1 1 September 19, 2017 Louise Carroll Associate Commissioner, Housing Incentives Department of Housing Development and Preservation 100 Gold Street New York, NY 10038 Re: 517-525 West 45 th Street Cure for Harassment Applications and Plans Dear Commissioner Carroll: On May 24 th , 2016, Manhattan Community Board 4’s (MCB4) Housing, Health, and Human Services Committee received a presentation from the owners of 517-525 West 45 th Street, a building for which they had submitted a Cure for Harassment Application. The owners presented plans for the building’s renovation, which included changes to existing units as part of the IMD legalization process. During that meeting, the Committee made a series of recommendations and requested clarification from the owner. The owner committed to returning to the Housing, Health, and Human Services Committee to present a revised set of plans based on the Board’s requests. The owner never returned to MCB4 to present scope of work approved by HPD Inclusionary Housing, which administers Cure provisions and DOB. There is no clarity as to the exact scope of work and work has proceeded in a poorly-managed way, resulting in a Stop Work Order issued on June 21, 2017. At its meeting on July 26, 2017, MCB4, by vote of XX in favor, XX opposed, XX abstaining, and XX present but not eligible to vote, voted to request that HPD provide the following: • A copy of the HPD-approved scope of work and plans for the Cure requirement • Review of the owner’s plans submitted to the Loft Board to ensure consistency with the HPD Scope and plans Furthermore, the Board requests that HPD review the owner’s plans submitted to the Loft Board and DOB to ensure consistency with the HPD approved Scope and plans. Background 517-525 West 45 th Street is a loft building complex consisting of five adjacent and connected structures of differing heights. All building wings are on a single zoning lot (Block 1074, Lot 18) CITY OF NEW YORK MANHATTAN COMMUNITY BOARD FOUR 330 West 42 nd Street, 26 th floor New York, NY 10036 tel: 212-736-4536 fax: 212-947-9512 www.nyc.gov/mcb4 Delores Rubin Chair Jesse Bodine District Manager
Transcript
1
1 September 19, 2017 Louise Carroll Associate Commissioner, Housing Incentives Department of Housing Development and Preservation 100 Gold Street New York, NY 10038
Re: 517-525 West 45th Street Cure for Harassment Applications and Plans
Dear Commissioner Carroll: On May 24th, 2016, Manhattan Community Board 4’s (MCB4) Housing, Health, and Human Services Committee received a presentation from the owners of 517-525 West 45th Street, a building for which they had submitted a Cure for Harassment Application. The owners presented plans for the building’s renovation, which included changes to existing units as part of the IMD legalization process. During that meeting, the Committee made a series of recommendations and requested clarification from the owner. The owner committed to returning to the Housing, Health, and Human Services Committee to present a revised set of plans based on the Board’s requests. The owner never returned to MCB4 to present scope of work approved by HPD Inclusionary Housing, which administers Cure provisions and DOB. There is no clarity as to the exact scope of work and work has proceeded in a poorly-managed way, resulting in a Stop Work Order issued on June 21, 2017. At its meeting on July 26, 2017, MCB4, by vote of XX in favor, XX opposed, XX abstaining, and XX present but not eligible to vote, voted to request that HPD provide the following:
• A copy of the HPD-approved scope of work and plans for the Cure requirement • Review of the owner’s plans submitted to the Loft Board to ensure consistency with the
HPD Scope and plans
Furthermore, the Board requests that HPD review the owner’s plans submitted to the Loft Board and DOB to ensure consistency with the HPD approved Scope and plans. Background 517-525 West 45th Street is a loft building complex consisting of five adjacent and connected structures of differing heights. All building wings are on a single zoning lot (Block 1074, Lot 18)
CITY OF NEW YORK
MANHATTAN COMMUNITY BOARD FOUR
330 West 42nd Street, 26th floor New York, NY 10036 tel: 212-736-4536 fax: 212-947-9512
www.nyc.gov/mcb4 Delores Rubin Chair Jesse Bodine District Manager
2
between Tenth and Eleventh Avenues1. The 517 portion of the building located on West 45th Street is four stories tall. Immediately to the west, the 525 portion of the building is five stories tall. Behind 517 and 525, off an interior courtyard, is a two-story portion called 525 Rear, as well as the 523 portion of the building, which is also a five-story structure. The building is located in the Preservation Area of the Special Clinton District (SCD). The building was first residentially occupied in 1963 under the Artist in Residence (AIR) Law, and became an IMD in 1986 (IMD #10516). The building contains a total of 18 apartments, of which 10 are Interim Multiple Dwelling (IMD) units. The IMD tenants of this building went through a series of tenant harassment tactics from 2004 through 2005, including withdrawal of building services and threatened use of force, aimed at forcing them out of their units. In 2008, per requirements of Section 96-110 of the Zoning Resolution for the Special Clinton District, former owner Shabbat LLC applied for a Certificate of No Harassment (CONH) prior to beginning construction work on the building. However, after an investigation, the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) determined that there was reasonable cause to believe that the building’s tenants had in fact been harassed. Shabbat LLC requested a hearing and on April 7, 2010, the New York City Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings found that there has been tenant harassment on the site. Because of the finding of harassment under the Special Clinton District, the owner is required to provide a Cure for Harassment (Cure) when applying for a building alteration through the Department of Buildings (DOB). The owner would be required to dedicate the greater of the following as affordable housing:
• 28% of the total residential floor area of the existing building; or • 20% of the total floor area of the newly proposed or enlarged building
517-525 West 45th Street is a unique circumstance in which a Cure for Harassment is also undergoing IMD unit legalization. Comments and Requests from May 24, 2016 Meeting At the Housing, Health, and Human Services Committee meeting held on May 24, 2016, the Board had the following concerns:
Minimum Distance between Buildings The building is required to keep a minimum of 60 foot distance between windows, per section 23-711 of the Zoning Resolution. The Board requested that the DOB review the plans submitted by the owner to ensure compliance with this and other zoning requirements.
1 See Appendix A – Tax Lot Diagram
3
False Forms under DOB Application No. 122204462 The owner had submitted DOB forms that misrepresented the extent of the work in the application. The Board requested that the owner re-submit these forms to correct the record. New DOB Tenant Protection Plan Requirement The Board noted that the building was subject to the new Tenant Protection Plan requirement, and that the owner would have to submit these plans prior to beginning work. The Board requested that these plans be reviewed By HPD’s Building and Land Development Services (BLDS) unit and that the DOB also ensure that the protection plan is adequate.
Registration with DHCR On December 13, 2016, the owner signed a Restrictive Declaration stating that the Cure units were required to be registered with DHCR. However, on December 15, 2016, under DOB Job No. 122204462, the owner submitted a PW1 form stating that the building did not contain residential units subject to rent stabilization2. The owner again submitted a PW1 under DOB Job No. 123090314 on May 11, 2017 that made the same misstatement3. Revised forms should be resubmitted by the owner with the correct information. Ensuring Plans Meet Requirements of ZR § 96-110 The owner repeatedly postponed their presentation to the Board over the course of several months, stating that they were working with HPD and tenants and had not yet come to an agreement. The owner explicitly stated that he would return to the Board prior to finalizing their agreement with HPD. Nonetheless, on December 13, 2016, the owner executed a Restrictive Declaration with HPD4, without any further input from the Board. This agreement embodies the Cure for Harassment requirement and specifies the owner is required to provide 11,365 square feet of floor area in the building as affordable housing. On February 16, 2017, the Loft Board sent a letter to the owner stating that they had certified the alteration plans and that the plans were in compliance with the requirements of 29 RCNY § 2-01(d)(2)5. Furthermore, on November 24, 2014, the owner submitted an application to DOB under Job No. 122204462 for the renovation of the building. The owner submitted revised building plans under that that application in December 2016. Those plans received DOB approval on February 27, 2017.
2 See Attachment B: PW1 dated December 15, 2016 3 See Attachment C: PW1 dated May 11, 2017 4 See Attachment D: Restrictive Declaration dated December 13, 2016 5 See Attachment E: Letter from Helaine Balsam dated February 16, 2017 and Attachment F: 29 RCNY § 2-01(d)(2)
4
The Loft Board and the DOB have both approved the owner’s proposed plans for the building. In the meantime, however, the owner did not present the final plans to the Board and the Board has not been able to confirm that the scope of work in the plans does in fact meet the Cure Requirement and the commitments made to the Board by the owner or is consistent with plans and scope approved by HPD. MCB4 requests the following:
• That HPD provide it with a copy of the HPD-approved scope of work and plans for the Cure Requirement
• That HPD review the owner’s plans submitted to the Loft Board to ensure consistency with the HPD Scope and plans.
• That DOB review the owner’s plans submitted to the Loft Board to ensure consistency with the DOB Scope and plans.
Conclusion By repeatedly postponing its final presentation of the Board, it is clear that the owner avoided the ongoing public process and then obtained HPD, Loft Board, and DOB approval for its plans and scope of renovation. MCB4 requests HPD provide clarity to ensure that the commitments made to MCB4 by the owner for the Cure for Harassment are embodied in the HPD approved plans. Further, the subsequent filings at the Loft Board and DOB must consistent with the HPD approved plans. Specifically, MCB4 seeks to ensure that the Cure units are fully ADA compliant and the apartment finishes are equal in all units throughout the building. Sincerely,
Delores Rubin MCB4 Chair (signed 9/19/17) (signed 9/19/17) Barbara Davis, Co-Chair Joe Restuccia, Co-Chair Housing, Health & Housing, Health & Human Services Committee Human Services Committee cc: R. Chandler, DOB
L. Carroll, HPD S. Bernstein, 517-525 West 45th Street, LLC
'Dot; #-i_
6A -E, 8B -C, 9-10, 12, 13C -F, 14, 18-20, 22 &
PW1A, P01DAlteration Type 1, OT: "No Work" 8C, 9-10 &
12, 13C -F, 14, 18-19, 22, PWIA, PD1
NYCBuildings
PW1: Plan / Work ApplicationMust be typewritten.
1)1.1111111111111111141,11111111111,11,11(111
1111111 1 11s111,11011°191111,1c!n1,011
1 Location Information Required for all applications.
House No(s) 517 Street Name West 45th Street
Borough Manhattan Block 1074 Lot 18 BIN 1,083,791 C.B. No.104
Work on Floor(s) 001 to 005 Apt. / Condo No(s)
2 Applicant Information Required for all applications. Fax, mobile telephone and e-mail address are optional information.
Last Name Bernstein First NameDaniel Middle Initial
Business Name Kutnicki Bernstein Architects Business Telephone (212) 431-5552
Business Address 434 Broadway, 4th Floor Business Fax
City New York State NY Zip 10,013 Mobile Telephone
4 Filing Status Required for all applications. Choose one and provide specified associated information.
Olnitial Filing 5, 7, 11, 12A, 25-26Choose only one:0 Standard Plan Examination or Review0 Professional Certification PC1, POC10 Professional Certification of Objections All
®Prior to Approval Actions 25-260 Amend Existing Filing 4A Subsequent Filing 6-7, BA (Alt -2 only), 11
6F OT/ANT - AntennaD OT/BPP - Builders Pavement Plan 8D
0 OT/FPP - Fire Protection Plan
0 OT/MAR - Marquee 8E, 26B
12114
PW1 PAGE 2
7 Plans/Construction Documents Submitted Plans are required for most applications.
Are plans being submitted with this PW1? Yes 0 No If yes, do the plans include: 0 FO - Foundation DEN - Energy Analysis
8 Additional Information
8A WT Cost WT Cost WT Cost 8B Is a building enlargement proposed?
El No enlargement is proposed
0 Yes 12, PD1
0 Horizontal 0 Vertical
Additional Construction Floor Area:
sq. ft.
8C Estimated Job Cost $1,505,000
8D Street Frontage: linear ft.
8E Height: ft. Width: ft
8F Total Construction Floor Area:
sq. ft.V.,., ///#9 Additional Considerations, Limitations or Restrictions
9A
9B
Review is requested under which building code? 2014 2008 X 1968 Prior to 1968
fres
0
0
No Yes No0 Alteration required to meet New Building 0 0 Change in number of
requirements (28-101.4.5) If yes, 13A-8 El 0 Change in occupancy0 Alteration is a major change to exits 0 g Change is inconsistent
dwelling units
/ use
with current certificate of occupancy
stories ."9C 0 g Facade Alteration0 0 Adult Establishment If yes, plot diagram (except0 0 Compensated Development (Inclusionary Housing)0 0 Low Income Housing (Inclusionary Housing)0 N Single Room Occupancy (SRO) Multiple Dwelling
0 g Filing includes Lot Merger / Reapportionment If yes,
0 0 Change in number ofDM) 0 0 lnfill Zoning
II 0 Loft Board Yes No Work Includes:0 0 Quality Housing 0 0 Prefab wood I -joists0 0 Site Safety Job/Project 0 0 Structural cold -formed steel
17 0 El Included in LMCCC 0 0 Open -web steel joists9D 0
0pEi
Ej
02]
0 Landmark 0 0 Filing to address violationsp Little "E" or RD Site (list #s-max. 5):
g Unmapped/CCO Street
E) Requesting legalization of work where no workwithout a permit violations have been issued
p Other (please specify on line provided below): 0 0 Filing to comply with LocalLaws (list its-max. 2)
r ..,
LL Number Year
Li CRFN(s) Restrictive Declaration /Easement (max.0 CRFN(s) Zoning Exhibit (I, II, Ill, etc. - max. 4):2015000152890,
4):
2015000152891
9E 0 0 BSA Calendar Numbers (max. 5):9F D m CPC Calendar Numbers (max. 5):9G g 0 Work includes lighting fixture and/or controls, installation or replacement. [ECC §404 and §505]
9H 0 0 Work includes modular construction under New York State jurisdiction0 lil Work includes modular construction under New York City jurisdiction
91 High Rise Team tracking #:
9J 0 g Structural peer review required per BC 16. If yes, provide NYS P.E. license number:
9K D D Work includes permanent removal of standpipe, sprinkler or fire suppression related systems
9L 0 I Work includes partial demolition as defined in AC §28-101.5, or the raising/moving of a building If yes, 218
0 [ il Structural stability affected by proposed work
L10 NYCECC Compliance New York City Energy Conservation Code
ID To the best of my knowledge, belief and professional judgment, all work under this application is in compliance with the NYCECC`
0 To the best of my knowledge, belief and professional judgment, all work under this application is exempt from the NYCECC* in accordance withone of the following (choose one):
0 The work is an alteration of a State or National historic building.0 The scope of the work is entirely in a "low -energy building" and is limited to the building envelope.0 The entire scope of work involves a temporary structure and/or one or more of the following work types:
FA, FP, SD, SP, FS, EQ, CC, OT/BPP, OT/FPP. Other work types are not exempt.0 This is a post -approval amendment and exempt under a prior edition of the energy code. See statement of exemption on attached drawings.
12/14
PW1 PAGE 3
11 Job Description 11A Related DOB Job Numbers
GENERAL CONSTRUCTION IN CONJUNCTION Wq.fl CHANGE OF USE TO RESIDENTIALAND IMD UNITS AS PER ARTICLE 7-C M.D.L. /
11B Primary application job no.
12 Zoning Characteristics
12A District(s) R8 12B Street legal width: 60 ft.
Overlay(s) Street Status: X Public Private
Special Dist.(s)CL If the zoning lot includes multiple
Map Number BC tax lots, list all tax lots here10-
12C Proposed: Use Zoning Floor Area District FAR /noosed Lot Details: Proposed Yard Details:
RESIDENTIAL 40,473s . ft. R8 2.93 Lot Type: 111Corner X Interior Through Check here if no yards: N or
COMMERCIAL 6,681sq. ft. R8 0.48 Lot Coverage 0 % Front Yard ft.
sq. ft. Lot Area 13,808 sq. ft. Rear Yard ft.
sq. ft. Lot Width 137 ft. Rear Yard Equivalent ft.
sq. ft. Proposed Other Details: Side Yard 1 ft.
sq. ft. / Enclosed Parking? Yes L. No Side Yard 2 ft.
Proposed Totals 47,154sq. . /3.41 / If yes, no. of parking spaces:
Existing Total 47,154sq. ft. / Z / Perimeter Wall Height 0 ft.
*Use can be one of the following: residential, commercial, manufacturing, or community facility. List only one use per line.
13 Building Characteristics *Main use/dominant occupancy per AC §28-101.5. **Use 2014 Code equivalents only. :Residential w/other use.
13A Primary structural system, choose one: MI Masonry
WoodIII Concrete (CIP)
Steel (Structural)II Concrete (Precast)
Steel (Cold -Formed) II Steel (Encased in Concrete)
138 Existing Proposed 13D Building Type: 1, 2, or 3 Family k:. Other
Structural Occupancy/Risk Cat. Mixed use building?t Yes C,', No
Seismic Design Cat.2014 Code
Designations'2014 Code
Designations' 13E Existing Proposed ,,,-
13C Occupancy Classification" RES [Yes ®No R-2 ®Yes** Building Height : ''''.i''r"tt 60 AConstruction Classification 3 OYes ONo 2-A [Yes ONo Building Stories 5 5 .
Multiple Dwelling Classification 'fr / /CAA 7 / Dwelling Units 1 29 .,./."13F Building was originally erected pursuant to which Building Code:
The earliest Code with which this building or any part of it is required to comply:
2014 2014 III
2008
2008 II1968 Ci
1968 E:4
Prior to 1968
Prior to 1968
14 Fill Choose one.
®Not Applicable LI On -Site Off -Site OUnder 300 cubic yards
15 Construction Equipment 16 Curb Cut Description
['Chute['Fence
OSidewalk Shed
Size: linear ft.
Construction Material: Size of cut (with splays): ft.
BSA/MEA Approval No. Distance to nearest corner: ft.
Supported Scaffold Other: to street:
17 Tax Lot Characteristics 18 Fire Protection Equipment
Original tax lots being merged or reapportioned (if applicable):
Tentative tax lot numbers (new tax lots only):
Existing ProposedYes No Yes No
Fire Alarm CI Li 0 ClFire Suppression El ElSprinkler CI 0 Li 0Standpipe CI 0 0 CI
12/14
PW1 PAGE 4
19 Open Spaces
Plaza Area
Existing Proposed
Arcade Area
Existing Proposed
sq. ft. sq. ft. sq. ft. sq. ft.
Parking Area sq. ft. sq. ft. Parking Spaces
Loading Berths sq. ft. sq. ft. Loading Berths
20 Site Characteristics 20A Flood Hazard Area Information
Yes No Yes No Yes No0 1:1 Tidal Wetlands Freshwater Wetlands 0 0 Substantial improvement?0 0 Coastal Erosion Hazard Area 0 IN Urban Renewal 0 0 Substantially damaged?0 D Fire District 0 Flood Hazard Area If yes, 20A 0 Floodshields part of proposed work?
21 I Demolition Details 'Mechanical equipment other than handheld devices to be used for demolition or removal of debris (BC P306.4).
Yes No21A 0 Demo. filing is for a secondary structure? If yes, specify structure being demolished:
O 0 Mechanical means* from out of building? If yes, mechanical means will demolish: ['entire structure or part of structure
O 0 Mechanical means* from within building? If yes, describe equipment proposed:
21B 0 0 Demolition work affects the exterior building envelopeO 0 The scope of work involves raising/moving of a building
22 Asbestos Abatement Compliance Choose one.
g:" The scope of work requires related asbestos abatement as defined in the regulations of the NYC Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).0 The scope of the work is not an asbestos project as defined in the regulations of the NYC DEP. DEP Control # is required.
DEP ACP-5 Control No.
['The scope of work is exempt from the asbestos requirement as defined in the regulations promulgated by the NYC DEP (15 RCNY 1-23(b))
or is an alteration to a building constructed pursuant to plans submitted for approval on or after April 1, 1987, in accordance with § 28-106.1.
23 I Sign
Purpose: Type: Estimated Cost: $ 23A Illuminated type: DDirect DFlashing [Indirect['Advertising ['Illuminated 23A Total Square Feet: Yes No
DNon-Advertising Non -Illuminated Height above Curb: ft. in. 0 0 If sign projects beyond building line, is ownerLocation: ['Ground ['Roof 23B El Wall Height above Roof: ft. in. billed for annual permit? If no, specify in 26B
Yes No 238 0 0 Is roof sign tight, closed or solid?O 0 Is sign inside building line? If no, sign projects by: Wft.Enin.O 0 Designed for changeable copy? If no, 23C
O Does an OAC have an interest in this sign or location? if yes, 23G
O Within 900' and within view of an arterial highway? If yes, 23D
Within 200' and within view of a park 1/2 acre or more? if yes, 23E
0. If answer is 'yes" to either of the above two questions and this is anadvertising sign, OAC sign number is required in section 23F
23C Sign wording. If extensive, provide only key wording.
23D Distance from Arterial Highway:
23E Distance from Park 1/2 acre or more:
23F OAC Sign Number:
23G OAC Registration Number:
24 Comments Place additional comments on an Al -1 form. See Guide for proper incorporation of professional certification statements.
125 I Applicant's Statements and Signatures Required for all applications.
Falsification of any statement Is a misdemeanor and is punishable by a fine or imprisonment, or both. It is unlawful to givebenefit, monetary or otherwise, either as a gratuity for properly performing the lob or In exchange for special consideratiI understand that R I am found after hearing to have knowingly or negligently made a false statement or to have knowincertificate, form, signed statement, application, report or certification of the correction of a violation required under thebarred from filing further applications or documents with the Department. I prepared or supervised the preparation ofsubmitted end to the best of my knowledge and belief, the construction documents and work shown thereon complyapplicable laws and rules, 0 («-check hers ifJ except as set forth in the accompanying documents_ I acknowledgethis application end supplementary schedules submitted Cluster Development Statement (rf applicable): I herebythose previously filed under the group lead job number, except as specified herein
For Initial New Building and Alteration 1 applications tiled under the 2008 or 2014 NYC BuildingCode only: does this building qualify for high-rise designation? 0 Yes Ej NoDirective 14 Initial applications only: I certify that the construction documents submitted andall construction documents related to this application do not require a new or amended Certificate ofOccupancy as there is no change In use, exits, or occupancy. CID Yea 0 No
Name (prin
Sign and Date.
P.E. / R.A. Seal (a s
oyee to accept, anyant or fine or both.
falsified anyncy, I may bes herewithode and others pertaining to
identical to
date over sea°
[ 26 [Property Owner's Statements and SignaturesFalsification of any statement Is a misdemeanor and is punishable by a fine or Imprisonment, or both. It is unlawful to give to e city employee, or for a city employee to accept, anybenefit monetary or otherwise, either as a gratuity for properly performing the job or in exchange for special consideration. Violation is punishable by imprisonment orfine or both. I
understand that If I arn found after hearing to have knowingly or negligently made a false statement or to have knowingly or negligently falsified or allowed to be falsified anycertificate, form, signed statement, application, report or certification of the correction of a violation required under the provisions of this code or of a rule of any agency, !may bebarred from tiling further applications or documents with the Department. Furthermore, I understand that I am responsible for Insuring that a final inspection be performed when thepermitted work is complete, end that a satisfactory report of final inspection be submitted, along with ail required submittal documents, so that the NYC Department of Buildings mayissue a letter of completion or certificate of occupancy within the time prescribed by law.
have authorized the applicant to file this application for the work speafied hereinarid all future amendments. I will not knowingly authonze any work that is not incompliance with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations
Yes No
O 0
O 0
Fee Exemption Request (Non -Prom Owned and Operated)In accordance with Administrative Code §28-112.1, Exception 1, I certifythat the deed holder is a corporation or association organized andoperated exclusively for the purposes Indicated In such section, and thatthe property Is used exclusively by such entity for such purposed. *
Fee Exemption Request (NYCHAHHC, NYC Agency, or OtherGovernment Owned and Operated) The building or any part thereof tobe constructed, renovated, altered or demolished is owned and operatedexclusively for the purposes of the NYC Agency, NYC Authority, NYSAgency, Federal Government or any other government entity. *
MI 0 Owner's Certifications Regarding Occupied HousingThe site of the building to be altered or demolished, or the site of the newbuilding to be constructed, contains one or more occupied dwelling unitsthat will remain occupied during construction. These occupied dwellingunits have been dearly Identified on the submitted constructiondocuments.
O au The site of the building to be altered or demolished, or the tide of the new
Owner pindividual El Partnership NYCHA I HHC
Type: ['Corporation p Other Government p NYC Agency['Condo Unit Owner or Co -Op Tenant -shareholder 26A
Is the deed holder a non-profit organization? 0 Yes ®No
Name (please print): SBA[ BERNSTEIN
Relationship to Owner. OWNER
Business Name/Agency: 517-525 WEST 45TE STREET, LLC
Street Address: 190 BEDFORD AVENUE
City: BROOKLYN State: NY Zip:11249 0Telephone Number: (9171 310-1865 Fax:
E -Mail Address: SEAIHNYCOGMAIL. COM (rf...I
Signature and Date
building to be constructed, contains occupied housing accommodations 126A I Condo/Co-Op Boardsubject to rent control or rent stabilization under Chapters 3 and 4 of Title26 of the New York City Administrative Code. if yes, effect one of the Name (please print):following:
IDThe owner Is not required to notify the New York State Homes andCommunity Renewal (NYSHCR) of the owner's intention to filebecause the nature and scope of the work proposed, pursuant toNYSHCR regulations, does not require notification.
Ekhowner has notifiedenewal
(NYSHCR) of its intention to file such constructione the New York Stale Homes end Community
documents/apply for such permit and has complied with allrequirements imposed by the regulations of such agency aspreconditions for such [filing/application].
Provide data NYSHCR notified:
aa 13 owner's Certification for Directive 14 Applications (if applicable)I have read and am fully aware of the applicant's statement that theconstruction documents submitted and all construction documents relatedto this application will not require a new or amended Certificate ofOccupancy as there is no change in use, exits, or occupancy and thework is not inconsistent with the current certificate of occupancyFurthermore, I understand that I em responsible for retaining a qualifieddesign professional to perform a final inspection when the permitted workis complete arid this professional must submit a satisfactory finalinspection report to the NYC Department of Buildings within the timefollowing Inspection prescribed by Department rule.
Notes for Section 28.4: Section required If unit owner signed Section 26 Signaturerequired for authorized representative of Condo or Co -Op board
* For lee waivers, please see the PW1 User Guide
See note in bottom left corner of page.
Title:
Street Address:
City: State: Zip:
Telephone Number: Fax:
E -Mail Address:
Signature and Date PI.
26B Lessee Responsible for Annual Sign or Marquee Permit
Name (please print):
Relationship to Owner.
Business Name/Agency:
Street Address:
City: State: Zip:
Telephone Number. Fax:
E -Mail Address:
DOB Reference Number: T00001589095User Ref ID: 2 923 90TPL 12/14
4 Filing Status Required for all applications. Choose one and provide specified associated information.
['Initial Filing 5, 7, 11, 12A, 25-26Choose only one:Ei Standard Plan Examination or Review0 Professional Certification PC1, POC1 Professional Certification of Objections All
['Prior to Approval Actions 25-26Amend Existing Filing 4A
OT/FPP - Fire Protection Plan0 OT/MAR - Marquee 8E, 26B
12/14
PW1 PAGE 2
7 Plans/Construction Documents Submitted Plans are required for most applications.
Are plans being submitted with this PW1? 1:1 Yes No If yes, do the plans include: 0 FO - Foundation 0 EN - Energy Analysis
8 Additional Information
8A WT Cost WT Cost WT Cost 8B Is a building enlargement proposed?
RI No enlargement is proposed
0 Yes 12, PD1
0 Horizontal 0 Vertical
Additional Construction Floor Area:
sq. ft.
8C Estimated Job Cost $ 1000
of 1000 8D Street Frontage: linear ft.
8E Height: ft. Width: ft.
8F Total Construction Floor Area:
sq. ft.
9 Additional Considerations, Limitations or Restrictions
9A
9B
Review is requested under which building code? 2014 2008 DJ 1968 U Prior to 1968
IYes
0
ID
No Yes No
Alteration required to meet New Building 0 E1 Change in number ofrequirements (28-101.4.5) If yes, 13A-8 0 I=1 Change in occupancy
0 Alteration is a major change to exits 0 N Change is inconsistent
dwelling units
/ use
with current certificate of occupancy
stories9C 0 El Facade Alteration0 EI Adult Establishment If yes, plot diagram (except
0 El Compensated Development (Inclusionary Housing)o p Low Income Housing (Inclusionary Housing)0 p Single Room Occupancy (SRO) Multiple Dwellingo p Filing includes Lot Merger / Reapportionment If yes,
0 El Change in number ofDM) 1:1 Ei lnfill Zoning
gi 0 Loft Board Yes No Work Includes:0 o Quality Housing 0 p Prefab wood I -joists0 p Site Safety Job/Project 0 Structural cold -formed steel
17 0 E Included in LMCCC 0 N Open -web steel joists9D 0
0p0
0
0I=1
p Landmark 1=1 o Filing to address violations
p Little "E" or RD Site (list #s-max. 5):
N Unmapped/CCO Streeto Requesting legalization of work where no work
without a permit violations have been issued
p Other (please specify on line provided below): 0 o Filing to comply with LocalLaws (list #s-max. 2)
LL Number Year
g CRFN(s) Restrictive Declaration/Easement (max.
g CRFN(s) Zoning Exhibit (I, II, Ill, etc. - max. 4):
4).
9E 0 0 BSA Calendar Numbers (max. 5):9F 0 N CPC Calendar Numbers (max. 5):9G 0 N Work includes lighting fixture and/or controls, installation or replacement. [ECC §404 and §505]
9H 0 O Work includes modular construction under New York State jurisdiction0 El Work includes modular construction under New York City jurisdiction
91 High Rise Team tracking #:
9J 0 El Structural peer review required per BC 16 If yes, provide NYS P.E. license number:
9K 0 N Work includes permanent removal of standpipe, sprinkler or fire suppression related systems
9L 0 0 Work includes partial demolition as defined in AC §28-101.5, or the raising/moving of a building If yes, 218
0 0 Structural stability affected by proposed work
10 NYCECC Compliance New York City Energy Conservation Code
[8] To the best of my knowledge, belief and professional judgment, all work under this application is in compliance with the NYCECC*
LI To the best of my knowledge, belief and professional judgment, all work under this application is exempt from the NYCECC* in accordance withone of the following (choose one):
0 The work is an alteration of a State or National historic building.0 The scope of the work is entirely in a "low -energy building" and is limited to the building envelope.El The entire scope of work involves a temporary structure and/or one or more of the following work types:
FA, FP, SD, SP, FS, EQ, CC, OT/BPP, OT/FPP. Other work types are not exempt.El This is a post -approval amendment and exempt under a prior edition of the energy code. See statement of exemption on attached drawings.
12/14
PW1 PAGE 3
11 Job Description
Application filed to provide energy analysis for structural work.
11A Related DOB Job Numbers
11B Primary application job no.
12 Zoning Characteristics
12A District(s) R8 12B Street legal width. ft.
Overlay(s) Street Status Ill Public Private
Special Dist.(s) CL If the zoning lot includes multiple
Map Number 8C tax lots, list all tax lots here O.
12C Proposed: Use* Zoning Floor Area District FAR Proposed Lot Details: Proposed Yard Details:
sq. ft. Lot Type: Corner Interior Through Check here if no yards: orsq. ft. Lot Coverage % Front Yard ft.
sq. ft. Lot Area sq. ft. Rear Yard ft.
sq. ft. Lot Width ft. Rear Yard Equivalent ft.
sq ft. Proposed Other Details: Side Yard 1 ft.
sq. ft. Enclosed Parking? Yes No Side Yard 2 ft.
Proposed Totals sq ft. If yes, no. of parking spaces
Existing Total sq. ft Perimeter Wall Height ft.
*Use can be one of the following: residential, commercial, manufacturing, or community facility. List only one use per line.
131 Building Characteristics *Main use/dominant occupancy per AC §28-101.5. **Use 2014 Code equivalents only. :Residential w/other use.
20 Site Characteristics 20A Flood Hazard Area Information
Yes No Yes No Yes No0 0 Tidal Wetlands 3 CI Freshwater Wetlands 0 0 Substantial improvement?0 0 Coastal Erosion Hazard Area 0 El Urban Renewal 0 0 Substantially damaged?ID 0 Fire District I=1 E Flood Hazard Area If yes, 20A Floodshields part of proposed work?
121 I Demolition Details *Mechanical equipment other than handheld devices to be used for demolition or removal of debris (BC 0306.4).
Yes No21A 0 Demo. filing is for a secondary structure? If yes, specify structure being demolished:
0 0 Mechanical means* from out of building?O 0 Mechanical means* from within building? If yes, describe equipment proposed:
If yes, mechanical means will demolish: p entire structure Or LI part of structure
21B 0 CI Demolition work affects the exterior building envelope
O 0 The scope of work involves raising/moving of a building
22 Asbestos Abatement Compliance Choose one.
Li The scope of work requires related asbestos abatement as defined in the regulations of the NYC Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).Ei The scope of the work is not an asbestos project as defined in the regulations of the NYC DEP. DEP Control # is required.
DEP ACP-5 Control No. 1296218['The scope of work is exempt from the asbestos requirement as defined in the regulations promulgated by the NYC DEP (15 RCNY 1-23(b))
or is an alteration to a building constructed pursuant to plans submitted for approval on or after April 1, 1987, in accordance with § 28-106.1.
I231 Sign
Purpose:
['AdvertisingID Non -Advertising
Type:
Li Illuminated 23A
Non -Illuminated
Location: ['Ground ['Roof 23B ['Wall
Yes No
0
Estimated Cost: $
Total Square Feet:
Height above Curb:
Height above Roof:
ft. in.
ft. in.
23A Illuminated type: ['Direct ['Flashing olndirectYes No
0 0 If sign projects beyond building line, is ownerbilled for annual permit? If no, specify in 26B
23B 0 0 Is roof sign tight, closed or solid?O Is sign inside building line? If no, sign projects by: ft. in. 23C Sign wording. If extensive, provide only key wording.
O Designed for changeable copy? If no, 23C
O Does an OAC have an interest in this sign or location? If yes, 23G
O Within 900' and within view of an arterial highway? If yes, 23D
O Within 200' and within view of a park 1/2 acre or more? If yes, 23E
0. If answer is 'yes" to either of the above two questions and this is anadvertising sign, OAC sign number is required in section 23F
23D Distance from Arterial Highway:
23E Distance from Park 1/2 acre or more:
23F OAC Sign Number:
23G OAC Registration Number:
24 Comments Place additional comments on an Al -1 form. See Guide for proper incorporation of professional certification statements.
25 Applicant's Statements and Signatures Required for all applications.
Falsification of any statement is a misdemeanor and is punishable by a fine or imprisonment, or both It is unlawful to give tobenefit, monetary or otherwise, either as a gratuity for properly performing the lob or in exchange for special considerationI understand that if I am found after hearing to have knowingly or negligently made a false statement or to have knowinglycertificate, form, signed statement, application, report or certification of the correction of a violation required under the prbarred from filing further applications or documents with the Department I prepared or supervised the preparation of thsubmitted and to the best of my knowledge and belief, the construction documents and work shown thereon comply withapplicable laws and rules, 0 6-check here if) except as set forth in the accompanying documents I acknowledge thatthis application and supplementary schedules submitted. Cluster Development Statement (if applicable) I hereby stthose previously filed under the group lead job number, except as specified herein
For initial New Building and Alteration 1 applications filed under the 2008 or 2014 NYC BuildingCode only: does this building qualify for high-nse designation? 0 Yes NoDirective 14 initial applications only: I certify that the construction documents submitted andall construction documents related to this application do not require a new or amended Certificate ofOccupancy as there is no change in use, exits, or occupancy 0 Yes 0 No PE /RA Seal apply sea
e to accept, anyor fine or bothified any
, I may berewithand other
ertaming todentical to
ate over seal)
26 Property Owner's Statements and Signatures
Falsification of any statement is a misdemeanor and is punishable by a fine or imprisonment, or both It is unlawful to give to a city employee, or for a city employee to accept, anybenefit, monetary or otherwise, either as a gratuity for properly performing the Job or in exchange for special consideration Violation is punishable by impnsonment or fine or both I
understand that if I am found after heanng to have knowingly or negligently made a false statement or to have knowingly or negligently falsified orallowed to be falsified anycertificate, form, signed statement, application, report or certification of the correction of a violation required under the provisions of this code or of a rule of any agency, I may bebarred from filing further applications or documents with the Department Furthermore, I understand that I am responsible for insuring that a final inspection be performedwhen thepermitted work is complete, and that a satisfactory report of final inspection be submitted, along with all required submittal documents, so that the NYC Department of Buildings mayissue a letter of completion or certificate of occupancy within the time prescribed by law
I have authonzed the applicant to file this application for the work specified hereinand all future amendments I will not knowingly authonze any work that is not incompliance with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations
Yes No
O 0 Fee Exemption Request (Non -Profit Owned and Operated)In accordance with Administrative Code §28-112 1, Exception 1, I certifythat the deed holder is a corporation or association organized andoperated exclusively for the purposes indicated in such section, and thatthe property is used exclusively by such entity for such purposed. *
O 0 Fee Exemption Request (NYCHA/HHC, NYC Agency, or OtherGovernment Owned and Operated) The building or any part thereof tobe constructed, renovated, altered or demolished is owned and operatedexclusively for the purposes of the NYC Agency, NYC Authonty, NYSAgency, Federal Government or any other government entity *g Owner's Certifications Regarding Occupied HousingThe site of the building to be altered or demolished, or the site of the newbuilding to be constructed, contains one or more occupied dwelling unitsthat will remain occupied dunng construction. These occupied dwellingunits have been clearly identified on the submitted constructiondocuments
0 is The site of the building to be altered or demolished, or the site of the newbuilding to be constructed, contains occupied housing accommodationssubject to rent control or rent stabilization under Chapters 3 and 4 of Title26 of the New York City Administrative Code If yes, select one of thefollowing:
The owner is not required to notify the New York State Homes andCommunity Renewal (NYSHCR) of the owner's intention to filebecause the nature and scope of the work proposed, pursuant toNYSHCR regulations, does not require notification.
The owner has notified the New York State Homes and CommunityRenewal (NYSHCR) of its intention to file such constructiondocuments/apply for such permit and has complied with allrequirements imposed by the regulations of such agency aspreconditions for such [filing/application]
Provide date NYSHCR notified:
Owner's Certification for Directive 14 Applications (if applicable)I have read and am fully aware of the applicant's statement that theconstruction documents submitted and all construction documents relatedto this application will not require a new or amended Certificate ofOccupancy as there is no change in use, exits, or occupancy and thework is not inconsistent with the current certificate of occupancyFurthermore, I understand that I am responsible for retaining a qualifieddesign professional to perform a final inspection when the permitted workis complete and this professional must submit a satisfactory finalinspection report to the NYC Department of Buildings within the timefollowing inspection prescnbed by Department rule
Notes for Section 28A: Section required if unit owner signed Section 26 Signaturerequired for authonzed representative of Condo or Co -Op board
* For fee waivers, please see the PW1 User Guide
Owner andividual 1E1 Partnership NYCHA / HHCType: 1-1jCorporation D Other Government D NYC Agency
EJ Condo Unit Owner or Co -Op Tenant -shareholder 26AIs the deed holder a non-profit organization? 0 Yes No
Name (please print): Shai Bernstein
Relationship to Owner: Owner
Business Name/Agency 517-525 West 45th Street, LLC
Street Address 223 Bedford Avenue, #90
City: Brooklyn State: NY Zip: 11211
Telephone Number: (917) 310-1865 Fax:
E -Mail Address: shaibnyc
Signature and Date
gmail.com
SI) 1/2C11"126Al Condo/Co-Op Board See note in bottom left corner of page I
Name (please print):
Title
Street Address:
City: State. Zip:
Telephone Number: Fax:
E -Mail Address
Signature and Date Pl.
26B Lessee Responsible for Annual Sign or Marquee Permit
This letter certifies compliance with all requirements of 29 RCNY § 2-01(d)(2).
Address517-525 West 45 Street
Job Application Plan No. and Date122204462 See attached Appendix A.
The original of this letter, with the raised seal affixed, must be submitted to theappropriate Borough Office of the Department of Buildings before you may obtain abuilding permit.
AFFIX LOFT BOARD SEAL:
Very truly yours,
Helaine BalsamExecutive Director
DEPT BLDGS Job No 122204462
Loft Board
ADnendix A - Plans Loft Board is CertifviPlan Number Plan Date
