1

2010 JOINT COLLOQUIUM OF THE COCHRANE &

CAMPBELL COLLABORATIONS

B R I N G I N G E V I D E N C E - B A S E D D E C I S I O N - M A K I N G T O N E W H E I G H T S

18-22 October 2010 K E Y S T O N E , C O L O R A D O , U S A

WWW.COCHRANE.ORG

WWW.CAMPBELLCOLLABORATION.ORG

2

PR

OGR

AM

ME A

T A

GLA

NCE

18

-Oct

-10

19-O

ct-1

020

-Oct

-10

21-O

ct-1

022

-Oct

-10

TIM

EM

ON

DAY

TUE

SD

AYW

ED

NE

SD

AYTH

UR

SD

AYF

RID

AY

7:30

Mee

tings

Mee

tings

Mee

tings

Mee

tings

Mee

tings

9:00

Mee

tings

Ple

nary

Ses

sion

IP

lena

ry S

essi

on II

Ple

nary

Ses

sion

III

Ple

nary

Ses

sion

IV

10:3

0 C

offe

e B

reak

Po

ster

Ses

sion

I &

Cof

fee

Bre

ak

Post

er S

essi

on II

&

Cof

fee

Bre

ak

Post

er S

essi

on II

I &

Cof

fee

Bre

ak

Post

er S

essi

on II

I&

Cof

fee

Bre

ak

11:1

5N

ewco

mer

’s S

essi

on&

Mee

tings

Ora

l Ses

sion

s &

Wor

ksho

psO

ral S

essi

ons

& W

orks

hops

Wor

ksho

psO

ral S

essi

ons

& W

orks

hops

12:4

5Lu

nch

Lunc

hLu

nch

Free

Afte

rnoo

n&

Mee

tings

Lunc

h

13:4

5O

peni

ng S

essi

onW

orks

hops

Wor

ksho

psW

orks

hops

15:4

5M

eet t

he E

ntiti

esC

offe

e B

reak

Post

er S

essi

on I

& C

offe

e B

reak

Post

er S

essi

on II

&

Cof

fee

Bre

akC

offe

e B

reak

16:3

0M

eetin

gsJe

rry

Lee

Lect

ure

&R

ecep

tion

Mee

tings

Clo

sing

Ses

sion

18:3

0

Wel

com

eR

ecep

tion

& D

inne

rFr

eeEv

enin

g

Fare

wel

lD

inne

r/B

arn

Dan

ce

3

Put on your hat and saddle up as we ride into Keystone for the 10th roundup of the Campbell Collaboration and the 18th roundup of the Cochrane Collaboration — the first Joint Colloquium of these two fine parties.

Now “Colloquium,” for those of you who might not know, is a highfalutin’ word for “big meeting,” with lots of talk and arguing about how to make the world right. Feel free to speak your mind on the importance of the best meta-analytical methodology for unbiased health and social care data summarization, but if it must come to fists — and we all know it does sometimes — please remember to take your brawling outside. The cost of broken barstools used to persuade your colleagues will be added to your tab.

Speaking of tabs, we are especially grateful to our posse. We extend a big “Thanks, partner!” to all of the sponsors, organizers, facilitators, presenters, chairs and committee members that made this gathering possible. We also offer a shout-out to the local sheriff for keeping the order.

Lastly, don’t spend all of your energy fussing and fighting ‘cuz we’re planning one heck of a shindig Thursday night at the barn, and we hope you’ll like the chuck. So make sure you take a bath and comb your hair. And wear lots of clothes ‘cuz it might get cold even if it ain’t snowing yet. And remember to smile pretty for the photographer — it’ll let the folks back home know you had a real good time in Colorado.

Bob Dellavalle MD, PhD, MSPH

Cochrane Local Organizer

a Carolyn DiGuiseppi MD, PhD, MPH

Campbell Local Organizer

“howdy y’all”

WELCOME TO COLORADO

5

..............................................6

......................................................8

.........................................................9

....................................................................10

...................................................14

............................17

.......................................................18

...................................................... 27

.............................................................28

..................... 30

................................................. 35

........................................................57

.........................................57

....................................... 63

................................. 73

......................................83

...........................................89

............................................... 97

Contents

6

LOCAL ORGANIZING COMMITTEE

Local Organizer

Robert Dellavalle, USA

Local Organizing Team

Carolyn DiGuiseppi, USAJodi Duke, USAVicky Koehler, USAL. Kendall Krause, USAPaula Marchionda, USAJen McIntyre, USA

ABSTRACT COMMITTEE

Chairs

Lisa Bero (Cochrane), USAPaul Montgomery (Campbell), UK

Committee Members

Joseph Beyene (Cochrane), CanadaArild Bjørndal (Campbell), NorwayKate Cahill (Cochrane), UKMiranda Cumpston (Cochrane), AustraliaJane Dennis (Cochrane), UKJenny Doust (Cochrane), AustraliaDavina Ghersi (WHO), AustraliaGill Gyte (Cochrane), UKDavid Haas (Cochrane), USAPeter Herbison (Cochrane), New ZealandGail Higgins (Cochrane), AustraliaJulian Higgins (Cochrane), UKAsbjørn Hróbjartsson (Cochrane), DenmarkNai Ming Lai (Cochrane), AustraliaMariska Leeflang (Cochrane), NetherlandsAndreas Lundh (Cochrane), DenmarkPetra Macaskill (Cochrane), AustraliaJacque Mallender, UKChris Mavergames (Cochrane), GermanyEvan Mayo, Wilson (Campbell), UKEamonn Noonan (Campbell), NorwayJane Noyes, UK

Donna Odierna (Cochrane), USADon Operario (Cochrane), USACraig Ramsay (Cochrane), UKMarta Roque (Cochrane), SpainKathy Sabadosa (Cochrane), USAGeorgia Salanti (Cochrane), GreeceMargaret Sampson (Cochrane), CanadaMiny Samuel (Cochrane), SingaporeNancy Santesso (Cochrane), CanadaIan Shemilt (Cochrane), UKAron Shlonsky (Campbell), CanadaNynke Smidt (Cochrane), NetherlandsAntje Timmer (Cochrane), Germany Jeff Valentine (Campbell), USAGunn Vist (Cochrane), Norway Phil Wiffen (Cochrane), UKPaula Williamson (Cochrane), UKJo Yaffe (Campbell), USA

AWARDS COMMITTEE

Chairs

Terri Pigott (Campbell), USAPeter Tugwell (Campbell), CanadaAron Shonsky (Campbell), CanadaJini Hetherington (Cochrane), UK

SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE

Chairs

Kay Dickersin (Cochrane), USAHannah Rothstein (Campbell), USA

Committee Members

Hilda Bastian, Germany Lorne Becker (Cochrane), USALisa Bero (Cochrane), USAMichael Borenstein (Cochrane Methods), USAAn-Wen Chan (Cochrane Methods/EQUATOR),

CanadaRachel Churchill (Cochrane), UKLuis Gabriel Cuervo (WHO/PAHO), USA

Colloquium Committees

7

Colloquium Committees

Cindy Farquhar (Cochrane), New ZealandMichael Feuer, USA Mark Gibson, USA Steve Goodman, USA Jessica Gurevitch, USA Mark Helfand, USA Gail Kennedy (Cochrane), USAMerete Konnerup (Campbell), DenmarkBarry Kramer, USA Julia Kreis, Germany/USA Ilkka Kunnamo, Finland Julia Littell (Campbell), USACynthia Mulrow (Cochrane), USADaniel Nagin (Campbell), USAChad Nye (Campbell), USAMark Petticrew (Campbell), UKMilo Puhan, USA Rich Rosenfeld (Cochrane), USAAron Shlonsky (Campbell), CanadaChris Schmid (Cochrane), USANandi Siegfried (Cochrane), South Africa Karla Soares (Cochrane), IsraelRoger Soll (Cochrane), USAPrathap Tharyan (Cochrane), IndiaDavid Tovey (Cochrane), UKJanet Wale (Cochrane), AustraliaBarbara Warren (Cochrane CCNet), USALiz Waters (Cochrane), Australia

STIPEND COMMITTEE

Chairs Consumers

Maryann Napoli (Cochrane), USA\Caroline Rouse (Cochrane), UK

Developing Countries

Luis Gabriel Cuervo (Cochrane), USACaroline Rouse (Cochrane), UK

WORKSHOP COMMITTEE

ChairsTerri Pigott (Campbell), USAKaren Robinson (Cochrane), USA

Committee Members

Miranda Cumpston (Cochrane), Australia Gail Higgins (Cochrane), AustraliaJulian Higgins (Cochrane), UKMarta Roque (Cochrane), SpainKathy Sabadosa (Cochrane), USASusan Norris (Cochrane), USAJeff Valentine (Campbell), USAAron Shlonsky (Campbell), CanadaRyan Williams (Campbell), USA

PROFESSIONAL CONFERENCE ORGANIZERS, ACE MANAGEMENT

Dorothy Shadrick Danette GarlockMartha Baeza

KEYSTONE RESORTHeather UlrichTim Stachelski

8

Acknowledgements

This Joint Colloquium would not have been possible without our dedicated international team. We would like to extend a sincere thank you to everyone who has provided

tremendous support leading up to this Colloquium.

Please help us recognize these fine folks!

Eamonn Noonan, Nick Royle and the Campbell and Cochrane Collaborations, for their invaluable leadership and vision.

For those who made the bid for this Colloquium possible: David Norris, Richard Krugman, Kim Huber, Kay Dickersin, Judy Baxter, and Jen McIntyre.

Paula Marchionda & Kendall Krause for their long nights and weekends and relentless drive for perfection.

Laura Simmonds at Wiley Blackwell for her tireless work on the abstract book (Congratulations, Laura!).

Jini Hetherington from the Cochrane Collaboration for her help, support, and unequaled knowledge base of Cochrane inner workings.

The Scientific, Abstract, and Workshop Committees for putting together an unparalleled program, especially Hannah Rothstein, Kay Dickersin, Lisa Bero, Paul Montgomery, Terri Pigott, and Karen Robinson.

The creativity and support of Jill Conley at Collage Creative.

Vicky Koehler & Jodi Duke for helping out in the home stretch.

The great Keystone team of Heather Ulrich and Tim Stachelski.

Roberta Scherer, Jay Rubin, and Janie Gordon at the US Cochrane Center.

Carolyn Wieber at the University of Colorado Continuing Medical Education office, for her assistance with registration and CME.

Our conference organizers, Dorothy Shadrick and Dannette Garlock at ACE Management.

All of the Department of Dermatology administrative staff (Carlos Fernandez, Gary Wylie, Jennifer McMahon and Pat Somerset) for handling the reams of paperwork.

Luis Gabriel Cuervo and PAHO for providing our telecommunication tool, Elluminate.

Jini Hetherington, Caroline Rouse, and Julianne Ried from the Cochrane Collaboration for their handling of sponsored registrations.

Maryann Napoli for ensuring consumer representation and participation via Consumer Stipends.

Luis Gabriel Cuervo and Caroline Rouse for supporting our colleagues with Developing Country Stipends.

And… Our plenary speakers

AHRQ, University of Colorado Denver, University of Colorado School of Medicine, University Physicians Inc., The Jerry Lee Foundation, Wiley Blackwell, JAMAevidence and all of our sponsors.

Past and future Colloquium organizers…. Especially Steve McDonald and Juliane Reed for being so generous with their experience from the 17th Cochrane Colloquium in Singapore.

To all of you for Bringing Evidence-Based Decision Making to New Heights!

With our greatest appreciation, The Local Organizing Committee

26

General InformationPrizes and Awards

The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO/WHO) supports and promotes the development and use of research to improve the life and wellbeing of the people of the Americas, as reflected in its policy on research for health (www.paho.org/researchportal). PAHO/WHO and the Cochrane Collaboration share synergic values and goals.

PAHO/WHO wants to inspire Cochrane reviewers to address key public health and health systems research questions through the development of systematic reviews that provide helpful conclusions, have robust methods, and address topics deemed as a priority to the governments of the Americas. PAHO/WHO has therefore decided to sponsor, in collaboration with the Ibero-American Cochrane Centre and Network and the graceful contribution of the Spanish Agency of International Cooperation for Development (AECID), a prize to recognize systematic reviews and protocols relevant to the Health Agenda for the Americas 2008-2017, signed by the national health authorities of the Americas in 2007. This prize is the result of a memorandum of understanding between PAHO/ WHO and the Ibero-American Cochrane Centre.

The selection committee was comprised of four senior PAHO/WHO delegates with diverse backgrounds that declared having no conflicts of interest. They screened systematic review and protocol titles as registered with the Ibero-American Cochrane Centre and Network and published in The Cochrane Library Issue 3 of 2009. Then, a selection panel scored the screened the reviews and protocols

by: relevance to the Health Agenda of the Americas 2008-2017, methodological quality, potential impact on public health, applicability, and equity considerations.

All authors of the winning and finalist publications will be acknowledged with a certificate. An author of the winning Cochrane Review will be invited to the 2011 Cochrane Colloquium in Madrid. Congratulations to all awardees of this prize.

Based on the scores and deliberations a decision was made to award recognitions as follows:

Cochrane Review:Interventions for American cutaneous and mucocutaneous leishmaniasis, by Urbà González, Mariona Pinart, Mónica Rengifo-Pardo, Antonio Macaya, Jorge Alvar, John A Tweed.

Cochrane Review Protocols:Supplementary feeding with nutritional education for caregivers for promoting growth and development in young children in developing countries, by Drs. Yanina Sguassero, Dave Booker, Jane A Dennis, Alicia Orellano and Edgardo Abalos.

Interventions for controlling emigration of health professionals from low and middle-income countries, by Drs. Blanca Peñaloza, Gabriel Rada, Tomás Pantoja, Gabriel Bastías and Cristian Herrera.

Note: PAHO/WHO Staff and first-degree relatives will not be eligible to receive the prize; they can receive the certificate and mention.

100

Exhibitors & Sponsors

We would like to thank our host and sponsors for making the Joint Colloquium possible!

Hosted by: University of Colorado Denver

This Colloquium was funded under grant numbers 1R13HSo19063 and R13HS016868 from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

Wiley Blackwell

University of Colorado School of Medicine

University Physicians, Inc.

JAMAevidence & McGraw Hill

The Jerry Lee Foundation

Department of Veteran’s Affairs Eastern Colorado Health Care System

Kaiser Permanente

Colorado Injury Control Research Center

Pan American Health Organization

We would also like to thank Rocky Mountain Sunscreen and LÄRABAR for their contributions to the welcome bags!

Sponsors

U n i v e r s i t y P h y s i c i a n s , I n c .

All sponsorship and support is in accordance with the Cochrane Colloquium Sponsorship Policy. The sponsors have not been involved in the planning and organization of the Colloquium.