Comprehensive Evaluation for Sustainable Transport Planning

8/8/2019 Comprehensive Evaluation for Sustainable Transport Planning

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comprehensive-evaluation-for-sustainable-transport-planning 1/64

Dfkx}oeo`tlzo

Ozbgubslf` jf}Tutsbl`bmgo

S}b`txf}s Xgb``lìSfcc Glskb`

Zldsf}lb S}b`txf}s Xfgld| L`tslsuso

X}oto`soc

M}fy` Mbi X}oto`sbslf`

23 Nbùb}| =822

Btlb` Cozogfxko`s Mbà

Kb`lgb' Xelglxxlòt



X}oto`sbslf` Tukkb}|

Seo x}oto`sbslf` ylgg cltdutt b òy BCM x}fi}bk sfcozogfx iulcoglòt b`c sffgt jf} kf}odfkx}oeo`tlzo ozbgubslf` fj s}b`txf}s x}fnodst

xb}sldugb}g| jf} u}mb` s}b`txf}s. Ls ylgg bgtf cltduttS}b`txf}s x}fnods ozbgubslf` mots x}bdsldot b`clkxbdst sebs b}o fjso` fzo}gffaoc l` df`zo`slf`bgs}b`txf}s odf`fkld b`bg|tlt.



Sfcc Glskb` Mlf

Sfcc Glskb` lt jfu`co} b`c ooduslzo cl}odsf} fj seo Zldsf}lbS}b`txf}s Xfgld| L`tslsuso' b` l`coxo`co`s }otob}de f}ib`l~bslf`cocldbsoc sf cozogfxlì l``fzbslzo tfguslf`t sf s}b`txf}s x}fmgokt.Elt yf}a eogxt oxb`c seo }bìo fj lkxbdst b`c fxslf`t df`tlco}oc l`s}b`txf}sbslf` codltlf`+kbalì' lkx}fzo ozbgubslf` kosefct' b`ckbao txodlbgl~oc sode`ldbg df`doxst bddottlmgo sf b gb}io} buclo`do.Elt }otob}de lt utoc yf}gcylco l` s}b`txf}s xgb``lì b`c xfgld|b`bg|tlt.

Eo busef}oc seo F`glò SCK O`d|dgfxoclb ' b dfkx}oeo`tlzo L`so}òs}otfu}do jf} lco`slj|lì b`c ozbgubslì kfmlgls| kb`bioko`sts}bsoilot1 S}b`txf}sbslf` Dfts b`c Moòjls B`bg|tlt> Sode`lruot'Otslkbsot b`c Lkxgldbslf`t ' b dfkx}oeo`tlzo tsuc| yelde x}fzlcot

dfts b`c moòjls l`jf}kbslf` l` b` obt|+sf+bxxg| jf}kbs1 b`c Xb}alì Kb`bioko`s Mots X}bdsldot ' seo kfts dfkx}oeo`tlzo mffa bzblgbmgof` kb`bioko`s tfguslf`t sf xb}alì x}fmgokt.



I}ooslìt j}fk Zldsf}lb' MD



Tutsbl`bmgo S}b`txf}s

• Iffc ybgalì b`c d|dglì df`clslf`%elieots mlao kfco teb}o l` Db`bcb,

• _`lzo}tbg cotli` %bddfkkfcbsot xofxgoylse cltbmlglslot,.

• Iffc xumgld s}b`tls to}zldo.

• Dfkxbds b`c kloc cozogfxko`s%òliemf}effc tefxt b`c to}zldot,.

• Ts}fì do`s}bg mutlòtt clts}lds %nfmt b`ctefxt df`do`s}bsoc cfy`sfy`,.

• Glklsoc elieyb| dbxbdls|.

• Kloc efutlì s|xot %kbnf} xf}slf` fjefutlì lt kugsl+jbklg|,



Zldsf}lb Tutsbl`bmlgls| Xgb`

• Df`do`s}bsotcozogfxko`s.

• Lkx}fzo ybgalì b`cd|dglì df`clslf`t.

• Ts}oostdbxlì

• Lkx}fzo xumgld s}b`txf}s%M]S f} G]S xgb`òc,.

• D}obso s}b`tls+f}lo soccozogfxko`s.

• L`d}obto bjjf}cbmgoefutlì tuxxg|.

• ]ocudo xb}alì tuxxg|b`c kf}o ojjldlo`sg| x}ldo

xumgld xb}alì.



Tofug' Tfuse Af}ob



2&24&=822

Tutsbl`bmlgls| Xgb``lì

Tutsbl`bmlgls|okxebtl~ot seo

l`soi}bsoc `bsu}o fjeukb` bdslzlslot b`cseo}ojf}o seo òoc sfdff}cl`bso xgb``lìbkfì cljjo}o`s todsf}t'

nu}ltcldslf`t b`ci}fuxt.



X}ozo`slì X}fmgokt

Tutsbl`bmlgls| xgb``lìlt sf cozogfxko`s yebs

x}ozo`slzo kocldlò ltsf eobgse> ls b`sldlxbsotb`c kb`biot x}fmgokt}bseo} seb` yblslì jf}d}ltot sf cozogfx.



Tutsbl`bmlgls| Fmnodslzot

Odf`fkld Tfdlbg O`zl}f`ko`sbg

Kfmlgls|&Bddottlmlgls|

Dfìotslf` }ocudslf`

]fbcyb| dfts tbzlìt

Xb}alì dfts tbzlìt

Df`tuko} tbzlìt

Oò}i| df`to}zbslfÒdf`fkld x}fcudslzls| b`ccozogfxko`s

Sb mu}co`

Oruls|&Jbl}òtt

Bjjf}cbmlgls|

Eukb` eobgse

Dfkku`ls| dfeotlf`

Dugsu}bg x}oto}zbslf`

Dfkku`ls| glzbmlgls|Xumgld Xb}sldlxbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Dglkbso x}fsodslf`

Ebmlsbs x}oto}zbslf`

Botseosldt



Tutsbl`bmlgo S}b`txf}sbslf`6

Yfugc yo ebzo b

tutsbl`bmgos}b`txf}sbslf`t|tsok lj ozo}|mfc|c}fzo e|m}lct6



E|m}lct Cf @fs

• ]ocudo s}bjjld dfìotslf`

• ]ocudo bddlco`st

• ]ocudo zoeldgo xu}debto dftst

• Lkx}fzo kfmlgls| jf} `f`+c}lzo}t

• Lkx}fzo xumgld jlsòtt b`c eobgse

• ]ocudo tx}byg

• ]ocudo sb mu}co`t

• ]ocudo gb`c uto tx}byg

• X}fsods ebmlsbs

• D}obso kf}o glzbmgo dfkku`lslot



S}b`txf}s Xgb``lì Xb}bclik Teljs

Fgc Xb}bclik @oy Xb}bclik

Ifbg Kblkl~o kfmlgls| %s}bzogtxooc b`c cltsb`do,

Ojjldlo`s bddottlmlgls| %eogx xofxgo}obde cotl}oc to}zldot b`c bdslzlslot l`seo kfts }otfu}do ojjldlo`s yb|,

Kosefct Bssokxst sf tbsltj| cokb`c os}bxfgbsoc j}fk xbts s}o`ct Otsbmglteot ts}bsoild ifbgt b`cfmnodslzot

Xgb``lì Tdfxo

Obde todsf}' kfco b`c nu}ltcldslf` lt xgb`òc l`ltfgbslf`

Xgb``lì lt l`soi}bsoc mosyoo`todsf}t' kfcot b`c nu}ltcldslf`t.

B`bg|tlt Tdfxo

]ocudslf`lts. Obde fmnodslzolt df`tlco}oc l` ltfgbslf`

L`soi}bsoc b`bg|tlt. Df`tlco}tkugslxgo fmnodslzot sf bzflc df`jgldstb`c lco`slj| ‗yl`+yl`‛ tfguslf`t.

Tfguslf`t Df`tlco}oc

Jfdutot f` jbdlgls|df`ts}udslf` b`c cotli`

L`dgucot xfgld| tfguslf`t tude btx}ldlì b`c gb`c uto kb`bioko`s.



Yebs lt ‗Seo‛ S}b`txf}sbslf` X}fmgok6

• L`df`zo`lo`s b`c u`dfkjf}sbmgos}bzog oxo}lo`do6

• S}bjjld dfìotslf`6

• ]fbc df`ts}udslf` dftst6

• Xb}alì dfìotslf` f} dftst6

• Odottlzo dftst sf df`tuko}t6

• S}bjjld d}bteot6

• Gbda fj kfmlgls| jf} `f`+c}lzo}t6

• Xff} j}olies to}zldot6

• O`zl}f`ko sbg lkxbdst6

• L`bcorubso xe|tldbg bdslzls|6

• Fseo}t6



Du}}o`s S}b`txf}s Xgb``lì

Du}}o`s xgb``lì so`ct sf mo }ocudslf`lts> obdex}fmgok lt bttliòc sf b tlìgo bio`d| ylse`b}}fyg| cojlòc }otxf`tlmlglslot. Jf} obkxgo>

• S}b`txf}s bio`dlot cobg ylse dfìotslf`.

• O`zl}f`ko`sbg bio`dlot cobg ylse xfgguslf`.

• Yogjb}o bio`dlot cobg ylse seo òoct fj cltbczb`sbioc

xofxgo.• Xumgld eobgse bio`dlot b}o df`do}òc ylse dfkku`ls|

jlsòtt.

• Osd.



]ocudslf`lts Codltlf`+Kbalì

]ocudslf`lts xgb``lì db`}otugs l` xumgld bio`dlotlkxgoko`slì tfguslf`t sffò x}fmgok sebsobdo}mbso fseo} x}fmgoktjbdlì tfdlos|' b`c so`ct sf

u`co}zbguo ts}bsoilot sebsx}fzlco kugslxgo mus kfcotsmoòjlst.



Yl`+Yl` Tfguslf`t

Xus b`fseo} yb|' kf}odfkx}oeo`tlzoxgb``lì eogxt lco`slj|‗Yl`+Yl`‛ ts}bsoilot>

tfguslf`t sf fòx}fmgok sebs bgtf eogx

tfgzo fseo} x}fmgoktjbdlì tfdlos|.

Bta>

‗Yelde dfìotslf`+}ocudslf`

ts}bsoi| bgtf }ocudot xb}alì dftst' tbzot df`tuko}t kfò|' b`c lkx}fzot kfmlgls| fxslf`t jf} `f`+ c}lzo}t.‛



Dfkxb}lì Moòjlst

Xgb``lìFmnodslzot Oxb`c]fbcyb|t Ojjldlo`s b`c Bgs.Juog Zoeldgot Teljst j}fk BusfBgso}`bslzo Kfcot

Zoeldgo S}bzog Lkxbdst L`d}obtoc ZKS L`d}obtoc ZKS ]ocudoc ZKS

Lkx}fzo s}bzog oxo}lo`do

]ocudo s}bjjld dfìotslf`

]fbc&}blgyb| dfts tbzlìt Xb}alì dfts tbzlìt

Df`tuko} dfts tbzlìt

Lkx}fzo kfmlgls| fxslf`t

Lkx}fzo s}bjjld tbjos|

Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot

Odf`fkld cozogfxko`s 6 6

Xumgld jlsòtt * eobgse



Odf`fkld Ozbgubslf` Tdfxo



S|xo fj Odf`fkld B`bg|tlt

Tutsbl`bmlgls| xgb``lì }orul}otdf`tlco}bslf` fj bgg tli`ljldb`s lkxbdst'l`dguclì sefto sebs b}o cljjldugs sfkobtu}o.

• Rubglsbslzo %cotd}lxslf` fj lkxbdst,

• Cl}odslf` fj lkxbds %iffc f} mbc1tuxxf}st f} df`s}bcldst fmnodslzot,

• ]bslìt %B sf J' 2+4' 2+28' +28 sf !28' osd.,

• Rub`slsbslzo %algfkoso}t xo} efu}' cobsetxo} 288'888 xfxugbslf`' cfggb}t xo} dbxlsb,

• Kfòsl~bslf` %uto kfòsb}| u`lst sfkobtu}o seo zbguo fj lkxbdst,



=2

Dfkxb}lì Dftst

#8.88

#8.8?

#8.28

#8.2?

#8.=8

#8.=?

#8.48

C f

g g b } t X o } Z o e

l d g o

K l g o



Lkxbdst Sf Df`tlco}

Lkxbdst Cojl`lslf` Dfkxfò`st

_to} oxo}lo`do S}bzog df`zo`lo`do b`c dfkjf}sObto fj fmsbl`lì l`jf}kbslf` b`c xb|lì jb}ot. Dfkjf}syelgo s}bzoglì b`c yblslì.

S}bjjld dfìotslf` Dfìotslf` cogb|t b`c dftst.S}bzog txooc' cogb| b`c }oglbmlgls|. Zoeldgo fxo}bslì dftst.Xfgguslf` oklttlf`t.

]fbc b`c }blgyb| dftst ]fbcyb| jbdlgls| dftst Df`ts}udslf`' gb`c' kbl`so`b`do b`c fxo}bslì dftst

Xb}alì dftst Xb}alì jbdlgls| dftst Df`ts}udslf`' gb`c' kbl`so`b`do b`c fxo}bslì dftst

Df`tuko} dftst Jl`b`dlbg dftst fj s}bzog sf uto}t Zoeldgo fyò}telx b`c fxo}bslì oxo`tot' jb}ot

Kfmlgls| fxslf`tS}b`txf}s fxslf`t' otxodlbgg|bjjf}cbmgo kfcot jf} `f`+c}lzo}t

Obto fj ybgalì' d|dglì' xumgld s}b`txf}s' zoeldgo }o`sbgt' sblto}zldot' sogoyf}a' coglzo}| to}zldot' osd.

S}bjjld tbjos| D}bte dftst b`c }ltatX}fxo}s| cbkbiot' kocldbg b`c cltbmlgls| dftst' x}fcudslzls|gfttot' xbl` b`c tujjo}lì' osd.

]otfu}do oso}`bglslotOso}`bg dftst fj }otfu}dodf`tukxslf`' xb}sldugb}g| oò}i|

Jbdlgls| b`c zoeldgo okmfcloc oò}i|' juog df`tukxslf`'x}fcudslf` oso}`bglslot.

Xfgguslf` oklttlf`t S}b`txf}s xfgguslf` oklttlf`t Bl}' `flto b`c ybso} xfgguslf` j}fk jbdlglslot b`c zoeldgot.

Gb`c uto lkxbdstCoi}oo xgb``lì codltlf`t tuxxf}sgb`c uto cozogfxko`s fmnodslzot Lkxo}zlfut tu}jbdo' tx}byg' dfkku`ls| }ocozogfxko`s

Odf`fkld cozogfxko`sCoi}oo xgb``lì codltlf`t tuxxf}sodf`fkld cozogfxko`s fmnodslzot

X}fcudslf` dftst' x}fcudslzls|' lkxf}s odebìo' tuxxf}s jf}ts}bsoild l`cuts}lot

Xumgld jlsòtt b`c eobgse Xe|tldbg jlsòtt b`c eobgse lkxbdst Bkfu`s fj ybgalì b`c d|dglì bdslzls|.



=4

Df`zo`slf`bg Ozbgubslf`

Ioò}bgg| Df`tlco}oc

• Dfìotslf` lkxbdst.

• Zoeldgo fxo}bslì dftst.

• Xo}+klgo d}bte lkxbdst.

• Xo}+klgo xfgguslfòklttlf`t.

Fjso` Fzo}gffaoc

• Xb}alì dftst.

• Sfsbg df`tuko} dftst.

• Cfy`ts}obk dfìotslf`.• D}bte' oò}i| * xfgguslf`

lkxbdst fj debìot l` klgobio.

• Gb`c uto lkxbdst.

• Lkxbdst f` kfmlgls| fxslf`t jf}`f`+c}lzo}t&oruls| lkxbdst.

• Debìot l` bdslzo s}b`txf}sb`c }ogbsoc eobgse lkxbdst.



Df`tlco}bslf` fj Lkxbdst

Lkxbdst Du}}o`s Df`tlco}bslf` Ozbgubslf` Kosefct_to} oxo}lo`do Fjso` cltduttoc mus `fs rub`sljloc L`df}xf}bso l` zbguo fj s}bzog slko

S}bjjld dfìotslf` Zoeldgo cogb| kfòsl~oc Zoeldgo b`c xocots}lb` cogb| kfòsl~oc

]fbc b`c }blg dftst Ioò}bgg| kfòsl~oc Kfòsl~oc utlì gljod|dgo dftst

Xb}alì dftst Ioò}bgg| li`f}oc Kfòsl~oc utlì gljod|dgo dftst

Df`tuko} dftst Zoeldgo fxo}bslì dftst b`c jb}ot Bgg zoeldgo dftst %l`dguclì fyò}telx,

Kfmlgls| fxslf`t Tfkoslkot cotd}lmoc Rub`slj|. Fxslf` zbguo b`c oruls| moòjlst

S}bjjld tbjos| Kfòsl~oc utlì cltsb`do+mbtoc }bsot Kfòsl~oc utlì xo} dbxlsb }bsot

]otfu}do oso}`bglslot @fs ioò}bgg| df`tlco}oc Kfòsl~oc utlì tebcfy x}ldlì

Xfgguslf` oklttlf`t Tfkoslkot kfòsl~oc Dfkx}oeo`tlzo kfòsl~bslf`

Gb`c uto lkxbdst Tfkoslkot cltduttoc mus `fs rub`sljloc L`soi}bsoc kfcoglì

Odf`fkld cozogfxko`s Tfko lkxbdst rub`sljloc Dfkx}oeo`tlzo kfcoglì

Xumgld jlsòtt b`c eobgse Ioò}bgg| li`f}oc Kfcoggoc b`c kfòsltoc



S}bjjld Jbsbgls| ]bsot

8

2

=

4

3

?

:

2<:8 2<:? 2<98 2<9? 2<58 2<5? 2<<8 2<<? =888

Jbsbglslot Xo} 288 Klgglf` Zoeldgo Klgot

Jbsbglslot Xo} 28'888 Xfxugbslf`

Yeo` d}bte }bsot b}okobtu}oc xo}zoeldgo klgo' seo|

codglòc tli`ljldb`sg|'mus yeo` kobtu}ocxo} dbxlsb seo| tefy}ogbslzog| glssgo codglò

cuo sf l`d}obtoc xo}dbxlsb zoeldgoklgobio.



S}bjjld Jbsbglslot

8

?

28

2?

=8

=?

8 =88 388 :88 588 2'888 2'=88

B`ùbg Xo} Dbxlsb S}b`tls Xbttoìo}+Klgot

S } b j j l d J b s b g l s l o t X o } 2 8 8 ' 8

8 8

] o t l c o ` s t

Busfkfmlgo Coxo`co`s

Kugsl+Kfcbg



L`so}`bslf`bg S}bjjld Cobse ]bsot

8

?

28

2?

=8

=?

+?88 ?88 2'?88 ='?88 4'?88 3'?88

B`ùbg Xo} Dbxlsb S}b`tls Xbttoìo}+Klgot

S } b

j j l d J b s b g l s l o t X o } 2 8 8 ' 8

8 8

X f x u g b s l f `

@f}seo}` Ou}fxoTfuseo}` Ou}fxo_TDb`bcbButs}bglb



Tkb}s I}fyse Tbjos| Lkxbdst



Oruls|

B kf}o clzo}to s}b`txf}sbslf`t|tsokt eogxt bdelozo oruls|fmnodslzot>

• B jbl} teb}o fj xumgld }otfu}dot jf}`f`+c}lzo}t.

• Jl`b`dlbg tbzlìt sf gfyo}+l`dfkoxofxgo.

• L`d}obtoc fxxf}su`ls| sf xofxgo yefb}o xe|tldbgg|' tfdlbgg| f} odf`fkldbgg|cltbczb`sbioc.



48

Mbtld Kfmlgls|

Do}sbl` iffct b`c to}zldot b}o

df`tlco}oc ‗otto`slbg‛ f} ‗mbtld‛>

• Oko}io`d| to}zldot %xfgldo' jl}o'

bkmugb`dot' osd.,.• Xumgld to}zldot b`c uslglslot %ib}mbio

dfggodslf`' uslgls| kbl`so`b`do' osd.,.

• Eobgse db}o.

• Mbtld jffc b`c dgfselì.• Ocudbslf` b`c okxgf|ko`s %dfkkuslì,.

• Tfko tfdlbg b`c }od}obslf`bg bdslzlslot.

• Kblg b`c j}olies coglzo}|.



S}b`txf}sbslf` Bjjf}cbmlgls|

8/

?/

28/

2?/

=8/

=?/

8 =88 388 :88 588 2'888 2'=88

Xo}+Dbxlsb B`ùbg S}b`tls Xbttoìo}+Klgot

S } b `

t x } f s X f } s l f ` f j

E f u t o e f g c

O x o ` c l s u } o t

Busfkfmlgo Coxo`co`s

Kusl+Kfcbg



Yebs Iost Xofxgo Kfzlì6

Ybgalì lt b `bsu}bgb`c otto`slbgbdslzls|. Lj |fu bta

toco`sb}| xofxgoyebs xe|tldbgbdslzls| seo| ylggkfts glaog| sf tsldaylse' ybgalì utubgg|}bàt jl}ts.



Odf`fkld Cozogfxko`s Moòjlst

8

?

28

2?

=8

=?

Xos}fgouk Io o}bg

Busfkfmlgo

Oxo`tot

Ioò}bg

Df`tuko}

Oxo`clsu}ot

Xumgld S}b`tls

N f m t D } o b s o c X o } # 2 k l g g l f `

O x o ` c l s u } o

• ]ocudlì s}b`txf}sbslf` dftst%dfìotslf`' xb}alì' x}fxo}s|sbot, l` yb|t sebs l`d}obtox}fcudslzls| b`c dfkxoslslzoòtt.

• Tuxxf}st ts}bsoild l`cuts}lot

%}otfu}do os}bdslf`' bi}ldugsu}o'sfu}ltk' }osblg' osd.,.

• ]ocudlì zoeldgo oxo`clsu}ot b`coxb`clì s}b`tls to}zldo l`d}obtot}oilf`bg okxgf|ko`s b`c mutlòtt

bdslzls|.

• Biigfko}bslf` ojjldlo`dlot.

• L`d}obtot bjjf}cbmlgls|' bggfylìmutlòttot sf bss}bds okxgf|oot l`b}obt ylse elie glzlì dftst.



Zbguo fj Elieyb| Oxb`tlf`

Yeo` seo elieyb|t|tsok ybt molìcozogfxoc l` seo

2<?8t b`c :8t lsx}fzlcoc elie }osu}`tf` l`zotsko`s. @fysebs seo t|tsok lt

kbsu}o' odf`fkld}osu}`t ebzocodglòc.

+=/

4/

5/

24/

25/

=4/

=5/

44/

45/

2<?8+?< 2<:8+:< 2<98+9< 2<58+5<

B ` ` u b g O d f ` f k l d ]

o s u } ` t

Elieyb| Dbxlsbg

X}lzbso Dbxlsbg



Xo} Dbxlsb ICX b`c ZKS

X}fcudslzls| so`ct sfcodglò ylse l`d}obtoczoeldgo s}bzog. %Obde cfslt b _.T. u}mb` }oilf`.,

Mu}obu fj Odf`fkld B`bg|tltb`c JEYB cbsb

]=

; 8.=<=4#8

#28'888

#=8'888

#48'888

#38'888

#?8'888

#:8'888

8 ?'888 28'888 2?'888 =8'888

Xo} Dbxlsb B`ùbg Klgobio %=88?,

X o }

D b x l s b B ` ` u b g

I C X % = 8 8 3 ,



Xo} Dbxlsb ICX b`c Juog X}ldot

X}fcudslzls| so`ctsf l`d}obto ylseelieo} juog x}ldot'xb}sldugb}g| l` flgdf`tuklìdfu`s}lot %obde cfslt b dfu`s}|,.

Juog x}ldo cbsb j}fkKostdelot' =88?



S}bzog Lkxbdst

Lkxbdst b}o bjjodsoc m| efy b x}fnodsbjjodst s}bzog bdslzls|>

• Tfko moòjlst coxo`c f` seo coi}oo sebsbusfkfmlgo s}bzog lt }ocudoc. Jf} obkxgo'

xumgld s}b`tls lkx}fzoko`s moòjlst coxo`c' l`xb}s' f` seo bkfu`s fj busfkfmlgo s}bzog}ocudoc.

• ]fbcyb| oxb`tlf` moòjlst db` mo }ocudocl`cudoc zoeldgo s}bzog' yelde }ocudotdfìotslf` }ocudslf` moòjlst b`c l`d}obtot

oso}`bg dftst l`dguclì bddlco`st' xfgguslf`b`c tx}byg.

• Tfko eobgse moòjlst coxo`c f` seo coi}oosebs ybgalì b`c d|dglì bdslzls| l`d}obtot.



Obkxgo — ]fbcyb| Oxb`tlf`

Xgb``lìFmnodslzot

]fbcyb| Oxb`tlf`

S}bzog Bdslzls| _`debìoc L`cudoc S}bzog



]fbc f} }blgyb| tbzlìt Xb}alì dfts tbzlìt




Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot

Odf`fkld cozogfxko`s


; xftlslzo lkxbds

; òibslzo Lkxbds



4<

Obkxgo + Mut ]bxlc S}b`tls

• I}bco+toxb}bsoc }lies+fj+yb|

• J}oruo`s' elie+dbxbdls|to}zldo %gott seb` 28+klùso

eobcyb|t,.• Elie+rubgls| zoeldgot.

• X}o+xblc jb}o dfggodslf`.

• Df`zo`lo`s uto} l`jf}kbslf`

• Dfkjf}sbmgo tsbslf`t.• Odoggo`s dutsfko} to}zldo.



Obkxgo + M]S

Xgb``lìFmnodslzot

Xumgld S}b`txf}sLkx}fzoko`s

S}bzog Bdslzls| _`debìoc Kfco Teljs



]fbc tbzlìt





Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot



; xftlslzo lkxbds

; òibslzo Lkxbds



@f`+Kfsf}l~oc Lkx}fzoko`s

Fmnodslzo @KSLkx}fzo s}bzog oxo}lo`do




_to} dfts tbzlìt



Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot



• Mulgc b`c lkx}fzo tlcoybgat

• Mulgc xbset b`c mlao gbòt

• Lkx}fzo d}ftttybgat

• Mld|dgo xb}alì

• Xumgld mlao }o`sbg

• Ylco} }fbc tefugco}t

• S}bjjld dbgklì b`c txooc df`s}fg



X}ldlì ]ojf}kt

Fmnodslzo X}ldo ]ojf}ktLkx}fzo s}bzog oxo}lo`do &




_to} dfts tbzlìt

Lkx}fzo kfmlgls| fxslf`t &


Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot



Kf}o ojjldlo`s x}ldlì fj>

• ]fbct• Xb}alì

• Juog

• Zoeldgo l`tu}b`do b`c}oilts}bslf` joot



Tkb}s I}fyse

Fmnodslzo Tkb}s I}fyseLkx}fzo s}bzog oxo}lo`do




_to} dfts tbzlìt



Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot



L`d}obtot bddottlmlgls| b`c }ocudotzoeldgo s}bzog m| tuxxf}slì gb`c utocozogfxko`s sebs lt>

• Dfkxbds

• Kloc+uto}

• Df`òdslzls|

• Kugsl+kfcbg



Obkxgot

Xgb``lì Fmnodslzot Oxb`c]fbc

Lkx}fzoS}b`tls

Lkx}fzo@KS

X}ldlì]ojf}k

Tkb}sI}fyse





_to} dfts tbzlìt &

Lkx}fzo kfmlgls| fxslf`t &


Oò}i| df`to}zbslf`

Xfgguslf` }ocudslf`

Gb`c uto fmnodslzot

Odf`fkld cozogfxko`s 6




Bxxgldbslf`t

_}mb`• L`zotsko`st l` tlcoybgat b`c xbset.

• ]fbc cotli` + ts}oostdbxlì

• Elieyb| zo}tut xumgld s}b`tlsl`zotsko`st.

• S}b`tls t|tsok cotli`.• ]fbc' xb}alì b`c juog x}ldlì.

• Xb}alì kb`bioko`s.

• Tkb}s i}fyse gb`c uto xfgldlot.

]u}bg

• Elieyb| zo}tut }blg l`zotsko`s

• Elieyb| cotli`

• Elieyb| txooc kb`bioko`s

• X}fzltlf` fj tefugco}t b`c xbset jf}

`f`+kfsf}l~oc s}bzog• Mut tsbslf`t l` sfy`t' ylse x}fi}bkt sf

jf}kbgl~o mut to}zldot.

• ]fbc sfggt b`c juog x}ldot.



Yl`+Yl` S}b`txf}sbslf` Tfguslf`t

Kb}aos }ojf}kt nutsljloc fòdf`fkld x}l`dlxgot sebs eogxx}fzlco zb}lfut odf`fkld'tfdlbg b`c o`zl}f`ko`sbgmoòjlst.

• Lkx}fzoc s}bzog fxslf`t.

• L`do`slzot sf uto s}bzog

bgso}`bslzot.• Bddottlmgo gb`c uto.

• Xfgld| b`c kb}aos }ojf}kt.



Tutsbl`bmgo S}b`txf}s Elo}b}de|

2. Ybgalì

=. D|dglì

4. Xumgld S}b`tls

3. To}zldo * J}olies

?. Sbl

:. EFZ

9. X}lzbso Busfkfmlgo





Kugsl+kfcbg ]fbcyb| Cotli`

• Bddott kb`bioko`s

• Df`sos to`tlslzo cotli`

• Ts}oostdbxlì

• Dfkxgoso ts}oost



?8

Xocyb| Bddott sf Kos}f Tsbslf`t

Xocyb|t b}odfzo}oc b`co`dgftoc ybgayb|t

sebs df`òdsefkot' mutlòttotb`c s}b`tls tsbslf`t'bggfylìdfkjf}sbmgo bddott

l` mbc yobseo}.Seoto modfkobss}bdslzo tefxxlìdo`so}t.



Ylco} ]fbcyb| Tefugco}t

BCS 7

=?8

BCS

=?8+388

BCS 388+

CEZ 288

CEZ 288+

=88

CEZ

=88+388

CEZ

0388

]u}bg B}so}lbgt 2.= 2.= 2.5 2.5 =.3 =.3

]u}bg Dfggodsf}t 8.: 8.: 2.= 2.5 =.3 =.3

]u}bg Gfdbg

]fusot

8.: 8.: 2.= 2.5 2.5 =.3

BCS ; Bzo}bio Cblg| S}bjjld CEZ ; Cotli` Efu} ZfgukoYlcset l` Koso}t> 8.:k ; = js1 2.=k ; 3 js.1 2.5k ; : js1 =.3k ; 5 js.



‗]blto K| X}ldot' Xgobto"‛

Fj dfu}to' kfsf}ltst cf `fsglao sf xb| kf}o jf} }fbctb`c xb}alì' mus u`x}ldoc

jbdlglslot b}o `fs }obgg| j}oo'df`tuko}t ugslkbsog| xb|se}fuie elieo} sbot b`c}osblg x}ldot. Seo defldo ltbdsubgg| mosyoo` xb|lìcl}odsg| f} l`cl}odsg|.



Kf}o Ojjldlo`s X}ldlì

]bà Dbsoif}| Obkxgot Mots Slko+ b`c gfdbslf`+

txodljld }fbc b`cxb}alì x}ldlì

Zb}lbmgo }fbc x}ldlì' gfdbslf`+txodljld xb}alìkb`bioko`s' gfdbslf`+txodljld oklttlf`deb}iot.

Todf`cMots

Klgobio+x}ldlì Yolies+cltsb`do deb}iot' klgobio+mbtoczoeldgo l`tu}b`do' x}f}bsoc KZOS' klgobiombtoc oklttlf` deb}iot.

Sel}c Mots Juog deb}iot L`d}obto juog sb' bxxg| ioò}bg tbgot sb sfjuog' xb|+bs+seo+xukx l`tu}b`do' db}mf` sb'l`d}obto Eb~b}cfut Tum. Sb.

Mbc Jloc zoeldgo deb}iot Du}}o`s KZOS' zoeldgo xu}debto b`c fyò}telxjoot.

Yf}ts Oso}`bg dftst%`fs deb}ioc sf

kfsf}ltst,

Ioò}bg sbot xb|lì jf} }fbct b`c s}bjjldto}zldot' xb}alì tumtlclot' u`dfkxo`tbsocoso}`bg dftst.



Juog Sbot

#8.88

#8.=8

#8.38

#8.:8

#8.58

#2.88

#2.=8

#2.38

#2.:8

#2.58

8 ?'888 28'888 2?'888 =8'888 =?'888

Bzo}bio B`ùbg Zoeldgo Algfkoso}t

I b t f g l ` o X } l d o % _ T # & G l s o } ,

Db`bcb

Co`kb}a

J}b`do

Io}kb`|

Lsbg|Nbxb`

@oseo}gb`ct

@f}yb|

Txbl`

Tyoco`

Tyls~o}gb`c

_ lsoc Al icfk

_`lsoc Tsbsot

_`lsoc

Tsbsot

Db`bcb



??

Ojjldlo`s Xb}alì X}ldlì

• X}ldo xb}alì l` kf}ob}obt.

• L`d}obto joot sf }ojgods

dfkko}dlbg }bsot.• Elieo} joot bs slkot b`c

gfdbslf`t yeo}o xb}alìcokb`c lt i}obsots.

• Cozogfx kf}o df`zo`lo`sxb|ko`s b`co`jf}doko`s t|tsokt.



Cltsb`do+Mbtoc X}ldlì

Kfsf}ltst xb| m| seo zoeldgo+algfkos}o' tf b #:88 b`ùbgx}okluk modfkot 4¢&ak b`c b

#='888 b`ùbg x}okluk modfkot28¢&ak. Selt ilzot kfsf}ltst btli`ljldb`s jl`b`dlbg l`do`slzo sfc}lzo gott' mus lt `fs b òy joo bs

bgg' tlkxg| b cljjo}o`s yb| sf xb|oltslì joot.



Xo}jf}kb`do L`cldbsf}t

Xo}jf}kb`dol`cldbsf}t b}o glao seo

tdf}o l` b ibko.Seo| cojlò yebskuts mobddfkxglteoc sf

tuddooc.



?5

Df`zo`slf`bg S}b`txf}s L`cldbsf}t

• ]fbcyb| Gozog+fj+To}zldo %GFT,

• Bzo}bio s}bjjld txooct.

• Xo} dbxlsb dfìotslf` cogb|.

• Xb}alì fdduxb`d| }bsot.

• S}bjjld jbsbglslot xo} mlgglf`

zoeldgo+klgot.



Kugsl+Kfcbg Gozog+Fj+To}zldo %GFT,

Kfco Gozog fj To}zldo Jbdsf}t Ybgalì Tlcoybga&xbse rubgls|' ts}oos d}fttlì df`clslf`t' gb`c uto

df`clslf`t' todu}ls|' x}otslio.

D|dglì Xbse rubgls|' ts}oos }lclì df`clslf`t' xb}alì df`clslf`t' todu}ls|.

]lcoteb}lì ]lcokbsdelì to}zldot' deb`dot fj jl`clì kbsdeot' EFZ x}lf}ls|.

Xumgld s}b`tls To}zldo dfzo}bio' j}oruo`d|' txooc %}ogbslzo sf c}lzlì,' zoeldgo b`cyblslì b}ob dfkjf}s' uto} l`jf}kbslf`' x}ldo' todu}ls|' x}otslio.

Busfkfmlgo Txooc' dfìotslf` cogb|' }fbcyb| df`clslf`t' xb}alì df`zo`lo`do'tbjos|.

Sogoyf}a Okxgf|o} bddoxsb`do&tuxxf}s fj sogodfkkuslì' L`so}òs bddott.

Coglzo}| to}zldot Dfzo}bio' txooc' df`zo`lo`do' bjjf}cbmlgls|.



:8

Kugsl+Kfcbg GFT %Nbdatf`zlggo,

D|dglì GFT Xocots}lb` GFT



Cojl`lì Cbsb Rubgls|

• Bddu}bd|. Seo kosefct utoc sf dfggods tsbsltsldtkuts mo tulsbmg| bddu}bso.

• S}b`txb}o`d|. Seo kosefct utoc sf dfggodstsbsltsldt kuts mo bddottlmgo jf} }ozloy.

• Dfkx}oeo`tlzoòtt. B` bcorubso }bìo fjtsbsltsldt tefugc mo dfggodsoc sf bggfy zb}lfuts|xot fj b`bg|tlt.

• J}oruo`d|. Cbsb tefugc mo dfggodsoc }oiugb}g|.

• Df`tltso`d|. Seo }bìo fj tsbsltsldt' cojl`lslf`t

b`c dfggodslf` kosefcfgfilot tefugc modf`tltso`s.

• Bzblgbmlgls|. Tsbsltsldt tefugc mo bzblgbmgo sfuto}t.



Cozogfxko`s b`c X}fjottlf`bg F}ib`l~bslf`t

Tutsbl`bmgo s}b`txf}s ifbgt b}o o`cf}tocm| kbnf} cozogfxko`s b`c x}fjottlf`bgf}ib`l~bslf`t>

• BCM b`c Yf}gc Mbà

• FODC

• _`lsoc @bslf`t

• L`tslsuso fj S}b`txf}sbslf` Oìlòo}t.

• Bko}ldb` Xgb``lì Bttfdlbslf`.

• Joco}bg' tsbso' }oilf`bg b`c gfdbgxgb``lì b`c s}b`txf}sbslf` bio`dlot.

• Eobgse f}ib`l~bslf`t.

• B`c kude kf}o...



Df`dgutlf`t

• Tutsbl`bmgo cozogfxko`s mbgb`dot odf`fkld'tfdlbg b`c o`zl}f`ko`sbg fmnodslzot.

• Tutsbl`bmgo s}b`txf}s xgb``lì }orul}otdfkx}oeo`tlzo ozbgubslf` fj lkxbdst' l`dguclìsefto sebs b}o l`cl}ods b`c gfì+so}k.

• Du}}o`s s}b`txf}s xgb``lì so`ct sf fzo}gffa tfkolkxbdst.

• Seo lkxbdst sebs b}o fzo}gffaoc so`c sfu`co}zbguo ybgalì' d|dglì b`c xumgld s}b`txf}slkx}fzoko`st' b`c kfmlgls| kb`bioko`s

ts}bsoilot tude bt x}ldlì }ojf}kt.

• B òy BCM x}fi}bk lt cozogfxlì iulcoglòt b`csffgt jf} kf}o dfkx}oeo`tlzo lkxbds b`bg|tlt.

• Yo yb`s joocmbda j}fk x}bdslslfò}t df`do}`lìselt x}fnods.



‗Dfkx}oeo`tlzo S}b`txf}sbslf` Ozbgubslf` J}bkoyf}a‛

‗L`s}fcudslf` sf Kugsl+Kfcbg S}b`txf}sbslf` Xgb``lì‛

‗Tkb}s S}b`txf}sbslf` Odf`fkld Tslkugbslf`‛

‗S}b`txf}sbslf` Dfts b`c Moòjls B`bg|tlt‛

‗Tutsbl`bmgo b`c Glzbmgo S}b`txf}sbslf`‛

‗Tkb}s S}b`txf}s Oklttlf` ]ocudslf`‛

‗F`glò SCK O`d|dgfxoclb‛

b`c kf}o...

yyy.zsxl.f}i

Date post:	09-Apr-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	asian-development-bank
View:	219 times
Download:	0 times

Comprehensive Evaluation for Sustainable Transport Planning

Documents