Consensus Report on Modernizing Onondaga County Government

8/20/2019 Consensus Report on Modernizing Onondaga County Government

1/83

i

"#$%&'( )*#&+$ ,-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'(

55563&'(*'(7(3'163&/


2/83

ii

809.* &: 2&'$*'$(

! #$%% &' !(&)'*+ ,- #$* .' /-&&-0 ;

10'(-22 /$(340'5*6 ?$+**$ 0'4 @%AB501 C0%'$*'0'3* >D0$*+ E':+0($+73$7+* ;FD0($*50$*+ E':+0($+73$7+* ;G?&.%4 D0($* 2&..*3$%&' ;>?7//0+1 &: H.$*+'0$%I*( ;J-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'( FF

15@%)( A$?-&B F=K%+* -+&$*3$%&' F=

?7//0+1 &: H.$*+'0$%I*( FJ-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'( GL

M/*+A*'31 C*4%30. ?*+I%3*( NMC?O GF-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'( G<

P05 M':&+3*/*'$ G=-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'( <D* 20' T& U*$$*+ ><8B* K%(30. )*0.%$1 K03%'A P&30. V&I*+'/*'$ >=W'*I*' )*A%&'0. V+&5$B >RC%''*(&$0X( ?B0+*4 V+&5$B -+&A+0/ >RP0'4 W(* -.0''%'A >Y-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'( RL


3/83

iii

G'F-0*$*(- R;P01%'A $B* V+&7'45&+S :&+ ?1($*/( 2B0'A* R;DB1 T& -.03*( MQ#.&+* $B* E4*0 &: Z8B%'S%'A U%AA*+[\ RF

H ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 ?$&+1^ _&$ `7($ 0 2%$1 ?$&+1 RG H -&.%31 C&$%I0$%&' $& Z8B%'S%'A U%AA*+[ RG H K%(30. C&$%I0$%&' $& Z8B%'S%'A U%AA*+[ R<-+*.%/%'0+1 2&//%$$** )*3&//*'40$%&'( R<

#'*(%52)'* RR

78- #';;)22)'* RY


4/83

1

H 20.. $& H3$%&'a D* 20' T& U*$$*+

A)*(- H$*5$0B IJKLM &8- #';;)22)'*'* N'($% G'F-0*;-*& C'6-0*)O$&)'*8$2 @--* P'03)*4 &' 28$:- $ F)2)'*?'0 ;'0- -??-(&)F- $*6 -??)()-*&4'F-0*$*(- $(0'22 &8- AB0$(52-QD*'*6$4$ (';;5*)&BR

8B%( (7//0+1 +*#&+$ &' $B* %((7*( 0'4#&+$7'%$%*( 5* B0I* %4*'$%:%*4 %( $B*'*Q$ ($*# %' 4*I*.%'A $B0$ I%(%&'6

78)2 )2 *'& '50 ?)*$% 2-& '?0-(';;-*6$&)'*2M @5& 0$&8-0 $

?'5*6$&)'* ?'0 (';;5*)&B 6)$%'45-R >*:0-2-*&)*4 &8- ':&)'*2 $*6:0-%);)*$0B 0-(';;-*6$&)'*2 (0$?&-6@B &8- #';;)22)'*S2 (';;)&&--2M P-8':- &' ($&$%BO- $* )*(%52)F- 0-4)'*$%('*F-02$&)'* '* P8$& P- T $2 &8-0-2)6-*&2 P8' ($%% &8- AB0$(52-QD*'*6$4$ (';;5*)&B 8';- T P$*&'50 %'($% 4'F-0*;-*& 2&05(&50-2 &'%''3 %)3- 'F-0 &8- *-=& 4-*-0$&)'*R

8B* +*#&+$ %( $B* #+&473$ &: $B&7(0'4( &:3&..*3$%I* B&7+( %'I*($*4 91 /*/9*+( &:$B* 2&//%((%&'^ +*(%4*'$( 0'4($0S*B&.4*+(^ 0.. /04* :&+ &'* +*0(&'a H(B0+*4 4*(%+* $& %/#+&I* &7+ 3&//7'%$16

!2 P- ('*&)*5- '50 P'03M P- ;52&0-('4*)O- &8$& &8- F)2)'* P- $0-(0-$&)*4 )2 $@'5& &8- :0-2-*&M @5&;'0- 2:-()?)($%%B $@'5& &8- ?5&50-R !?5&50- )* P8)(8 &8- AB0$(52-Q

D*'*6$4$ (';;5*)&B )2 2&0'*4-0M

;

B$$#abb55569+&&S%'A(6*47b+*(*0+3Bb+*#&+$(FbFL;=bL;bFF]A.&90.]/*$+&]/&'%$&+ F B$$#abb0##(6$3:6&+Ab0+3B%$*3$7+*]&:](*A+*A0$%&'

G

B$$#abb5556&'A&I6'*$b09&7$b#.0$%&'8+*'4(6B$/.

;'0- (';:-&)&)F- $*6 $* -F-* @-&&-0:%$(- &' %)F-M P'03 $*6 :%$BR

8B&7AB &7+ 5&+S 3&'$%'7*(^ 5* S'&5$B%(a K&..&5%'A ;J /&'$B( &: +*I%*5^4%(37((%&'^ 0'0.1(%( 0'4 3&':*++0. 5%$B.*04*+( %' &$B*+ +*A%&'( 03+&(( $B*3&7'$+1^ $B* 2&//%((%&' B0( 3&'3.74*4^(%/#.1^ $B0$ 5* c $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 c 30' 4& 9*$$*+6

/-&&-0 &8$* IUL&8 )* -('*';)(:-0?'0;$*(-RK /-&&-0 &8$* 8)48-2& )*

-=&0-;- :'F-0&B ('*(-*&0$&)'*RI

/-&&-0 &8$* KU '? VW ;5*)():$%)&)-2%'2)*4 :':5%$&)'* )* &8- %$2& #-*252RV /-&&-0 &8$* $* $F-0$4- P$4- &8$& )2IJX %'P-0 &8$* &8- *$&)'*S2RL /-&&-0&8$* $ UX 6-(%)*- )* Y'@2 2)*(- KUUJRW

"7+ +*A%&'X( $+7$B c $B0$ $&& /0'1*3&'&/%3 #&+$7'%$%*( B0I* A&'**.(*5B*+*^ $&& /0'1 +*(%4*'$( B0I* .*:$^0'4 $&& :*5 &: &7+ 3B%.4+*' 0'4

A+0'43B%.4+*' 0+* %' 0 #&(%$%&' $& +*/0%'B*+* c %( 7'3&/:&+$09.*^ 97$ %$ 4&*('X$/0S* %$ 0'1 .*(( $+7$B:7.6

,- ($* 6' @-&&-0R

H'4 5* 30' ($0+$ 91 3+*0$%'A 0 .&30.A&I*+'/*'$ ($+73$7+* %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 5&+$B1 &: &7+#*.*6 H A.&90..1]3&/#*$%$%I* :7$7+*4*#*'4( 7#&' $B* /&4*+'%d0$%&' &: *03B0'4 *I*+1 &'* &: &7+ A&I*+'/*'$0.

<

B$$#abb3*'$*+($0$*#&+$7'%$163&/b:%.*(bYF;GbJGJGbGGYGb2*'$*+?$0$*eHM"e?7//0+16#4: = B$$#abb55569.(6A&Ib.07b


5/83

2

($+73$7+*(6 DB%.* *I*+1 .*I*. &:A&I*+'/*'$ c &7+ 2&7'$1^ 2%$1^ 8&5'(0'4 f%..0A*( c B0( :&7'4 501( $&%''&I0$* 0'4 %/#+&I* 9&$B (*+I%3*4*.%I*+1 0'4 3&($]*::%3%*'31 &I*+ $B*1*0+(^ %$ %( 0.(& $+7* $B0$ *I*+1 .*I*. &:A&I*+'/*'$ B0( /&+* 5&+S $& 4& $&$+0'(3*'4 5B0$ 0+* %' (&/* %'($0'3*(3*'$7+%*(]&.4 $+04%$%&'(^ #+03$%3*( 0'4501( &: 4&%'A 97(%'*((6

,- 3*'P &8-2- (8$*4-2 ($**'&8$::-* 'F-0*)48&R *6)$*$:'%)2 :0'F- &8-2- (8$*4-2 ($*M)* ?$(&M -*8$*(- &8- F')(- $*6%-$6-028): :'2)&)'* '? &0$6)&)'*$%%B

5*6-00-:0-2-*&-6 (';;5*)&)-2R ,-($* T $*6 ;52& T 6' )&M &''R

8B*+* 0+* /0'1 +*0(&'( $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 B0( ($+7AA.*4 $&3&/#*$* :&+ $B* #0($ $5& A*'*+0$%&'(^0'4 %$ 5&7.4 9* 5+&'A $& 9.0/* 0 .&30.A&I*+'/*'$ (1($*/ $B0$ B0( #*+(*I*+*4

4*(#%$* %'3+*4%9.1 3B0..*'A%'A :%'0'3%0.3%+37/($0'3*(6

>& P'5%6 @- -Z5$%%B P0'*4 &' ('*(%56-&8-2- (8$%%-*4-2 $0- -=(%52)F- &' '50

(-*&0$% ()&BR ,- ?--% &8-; )* ;$*B('0*-02 '? '50 (';;5*)&BR !*6 $0-4)'* :-0?'0;)*4 P-%% )* :'(3-&2 )2*'& $ 0-4)'* :-0?'0;)*4 P-%% 'F-0$%%R

U74A*$ 4*:%3%$( 0+*'X$ *Q3.7(%I* $& $B*2%$1a ;= &: &7+ ;Y $&5'( :03* #+&g*3$*44*:%3%$( 90(*4 &' 37++*'$ (#*'4%'A b+*I*'7* $+*'4(6

1':5%$&)'* %'22 )2*S& -=(%52)F- &' &8-

#)&B+ ] '? '50 KU &'P*2M $*6 KK '? '50KW F)%%$4-2 $(&5$%%B %'2& :':5%$&)'*@-&P--* IJJJ $*6 IJKJR

`&9 .&((*( 0+*'X$ *Q3.7(%I* $& $B* 2%$1a8B* */#.&1/*'$ 90(* %' &7+ $&5'( %(4&5' G6Fh %' $B* #0($ F= 1*0+(6

AB2&-;)( (8$%%-*4-2 ($%% ?'0 2B2&-;)(2'%5&)'*2M $*6 ;'6-0*)O)*4 8'P P-[6'\ %'($% 4'F-0*;-*& P)%% &$3-

2B2&-;)( (8$*4- '* &8- :$0& '? $%% '?52 $*6 $%% '50 4'F-0*;-*&2+ #'5*&BM#)&BM 7'P*2 $*6 ^)%%$4-2R

D* 0.(& '**4 $B* 3&//%$/*'$ &: ($0$*A&I*+'/*'$ $& 9*%'A 0 5%..%'A #0+$'*+ %'&7+ /&4*+'%d0$%&'6 _&$ &'.1 %' +*.%*I%'A&7+ .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( &: 3&($.1/0'40$*(^ 97$ 03$%I*.1 */#&5*+%'A &7+*::&+$( $& B*.# &7+(*.I*( 0'4 (7##&+$%'A*::&+$( $& 30+I* &7$ 0 /&+* #&(%$%I*4%+*3$%&' :&+ &7+ 3&//7'%$16

#8$*4- )2 8$06M @5& (8$*4- P- ;52&R78- :0-%);)*$0B 0-(';;-*6$&)'*2 )*&8)2 0-:'0& 0-Z5)0- (8$*4- ?0'; -$(8$*6 -F-0B 5*)& '? %'($% 4'F-0*;-*&RA';- (8$*4-2 $0- @'%6 $*6 60$;$&)($*6 %)3-%B &' 4-*-0$&- 2)4*)?)($*&6-@$&-R D&8-02 $0- ;'0- 25@&%-M @5&


6/83

3

-Z5$%%B *-(-22$0BR A';- (8$*4-2 ($*$*6 28'5%6 @- ;$6- Z5)(3%BR D&8-02;$B &$3- B-$02 &' ?5%%B );:%-;-*&R

U7$ $5& $B%'A( 0+* 3&'($0'$ %' *03B 0'4

*I*+1 30(*6 K%+($^ $B*(* 3B0'A*( +*i7%+*&7+ 5*..]%'$*'$%&'*4 #79.%3 (*+I0'$( $&$0S* $B* +%(S 0((&3%0$*4 5%$B 9&.4.*04*+(B%#6 ?*3&'4^ $B*1 +*i7%+* 0.. &: 7($& *'I%(%&' 0 9*$$*+ 0'4 /&+* #+&(#*+&7(:7$7+* $B0$ 5%.. &'.1 9* 03B%*I*4 $B+&7AB0 (B0+*4 3&//%$/*'$ $& 3&'$%'7&7(%/#+&I*/*'$6

D50 8)2&'0B &-%%2 52 P- ($* (';-&'4-&8-0 $2 $ (';;5*)&B &' :0'65(-

:'2)&)F- (8$*4-R ,- 8$F- 25((-222&'0)-2 )* '50 :$2&M 8$F)*4 $%0-$6B0-4)'*$%%B 0-'04$*)O-6 $*6;'6-0*)O-6 2-0F)(-2 25(8 $2 UKK(';;5*)($&)'*2M :5@%)( 8-$%&8M 2'%)6P$2&- 6)2:'2$% $*6 %)@0$0)-2R 78$&('':-0$&)F- 2:)0)& ?5-%2 &8)2 -??'0&R

8B*(* 3B0'A*( 0.&'* 0+* B0+4.1 0 Z(%.I*+97..*$^[ 97$ $B*1 30' 9* #0+$ &: 0 ($+&'A*+^/&+* I%9+0'$ 0'4 /&+* 3&/#*$%$%I*

:&7'40$%&' :&+ &7+ +*A%&' 0'4 %$( :7$7+*62&//7'%$%*( $B0$ B0I* A&'* 9*:&+* 7( %'/&4*+'%d%'A $B*%+ ($+73$7+*( B0I* (*'$%/#&+$0'$ (%A'0.( 09&7$ $B*%+ 5%..%'A'*(($& %/#+&I*^ 3&/#*$* 0'4 A+&56 8B%(*::&+$ &::*+( 0 A+*0$*+ #&$*'$%0. :&+*3&'&/%3 A+&5$B6

!*6 ?'0 &8- 2$3- '? '50 (8)%60-* $*640$*6(8)%60-*M $*6 &8'2- &8$& P)%% ($%%&8- AB0$(52-QD*'*6$4$ (';;5*)&B[8';-\ )* &8- 4-*-0$&)'*2 &' (';-M&8-B $0- '::'0&5*)&)-2 P- 2);:%B($**'& )4*'0-R

8B%( +*#&+$^ 5B%3B (*$( &7$ $B*2&//%((%&'X( #+*.%/%'0+1 3&//%$$**+*3&//*'40$%&'(^ %( %'$*'4*4 $& .07'3B0 +&97($ #79.%3 *'A0A*/*'$ #+&3*((68B0$ 3&'I*+(0$%&' 0( %/#&+$0'$ 0( 0'1$B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 B0(B046


7/83

4

-+&3*(( U03SA+&7'4

#'*2-*252 T &8- #';;)22)'* '* N'($% G'F-0*;-*& C'6-0*)O$&)'* T P$2 %$5*(8-6)* IJKL $2 $ :$0&*-028): '? A`9!#aAE IJbIJM #-*&-0A&$&- #EDM &8- #'5*&B '?D*'*6$4$M &8- #)&B '? AB0$(52-M cD#aA G0-$&-0 AB0$(52-M &8- N-$45- '? ,';-*^'&-02 '? &8- AB0$(52- C-&0':'%)&$* !0-$M &8- D*'*6$4$ #)&)O-*2 N-$45- $*6 &8-d';-@5)%6-02 e 9-;'6-%-02 !22'()$&)'* '? #


8/83

5

E('*';)( .-F-%':;-*&M :&37(%'A &' :%(30. 0'4 *3&'&/%3 +*.0$%&'(B%#( 0/&'A$B* 2&7'$1X( A&I*+'/*'$(^ 0( 5*.. 0( $B* .0'4 7(* 0'4 #&.%31 %/#03$( &: .&30.A&I*+'/*'$ 03$%&'(l 0'4

G'F-0*$*(-M :&37(%'A &' $B* &I*+0+3B%'A ($+73$7+*( &: .&30. 0'4 +*A%&'0.

A&I*+'0'3* 0'4 $B* *Q$*'$ $& 5B%3B $B* 2&7'$1X( S*1 #&.%31 %((7*( 0+* 04*i70$*.10.%A'*4 5%$B %$( #&.%31 /0S%'A 30#03%$16

M03B 3&//%$$** 50( 3B0%+*4 91 0 I&$%'A /*/9*+ &: $B* 2&//%((%&'6 2&//%$$**( 0.(&(&7AB$ &7$ $*3B'%30. 0'4 (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 *Q#*+$( $& :7+$B*+ %':&+/ $B*%+ +*I%*5(6 E' (&/*30(*(^ 3&//%$$**( B04 &7$(%4* *Q#*+$( (*+I* 0( +*A7.0+ /*/9*+( &: $B* 3&//%$$**l %'&$B*+(^ &7$(%4* *Q#*+$( (*+I*4 0( %'I%$*4 #+*(*'$*+(^ :03%.%$0$%'A /&+* 4*$0%.*4 4%(37((%&'(&: (#*3%:%3 /7'%3%#0. (*+I%3*( 0'4 $B* 3B0..*'A*( 0'4 #&+$7'%$%*( +*.0$%'A $B*+*$&6

H (%Q$B 3&//%$$**^ 15@%)( E*4$4-;-*&M 50( *($09.%(B*4 0$ $B* 9*A%''%'A &: $B* #+&3*(($& *'(7+* 0 3&'(%($*'$ 0'4 +&97($ 3&//7'%$1 3&'I*+(0$%&' $0S*( #.03* +*A0+4%'A $B*

2&//%((%&'X( 5&+S^ 9&$B 47+%'A $B* #+&3*(( 0'4 :&..&5%'A +*.*0(* &: $B* :%'0.+*3&//*'40$%&'(6

8B%( )*#&+$ 0'4 DB0$ 2&/*( _*Q$

78)2 )2 *'& &8- #';;)22)'*S2 ?)*$% 0-:'0&R >& )2 )*&-*6-6 $2 $ *-P &''% ?'0 -*4$4)*4&8- :5@%)( )* &8)2 F)&$%%B );:'0&$*& ('*F-02$&)'* $@'5& &8- ?5&50- '? '50 (';;5*)&BR!2 $ %$5*(8)*4 :$6 ?'0 &8$& ('*F-02$&)'*M )& '??-02 0-$6-02 &8- ?'%%'P)*4+

DF-0F)-P2 &: %':&+/0$%&' $B* 2&//%((%&' B0( +*I%*5*4 (%'3* $B* +*.*0(* &: $B*90(*.%'* +*#&+$^ 5%$B %$( 3&//%$$**( B0I%'A 3&/#.*$*4 /&+* 4*$0%.*4 *Q0/%'0$%&'(&: '*0+.1 *I*+1 .&30. A&I*+'/*'$ (*+I%3* #+&I%4*4 %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$1l

d)48%)48&2 &: S*1 %((7*( %4*'$%:%*4 91 *03B 3&//%$$** +*A0+4%'A $B* 37++*'$(*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 0'4 A&I*+'%'A :+0/*5&+S( (*+I%'A $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A02&//7'%$1l

D:&)'*2 $B* 3&//%$$**( B0I* +*I%*5*4 $& %/#+&I* (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 0'4 A&I*+'%'A:+0/*5&+S( 5%$B%' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1l 0'4

10-%);)*$0B 0-(';;-*6$&)'*2 +*03B*4 91 3&//%$$**( &' #&+$7'%$%*( $&/&4*+'%d* 0'4 %/#+&I* $B* *::*3$%I*'*((^ +*(#&'(%I*'*(( 0'4 *::%3%*'31 &: (*+I%3*4*.%I*+1 0'4 A&I*+'%'A :+0/*5&+S( 5%$B%' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^0.&'A 5%$B $B* +0$%&'0.* :&+ $B&(* #+*.%/%'0+1 +*3&//*'40$%&'(6

)*04*+( (B&7.4 '&$* 0 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ #&%'$ 09&7$ $B*(* -+*.%/%'0+1+*3&//*'40$%&'(6 8B*1 0+*^ %' 0 I*+1 +*0. 501^ #+*.%/%'0+16 8B*1 +*#+*(*'$ $B* 5&+S


9/83

6

E':+0($+73$7+*

8B* E':+0($+73$7+* 2&//%$$** :&37(*4 &' :&7+ 3+%$%30. (*+I%3* 0+*0(a

?$+**$ 0'4 @%AB501 C0%'$*'0'3*lD0$*+lD0($*50$*+l 0'4?&.%4 D0($* 2&..*3$%&'6

?8)MM8 H_T @EV@DHj C HE_8M_H_2M

?$+**$ 0'4 B%AB501 /0%'$*'0'3* %( 0/&'A $B* /&($ I%(%9.* (*+I%3*( 0'1 .&30.A&I*+'/*'$ #+&I%4*(^ *(#*3%0..1 (& %' 0 3&//7'%$1 $B0$ +*3*%I*( 0I*+0A* 0''70. ('&5:0..

&: ;F :**$6 K+&/ #.&5%'A 0'4 (0.$%'A +&04( (*0(&'0..1^ $& +*#0%+%'A 4+%I09.* %':+0($+73$7+*1*0+]+&7'4 $& *'(7+* 033*(( 0'4 (0:*$1^ B%AB]i70.%$1 #79.%3 5&+S( (*+I%3*( 0+* *((*'$%0.$& $B* i70.%$1 &: .%:*^ (7($0%'09%.%$1 0'4 A+&5$B &: $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

8B*+* 0+* G> (*#0+0$* (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^%'3.74%'A $B* 2&7'$1^ 2%$1^ ;Y $&5'( 0'4 ;= I%..0A*(6

8B*+* %( I0($ 4%(#0+%$1 %' $B* (30.* &: $B*(* #+&I%4*+(6 P0'4 0+*0 +*(#&'(%9%.%$%*(+0'A* :+&/ m /%F $& RJL /%Fl #.0$%&'( (*+I*4 +0'A* :+&/ :*5*+ $B0'


10/83

7

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

;6 8B* G> (*#0+0$* (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+( B0I* %'4*#*'4*'$ 5&+S:&+3*(^ :.**$(^ ($0::*Q#*+$( 0'4 #.0''%'A #+&3*((*(^ 5B%3B +*(7.$( %' (&/* 47#.%30$%&' &: ($0:: 0'430#%$0. *i7%#/*'$6

F6 ?*+I%3* Z4*04B*04%'A[ &337+( 0$ /7'%3%#0. 9&+4*+( N*6A6 ('&5 #.&5 9.04*( 9*%'A.%:$*4 7# 0$ $B* /7'%3%#0. .%'*O^ 5%$B .*A0. 9&7'40+%*( 4%3$0$%'A (*+I%3* 0+*0( b+&7$*( /&+* $B0' 3&'(%4*+0$%&'( &: *::%3%*'31 0'4 +*(#&'(%I*'*((6

G6 H.$B&7AB 0 /0$*+%0. 0/&7'$ &: 3&*+0$%&' &337+( 9*$5**' #79.%3 0A*'3%*(^ /73B&: %$ %( %':&+/0. /*0'%'A $B0$ %$ 30' 9* (79g*3$ $& %'$*+#*+(&'0. 41'0/%3( +0$B*+$B0' 5B0$ /0S*( $B* /&($ (*'(* %' $*+/( &: (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+16

6 2&..*3$%I*.1^ .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 *+0$* GY#79.%3 5&+S( :03%.%$%*(6


11/83

8


12/83

9


13/83

10


14/83

11


15/83

12

D H8M) E_K)H?8)W28W)M

D0$*+ %( 0 /0g&+ *3&'&/%3 +*(&7+3* :&+ $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 E$(%/#&+$0'3* $& &7+ 3&//7'%$1X( I%$0.%$1 %( B*%AB$*'*4 91 50$*+ 033*(( 3B0..*'A*( $B0$ 0+*

%'3+*0(%'A.1 %/#03$%'A &$B*+ #0+$( &: $B* 3&7'$+16 M'(7+%'A 033*(( $& 3.*0'^ 3&($]*::*3$%I*50$*+ %( 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ $& &7+ :7$7+* *3&'&/1 0'4 i70.%$1 &: .%:*6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

8B*+* 0+* $B+** /0%' *'$%$%*( N$5& /0g&+ +*$0%. #+&I%4*+(O 5%$B #+%/0+1 +*(#&'(%9%.%$1:&+ #+&I%4%'A 50$*+ (*+I%3*( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 c 8B*C*$+&.%$0' D0$*+ U&0+4 N0'4 $B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 D0$*+ T%($+%3$O^ $B*"'&'40A0 2&7'$1 D0$*+ H7$B&+%$1 0'4 $B* 2%$1 &: ?1+037(* D0$*+ T*#0+$/*'$62&..*3$%I*.1^ $B*1 (7##.1 0##+&Q%/0$*.1 YLh &: +*(%4*'$( %' "'&'40A0 2&7'$16 8B*C*$+&.%$0' D0$*+ U&0+4 (7##.%*( FbG &: $B* 50$*+ I&.7/* 0'4 B0( GF /0g&+%'47($+%0. 7(*+(6

E' 044%$%&' $& $B*(* #+%/0+1 #+&I%4*+(^ +*(%4*'$( %' (&/* #0+$( &: $B* 2&7'$1 A*$$B*%+ 50$*+ :+&/ .&30. /7'%3%#0. 5*..( N%' U0.45%'(I%..* 0'4 87..1O &+ %'4%I%470.5*..(6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

8B* 37++*'$ 50$*+ %':+0($+73$7+* '*$5&+S %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1:03*( (%A'%:%30'$ 0'4 A+&5%'A '**4(^ 0'4 4*:*++*4 /0%'$*'0'3* B0( 3&/#+&/%(*4$B* (1($*/X( %'$*A+%$16

K*4*+0. :7'4%'A 0((%($0'3* B0( 9**' 50'%'A6

8B* :+0A/*'$0$%&' &: $B* +0$*#01*+ 90(* 0/&'A (7##.%*+( 0'4 4%($+%3$( 30' /0S*/0g&+ %'I*($/*'$( c *I*' 5B*' '*3*((0+1 c 3&($ #+&B%9%$%I* 0'4 *Q03*+90$* $B*4*:*++*4 /0%'$*'0'3* #+&9.*/6

8B*+* %( (&/* :7'3$%&'0. 47#.%30$%&' 03+&(( $B* $5& /0g&+ +*$0%. #+&I%4*+( %' $*+/(&: 04/%'%($+0$%&'^ /*$*+ +*04%'A^ 9%..%'A 0'4 $+*0$/*'$ #.0'$ *+0$%&'(6


16/83

13

D H?8MDH8M) E_K)H?8)W28W)M

8B* #+*+ :7'3$%&'%'A 0'4 /0%'$*'0'3* &: &7+ '*$5&+S &: #%#*(^ $+*0$/*'$ #.0'$( 0'4&7$:0..( 0+* 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ '&$ &'.1 $& $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1X( *3&'&/%3

I%09%.%$1^ 97$ &7+ *'I%+&'/*'$ 0'4 i70.%$1 &: .%:*6,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

D0($*50$*+ $+*0$/*'$ :&+ /&($ /7'%3%#0.%$%*( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$1 %( #+&I%4*4 91 $B* 2&7'$1 T*#0+$/*'$ &: D0$*+ M'I%+&'/*'$-+&$*3$%&'^ 5B%3B *+0$*( > $+*0$/*'$ #.0'$( 0'4 /&+* $B0' ;=L #7/#%'A ($0$%&'(%' $B* 2&'(&.%40$*4 ?0'%$0+1 T%($+%3$6 2&7'$1 (*5*+ (*+I%3* %( 3&':%'*4 $& $B%(4%($+%3$ 0'4 %'3.74*( 0.. &+ #&+$%&'( &: F; /7'%3%#0.%$%*(6 ?*I*+0. I%..0A*( &5' 0'4/0%'$0%' $B*%+ &5' (*50A* $+*0$/*'$ #.0'$(6

D0($*50$*+ 3&($( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 $&$0.*4 n;


17/83

14

HA%'A 3&..*3$%&' %':+0($+73$7+* %' $B* 2&7'$1 B0( /&+* *Q$+0'*&7( A+&7'450$*+

%':%.$+0$%&' 0'4 %':.&5^ %'3+*0(%'A $B* 3&($ &: $+*0$/*'$ 0'4 A*'*+0. *+0$%'A 3&($(6

Source: “A Primer for Water and Wastewater Utilities,” U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

10'65(& f5$%)&B-+&473*( #&$09.* 50$*+^ $+*0$*4 *::.7*'$^ 0'4#+&3*(( +*(%470.( %' :7.. 3&/#.%0'3* 5%$B+*A7.0$&+1 0'4 +*.%09%.%$1 +*i7%+*/*'$( 0'43&'(%($*'$ 5%$B 37($&/*+^ #79.%3 B*0.$B^ 0'4*3&.&A%30. '**4(6

#52&';-0 A$&)2?$(&)'*

-+&I%4*( +*.%09.*^ +*(#&'(%I*^ 0'4 0::&+409.*(*+I%3*( %' .%'* 5%$B *Q#.%3%$^ 37($&/*+]033*#$*4 (*+I%3* .*I*.(6 )*3*%I*( $%/*.137($&/*+ :**4903S $& /0%'$0%'+*(#&'(%I*'*(( $& 37($&/*+ '**4( 0'4*/*+A*'3%*(6

E;:%'B-- $*6 N-$6-028): .-F-%':;-*&)*3+7%$( 0'4 +*$0%'( 0 5&+S:&+3* $B0$ %(3&/#*$*'$^ /&$%I0$*4^ 040#$%I*^ 0'4 (0:*]5&+S%'A6 M($09.%(B*( 0 #0+$%3%#0$&+1^3&..09&+0$%I* &+A0'%d0$%&' 4*4%30$*4 $&3&'$%'70. .*0+'%'A 0'4 %/#+&I*/*'$6M'(7+*( */#.&1** %'($%$7$%&'0. S'&5.*4A* %(+*$0%'*4 0'4 %/#+&I*4 7#&' &I*+ $%/*6

-+&I%4*( 0 :&37( &' 0'4 */#B0(%d*(#&+$7'%$%*( :&+ #+&:*((%&'0. 0'4 .*04*+(B%#4*I*./*'$ 0'4 ($+%I*( $& 3+*0$* 0'%'$*A+0$*4 0'4 5*..]3&&+4%'0$*4 (*'%&+.*04*+(B%# $*0/6

D:-0$&)'*$% D:&);)O$&)'*M'(7+*( &'A&%'A^ $%/*.1^ 3&($]*::*3$%I*^+*.%09.*^ 0'4 (7($0%'09.* #*+:&+/0'3*


18/83

15

%/#+&I*/*'$( %' 0.. :03*$( &: %$( *+0$%&'(6C%'%/%d*( +*(&7+3* 7(*^ .&((^ 0'4 %/#03$(:+&/ 401]$&]401 *+0$%&'(6 C0%'$0%'(050+*'*(( &: %':&+/0$%&' 0'4 *+0$%&'0.$*3B'&.&A1 4*I*./*'$( $& 0'$%3%#0$* 0'4

(7##&+$ $%/*.1 04$%&' &: %/#+&I*/*'$(6

c)*$*()$% ^)$@)%)&BW'4*+($0'4( $B* :7.. .%:*]313.* 3&($ &: $B*7$%.%$1 0'4 *($09.%(B*( 0'4 /0%'$0%'( 0'*::*3$%I* 90.0'3* 9*$5**' .&'A]$*+/ 4*9$^0((*$ I0.7*(^ *+0$%&'( 0'4 /0%'$*'0'3**Q#*'4%$7+*(^ 0'4 *+0$%'A +*I*'7*(6M($09.%(B*( #+*4%3$09.* +0$*(o3&'(%($*'$5%$B 3&//7'%$1 *Q#*3$0$%&'( 0'4033*#$09%.%$1o04*i70$* $& +*3&I*+ 3&($(^#+&I%4* :&+ +*(*+I*(^ /0%'$0%' (7##&+$ :+&/

9&'4 +0$%'A 0A*'3%*(^ 0'4 #.0' 0'4 %'I*($ :&+:7$7+* '**4(6

>*?0$2&05(&50- A&$@)%)&BW'4*+($0'4( $B* 3&'4%$%&' &: 0'4 3&($(0((&3%0$*4 5%$B 3+%$%30. %':+0($+73$7+* 0((*$(6C0%'$0%'( 0'4 *'B0'3*( $B* 3&'4%$%&' &: 0..0((*$( &I*+ $B* .&'A]$*+/ 0$ $B* .&5*($#&((%9.* .%:*]313.* 3&($ 0'4 033*#$09.* +%(S3&'(%($*'$ 5%$B 37($&/*+^ 3&//7'%$1^ 0'4+*A7.0$&+](7##&+$*4 (*+I%3* .*I*.(^ 0'43&'(%($*'$ 5%$B 0'$%3%#0$*4 A+&5$B 0'4

(1($*/ +*.%09%.%$1 A&0.(6 H((7+*( 0((*$ +*#0%+^+*B09%.%$0$%&'^ 0'4 +*#.03*/*'$ *::&+$( 0+*3&&+4%'0$*4 5%$B%' $B* 3&//7'%$1 $&/%'%/%d* 4%(+7#$%&'( 0'4 &$B*+ '*A0$%I*3&'(*i7*'3*(6

D:-0$&)'*$% 9-2)%)-*(BM'(7+*( 7$%.%$1 .*04*+(B%# 0'4 ($0:: 5&+S$&A*$B*+ $& 0'$%3%#0$* 0'4 0I&%4 #+&9.*/(6-+&03$%I*.1 %4*'$%:%*(^ 0((*((*(^ *($09.%(B*($&.*+0'3* .*I*.( :&+^ 0'4 *::*3$%I*.1 /0'0A*(0 :7.. +0'A* &: 97(%'*(( +%(S( N%'3.74%'A .*A0.^

+*A7.0$&+1^ :%'0'3%0.^ *'I%+&'/*'$0.^ (0:*$1^(*37+%$1^ 0'4 '0$7+0. 4%(0($*+]+*.0$*4O %' 0#+&03$%I* 501 3&'(%($*'$ 5%$B %'47($+1 $+*'4(0'4 (1($*/ +*.%09%.%$1 A&0.(6

#';;5*)&B A52&$)*$@)%)&BE( *Q#.%3%$.1 3&A'%d0'$ &: 0'4 0$$*'$%I* $& $B*%/#03$( %$( 4*3%(%&'( B0I* &' 37++*'$ 0'4.&'A]$*+/ :7$7+* 3&//7'%$1 0'4 50$*+(B*4B*0.$B 0'4 5*.:0+*6 C0'0A*( *+0$%&'(^%':+0($+73$7+*^ 0'4 %'I*($/*'$( $& #+&$*3$^+*($&+*^ 0'4 *'B0'3* $B* '0$7+0.*'I%+&'/*'$l *::%3%*'$.1 7(*( 50$*+ 0'4*'*+A1 +*(&7+3*(l #+&/&$*( *3&'&/%3I%$0.%$1l 0'4 *'A*'4*+( &I*+0.. 3&//7'%$1%/#+&I*/*'$6 MQ#.%3%$.1 3&'(%4*+( 0 I0+%*$1 &:#&..7$%&' #+*I*'$%&'^ 50$*+(B*4^ 0'4 (&7+3*

50$*+ #+&$*3$%&' 0##+&03B*( 0( #0+$ &: 0'&I*+0.. ($+0$*A1 $& /0%'$0%' 0'4 *'B0'3**3&.&A%30. 0'4 3&//7'%$1 (7($0%'09%.%$16

,$&-0 9-2'50(- !6-Z5$(BM'(7+*( 50$*+ 0I0%.09%.%$1 3&'(%($*'$ 5%$B37++*'$ 0'4 :7$7+* 37($&/*+ '**4( $B+&7AB.&'A]$*+/ +*(&7+3* (7##.1 0'4 4*/0'40'0.1(%(^ 3&'(*+I0$%&'^ 0'4 #79.%3 *4730$%&'6MQ#.%3%$.1 3&'(%4*+( %$( +&.* %' 50$*+0I0%.09%.%$1 0'4 /0'0A*( *+0$%&'( $&#+&I%4* :&+ .&'A]$*+/ 0i7%:*+ 0'4 (7+:03*

50$*+ (7($0%'09%.%$1 0'4 +*#.*'%(B/*'$6

A&$3-8'%6-0 a*6-02&$*6)*4 $*6 A5::'0&M'A*'4*+( 7'4*+($0'4%'A 0'4 (7##&+$ :+&/&I*+(%AB$ 9&4%*(^ 3&//7'%$1 0'4 50$*+(B*4%'$*+*($(^ 0'4 +*A7.0$&+1 9&4%*( :&+ (*+I%3*.*I*.(^ +0$* ($+73$7+*(^ *+0$%'A 974A*$(^30#%$0. %/#+&I*/*'$ #+&A+0/(^ 0'4 +%(S/0'0A*/*'$ 4*3%(%&'(6 H3$%I*.1 %'I&.I*(($0S*B&.4*+( %' $B* 4*3%(%&'( $B0$ 5%.. 0::*3$$B*/6


19/83

16

?"PET D H?8M 2"PPM28E"_

?0'%$0$%&' (*+I%3*( 0+* 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ $& $B* i70.%$1 &: .%:* 0'4 *'I%+&'/*'$ %' $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

?0'%$0$%&' (*+I%3*( 0+* B0'4.*4 %' 0 I0+%*$1 &: 501( $B+&7AB&7$ $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 8B+** 90(%3 0##+&03B*( 0+* 7(*46 ?&/* /7'%3%#0.%$%*(#+&I%4* $B* (*+I%3* 4%+*3$.1 7(%'A $B*%+ &5' */#.&1**( 0'4 *i7%#/*'$l &$B*+(Z9+&S*+[ $B* (*+I%3* &' 9*B0.: &: $B*%+ +*(%4*'$( 91 3&'$+03$%'A $& 0 #+%I0$* (*+I%3*#+&I%4*+ 0'4 .*I1%'A 3&($( &' B&/*&5'*+( $B+&7AB #+*+$1 $0Q*( &+ 4%($+%3$]90(*4:**(6 K7+$B*+^ (&/* /7'%3%#0.%$%*( B0I* '& %'I&.I*/*'$ %' $B* :7'3$%&' 0$ 0..^ %'5B%3B 30(* #+*+$1 &5'*+( 30' 4%+*3$.1 3&'$+03$ 5%$B #+%I0$* B07.*+( &+ (*.:]$+0'(#&+$ $B*%+ 50($* $& 0 .0'4:%..6

?%Q /7'%3%#0.%$%*( c %'3.74%'A $B* 2%$1 0'4 :%I* I%..0A*( c 4*.%I*+ $B* (*+I%3*$B*/(*.I*(6

85*'$1 /7'%3%#0.%$%*( c %'3.74%'A ;G $&5'( 0'4 R I%..0A*( c 3&'$+03$ 5%$B 0'&7$(%4* I*'4&+ $& #+&I%4* $B* (*+I%3* $& +*(%4*'$(6

8B* +*/0%'%'A .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( B0I* '& %'I&.I*/*'$ %' (0'%$0$%&' (*+I%3*( *%$B*+0( 0 #+&I%4*+ &+ 9+&S*+6

": $B* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 $B0$ 4%+*3$.1(#*'4 &' (0'%$0$%&' 0'4 +*313.%'A^ nFF6F /%..%&' 50( (#*'$ %' FL;G6 8B%( :%A7+*

4&*( '&$ %'3.74* $B* 3&($ &: 3&'$+03$( 9*$5**' %'4%I%470. #+*+$1 &5'*+( 0'4#+%I0$* B07.*+( %' $B&(* 3&//7'%$%*( 5B*+* $B* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$ %( '&$ %'I&.I*4 %'$B* (*+I%3*6 8B* $+7* &I*+0.. 3&($ &: $B* (*+I%3* %( $B*+*:&+* B%AB*+ $B0' $B%( :%A7+*6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

"22)H c $B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 )*(&7+3* )*3&I*+1 HA*'31 c %( 0 #79.%3 9*'*:%$3&+#&+0$%&' 3+*0$*4 %' ;YJ; 7'4*+ ($0$* .05 0'4 /04* +*(#&'(%9.* :&+%/#.*/*'$%'A $B* 2&7'$1 ?&.%4 D0($* C0'0A*/*'$ -+&A+0/^ 0( 5*.. 0( $B*3&'($+73$%&'^ *+0$%&' 0'4 0I0%.09%.%$1 &: (&.%4 50($* /0'0A*/*'$ 0'4 +*313.%'A:03%.%$%*( :&+ /7'%3%#0.%$%*( %' $B* 2&7'$16 8B* HA*'31 %( 0 /&4*. +*A%&'0.3&*+0$%&' :+0/*5&+S6

8B*+* %( .%$$.* %'$*+/7'%3%#0. 3&&+4%'0$%&' +*A0+4%'A (&.%4 50($* (*+I%3*( %' $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 0(%4* :+&/ $B* ?&7$B*+' "'&'40A0 8+0(B ?1($*/N?"8?O^ 5B%3B %( 0 /7.$%]$&5' 3&'(&+$%7/ %' $B* (&7$B*0($ i704+0'$ &: $B* 2&7'$1$B0$ g&%'$.1 3&'$+03$( :&+ (*+I%3*6

8B* 4%I*+(%$1 &: 0##+&03B*( 7(*4 03+&(( $B* 2&7'$1^ 0'4 $B* 09(*'3* &:3&&+4%'0$%&' &7$(%4* &: "22)H 0'4 ?"8?^ 3&/#+&/%(*( *3&'&/%*( &: (30.* $B0$


20/83

17

3&7.4 &$B*+5%(* 1%*.4 .&5*+ 3&($(6 H #+*I%&7( 9*'3B/0+S%'A +*#&+$ #+&473*4 91$B* C0Q5*.. ?3B&&. 0$ ?1+037(* W'%I*+(%$1 :&7'4 $B0$^ &: $B* I0+%*4 0##+&03B*( $&B0'4.%'A +*(%4*'$%0. $+0(B (*+I%3*( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^/7'%3%#0..1]9+&S*+*4 b 3&'$+03$*4 50( $B* .*0($ 3&($.16 U1 3&'$+0($^ %' $B&(*3&//7'%$%*( 5B*+* $B* /7'%3%#0.%$1 B04 '& %'I&.I*/*'$ %' $B* (*+I%3*^ +*(%4*'$(%'4%I%470..1 3&'$+03$*4 :&+ $+0(B 3&..*3$%&' 0$ +&7AB.1 4&79.* $B* 3&($ &: /7'%3%#0..1]9+&S*+*4 3&//7'%$%*(6>

> Z)*(%4*'$%0. 8+0(B 2&..*3$%&' %' "'&'40A0 2&7'$1a H ?$741 2&/#0+%'A 2&($ 0'4 81#* &: ?*+I%3*^[`7'* ;YYY^ ?1+037(* W'%I*+(%$1^ C0Q5*.. ?3B&&. &: 2%$%d*'(B%# 0'4 -79.%3 H::0%+(6


21/83

18

?WCCH)j "K HP8M)_H8EfM?

E' +*I%*5%'A ($+**$ 0'4 B%AB501 /0%'$*'0'3*^ 50$*+^ 50($*50$*+ 0'4 (&.%4 50($*3&..*3$%&'^ $B* E':+0($+73$7+* 2&//%$$** *Q#.&+*4 0 +0'A* &: (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 $%&'(6

H.$B&7AB 3*+$0%' $%&'( 0+* /&+* 0##.%309.* %' $B* 3&'$*Q$ &: (&/* %':+0($+73$7+*]+*.0$*4:7'3$%&'( $B0' %' &$B*+(^ $B* :&..&5%'A (7//0+1 A*'*+0..1 &7$.%'*( $B* +0'A* &:0.$*+'0$%I*(6

C&4*.( &: .&30. A&I*+'/*'$ #79.%3 5&+S( 0'4 ($+**$ b B%AB501 /0%'$*'0'3* (*+I%3*(+0'A* :+&/ .&30. /&4*.( %' 5B%3B /7.$%#.* A&I*+'/*'$( 9*0+ +*(#&'(%9%.%$1 :&+ #+&I%4%'A(*+I%3*( %' %'4%I%470. 3&//7'%$%*( N0( %( $B* 30(* %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1$&401O^ $& 3&7'$15%4* /&4*.( %' 5B%3B 0 (%'A.* #+&I%4*+ %( +*(#&'(%9.* :&+ 0 9+&04*+A*&A+0#B%3 0+*06

E' $B* /%44.* &: $B* +0'A* 0+* %'$*+/7'%3%#0. b B19+%4 /&4*.( 90(*4 &' %'$*+/7'%3%#0.(B0+*4 (*+I%3*(^ 5B*+* 04/%'%($+0$%I* :7'3$%&'(^ *+0$%&'( 0'4 b &+ 30#%$0. *i7%#/*'$

0+* (B0+*4 9*$5**' &+ 0/&'A &$B*+5%(* %'4*#*'4*'$ A&I*+'/*'$ 7'%$(6

C'6-% K+ N'($% !::0'$(8-2

H$ &'* *'4 &: $B* 3&'$%'77/ %( $B* 4*.%I*+1 &: #79.%3 5&+S( (*+I%3*( 7(%'A 0 .&30. /&4*. &:04/%'%($+0$%&'^ *+0$%&'( 0'4 30#%$0.6 W'4*+ $B%( :+0/*5&+S^ %'4%I%470. .&30.A&I*+'/*'$( 4*.%I*+ $B* (*+I%3* %'4*#*'4*'$.1 5%$B%' $B*%+ 9&7'40+%*( 0'4 +*$0%'07$&'&/1 &I*+ $B* $1#*^ .*I*. 0'4 3&($ &: (*+I%3*( #+&I%4*46 H( 0 +*(7.$^ (&/* (*+I%3*4%::*+*'$%0$%&' *Q%($( 03+&(( .&30. A&I*+'/*'$(6

K&+ *Q0/#.*^ (&/* A&I*+'/*'$( #+&I%4* $+0(B 3&..*3$%&' 0( 0 /7'%3%#0. (*+I%3*^ (&/*

3&'$+03$ %$ &7$ $& 0 #+%I0$* I*'4&+^ 0'4 &$B*+( #.01 '& +&.* 0$ 0..6 ?%/%.0+.1^ (&/* #79.%35&+S( 4*#0+$/*'$( B0I* $B* 30#03%$1^ *i7%#/*'$ 0'4 *Q#*+$%(* $& #*+:&+/ /0g&+ 30#%$0.+*#0%+( %']B&7(*l &$B*+( 3&'$+03$ $B* :7'3$%&' &7$ 3&/#.*$*.16

8B* .&30. /&4*. 3B0+03$*+%d*( /&($ #79.%3 5&+S( (*+I%3*( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$1 $&4016 E' $&$0.^ $B* 3&7'$1 %( B&/* $& G> (*#0+0$* #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'3%*( c &'**03B %' $B* 2&7'$1^ 2%$1^ ;Y $&5'( 0'4 ;= I%..0A*(6 8B&7AB $B* 0A*'3%*( 4& 3&..09&+0$* c$1#%30..1 &' 0' %':&+/0.^ 0( '**4*4 90(%( c $B*1 B0'4.* 04/%'%($+0$%&'^ *+0$%&'( 0'430#%$0. *i7%#/*'$ %'4*#*'4*'$ &: &'* 0'&$B*+6 MQ0/#.*( &: 3&..09&+0$%&' %'3.74* %'$*+]0A*'31 (7##&+$ :&+ .0+A* (30.* g&9(^ (B0+*4 :03%.%$%*(^ (B0+*4 :7*.%'A 4*#&$( 0'4 97.S 9%4#7+3B0(%'A &: 3&//&' (7##.%*(6

-*+3*%I*4 H4I0'$0A*(

T*#0+$/*'$ 04/%'%($+0$%&' %( 3.&(*+ $& 3&//7'%$1 %$ (*+I*(2&'($%$7*'$ 3&''*3$%&' 5%$B #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'31P&30. ($+73$7+* 3+*0$*( A+*0$*+ 4%+*3$ $%* $& 3&//7'%$%*( (*+I*4V+*0$*+ (*'(%$%I%$1 $& N0'4 #+%&+%$%d0$%&' &:O .&30. 3&//7'%$1 (*+I%3* '**4(p7%3S*+ +*(#&'(* $%/* $& .&30. '**4(P&30. 4*3%(%&']/0S%'A 07$&'&/1 &I*+ $1#* 0'4 .*I*. &: (*+I%3*( #+&I%4*4


22/83

19

M03B A&I*+'/*'$ 30' /0$3B %$( &5' *i7%#/*'$ $& %$( &5' 4*(%+*(^ '**4(M03B A&I*+'/*'$ B0( +*041 033*(( $& %$( &5' *i7%#/*'$ :&+ .&30. 7(*

-*+3*%I*4 T%(04I0'$0A*(

H4/%'%($+0$%I* 47#.%30$%&' 03+&(( '*%AB9&+%'A /7'%3%#0.%$%*( H4/%'%($+0$%I* 3&($ 3&'3*'$+0$*4 &' (/0..*+ $0Q 90(* 0'4 A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0?*+I%3*( '&$ #+%&+%$%d*4 90(*4 &' +*A%&'0. '**4("#*+0$%&'0. 3&($ 3&'3*'$+0$*4 &' (/0..*+ $0Q 90(* 0'4 A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0K03%.%$%*( &:$*' %' 3.&(* #+&Q%/%$1 $& &'* 0'&$B*+?*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 30' Z4*04 B*04[ 0$ /7'%3%#0. 9&+4*+(^ 3+*0$%'A %'*::%3%*'3%*(Mi7%#/*'$ +*47'40'31 %' '*%AB9&+%'A g7+%(4%3$%&'( 0'4 3&7'$15%4*Mi7%#/*'$ +*47'40'31 3+*0$*( /0%'$*'0'3* +*47'40'31

H9(*'3* &: #&&.*4 #7+3B0(%'A 3&/#+&/%(*( *3&'&/%*( &: (30.*C7'%3%#0.].*I*. *i7%#/*'$ $+03S%'A %( &:$*' .*(( (B%($%30$*4 0'4 /0S*( %$ 4%::%37.$$& 4*$*+/%'* Z.%:* 3&($([ &: /0%'$0%'*4 *i7%#/*'$

20#%$0. 3&($ 3&'3*'$+0$*4 &' (/0..*+ $0Q 90(* 0'4 A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0

C'6-% I+ dB@0)6 b >*&-0;5*)():$% A8$0-6 A-0F)(-2

_*Q$ 0+* B19+%4 /&4*.( $B0$ .*I*+0A* %'$*+]/7'%3%#0. (B0+*4 (*+I%3*( %' 04/%'%($+0$%&'^*+0$%&'( &+ 30#%$0. *i7%#/*'$ $& 3&..09&+0$%I*.1 4*.%I*+ #79.%3 5&+S( (*+I%3*( 03+&((&$B*+5%(* %'4*#*'4*'$ A&I*+'/*'$(6 8B%( /01 B0##*' 9+&04.1 0'4 3&I*+ 0.. (*+I%3*(N*6A6 0 :7.. *+0$%&'0. &+ 04/%'%($+0$%I* /*+A*+ &: #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'3%*(O^ &+ /&+*'0++&5.1 :&37(*4 &' 0 (#*3%:%3 $1#* &: (*+I%3* N*6A6 3&7'$1 3&'$+03$%'A 5%$B .&30.A&I*+'/*'$( $& B0'4.* %3* 0'4 ('&5 +*/&I0. &' 3&7'$1 +&04(O^ (73B 0( &337+( %' $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 &' 3*+$0%' ($+**$ /0%'$*'0'3* :7'3$%&'(6

H' *Q0/%'0$%&' &: (*.*3$ B19+%4 /&4*.( 5%$B%' _*5 j&+S %..7($+0$*( $B* 4%I*+(%$1 &: %'$*+]/7'%3%#0. 0##+&03B*(a

D*'*6$4$ #'5*&B 3&'$+03$( 5%$B (*I*+0. $&5'( 0'4 I%..0A*( $& #+&I%4* ('&5 0'4%3* +*/&I0. &' 3&7'$1]&5'*4 +&04( 47+%'A $B* 5%'$*+6

C'*0'- $*6 H-??-02'* #'5*&)-2 #+&I%4* $*3B'%30. 0((%($0'3* $& .&30.A&I*+'/*'$( $B+&7AB&7$ $B* 3&7'$1^ 5B%.* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( /0%'$0%' 0.. .&30.]0'4 3&7'$1]&5'*4 +&04( 5%$B%' $B*%+ 9&7'40+%*(6

H .0+A* '7/9*+ &: #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'3%*( $B+&7AB&7$ $B* ($0$*^ %'3.74%'A %' $B*

7'P* '? 18)%$6-%:8)$ 0'4 7'P* '? !66)2'*^ *+0$* :7*. 4*#&$( $B0$ 0+* g&%'$.17(*4 91 #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'3%*( &: $B* 3&7'$%*(^ $&5'( 0'4 I%..0A*(^ 0( 5*.. 0( $B*.&30. (3B&&. 4%($+%3$(6

#8-;5*4 #'5*&B B0( #+&I%4*4 #79.%3 5&+S( 04/%'%($+0$%I* 0'4 ($0:: (7#*+I%(%&'7'4*+ 3&'$+03$ $& $B* 8&5' &: U%A K.0$( :&+ $B* #0($ 1*0+6 C&+* +*3*'$.1^ $B* 3&7'$10''&7'3*4 %' `0'70+1 FL;= $B0$ %$ B04 +*03B*4 0A+**/*'$ 5%$B $B* 2%$1 &: M./%+0$& 3&'(&.%40$* $B* $5& A&I*+'/*'$(X #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'3%*(6 W'4*+ $B0$ #.0'^ 3%$1


23/83

20

#79.%3 5&+S( */#.&1**( 5%.. 9*3&/* 3&7'$1 */#.&1**(^ 1%*.4%'A 0 A*&A+0#B%30..1.0+A*+ 0'4 /&+* ($+*0/.%'*4 #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'316 M::%3%*'31 (0I%'A( $& $B* 3%$1:+&/ /*+A%'A 04/%'%($+0$%I* :7'3$%&'( 0+* *($%/0$*4 0$ n;6J /%..%&'6

2B*/7'A 2&7'$1X( *Q#*+%*'3* &::*+( 0' 044%$%&'0. /&4*. $B0$^ B04 %$ 9**' :7..1

%/#.*/*'$*4^ 5&7.4 B0I* +*#+*(*'$*4 0 :%+($ &: %$( S%'4 %' _*5 j&+S6 E' FL;L^ $B* 3&7'$1+*.*0(*4 0 ($741 &: B%AB501 (*+I%3*( $B0$ +*3&//*'4*4 0 +*A%&'0.]B19+%4 /&4*. &:04/%'%($+0$%&' 0'4 *+0$%&'(6 E$ 3&'(%($*4 &: $B+** /0%' 3&/#&'*'$(6

K%+($^ 0 3&'(&.%40$*4 Z7+90' B%AB501 (*+I%3*( 0+*0[ NW@?HO 5&7.4 B0I* 9**'3+*0$*4 0/&'A $B* 3&7'$1^ $B* 2%$1 &: M./%+0 0'4 $B* 3%$1X( 4*'(* %''*+]+%'A'*%AB9&+(^ %'3.74%'A $B* $&5'( &: @&+(*B*04( 0'4 M./%+0^ 0'4 $B* I%..0A*( &:M./%+0 @*%AB$( 0'4 @&+(*B*04(l

?*3&'4^ 0 /*3B0'%(/ :&+ #+&I%4%'A 3*+$0%' 3&//&' 0'4 (#*3%0.%d*4 B%AB501(*+I%3*( &' 0 3&7'$15%4* 90(%( %'($*04 &: &' 0 /7'%3%#0. 90(%(^ 30#%$0.%d%'A &' $B*

9*'*:%$( &: .0+A*+ (30.* (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1l 0'4

8B%+4^ $+0'(:*++%'A +&7$%'* (*0(&'0. /0%'$*'0'3* 0'4 +*#0%+ 47$%*( &' 3&7'$1]&5'*4 %':+0($+73$7+* $& /7'%3%#0. #79.%3 5&+S( 0A*'3%*( %' 0' *::&+$ $& 9*$$*+3&&+4%'0$* .&30. +&04 /0%'$*'0'3*6

8B&7AB $B* U%A K.0$( 0'4 2%$1 &: M./%+0 04/%'%($+0$%I* 3&'(&.%40$%&'( 5%$B $B* 3&7'$1B0I* /&I*4 :&+50+4^ $B* 9+&04*+ $*'*$( &: $B* #.0' B0I* '&$6

-*+3*%I*4 H4I0'$0A*(

2&..09&+0$%&' 5B*+* *::%3%*'31 #&+$7'%$%*( 30' 9* .*I*+0A*4

E'4%I%470. .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( +*$0%' (&/* 07$&'&/1 &I*+ (*+I%3*(^ .*I*.(C%$%A0$* 04/%'%($+0$%I*^ *+0$%&'0. 47#.%30$%&' 5B*+* %$ *Q%($(C%$%A0$* (&/* (*+I%3* Z4*04B*04%'A[ 0$ /7'%3%#0. 9&7'40+%*(C%$%A0$* (&/* (*+I%3* 47#.%30$%&' %' '*%AB9&+%'A g7+%(4%3$%&'(?$0'40+4%d* (*+I%3*( 0'4 *i7%#/*'$ 03+&(( 3&//7'%$%*(C&+* 3&&+4%'0$*4 0'4 9+&04*+ 30#%$0. *i7%#/*'$ +*#.03*/*'$ ($+0$*A1 03+&((3&//7'%$%*( 30' 1%*.4 *3&'&/%*( &: (30.*M'.0+A*4 b g&%'$ $0Q 90(* &I*+ 5B%3B $& (#+*04 30#%$0. *Q#*'4%$7+*(^ (&/* &: 5B%3B0+* (%A'%:%30'$ N*6A6 47/# $+73S(^ #.&5(^ $+0(B 3&..*3$%&' $+73S(O

-*+3*%I*4 T%(04I0'$0A*(

)*473*4 033&7'$09%.%$1 0( 04/%'%($+0$&+( 0+* :7+$B*+ :+&/ 3&'($%$7*'$(P&30. A&I*+'/*'$( +*.%'i7%(B (&/* 07$B&+%$1 b 3&'$+&. &I*+ (*+I%3*(^ .*I*.(P&(( &: (*+I%3* 4%::*+*'$%0$%&' 0/&'A 3&//7'%$%*(?*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 30' ($%.. Z4*04 B*04[ 0$ /7'%3%#0. 9&+4*+(^ 3+*0$%'A %'*::%3%*'3%*(?B0+*4 &+ g&%'$.1]&5'*4 *i7%#/*'$ 30' 9* 3&/#.%30$*4 $& (3B*47.* 0'4 /0%'$0%'*i7%$09.1


24/83

21

C'6-% V+ #'5*&BP)6-

H$ $B* &$B*+ *'4 &: $B* 3&'$%'77/ 0+* (*+I%3*( 4*.%I*+*4 $B+&7AB 0 3&7'$15%4* /&4*. 910 (%'A.* A&I*+'/*'$ b (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+6 W'4*+ $B%( /&4*.^ 0.. #79.%3 5&+S( (*+I%3*( 0+*3&'(&.%40$*4 %'$& 0 3&7'$15%4* &+A0'%d0$%&'^ 5%$B .&30. #+*(*'3* *($09.%(B*4 $B+&7AB

Z(0$*..%$*[ :03%.%$%*( ($+0$*A%30..1 .&30$*4 $B+&7AB&7$ $B* +*A%&'6 H 7'%:%*4^ ($+*0/.%'*404/%'%($+0$%&' &I*+(**( $B* *'$%+* *+0$%&' 0'4 4*#.&1( #*+(&''*. 0'4 30#%$0. +*(&7+3*(%' +*(#&'(* $& 9&$B +*A%&'0. 0'4 .&30. (*+I%3* '**4(6

-*+3*%I*4 H4I0'$0A*(

2&7'$15%4* 3&&+4%'0$%&' &: (*+I%3*(^ #*+(&''*.^ *i7%#/*'$ 0'4 :03%.%$1 4*#.&1/*'$?$0'40+4%d*4 #&.%3%*( 0'4 #+&3*47+*( $& *'(7+* 3&'(%($*'$ (*+I%3* .*I*.(^ g&9$+0%'%'A 0'4 (0:*$1C%$%A0$* 04/%'%($+0$%I* 47#.%30$%&'T**#*+ &+A0'%d0$%&'0. 30#03%$1 :&+ g&9( +*i7%+%'A 3&'3*'$+0$*4 *Q#*+$%(* &+

/0'#&5*+C%$%A0$* *+0$%&'0. 47#.%30$%&'M.%/%'0$* (*+I%3* Z4*04B*04%'A[ 0$ /7'%3%#0. 9&7'40+%*(M'.0+A*4 $0Q 90(* &I*+ 5B%3B $& (#+*04 *Q#*'4%$7+*(?$0'40+4%d* (*+I%3*( 0'4 *i7%#/*'$ 03+&(( 3&7'$1P0+A*+ #&&. &: #*+(&''*. 0..&5( :&+ (#*3%0.%d0$%&' 0'4 /&+* $*3B'%30. #+&g*3$( $& 9*4&'* %']B&7(*C&+* *::%3%*'$ :03%.%$1 4%($+%97$%&' $B+&7AB&7$ 3&7'$1C&+* 3&&+4%'0$*4 0'4 9+&04*+ 30#%$0. *i7%#/*'$ +*#.03*/*'$ ($+0$*A1 03+&((+*A%&' 30' 1%*.4 *3&'&/%*( &: (30.* $B+&7AB (%'A.* #+&37+*/*'$ 0A*'31)*473*4 47#.%30$%&' &: (#*3%0.%d*4 *i7%#/*'$

M'.0+A*4 $0Q 90(* &I*+ 5B%3B $& (#+*04 30#%$0. *Q#*'4%$7+*(^ (&/* &: 5B%3B 0+*(%A'%:%30'$ N*6A6 47/#(^ #.&5(^ $+0(B 3&..*3$%&' $+73S(O

-*+3*%I*4 T%(04I0'$0A*(

)*473*4 033&7'$09%.%$1 0( 04/%'%($+0$&+( 0+* :7+$B*+ :+&/ 3&'($%$7*'$(P&(( &: (*+I%3* 4%::*+*'$%0$%&' 0/&'A 3&//7'%$%*(P&(( &: .&30. 4*3%(%&']/0S%'A 07$B&+%$1 &I*+ (*+I%3*(^ .*I*.(P*(( +*(#&'(%I*'*(( $& .&30. b '*%AB9&+B&&4].*I*. 3&'3*+'(P&30. A&I*+'/*'$( +*.%'i7%(B 3&'$+&. &I*+ (*+I%3*(^ .*I*.(P&(( &: (*+I%3* 4%::*+*'$%0$%&' 0/&'A 3&//7'%$%*(P&30. A&I*+'/*'$( +*.%'i7%(B 3&'$+&. &I*+ *i7%#/*'$^ (7##.%*(

H((*$ 4%($+%97$%&' /01 9* .*(( +*(#&'(%I* $& 3&//7'%$1 b '*%AB9&+B&&4 '**4(


25/83

22

-)MPECE_H)j 2"CCE88MM )M2"CCM_TH8E"_?

8B* E':+0($+73$7+* 2&//%$$** B0( 4*I*.*4 $B* :&..&5%'A #+*.%/%'0+1

+*3&//*'40$%&'( +*A0+4%'A ($+**$ 0'4 B%AB501 /0%'$*'0'3*^ 50$*+^ 50($*50$*+ 0'4(&.%4 50($* (*+I%3*(6 8B*(* B0I* '&$ 1*$ 9**' :&+/0..1 033*#$*4 91 $B* :7..2&//%((%&'6

A&0--& $*6 d)48P$B C$)*&-*$*(-

;6 2+*0$* 0 3&&+4%'0$*4 Z2&+* @%AB501 ?*+I%3*( H+*0[ N2@?HO $B0$ %'$*A+0$*( $B*2%$1 &: ?1+037(* 0'4 /&+* 4*'(*.1 4*I*.*4 (797+90' 3&//7'%$%*( $& %$(_&+$B^ M0($ 0'4 D*($^ %' &+4*+ $& .*I*+0A* B%AB.1 3&'(%($*'$ (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1/*'7(^ *i7%#/*'$ '**4( 0'4 $B* #79.%3 5&+S( (*+I%3* (%/%.0+%$%*( $B0$ +*(7.$:+&/ 4*'(%$16

06 ?$0'40+4%d* *i7%#/*'$

96 ?B0+* (*+I%3*(

36 2&&+4%'0$* 30#%$0. #.0''%'A :&+ *i7%#/*'$ 0'4 %':+0($+73$7+*

46 )*I%(* *+0$%&'0. #.0'( $& 044+*(( /7'%3%#0. 9&+4*+ 0+*0( 5B*+*(*+I%3*( &:$*' Z4*04 B*04[

*6 ?$0'40+4%d* 0.. 3&'$+03$(

F6 T*.%I*+ 3&//&' (#*3%0.%d*4 b $*3B'%30. :7'3$%&'( &' 0 (B0+*4 3&7'$15%4* 90(%(%'($*04 &: 5%$B%' *03B 0A*'31^ I%0 %'$*+/7'%3%#0. 0A+**/*'$6

06 M'A%'**+%'A

96 -7+3B0(%'A

36 -0I*/*'$ /0+S%'A 0'4 ($+%#%'A

46 U+%4A* 0'4 37.I*+$ /0%'$*'0'3*

*6 ?%A' :09+%30$%&' 0'4 /0%'$*'0'3*

:6 ?0.$ ($&+0A* 0'4 *i7%#/*'$ 90+'(

A6 E'(7+0'3*^ @)^ 4*I*./*'$ 0'4 $+0%'%'A

G6 H##&%'$ 0 @%AB501 H4I%(&+1 ?*+I%3*( 2&//%$$** $& #+&I%4* &I*+(%AB$3&7'$15%4*6


26/83

23

*?0$2&05(&50-

;6 "2DH B0( 9**' %'3+*/*'$0..1 $0S%'A &I*+ $B* 0((*$( 0'4 *+0$%&'( &: (/0..*+50$*+ 4%($+%3$(l $B%( #+&3*(( (B&7.4 3&'$%'7* 0'4 9* *Q#*4%$*46

F6 C*+A* "2DH 0'4 $B* 2%$1 D0$*+ T*#0+$/*'$ $& .*I*+0A* %'$*+'0. *::%3%*'3%*( %'04/%'%($+0$%&' 0'4 *+0$%&'(^ 0'4 $& 9+&04*' $B* +0$*#01*+ 90(*6

G6 T%A%$%d* $B* *'$%+* 3&7'$15%4* (1($*/ $& #+&I%4* 0 90(%( :&+ #.0''%'A %' 0 /&+*3&/#+*B*'(%I* 5016

*?0$2&05(&50-

;6 -+*#0+* 0' H((*$ C0'0A*/*'$ ?1($*/ :&+ $+*0$/*'$ 0'4 3&..*3$%&' (1($*/(3&7'$15%4* $& (*+I* 0( $B* 90(%( :&+ %'$*A+0$%'A 0'4 *I0.70$%'A (1($*/(3&7'$15%4*6

F6 H33*(( T*#0+$/*'$ &: ?$0$* #.0''%'A A+0'$ $& 3&'473$ 0 (1($*/ 074%$ 0'44*I*. 0' 0((*$ /0'0A*/*'$ (1($*/ b #.0'6

G6 T*I*. 0 #.0' $& +*$%+* b 0((7/* 4*9$ 30++%*4 91 4%($+%3$( '&$ 0.+*041 #0+$ &: $B*2&'(&.%40$*4 ?0'%$0+1 T%($+%3$6


27/83

24

A'%)6 ,$2&-

;6 MQ#0'4 $B* ?&7$B*+' "'&'40A0 8+0(B ?1($*/ %'$& 3&'$%A7&7( $&5'( $B0$

0.+*041 B0I* 3&'$+03$( 5%$B 0 #+%I0$* B07.*+6

F6 -7+(7* 97.S 9%44%'A &: B07.*+ (*+I%3*( 03+&(( /7.$%#.* /7'%3%#0.%$%*( $& %'3+*0(*3&..*3$%&' I&.7/* 0'4 4+%I* 4&5' 7'%$ 3&($(6

G6 E' $&5'( 5%$B '& 37++*'$ %'I&.I*/*'$^ 4*I*. (*+I%3* 4%($+%3$( 0'4 9%4 3&..*3$%&'(*+I%3*( %' 0AA+*A0$* $& 4+%I* 4&5' 3&($( :&+ %'4%I%470. #+*+$1 &5'*+( 5B& 0+*37++*'$.1 #01%'A 4%+*3$ $& #+%I0$* B07.*+( &' 0 #+*+$1]91]#+*+$1 90(%(6

!66)&)'*$% 9-(';;-*6$&)'*2

E' $B* 3&7+(* &: $B* E':+0($+73$7+* 2&//%$$**X( 5&+S^ (*I*+0. 044%$%&'0. 0+*0( 5*+**Q0/%'*4 0'4 #&+$7'%$%*( $& %/#+&I* 5*+* %4*'$%:%*46 8B* :&..&5%'A #+*.%/%'0+1+*3&//*'40$%&'( 0+* $B*+*:&+* &::*+*4a

;6 -0+S( C0%'$*'0'3*a H.. 0A*'3%*( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 (B&7.49* /*+A*4 7'4*+ 0 (%'A.* +&&:^ %' 0 501 $B0$ +*$0%'( %'4%I%470. 3&//7'%$1 b #0+S%4*'$%$%*( 97$ /0Q%/%d*( *3&'&/%*( &: (30.*6

F6 U+&0490'4 H33*((a 8B%( %( 0 3+&((&I*+ %((7* 5%$B $B* M3&'&/%3 T*I*./*'$2&//%$$**6 8B* #&+$7'%$1 (B&7.4 9* #7+(7*4 $& #+&I%4* B%AB (#**4 033*(( $&0.. %' $B* 3&//7'%$16 8B* ?$0$* &: _*5 j&+S 37++*'$.1 B0( 0 :7'4%'A #&+$7'%$1&: n=L /%..%&' :&+ *Q#0'(%&' &: 9+&0490'4 $& 7'4*+(*+I*4 0+*0(6

G6 C0(( 8+0'(%$a 8B*+* (B&7.4 9* +*A%&'0. 4%(37((%&' $& (7##&+$ 2M_8)" c $B*2*'$+0. _*5 j&+S )*A%&'0. 8+0'(#&+$0$%&' H7$B&+%$1 c 0'4 5&+S $&A*$B*+ &' 0(7($0%'09.* .&'A $*+/ #.0'6 )*(*0+3B I&73B*+( 0'4 3&'$+03$ /&4*.( :&+*::*3$%I*'*((6


28/83

25

-79.%3 ?0:*$1

8B* -79.%3 ?0:*$1 2&//%$$** :&37(*4 &' :&7+ 3+%$%30. (*+I%3* 0+*0(a

K%+* -+&$*3$%&'lM/*+A*'31 C*4%30. ?*+I%3*( NMC?OlP05 M':&+3*/*'$l 0'42&++*3$%&'(6

KE)M -)"8M28E"_

K%+* #+&$*3$%&' %( '&$ &'.1 &'* &: $B* /&($ I%(%9.* (*+I%3*( #+&I%4*4 91 .&30. A&I*+'/*'$^97$ &'* &: $B* /&($ *((*'$%0.6 H +&97($ 0'4 *::*3$%I* +*(#&'(* (1($*/ %( '*3*((0+1 $&#+&$*3$ .%:* 0'4 #+*+$16

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

8B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 %( (*+I*4 91 '*0+.1 :%I* 4&d*' (*#0+0$*0A*'3%*(6 MQ3.74%'A $B* "'&'40A0 _0$%&' K%+* T*#0+$/*'$^ =R 0A*'3%*( #+&I%4*:%+* #+&$*3$%&' $& #&+$%&'( &: $B* 2&7'$16

E' FL;G^ =R 4%::*+*'$ :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( +*(#&'4*4 $& ==^FJ> +*i7*($( :&+ (*+I%3* %'$B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 8B%( 0/&7'$( $& 09&7$ ;=L 30..( #*+ 401 0'409&7$ &'* 30.. :&+ *I*+1 J6< +*(%4*'$(6 K%:$1 #*+3*'$ &: 30..( 5*+* 0'(5*+*4 91 $B*2%$1 &: ?1+037(*^ ;Yh 91 $B* '*Q$ J 97(%*($ 4*#0+$/*'$( %' $B* '*%AB9&+%'A(797+9( N*03B 5%$B /&+* $B0' ;^LLL 30..( #*+ 1*0+O^ 0'4 FLh 91 ;J 4*#0+$/*'$(

$B0$ B0'4.* 9*$5**'


29/83

26

H/&'A $B* 0A*'3%*( (*+I%'A $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^ (*+I%3* 0+*0(+0'A* :+&/ .*(( $B0' ; /%F $& /&+* $B0' GJ /%F6

K%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( 0.+*041 3&*+0$* B*0I%.1 &' $B* B0+4*($ #0+$ &: $B*%+ g&9 c5&+S%'A 0$ */*+A*'31 (3*'*(6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

8B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 %( (*+I*4 91 0 .0+A* '7/9*+ &: :%+*4*#0+$/*'$( 5%$B +%(%'A 3&($(6

8B*+* %( 0 3B0..*'A* %' +*3+7%$%'A 0'4 +*$0%'%'A I&.7'$**+(^ *Q03*+90$*4 91 $B*'**4 $& (#+*04 $B0$ .%/%$*4 90(* 03+&(( =R 0A*'3%*(6

8B*+* %( .03S &: %'$*+]0A*'31 3&&+4%'0$%&' %' #7+3B0(%'A 0##0+0$7( 0'4 #.0''%'A30#%$0. :03%.%$1 #+&g*3$(^ 5B%3B +*(7.$( %' B%AB*+ 3&($( 0'4 %'*::%3%*'31 4%($+%97$%&' &:

0((*$( (*+I%'A (/0..*+ A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0(6

)*(#&'(* +*(&7+3*( 0+* '&$ 0.501( /0$3B*4 $& .&30$%&'6

)*(&7+3* 4%($+%97$%&' 3B0..*'A*( 0+* 3&/#&7'4*4 91 $B* 4*3+*0(%'A 0I0%.09%.%$1 &:I&.7'$**+(^ *(#*3%0..1 47+%'A 401$%/* B&7+(6

H'1 4*3%(%&'( 09&7$ 3B0'A*( %' $B* :%+* (*+I%3* '**4 $& 3&'(%4*+ $B* .0+A* '7/9*+N0'4 I0+%09.* 3B0+03$*+%($%3(O &: $B* 4%::*+*'$ :%+* 0A*'3%*( 0'4 03S'&5.*4A* $B*3B0..*'A*( $& *'03$%'A 3B0'A*6

8B*+* 0+* 3&I*+0A* 4%::*+*'$%0.( 03+&(( $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^ 5%$B

$B* 2%$1 0'4 %''*+ +%'A (797+9( 3.&(*+ $& :%+* +*(#&'(* +*(&7+3*( $B0' $B* *Q]7+90'0+*0( &' $B* 2&7'$1X( &7$(S%+$(6


30/83

27


31/83

28

KE)M -)"8M28E"_a ?WCCH)j "K HP8M)_H8EfM?

"#$%&'( +0'A* :+&/ .&30. /&4*.( %' 5B%3B /7.$%#.* (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+( 3&I*+ (/0..*+A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0(^ &:$*' 0 (%'A.* /7'%3%#0.%$1 &+ #&+$%&'( &: 0 (%'A.* /7'%3%#0.%$1^ $&+*A%&'0. /&4*.( %' 5B%3B (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 %( 3&'(&.%40$*4 03+&(( /0'1 &+ 0.. /7'%3%#0.%$%*(%' $B* +*A%&'6 E' $B* /%44.* &: $B* +0'A* 0+* %'$*+/7'%3%#0. b B19+%4 /&4*.( 5B*+* /7.$%#.*/7'%3%#0.%$%*( (B0+* $B* :7'3$%&' %' 0' *::&+$ $& A*'*+0$* *3&'&/%*( &: (30.* 0'4 #+&473**::%3%*'3%*( $B+&7AB B%AB*+ 30.. I&.7/*6

C'6-% K+ N'($%

8B* .&30. /&4*. 3B0+03$*+%d*( $B* 37++*'$ 0##+&03B $& :%+* #+&$*3$%&' %' "'&'40A02&7'$16 K%:$1](*I*' 4%::*+*'$ :%+* #+&$*3$%&' 0A*'3%*( (*+I* $B* 2&7'$1^ *03B 5%$B #+%/0+1

g7+%(4%3$%&' &I*+ 0 (/0.. A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0 3&'(%($%'A &: &'* 3%$1 &+ I%..0A*^ &+ 0 #&+$%&' &:&'* $&5'6 C0'1 &: $B*(* 0A*'3%*( 0+* *+0$*4 &7$(%4* &: $B* A*'*+0. /7'%3%#0.A&I*+'/*'$( c %' :03$^


32/83

29

C'6-% I+ dB@0)6 b A5@Q9-4)'*$% '0 #'%%$@'0$&)F-

U*$5**' $B* .&30. 0'4 +*A%&'0. /&4*.( 0+* *Q0/#.*( &: 3&//7'%$%*( 5B*+* +*($+73$7+%'A&+ /*+A*+ B0( +*(7.$*4 %' '*5 #+&I%4*+ 3&/9%'0$%&'( (*+I%'A /7.$%#.* 3&//7'%$%*(6 E'_*5 j&+S^ $B%( B0( A*'*+0..1 9**' $B* +*(7.$ &: :%+* 4%($+%3$ 3&'(&.%40$%&' &+ g&%'$

3&'$+03$%'A 5%$B 0 (%'A.* (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+6

W'4*+ ($0$* .05^ $B* /&($ 3&//&' +*(7.$ &: 0 3&'(&.%40$%&' &+ /*+A*+ %( *%$B*+ 0 Zg&%'$ :%+*4%($+%3$[ &+ 0 '*5 :%+* 4%($+%3$ 5%$B .0+A*+ 9&+4*+(6 H.$B&7AB $B* A&I*+'0'3* &: $B* $5& %((.%AB$.1 4%::*+*'$^ $B* +*(7.$ %( 0 (#*3%0. #7+#&(* A&I*+'/*'$0. 7'%$ #+&I%4%'A (*+I%3*( $& 0(.%AB$.1 .0+A*+ 0+*06 8&5'( 30' 0.(& *'09.* $B* *Q#0'(%&' &: 0 :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$X( $*++%$&+191 3B0'A%'A B&5 $B*1 3&'$+03$ 5%$B :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( $& #+&I%4* (*+I%3*( $& $B*%+ :%+*#+&$*3$%&' 4%($+%3$(6 8&5'( 30' 04g7($ $B*%+ 3&'$+03$( (& $B0$ %'4%I%470. 4*#0+$/*'$( B0I*.0+A*+ (*+I%3* 0+*0(6

C'6-% V+ #'5*&BP)6- '0 9-4)'*$%

W'4*+ $B* +*A%&'0. /&4*.^ 0 9%AA*+ A*&A+0#B%3 0+*0 %( (*+I%3*4 $B+&7AB 0 (%'A.* 7'%:%*4#+&I%4*+6

f0+%0$%&' Ha C&4*.( %' 5B%3B 0 (%'A.* A&I*+'/*'$ (*+I*( *((*'$%0..1 0( $B* *Q3.7(%I* :%+*(*+I%3* #+&I%4*+ %' $B* *'$%+* 3&7'$16 DB%.* $B%( /&4*. %( (**' %' _*5 j&+S 2%$1^ %$ %( 0.(&:&7'4 %' /0'1 0+*0( &: $B* 3&7'$+1 &7$(%4* &: $B* _&+$B*0($ 0'4 C%45*($6 E$ %( 3&//&' $&:%'4 :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( 3&I*+%'A *'$%+* 3&7'$%*( %' K.&+%40^ 20.%:&+'%0^ f%+A%'%0 0'4 C0+1.0'46

"'* (73B 3&7'$1 5%$B 3&/#0+09.* (%d* $& "'&'40A0 %( U+*I0+4 2&7'$1 &' $B* *0($ 3&0($&: K.&+%406 U+*I0+4 2&7'$1 K%+* )*(37* (55569+*I0+43&7'$167(bK%+*)*(37*O #+&I%4*( :%+*0'4 MC? $+0'(#&+$ (*+I%3*( :&+ 0 3&7'$1 &: 09&7$ =


33/83

30

($0$%&'( 0+* &5'*4 91 (*#0+0$* I&.7'$**+ 4*#0+$/*'$( 5B%.* &$B*+( 0+* &5'*4 91$B* 2&7'$16 8B* I&.7'$**+( /0%'$0%' $B*%+ Z9+0'4%'A[ &' /0'1 ($0$%&'(^ 7'%:&+/(0'4 0##0+0$7(6 @&5*I*+^ 0.. $7+' &7$ A*0+ %( &5'*4 91 $B* 2&7'$1 0'4 B0(3&'(%($*'$ /0+S%'A(l 0.. /*/9*+( N#0%4 &+ I&.7'$**+O '**4 $& /**$ 3&'(%($*'$$+0%'%'A ($0'40+4(l 0'4 0.. *+0$* 7'4*+ 0 (%'A.* 7'%:%*4 3&//0'4 ($+73$7+*6 H..*((*'$%0. :7'3$%&'( 0+* :7'4*4 $B+&7AB 2&7'$1 :7'4( 0'4 #0$%*'$ 9%..%'A(^ 5B%.* $B*I&.7'$**+ 4*#0+$/*'$( B0I* (*#0+0$* :7'4+0%(*+( $& (7##&+$ $B*%+ 03$%I%$%*(6 8B*2&7'$1 4*#0+$/*'$ #+&I%4*( 9&$B :%+* 0'4 MC? $+0'(#&+$ (*+I%3*(6 E' (7/^ $B%(/&4*. %( $B* +*(7.$ &: Z+*A%&'0.%d0$%&' 91 *I&.7$%&'[ 0( I&.7'$**+ 4*#0+$/*'$( B0I*(.&5.1 $7+'*4 $& $B* 2&7'$1 :&+ (7##&+$ &I*+ /0'1 4*304*( $& $B* #&%'$ 5B*+* $B*/0g&+%$1 &: (*+I%3*( 0+* #+&I%4*4 91 #0%4 ($0::^ 97$ I&.7'$**+( ($%.. #.01 0' %/#&+$0'$+&.*6 N5556:0%+:0Q3&7'$16A&Ib:+bO

2+3#"+"4)5#61 8B* 3%$1 0'4 (7++&7'4%'A C0+%&' 2&7'$1 /*+A*4 %' ;YRL 91 03$ &: $B*($0$* .*A%(.0$7+*6 M.*I*' Z%'3.74*4 $&5'([ $B0$ *Q%($*4 &7$(%4* $B* :&+/*+ 2%$1 &:E'4%0'0#&.%( 5*+* #*+/%$$*4 $& +*$0%' (&/* 07$&'&/1 0'4 .&30. A&I*+'%'A b (*+I%3*

4*.%I*+1 +*(#&'(%9%.%$%*(6 ?&/* &: $B*(* $&5'( #+&I%4* $B*%+ &5' :%+* #+&$*3$%&'^5B%.* &$B*+( 3&'$+03$ 5%$B $B* E'4%0'0#&.%( K%+* T*#0+$/*'$6 8B* 3%$1 :%+*4*#0+$/*'$ &'.1 #+&I%4*( :%+* 0'4 +*(37* (*+I%3*(l MC? $+0'(#&+$ %( #*+:&+/*4 910 (*#0+0$* +*A%&'0. &+A0'%d0$%&'6 N5556%'416A&Ib*A&Ib3%$1b4#(b%:4bO


8B* -79.%3 ?0:*$1 2&//%$$** B0( 4*I*.*4 $B* :&..&5%'A #+*.%/%'0+1+*3&//*'40$%&'( +*A0+4%'A :%+* #+&$*3$%&'6 8B*(* B0I* '&$ 1*$ 9**' :&+/0..1 033*#$*491 $B* :7.. 2&//%((%&'6

*)&)$% A&-:2

"I*+ $B* '*Q$ G 1*0+(^ $B* :%+* (*+I%3* (B&7.4 3&'(%4*+ $B* :&..&5%'A ($*#( $B0$ 5%.. '&$+*i7%+* 0 (79($0'$%0. 3B0'A* %' $B*%+ *+0$%&'(a

;6 V+&7# (#*3%:%30$%&' 0'4 #7+3B0(%'A &: 0##0+0$7( 0'4 *i7%#/*'$ &' 03&7'$15%4* 90(%(6 E' #0+$%37.0+^ $7+'&7$ A*0+^ B&(*(^ ?2UH(^ +04%&( 0'43&/#7$*+( 3&7.4 0.. 9* #7+3B0(*4 %' 97.S 0$ 0 4%(3&7'$*4 #+%3* .*04%'A $&($0'40+4%d0$%&' 0'4 +*473*4 3&($(6 V+&7# (#*3%:%30$%&' 0'4 #7+3B0(%'A 3&7.4 9*


34/83

31

033&/#.%(B*4 7'4*+ *Q%($%'A &+A0'%d0$%&'0. ($+73$7+* 7(%'A "'&'40A0 2&7'$1T%I%(%&' &: -7+3B0(*6

F6 ?B0+* +*(&7+3*( :&+ $B* $+0%'%'A &: :%+*:%AB$%'A (S%..( %'3.74%'A $B* 3&'($+73$%&' &:#+( 0'4 4*I*./*'$ &: %'](*+I%3* *4730$%&'6 T*I*. ($+0$*A%30..1 .&30$*4

0'4 3*'$+0..1 /0'0A*4 $+0%'%'A :03%.%$%*( $& 0((%($ 9&$B #0%4 0'4 I&.7'$**+:%+*:%AB$*+( 4*I*. 0'4 /0%'$0%' $B*%+ (S%..(6

G6 T*I*. 3&//7'%$1 5%4* #*+:&+/0'3* /*0(7+*( :&+ +*(#&'4%'A $& */*+A*'3%*(^$+0%'%'A^ 0'4 +*3+7%$%'A 5%$B 0 ($0'40+4%d*4 /*$B&4 :&+ +*#&+$%'A $& $B*3&//7'%$16

6 2*'$+0..1 3&&+4%'0$* 0'4 :7'4 $B* #+&I%(%&' &: (#*3%0.%d*4 :%+* +*(#&'(* 0((*$((73B 0( B0d0+4&7( /0$*+%0.(^ 3&':%'*4 (#03*^ B%AB 0'A.*^ 0'4 $+*'3B +*(37*6?1+037(* K%+* T*#0+$/*'$ 0.+*041 #*+:&+/( /0'1 &: $B*(* :7'3$%&'(6

>*&-0;-6)$&- D:&)'*

E' &+4*+ $& %/#+&I* 3&&+4%'0$%&' &: (*+I%3* 0'4 044+*(( *(30.0$%'A 3&($( %' (*+I%3*#+&I%(%&'^ 0 /*$+&.%$0' :%+* 07$B&+%$1 (B&7.4 9* 3+*0$*46 8B%( 07$B&+%$1 5&7.4 B0I*3&//%((%&'*+( $B0$ +*#+*(*'$ $B* 4%I*+(* ($0S*B&.4*+( &: $B* :%+* (*+I%3* %'3.74%'A

*.*3$*4 &::%3%0.(^ &$B*+ A&I*+'/*'$ +*#+*(*'$0$%I*(^ I&.7'$**+ :%+*:%AB$*+(^ 0'4 30+**+:%+*:%AB$*+(6 -.0''%'A :&+ $B%( $%&' (B&7.4 9*A%' i7%3S.1^ 97$ %$ %( '&$ 0'$%3%#0$*4 $& $0S**::*3$ :&+ 0$ .*0($ :%I* $& (*I*' 1*0+(6

8B* 07$B&+%$1 5&7.4 (7##&+$ $B* *Q%($%'A (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+( $B+&7AB #+&I%4%'A04/%'%($+0$%I* (7##&+$^ .&'A $*+/ #.0''%'A^ 0'4 3&&+4%'0$%&' &: 30#%$0. *Q#*'(*(^+*3+7%$%'A 0'4 $+0%'%'A &: :%+*:%AB$*+(6 "'* &: $B* &9g*3$%I*( $B0$ 3&7.4 9* :03%.%$0$*4 91$B%( &+A0'%d0$%&' 5&7.4 9* $& +*473* $B* '7/9*+ &: (*#0+0$* A&I*+'/*'$ 0'4 $0Q%'A

g7+%(4%3$%&'( 0/&'A $B* 0A*'3%*( (*+I%'A *Q]7+90' #&+$%&'( &: $B* 3&7'$16 8B%( 3&7.4 9*033&/#.%(B*4 $B+&7AB 0 /*+A%'A &: :%+* 4%($+%3$( 0'4 b &+ $&5'( +*4+05%'A :%+* #+&$*3$%&'4%($+%3$ 9&7'40+%*( %' 0 501 $B0$ +*(7.$( %' 0 i704+0'$]$1#* 4%($+%3$ (1($*/ &7$(%4* $B*

2%$1 b %''*+ +%'A6

)*473%'A $B* '7/9*+ &: (*#0+0$* 4%($+%3$( 5&7.4 %/#+&I* 7#&' $5& %((7*(6 K%+($^ :*5*+4%($+%3$( +*473*( 30#%$0. b 0##0+0$7( '**4( N*6A6 .044*+ $+73S(O 91 #.0''%'A &I*+ 0 .0+A*+A*&A+0#B16


35/83

32

?*3&'4^ %$ 5&7.4 /%$%A0$* $B* 37++*'$ +*0.%$1 $B0$ +*(#&'(* +*(&7+3*( 0+* '&$ 0.501(*::*3$%I*.1 /0$3B*4 $& .&30$%&'l $B0$ %(^ &330(%&'0..1 $B* (1($*/ +*(#&'4( $& 30..( 5%$B(&/*$B%'A &$B*+ $B0' $B* 3.&(*($ +*(&7+3*^ (%/#.1 9*307(* &: $B* *Q$*'$ &: $*++%$&+%0.9&7'40+%*( 3+*0$*4 5B*' $B* 0+*0 50( (#0+(*.1 #.0$*46

_&$*a H( /73B 0( #&((%9.* 7'4*+ $B%( $%&'^ :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( (B&7.4 +*$0%' $B*%+37++*'$ '0/*( 0'4 ($0$%&'( $& 3&'$%'7* $& :&($*+ $+04%$%&' 0'4 3&//7'%$1 3&''*3$%&'6

N'*4Q9$*4- D:&)'*

DB%.* 3*+$0%' 4*#0+$/*'$( 0+* 0' *Q3*#$%&'^ /&($ I&.7'$**+ :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( 0+* :03%'A0 .&'A $*+/ 4*3+*0(* %' $B* '7/9*+ I&.7'$**+( 0'4 3&'(*i7*'$.1 /01 (&&' B0I*A+&5%'A 4%::%37.$1 %' +*(#&'4%'A $& */*+A*'3%*( 0##++%0$*.16 K&+ $B* /&+* 4*'(*.1#.0$*4^ 3&//*+3%0..1 4*I*.*4 (797+90' 0+*0( 04g03*'$ $& $B* 2%$1 &: ?1+037(*^ 0$+0'(%$%&' $& 0 #+*4&/%'0$*.1 30+**+^ 3*'$+0..1]/0'0A*4 /*$+&.%$0' 4*#0+$/*'$ 5&7.4

9* $B* 9*($ (&.7$%&'6 8B%( 0.$*+'0$%I* 5&7.4 '**4 $& 9* 3&($ *::*3$%I* 0'4 #+&I%4* 0$.*0($ $B* (0/* .*I*. &: (*+I%3* $& $B* 3&//7'%$%*(^ 5%$B '& 4*3+*0(* %' &9g*3$%I*#*+:&+/0'3* /*0(7+*(6 E' $B* &7$.1%'A 0+*0(^ $B* ($+0$*A%3 0..&30$%&' &: #0%4 +*(&7+3*(:+&/ $B* /*$+&.%$0' 4*#0+$/*'$ 5&7.4 07A/*'$ $B* *Q%($%'A I&.7'$**+ 4*#0+$/*'$(68B* .&'A $*+/ $%&' 5&7.4 9* 0' Z$]%'[ (1($*/ 5B*+*91 :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$( 3&7.43B&&(* $& g&%' 90(*4 &' $B*%+ 09%.%$1 $& (7($0%' $B*%+ 37++*'$ *+0$%&'(6 8B* Z$]%'[(1($*/ 5&7.4 :&37( &' *'(7+%'A (*+I%3*( %' 0+*0( 5B*+* I&.7'$**+( '**4 0((%($0'3*0'4 4*#0+$/*'$( 3&7.4 3B&&(* $& B0I* 0((%($0'3* &'.1 47+%'A 3*+$0%' #*+%&4( &: $B*4016

MCM)VM_2j CMTE2HP ?M)fE2M? NMC?O

M/*+A*'31 C*4%30. ?*+I%3*( %( 0 4%($%'3$ #79.%3 (0:*$1 (*+I%3* $B0$ %( #+&I%4*4 91 03&/9%'0$%&' &: 3&//*+3%0. 0/97.0'3* (*+I%3*(^ '&']#+&:%$ 3&/9%'0$%&' #0%4 b I&.7'$**+(*+I%3*( N%'3.74%'A :%+* 4*#0+$/*'$(O^ 0'4 3&/#.*$*.1 I&.7'$**+ (*+I%3*( N#+%/0+%.1 %' +7+0.0+*0(O6 8B* (1($*/ B0( 0.+*041 9**' *I&.I%'A %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^ $&0 #&%'$ 5B*+* +*/0+S09.1 :*5 30..( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 0+* 37++*'$.1B0'4.*4 91 #7+*.1 I&.7'$**+ &+A0'%d0$%&'(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

E' FL;G^ ;R 4%::*+*'$ MC? #+&I%4*+( +*(#&'4*4 $& RF^J;= MC? 30..( %' $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 8B%( 0/&7'$( $& FLL 30..( #*+ 401 0'4 09&7$ &'*30.. :&+ *I*+1 >6< +*(%4*'$(6 ?%Q$1 #*+3*'$ &: 30..( 5*+* 0'(5*+*4 91 )7+0. b C*$+&C*4%30. ?*+I%3*( 0'4 0'&$B*+ FLh 91 $B+** .0+A* '&']#+&:%$ 0/97.0'3* 3&/#0'%*(5%$B (79($0'$%0. #0%4 ($0::6

C&+* $B0' YLh &: MC? 30..( 5*+* 0'(5*+*4 91 0A*'3%*( $B0$ 9%.. :&+ (*+I%3* 0'4#01 0$ .*0($ 0 #&+$%&' &: $B*%+ ($0::6


36/83

33

_*0+.1 0.. 0A*'3%*( +*(#&'4 5%$B $B*%+ &5' 04I0'3*4 .%:* (7##&+$ N#0+0/*4%3(O &+B0I* 0++0'A*/*'$( :&+ $B0$ (*+I%3* :+&/ 0' %//*4%0$* '*%AB9&+6

H4I0'3*4 .%:* (7##&+$ %( #+*(*'$ %' 0.. 3&//7'%$%*(6

H (79($0'$%0. #0%4 ($0:: %( (#+*04 $B+&7AB&7$ $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1^5%$B /&($ &: $B*/ 9*%'A #7+*.1 MC? #+&:*((%&'0.( */#.&1*4 91 #+%I0$*&+A0'%d0$%&'( N'&']#+&:%$ 0'4 3&//*+3%0.O6 8B* +*/0%'4*+ 0+* 470. MC8]:%+*:%AB$*+( */#.&1*4 91 /7'%3%#0.%$%*(^ 5B%3B 0+* /&+* *Q#*'(%I* $B0' (%'A.*#7+#&(* */#.&1**(6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

E' A*'*+0.^ $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 B0( 0 +*.0$%I*.1 +0#%4 +*(#&'(*:+&/ i70.%:%*4 #+&I%4*+(6 @&5*I*+^ 044%$%&'0. 3&&+4%'0$%&' &: +*(&7+3*( 0'4 &$B*+&+A0'%d0$%&'0. 3B0'A*( 3&7.4 .*04 $& %/#+&I*4 (*+I%3*(6

?*+I%3* .*I*.( %' $B* 2%$1 0'4 #&3S*$( &: $B* %''*+ (797+9( /**$ $B* *Q#*3$0$%&'(&: $B* 3&//7'%$%*( 0'4 0+* 3.&(* $& %'47($+1 B%AB #*+:&+/0'3* $0+A*$(6 8B* A&0.(B&7.4 9* $& A*$ JLh &: $B* $&$0. #.0$%&' 7# $& 0 ZB%AB[ .*I*. &: (*+I%3*^ +0$B*+$B0' g7($ B0I%'A B%AB (*+I%3* %' (#*3%:%3 #&3S*$( &: $B* 3&7'$1 N*6A6 2%$1^K01*$$*I%..*^ #&+$%&'( &: 2.01 0'4 T*5%$$^ M0($ ?1+037(*O6 8B*+* 0+* 3&I*+0A*3B0..*'A*( %' /&+* +7+0. 0+*0( 5B*+* .%/%$*4 30.. I&.7/*( /0S* B%AB (*+I%3* .*I*.(.*(( *3&'&/%30..1 I%09.*6

H9(*'3* &: 41'0/%3 #&(%$%&'%'A &: 0/97.0'3*( 0'4 #*+(&''*. +*(&7+3*( +*473*((1($*/ *::%3%*'316

8*++%$&+%0. 9&7'40+%*( +*#+*(*'$ 0 +*0. %'*::%3%*'316 ?$0$* #79.%3 @*0.$B .05#+&B%9%$( 0A*'3%*( :+&/ (B0+%'A +*(&7+3*( 03+&(( $B*(* 9&7'40+%*( #+%&+ $& $B*+*9*%'A 0 30.. +*i7*($^ (& $B* /&+* $*++%$&+%0. 9&7'40+%*( $B0$ *Q%($^ $B* .&5*+ $B**::%3%*'31 b *::*3$%I*'*(( &: $B* (1($*/6 )*473%'A $B* '7/9*+ &: 9&7'40+%*( 5&7.41%*.4 0 /&+* *::%3%*'$ 4*#.&1/*'$ &: 0/97.0'3*( 0'4 #*+(&''*.6 ?#*3%:%30..1^ :*5*+9&7'40+%*( 5&7.4 0..&5 :&+ /&+* 41'0/%3 #&(%$%&'%'A &: +*(&7+3*( 0'4 +*473*+*(#&'(* $%/*(6

8B*+* %( '& 3*'$+0. /*0(7+*/*'$ &: #*+:&+/0'3* %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$1 :&+ S*1 %'4%30$&+( (73B 0( 0##++%0$*'*(( &: 30+*^ (7+I%I0. +0$*(^$+0'(#&+$ $& 3&++*3$ :03%.%$%*( &+ 3&($ &: *+0$%&'6

8B*+* %( '& +*.%09.* 40$0 &' MC? 5&+S:&+3* %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1%'3.74%'A #01 +0$*(^ .*I*. &: 3*+$%:%30$%&'^ B&7+( 5&+S*4 b I&.7'$**+*4 0'4 $B*0A*'3%*( $B0$ I&.7'$**+( 5&+S :&+ %' $B* 3&//7'%$16

H'*34&$0..1^ $B*+* 0+* :*5*+ MC? I&.7'$**+( $B0' g7($ 0 :*5 1*0+( 0A& 0'4 $B**Q%($%'A #0%4 5&+S:&+3* %( (#+*04 $B%'.1 03+&(( /7.$%#.* 0A*'3%*(^ 5%$B $B* /0g&+%$1&: */#.&1**( 5&+S%'A :&+ /7.$%#.* &+A0'%d0$%&'(6


37/83

34


8B* -79.%3 ?0:*$1 2&//%$$** B0( 4*I*.*4 $B* :&..&5%'A #+*.%/%'0+1

+*3&//*'40$%&'( +*A0+4%'A */*+A*'31 /*4%30. (*+I%3*(6 8B*(* B0I* '&$ 1*$ 9**':&+/0..1 033*#$*4 91 $B* :7.. 2&//%((%&'6


38/83

35

P HD M_K")2MCM_8

8B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 %( (*+I*4 91 ;= .&30. .05 *':&+3*/*'$ 0A*'3%*( $B0$(#0' $5& .*I*.( &: A&I*+'/*'$a 8B* 2&7'$1^ $B+&7AB $B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 ?B*+%::X(

"::%3*^ 0'4 $B&(* /7'%3%#0.%$%*( 5B%3B /0%'$0%' 0'4 :7'4 $B*%+ &5' #&.%3* 4*#0+$/*'$(6 H/&'A $B* /7'%3%#0. 0A*'3%*(^ $B* 2%$1 &: ?1+037(* -&.%3* T*#0+$/*'$ %( $B* .0+A*($ %':&+3* (%d*^ 974A*$ 0'4 30.. I&.7/*6

8B* 033&/#0'1%'A /0# %..7($+0$*( $B* 4%($+%97$%&' &: #&.%3* 4*#0+$/*'$( $B+&7AB&7$ $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 H.$B&7AB $B* 2&7'$1 ?B*+%::X( "::%3* $*3B'%30..1 B0(3&7'$15%4* g7+%(4%3$%&'^ %$ (*+I*( 0( $B* #+%/0+1 .05 *':&+3*/*'$ 0A*'31 &'.1 %' $B&(*.&30.%$%*( '&$ &$B*+5%(* 3&I*+*4 91 $B*%+ &5' /7'%3%#0. 4*#0+$/*'$ N%' $B* /0#^ $B&(*0+*0( (B04*4 %' .%AB$ A+01O6 E'3.74%'A $B* 2%$1 &: ?1+037(*^ $B*+* 0+* :&7+$**' (73B/7'%3%#0. 4*#0+$/*'$(^ 3&'3*'$+0$*4 A*'*+0..1 %' $B* '&+$B*+' B0.: &: $B* 2&7'$1 N%' $B*/0#^ $B&(* 0+*0( (B04*4 %' 3&.&+O6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

E' FL;G^ 0'4 %'3.74%'A $B* ?$0$* -&.%3*^ ;R 4%::*+*'$ .05 *':&+3*/*'$ 0A*'3%*(R +*(#&'4*4 $& < 30..( :&+ (*+I%3* %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 8B%(0/&7'$( $& 0' 0I*+0A* &: ;^;;R 30..( #*+ 401 0'4 09&7$ JRL 30..( #*+ $B&7(0'4+*(%4*'$(6

U0(*4 &' 30..( :&+ (*+I%3*^ $B* ?1+037(* -&.%3* T*#0+$/*'$^ "'&'40A0 2&7'$1?B*+%:: 0'4 _*5 j&+S ?$0$* -&.%3* 5*+* $B* $ G 97(%*($ 0A*'3%*(6 8B*1033&7'$*4 :&+ +&7AB.1 $5&]$B%+4( &: 0.. 30..( :&+ (*+I%3* 0'4 (*+I*4 /&+* $B0' >Lh&: $B* 3&7'$1X( #.0$%&' 0( #+%/0+1 +*(#&'4*+ :&+ .05 *':&+3*/*'$ 30..( :&+

(*+I%3*6

8B* $&$0. *Q#*'(* :&+ .05 *':&+3*/*'$ N*Q3.74%'A ?$0$* -&.%3*O 50( &I*+ nJJ/%..%&' &+ 09&7$ n;JJ #*+ 30#%$0 %' FL;G6

f%..0A* 0'4 $&5' #&.%3* &::%3%0.( %'$*+I%*5*4 %' $B* 3&7+(* &: $B* #+&g*3$ +*#&+$ $B0$$B*%+ +0#%4 +*(#&'(* $%/* 0'4 4*$0%.*4 S'&5.*4A* &: $B* 3&//7'%$1 0+* I0.7*4 91+*(%4*'$( 0'4 5&+$B $B* 044%$%&'0. 3&($6 H.. +*(%4*'$( %' $B* 2&7'$1 #01 $0Q*( :&+9&$B $B* ?B*+%::X( "::%3* 0'4 ?$0$* -&.%3*l %'4%I%470. /7'%3%#0. #&.%3* 4*#0+$/*'$(0+* #+*+$1 $0Q :7'4*4 %' 044%$%&' $& #01%'A :&+ $B*(* $5& (*+I%3*(6

E' /0'1 0+*0( $B* 4%::*+*'$ 0A*'3%*( 5&+S 5*.. $&A*$B*+ $B+&7AB 9&$B :&+/0. 0'4%':&+/0. 0++0'A*/*'$(6 ?&/* *Q0/#.*( %'3.74* g&%'$ $+0%'%'A^ 3+%/%'0. %'I*($%A0$%I*

R 8B*+* 0+* (*I*+0. &$B*+ .05 *':&+3*/*'$ 0A*'3%*( $B0$ (*+I* (#*3%:%3 .&30$%&'( (73B 0( $B* ?1+037(*

W'%I*+(%$1 -79.%3 ?0:*$1 T*#0+$/*'$ 0'4 $B* "'&'40A0 2&//7'%$1 2&..*A* -79.%3 ?0:*$1 T*#0+$/*'$ $B0$0+* *Q3.74*4 :+&/ $B* +*#&+$ 9*307(* $B*1 #+%/0+%.1 (*+I* &'.1 0 (#*3%:%3 (/0.. 0+*0 0'4 4& '&$ +&7$%'*.1+*(#&'4 $& Y;; 30..(6 8B*1 0+* 0' %/#&+$0'$ #0+$ &: .05 *':&+3*/*'$ %' $B* 3&//7'%$1^ 97$ $B*%++*(#&'(%9%.%$%*( 5&7.4 '&$ 3B0'A* 90(*4 &' +*#&+$ +*3&//*'40$%&'(6


39/83

36

$0(S :&+3*(^ 7(%'A $B* 3.&(*($ +*(&7+3* :&+ (*+%&7( 30..( 0'4 %':&+/0$%&' (B0+%'A6"$B*+ (#*3%:%3 *+0$%&'0. *Q0/#.*( %'3.74* $B* 0I0%.09%.%$1 &: H%+ "'* $& 0..0A*'3%*(^ g&%'$ $+0%'%'A :&+ $03$%30. $*0/(^ 0'4 3&&+4%'0$*4 $+0::%3 (0:*$1 0'4*':&+3*/*'$ 30/#0%A'( (73B 0( U73S.* W# 0'4 ?$]TDE6

H.. .05 *':&+3*/*'$ 0A*'3%*( 0+* 4%(#0$3B*4 $B+&7AB $B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 Y;;2*'$*+^ 0'4 0.. .05 *':&+3*/*'$ I*B%3.*( B0I* 07$&/0$%3 I*B%3.* .&30$&+$*3B'&.&A16 8B%( $*3B'&.&A1 5&+S( %' #0+0..*. 5%$B 3&/#7$*+ 0%4*4 4%(#0$3B%'A 0'40 /7$70. 0((%($0'3* 0A+**/*'$ $& *'(7+* $B0$ $B* 3.&(*($ #&.%3* 0A*'31 %(4%(#0$3B*4 $& B%AB #+%&+%$1 30..(6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 D::'0&5*)&)-2

8B* $&$0. '7/9*+ &: (5&+' &::%3*+( %' $B* 3&//7'%$1 B0( 4*3+*0(*4 91 ;Lh^ &+;LF &::%3*+(^ :+&/ FLLR6 8B* 2%$1X( :&+3* B0( (B+7'S 91 R6Jh^ &+ GJ &::%3*+( &I*+$B* (0/* #*+%&46 8B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 ?B*+%:: B0( .&($ ;;6Fh^ &+ FY &::%3*+(6 8B*

$&$0. .&(( &: &::%3*+( :&+ *I*+1 &$B*+ 4*#0+$/*'$ %' $B* 3&//7'%$1 50( ;G6


40/83

37

K*4*+0..1 +*#&+$*4 (*+%&7( 3+%/* 40$0 :&+ $B* .0($ F= 1*0+( (B&5( $B0$ $B* +0$* &:+*#&+$*4 #+*+$1 3+%/* B0( 4*3+*0(*4 (79($0'$%0..1 %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$16 8B* 0/&7'$ &: (*+%&7( 3+%/* +*#&+$*4 %(^ &' 0I*+0A*^


41/83

38

8B* '7/9*+ &: +*#&+$*4 I%&.*'$ 3+%/*( %' ?1+037(* B0( 4+#*4 %' $B* .0($ (*I*+0.1*0+( :+&/ $B* .&'A $*+/ 0I*+0A* &: 09&7$ ;^


42/83

39

8B* 3&($ &: #+&I%4%'A .05 *':&+3*/*'$ %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$13&'$%'7*( $& 3.%/9 0$ 0 ($*041 +0$* B%AB*+ $B0' %':.0$%&'6

?*I*+0. &: $B* %'$*+I%*5*4 &::%3%0.( %'4%30$*4 $B0$ 0 +%(* %' 3+%/* 3&//%$$*4 911&7'A*+ %'4%I%470.(^ 0'4 #0+$%37.0+.1 91 A0'A /*/9*+(^ %( 0 3&'3*+'6 8B* *'$%+*3&//7'%$1 '**4( $& 5&+S $& +*473* #&I*+$1^ %/#+&I* *4730$%&' 0'4 #+&I%4* 0#0$B501 0501 :+&/ 3+%/%'0. 9*B0I%&+6


43/83

40


44/83

41


8B* -79.%3 ?0:*$1 2&//%$$** B0( 4*I*.*4 $B* :&..&5%'A #+*.%/%'0+1

+*3&//*'40$%&'( +*A0+4%'A .05 *':&+3*/*'$ (*+I%3*(6 8B*(* B0I* '&$ 1*$ 9**':&+/0..1 033*#$*4 91 $B* :7.. 2&//%((%&'6


45/83

42

2"))M28E"_?

8B* 2&7'$1 %( *Q3.7(%I*.1 +*(#&'(%9.* :&+ #+&I%4%'A 0'4 04/%'%($*+%'A 3&++*3$%&'( 0'4%'30+3*+0$%&'( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 @&5*I*+^ $B*+* 0+* %'*::%3%*'3%*(

3+*0$*4 91 $B* 2&7'$1X( *+0$%&' &: $5& (*#0+0$* 3&++*3$%&'( 4*#0+$/*'$( c &'* 91 $B*?B*+%:: :&+ #+%(&'*+( $B0$ B0I* '&$ 1*$ 9**' (*'$*'3*4^ 0'4 &'* 91 $B* T*#0+$/*'$ &:2&++*3$%&'( :&+ #+%(&'*+( $B0$ B0I* 9**' (*'$*'3*46 "'&'40A0 %( $B* &'.1 _*5 j&+S3&7'$1 $B0$ B0( '&$ 7'%:%*4 %$( #+%(&' *+0$%&'(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

K&+ FL;G^ $B* 0I*+0A* 40%.1 3*'(7( &: $B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 `7($%3* 2*'$*+^ *+0$*491 $B* ?B*+%::^ 50( >;


46/83

43


8B* -79.%3 ?0:*$1 2&//%$$** B0( 4*I*.*4 $B* :&..&5%'A #+*.%/%'0+1

+*3&//*'40$%&'( +*A0+4%'A 3&++*3$%&'( (*+I%3*(6 8B*(* B0I* '&$ 1*$ 9**' :&+/0..1033*#$*4 91 $B* :7.. 2&//%((%&'6


47/83

44

C7'%3%#0. "#*+0$%&'(

8B* C7'%3%#0. "#*+0$%&'( 2&//%$$** :&37(*4 &' $B&(* (*+I%3* 0+*0( $B0$ 5*+* '*%$B*+%':+0($+73$7+* '&+ #79.%3 (0:*$1 +*.0$*4^ %'3.74%'Aa

80Q H((*((/*'$lK%'0'3%0. H4/%'%($+0$%&'l2&7+$(l2&4* M':&+3*/*'$l2.*+Sl?&3%0. ?*+I%3*( 0'4 @*0.$Bl 0'4P%9+0+%*(6

8 Hq H??M??CM_8

-+*+$1 $0Q*( 0+* 0 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ +*I*'7* (&7+3* :&+ .&30. A&I*+'/*'$(6 H( 0+*(7.$^ 0' *::*3$%I* 0'4 *i7%$09.* $0Q 0((*((/*'$ (1($*/ %( $B* 90(%( :&+ :7'4%'A/7'%3%#0. A&I*+'/*'$ 0'4 $B* (*+I%3*( %$ #+&I%4*(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

8B*+* 0+* ;R (*#0+0$* $0Q 0((*((/*'$ 7'%$( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$1^ %'3.74%'A $B* 2%$1 0'4 ;> $&5']90(*4 #+&I%4*+(6

8B*+* 0+* 9+&04 (30.* 4%::*+*'3*( %' $B* g7+%(4%3$%&' &: $B*(* 0A*'3%*(6 8B* .0+A*($%( $B* 2%$1^ 5B%3B /0%'$0%'( 0((*((/*'$( &' /&+* $B0'


48/83

45

8B*+* 0+* .0+A* (30.* 4%::*+*'3*( 03+&(( $B* 0((*((/*'$ 7'%$(a M%AB$ 7'%$( B0'4.*/&+* $B0' ;L^LLL #+*+$%*( *03B^ 5B%.* :%I* 7'%$( B0'4.* :*5*+ $B0' G^LLL#+*+$%*( *03B6

8B* $*3B'%30. *Q#*+$%(* +*i7%+*4 $& 04/%'%($*+ 0337+0$*^ *i7%$09.* 0((*((/*'$( %(

%' .%/%$*4 (7##.1^ 3+*0$%'A (733*((%&' 3B0..*'A*( 9*1&'4 $B* 37++*'$ A+&7# &:0((*((&+( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16

80Q 3*+$%&+0+% .05(7%$ 4*:*'(* %( 3&($.1 0'4 30' 3+*0$* (79($0'$%0. 97+4*'( :&+(/0..*+ /7'%3%#0.%$%*(6

8B*+* %( 0 ($0$%($%30. 3&++*.0$%&' 9*$5**' (30.* &: 0((*((%'A 7'%$( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 0'4 $B*%+ 7'%$ 3&($(^ 5%$B $B&(* (*+I%'A 0 B%AB*+ '7/9*+ &:#0+3*.( $*'4%'A $& B0I* .&5*+ 7'%$ 3&($(^ 0( (B&5' %' $B* :&..&5%'A A+0#B6


49/83

46

KE_H_2EHP HTCE_E?8)H8E"_

H ($+&'A :%'0'3%0. 04/%'%($+0$%&' :7'3$%&' %( 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ $& #+74*'$ :%(30./0'0A*/*'$ %' .&30. A&I*+'/*'$^ *(#*3%0..1 %' .%AB$ &: $B* 974A*$0+1 3B0..*'A*(/7'%3%#0.%$%*( %'3+*0(%'A.1 :03*6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

K%'0'3%0. 04/%'%($+0$%&' %( 4%(0AA+*A0$*4 03+&(( $B* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( &: $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 MI*+1 A*'*+0. #7+#&(* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$ B0( 0

$+*0(7+*+^ 974A*$ &::%3*+ 0'4 b &+ :%'0'3* 4*#0+$/*'$ $& 04/%'%($*+ %$( :%'0'3%0./0'0A*/*'$ +*(#&'(%9%.%$%*(6

8B* (%d*^ 3&($ 0'4 30#03%$1 &: $B* :7'3$%&' I0+%*(^ 5%$B $B* .0+A*($]974A*$A&I*+'/*'$( $*'4%'A $& B0I* $B* A+*0$*($ %'I*($/*'$ %' :%'0'3%0. 04/%'%($+0$%&'6 E'(/0..*+ A&I*+'/*'$(^ $B* 974A*$ &::%3*+ +*(#&'(%9%.%$1 %( 9&+'* 91 $B* $&5'(7#*+I%(&+ &+ I%..0A* /01&+X( &::%3*^ 5%$B %'#7$ :+&/ 4*#0+$/*'$ B*04( 5B& &I*+(**


50/83

47

(#*3%:%3 :7'3$%&'0. 0+*0(l %' .0+A*+ A&I*+'/*'$(^ $B* :7'3$%&' %( $1#%30..1 0 (*#0+0$*4*#0+$/*'$6

E' $B* 2&7'$1^ $B* K%'0'3* T*#0+$/*'$ (*+I*( $B* :%'0'3%0. /0'0A*/*'$ +&.*6 H44%$%&'0..1^ $B* 2&7'$1 B0( 0 (*#0+0$*.1]*.*3$*4 2&/#$+&..*+ 3B0+A*4 5%$B

%'4*#*'4*'$.1 &I*+(**%'A :%'0'3* 0'4 074%$ :7'3$%&'( 03+&(( 2&7'$1 A&I*+'/*'$6

8B* Z3B*3S 0'4 90.0'3*[ +&.* &: :%'0'3%0. 04/%'%($+0$%&' /0S*( (&/* .*I*. &: .&30.&I*+(%AB$ %/#&+$0'$6

8*3B'&.&A%30. 30#03%$1 c %/#&+$0'$ :&+ :%'0'3%0. /0'0A*/*'$ A*'*+0..1 0'4 $B*40$0 $B0$ (7##&+$( %$ c I0+%*( 03+&(( .&30. A&I*+'/*'$(6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

8B*+* %( '& ($0'40+4 :%'0'3%0. (&:$50+* (1($*/ %' 7(* 03+&(( $B* .&30.

A&I*+'/*'$( &: $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16

-+&37+*/*'$ #+&3*((*( 0+* B0'4.*4 (*#0+0$*.1 91 *03B .&30. A&I*+'/*'$^ *Q3*#$:&+ &330(%&'0. #+&37+*/*'$ &:: ?$0$* &+ 2&7'$1 9%4( N0'4 5%$B $B* *Q3*#$%&' &: $B*2&7'$1^ 2%$1 0'4 2%$1 ?3B&&. T%($+%3$X( g&%'$ #+&37+*/*'$ :+0/*5&+SO6

8B*+* %( .%/%$*4 %':&+/0$%&' $*3B'&.&A1 30#03%$1 %' (&/* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$(^*(#*3%0..1 (/0..*+ /7'%3%#0.%$%*( 5B*+* $B* %'I*($/*'$ /01 9* 3&($ #+&B%9%$%I*6

2"W)8?

8B* &+A0'%d0$%&' &: _*5 j&+S ?$0$*X( 3&7+$ (1($*/ +*(7.$( %' 4%::*+*'$ .*I*.( &: .&30.A&I*+'/*'$ B0I%'A /0+S*4.1 4%::*+*'$ +*(#&'(%9%.%$%*(6 H$ $B* $&5' 0'4 I%..0A* .*I*.^.&30..1]:7'4*4 g7($%3* 3&7+$( B0'4.* 0 +0'A* &: 3+%/%'0. #+&3**4%'A( %'3.74%'A :*.&'%*(^/%(4*/*0'&+( b I%&.0$%&'( 0'4 $+0::%3 %':+03$%&'(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

8B*+* 0+* ;Y $&5' 3&7+$( 0'4 Y I%..0A* 3&7+$(^ 0.. &: 5B%3B 0+* .&30..1]:7'4*46?*#0+0$* 2%$1 0'4 2&7'$1 3&7+$( 0+* ($0$*]:7'4*46

8&$0. g74%3%0. 3&($( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 $&$0.*4 '*0+.1 n;J6G/%..%&' %' FL;G6 2&7'$1 3&($(^ 5B%3B 0.(& %'3.74*4 ($0$*]/0'40$*4 :7'3$%&'( (73B0( 4%($+%3$ 0$$&+'*1 0'4 #79.%3 4*:*'4*+^ 033&7'$*4 :&+ JLhl $&5' 0'4 I%..0A* 3&($(033&7'$*4 :&+ ;Rh &: $B* $&$0.6

MI*+1 $&5' A&I*+'/*'$ %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 *+0$*( %$( &5'3&7+$^ 5B%.* Y &: $B* :%:$**' I%..0A*( 4& (&6 K&+ $B&(* > I%..0A*( $B0$ 4& '&$ /0%'$0%'$B*%+ &5' 3&7+$^ #+&3**4%'A( 0+* B0'4.*4 91 $B* (7++&7'4%'A $&5'X( 3&7+$6


51/83

48

8&5' 0'4 I%..0A* g7($%3* 3&7+$( 4& A*'*+0$* (&/* +*I*'7* $& &::(*$ 0 #&+$%&' &:$B*%+ .&30. 3&($ 97+4*'6 8B* '*$ /7'%3%#0. (B0+* N0:$*+ ?$0$* 0'4 2&7'$1 :**( 0+*0((*((*4O &: 3&7+$ +*I*'7*( A*'*+0$*4 %' FL;G +0'A*4 :+&/ 0 B%AB &: n;6L /%..%&'$& 0 .&5 &: .*(( $B0' n;L^LLL6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

8B*+* %( .%/%$*4 %'$*+/7'%3%#0. (B0+%'A &: 04/%'%($+0$%I* 30#03%$1^ g7($%3*( &+:03%.%$%*( 0$ $B* #+*(*'$ $%/*6

_j? W'%:&+/ `7($%3* 2&7+$ H3$^ ?*3$%&' ;L>]0^ 07$B&+%d*( $5& &+ /&+* 3&'$%A7&7($&5'( $& (B0+* 0 3&7+$6

H4*i70$* :03%.%$%*( 0+* 0 +*0. 0'4 A+&5%'A 3&'3*+' :&+ /0'1 g7($%3* 3&7+$(6

8&5' 0'4 I%..0A* 3&7+$( 4& A*'*+0$* (&/* +*I*'7* $B+&7AB :%'*( 0'4 :**(^ 97$

/&($ +7' 0 Z4*:%3%$[ 5%$B .&30. $0Q#01*+( :7'4%'A $B* 4%::*+*'3*6 8B* 0I*+0A* 4*:%3%$03+&(( 0.. $&5' 0'4 I%..0A* g7($%3* 3&7+$( %' FL;G 50( 0##+&Q%/0$*.1 n=


52/83

49


53/83

50


54/83

51


55/83

52

2"TM M_K")2MCM_8

2&4* *':&+3*/*'$^ 5B%3B %( 3+%$%30..1 %/#&+$0'$ $& *'(7+%'A $B* B*0.$B 0'4 5*..]9*%'A &:#*+(&'( 0'4 #+*+$1^ %'I&.I*( $B* %'I*($%A0$%&' 0'4 *':&+3*/*'$ &: ?$0$* .05( 0'4 .&30.&+4%'0'3*( #*+$0%'%'A $& 97%.4%'A ($0'40+4(^ #+*+$1 b .0'4 7(*^ 0'4 %/#&+$0'$ i70.%$1 &:.%:* /*0(7+*(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

_*0+.1 *I*+1 /7'%3%#0.%$1 %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 B0'4.*( %$( &5'3&4* *':&+3*/*'$^ $B&7AB $B*+* %( (&/* 3&..09&+0$%&' 9*$5**' $&5'( 0'4 $B*%+I%..0A*( N*6A6 8&5' &: M.9+%4A* 0'4 $B* f%..0A*( &: M.9+%4A* 0'4 `&+40'O6

2&4* *':&+3*/*'$ +*(#&'(%9%.%$%*( (#0' 9&$B $B* ?$0$* W'%:&+/ 2&4* N5B%3B %( $B*(0/* :&+ 0.. .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( *i70..1O 0'4 (#*3%:%3 #+&I%(%&'( &: $B* /7'%3%#0.3&4* N5B%3B %( 4%::*+*'$ 03+&(( /7'%3%#0.%$%*( 0'4 &:$*' +*:.*3$( 3*+$0%' i70.%$1 &:

.%:* /0$$*+( $B* .&30. 3&//7'%$1 50'$( $& :&37( %$( *':&+3*/*'$ *::&+$( &'O6 "'90.0'3*^ $B* ($0$*]*($09.%(B*4 W'%:&+/ 2&4* 3&I*+( 09&7$ YLh &: *':&+3*/*'$+*(#&'(%9%.%$%*(^ 5%$B .&30. &+4%'0'3*( +*#+*(*'$%'A $B* &$B*+ ;Lh6

_*%AB9&+%'A 3&//7'%$%*( 5%$B (%/%.0+ 4*I*./*'$ 4*'(%$1 0'4 .0'4 7(*( $*'4 $&B0I* 3&//&' 3&4* 0##+&03B*( 0'4 :03* (%/%.0+ *':&+3*/*'$ 3B0..*'A*(6

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

2&4* *':&+3*/*'$ *Q#*+$%(* 0'4 ($0:: 30#03%$1 %( .%/%$*4^ #0+$%37.0+.1 %' (/0..*+/7'%3%#0.%$%*( 5B*+* $B* :7'3$%&' %( .*(( $B0' :7..]$%/*6

8B* $*3B'%30. *Q#*+$%(* +*i7%+*4 $& %/#.*/*'$ *::*3$%I* 3&4* *':&+3*/*'$ %( %'.%/%$*4 (7##.1^ 3+*0$%'A (733*((%&' 3B0..*'A*( 9*1&'4 $B* 37++*'$ A+&7# &: 3&4**':&+3*/*'$ #*+(&''*. %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16

8B*+* 0+* 4%(#0+%$%*( %' $*3B'&.&A1 7$%.%d0$%&' :&+ +*3&+4 S**#%'A 03+&((/7'%3%#0.%$%*(6


56/83

53

2PM)k

":$*' $B* Z:03*[ &: /7'%3%#0. A&I*+'/*'$^ *I*+1 A*'*+0. #7+#&(* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$ B0( 03.*+S #&(%$%&'6 T7$%*( $1#%30..1 %'3.74* %'$*+:03%'A 5%$B $B* #79.%3 &' #*+/%$ 0'4 .%3*'(*0##.%30$%&'(^ 0'4 /0%'$0%'%'A $B* 9&&S(^ :%.*( 0'4 +*3&+4( &: .&30. A&I*+'/*'$6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

8B*+* 0+* G> (*#0+0$* /7'%3%#0. 3.*+S( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 c&'* %' *03B A*'*+0. #7+#&(* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$6 E' /0'1 30(*(^ $B&(* #&(%$%&'( 0+*(7##&+$*4 91 4*#7$1 3.*+S 0'4 b &+ 3.*+%30. #*+(&''*.6

E' $B* 2&7'$1^ $B* 3.*+S %( 0' *.*3$*4 #&(%$%&' %' 033&+40'3* 5%$B ?$0$* 2&7'$1P056 E' $B* 2%$1^ %$ %( 0' 0##&%'$*4 #&(%$%&' %' 033&+40'3* 5%$B $B* 2%$1 2B0+$*+6 E'$&5'(^ 3.*+S #&(%$%&'( 0+* 0./&($ 0.501( *.*3$*4^ #7+(70'$ $& ?$0$* 8&5' P05N0.$B&7AB (&/* $&5'( %' _*5 j&+S ?$0$* B0I* (&7AB$ $& 3&'I*+$ $B* #&(%$%&' $& 0'

0##&%'$*4 &'* %' +*3*'$ 1*0+(O6 E' I%..0A*(^ 3.*+S( 0+* 0##&%'$*4 91 $B* /01&+ 0'49&0+4^ %' 033&+40'3* 5%$B ?$0$* f%..0A* P056

#8$%%-*4-2 $*6 '::'0&5*)&)-2

H.$B&7AB #+&A+*(( B0( 9**' /04*^ .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A03&//7'%$1 0+* '&$ 1*$ /0S%'A $%/0. 7(* &: &'.%'* b *.*3$+&'%3 #&+$7'%$%*( :&+$B* :%.%'A 0'4 #*+/%$ #+&3*((%'A +*(#&'(%9%.%$%*( $B0$ 3.*+S &::%3*( A*'*+0..1 B0'4.*6

8B*+* %( 0 +0'A* &: %':&+/0$%&' $*3B'&.&A1 30#03%$1 %' #.03* 03+&(( 3.*+S &::%3*(^5%$B (&/* B0I%'A (%A'%:%30'$.1 /&+* +&97($ 30#09%.%$%*( $B0' &$B*+(6


57/83

54

?"2EHP ?M)fE2M? H_T @MHP8@

?&3%0. (*+I%3*( 0'4 #79.%3 b /*'$0. B*0.$B 0+* 0/&'A $B* .0+A*($ A&I*+'/*'$0. 3&($3*'$*+( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 H.$B&7AB /73B &: $B* #+&A+0//%'A %(4*$*+/%'*4 91 $B* ?$0$*^ $B* 2&7'$1 %( #+%/0+%.1 +*(#&'(%9.* :&+ 04/%'%($*+%'A 0'44*.%I*+%'A $B*(* :7'3$%&'(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

?&3%0. (*+I%3*( +*#+*(*'$( $B* (%'A.* .0+A*($ :7'3$%&'0. 3&($ 3*'$*+ 0/&'AA&I*+'/*'$( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$16 D%$B nF>R6> /%..%&' %' FL;G(#*'4%'A^ $B* :7'3$%&' *i70$*( $& 0##+&Q%/0$*.1 n=R; #*+ 30#%$06

-79.%3 B*0.$B :7'3$%&'( +*#+*(*'$ $B* :%:$B].0+A*($ .&30. A&I*+'/*'$ 3&($ 3*'$*+^ 0$n>>6= /%..%&' %' FL;G &+ n;


58/83

55

PEU)H)EM?

P%9+0+1 (*+I%3*( %' $B* ?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 0+* *((*'$%0..1 3&'(&.%40$*4 7'4*+$B* "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 -79.%3 P%9+0+1 N"2-PO6 8B* #+&473$ &: 0 ;YR> /*+A*+ &: $B*?1+037(* -79.%3 P%9+0+1 0'4 $B* '&'#+&:%$ "'&'40A0 P%9+0+1 ?1($*/^ "2-P %( &'* &: FG#79.%3 .%9+0+1 (1($*/( 3B0+$*+*4 91 $B* _*5 j&+S ?$0$* U&0+4 &: )*A*'$(6 E$ %(+*(#&'(%9.* :&+ #+&I%4%'A .%9+0+1 4*I*./*'$ 0'4 +*(&7+3* (B0+%'A (7##&+$ 03+&(( $B*(1($*/X( /*/9*+ .%9+0+%*(^ 0( 5*.. 0( 0' %'$*A+0$*4 +*3&+4( (1($*/ $B0$ .%'S( /*/9*+.%9+0+%*(6

,8$& P- 8$F- &'6$B

"2-P *+0$*( 0 2*'$+0. .%9+0+1 4&5'$&5'^ J 9+0'3B .%9+0+%*( 5%$B%' $B* 2%$1^ F(0$*..%$* .%9+0+%*( 0'4 ;F %'4*#*'4*'$ (797+90' /*/9*+ .%9+0+%*(6

8B* .%9+0+%*( 5%$B%' "2-P 0+* 0 I0+%*$1 &: 4%::*+*'$ $1#*(^ 5B%3B %/#03$( $B*%+

A&I*+'0'3* ($+73$7+* 0'4 :7'4%'A :+0/*5&+S6 8B* $1#*( %'3.74* #79.%3 (3B&&.4%($+%3$ .%9+0+%*(^ #79.%3 (#*3%0. .*A%(.0$%I* 4%($+%3$ .%9+0+%*(^ 0((&3%0$%&' .%9+0+%*( 0'4#79.%3 b /7'%3%#0. .%9+0+%*(6


59/83

56

?WCCH)j "K HP8M)_H8EfM?

E' +*I%*5%'A $B*(* :7'3$%&'0. 0+*0(^ $B* C7'%3%#0. "#*+0$%&'( 2&//%$$** *Q#.&+*4 0+0'A* &: (*+I%3* 4*.%I*+1 $%&'(6 E' A*'*+0.^ $B*+* %( 0 +0'A* &: 501( %' 5B%3B $B*(* .&30.

A&I*+'/*'$ (*+I%3*( 30' 9* #+&I%4*46 8B* 4%I*+(%$1 &: 0##+&03B*( %( *I%4*'$ %' $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 $&4016

H$ &'* *'4 &: $B* 3&'$%'77/ 0+* (*+I%3*( $B0$ 0+* 90(*4 0$ $B* /&($ .&30. .*I*.^ 4*.%I*+*491 %'4%I%470. .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( &+ (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+( A*'*+0..1 *+0$%'A %'4*#*'4*'$.1 &:&'* 0'&$B*+6 MQ0/#.*( %'3.74* :%'0'3%0. 04/%'%($+0$%&' 0'4 3.*+S^ 9&$B &: 5B%3B 0+*#+&I%4*4 91 G> (*#0+0$* *'$%$%*(6 DB%.* $B*+* %( &330(%&'0. %'$*+]/7'%3%#0. 3&..09&+0$%&' %'$B*(* (*+I%3*(^ $B* 90(%3 ($+73$7+* %( 4%(0AA+*A0$*4 03+&(( $B* 2&7'$16

H$ $B* &$B*+ *'4 &: $B* 3&'$%'77/ 0+* (*+I%3*( $B0$ 0+* 90(*4 0$ $B* +*A%&'0. &+3&7'$15%4* .*I*.^ 4*.%I*+*4 91 0 (%'A.* A&I*+'/*'$ 5%$B (*+I%3* g7+%(4%3$%&' (#0''%'A&$B*+5%(* %'4*#*'4*'$ /7'%3%#0.%$%*(6 8B*(* %'3.74* (&3%0. (*+I%3*(^ #79.%3 B*0.$B 0'4

/*'$0. B*0.$B^ *03B &: 5B%3B %( #+&I%4*4 *Q3.7(%I*.1 91 "'&'40A0 2&7'$1 &' 03&7'$15%4* 90(%( %' 033&+40'3* 5%$B ($0$* .056

E' 9*$5**' 0+* B19+%4 /&4*.( %' 5B%3B (*+I%3*( 0+* 4*.%I*+*4 &I*+ A*&A+0#B%*( $B0$ 0+*.0+A*+ $B0' %'4%I%470. 3&//7'%$%*(^ 97$ (/0..*+ $B0' $B* *'$%+* 2&7'$16 MQ0/#.*( %' $B*?1+037(*]"'&'40A0 3&//7'%$1 %'3.74* $0Q 0((*((/*'$ N;R (*#0+0$* 0A*'3%*(^ 5%$B 0..I%..0A*( 0.+*041 /*+A*4 %'$& $B*%+ $&5'( 0'4 $B+** 3&'(&.%40$*4 /7.$%]$&5' 0A*'3%*(O 0'4.%9+0+%*( N5B*+* 0 (%'A.* +*A%&'0. Z7/9+*..0[ (1($*/ (*+I*( G; .%9+0+%*(^ %'3.74%'A F;%'4*#*'4*'$ (797+90' .%9+0+%*(O6

C'6-% K+ N'($%

W'4*+ $B%( /&4*.^ 0 (*+I%3* %( 4*.%I*+*4 /&+* &+ .*(( %'4*#*'4*'$.1 91 0 /7.$%$74* &:(*+I%3* #+&I%4*+(6 81#%30..1 $B&(* (*+I%3* #+&I%4*+( 0+* /7'%3%#0.%$%*(^ 0.$B&7AB %' (&/*30(*( N*6A6 :%+* #+&$*3$%&'O $B*1 0+* '&$ A*'*+0. #7+#&(* .&30. A&I*+'/*'$(6 8B* /&4*. %(*'09.*4 91 ($0$* .05 A+0'$%'A .&30. A&I*+'/*'$( N%6*6 %'4%I%470. 3&//7'%$%*(O $B*07$&'&/1 $& 4*3%4* 5

Date post:	07-Aug-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	robertharding22
View:	214 times
Download:	0 times

Consensus Report on Modernizing Onondaga County Government

Documents