective
programming of the mind that distinguishes the members of one human group from another. The
four cultural dimensions that he identified were Individualism versus collectivism, Large versus
small power distance, Strong versus weak uncertainty avoidance, Masculinity versus femininity.
Collectivism dominates Chinese culture as opposed to individualism. Authority by an upper
hand and the level of respect towards seniors is strongly accepted. This goes to show that there
is a large power distance. Since Chinese people do not tolerate extreme changes, they would
prefer to avoid a sense of avoidance. They view that everything has its own cycle eventually the
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
21/26
cycle will itself die out. Lastly, culture values such as relationship and harmony in China point
out that the country can be categorized as feminism as opposed to masculinity.
Based on the preceding four cultural dimensions identified by Hofstede, there is
uniformity, secrecy, low professionalism, and high regulatory control in China. As an example
of large power distance, in recent years that poor have become poorer, while the rich have
become richer. This gap, mainly created from Chinas transition from a planned economy to a
market economy, has given opportunities to many privileged people to make a lot of money.
The vast majority of accountants in China abide by the many detailed regulations set
forth in accounting standards. They lack the skills of judgment and self-discipline. These rules
and standards direct the accountants how to act given different situations. However, since real
life scenarios can be vastly different from what is written in accounting standards, Chinese
Accountants tend to become clueless as to what actions to perform. The accounting regulations
and laws implemented in China is set by the government. Private bodies and individuals rarely
have any say on the design of accounting standards. In regards to Uniformity, this concept is
highly correlated with uncertainty avoidance and low individualism. Chinas acceptance of its
enforcement regulations set for by the government also goes to show that uniformity is related to
the degree of high power distance in the nation.
The concept of secrecy reflected in China portrays the fact that the financial information
provided need not to be transparent. Since a majority of the enterprises in China are state-
owned, the financial information which are produced are mainly used by the management of the
same entities. The large power distance and low individualism in China contribute to the fact
that financial information is not widely dispersed with the public.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
22/26
With the introduction of the new accounting standards in 2006, there is a greater
likelihood that there will be greater evidence of higher professionalism. This is mainly reflected
by the new standards requirement of professional judgment by accounting professionals and the
need for financial information to be useful for decision making. The new standards mandate
enterprises present reliable and fair information to investors. Furthermore, the increase in the
number of college graduates studying accounting will also help increase the level of high
professionalism. The creation of a good moral standard can promote honesty amongst
accountants, resulting in the production of fair and authentic financial information.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
23/26
Appendix 1. Comparison of CASs and ISAs (As of 2006)
Chinese Auditing Standards
Equivalent
International
Standard
General Standard
1 General Standard for Assurance Engagements ISA 120
Auditing Standards for CPAs of China
2 No 1101 - Objective and general principles governing an audit of financial
statement
ISA 200
3 No. 1111 - Audit engagement letters ISA 210
4 No. 1121 - Quality control for audits of historical financial information ISA 220R
5 No. 1131 - Audit working papers ISA 230R
6 No. 1141Consideration of fraud in an audit of financial statements ISA 240
7 No. 1142Consideration of laws and regulations in an audit of financial
statements
ISA 250
8 No. 1151Communications with those charged with governance ISA 260
9 No. 1152Communications between predecessor and successor CPAs
10 No. 1201Planning an audit ISA 300
11 No. 1211- Understanding the entity and its environment and assessing the risks of
material misstatement
ISA 315
12 No. 1212Consideration relating to entities using service organizations ISA 402
13 No. 1221 - Materiality ISA 320
14 No. 1231Procedures in response to assessed risks of material misstatement ISA 330
15 No. 1301Audit evidence ISA 500
16 No. 1311Supervision of physical inventory count ISA 501 PartA
17 No. 1312 - Confirmations ISA 505
18 No. 1313Analytical procedures ISA 520
19 No. 1314Audit sampling and other means of testing ISA 530
20 No. 1321Audit of accounting estimates ISA 540
21 No. 1322Auditing fair values measurements and disclosures ISA 545
22 No. 1323Related parties ISA 550
23 No. 1324Going concern ISA 570
24 No. 1331Audit of opening balances on initial engagements ISA 510
25 No. 1332Subsequent events ISA 560
26 No. 1341Management representations ISA 580
27 No. 1401Using the work of other CPAs ISA 600
28 No. 1411Considering the work of internal auditing ISA 610
29 No. 1421Using the work of an expert ISA 620
30 No. 1501Auditors report ISA 700R
31 No. 1502Modified auditors report ISA 701
32 No. 1511 - Comparatives ISA 710
33 No. 1521Other information in documents containing audited financial
statements
ISA 720
34 No. 1601Auditors report on special purpose audit engagements ISA 800
35 No. 1602Verification of capital contributions
36 No. 1611Audit of financial statements of commercial banks IAPS 1006
37 No. 1612Inter-bank confirmation procedures IAPS 1000
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
24/26
38 No. 1613Relationship between banking supervisors IAPS 1004
39 No. 1621Special considerations for audit of small entities IAPS 100540 No. 1631Consideration of environmental matters in an audit of financial
statements
IAPS 1010
41 No. 1632Auditing derivative financial instruments IAPS 1012
42 No. 1633Effect of electronic commerce on the audit of financial statement IAPS 1013
Standard on Review Engagements for CPAs of China
43 No. 2101Engagements to review financial statements ISRE 2400
Standards on Other Assurance Engagements for CPAs of China
44 No. 3101Assurance engagements other than audits or reviews of historicalfinancial information
ISAE 3000R
45 No. 3111Examination of prospective financial information ISAE 3400
Standards on Related Service for CPAs of China
46 No. 4101Engagements to perform agreed-upon procedures regarding financialinformation
ISRS 4400
47 No. 4111Compilation of financial information ISRS 4410
Standard on Quality Control for CPA Firms
48 No. 5101Quality control of professional work ISQC 1
(Source: Earnest & Young China, 2006)
ISAInternational Standards on Auditing
IAPSInternational Auditing Practice Statement
ISREInternational Standards on Review Engagements
ISAEInternational Standards on Assurance Engagements
ISRSInternational Standards on Related Services
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
25/26
Appendix 2. Accounting Firms in China
The accounting profession experienced robust revenue growth in 2010, reaching a record
high of 37.5 billion RMB, an increase of 18 percent and higher than the growing pace of GDP.
Revenues for the Top 100 were 61.6 percent of the profession, or 23.1 billion RBM. The top 10
domestic firms grew over 20 percent, which was way above the Big Fours 4.24 percent.
By the end of 2010, excluding firms which are organized in the form of Chinese-Foreign
cooperation, firms with securities practice qualification have established 64 subsidiaries,
members or associates in Hong Kong or other overseas regions, generating revenue of 0.57
billion RMB, or 1.58 percent of the profession.
The Top 100 employed a total of 24,968 certified public accountants, an increase of 8
percent. Average revenue per capita (ARPC) continued growth trend, reaching 340,000 RMB in
2010, increased by 34,000 RMB, or 11.53 percent.
7/31/2019 Chinese Accounting System
26/26
Bibliography