Citizens and Governance in Citizens and Governance in a Knowledge-based Societya Knowledge-based Society
Results of first call Results of first call
Presented by Henry Scott, EKTPresented by Henry Scott, EKT
Implementation OverviewImplementation Overview
First Call in three parts shared between two First Call in three parts shared between two deadlines:deadlines:
1515thth April 2003 April 2003 Citizens-1: open to Networks of Excellence Citizens-1: open to Networks of Excellence
(NoEs) and Integrated Projects (IPs)(NoEs) and Integrated Projects (IPs) Citizens-2: open to Specific Targeted Research Citizens-2: open to Specific Targeted Research
Projects (STREPs) and Coordination Actions Projects (STREPs) and Coordination Actions (CAs)(CAs)
1010thth December 2003 December 2003 Citizens-3: open to NoEs and IPs onlyCitizens-3: open to NoEs and IPs only
Citizens-1 Research topicsCitizens-1 Research topics
Open to NoEs and IPsOpen to NoEs and IPs 1.1.3 Science and Technology in the knowledge- 1.1.3 Science and Technology in the knowledge-
based society based society 2.1.1 Societal trends in the KBS and their 2.1.1 Societal trends in the KBS and their
implications for quality of life implications for quality of life 3.1.1 Migration immigration and 3.1.1 Migration immigration and
multiculturalism as challenges for KBSsmulticulturalism as challenges for KBSs 5.1.2 Multilevel governance, democracy and new 5.1.2 Multilevel governance, democracy and new
policy instrumentspolicy instruments 6.1.1 New approaches to security and the role of 6.1.1 New approaches to security and the role of
Europe Europe
Citizens-1 OutcomeCitizens-1 Outcome Budget: 20 million EurosBudget: 20 million Euros Funding for “up to one proposal per topic”Funding for “up to one proposal per topic” 5 topics covered5 topics covered
OverallOverall 70 proposals received70 proposals received 6 were ineligible / withdrawn by proposers6 were ineligible / withdrawn by proposers 14 passed evaluation criteria thresholds (20%)14 passed evaluation criteria thresholds (20%) 5 were funded (7%): 3 NoEs + 2 IPs 5 were funded (7%): 3 NoEs + 2 IPs 36% of those passing thresholds were funded (very 36% of those passing thresholds were funded (very
low)low) Topic 2.1.1 – ‘Societal trends in the KBS and their Topic 2.1.1 – ‘Societal trends in the KBS and their
implications for quality of life’ - no proposal passed implications for quality of life’ - no proposal passed the threshold of evaluation criteria!the threshold of evaluation criteria!
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-1Citizens-1
Proposals by area
98
17
14
16
3 3
5
3
01 1
21
00
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
Science & technology inthe KBS
New approaches tosecurity
Multilevel governance Migration, Immigration &Multiculturalism
Societal trends in theKBS
proposals evaluated passed threshold to be funded
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-1Citizens-1
Country participation (EU-15)
50
90
132
27
92
47
115
37
22
123
1
63
29
44
150
6 5
30
310
311
4 510
0
113
7
27
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
AT BE DE DK ES FI FR GR IE IT LU NL PT SE UK
evaluated proposals passed threshold
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-1Citizens-1
Participation in proposals (ASS/ACC)
32
13
30
2225
3
26
19
45
15
19
4
56
17
21
13
74
1 0 02
4
0
42
9
0 0 1
9
0 1 1 00
10
20
30
40
50
60
CH IL IS LI NO BG CY CZ EE HU LT LV MT PL RO SI SK TR
evaluated proposals passed threshold
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-1Citizens-1
Researchers involved in proposals on the selection list
26%
74%
female male
Citizens-2 Research TopicsCitizens-2 Research Topics
Open to STREPs and CAsOpen to STREPs and CAs 1.2.1 Understanding of a KBS1.2.1 Understanding of a KBS 1.2.2 Knowledge-based entrepreneurship1.2.2 Knowledge-based entrepreneurship 1.2.3 New knowledge and integration of social 1.2.3 New knowledge and integration of social
sciences and humanities in Europe sciences and humanities in Europe 2.2.1 Education challenges for the KBS2.2.1 Education challenges for the KBS 2.2.2 Links between science and education2.2.2 Links between science and education 2.2.3 Intergenerational inheritance of 2.2.3 Intergenerational inheritance of
inequalities inequalities 2.2.4 Insecurity2.2.4 Insecurity
Citizens-2 Topics (contd)Citizens-2 Topics (contd) 3.1.2 “Knowledge for Humankind” initiative3.1.2 “Knowledge for Humankind” initiative 3.2.1 Historical development of socio-3.2.1 Historical development of socio-
economic models economic models 3.2.2 Citizens’ attitudes and civic values3.2.2 Citizens’ attitudes and civic values 3.2.3 Sustainable development and KBS3.2.3 Sustainable development and KBS 4.2 Transformations in the Candidate 4.2 Transformations in the Candidate
Countries Countries 5.2 Corporate social responsibility5.2 Corporate social responsibility 6.2.1 Human rights6.2.1 Human rights 6.2.2 Roots of violent conflicts6.2.2 Roots of violent conflicts 7.2.1 Active civic participation7.2.1 Active civic participation 7.2.2 The European public sphere7.2.2 The European public sphere
Citizens-2 OutcomeCitizens-2 Outcome
Budget: 33M EurosBudget: 33M Euros 17 topics17 topics 194 proposals received194 proposals received 54 above thresholds (28%)54 above thresholds (28%) 39 selected for funding (20%)39 selected for funding (20%) 72% of those above threshold selected for funding 72% of those above threshold selected for funding
(acceptable ratios – slightly better than in FP5)(acceptable ratios – slightly better than in FP5)
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-2Citizens-2
Proposals by area
15
19
8
22
5
10
7
12
5
3
17
23
8 8
22
10
2
54
3
1
43
4
21
5 5
12
6 6
1
3 32
1
3 3 32
1
34
12
43
0
5
10
15
20
25
1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.3 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3 2.2.4 3.2.1 3.2.2 3.2.3 4.2 5.2 6.2.1 6.2.2 7.2.1 7.2.2
proposals evaluated above threshold proposals to be funded
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-2Citizens-2
Country participation in proposals (EU-15)
6270
181
34
115
46
110
3423
163
0
82
36
63
203
16 20
56
8
2514
43
11 10
39
0
27
817
64
0
50
100
150
200
250
AT BE DE DK ES FI FR GR IE IT LU NL PT SE UK
evaluated proposals passed threshold
FirstFirst Call FP6: Call FP6: Citizens-2Citizens-2
Country participation in proposals (ASS/ACC)
22
17
1 0
3331
11
3128
53
23
14
6
77
25
41
1416
6
1 0 0
11
63
69
11
4 3 2
24
48
35
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
CH IL IS LI NO BG CY CZ EE HU LT LV MT PL RO SI SK TR
evaluated proposals passed threshold
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-2Citizens-2
First levelFirst level Second levelSecond level
Third levelThird level– Fourth levelFourth level
Fifth levelFifth level
Researchers involved in selected proposals
34%
66%
female male
Citizens-3 Research TopicsCitizens-3 Research Topics
Open to NoEs and IPs onlyOpen to NoEs and IPs only 1.1.1 Understanding Knowledge1.1.1 Understanding Knowledge 1.1.2 Knowledge dynamics and economic and societal 1.1.2 Knowledge dynamics and economic and societal
development I Europe and in its regions development I Europe and in its regions 2.1.2 Social cohesion in the KBS2.1.2 Social cohesion in the KBS 2.1.3 Changes in work in the knowledge society2.1.3 Changes in work in the knowledge society 2.1.4 promoting the knowledge society through life-long 2.1.4 promoting the knowledge society through life-long
learning learning 4.1.1 “Deepening and widening of the European Union”: 4.1.1 “Deepening and widening of the European Union”:
lessons from the past and visions of the future lessons from the past and visions of the future 4.1.2 Global governance, regulatory frameworks and the 4.1.2 Global governance, regulatory frameworks and the
role of the European Union role of the European Union
Citizens-3 Topics (contd)Citizens-3 Topics (contd)
5.1.1 Public interest: conception, regulation and 5.1.1 Public interest: conception, regulation and implementation implementation
5.1.3 Towards a European Contract Law5.1.3 Towards a European Contract Law 7.1.1 European Citizenship and multiple identities7.1.1 European Citizenship and multiple identities 7.1.2 Cultural dialogue and the European society7.1.2 Cultural dialogue and the European society 7.1.3 New perspectives on European History7.1.3 New perspectives on European History
Citizens-3 OutcomeCitizens-3 Outcome
Budget: 48 Million EurosBudget: 48 Million Euros 12 Topics12 Topics 169 proposals evaluated169 proposals evaluated 22 passed thresholds (13%)22 passed thresholds (13%) 15 selected for funding (9%)15 selected for funding (9%) 68% of those above threshold selected for 68% of those above threshold selected for
funding (acceptable ratio)funding (acceptable ratio)
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
First levelFirst level Second levelSecond level
Third levelThird level– Fourth levelFourth level
Fifth levelFifth level
169 Proposals Evaluated
111
58
IP NoE
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
Proposals by area
16
26
1816
107
11
8
3
30
16
8
0
3 2 1 2 1 1 1 1
5
2 3
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Proposals evaluated passed thresholds
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
First levelFirst level Second levelSecond level
Third levelThird level– Fourth levelFourth level
Fifth levelFifth level
Proposals that passed the thresholds
1111
IP passed NoE passed
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
Proposals selected for funding
0
1 1
2
1 1
0
1
1 1 1 1
1
2
1
IP NoE
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
Participants per Country in Evaluated Proposals EU-15 and ASS
138121
359
90
260
90
294
128
53
357
0
141
82
117
386
61
2410 0
85
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
AT BE DE DK ES FI FR GR IE IT LU NL PT SE UK CH IL IS LI NO
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
Participants per Country in Evaluated Proposals New MS and CC
15
73
43
123
31
12 9
140
63
32
70 71
43
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
CY CZ EE HU LT LV MT PL SI SK BG RO TR
First Call FP6: First Call FP6: Citizens-3Citizens-3
Participants per Country in Evaluated Proposals Third Countries
35
118
6
19
3 4
36
8
23
3
13
36
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40