8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

1/30

Afobdyj {mfoa dqqjqqbjnydni

dndfqoq mn amb{dudefj ujizayomn j``muyq

" ioqazqqomnq mn ygj boi"yjub yduljy "

Ydyqzd Gdndmhd

Ajnyju `mu Lfmedf Jnpoumnbjnydf Ujqjduag

Ndyomndf Onqyoyzyj `mu Jnpoumnbjnydf Qyziojq

4qy Cd{dn Ndyomndf \muhqgm{ mn Jamnmboaq m` Afobdyj Agdnlj dni

Fm| Aduemn Lum|yg Qyudyjlojq on Nmuygjdqy Dqod

Ymhm Cd{dn

5;"54 D{uof 5;4;

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

2/30

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

3/30

Jnizqj-QIE y{j bmizfjqJnjul jni"zqj& Ujnj|defj jnjul&\dqyj yujdybjny-ioq{mqdf& Ujqmzuajujaafonl

DOB-Jamqqyjb

XamznyuR

Emyymb"z{& jnizqj&QIE d{{umdagLfmedf Ndyomndf

DOB-Jamqqyjb

XlfmedfR

Emyymb z{-daamznyonl

bmijfq

DOB-BdyjuodfDOB-ALJDOB-Jnizqj bmijfq

'Jnjul& Bdyjuodfq/

DOB-Ob{dayX[mfoaR

Qob{fo`oji bmijf `muFmnl"yjub dqqjqqbjny m` afobdyj agdnlj

[umajqq-QIE y{j bmizfjqFdni"zqj& [m{zfdyomn"zuednosdyomn@mujqyu& Dluoazfyzuj\dyju Ujqmzuaj dni On`udqyuzayzujqDou Fmdi-jboqqomn

Mpjupoj| m` jboqqomn bmijfq

ALJ d{{umdag

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

4/30

Dndfqoq mn Amb{dudefj J``muyqe zqonl ygj DOB-JnizqjXLfmedfR

"Ioqazqqomnq dni {umajqqjq m`ygj Cd{dnq boi"yjub ujizayomn yduljy

"

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

5/30

DOB-Jnizqj XLfmedfR

Lfmedf emyymb"z{ bmijfUOYJ

LGL boyoldyomn{myjnyodfq amb{duoqmnqdaumqq Dnnjw O

amznyuojq

DOB-Jnizqj XCd{dnR

Cd{dn emyymb"z{ bmijfOJJC

Dndfqoq m` ijydofji

boyoldyomn m{yomnq |oyg

{mfoaojq on Cd{dn

DOB-ALJ XCd{dnR

Cd{dn ALJ bmijfCAJU& HZ

Dndfqoq m` jamnmboa

ob{day

DOB bmijfq on NOJQ

[umajqq dni amnyuoezyomn m` NOJQym Cd{dnq boi"yjub yduljy ioqazqqomnq

Mygju onqyoyzyjq

Amb{duonl

ujqzfyq

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

6/30

0 m{yomnq Cd{dnq boiifj"yjub yduljy'dq m` 49 D{uof 5;;?/

0

(:*

;*

":*

"4;*

"4:*

"5;*

"5:*

jboqqomn ym

4??; fjpjf

4

1

:

0

5

9

jboqqomn ym5;;: fjpjf

":*

"4;*

"4:*

"5;*

"5:*

"1;*

;*BDA

:;

)-yAM5

4:;)-yAM5

5;;

)-yAM5

1;;)-yAM5

;)-yAM5

{gmympmfydoa

49 bof. h\

'4; yobjq/

1< bof. h\

'5: yobjq/

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

7/30

Emyymb"z{ bmijfq

Amqyq3 ij`onoyomnq dni ijyjubondnyq

4/ Ygj ioujay jnlonjjuonl dni `ondnaodf amqyq m` q{jao`oa yjagnoadf bjdqzujqAmqy m` q|oyagonl `umb amdf ym ldq on jfjayuoa {umizayomn m` ob{umponl jnjul

j``oaojna m` d{{fodnajq m` {fdnyonl yujjq on uj`mujqydyomn {umludb. Yjagnoadf amqyq

adn qgm| njldyopj njy amqyq ejadzqj d lopjn yjagnmfml bd ojfi jnmzlg jnjul

amqy qdponl ym bmuj ygdn m``qjy ygj amqyq m` dim{yonl dni zqonl ygj yjagnmfml. Ygjqj

amqyq ij{jni mn emyg yjagnoadf"jamnmboa idyd dni d lopjn onyjujqy udyj.

5/ Jamnmboa amqyq `mu d lopjn qjaymuAmqy e {duyodf jtzofoeuozb dndfqoq on qjayumudf bmijfq ygdy im nmy ad{yzuj ygj

`jjiedah j``jayq ejy|jjn ygj ejgdpomzu m` d qjaymu dni ygdy m` ygj mpjudff jamnmb.

1/ Bdaumjamnmboa amqyqYgj ob{day m` d lopjn qyudyjl mn ygj fjpjf m` ygj LI[ dni oyq amb{mnjnyq

'gmzqjgmfi amnqzb{yomn onpjqybjnyjya/. Ygoq dllujldyji onijw bjdqzujq ygj

bmnjydu pdfzj diiji m` lmmiq dni qjupoajq dni {umpoijq dn onijw m` ygj qadfj m`

gzbdn dayopoyojq onafzionl ygj `jjiedah j``jayq ejy|jjn ygj ejgdpomzu dni jamnmb.

9/ \jf`duj amqyq

Qjj on ijydof3 O[AA Qjamni Dqqjqqbjny Uj{muy \LOOO Agd{yju 7 {{50?"5

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

8/30

Umfj m` m` DOB-JnizqjXLfmedfR

4/ Jqyobdyomn m` bdulondf dedyjbjny amqyq dnijpdfzdyj LGL boyoldyomn {myjnyodfq on |mufi ujlomnq.

" Ujlomn"|oqj boyoldyomn {myjnyodfq dni amqyq" Qjaymu"|oqj boyoldyomn {myjnyodfq dni amqyq

5/ Dndfqoq m` ygj ob{day m` {mfoa onqyuzbjnyq dniamnqjtzjny j``jayq mn LGL jboqqomn ujizayomnq.

" {mqqoeofoy m` dagojpjbjny m` ujtzouji ujizayomn

zniju qydeofosdyomn amnqyudonyq

Gm| bzag oq yjagnmfmloadf boyoldyomn {myjnyodf

e ujlomn & e qjaymu=

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

9/30

C[N 'Cd{dn/

DZQ 'Dzqyudfod/

NSF 'Nj| Sjdfdni/

UZQ 'Uzqqod/

AGN 'Agond/

ONI 'Oniod/

OIN 'Onimnjqod/

YGD 'Ygdofdni/

Ygj fdyjqy pjuqomn3

\mufi 15 ujlomnq

ZQD 'Znoyji Qydyjq/

WJ4: '\jqyjun JZ"4:/

WJ4; 'Jdqyjun JZ"4;/

WJ5 'Mygju JZ"5/

WQD 'Mygju Qmzyg Dqod/

WJD 'Mygju Jdqy Dqod/

WQJ 'Mygju Qmzyg"Jdqy Dqod/

B_Q 'Bdfdqod/

ADN 'Adndid/

YZU 'Yzuhj/

WJ\O 'Mygju \jqyjun JZ on Dnnjw O/

WJJO 'Mygju Jdqyjun JZ on Dnnjw O/

WJNO 'Mygju JZ/

WAQ 'Ajnyudf Dqod/

WMA 'Mygju Majdnod/

PNB 'Pojy Ndb/

HMU 'Hmujd/

BJW 'Bjwoam/

EUD 'Eudsof/

DUL 'Duljnyonj/

WFB 'Mygju Fdyon Dbjuoad/

SD@ 'Qmzyg D`uoad/

WD@ 'Mygju D`uoad/

WBJ 'Boiifj Jdqy/

Dnnjw O MJAI

DQJDN

Ujlomndf afdqqo`oadyomn

z{idyj

Izuonl ygj ioqazqqomnqm` boi"yjub yduljy3\mufi 51 ujlomnq

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

10/30

Yduljy ldq dni qjaymuq

LGL Qjaymu Bjdqzujq

AM5AG9N5M

[m|ju ljnjudyomn Amdf {m|ju {fdny Mof {m|ju {fdny Ldq {m|ju {fdny Ujnj|defj

'\oni Eombdqq [P/

Onizqyu Oumn dni qyjjfAjbjnyMygju onizqyuojq Emofju bmymu jya

Yudnq{muydyomn [dqqjnlju pjgoafj YuzahEzqQgo{ Douaud`y[dqqjnlju yudon@ujolgy yudon 'jwaj{y mu {o{jfonj yudnq{muy dni onyjundyomndfyudnq{muy/

Ujqoijnyodf dni& Ambbjuaodf

Ammfonl Gjdyonl Gmy"|dyjuAmmhonlFolgyonlUj`uoljudymu YP

AG9N5M

Dluoazfyzuj Fopjqymah uzbondyomn Bdnzuj bdndljbjny [dii ojfi Aum{fdni

BQ\ Bznoao{df qmfoi |dqyj

AG9 @zloyopj@zloyopj jboqqomn umb zjf

G@Aq

[@AqQ@0

@ldq jboqqomnq E"{umizay m` GA@A"55 Uj`uoljudny Djumqmf @mdbq Qmfpjny

Jyagonl Dfzbonzb {umizayomn Onqzfdyomn ldq mygjuq.

Nmyj/

Nzafjdu {m|ju gium {m|ju dni ljmygjubdf {m|ju ljnjudyomn duj onafziji on ygj edqjfonjdni ygj duj nmy amnqoijuji dq boyoldyomn m{yomnq on ygoq qyzi.

Ygjuj duj qmbj boyoldyomn m{yomnq |goag duj nmy defj ym ej amnqoijuji on ygoq qyzi izj ymygj fdah m` idyd dpdofdeofoy `mu jwdb{fj AM5 boyoldyomn m{yomnq on {jyumagjboadf N5M

boyoldyomn m{yomnq on |dqyj |dyju AM5 boyoldyomn m{yomnq on dluoazfyzuj jya.

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

11/30

Yjagnmfml m{yomnq `mu boyoldyomn bjdqzujq

Qjaymu Adyjlmu Yjagnmfml m{yomnq

Jnjulqz{{f

Amdf {m|ju{fdny J``oaojny amdf {m|ju {fdny [@EA '[ujqqzuosji `fzoiosji eji ambezqyomn/OLAA 'Onyjludyji Ldqo`oadyomn Ambeonji Aafj/Ldq {m|ju{fdny J``oaojny ldq {m|ju {fdny DAA 'Dipdnaji Ambeonji Aafj/Ujnj|defjq \oni {m|ju [gmympmfydoaq Eombdqq {m|ju {fdny

Onizqyu

Qyjjf

Amhj mpjn 'Amhj ldq ujampju& Dzymbdyoa ambezqyomn& Amdf |jy diczqybjny &Amhj iu y{j tzjnagonl& AML fdyjny gjdy ujampju& Njwy ljnjudyomn amhjmpjn/ Qonyju zundaj 'Dzymbdyoa olnoyju& Ammfju |dqyj gjdy ujampju& Bdonf|dqyj gjdy ujampju& J``oaojny olnoyju/ Efdqy zundaj 'Fdulj qosj efdqy`zundaj& Efdqy `zundaj ldq ujampju& \jy ym{ {ujqqzuj ujampju yzueonj& Iuym{ {ujqqzuj ujampju yzueonj& Gjdy ujampju m` gmy efdqy qympj& Amdfoncjayomn& Iu ym{ {ujqqzuj ldq ujampju/ Edqoa mwljn `zundaj 'FILujampju& FIL fdyjny gjdy ujampju/ Adqyonl & umffonl 'Amnyonzmzq adqyju&Gmy agdulj umffonl& Gmy ioujay umffonl& J``oaojny gjdyonl `zundaj& Gjdy`zundaj |oyg ujljnjudyopj ezunju& Amnyonzmzq dnnjdfonl fonjq/ Jfjayuoa`zundaj 'IA jfjayuoa `zundaj& Qaud{ {uj"gjdy/

Ajbjny Boff 'Yzej boff& Pjuyoadf boff/ Hofn '\jy hofn& Qjbo"|jy hofn& Iu fmnl hofn&Iu qgd`y hofn& Q[-NQ[/

Mygjuonizqyuojq

Emofju 'J``oaojny emofju Xamdf& mof& ldqR& Emofju |oyg ambezqyomn amnyumf Xamdf&mof& ldqR& Amljnjudyomn Xamdf& mof& ldqR& Ujljnjudyopj ldq emofju/& [umajqq gjdy

'J``oaojny onizqyuodf `zundaj Xmof& ldqR/ Bmymuq 'Bmymu |oyg Onpjuyju amnyumf&J``oaojny bmymu/

Ygoq qyzi oq edqji mn ujdfoqyoa dni azuujnyf jwoqyonl yjagnmfmlojq dni`zyzuj onnmpdyopj yjagnmfmlojq jw{jayji on 5;5; duj nmy ydhjn onym daamzny.

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

12/30

[m{zfdyomn

LI[Qjaymu"|oqj pdfzj diiji

Qmaom"jamnmboa bdaum `udbj bmijf

Qyjjf {umizayomndni yudij bmijf

Ajbjny{umizayomn bmijf

Yudnq{muydyomnijbdni bmijf

jnjul qjupoajijbdni bmijf

Dluoazfyzudfyudij bmijf

\dqyjljnjudyomn

bmijf

Auzij qyjjf{umizayomn

Ajbjny{umizayomn

Pdfzj diijim` qjamnidu

onizqyu

Yudnq{muydyomnpmfzbj

Jnjul qjupoajijbdni

'ujqoijnyodf/

Dluoazfyzudf{umizayomn

\dqyjljnjudyomn

Yjagnmfmlemyymb"z{ bmijf

{m|ju ljnjudyomn qjaymu

LGL jboqqomn

Jboqqomn m``fzmumaduemn

[uobdu jnjul{umizayomn

Bmijf

Jnimljnmzqpduodefj

Yjagnmfml idydedqj

Jnjul idydedqj

Yjagnmfmlemyymb"z{ bmijf

jnjul bononl qjaymu

Oumn dni qyjjfqjaymu

Ajbjny qjaymuMygju onizqyuojq

qjaymuYudnq{muydyomn

qjaymuUjqoijnyodf

qjaymu

Jnjul qjupoajijbdni

'ambbjuaodf/

Ambbjuaodfqjaymu

Dluoazfyzujqjaymu

\dqyjbdndljbjny

qjaymu

@fzmumaduemnjboqqomn qjaymu

Idydedqj

Yjagnmfml emyymb"z{ bmijf

Bdaumjamnmboa bmijf

Qjupoaj ijbdni bmijf

Yjagnmfml emyymb"z{ bmijf

Jfjayuoaoy ijbdni

Jnjul {uoaj

Jboqqomn daymu

Ono yodf amqy J` o aojna

fo`jyobjBdwobzb

io``zqomn udyj

Jwmljnmzqpduodefj

@fzmumaduemnjboqqomn bmijf

Mpjupoj| m` DOB-JnizqjXLfmedfR

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

13/30

Ampjudlj4/ Ljmlud{goadf ampjudlj5/ Qjaymudf ampjudlj

1/ LGL ampjudlj9/ Boyoldyomn m{yomnq ampjudlj

Idyd dqqzb{yomnq4/ [m{zfdyomn

5/ LI[ dni qjupoaj ijbdniq1/ Jnjul {uoaj9/ Ioqamzny udyj:/ [dedah {juomi0/ Amb{mqoyomn m` {m|ju qmzuajq

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

14/30

Adqj qyziojq `mu amb{dudefj j``muyq

Qajnduom D3 qgmuy {dedah {juomi

dumzni 1"jduq {dedah {juomi on bmqy m` qjaymuq.

dumzni 4;"jduq {dedah {juomi `mu fdulj {fdnyq qzag on {m|ju ljnjudyomn dni onizqyu Qajnduom E3 fmnl {dedah {juomi e {mfoa onyjupjnyomn

dijtzdyjf {dedah {juomiq amuujq{mnionl ym demzy :;~

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

15/30

Uj{fdajbjny

Nj| ijbdniq

W W(4

Onyumizayomnon jdu W(4

Qjupoaj ijbdni

Fmloa m` yjagnmfml qjfjayomn

_jdu

Dq {uopdyj onizqyuojq ydhj onym daamzny golg onpjqybjny uoqh `mu jnjul amnqjuponl

yjagnmfmlojq& d {dedah {juomi m` 1"jduq oq dqqzbji.

Yjagnmfml D'edqjfonj yjag/

Yjagnmfml E'boyoldyomn yjag/

O` Yjag D Yjag E ygjn Yjag D oq qjfjayji

Onoyodf amqy Uznnonl amqy `mu W jduq

Jwoqyonl

'4/ Uj{fdajbjny& nj| ijbdniq

Onoyodf amqy Uznnonl amqy `mu W jduq

Jwyjnqomn m`{d edah {juomi

O` Yjag D Yjag E ygjn Yjag E oq qjfjayji

Yjagnmfml D'edqjfonj yjag/

Yjagnmfml E'boyoldyomn yjag/

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

16/30

;

:;;

4&;;;

4&:;;

5&;;;

5&:;;

1&;;;

1&:;;

9&;;;

9&:;;

:&;;;

5;;:

Edqjfonj

;

5

;

:

;

4

;;

5

;;

Jfjayuoaoymzy{zy'Y\g/

[P

\ON

EBQ

LJM-G_I

NZA

LDQ

MOF

AMF

;

5;;

9;;

0;;

7;;4&;;;

4&5;;

4&9;;

4&0;;

5;;:

Edqjfonj

;

5

;

:

;

4

;;

5

;;

Jfjayuoaoymzy{zy'Y\g/

[P

\ON

EBQ

LJM-G_I

NZA

LDQ

MOF

AMF

;

:;;

4&;;;

4&:;;

5&;;;

5&:;;

1&;;;

1&:;;

9&;;;

5;;:

Edqjfonj

;

5

;

:

;

4

;;

5

;;

Jfjayuoaoymzy{z

y'Y\g/

[P

\ON

EBQ

LJM-G_I

NZA

LDQ

MOF

AMF

;

:;;

4&;;;

4&:;;

5&;;;

5&:;;

1&;;;

1&:;;

9&;;;

9&:;;

:&;;;

5;;:

Edqjfonj

;

5

;

:

;

4

;;

5

;;

Jfjayuoaoymzy{zy'Y\

g/

[P

\ON

EBQ

LJM-G_I

NZA

LDQ

MOF

AMF

;

5;;

9;;

0;;

7;;

4&;;;

4&5;;

4&9;;

4&0;;

5;;:

Edq

jfonj

;

5

;

:

;

4

;;

5

;;

Jfjayuoaoymzy{zy'Y\

g/

[P

\ON

EBQ

LJM-G_I

NZA

LDQ

MOF

AMF

Jwdb{fj m` amb{mqoyomn m` {m|ju qmzuajq

Qajnduom

D

;

:;;

4&;;;

4&:;;

5&;;;

5&:;;

1&;;;

1&:;;

9&;;;

5;;:

Edqjfonj

;

5

;

:

;

4;;

5;;

Jfjayuoaoymzy{zy'Y\

g/

[P

\ON

EBQ

LJM-G_I

NZA

LDQ

MOF

AMF

Cd{dn ZQD JZ5:

D iudqyoa jnjul qgo`y `umb amdf dni mof ym ldq oq dffm|ji o` oy oq amqy j``jayopj.

Qmaodf eduuojuq ujqyuoay dn iudqyoa jnjul qgo`y amnqoijuonl ujdfoqyoa qydyj.

Qajnduom

E

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

17/30

"

5;

9;

0;

7;

4;;

45;

49;

40;

47;

5;;

" :;; 4&;;; 4&:;; 5&;;; 5&:;; 1&;;; 1&:;; 9&;;;

LGL ujizayomnq 'ByAM5jt& 5;5;/

Bdulondfdedyjb

jnyamqy'ZQ)-yAM5jt/

C[N ZQD JZ5: UZQ

"

5;

9;

0;

7;

4;;

45;

49;

40;

47;

5;;

" :;; 4&;;; 4&:;; 5&;;; 5&:;; 1&;;; 1&:;; 9&;;;

LGL ujizayomnq 'ByAM5jt& 5;5;/

Bdulondfdedyjb

jnyamqy'ZQ)-yAM5jt/

C[N ZQD JZ5: UZQ

Jwdb{fj m` io``jujnaj m` dedyjbjny amqy azupjqon bdcmu ijpjfm{ji amznyuojq

Zniju ygj fmnl {dedah {juomi bmuj ujizayomn {myjnyodfq dy fm|ju amqyq duj jqyobdyji izj ym

ygj j``jayq m` {umbmyonl golg j``oaojny yjagnmfmlojq mn ygj ijbdni qoij.

Zniju amqy m{yobosdyomn |oygmzy jnjul qjazuoy ujqyuoayomnq on {m|ju ljnjudyomn bmuj

boyoldyomn {myjnyodfq duj jqyobdyji dempj :; ZQ)-y"AM5 jt izj ym ygj j``jayq m` d iudqyoa jnjul

qgo`y `umb jwoqyonl amdf dni mof {m|ju {fdnyq ym nj| j``oaojny ldq {m|ju {fdnyq.

Qajnduom D

" qgmuy {dedah {juomi" amqy m{yobosdyomn on {m|ju qjaymu

Cd{dn ZQD JZ5: Uzqqod

Qajnduom E

" fmnl {dedah {juomi" jnjul qjazuoy ujqyuoayomnq on {m|ju qjaymu

Cd{dn ZQD JZ5: Uzqqod

Dedyjbjnyamq

y'ZQ)-yAM5/

Dedyjbjnyamqy'ZQ)-yAM5/

8/9/2019 Climate Policy Assessment and Analysis in Comparable Reduction Efforts

18/30

Ioqazqqomnq on ygj O[AA DU9

Cd{dnjqj Lmpjunbjny |dnyji ym hnm| ygj amb{dudefj ujizayomn j``muyq

daumqq Dnnjw O amznyuojq ym dagojpj ygj 5:* ujizayomn `umb ygj 4??; fjpjf.

\muhonl Lumz{ Agd{yju 41 Emw41.