Cloud-Chasing and Gummi Bears:A vaping and edibles update for primary care
December 4, 2019
Dr. Peter SelbyMBBS, CCFP, FCFP, MHSc, dipABAM, DFASAMChief – Medicine in Psychiatry Division, Clinical Scientist – Addictions, CAMH
Professor, DFCM, Psychiatry, and the Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto@drpselby www.nicotinedependenceclinic.com
Presenter Biography
Peter Selby is the Chief of Medicine in Psychiatry Division and a Clinician Scientist at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH). He is a Professor in the Departments of Family and Community Medicine, Psychiatry, and the Dalla Lana School of Public Health at the University of Toronto. He is also a Clinician Scientist in the Department of Family and Community Medicine. His research focus is on innovative methods to understand and treat addictive behaviours and their comorbidities. He also uses technology to combine clinical medicine and public health methods to scale up and test health interventions. His cohort of 240,000 treated smokers in Ontario is an example.
He has received grant funding totaling over 85 million dollars from CIHR, NIH, and Ministry of Health and has published 150 peer reviewed publications. He has published 6 books (including 5 edited), is the author of 31 book chapters, and 38 research reports prepared for the government. He is the Chair of the Medical Education Council for the American Society of Addiction Medicine. Dr. Selby mentors Fellows in Addiction Medicine and Addiction Psychiatry, junior investigators and medical students. The use of innovative methods to communicate messages makes Dr. Selby a sought after speaker for various topics including addictive disorders, motivational interviewing, and health behavior change at individual and system levels.
Peter Selby, MBBS, CCFP, FCFP, MHSc, DipABAM, DFASAMChief, Medicine in Psychiatry Division, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH)Clinician Scientist, Addictions Division, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH)Professor, Departments of Family and Community Medicine and Psychiatry, and Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of [email protected](416) 535-8501 ext. 36859
Grants/Research Support:• CAMH, Health Canada, OMOH, CIHR, CCSA, PHAC, Pfizer Inc./Canada, OLA,
• Medical Psychiatry Alliance, ECHO, CCSRI, CCO, OICR, Ontario Brain Institute,
• McLaughlin Centre, AHSC/AFP, WSIB, NIH, AFMC, Shoppers Drug Mart,
• Bhasin Consulting Fund Inc., Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute
Speaking Engagements (Content not subject to sponsors approval)/Honoraria:• Pfizer Canada Inc., ABBVie, Bristol-Myers Squibb
Consulting Fees: • Pfizer Inc./Canada, Evidera Inc., Johnson & Johnson Group of Companies,
• Medcan Clinic, Inflexxion Inc., V-CC Systems Inc., MedPlan Communications,
• Kataka Medical Communications, Miller Medical Communications, Nvision
• Insight Group, Sun Life Financial
Other: (Received drugs free/discounted for study through open tender process)• Johnson & Johnson, Novartis, Pfizer Inc.
NO TOBACCO or CANNABIS or VAPING or ALCOHOL or FOOD INDUSTRY FUNDING
Disclosures
Mitigating Potential Bias
In order to mitigate the potential for bias, all thematerial presented herein is based explicitly onevidence-based research.
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Learning Objectives
5
1Describe various vaping and dabbing delivery systems and the health outcomes of vaping and dabbing
2Describe the safety and effectiveness of vaping products as a smoking cessation aid
Identify current regulations on cannabis edibles and their health impacts
Discuss challenging case studies
3 4
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Describe various vaping and dabbing delivery systems and the health outcomes of vaping and dabbing
1
6
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Interest in Heat Not Burn is Rising
From 2015 to 2017, average monthly queries for heat not burn tobacco
increased by 2,956% compared to 7% for e-cigarettes Caputi et al., 2017
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Objective Design Participants Main Outcome
Measures
Results
Examine differences
in vaping and
smoking prevalence
among adolescents
Repeat online
cross sectional
surveys
National samples, 16-
19yo
2017-2018
Canada (n=7891)
England (n=7897)
US (n=8140)
Prevalence of
vaping and smoking
in past 30 days,
past 7 days, and on
15 or more days in
the past month
Vaping: Increase in
Canada (P<0.001
for all)
Ø England
Smoking:
Increase in Canada
(P<0.001), modest
increase in England,
Ø US
14
Prevalence of vaping and smoking among adolescents in Canada, England, and the United States
Hammond et al 2019
polling question
What is dabbing?A) A hip hop dance
B) Inhaling the vapors of concentrated THC
C) A term coined by rapper Bow Wow
D) The act of using gauze to soak up blood
Copyright © 2017, CAMH17
Inhalation:Dabbing
Stogner and Miller 2015
• Dabbing is the inhalation of vaporized butane-
extracted cannabis products
• Butane is used in production, not during
administration, and is (mostly) purged from product
prior to use
• The THC concentration in dab is (conservatively)
3-4x greater than in flower cannabis
polling question
Odds of developing Cannabis Use Disorder is how many
times higher for adolescents than for adults?
A) 1-2x higher
B) 2-3x higher
C) 4-7x higher
D) 10x higher
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Cannabis Dependence and Addiction
Winters and Lee, 2008; Hasin et al., 2015Winters and Lee, 2008; Hasin et al., 2015; National Institute on Drug Abuse (2017)
Cannabis dependence becomes addiction when the individual cannot stop substance use, despite
interfering with several aspects of life
• Odds of developing CUD 4-7 times higher for adolescents (12-18 yr. old) vs. adults (22-26 yr. old)
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Cannabis Use Disorders/ Addiction
Approximately 9% of cannabis users will develop dependence vs 68%of individuals using nicotine
• 17% if start using in their teens
• 20-25% if daily cannabis use
• Psychological dependence: cravings for the “high” feeling associated with use
• Physical Dependence: quit attempt after long term use can lead to mild withdrawal syndrome, lasting up to one week
• Disturbed sleep• Irritability• Anxiety
Anthony et al., 1994; Lopez-Quintero et al., 2011; NIH, 2017
• Upset stomach• Loss of appetite
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Short Term:
Attention
Memory
Motor function
Poor cognitive function
Coordination/balance
Decreased blood pressure
Increased heart rate
Anxiety, fear, distrust, or panic → “bad trip”
Cannabis Use: Adverse Health EffectsEffects are dependent on dose, route of administration, user’s previous experience, and setting
Hall and Degenhardt., 2009; Maistro et al., 2013; Rocchetti et al., 2013; Volkow et al., 2014; Gunn et al., 2016
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Long Term:All of the short-term effects +Increased risk of psychosis, depression, anxietyBrain
•Reduced hippocampal volume
•Increased cognitive impairments among adolescent users (reduced neural connectivity)
Respiratory Effects•Bronchitis
•Airflow Obstruction
•Bullous Disease & Emphysema
•Legionnaires’ Disease
Heart•Myocardial infarction, stroke and transient ischemic attacks
Cancer•Lung cancer, Testicular cancer (?)
•Larynx and esophageal cancer
Reproductive Effects•Slows fetal growth
•Greater risk of fetal malformation, anemia and cognitive impairments
Hall and Degenhardt., 2009; Maistro et al., 2013; Rocchetti et al., 2013; Volkow et al., 2014; Gunn et al., 2016
Cannabis Use: Adverse Health Effects
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
What are the effects of cannabis smoke on the airways?
Biehl,JR et al. 2015
➢ Increase in respiratory symptoms:cough, dyspnea, sputum
➢Concordant physiological changes observed of chronic bronchitis/ loss of ciliahyperplasia of goblet cells, edema/swelling of airways
➢CB1 receptors on SM are dose dependent
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
# of
Studies
Risk Ratio (RR)
(95% CI)
What does this mean? Limitations
Current/
former
cannabis use
vs. never
smoked
cannabis
N = 13 1.22*
(1.00 – 1.5)
Cannabis smoking, with
or without concurrent
tobacco use is
associated with a
increased future risk of
developing lung cancer
Study follow-up may
be too short to
observe clinical
development of lung
cancer
Cannabis Smoking and Risk of Lung Cancer: Meta-Analysis
Risk of lung cancer associated with cannabis smoking
*p = 0.05
Bouti et al., 2014
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
• ~three-fold increase in amount of tar inhaled and deposited into respiratory tract
• ~two thirds greater puff volume
• one-third deeper inhalation
• 4-fold longer breath-holding time
• ~ five-fold higher blood carboxyhemoglobin level
Compared to tobacco, smoking cannabis cigarette
associated with:
Relative Harms: Cannabis vs Tobacco
Wu et al., 1988; Bouti et al., 2014
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Tobacco:
• Reduce frequency and number of cigarettes smoked
• Smokeless forms of tobacco
• Non-tobacco products (i.e. NRT)
Cannabis:
• Avoid mixing with tobacco
• Reduce depth of inhalation and breath-holding time
• Alternative methods of delivery (i.e. edibles, vaporizers)
• Lower THC concentration
Harm Reduction Strategies
Rodu and Godshall, 2006
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Describe the safety and effectiveness of vaping products as a smoking cessation aid
2
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
E-cigarette vs Tobacco
• Non-combustible delivery of
nicotine → reduced harm
– Nicotine not classified as a
carcinogen by International Agency
for Research on Cancer
– Meta-analysis of 35 clinical trials
reported no increased risk of CVD or
other detrimental health effects
associated with nicotine intake
• E-cigarettes are less harmful
than smoked tobacco
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Comparison of Toxicants: Conventional
Cigarettes vs E-cigarettes
Toxic Compound
Conventional
Cigarette (µg in
mainstream
smoke)
E-cigarette (µg per
15 puffs)
Average Ratio
(Conventional
Cigarettes vs E-
cigarette)
Formaldehyde 1.6 - 52 0.20 – 5.61 9
Acetaldehyde 52 - 140 0.11 – 1.36 450
Acrolein 2.4 - 62 0.07 – 4.19 15
Toluene 8.3 - 70 0.02 – 0.63 120
NNN 0.005 – 0.19 0.00008–0.00043 380
NNK 0.012 – 0.11 0.0001 –0.00283 40
Goniewicz et al. 2014
NNN: N’-nitrosonornicotineNNK: 4-(methylonitrosoamino)-1-(3-pirydyl)-l-butanone
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Do e-cig help smokers quit? The early evidence
• Evidence from randomized controlled trials
– Bullen et al, Lancet 2013:382:1629-37
• 1st gen e-cigs (with and without nicotine) vs patch
• No sig difference in 6-month abstinence
– Caponnetto et al, PLoS One 2013
• E-cig with different doses of nicotine cartridge
• Decreased smoking and ~10% abstinence regardless of dose (in smokers
not interested in quitting)
– Halpern et al, NEJM 2018;378:2302-10
• Randomized to e-cigs (cigalikes), NRT, incentives
• Only 20% ‘engaged’
• V. low 6-month abstinence 0.1% to 2.9%
Copyright © 2017, CAMH36
Study Population Method Results
Hajek et al
2019
E-cigarettes vs
NRT
N=886
Adults from UK
National Health
Service stop-
smoking
services
Smokers
randomized to either
NRT or e-cigarette,
Both received
behavioural support
1-year abstinence rate:
18% in the e-cig group
9.9% in NRT group
E-cigarettes were more effective
for smoking cessation than NRT
Walker et al
2019
Patches in
combination
with e-
cigarettes
N=1124
Gen pop
Adult smokers
New Zealand
Motivated to quit
E-cig naïve
Smokers were
randomized 1:4:4,
patches only
(n=125);
patches + nicotine
e-cig (n=500)
Patches + nicotine
free e-cig (n=499)
Withdrew/lost to FU
50% in patches group;
32% in nicotine e-cig;
33% in nicotine-free e-cig
Patches + nicotine e-cig showed
modest improvement in smoking
cessation over that obtained from
patch + nicotine free e-cig
Copyright © 2017, CAMH37
Acute Lung Distress and Vaping
Study Population Symptoms Method Findings
Layden et al.
2019
Pulmonary
illness related to
e-cig us in
Wisconsin
N=53
83% male
Median age = 19
Sample from
people reporting
e-cig use in the
90 days before
symptom onset
respiratory
symptoms
(98%),
gastrointestinal
symptoms
(81%), and
constitutional
symptoms
(100%).
Medical
record
abstraction
and case
patient
interviews
94% of the patients
were hospitalized,
32% underwent
intubation and
mechanical
ventilation, and one
death was reported
Suggests additional research is needed
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
• CDC has identified vitamin E acetate as a chemical of concern among people with
EVALI
• Vitamin E acetate is used as an additive, most notably as a thickening agent in THC-
containing e-cigarette, or vaping, products
• CDC recommends that people should not use THC-containing e-cigarette, or vaping,
products, particularly from informal sources like friends, or family, or in-person or
online dealers
• In addition, people should not add any substance to e-cigarette or vaping products
that are not intended by the manufacturer
38
Acute Lung Distress and Vaping
Recent case clusters of E-cigarette or Vaping
Associated Lung Injury (EVALI)
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Vaping e-liquids expose user to several potentially harmful chemicals
39
Life-threatening bronchiolitis related to electronic cigarette use in a Canadian youth
• Diacetyl (flavouring compound associated with bronchiolitis obliterans with
inhalational exposure – “popcorn lung”)
• Case: 17y/o previously healthy Cdn
• severe acute bronchiolitis causing near-fatal hypercapnic respiratory failure and chronic airflow obstruction
• Calls for further research on the potentially toxic components of e-liquids
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
Identify current regulations on cannabis edibles and their health impacts
340
Copyright © 2017, CAMH41
Use of Edibles
Canadian Cannabis Survey
Canadian Cannabis Survey (CCS), 2018
n=12,958
41% of cannabis users reported using edibles
Increase from 32% in 2017
In all provinces, edibles were the second most commonly reported product of use (39-51%) amongst cannabis users, behind dried flower/leaf (80-87%)
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
• Harder to titrate the intoxicating effects due to delayed/variable onset of effects
• Accidental “overdose” following ingestion of additional doses
• At high doses THC can produce anxiety, panic attacks, and/or psychotic symptoms, increased heart rate and changes in blood pressure
42
Challenges Associated with Edibles
MacCoun et al 2015
Different pharmacokinetic and metabolic effects of cannabis when ingested rather than smoked
Copyright © 2017, CAMH
1 mg of Δ9-THC contained in an edible produces a behavioral effect similar to 5.71 mg of Δ9-THC contained
in smokable cannabis
43
Challenges Associated with Edibles
Barrus et al 2016
Case Study # 1
Kerri is a 34 year old woman who used vaping to quit smoking in the past. She has come back to you in her first trimester of pregnancy and is concerned that vaping could be harmful to the baby. She has heard that champix and zyban are effective to help people quit smoking and would like a prescription for either one. Her husband smokes and has no interest in quitting. Neither of them smoke or vape inside the home. Kerri has no family support and limited contact with friends.
How would you advise?
What resources would you provide/refer to?
Clinical Guidance
✓ Advise her to stop vaping, as the long term health effects and effects on the fetus are yet unknown.
✓ Assess for depression/ anxiety.
✓ First try behavioral strategies for cessation (i.e. changing her routines, using 4d (deep breathing, distract, drink water, delay) individual, group or telephone counselling).
✓ Suggest husband attend an appointment and utilize motivational interviewing to assess readiness and provide support to client
✓ Suggest she join the Pregnets online forum as it would also provide some needed social support.
✓ If behavioral strategies are not effective, then begin using intermittent NRT (i.e. gum, lozenge) to manage cravings, ONLY once she has entered her second trimester.
✓ - * Champix and Zyban have not been approved for use in pregnancy.
Resources:
▪ Pregnets website and online support
▪ Telehealth for supportive telephone counselling
▪ Smokers Helpline online support
▪ Region of Peel Public Health website (Parentinginpeel.ca)
Case Study # 2
A parent comes to see you because she recently found out that her 14 year old son is vaping. He tells her he got the vape pen from a friend and he was vaping to quit smoking. The parent did not know that her son was smoking. Both are scared about vaping because of all the news about the illnesses and deaths in the media. He is worried that if he stops vaping, he will return to smoking. The parent has resorted to buying vapes for her son to reduce the risk of him buying them online illegally and/ or getting illegal products from his friends.
How would you advise?
What resources would you provide/refer to?
Clinical Guidance✓ Inform parent that although purchasing legitimate vaping products for her son
reduces the risks associated with defective vaping products (i.e. burns and injuries from batteries), there are still risks. Also, it is illegal to supply e-cigarettes to anyone under the age of 19 (Smoke Free Ontario Act, 2017).
✓Advise the parent that it is not safe for youth to use any nicotine products, including cigarettes and vaping products. Youth can become addicted to nicotine much quicker than adults, and it can alter teen brain development.
✓Advise her that her son should stop vaping immediately and not return to smoking cigarettes. He should first try behavioral strategies for cessation (i.e. changing routines, identifying and avoiding triggers, developing effective strategies for stress management, etc.).
✓ If he is still having cravings that he cannot manage, advise her to bring him in to speak with you (or his doctor if different) or pharmacist about using intermittent NRT (i.e. gum, lozenge).
Resources:
▪ Peel Public Health community resources sheet (especially noting Youth Substance Abuse Program (YSAP) of Peel)
▪ Region of Peel Public Health website
▪ Health Canada’s tip sheet “Talking with your teen about vaping”
▪ Notanexperiment.ca
Case Study #3
A 25 year old female school landscaper has had a third visit to the ED in 3 weeks due to excess vomiting. She presents mildly dehydrated and after a day or two of admission with IV fluids and antiemetics she feels better but returns within a week with recurrent vomiting.
• No medical or psychiatric diagnosis• Consumes 2-3 edibles/day• Alcohol (3 to 4 beers on the weekend)• Tobacco (20 cpd)• Denies other substances currently. Past use of LSD, mushrooms but none in the last 3
months• Afebrile, vitals stable and no evidence of raised intracranial pressure. Pregnancy tests are
negative• Notices that a warm bath stops her nausea and vomiting
How would you advise?
What resources would you provide/refer to?