CONTEXT OF DECISION MAKING
Module 2
PART 1: DETERMINANTS OF DDU
Part 1: Session Objectives
Highlight the determinants of data use List potential barriers to data use Introduce the Action Plan to Address Barriers
to Data Use tool
What Determines Data Demand & Use?
ORGANIZATIONALTECHNICAL
BEHAVIORAL
* Based on PRISM analytical framework (LaFond, Fields et al. 2005 The PRISM: An Analytical Framework for Understanding Performance of Health Information Systems in Developing Countries. MEASURE Evaluation).
Data are often underutilized because of…
Technical constraints Individual technical skills Availability of computers Data system design Definition of indicators Lack of data quality assurance protocols
Data are often underutilized because of…
Organizational constraints Structural – roads, telecommunication Organizational – clarity of roles, support,
flow of information Political interference
Data are often underutilized because of…
Individual constraints Decision-maker attitudes, Staff motivation, Lack of “data culture”
What Determines Data Demand & Use?
ORGANIZATIONALTECHNICAL
BEHAVIORALPOLITICS
CULTURE
SOCIETY
* Based on PRISM analytical Fields et al. 2005 The PRISM: An Analytical Framework for Understanding Performance of Health Information Systems in Developing Countries. MEASURE Evaluation).
What barriers have you faced to using or getting others to use data and
information?
Group Participation
Assessment of Data Use Constraints Tool
Purpose To improve understanding of the demand for data and the
constraints to data use
Description Key informant interview guide designed to identify
constraints Identifies effective practices in data use Two versions – Facility-level assessment & national and
subnational assessments
Assessment of Data Use Constraints ToolTechnical Constraints
Technical constraints are related to the ability to generate high-quality data and analyses.
RA8 Have you ever had an experience while making a policy or program-related decision when you were concerned about the quality of the information being used?
RA9 Are there multiple sources of information or statistics for issues of importance to you, and have you experienced any problems caused by having different estimates?
RA10 I am interested in knowing about technical capacity for collecting and using information. Does your agency have the technical capacity to produce reliable information without a lot of external technical assistance?
RA11 Does your agency have the technical capacity to ensure access to and availability of reliable data?
RA12 Has there been an occasion when data quality or local technical capacity made it difficult for you to use information in making a decision?
RA13 How would you have gone about preventing this situation?
Barrier: Steps Involved
PersonResponsible
Other Stake-holders
General Timeline
Action Plan for Addressing Barriers to Data Use
Small Group Activity 2: InstructionsChoose a note taker Discuss barriers to data use experienced in your work. Here are some questions to start your discussion:
Have you ever had an experience while making a policy or program-related decision when you were concerned about the quality of the information being used?
Does your agency have the technical capacity to ensure access to and availability of reliable data?
What specific challenges have you experienced among your staff when it comes to using data?
How does your organization support having the necessary information to make decisions?
Time for activity: 1 hour
Barrier: Lack of technical capacity in M&E
Steps Involved
PersonResponsible
Other Stake-holders
General Timeline
Proposed Intervention: Train all program managers in X organization on basic monitoring and evaluation (indicators, developing M&E plan, documenting results, managing toward results, etc.)
Identify funding
Director Deputy, Program mgr
January2008
Seek out trainers and curricula
M&E Specialist
Deputy director, Training coordinator
February 2008
Action Plan for Addressing Barriers to Data Use
Small Group Activity: Report Back
Share priority barriers Discuss solutions crafted Present action plan for two priority barriers Time for report back: Each group has 10–15
minutes
PART 2: CONTEXT OF DECISION MAKING
Part 2: Session Objectives
Explain the context of decision making Define the concept of stakeholders Explain the importance of involving
stakeholders throughout the data use in decision making cycle
Introduce the Stakeholder Analysis and Engagement tools
Group Participation
How can we ensure that information is being used to make diagnoses
and inform decisions?
Stake-holders
Decisions
Context of Decision Making
Data
Stake-holders
Decisions
Context of Decision Making
Data
What Is a Stakeholder?Any person, group, or organization with a particular interest in a policy or program Government agencies Beneficiaries Policymakers Funding agencies Providers / implementers Civil society Researchers M&E specialists
Stakeholders Nongovernmental organizations Professional associations Religious leaders Journalists/media Private sector/business
Data Producers vs. Data UsersData producers think that decision makers:• Value “political” considerations over evidence• Are unprepared to measure or evaluate the
consequences of their decisions
Decision makers or data users think that health researchers and M&E specialists:
Lack responsiveness to priorities Favor numbers / jargon to transparent communication Prefer written reports to face-to-face conversation
Importance of Knowing Your Stakeholders
View activities from different perspectives
Have different degrees of understanding
Need/want different information
Need information at different levels of complexity
Have different intensities of interest
Have different roles in the decision-making process
Results of Involving Stakeholders in Data Use Process
Relevance of data Ownership of data Appropriate dissemination of data Use of data
Stakeholder Analysis Matrix & Engagement Plan
Clarify who has interest in a program and what that interest is
Identify who can help a program and how, and who can hurt it
Help you use this information for the success of the planning effort
Stakeholder Analysis Matrix
The Stakeholder Analysis Matrix is a framework and process for:
Identifying stakeholders Defining their roles and resources Identifying dynamics among stakeholders Setting the optimum stakeholder group
Stakeholder Analysis MatrixName of stakeholder organization, group, or individual
Stakeholder descriptionPrimary purpose, affiliation, funding
Potential role in the issue or activity
Level of knowledge of the issue
Level of commitmentSupport or oppose the activity, to what extent, and why?
Available resourcesStaff, money, technology, information, influence
Name of stakeholder organization, group, or individual
Stakeholder descriptionPrimary purpose, affiliation, funding
Potential role in the issue or activity
Level of knowledge of the issue
Level of commitmentSupport or oppose the activity, to what extent, and why?
Available resourcesStaff, money, technology, information, influence
National AIDS Control Committee
Involved in planning, implementation, M&E of all HIV/AIDS programs in the country; approves donor and NGO-funded HIV/AIDS programs
Facilitates the stakeholder meeting, prepares for meeting by identifying data sources and preparing an agenda
High – receives reports on PMTCT activities from MCH division at MOH; Medium level of knowledge of int’l guidelines and studies
Strongly supports activity but hesitant to use international data sources. NACC opposes use of the DHS and most recent international estimates, as it considers these sources to overestimate HIV prevalence
Staff available to facilitate; Room and computers available for meetings at NACC headquarters
Stakeholder Analysis Matrix Program issue Develop plan (inc. M&E plan) to scale up PMTCT programs throughout system.Proposed activity Convene stakeholders to identify priorities based on available data and develop action plan.Date November 2006
How to Involve Stakeholders Quarterly program management meetings
Quarterly meetings to interpret RHIS data Involvement of facility staff to interpret program
data M&E system improvement
Indicator planning and/or harmonization Data quality review meetings
Stakeholder Engagement Plan
Stakeholder organization, group,
or individual
Potential role in the activity
Engagement strategy
How will you engage this stakeholder in the activity?
Follow-up strategyPlans for feedback or
continued involvement
Program issueProposed activityDate
Stakeholder Engagement Plan
Stakeholder organization, group, or individual
Potential role in the activity
Engagement strategyHow will you engage this
stakeholder in the activity?
Follow-up strategyPlans for feedback or
continued involvement
National AIDS Control Committee (NACC)
Facilitates the stakeholder meeting, prepares for meeting by identifying data sources and preparing an agenda that allows for the sources to be discussed
The NACC is the lead in this activity. It will be important for the NACC to involve more specifically the PMTCT coordinator, clinical care coordinator, and National AIDS Program Coordinator
The NACC is responsible for following up with the prioritized stakeholders
Program issue Develop plan (inc. M&E plan) to scale up PMTCT programs throughout system.Proposed activity Convene stakeholders to identify priorities based on available data and develop action plan.Date November 2006
Stake-holders
Decisions
Context of Decision Making
Data
Decision Areas
Program design and evaluation Program management and improvement Strategic planning Advocacy and policy development
Program Design and Evaluation
Design Select messages for prevention campaigns
Evaluation Determine if new program approaches are
needed to ensure that health impact objectives are met
Program Management and Improvement
Management Determine if the program is meeting its
process objectives Improvement
Develop new strategies to increase coverage
Strategic Planning
Identify geographic areas of highest need
Determine human resource allocation Determine which of offered services is
making the greatest impact
Advocacy and Policy Development
Identifying and quantifying underserved populations
Identifying focus areas for new policies
Stake-holders
Decisions
Context of Decision Making
Data
Data and Information Census Vital events data Surveillance data Household surveys Facilities-level service statistics Financial and management information Modeling, estimates, and projections Health research
Stake-holders
Decisions
Factors Other than Data that Influence Decisions
Data
Political Ideology
Competing Priorities
Power Relationships
Public Opinion
Arbitrariness
Stakeholders Involve new counterparts
Strengthening the Decision-making Process
Decisions Understand service delivery realities
Data May require additional data
Small Group Activity 3: Instructions Break into small groups. Each group should select a decision that they make in
their work settings and complete the Stakeholder Analysis Matrix around that decision.
A minimum of 7 stakeholders should be identified. Complete the Matrix across the columns for 1–2
stakeholders. Select one stakeholder and complete the Stakeholder
Engagement Plan for that stakeholder. Time for activity: 45 minutes
Group Work Report Back Have note taker transfer your final Stakeholder
Analysis Matrix onto flip chart paper Share the decision your group chose Share the priority stakeholders selected Choose 1 stakeholder and share the entire row
from the Matrix for that stakeholder Share the Engagement Plan for the same
stakeholder Time for report back: 10–15 min per group
THANK YOU!MEASURE Evaluation is a MEASURE project funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development and implemented by the
Carolina Population Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partnership with Futures Group International, ICF Macro, John Snow, Inc., Management Sciences for Health, and Tulane University. Views expressed in this presentation do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the U.S. Government.
MEASURE Evaluation is the USAID Global Health Bureau's primary vehicle for supporting improvements in monitoring and evaluation in
population, health and nutrition worldwide.
Visit us online at http://www.cpc.unc.edu/measure