CLINICAL PERSPECTIVE ON MANAGING POLYPHARMACY
IN THE ELDERLY Gianni Di Perri
Clinica di Malattie Infettive Università degli Studi di Torino
Ospedale Amedeo di Savoia
Ospedale Amedeo di Savoia
About Aging…… • General figures on aging and aging with HIV Polypharmacy • General figures about elderly, polypharmacy and HIV infection Drug disposition in the elderly • Absorption, distribution, metabolism, clearance Antiretrovirals pharmacokinetics in the elderly • Old and new ARVs In Perspective….
About Aging…… • General figures on aging and aging with HIV Polypharmacy • General figures about elderly, polypharmacy and HIV infection Drug disposition in the elderly • Absorption, distribution, metabolism, clearance Antiretrovirals pharmacokinetics in the elderly • Old and new ARVs In Perspective….
According to demographic predictions, in the year 2030 at least 20% of the western
societies will consist of subjects aged > 65
….including healthy people….
….but also people with chronic disorders affecting different organs….
….and people with chronic metabolic disorders ….
Changing populations: the proportion of elderly people in the general population is increasing
Gavazzi & Krause. Lancet Infect Dis 2002;2:659–666
Old (65–79 years) 2% 11% 15%
Very old (>80 years) <0.5% 4% 9%
1900 2030 2000 Data from Switzerland
Elderly (>65 years) 4% 13% 21%
1900 2030 2000
Data from USA
Men will soon live longer than women for the first time as they ditch their unhealthy lifestyles Boys born in 2000 will live to 87 - the same as girls Younger boys forecast to then outlive their female counterparts All due to a decline in heavy industry, fewer smokers and improved healthcare
Women on average live longer than men in all countries, with the exception of:Zimbabwe, Lesotho, Swaziland and Afghanistan. 52 52 49 50
74,000
22%
30,000 12%
Età mediana alla diagnosi di AIDS per sesso ed anno
Survival of Patients with > 500 CD4+ T-cells/mm3 for > 5 years is similar to the general population
Standardized mortality ratio = mortality in HIV-infected patients / mortality in general population
Lewden C, et al J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2007; 46: 72-77
PIR = Patients with Immune recovery: antiretroviral experienced who had a nadir CD4+ count < 350/mm3 and reached a CD4+ count > 500/mm3, confirmed at censored time
nPIR = Patients with no immune recovery: antiretroviral experienced who started HAART after 31st December 1996 with a nadir CD4+ count < 350/mm3 and did not reach a CD4+ count > 500/mm3
Expected numbers of years left
courtesy of Giovanni Guaraldi, ISS, Rome, Sept. 2012
About Aging…… • General figures on aging and aging with HIV Polypharmacy • General figures about elderly, polypharmacy and HIV infection Drug disposition in the elderly • Absorption, distribution, metabolism, clearance Antiretrovirals pharmacokinetics in the elderly • Old and new ARVs In Perspective….
Prevalence and Risk of Polypharmacy among the Elderly in an Outpatient Setting: A Retrospective Cohort Study in the Emilia-Romagna Region, Italy (2011) Slabaugh SL, et al. School of Population Health Faculty Papers. Paper 44.
Outpatient Pharmacy database, 2007
Patient information available from a demographic file of approximately 1 million residents aged > 65 years (out of a total population of 4.459.246 = 22.4%)
The cohort was comprised of 887.165 elderly subjects who had at least 1 prescription filled during the study year
Duration of treatment for a given drug by using the WHO’s defined
daily dose (DDD)
Polypharmacy episode defined as overlapping treatment with 5 or more medications occurring for at least 1 day
Odds for exposure to polypharmacy were higher for: Older subjects Males Residents of urban areas
Prevalence and Risk of Polypharmacy among the Elderly in an Outpatient Setting: A Retrospective Cohort Study in the Emilia-Romagna Region, Italy (2011) Slabaugh SL, et al. School of Population Health Faculty Papers. Paper 44.
887.165 (88.7%)
112.835 (11.3%)
349.689 (39.4%)
537.476 (60.9%)
35% of polypharmacy intakers were exposed for > 100 days in the study year Top 3 classes of
medications: Antithrombotics Peptic ulcer disease &
G/Oe reflux disease ACE inhibitors
Prevalence and Risk of Polypharmacy among the Elderly in an Outpatient Setting: A Retrospective Cohort Study in the Emilia-Romagna Region, Italy (2011) Slabaugh SL, et al. School of Population Health Faculty Papers. Paper 44.
Adherence not measureable
Not including medications not reimbursed (benzodiazepines and over the counter drugs, eg. Herbal remedies, dietary supplements)
HIV-infected patients (commonly taking 3 antiretrovirals) aged less than 65 not included in the study
DDD definition: “the assumed average maintenance dose per day for a drug used for its main indication in adults” – substantial differences may exist between DDD and actually prescribed dose (e.g. antithrombotics)
Elderly often require more frequent dose adjustments due to decreased renal and/or hepatic function
LIMITATIONS
courtesy of Giovanni Guaraldi, ISS, Rome, Sept. 2012
Comparison of daily pill burden in HIV+ and HIV- subjects according to age
Guaraldi G, et al. CID 2011; 11: 1120-6
About Aging…… • General figures on aging and aging with HIV Polypharmacy • General figures about elderly, polypharmacy and HIV infection Drug disposition in the elderly • Absorption, distribution, metabolism, clearance Antiretrovirals pharmacokinetics in the elderly • Old and new ARVs In Perspective….
Increased pH Delayed emptying Decreased splachnic flow Decreased motility Decreased absorption surface
Reduced intestinal enzymes: • CYP3A4 • ABCB1 (Pgp)
GASTROINTESTINAL CHANGES ASSOCIATED WITH AGING
ATV RPV
PIs MVC
NNRTIs
BODY CHANGES ASSOCIATED WITH AGING
Decreased albumin increased Vd (albumin-bound drugs) Increased α1-acid glycoprotein (AAG) +/- decreased Vd (AAG-bound drugs) Decreased Pgp activity at blood-brain barrier Toornvliet R, et al. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2006; 79: 540-8 • Increased [ARV] > efficacy
• Increased CNS toxicity
LIVER CHANGES ASSOCIATED WITH AGING
Schmucker DL. Exp Gerontol. 2005; Maclean AJ et al. J Pathol 2003; Housset et al. Res Virol 1990; Banerjee et al. AIDS 1992; Blackard JT et al. J viral hepat. 2008; Hong F et al. Hepatology 2010.
Decrease in Liver size (up to 30%) (Maximal – Vmax) metabolic capacity is proportional to liver size, and its decrease with aging corresponds to decreased intrinsic clearance for oral drugs metabolized by the liver. This reduced metabolism can be counterbalanced by changes in plasma protein binding. Decrease in liver blood flow
10 30 50 70 90
2000
1500
1000
500 FHF
(ml/
min
) Age
Zoli M, et al. Age and Aging 1999; 28: 29-33
Decrease in enzymatic activity
• CYP3A4 • UGT seems to be preserved (conflicting data, 1.4 fold higher AUCs)
20 – 29 30 – 40 40 – 50 > 70 age // //
The antipyrine (phenazone) clearance rate declined after 40 years by a rate of 0.34 ml · min−1 per year toward old age (−29%, p < 0.001).
Half-life increased by 30% in old age
Age and cytochrome P450-linked drug metabolism in humans: An analysis of 226 subjects with equal histopathologic conditions. Sotaniemi EA, et al. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1997; 61: 331-9
P450 (nmol.gm-1) in liver biopsy from 226 subjects with comparable liver histology
RENAL CHANGES ASSOCIATED WITH AGING
Hallan SI, et al. Br Med J. 2006; 333:1047. Age (Yrs)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 20s 30s 40s 50s 60s 70s 80s > 90
< 30
Prev
alen
ce (%
)
GFR (mL/min/1.73 m2):
10s
30-44 45-59
Decreased GFR “ kidney mass “ nephron size “ nephron number “ glomerular surface area “ tubular function “ renal blood flow
Age is a critical variable in the Cockroft-Gault and Modification of Diet in Renal Disease (MDRD) which are used for estimating GFR for drug dosing
PK parameter Age-related changes affecting PK
PK impact Predicted overall PK effect
ARVs potentially
affected
Absorption (Ka, F)
^ Gastric pH v Gastric emptying v Splanchnic flow v Intestinal CYP3A4 v Intestinal Pgp
v F < > F, v Ka < > F, v Ka ^ F ^ F
v F or ^ F v Ka
ATV RPV other PIs MVC
Distribution (Vd) v albumin ^ AAG ^ body fat v lean muscle & body water v transp prot activ.
^ Vd v Vd ^ Vd (lipophilic drugs) ^ Vd
^ VD NNRTIs PIs MVC
Metabolism (CL) v albumin ^ AAG v liver mass v hepatic flow
^ CL/F v CL/F v CL/F < > CL/F
v CL/F PIs NNRTIs MVC InSTIs
Excretion (CL) v renal function v transport process
v CL/F v CL/F
v CL/F
N/NtRTIs
Potential Impact of Age-related Changes on PK
Schoen C, et al. Expert Opin Drug Metabol Toxicol 2013
About Aging…… • General figures on aging and aging with HIV Polypharmacy • General figures about elderly, polypharmacy and HIV infection Drug disposition in the elderly • Absorption, distribution, metabolism, clearance Antiretrovirals pharmacokinetics in the elderly • Old and new ARVs In Perspective….
n = 37 in 18-30 y n = 40 in 45-79 y ART naïve (or < 14 days) on LPV/r + 2 Nukes to 192 weeks. [LPV] in n = 44 at 24, 36, 96 wks.
Data shown is difference at week 24 when controlled for adherence score. However the difference was not significant at week 36 and 96!
Age-related changes in exposure of Darunavir
ARTEMIS – DRV/r 800/100 qd
TITAN – DRV/r 600/100
Sekar VJ et al 2008
Darunavir – 18% increase in AUC
Age-related changes in exposure of Atazanavir
Regimen Effect of Age on AUC
Reference
ATV/r 200/100 mg at steady state in patients
AUC 34% higher in patients > 42 years
Avihingsanon A et al 2008
ATV 400 mg single dose in healthy volunteers
AUC 17% higher in ‘elderly’ vs young.
O’Mara E et al 2001
Pharmacokinetics of two common antiretroviral regimens in older HIV-infected patients: a pilot study Dumond JB, et al. HIV Medicine, 2013
6 patients aged > 55 yrs per arm: EFV/TDF/FTC vs ATV/r + TDF/FTC Intensive sampling
TDF FTC EFV TDF FTC ATV RTV
AUC 0-24h
0.92
1.75
1.05
0.9
1.31
0.88
1.19
Cmax
0.87
1.26
0.84
0.94
1.31
1.09
1.78
EFV/TDF/FTC ATV/r + TDF/FTC
Median ratios for each drug, by regimen, in comparison to literature values
73 retrospective PK studies with age as covariate. Schoen C, et al. Expert opin Drug Metabol Toxicol 2013
Drug n. of studies No association found
Positive findings
LPV/r 9 8 100% increase AUC from 25 to 60 years of age
ATV +/- RTV 9 8 Slower ATV CL in aged > 30 yrs
AMP 2 2
DRV 3 1 Slightly higher AUC with age in 2 studies
IDV 6 4 [IDV] higher in 40-50 yrs aged & lower in 50-60 yrs aged / increase in volume but no effect on CL
NFV 3 1 Reduced [M8] metabolte in older adults
RTV 7 6 Faster elimination rate in middle aged (40 yrs) vs younger adults (20 yrs)
SQV 2 1 Slower clearance with age
Protease Inhibitors
-Regazzi M et al. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2005; 49: 643
Changes in Nelfinavir PK with Cirrhosis CYP2C19 is exquisitely sensitive to the presence of liver disease Branch, R. A. 1998. Drugs in liver disease. Clin. Pharmacol. Ther. 64:462– 464.
Efavirenz No difference in PK
The effects of age on antiretroviral plasma drug concentration in HIV-infected subjects undergoing routine
therapeutic drug monitoring Winston A et al 2013
Data from 3589 TDM samples were available for 2447 subjects (404 were > 50 years)
As age increased, NNRTI concentrations remained constant but PI concentrations increased.
p = .004
p = .05
Croteau D, et al. CROI 2012, paper 592
73 retrospective PK studies with age as covariate. Schoen C, et al. Expert opin Drug Metabol Toxicol 2013
Non-Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors
Drug n. of studies
No association found
Positive findings
DLV 1 0 Correlation between age and intrinsic CL (large proportion of PK variability)
EFV 12 10 +/2 2 studies found an age effect on univariate not retained in multivariate
ETV 2 1 5% AUC increase per decade of age
NVP 12 8 1 study found a 1.56% increase in AUC per year after 35 years of age / 2 studies found decreases in CL with age / 1 study found changes in CL with age but < > not reported
RPV 1 1
<60 years N=36
≥60 years N=18
0
100
200
300
Teno
fovi
r CL/
F (L
/h)
<60 years N=36
≥60 years N=18
0.0
2.5
5.0
7.5
10.0
Teno
fovi
r AU
C 0-2
4 (m
g.h/
L)
<60 years N=36
≥60 years N=18
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
Teno
fovi
r C24
(ng/
ml)
p = 0.045 p = 0.046
p = 0.077
Cevik M et al EACS, Belgrqde; 2011
Tenofovir (TFV) pharmacokinetics (PK) in HIV infected individuals over 40 years of age
TDF
N=899 N=482
P<0.001
Torino, data on file, 2013
TDF TDF
TDF TDF TDF TDF
TDF treatment is associated to renal alterations; although mostly reported as reduction in Cr-based measures (GFR by CG or MDRD), most severe disturbances are on tubular function Post FA, et al. JAIDS 2010;5:49-57.
TDF-associated renal toxicity is proportional to pK exposure Rodríguez-Nóvoa S et al. AIDS 2010; 24: 1064–1066 Poizot-Martin I, et al. 18th CROI, Boston, 2011. Abstr. n. 842 Ezinga M, et al. CROI 2012, Paper #603
TDF intake also associated to reduction in BMD, possibly with a mechanism including increased PTH secretion Masiá M, et al. AIDS Research and Human Retroviruses. 2012, 28(3): 242-246 Cotter AG, et al. JCEM; (Feb, 22) 2013
Both glomerular and tubular functions decline with age and chronic TDF intake might particularly impact in the elderly Mayersohn M. Applied pharmacokinetics: principles of TDM. 3rd ed. Applied Therapeutics. Vancouver, WA, 1992
TDF pK exposures varies according to companion drugs Calcagno A, et al. AAC 2013;57:1840-3 Ramanathan S, et al. CROI 2013; Atlanta, GA. #529
Ramanathan S, et al. CROI 2013; Atlanta, GA. #529
TFV AUC (mean [%CV]) Severe Renal Impairment (eGFR 15-29 mL/min)
TAF 25mg (n=14) 2070 (47)
Normal Renal Function
EVG/COBI/FTC/TDF (n=62) 4400 (50)
ATV+RTV (n=26) 3940 (30)
DRV+RTV (n=12) 4630 (16)
LPV/r (n=45) 3500 (27)
RPV/FTC/TDF (n=24) 3610 (21)
EFV/FTC/TDF (n=30) 2280 (19)
TAF 25mg Severe Renal Impairment (15-29 mL/min) (n=14) TDF 300mg Normal Renal Function (n=24)
TAF
TDF
TAF PK in Severe Renal Impairment • Open-label, single-dose study evaluating TFV PK following TAF
administration in severe renal impairment vs. matched controls vs. TDF in normal renal function
TFV exposures from TAF 25 mg are significantly higher (~5.7-fold) in severe renal impairment vs. matched controls, but still lower vs. TDF 300mg in subjects with normal renal function
TAF 25mg Matched Controls (≥90 mL/min) (n=13)
* Historical data
1
10
100
0 6 12 18 24 48 96 144 Mean (SD)
50
500
Time (hr)
TFV
Conc
entr
atio
n (n
g/m
L)
43
73 retrospective PK studies with age as covariate. Schoen C, et al. Expert opin Drug Metabol Toxicol 2013
Nucleoside/Nucleotide Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors
Drug n. of studies No association found
Positive findings
ABV 1 1
3TC 3 2 Age, [Cr] or CrCL correlated with drug CL
TDF 4 - Age, [Cr] or CrCL correlated with drug CL
ddI 2 2
d4T 2 2
AZT 4 2 1 study found slower CL in pts < 30 / 1 study found decreased CL in pts > 50
73 retrospective PK studies with age as covariate. Schoen C, et al. Expert opin Drug Metabol Toxicol 2013
Cell Entry and Integrase Inhibitors
Drug n. of studies No association found
Positive findings
MVC 3 2 Faster distribution rate in older pts with no impact on AUC
T-20 1 1
RAL 2 2
ELV 1 1
MVC
N=148 N=96
About Aging…… • General figures on aging and aging with HIV Polypharmacy • General figures about elderly, polypharmacy and HIV infection Drug disposition in the elderly • Absorption, distribution, metabolism, clearance Antiretrovirals pharmacokinetics in the elderly • Old and new ARVs In Perspective….
*
** **
***
***
*** ***
*** *** ***
*** ***
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
patie
nts
(%)
< 50 years
≥ 50 years
The therapeutic classes for potential DDIs in the ageing HIV population
Marzolini C et al. J Antimicrob Chemother 2011; 66: 2107-11
: 35% had DDI
: 51% had DDI
Drug prescriptions analysed for 1497 HIV-infected subjects; 477 age >50 y and 1020 age <50 y.
209 admissions in which an ARV was prescribed for HIV+ patient
Review of Records: 89 potential errors in 77 admissions
17 patients given HAART > 24h after admission
44 patients given incorrect dose or frequency
15 patients received < 3 antiretrovirals
13 patients received contraindicated combination of drugs
12 patients received contraindicated drug for > 24h*
1 error corrected within 24h
* 6 – Simvastatin + boosted PI 6 – PPI + Atazanavir
CID 2006; 43: 933-8
CONCLUSIONS • Based on available data, PK/PD parameters of most ARVs do not seem to
undergo clinically relevant modifications in the elderly
• A single exception might be TDF, whose clearance is further decreased in the elderly, but alternative solutions are available, including the development f the new pro-drug (TAF)
• Most uncertainty comes from the appropriate management of DDIs, whose likelihood increases with polypharmacy
• Newly marketed generics might put at risk the release of STRs (single-tablet regimens) with potentially more consequences on those patients already taking multiple medications
• More studies are required to better understand the full impact of aging on the management of polypharmacy, especially in patients with specific co-morbidities
Acknowledgments
THE UNIVERSITY of LIVERPOOL
TORINO: Stefano Bonora
Antonio D’Avolio
Mauro Sciandra
Marco Siccardi
Daniel Gonzalez de Requena
Lorena Baietto
Cristina Tettoni
Sabrina Audagnotto
Letizia Marinaro
Margherita Bracchi
Laura Trentini
Andrea Calcagno
Marco Simiele
Amedeo De Nicolò
Anna Lucchini
Filippo Lipani
Roberto Bertucci
Agostino Maiello
Bernardino Salassa
Francesco G. De Rosa
Chiara Montrucchio
Chiara Alcantarini
Chiara Cardellino
LIVERPOOL:
David Back
Saye Khoo
Andy Owen
Marco Siccardi
LONDON:
Marta Boffito
Anton Pozniak
ROMA:
Andrea Antinori
Emanuele Nicastri
Giuseppe Ippolito