SCOTTISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DISTINCTION AWARDS

2016 Annual Report

Published December 2017

ContentsPage

Foreword 1

Report on the 2016 Awards Round 2

Appendices

A. List of award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2016 5

B. Analysis by age group and category of consultants who retired in the 2016 awards round

12

Analysis of award holders as at 30 September 2016

C. Age group 13

D. Nature of contract 14

E. NHS Board 15

F. Specialty 16

G. Gender 18

H. Ethnic Origin 19

Membership of SACDA

I. For the 2017 awards round 20

Foreword

This is the eighteenth Annual Report of the Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards (SACDA). This report is freely available to consultants, NHS Boards, and all others who have an interest in the awards scheme.

The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, Shona Robison, took the decision to continue to freeze the awards budget in 2016, meaning that no new distinction awards were granted. The committee was required only to review existing awards in line with the normal five-yearly and supplementary review procedures.

Accordingly, there is no analysis of awards granted, or of the Scoring System used by SACDA in granting awards. Instead, the report includes a list of Distinction Award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2016, together with supporting statistical analysis of the award holding and general consultant population.

All statistics in the report are based on consultant data extracted from the SWISS database, which is maintained by NHS Boards. SACDA is aware that much of this data is incorrect or incomplete, particularly the data in relation to contract type, retirals and honorary contract holders; this should be taken into account when viewing the tables. SACDA has continued to work with NHS Boards to improve the quality of the data.

Ken ThomsonChair

1

Report on the 2016 Awards Round(1 October 2015 – 30 September 2016)

IntroductionThe Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards (SACDA) was set up in November 1998 to replace the Scottish Sub-Committee of the Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards (ACDA).

SACDA, a non-departmental public body, acts on behalf of the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing in deciding which medical and dental consultants in the NHS in Scotland should receive distinction awards for outstanding professional work. As per the foreword to the report, no new awards were granted in the 2016 awards round.

However, SACDA remained responsible for the operation of the Distinction Awards scheme in Scotland. The Advisory Committee on Clinical Excellence Awards (ACCEA) is responsible for its operation in England and Wales and, although the two committees are completely independent, close contact between the Chairs and Medical Directors of SACDA and ACCEA has been maintained. We attach weight to ensuring general consistency of approach.

Membership of SACDA during the year ended 30 September 2016 Mr Ken Thomson Chair Professor Charles Swainson Medical Director / Vice-ChairDr Catherine Calderwood (Chief Medical Officer) ex-officio SGHSCD Mrs Sandra DouglasDr Frances DowProfessor Brenda GibsonMr Paul Gray (Chief Executive NHS Scotland) ex-officio SGHSCDProfessor James McDonaldProfessor Gordon McInnesProfessor Ken Paterson

(Vacancies on committee: one medical and one NHS Employer member)

Details of SACDA committee members for the 2016 awards round are set out in Appendix I.

Award holdersAs at 30 September 2016 there were 292 holders of awards in Scotland, as set out below:

2

Award Award Holders

% of all Consultants

A+ 21 0.4A 62 1.1B 209 3.8Total 292

A list of all award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2016 is at Appendix A and related statistical analysis is set out in Appendices B to H.

2016 saw a steady number of retirals amongst consultants, both award holding and non-award holding. Slightly fewer award holders retired during this year compared to last.

Five-Yearly and Supplementary Reviews of AwardsDuring the 2016 awards round, 36 awards (27 B, 7 A, and 2 A+) were reviewed by SACDA. The Committee recommended continuation of all 36 awards.

Scoring SystemSACDA again scored all of the five-yearly review and supplementary review paperwork using the standard scoring system and criteria for awards that would have been applied to new applicants. As with the assessment of applicants for new awards, the scoring results formed the basis for the committee’s evaluation of award holders under review but the final decisions reflected SACDA’s overall judgement and were not based purely on scores. The scoring results of the reviews demonstrated that the vast majority of award holders continued to perform at or above the level for which their awards were granted. Full details of the SACDA scoring system may be found on the SACDA website at: http://www.scclea.scot.nhs.uk

Equality and DiversitySACDA remained committed to recognising issues of equality and diversity in its work.

Guide for 2017The SACDA Online system was used again in the 2016 five-yearly review round for the submission of all documentation. At the time of writing, no new Guide to the Scheme has been published. Once the Scottish Government announces its intentions for the scheme in 2017, guidance on this, or on any new scheme that may be implemented in the future, will be published on the SACDA website.

Forward PlanningAs advised in the 2012 report, an independent, UK-wide review of the Clinical Excellence and Distinction Awards schemes, was carried out by the Doctors’ and Dentists’ Review Body in 2011. The report was published on 17 December 2012 and the former Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing stated that consideration of the report’s recommendations would be taken forward on a UK basis by the four Health Departments.  SACDA supports the recommendations and is keen to see some progress in implementing the report in Scotland but understands that this will form part

3

of future discussions around consultant contracts which will form part of wider work on a whole-system approach to achieving a sustainable healthcare service for 2020 and beyond.

Mr Ken Thomson Professor Charles SwainsonChair Medical Director

4

Appendix A

Distinction Award Holders in ScotlandAs at 30 September 2016

The nominal roll listing all consultants in NHS Scotland can be found on the SACDA website at http://www.scclea.scot.nhs.uk

Name Initials Speciality Employing Authority Award Level DateAbu-Arafeh IA Paediatrics NHS Forth Valley B 2008Aitman T General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010Akyol A General Surgery NHS Lothian B 2005Anderson J General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Andrews P Anaesthetics NHS Lothian A 2009Arends M Histopathology NHS Lothian B 2008Ayoub A Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Bagg J Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006Bain M Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 2009Baldacchino A General Psychiatry NHS Fife B 2009Baxter G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005Belch J General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2008Berg G Cardiothoracic Surgery National Waiting Times Centre B 2007Bhattacharya S Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 2008Bhattacharya J Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Bhopal R General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2004Bilsland D Dermatology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Binning A Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Booth M Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Brady A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Brenkel I Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Fife B 2007Breusch S Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 2010Brewster D Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 2008Bridges A General Medicine NHS Forth Valley B 2006Brittenden J General Surgery NHS Grampian B 2009Brodie M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2002Byrne D General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010Cameron A Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008Cameron D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008Campbell H General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2006Cantwell R General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Carey F Histopathology NHS Tayside B 2007Carter C General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005

Carton AOral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Lanarkshire B 2009

Chambers W Anaesthetics NHS Grampian A 2001Clarkson J Dentistry NES B 2009Clift B Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Tayside B 2009

Coia JMedical Microbiology & Virology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008

Colvin J Anaesthetics NHS Tayside B 2008Conn I Urology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010Connacher A General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2008

5

Appendix A

CONNELL JMC General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2005Connolly M General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Cook B Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 2010Cook A General Psychiatry NHS Lanarkshire B 2010

COOPER SPsychiatry of Learning Disability NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2009

Critchley H Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Lothian A+ 2009CROSSMAN D General Medicine NHS Fife A 2013Cruickshank M Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 2009Culligan D Haematology NHS Grampian B 2009Daniel M Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010Davis C Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007De Caestecker L Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2004Dean J Clinical Genetics NHS Grampian B 2006Dempster J ENT Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2009Dennis M General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2007Dhillon B Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 2005Diament R General Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2009Dillon J General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2010Dixon J General Surgery NHS Lothian A 2010Dobson H Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2002Docherty J General Medicine NHS Highland B 2010Dominiczak A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2007Dominiczak M Chemical Pathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2000Dow E Chemical Pathology NHS Tayside B 2006Doyle E Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 2009Dreyer J General Surgery NHS Dumfries and Galloway B 2010Dunlop M General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2010Dunlop D General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Dunn L Neurosurgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Elder A Geriatric Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010El-Shafei H Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Grampian B 2009Eteiba H General Medicine National Waiting Times Centre B 2008Evans T Chemical Pathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Evans A Histopathology NHS Tayside B 2009Evans AJ Diagnostic Radiology NHS Tayside B 2005Farquharson D General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2008Fearon K General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2006Felix D Dentistry NES A 2009Ferguson J Emergency Medicine NHS Grampian B 2005Findlay I General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006Fisher B General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003Fitzsimons E Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2002Flapan A General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008Fleming S Histopathology NHS Tayside A 2009Forsythe J General Surgery NHS Lothian A 2005Foulis A Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 1992Fox R Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008

6

Appendix A

Fox J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Fraser A Public Health Medicine NHS Health Scotland B 2006Gallacher S General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Garden O General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2004Gibson B Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2009Gillespie S Histopathology NHS Fife A 2005Going J Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2001Goldberg D Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland A 2005

Gould IMedical Microbiology & Virology NHS Grampian A 2004

Grant R Neurology NHS Lothian B 2006Gray A Emergency Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008Grosset D Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005Haddock G Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Hall D General Psychiatry NHS Dumfries and Galloway B 2005Hannaford P General Medicine NHS Grampian B 2006Harrison D Chemical Pathology NHS Lothian A+ 2009Haslett C General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2001Hay A Forensic Psychiatry NHS Highland B 2008Hayes P General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2003Hendry A Geriatric Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2005Herriot R Haematology NHS Grampian A 2009HEYS SD General Surgery NHS Grampian A 2008

Hislop WOral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2005

Holyoake T Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006

Hood JMedical Microbiology & Virology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005

Horgan P General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Houston J Diagnostic Radiology NHS Tayside B 2010Hughes R Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Lothian B 2007Hunter J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Hunter R General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2002Hussain S ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 2008Ibbotson S Dermatology NHS Tayside B 2010Ironside J Histopathology NHS Tayside A+ 2008Jardine A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Johnston P Histopathology NHS Grampian B 2009

Jones BMedical Microbiology & Virology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009

Keating J Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 2008Keel A Haematology NHS Lothian B 2007Kennedy N General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2009Ker J General Practice NHS Tayside B 2008Kerr K Histopathology NHS Grampian A 2005Kidd B General Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 2002Kinsella J Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008Kirk A Cardiothoracic Surgery National Waiting Times Centre B 2009Kirkpatrick M Paediatrics NHS Tayside B 2009

7

Appendix A

Knight P Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010Knight R General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2004Lam Shang Leen C Communicable Diseases NHS Lothian B 2008Lang C General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2007LANGHORNE P Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006Large D Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2009Lawrie S General Psychiatry NHS Lothian B 2008Lean M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2002LEES KR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2005Leese G General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2005Leung H Urology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Lipworth B General Medicine NHS Tayside A 2008LUMSDEN MA Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2007Macarthur K Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2009Macdonald T General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2009Macewen C Ophthalmology NHS Tayside A 2009Macfadyen UM Paediatrics NHS Forth Valley A 2001Macfie A Anaesthetics National Waiting Times Centre B 2008Macgilchrist A General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010Mackay T Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian B 2005MACKINLAY GA Paediatric Surgery NHS Lothian B 2004Macpherson L Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Macrury S General Medicine NHS Highland B 2006Mactier R General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Madhok R General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003Mahmood T Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Fife A 2006Mallon E Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Mathers A Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008Matthews K General Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 2005Maxwell S General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008Mcalpine L General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2004Mcalpine C Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Mccoll K General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2008Mcgarry GW ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010Mcgrady E Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Mcgregor J General Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran A 2009Mcinnes I General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2009Mckay P Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Mckay C General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Mckee R General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005Mckillop G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 2009Mckinlay A General Medicine NHS Grampian B 2010Mcknight J NHS Lothian B 2008Mclellan A General Medicine NES A 2009Mclintock T Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010Mcmurray J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2010Mcritchie H Diagnostic Radiology NHS Borders B 2009

8

Appendix A

Meddings R Urology NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2008Mehta A Paediatrics NHS Tayside B 2008Mires G Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Tayside B 2004Molloy R General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Morris A General Medicine NHS Tayside A 2007Morris A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Morrison J General Practice NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Morrison R Forensic Psychiatry NHS Forth Valley B 2009Morton C Dermatology NHS Forth Valley B 2010Mossey P Dentistry NHS Tayside B 2007Mountain R ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 2005Muir K Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010Mumford C Neurology NHS Lothian B 2009Murchison J Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 2008MURRAY GI Histopathology NHS Grampian B 2005Murray S General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008Murray A Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian B 2007Nandwani R Genito-Urinary Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005Nathwani D Communicable Diseases NHS Tayside A 2009N'Dow J Urology NHS Grampian B 2009Neilly J Respiratory Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Newby D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2007Nicolson M Radiotherapy NHS Grampian B 2005Norman J General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2004O'Dwyer P General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2002

Ogden GOral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Tayside A 2008

O'Kelly T General Surgery NHS Grampian B 2005Oldroyd K General Medicine National Waiting Times Centre B 2006

O'Regan MOral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Fife B 2004

Owen P Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Owens D General Psychiatry NHS Lothian A 2002Pace N Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Parks R General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2010Paterson-Brown S General Surgery NHS Lothian A 2009Patey R Anaesthetics NHS Grampian B 2009Paton J Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008Pell JP Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010Penman I General Surgery NHS Lothian B 2008Petrie J General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2009Porteous M Clinical Genetics NHS Lothian A 2009Ralston S General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2009Ray D Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 2009Rees J General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2005Reid W Geriatric Medicine NES B 2008Ritchie L Public Health Medicine NHS Grampian A 2007Robertson I Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007

9

Appendix A

Roditi G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Rymaszewski L Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2001Salter D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2009Satsangi J General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2006Sattar NA Chemical Pathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Savill J General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2005Scott H General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2008Seaton R Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Seckl J General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2009Serpell M Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2004Shearer A Dentistry NES B 2009Sheikh A General Practice NHS Lothian B 2009Shimi S General Surgery NHS Tayside B 2005Siddiqui N Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Simpson A Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian A 2009Singh J Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 2008Small M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003Smith I General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003Smith D General Surgery NHS Tayside B 2008St Clair D General Psychiatry NHS Grampian B 2008Stark C Public Health Medicine NHS Highland B 2010Starr J Geriatric Medicine NHS Lothian B 2006Steele R General Surgery NHS Tayside A+ 2008Stenson B Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 2009Stonebridge P General Surgery NHS Tayside B 2006Stott D Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Strachan M General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010Struthers A General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2007Sullivan F General Practice NHS Tayside B 2007Swan IH General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007Taha A General Medicine NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2007Tait R Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Taylor J Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Taylor J General Psychiatry NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2010Thomas A Paediatrics NHS Lothian A 2008Thomas J Chemical Pathology NHS Lothian B 2009Thomson L General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008TURNER ML Blood Transfusion NHS National Services Scotland B 2006TURNER AN General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008Uren N General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2009Walker B General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2010Walker A Public Health Medicine NHS Tayside B 2009Walker W Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Lothian B 2008Wallace W Paediatrics NHS Lothian A 2008WALLS AWG Dentistry NHS Lothian A 2011Walsh T General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2007Walters M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Ward H Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 2009

10

Appendix A

Wardlaw J General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2008Watson H Haematology NHS Grampian B 2008Watson S Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009Watt G General Practice NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2007Webb D General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2008WEBSTER NR Anaesthetics NHS Grampian A 2003Webster J General Medicine NHS Grampian A+ 2010Weiler-Mithoff E Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008Welbury RRR Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006Weller D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2007White P ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 2007Whyte M General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2014Wigmore S General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2009Williams A Chemical Pathology NHS Lothian B 2010WILLIAMS C General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006Willison H Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008

11

Appendix B

ANALYSIS BY AGE GROUP AND CATEGORYOF CONSULTANTS WHO RETIRED

Scotland – 2016 Awards Round

Age Group

Distinction Award Holders

A+ A B TotalUnder 65 Number 2 3 9 14

% 9.5% 4.8% 4.3% 4.8%

65 and over Number 1 0 3 4

% 4.7% 0% 1.4% 1.4%

Total Number 3 3 12 18

% 14.3% 4.8% 5.7% 6.2%

12

Appendix C

ANALYSIS BY AGE GROUP(All Consultants)

Scotland as at 30 September 2016

Age Group

Award Holders Non-Award

HoldersAll

ConsultantsA+ A B Total

Under 35 0 0 0 0 135 135

35-39 0 0 0 0 884 884

40-44 1 1 1189 1190

45-49 0 4 4 1128 1132

50-54 6 54 60 962 1022

55-59 7 28 109 144 578 722

60-6411 24 36 71 206 277

65 and over

3 4 5 12 69 81

Total 0 62 209 292 5151 5443

13

Appendix D

ANALYSIS BY NATURE OF CONTRACT

Scotland as at 30 September 2016

Nature of Contract

A+ A B NON-AWARD HOLDERS

Honorary 19 32 56 119

Permanent 2 30 153 5324

Total 21 62 209 5443

14

Appendix E

ANALYSIS BY NHS BOARD

Scotland as at 30 September 2016Award Holders

All ConsultantsA+ A B Total Non-Award

HoldersNHS Board No. % Per

AreaNo. % Per

AreaNo. % Per

AreaNo. % Per

AreaNo. % Per

Area

Ayrshire and Arran 1 0.4 7 2.6 8 3.0 254 96.9 262Borders 1 1.0 1 1.0 97 99.0 98

Dumfries and Galloway 2 1.7 2 1.7 116 98.3 118

Fife 3 1.2 3 1.2 6 2.4 246 97.6 252Forth Valley 1 0.4 4 1.8 5 2.2 224 97.8 229Grampian 1 0.2 7 1.3 18 3.4 26 4.9 505 95.1 531Greater Glasgow & Clyde 4 0.3 22 1.4 74 4.8 100 6.4 1454 93.6 1554Highland 4 1.5 4 1.5 263 98.5 267Lanarkshire 6 1.4 6 1.4 440 98.6 446Lothian 9 0.9 19 1.9 49 4.8 77 7.6 935 92.4 1012National (1) 1 0.8 3 2.3 13 9.8 17 12.8 116 87.2 133Orkney 0.0 0.0 14 100.0 14Shetland 0.0 16 100.0 16Tayside 6 1.2 6 1.2 28 5.6 40 8.0 463 92.1 503Western Isles 0.0 8 100.0 8

Total 21 0.4 62 1.1 209 3.8 292 5.4 5151 94.6 5443

Note: (1) Includes consultants working in National Organisations; NHS National Services Scotland (operating name for the Common Services Agency), NHS Education for Scotland, Healthcare Improvement Scotland, NHS Health Scotland, the Scottish Ambulance Service, the State Hospitals Board for Scotland, the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland, the National Waiting Times Centre and NHS 24.

15

Appendix FANALYSIS BY SPECIALTY

Scotland as at 30 September 2016

Total No. of Consultants

% of All Consultants

Award Holders Non-Award Holders

in Specialty

 Specialty A+ A B Total

No. 0% of Specialty

No. % of Specialty

No. % of Specialty

No. % of Specialty

No. % of Specialty

Anaesthetics 744 13.7% 0.0% 4 0.5% 9 1.2% 13 1.7% 731 98.3%

Public Health Medicine 111 2.0% 1 0.9% 2 1.8% 7 6.3% 10 9.0% 101 91.0%

General Practice 22 0.4% 0.0% 1 4.5% 4 18.2% 5 22.7% 17 77.3%

Occupational Medicine 16 0.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 16 100.0%

Dentistry (1) 112 2.1% 0.0% 5 4.5% 5 4.5% 10 8.9% 102 91.1%

Blood Transfusion 3 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 1 33.3% 1 33.3% 2 66.7%

Chemical Pathology (2) 70 1.3% 1 1.4% 0.0% 6 8.6% 7 10.0% 63 90.0%

Haematology 99 1.8% 1 1.0% 0 0.0% 7 7.1% 8 8.1% 91 91.9%

Clinical Genetics 21 0.4% 0.0% 1 4.8% 1 4.8% 2 9.5% 19 90.5%

Medical Microbiology & Virology

59 1.1% 0.0% 1 1.7% 1 1.7% 2 3.4% 57 96.6%

Histopathology 105 1.9% 1 1.0% 3 2.9% 8 7.6% 12 11.4% 93 88.6%

Communicable Diseases 31 0.6% 0.0% 1 3.2% 2 6.5% 3 9.7% 28 90.3%

Dermatology 76 1.4% 0.0% 0 0.0% 3 3.9% 3 3.9% 73 96.1%

General Medicine (3) 637 11.7% 15 2.4% 19 3.0% 57 8.9% 91 14.3% 546 85.7%

Geriatric Medicine 181 3.3% 0.0% 2 1.1% 7 3.9% 9 5.0% 172 95.0%

Paediatrics (4) 326 6.0% 0.0% 4 1.2% 4 1.2% 8 2.5% 318 97.5%

Palliative Medicine 40 0.7% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 40 100.0%

Neurology 82 1.5% 0.0% 1 1.2% 4 4.9% 5 6.1% 77 93.9%

Rehabilitation Medicine 26 0.5% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 26 100.0%

Respiratory Medicine 108 2.0% 0.0% 0.0% 2 1.9% 2 1.9% 106 98.1%

16

Appendix FGenito Urinary Medicine 23 0.4% 0.0% 0.0% 1 4.3% 1 4.3% 22 95.7%

Obstetrics & Gynaecology 267 4.9% 1 0.4% 4 1.5% 6 2.2% 11 4.1% 256 95.9%

General Psychiatry 384 7.1% 0.0% 1 0.3% 12 3.1% 13 3.4% 371 96.6%

Psychotherapy 14 0.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 14 100.0%

Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 66 1.2% 0.0% 0.0% 0 0.0% 0 0.0% 66 100.0%

Forensic Psychiatry 48 0.9% 0.0% 0.0% 2 4.2% 2 4.2% 46 95.8%

Psychiatry of Learning Disability

56 1.0% 0.0% 1 1.8% 0.0% 1 1.8% 55 98.2%

Old Age Psychiatry 59 1.1% 0.0% 1 1.7% 0.0% 1 1.7% 58 98.3%

Diagnostic Radiology (5) 343 6.3% 0.0% 0.0% 11 3.2% 11 3.2% 332 96.8%

Radiotherapy (Clinical Oncology)

88 1.6% 0.0% 0.0% 1 1.1% 1 1.1% 87 98.9%

Emergency Medicine (6) 231 4.2% 0.0% 0 0.0% 2 0.9% 2 0.9% 229 99.1%

ENT Surgery (Otolaryngology) 87 1.6% 0.0% 1 1.1% 4 4.6% 5 5.7% 82 94.3%

General Surgery 278 5.1% 1 0.4% 6 2.2% 19 6.8% 26 9.4% 252 90.6%

Neurosurgery 35 0.6% 0.0% 0.0% 1 2.9% 1 2.9% 34 97.1%

Ophthalmology 135 2.5% 0.0% 1 0.7% 2 1.5% 3 2.2% 132 97.8%

Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery 27 0.5% 0.0% 0.0% 3 11.1% 3 11.1% 24 88.9%

Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgery

257 4.7% 0.0% 1 0.4% 6 2.3% 7 2.7% 250 97.3%

Plastic Surgery 44 0.8% 0.0% 0.0% 2 4.5% 2 4.5% 42 95.5%

Paediatric Surgery 28 0.5% 0.0% 0.0% 2 7.1% 2 7.1% 26 92.9%

Cardiothoracic Surgery 29 0.5% 0.0% 1 3.4% 4 13.8% 5 17.2% 24 82.8%

Urology 75 1.4% 0.0% 1 1.3% 3 4.0% 4 5.3% 71 94.7%

Total of all consultants 5443 100 21 0.4% 62 1.1% 209 3.8% 292 5.4% 5151 94.6%

17

Appendix G

ANALYSIS BY GENDER (Of All Current Award Holders)

Scotland as at 30 September 2016

All Consultants

Male Female All

No. % No. % No. %

3351 62 2092 38 5443 100

% of Award Level(1)

% of Award Level(1)

% of Awards(2)

A+ 17 80.9 4 19.1 21 7.2

A 53 85.5 9 14.5 62 21.2

B 176 84.2 33 15.8 209 71.6

Total Awards

246 84.2 46 15.7 292 100

NOTES:(1) % refers to awards within specific award level(2) % refers to all awards

APPENDIX H

ANALYSIS BY ETHNIC ORIGIN – Scotland as at 30 September 2016

ETHNIC GROUP

AWARD HOLDERS NON-AWARD HOLDERS

ALL CONSULTANTS

A+ A B

White – Other British 1 8 23 775 807

White – Irish 1 0 3 124 128

White – Scottish 3 16 47 1596 1662

White – Other 2 7 17 373 399

African 26 26

Mixed or Multiple Ethnic Group

2 37 39

Asian - Bangladeshi 12 12

Asian - Chinese 1 53 54

Asian – Indian 1 4 331 336

Asian – Other 30 30

Asian – Pakistani 1 2 55 58

Caribbean or Black - Black

2 2

Caribbean or Black - Caribbean

6 6

Caribbean or Black - Other

5 5

Other Ethnic Group - Arab

1 4 5

Other Ethnic Group - Other

5 66 71

Declined 10 12 33 991 1046

Unknown 4 17 71 883 975

Totals 21 62 209 5369 5661

19

Appendix I

MEMBERSHIP OF SACDA FOR THE 2017 AWARDS ROUND

Chair

Mr Ken Thomson (to serve a third term until 28 February 2018) worked for 32 years in NHS management, latterly as Chief Executive of Yorkhill NHS Trust. Since taking early retiral he worked for five years as Project Director of An Lòchran - a Gaelic language cultural promotion organisation in Glasgow. In addition he is a lay member of Employment Tribunals (Scotland) and of the Conduct Sub-Committee of the Scottish Social Services Council. Mr Thomson formerly held a non-executive member position with the National Waiting Times Centre Board, between August 2003 and July 2009. He has also been conductor of the prestigious Gaelic choir - The Glasgow Gaelic Musical Association - and is a prolific arranger of songs for Gaelic choirs, having published a book of twenty of his arrangements.

Medical Director and Vice-Chair

Professor Charles Swainson (to serve a third term until 31 October 2017) was Medical Director at NHS Lothian from 1996 - 2010.  After training in the UK and Sydney in Renal Medicine, he went to Christchurch, New Zealand as a Senior Lecturer in 1981.  He returned to a consultant post in Edinburgh in 1986.  He has served on the Council of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh, was a founder member of the Cochrane Renal Collaboration, and founder member and deputy chairman of the Scottish Association of Medical Directors. He is Treasurer of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh.

Committee Members

Dr Frances Dow CBE (to serve until 28 February 2017) is a former Vice Principal of the University of Edinburgh. She has held a number of appointments in the public and voluntary sectors, mainly in healthcare and education. She was a lay member on the Council for Healthcare Regulatory Excellence (now the Professional Standards Authority) from 2003 to 2008 and has chaired two Scottish Government Health Directorates steering groups: on the Regulation of Healthcare Support Workers (2005-2009) and on Professionalism with particular reference to the Nursing and Allied Health Profession (2010-2012). From 2007 to 2011 she chaired the Marshall Aid Commemoration Commission.

Professor Brenda Gibson (to serve until 28 February 2017) became an A+ award holder in 2009. She is a Paediatric Haematologist with an interest in stem cell transplantation and is based at the Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow, Scotland. She is currently the National Clinical Director for the Managed Service Network for Children & Young People with Cancer (MSN CYPC). She is past President of the British Society for Haematology and was the Chair of the Childhood Leukaemia Working Party from 2002 - 2014. She has extensive knowledge of

20

Appendix I

clinical trials and has been a Chief Investigator on a number of national paediatric leukaemia trials. She is an active member of a number of international groups including EBMT Paediatric Diseases Working Party, I-BFM AML Steering Committee and EMA Paediatric Committee on Medicines for Children.

Professor Gordon McInnes (to serve a third term until 31 December 2018) became an A award holder in 2007. He is a retired physician previously based at the Western Infirmary, Glasgow and Professor Emeritus in Clinical Pharmacology at the University of Glasgow. He is past president of the British Hypertension Society and the Scottish Society of Physicians, past Chair of the Committee of Heads and Professors of Clinical Pharmacology at the British Pharmacological Society and past member of the Specialist Advisory Committee in Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics and the Council of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow.

2 x Medical member /Academy of Royal Colleges and Faculties vacancy1 x NHS Employer vacancy1x Lay Member vacancy

The Medical and Lay Members vacancies have been advertised with a view to appointment early in 2017

Ex-officio Members

Dr Catherine Calderwood Chief Medical Officer for Scotland

Mr Paul Gray Director General for Health and Social Care and Chief Executive of the NHS in Scotland

21