Conflict at Pierce CollegeLelia Brinegar, Carrie Connolly, Anjour Harris, Rob Tench, and Jay White
Where do you think Kate made her biggest mistake? A. Not sitting down with Steve and
Virginia upon being hired to learn the organizational culture.
B. Drawing conclusions from Renee’s input.
C. Consulting personnel before speaking with her direct supervisor.
Why do you think Frank changed his view on the situation?A. Frank is concerned about his
relationship with the president due to his involvement in the matter.
B. Concern that Personnel may dig deeper into the situation and audit the department.
C. Attempting to avoid further confrontation with Steve.
Kidder’s Ethical Checkpoints
Recognize that there is a problem
Who is responsible for addressing the problem?A. KateB. ChrisC. FrankD. Personnel
Gather the relevant facts
Test for Right vs. Wrong The stench test The front page test The mom test
Test for Right vs. RightFrank vs. Kate
Apply the ethical standards and perspectives Kant’s Categorical Imperative
Do what is right no matter what the cost
Look for a third way
What would you do? A. Kate takes no action at all. B. Kate talks to Steve and Virginia
about her concerns. C. Kate waits to talk to Chris before
making a decision to act. D. Kate goes to Personnel with her
discovery (as seen in skit) E. Other
Reflection Video