CONSTRUCTION EXCELLENCE: VALUE IN BUILDINGS
12 JANUARY 2016
INTRODUCTION1
VALUE/QUALITY2
BACKGROUND3
METHODOLOGIES4
CASE STUDIES5
SUMMARY6
Q&AS7
DQI
BENCHMARKING
KPI’S
BIM
POE
INTRODUCTION1
VALUE/QUALITY2
5 PANCREAS SQUARE, KINGS CROSS, LONDON
2
THE FALKIRK WHEEL, FORTH AND CLYDE CANAL, SCOTLAND
VALUE/QUALITY
2 VALUE/QUALITY
BACKGROUND3
1
5
200
3 BACKGROUND
1
0.4
12
0.1
3
QUALITYCOST
TIME
THREE LEGGED STOOL
BACKGROUND
METHODOLOGIES4
ASSESSMENT METHODS
METHODOLOGY4
DQI
METHODOLOGY
RIBA HEDQF
4The HEDQF believes that a high quality building should: / Meet users needs and exceed their expectations.
/ Provide a positive environment for the activities that are accommodated.
/ Make a positive contribution to its immediate surroundings.
/ Help to promote a sense of community and social interaction.
/ Be economic in maintenance and running terms.
/ Be constructed with future needs or possible uses in mind.
/ Be environmentally appropriate and incorporate current best practice.
/ Provide value for money / Be constructed on time and on budget.
METHODOLOGY4
NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
N
Ground Floor - Entrance Forum Area
Ground Floor - Arts Space
Ground Floor - Break Out Space
Vistas - opening the classrooms to the outsideA connection between the Open Heart space and the views to the landscape beyond is required to extend the learning experience.
Gro
und
Floo
r
Vistas - opening the classrooms to the outside Community Pavilion The fourth Community building, and the principal address of the school, is the Community Pavilion. This building provides the internal communal focus for the school. The visitor entrance, central staff services, SEN and behavioural support space, library, 6th Form space, assembly and dining spaces are all housed here.
Ground Floor Plan - Scale 1:400
Learning Communities - Flexible Open Learning
3.4.
Block BMaths and Applied Science
Block CCommunication and Arts
Block ACommunity Pavilion
Block DHumanities and Technology
We provide a fluid arrangement of learning spaces, clustered around circulation spaces that aim to blur the distinction between ‘classroom’ and ‘learning space’.Project Work areas have been designed as a sequence of collective learning spaces within a larger volume; from a large gathering to a more intimate group working around a table in the interstitial zone between ‘classroom’ and circulation.
Internet
Cafe
SeminarArt
Store WC
Drama Music
Comms Classrooms
Faculty OfficeBreakout
WC
WC
Tech Classroom
Seminar
WC
Science LabScience Lab
Internet
Cafe
WC
Science
Prep
Science
Labs
Adult CollegeEducation
Food
Tech
Rooms
Seminar
Main Hall
Courtyard
WC
Entrance
SCN
Plant
Dining
Hum Project Space
ICT
Faculty
Office
WC
Kitchen
Hum Project Space
Tech Faculty
Project Space
Maths Teaching
Tech Classroom
Comms Classrooms Art Classrooms
ArtComputer Lab
Tech Project
Space
CABE presentation.c.indd 3 30/01/2009 11:46:46
WAINGELS COLLEGE, WOKINGHAM
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
WAINGELS COLLEGE, WOKINGHAM
WAINGELS COLLEGE, WOKINGHAM
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
THE OPEN ACADEMY, NORWICH
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
ARCHBISHOP BLANCH SCHOOL, LIVERPOOL
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
NOTRE DAME CATHOLIC COLLEGE, LIVERPOOL
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 1: DQI’S
NOTRE DAME CATHOLIC COLLEGE, LIVERPOOL
CASE STUDY 2: BENCHMARKING
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
Collecting an enhanced Activity-Driven Design brief
Activity-Driven Design Business Plan
Establish transformational change (objectives)
Organisational Drivers
WorkPatterns
Workspace Efficiency Occupancy Space
Utilisation People Profile Benchmarking
ACTIVITY ANALYSIS
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
BBC NORTH
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
BBC NORTH
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
BBC NORTH
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
ALAN GILBERT LEARNING COMMONS
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
ALAN GILBERT LEARNING COMMONS
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
ALAN GILBERT LEARNING COMMONS
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 2: BBC
THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
ALAN GILBERT LEARNING COMMONS
CASE STUDY 3: KPI’S
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 3: KPI’S
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 3: KPI’S
BRUNEL UNIVERSITY, RESIDENTIAL PHASE 4
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 3: KPI’S
BRUNEL UNIVERSITY, RESIDENTIAL PHASE 5
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 3: KPI’S
BRUNEL UNIVERSITY, RESIDENTIAL PHASE 6
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 3: KPI’S
BRUNEL UNIVERSITY, RESIDENTIAL PHASE 6
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
CASE STUDIES2
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
GREENBANK RESIDENTIAL
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
D
SX
2
ELECTRICAL SERVICES LEGEND
LIGHT SWITCH LOCATION
DADO TRUNKING
DATA POINT LOCATION
WIRLESS ACCESS POINT. FINAL LOCATION / QTY. AS PER UoL CSD WIFIMAPPING.
TWO -WAY LIGHT SWITCH
SWITCHED FUSED CONNECTION UNIT FOR TOWEL RAIL
QUANTITY
05
WALL LIGHT MOUNTED OVER STUDY DESK
02
SHAVER SOCKET 01
SMOKE DETECTOR + SOUNDER + BEACON
01
01
02
DOUBLE SWITCHED SOCKET LOCATION
01
05
01
01
01
FIRE ALARM BEACON + SOUNDER
ITEM TO BE AT LOW LEVEL
SWITCHED FUSED CONNECTION UNIT 14
ITEM TO BE AT HIGH LEVEL
ALARM RESET POINT AND EMERGENCY RELEASE TO BATHROOM DOOR
EMERGENCY ALARM PULL CORD - DOUBLE HEIGHT (IN BATHROOM ANDADJACENT TO BED - HEAD) INCLUDING CONFIDENCE INDICATOR & SOUNDER
DISABLED ALARM OVER DOOR LIGHT
01
04
01
01
DIMMING / DIMMABLE
ANXIOUS ALARM PULL CORD. TO BE PROGRAMMED WITH THE FIRE ALARMSYSTEM. UoL TO CONFIRM EXACT REQUIREMENT 01
CEILING SURFACE MOUNTED LUMINAIRE
MECHANICAL SERVICES LEGEND
SUPPLY VALVE (CEILING MOUNTED)
EXTRACT VALVE (CEILING MOUNTED)
HOT WATER SUPPLY
COLD WATER SUPPLY
MVHR BOOST CONTROLER AT HIGH LEVEL
SOIL VENT PIPE
LTHW PIPEWORK F/R DROP
QUANTITY
-
01
-
01
01
-
-
-
DOMESTIC COLD WATER SUPPLY PIPEWORK DROP
DOMESTIC HOT WATER SUPPLY PIPEWORK F/R DROP
LOW SURFACE TEMPERATURE TOWEL RAIL (ELECTRIC)
02
01
02
LTHW-LOW SURFACE TEMPERATURE RADIATOR C/W TRV (ACCOMMODATION ZONE)
TO SERVE WET ROOM AUTOMATIC WC 01
REFER TO DRAWING NO. A083169_27_M_1010 FOR ELECTRICAL SETTING OUT DETAILS
CONSUMER UNIT 01
LST TR
S
TR
LL
HL
DIM
SVP
SV
EV
LST RAD
CLOSOMAT
WAP
(ACCOMMODATION)B
2
R
AA
SX
D
2
2
B
WAP
DOORHL
POWERED BED (HL)WIN
DO
W (H
L)B
LIN
D/C
UR
TAIN
AC
TUA
TOR
(HL)
S
POWERED DESK (HL)
WIN
DO
W (H
L)
DOORHL
CLOSOMATHL
BODYDYERHL
HO
IST
(HL)
SVP
EV
SV
SV BLI
ND
/CU
RTA
IN A
CTU
ATO
R (H
L)
TRHL(ACCOMMODATION)
LST RAD
(AC
CO
MM
OD
ATIO
N)
LST
RAD LL
AA
R
Desk type 3 - Accommodation - Accessible.Overall dimensions - W1800 x D600 x H675-775mm.Desk and suspended storage beneath to be electrically height adjustable.
FF&E Legend
Coat hooks type 2 - accessible accommodationTwo rows - upper edges fixed at 1100mm and 1800mm AFFL.
Wardrobe type 3 - accessible.W1000 x D585 x H1800mm
&Eq
uipm
e nt
Fitte
d Fu
rnitu
re
Wall mounted mirror type 1W500 x H1700mm. Frameless with polished edges and no visible fixings.
FF-W3
FF-D3
E-CH2
E-M1
Curtains & wall fixed pole. Dimensions in accordance with WindowSchedule. Electrical motor to blind window. Curtains & windows to beelectronically operated by remote.
Tre
atm
ent
Win
dow
General Notes:
- For M&E Legend refer to 5063-C-79-605b- All rooms suitable for visually impaired users.- Refer to FF&E schedule for detailed product description.- Radiators to M&E Specifications.
- Only 1 No. fully fitted accessible bedroom with equipment shown inRED.- A total of 5 extra long (6’ 10”) single beds, cantilevered ergonomic taskchairs, sets of grabrail and shower seats to be procured and stored onthe site for future use.- Toilet Roll Holder Provided as part of the Doc M Pack
FF-WC2
1
1
1
2
1
2
Long Beds along with mattresses and protectors to be purchased andstored on site. Doc M pack only fitted in 1 No room, all others stored.Standard single beds, mattresses and protector to be provided andstored for all but 1No M2 which will have single bed. All others (with noDoc M pack) to have standard ¾ double bed.
Fitted noticeboard above trunking W1800 x D20 x H650mm.E-NB4 1
Bed type 1 - UK 3/4 size - Student'sW1950 x D1275 x H333mm. All beds to include mattress and protector
Operators chair - Student's bedroomsOperators Chair with height adjustable arms.
LF-B1
LF-BT1
LF-CO1
1
1Fu
rnitu
reLo
ose
Bed type 2 - UK single - Student's Metal framed bed -W1950 x D910 x H333mm. To include mattress and protector
LF-B2 1
Bedside Cabinet - Student's W400 x D490 x H580mm. 1
Washbasin and Tap - AccessibleWall mounted, no pedestal, to fit height adjustable bracket.
Accessible WC Pack - Accessible BedroomsDoc M compliant standard WC with spacer box, low level cistern,washbasin, tap fitting, grabrails, hinged support rail and toilet roll holder.Sa
nita
ry F
ittin
gs
Shower Fitting - Mixer pack to include built-in mixer, showerhead, hose and adjustable sliding rail
Colostomy Shelf - Shower room W400 x D100mm.FF-SC
1
1
1
1
S-SH2
S-WC2
S-WB2
Mirror - Bathroom PodW400 x H800mm - please note ammendment to standard specification toallow provision for fittted grabrails in future.
E-M6 1
Waste Bin - AccommodationTo Bedrooms & Living areas
E-WB
Sanitary Bin - AccommodationBathroom Pods & Ensuites. To be supplied post contract by PHS
E-SB
Toilet Brush - AccommodationBathroom Pods & Ensuites
E-TB1
1
1
1
Quantity
Bed headboard type 1 - fits 3/4 size bed. W1275 x H600 x D18mm.FF-BH1
- All funiture to have rounded edges.
Coat HookE-CH5 2
Waste Bin - Accommodation To Bedrooms & Living areasE-WB 1
LF-BS1 Bookcase - Accessible bedrooms. W800 x D300 x H1350mm. 1
2
2 1
1
44
33
LF-B1
FF-WC2 FF-WC2
RISER
RISER
1010 S/O
Towel Rail
LF-BT1
746
350
700
500
CL
E-M1
FF-W3
1010 S/O
CLWET ROOM
LF-BS1
FF-SC
585
LF-B2
S-SH2
LF-CO1
E-CH2S-WC2
S-WB2&
S-WBB
AREA: 21M2(NOT INCLDUING
BATHROOM)
AREA:6.7m2
E-NB4
FF-BH1
ELECTRICALLYOPERATED CURTAINS
ELECTRICALLYOPERATED CURTAINS
DESK TO BEELECTRICALLYADJUSTABLE
WHEELCHAIRCHARGING AREA
FF-D3
FIRE SIGN
CONTRASTINGTOILET SEAT
E-WB
E-SB
E-TB1
E-CH5
E-CH5
60065500150
630
33
63 294
300
250
165
500
320
150
762 1160
150
320
equalequal equal equal
1000
200
500
170
400
3012
7581
0
1023 265 800 500 1023 1196
Pattress for fixtures and fitted equipment (12mm plywood).Refer to Pattresses drawing for typical fixing heights.
N
CLIENT
PROJECT
SCALE@A1 ORIGINATOR CHECKED
DRAWING NO. REV.
A1
The copyright in this drawing is vested in Sheppard Robson and no license orassignment of any kind has been, or is, granted to any third party whether byprovision of copies or originals or otherwise unless agreed in writing.
The areas are approximate and can only be verified by a detailed dimensionalsurvey of the completed building. Any decisions to be made on the basis of thesepredictions, whether as to project viability, pre-letting, lease agreements or the like,should include due allowance for the increases and decreases inherent in the designdevelopment and building processes. Figures relate to the likely areas of thebuilding at the current state of the design and using the Gross External Area (GEA) /Gross Internal Area (GIA) / Nett Internal Area (NIA) method of measurement from theCode of Measuring Practice, 6th Edition (RICS Code of Practice). All areas aresubject to Town Planning and Conservation Area Consent, and detailed Rights toLight analysis.
AREA MEASUREMENT
FOR ELECTRONIC DATA ISSUE
The contractor shall check and verify all dimensions on site and report any discrepancies in writingto Sheppard Robson before proceeding work
Electronic Data / drawings are issued as "read only" and should not beinterrogated for measurement. All dimensions and levels should read, only fromthose values stated in test, on the drawing.
DO NOT SCALE FROM THIS DRAWING
© COPYRIGHT
DATE AUTHORISED
KEYPLAN
27th Floor City Tower piccadilly Plaza Manchester M1 4BTT: +44 (0)161 233 8900 E: [email protected]
University of Liverpool
C
Derby Old Court
DerbyHall
RathboneHall
GreenbankHouse
GladstoneHall
RoscoeHall
H
1 : 20
14/1
2/20
15 1
7:39
:11
Greenbank Student Village
5063-C-79-605a
Accessible Bedroom Layout - M2- Sheet 1 of 3
02/10/14 TN ET
TENDER
ET
1 : 20Accessible Bedroom Layout - M2
- Only 1No. M2 Bedroom to be fully fitted with accessible fittings to have a single bed shown in RED.All others should be installed with 3/4 doubles, but should have single beds and mattresses purchasedand stored.
- 5No. M2 Bedrooms to be fitted without items shown in RED. Fixings for all grab Rails to be provided for future useand have standard 3/4 bed.
For number of bedrooms refer to accommodation schedule. (ref no 5063_00_912)
REV. DATE AMENDENT
A 28/10/14 Mechanical and Electrical Services added as per WYGSketch Information
B 10/11/14 Colostomy shelf added. General notes updated – Seenotes. Wardrobe amended to University requirements.Bedside table amended to University requirements.Bed headboard and sideboard added, drawer removedbased on University requirements. Desk dimensionamended. Drawer and cupboard added to Desk.Intercom omitted. Coat Hooks mounted on two heights.
C 21/11/14 Issued for pricing.D 12/12/14 Coordinated M&E.E 17/03/15 Issue to WYG for co-ordinationF 25/03/15 Coordinated M&E Issued to UniversityG 01/05/15 Issued to client for ER'sH 15/12/15 Issued for Tender
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
UNIVERSITY OF WOLVERHAMPTON
BUSINESS SCHOOL
/ Open plan opportunities
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
/ 2.no rooms @ 76.no students
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
/ 1no room @ 60no students
/ 2no larger rooms @ 48no students
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
/ 2no rooms @ 23no students
/ 2no rooms @ 17no students
/ 1no room @ 20no students
/ 2no rooms @ 12no students
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 4: BIM
CASE STUDY 5: POE
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 5: ENVIRONMENTAL
ARUP FITZROVIA
/ Monitoring building environment: direct from individual PC’s
/ Potential to manipulate immediate environment: control system = 1% of the building cost
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 5: ENVIRONMENTAL
ARUP FITZROVIA
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 5: ENVIRONMENTAL
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 5: ENVIRONMENTAL
BLAVANIK SCHOOL OF GOVERNMENT
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 5: ENVIRONMENTAL
SIEMENS MIDDLE EAST HEADQUARTERS
ENERGY REDUCTION OVER UAE OFFICES65%
£3M UNDER BUDGET
82% EFFICIENCY OF FLOOR PLATES
60% APPROXIMATE REDUCTION IN MATERIALS USED
CASE STUDIES5
CASE STUDY 5: ENVIRONMENTAL
SUMMARY6
/ Value is subjective but tangible
/ Numerous methods of measurement
/ Inconsistency and lack of cohesion
/ Empirical environmental data is growing
/ Feedback loop adds benefit
/ Need is for national codification
Q&A7