COPD in Wandsworth:
Health Needs Assessment
Felix Greaves
Josephine Ruwende
May 2010
1
ContentsExecutive Summary...............................................................................................................................3
Aim:.......................................................................................................................................................4
Background............................................................................................................................................5
COPD definition, natural history and burden of disease....................................................................5
Global burden....................................................................................................................................5
Diagnosis...........................................................................................................................................6
Treatment..........................................................................................................................................6
Burden of disease in Wandsworth.........................................................................................................7
Prevalence.........................................................................................................................................7
Observed Vs Modelled Prevalence....................................................................................................9
Future Projections of Prevalence.....................................................................................................12
Prevalence and inequalities.............................................................................................................13
Risk factors......................................................................................................................................15
Mortality..........................................................................................................................................18
The COPD Service Pathway in Wandsworth........................................................................................22
Service Pathway...............................................................................................................................22
Evidence based guidance.................................................................................................................22
Measuring performance of services....................................................................................................25
Diagnosis.........................................................................................................................................25
Chronic Disease Management.........................................................................................................28
Aggregated measures......................................................................................................................31
Management of Acute Exacerbations..............................................................................................32
Discharge services...........................................................................................................................36
Service costs........................................................................................................................................40
Elements of innovative Service Provision in NHS Wandsworth...........................................................42
Views from local stakeholders.............................................................................................................43
Policy context......................................................................................................................................45
Analysis and Discussion.......................................................................................................................46
Recommendations to improve services...............................................................................................48
Appendix 1: Management Protocols NICE...........................................................................................49
Appendix 2: Management Protocols NHSW........................................................................................51
2
Executive Summary
Burden of disease COPD is a common chronic disease. The prevalence of COPD in Wandsworth is less
than the national average, as a result of the younger population. QOF data reveals 2,700 patients who have been diagnosed with the disease. Modelled
estimates suggest there may be as many as 7,400 patients who have the disease. This suggests a substantial level of under-diagnosis.
Mortality from COPD in Wandsworth is similar to national levels.
COPD Care in Wandsworth The services provided by the borough to manage COPD are well developed, with good
links between primary and secondary care, a well established community nursing team, and a clearly defined pathway.
NHS Wandsworth has clearly defined standards of care that it hopes to achieve, with established evidence based protocols, which are based on national NICE guidance. However it does not have complete systems in place to monitor whether these standards are being met.
The QOF data reveals generally good performance in COPD management in general practice, although it also reveals a small number of GP surgeries that are consistent underperformers across a number of indicators.
There is variability in general practice COPD management across all of the polysystems, and in particular across the potential South Wandsworth Polysystem.
Emergency admission rates are higher than the national average, but lower than the cluster average. There is variation in emergency admission rates between practices. The six practices with a statistically significantly level of emergency admission compared to the average are candidates for investigation and improvement.
While length of stay in hospital for COPD in Wandsworth is above average, readmission rates are lower than average. This suggests there is potential for the improvement of discharge services.
Data on service performance is available, but not complete. Data is available from national sources to allow evaluation of some aspects of services at the primary and secondary level, but there are few local mechanisms to audit services.
Recommendations NHSW should work to understand and reduce the variation in COPD diagnosis and
management between GP practices. Existing practice based commissioning clusters or potential future polysystems should
take local action to deal with specific local areas of poor performance. The PCT needs to work with its partners at St George’s Hospital to strengthen the
nature of discharge provision. The PCT needs to consider expanding existing provision of pulmonary rehabilitation
services, in order to meet the increasingly unmet need for this service. The PCT should work with its community respiratory team to develop systems to
generate stronger measures of process and activity. Audits of COPD management should be undertaken in primary and secondary care,
to measure compliance with local and NICE guidance.COPD in Wandsworth: Health Needs Assessment
3
Aim:To understand the health needs of all patients, of any age, with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in Wandsworth. To use this information, together with information on current services available in Wandsworth, to inform the design of future services for this disease. It will identify any shortfall in service provision and will make recommendations to address any unmet need.
Objectives Collate and synthesise existing knowledge from local, regional and national policy
documents and service plans relating to COPD health services Collate and summarise the available epidemiological data on COPD disease
frequency and risk factors Map and describe the current provision of COPD health services which are
commissioned at the local (Wandsworth), sector (South West London) and regional (London) scale.
o Review access routes to care, and assess the views of the local population on their experiences of existing COPD services
Assess the views of respiratory health staff on:o The needs of the local population o COPD service development needs and any gaps in the current provision of
COPD services Summarise the findings of the needs assessment and make recommendations to
NHS Wandsworth and other providers of COPD services.
4
Background
COPD definition and natural historyThe World Health Organization describes Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) as: “a lung ailment that is characterized by a persistent blockage of airflow from the lungs. It is an under-diagnosed, life-threatening lung disease that interferes with normal breathing and is not fully reversible1.”
Global burdenMore than 80 million people around the world have moderate to severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and more than 3 million people died as a result of it in 2005. This makes it the fifth highest cause of death. Total deaths from COPD are projected to increase by more than 30% in the next 10 years.
National BurdenIn the UK, COPD leads to more than 27,000 deaths per year2, corresponding to 5.7 percent of adult male and 4 percent of adult female deaths. There are currently an estimated 3 million people suffering from COPD in the UK, and only about 900,000 of these patients have been diagnosed and are receiving treatment3.
COPD is responsible for a large number of hospital admissions: more than one million (1,099,440) hospital bed days a year in England4. 1.4% of the population consult their general practitioners (GPs) for COPD each year5. The disease accounts for 2% of hospital admissions and over 3% of bed-days in adults, costing the NHS £800 million, and 13% of a population of COPD patients will be hospitalized in a 3 year period6. Approximately 16% of patients admitted to hospital for COPD will die within three months, and almost a quarter will die within a year after admission7.
There is also a substantial burden of morbidity and economic cost. 60% of COPD patients will report some limitation in the daily activities, with 45% unable to work, and 75% having difficulty climbing stairs8. The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) estimates in 2004 that the direct cost of COPD in England is more than £491 million per year and £982 million per year when including indirect costs. It is the cause of 24 million lost working days each year9.
Risk Factors The main risk factor for COPD is smoking. Between 80% and 90% of people with
COPD are or used to be smokers10. There is also a strong association with deprivation11. This is largely because of the
link between increasing deprivation and increasing smoking rates. COPD is also linked to Industrial exposure, such as gases, dust and vapours at work.
This is estimated at 15% of attributable risk12. In a very small number of cases, COPD is associated with particular genetic
conditions, e.g. Alpha-1 Antitrypsin (AAT) deficiency13. There is debate about whether ethnicity is also a risk factor14.
5
DiagnosisThere is no single diagnostic test for COPD. Making a diagnosis relies on clinical judgement based on a combination of history, physical examination and confirmation of the presence of airflow obstruction using spirometry. Diagnosis of COPD should be considered in any patient who has symptoms of a chronic cough, sputum production, dyspnoea (difficult or laboured breathing) and a history of exposure to risk factors for the disease.
Airflow obstruction is defined as a reduced FEV1 (forced expiratory volume in 1 second) and a reduced FEV1/FVC ratio (where FVC is forced vital capacity), such that FEV1 is less than 80% predicted and FEV1/FVC is less than 0.7. A low peak flow is consistent with COPD, but may not be specific to COPD because it can be caused by other lung diseases and by poor performance during testing. Because COPD develops slowly, it is most frequently diagnosed in people aged 40 years or over.
Treatment There are a number of treatment options for COPD depending on the severity and the nature of the disease. The treatments act to provide symptom relief rather than cure, or reversal of pathology. Pharmacological therapies include inhaled bronchodilators, inhaled or oral corticosteroids and theophyline. These are often given in combination. For patients with more severe disease, long term oxygen therapy and pulmonary rehabilitation are also an important component of treatment. Patients with COPD should also be offered pneumococcal and annual influenza vaccination.
Acute exacerbations of the illness, often caused by bacterial co-infection, require specific management measures, including the use of antibiotics. Guidance for both stable management of the condition and management of exacerbations is described by NICE and discussed more fully in a later section.
6
Burden of disease in WandsworthBurden of disease in Wandsworth can be measured in terms of disease frequency (in the form of prevalence) and mortality.
PrevalencePrevalence levels for COPD can be derived from the general practice Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF), as all patients with a diagnosis of COPD should be on their general practitioner’s COPD register. For Wandsworth PCT, 2740 people were on a COPD register in 2008/09 (a population prevalence of 0.82%). There are significant potential inaccuracies with this data. This method of measuring prevalence relies on the diagnostic accuracy of the GPs in the area. It is likely that there will be significant levels of undiagnosed COPD in the community.
Table 1 below shows that the population prevalence in Wandsworth is lower than the national, London and cluster averages. This is likely to be in part due to the age structure of Wandsworth, where the population is predominantly younger than other parts of the country. An analysis of individual practices demonstrates considerable variation in prevalence between the different practices.
Table 1: Observed COPD Prevalence
Prevalence of COPD (%) 2008/9
England 1.54London SHA 0.97Central London Cluster 1.00Wandsworth PCT 0.82
Source: QOF data, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9Figure 1
SAI M
EDICAL C
ENTR
E
TOOTIN
G BEC SU
RGERY
BALHAM
HEA
LTH CEN
TRE
THE H
ERITA
GE MED
ICAL CEN
TRE
The P
utney
Surge
ry
BATTER
SEA RISE
GROUP PRACTIC
E
TOOTIN
G SOUTH
MED
ICAL CEN
TRE
BALHAM
HILL
MED
ICAL PRACTIC
E
BALHAM
PARK SURGER
Y
THE F
ALCON ROAD M
EDICAL C
ENTR
E
THE F
RANCISCAN SU
RGERY
BEDFO
RD HILL
FAM
ILY PRACTIC
E
THE M
EDICAL C
ENTR
E
ST PAUL'S
COTTAGE P
RACTICE
BATTER
SEA FI
ELDS P
RACTICE
EARLS
FIELD
SURGER
Y
THE H
EATH
BRIDGE P
RACTICE
THE R
OEHAM
PTON SU
RGERY
CHATFIEL
D MED
ICAL CEN
TRE
QUEENST
OWN ROAD M
EDICAL P
RACTICE
STREA
THAM
PARK SURGER
Y
THE S
URGERY
TUDOR LO
DGE HEA
LTH CEN
TRE
MAYF
IELD SU
RGERY0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
Prevalence of COPD in Wandsworth GP practices England
LondonWandsworth
Source: QOF data, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
7
Figure 1 demonstrates the variation in observed COPD rates across practices in the borough. As the PCT is increasing moving its thinking towards a polysystem based approach, this needs assessment will present practice level data, where available, split into the four proposed polysystems that have been outlined, defined as follows:
This variable prevalence can also been broken down by the potential polysystems in Wandsworth, revealing a gradient of prevalence across each of the polysystems.
Figure 2
SAI M
EDIC
AL CE
NTRE
TOOT
ING
BEC
SURG
ERY
MIT
CHAM
ROA
D SU
RGER
YBA
LHAM
HEA
LTH
CENT
RETH
URLE
IGH
ROAD
PRA
CTIC
ETO
OTIN
G SO
UTH
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
BALH
AM H
ILL M
EDICA
L PRA
CTIC
EFU
RZED
OWN
PRIM
ARY
CARE
CEN
TRE
BALH
AM P
ARK
SURG
ERY
THE
GRAY
SWOO
D PR
ACTI
CETH
E FRA
NCISC
AN SU
RGER
YOP
EN D
OOR
SURG
ERY
BEDF
ORD
HILL
FAM
ILY P
RACT
ICE
DR N
ICHO
LAS
& PA
RTNE
RSW
ATER
FALL
HOU
SEST
REAT
HAM
PAR
K SUR
GERY
GRAN
VILL
E RO
AD S
URGE
RYEL
BORO
UGH
STRE
ET S
URGE
RYBR
OCKL
EBAN
K HE
ALTH
CEN
TRE
THE M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
EST
. JOH
N'S
HILL
PRA
CTIC
EEA
RLSF
IELD
SURG
ERY
SOUT
HFIEL
DS G
ROUP
PRA
CTICE
TRIA
NGLE
SUR
GERY
THE
SURG
ERY
THE
HERI
TAGE
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
LAVE
NDER
HILL
SUR
GERY
BATT
ERSE
A RI
SE G
ROUP
PRA
CTIC
ELA
VEND
ER H
ILL G
ROUP
PRA
CTIC
ETH
E FA
LCON
ROA
D M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
ENO
RTHC
OTE
ROAD
SUR
GERY
BATT
ERSE
A FI
ELDS
PRA
CTIC
ECH
ATFIE
LD M
EDICA
L CEN
TRE
BRID
GE LA
NE G
ROUP
PRA
CTIC
EQU
EENS
TOW
N RO
AD M
EDIC
AL PR
ACTIC
E
PUTN
EYM
EAD
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
The
Putn
ey S
urge
ryTH
E SU
RGER
YST
PAUL
'S CO
TTAG
E PR
ACTI
CETH
E HEA
THBR
IDGE
PRAC
TICE
CHAR
TFIE
LD S
URGE
RYTH
E ROE
HAM
PTON
SURG
ERY
THE
ALTO
N PR
ACTI
CEDA
NEBU
RY A
VENU
E SU
RGER
YTU
DOR
LODG
E HE
ALTH
CEN
TRE
South Central North West
0.0%0.2%0.4%0.6%0.8%1.0%1.2%1.4%1.6%1.8% Prevalence of COPD in Wandsworth GP
practices EnglandLondonWandsworth
Source: QOF data, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
8
Observed Vs Modelled PrevalenceAnother method to measure prevalence is to use synthetic estimates of prevalence calculated from data from the 2001 Health Survey for England. This has been done by the Eastern Region Public Health Observatory (ERPHO for all regions of England. In this model, prevalence been adjusted for the adjusted for the age, sex, ethnicity, smoking status and deprivation of the local population.
According to this methodology, the estimated COPD prevalence for the borough of Wandsworth was 7,409 in 2008. This is more than 2.7 times the prevalence from QOF data, suggesting that there is a considerable level of under diagnosis in the community.
Modelled prevalence figures are also available at the practice level, and allow comparison of observed versus modelled prevalence15 (see Figure 3).
Figure 3
GRANVILLE ROAD SU
RGERY
TOOTING BEC SU
RGERY
BALHAM HEALTH CENTRE
PUTNEY MEAN MEDICAL C
ENTRE
OPEN DOOR SURGERY
BALHAM HILL MEDICAL P
RACTICE
THE FALCON ROAD MEDICAL C
ENTRE
BATTERSEA
RISE GROUP PRACTIC
E
BICKERSTETH ROAD SU
RGERY
THE ROEHAMPTON SU
RGERY
BALHAM PARK SURGERY
BATTERSEA
FIELDS P
RACTICE
BEDFORD HILL FAMILY
PRACTICE
THE MEDICAL C
ENTRE
EARLSFIELD
SURGERY
ST. PAUL'S
COTTAGE SU
RGERY
ST. JOHN'S H
ILL PRACTIC
E
STREATHAM PARK SU
RGERY
TRIANGLE SURGERY
QUEENSTO
WN ROAD MEDICAL PRAC...
THE ALTO
N PRACTICE
WATERFALL H
OUSE
INNER PARK ROAD HEALTH CENTRE
TUDOR LODGE H
EALTH CENTRE
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
QOF prevalence vs modelled prevalence for COPD in practices in WandsworthModelled Prevalence QOF prevalence
Prev
alenc
e %
Source: QOF data, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9 and ERPHO, 2008-9
These data demonstrate the existence of variable gaps between observed and expected prevalence in many of the practices. Of concern are a number of practices with very low observed prevalence, but relatively high modelled prevalence. This might suggest variable
9
levels of diagnosis between the practices, and may suggest a list of practices that would benefit from strengthening their diagnostic process and GP awareness.
Looking at the different prevalence by ward, as demonstrated in the maps below, reveals different patterns of prevalence if modelled or measured values are used. In both maps the north and far west of the ward appear to have high prevalence. The modelled prevalence, however, reveals an area of potential high prevalence in the south of the borough, in the more deprived wards of Tooting, Graveney and Furzedown, which do not appear to have been detected by the QOF. Further work would be useful to evaluate whether the model or the QOF records are inaccurate.
This matches national observations, where the overall prevalence of COPD in England is estimated as 1.3 million, of whom as many as 600,000 people may be unaware of their diagnosis, therefore missing the opportunity of benefiting from early interventions16.
10
Figure 4 Prevalence observed by QOF (% of total population on COPD register) (2008-9)
Figure 5 Modelled COPD Prevalence from ERPHO (2008-9) (NB different scales)
11
Future Projections of Prevalence
The Eastern Regional Public Health Observatory has developed estimates and projections of the prevalence of COPD, based on a model developed by Nacul & Soljak3. These projections provide values until 2020.
Figure 6 demonstrates that prevalence both nationally and in Wandsworth is predicted to remain remarkably constant over the next ten years. This figure also demonstrates the lower prevalence in Wandsworth compared to many of the other PCTs in its cluster. This is likely to be a result of the younger population of Wandsworth.
Figure 6
Source: ERPHO, 200917
This pattern of prevalence is observed because the increasing proportion of elderly people is countered by reduced levels of smoking in the population, leading to a relatively flat prevalence of the disease overall in the population over time.
12
Prevalence and inequalities
An analysis of COPD prevalence at the practice level compared with the practice level of deprivation (measured as the local index of multiple deprivation) reveals a very weak association between increasing deprivation and increasing prevalence of the disease.
Figure 7
5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.00.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
R² = 0.018314834572816
Graph of prevalence of COPD against Deprivation Score of Practice
Average IMD of Practice
Prev
alenc
e of C
OPD
Source: QOF data, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9 and London Health Observatory 2009
At the national level, a similar positive correlation between increasing deprivation and increasing prevalence of COPD is observed, but with a stronger correlation. This is mainly due to the relationship between level of deprivation and prevalence of smoking, the main risk factor for COPD.
13
Prevalence and ethnicity
A modelled analysis of prevalence by ethnicity, calculated from Eastern Region model, reveals a variation in prevalence between different ethnic groups. The black population has the highest prevalence (4.6%), the white population has a prevalence of (3.0%), and the Asian population has the lowest prevalence (2.6%).
Figure 8
Asian Black White0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
Modelled Prevalence of COPD by ethnicity in Wandsworth, 2009
WandsworthEngland
Prev
alenc
e (%
)
Source: London Health Observatory Health Needs Assessment Toolkit, 2009
The observed variation in modelled prevalence between different ethnic groups is due to different risk factor distributions between ethnic groups. The main contributing risk factors are smoking and deprivation levels, both of which are higher in the Black population than White and Asian populations.
The difference between modelled COPD prevalence in England compared to Wandsworth is because of local differences in age and risk factor distribution among the various ethnic populations in Wandsworth compared to the national average.
14
Risk factors
SmokingSmoking is thought to have an attributable fraction of between 80 and 90% for COPD18. Understanding the pattern of smoking in Wandsworth is therefore important to understanding the pattern of disease.
Data on smoking prevalence is available from the QOF database, or by using modelled estimates. In comparison with other boroughs, Wandsworth sits at around the London regional average figure when using modelled estimates (Figure 9).
Figure 9
Source: London Health Observatory
Looking at QOF data at the practice level, it is noticeable that there is variation in recorded smoking prevalence from less that 10% to greater than 20%. A comparison between smoking prevalence and social deprivation (Figure 11) reveals a weak positive correlation between increasing deprivation and increasing smoking prevalence. This is in line with existing and historical literature which notes higher levels of smoking at lower levels of socio-economic status. On a national level, this positive correlation is observed more strongly.
These data for prevalence and deprivation are also plotted on maps in Figures 13 and 14.
15
Figure 10
5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.00.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
R² = 0.140187037460234
Smoking prevalence versus deprevation index by GP practices in Wandsworth
Practice average IMD
Smo
kin
g p
reva
len
ce
Source: QOF, 2008-9
The following chart also shows that smoking cessation advice rates in Wandsworth are just below the national average, with 91.9% of patients with disease worsened by smoking having been offered smoking cessation advice, compared to a figure of 92.9% nationally.
Figure 11
Tower Ham
lets PCT
Hamm
ersmith and Fulha...
Camden PCT
Islington PCT
Kensington and Chelsea PCT
Westm
inster PCT
Wandsw
orth Teaching PCT
0102030405060708090
100
% of smokers with COPD, Cardiovascular disease or Dia-betes offered smoking cessation advice in the previous 15
months
EnglandLondon
Source: NCHOD, 2008-9
16
Figure 12 Smoking Prevalence in Wandsworth
Source: London Health Observatory 2008
Figure 13 Deprivation in Wandsworth
Source: London Health Observatory 2008
17
MortalityData from the National Centre for Health Outcomes, calculated from death certificates, allows comparison of mortality rates between Wandsworth, the national, regional averages, and the average figure in demographically similar PCTs.
In Figure 14 we see that overall, mortality rates in Wandsworth are lower than the London and England averages, and similar to the cluster average. However, mortality in the older age groups is higher than the average in Wandsworth.
Figure 14
Overall
1-4
5-14
15-34
35-64
65-74
75+
Overall
1-4
5-14
15-34
35-64
65-74
75+
Overall
1-4
5-14
15-34
35-64
65-74
75+
MALES FEMALES PERSONS
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Age specific mortality rates for COPD in dif -ferent geographical areas
England
Deat
h Ra
te P
er 1
00,0
00
Source: NCHOD, 2005-7
Mortality rates from COPD are noticable in their consistancy with observed patterns at the London and national levels. It is not however, possible to tell if there is any statistically significant difference from these figures.
Another figure (Figure 15) from the LHO allows us to look at mortality rates across the London Boroughs. Here we see that Wandsworth sits close to the London average, and certainly not significantly different from the average.
18
Figure 15
Source: London Health Observatory, 2005-2007
Patterns of change in mortality over time demonstrate that Wandsworth is following the established national patterns, with mortality in males falling considerably over the past 15 years, while mortality in females has remained roughly constant (Figure 16). This gender specific pattern is thought to be related to changes in risk factor exposure between genders. The smoking rate in men has been falling considerably faster than smoking rate in women over the last 40 years.
19
Figure 16
1993199419951996199719981999200020012002200320042005200620072008
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Directly Age standardized mortality rate for COPD in men and women
England FemaleLondon FemaleLondon centre femaleWandsworth FemaleEngland MaleLondon MaleLondon Centre MaleWandsworth MaleM
orta
lity R
ate
per 1
00,0
00
Source: NCHOD, 2009
Figure 17
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Directly Standardized mortality rate for COPD (both genders)
ENGLANDLONDONLONDON CENTREWandsworth
Mor
talit
y Ra
te p
er 1
00,0
00
Source: NCHOD, 2009
The current level of deaths in Wandsworth from COPD per year is recorded as 90 in 2008, although COPD is likely to be a contributory factor is a considerably large number of deaths. The breakdown of the age and gender of these deaths can be seen in Table 2.
20
Table 2 Numbers of COPD deaths in Wandsworth (2008)
Total1-4
years5-14 years
15-34 years
35-64 years
65-74 years
75+ years
MALES 41 0 0 0 * * 22
FEMALES 49 0 0 0 * * 41PERSONS 90 0 0 0 * * 63
Source: NCHOD, 2009
* represents numbers that have been suppressed for reasons of confidentiality due to small numbers.
21
The COPD Service Pathway in Wandsworth
Service PathwayWandsworth has a stated service pathway for people with COPD. This is adapted from the pathway set out by the East of England SHA.
The service is based around three escalating levels of clinical care: Primary Care, Specialist care and supra specialist care. At each stage there are suggested diagnostic procedures and treatments that should be decided by the patient and clinician in a shared decision making process on as a part of a care plan.
Community care is delivered by in general practice, supplemented by a team of 4.4 WTE equivalent specialist respiratory nurses. These specialist nurses work closely with GPs and the Respiratory Service at St George’s Hospital.
The respiratory nurses run a network of clinics at a number of practices around the borough. They work with named GP practices, to develop skills of practice teams in managing patients with COPD. They also work with less well patients at home, managing acute exacerbations, working with patients recently discharged from the hospital, and monitoring at risk patients, including through the use of the Telehealth service.
The Respiratory Service at St George’s Hospital is delivered by a team of specialist clinicians, included a nurse consultant, specialist nurses, respiratory consultants and a wider team of associated health professionals.
Evidence based guidance
NICE GuidanceEstablished standards of Care for COPD in primary care have been established, in the form of NICE guidance19. This guidance includes a number of factors, including the initial diagnosis and management of the disease, going on to cover management of acute exacerbations. NICE guidance is available in Appendix 1.
Wandsworth also has specific protocols for the management of stable COPD and acute exacerbations of COPD. These are set out in the Appendix 2. These protocols are designed to incorporate the national NICE guidance.
22
NICE PrioritiesThe following areas were highlighted by the NICE guidance as priorities for implementation:
Diagnose COPD• A diagnosis of COPD should be considered in patients over the age of 35 who
have a risk factor (generally smoking) and who present with exertional breathlessness, chronic cough, regular sputum production, frequent winter ‘bronchitis’ or wheeze.
• The presence of airflow obstruction should be confirmed by performing spirometry. All health professionals managing patients with COPD should have access to spirometry and be competent in the interpretation of the results.
Stop smoking• Encouraging patients with COPD to stop smoking is one of the most important
components of their management. All COPD patients still smoking, regardless of age, should be encouraged to stop, and offered help to do so, at every opportunity.
Effective inhaled therapy• Long-acting inhaled bronchodilators (beta2-agonists or anticholinergics) should
be used to control symptoms and improve exercise capacity in patients who continue to experience problems despite the use of short-acting drugs.
• Inhaled corticosteroids should be added to long-acting bronchodilators to decrease exacerbation frequency in patients with an FEV1 less than or equal to 50% predicted who have had two or more exacerbations requiring treatment with antibiotics or oral corticosteroids in a 12-month period.
Pulmonary rehabilitation for all who need it• Pulmonary rehabilitation should be made available to all appropriate patients
with COPD.
Use non-invasive ventilation• Non-invasive ventilation (NIV) should be used as the treatment of choice for
persistent hypercapnic ventilatory failure during exacerbations not responding to medical therapy. It should be delivered by staff trained in its application, experienced in its use and aware of its limitations.
• When patients are started on NIV, there should be a clear plan covering what to do in the event of deterioration and ceilings of therapy should be agreed.
Manage exacerbations• The frequency of exacerbations should be reduced by appropriate use of
inhaled corticosteroids and bronchodilators, and vaccinations.• The impact of exacerbations should be minimised by:
– giving self-management advice on responding promptly to the symptoms of an exacerbation
– starting appropriate treatment with oral steroids and/or antibiotics– use of NIV when indicated– use of hospital-at-home or assisted-discharge schemes.
23
Multidisciplinary working• COPD care should be delivered by a multidisciplinary team.
Since the introduction of the NICE guidance on the diagnosis and management of the disease, it has issued further specific guidance on the issues of early discharge and pulmonary rehabilitation.
Early assisted discharge schemesNICE has set out specific criteria for the commissioning of early assisted discharged schemes20.
The key components of an effective assisted-discharge service for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are:
full assessment of the patient within secondary care to determine if they are appropriate to receive assisted-discharge
support in the community for patients deemed appropriate for assisted-discharge developing a high-quality assisted-discharge service.
Pulmonary rehabilitationNICE has set out specific criteria for the provision of pulmonary rehab services schemes21.
24
Measuring performance of services
The performance of the COPD services can be measured through evaluation of a number of indicators. These include both outcome indicators and process indicators. Some of these indicators include data derived at the general practice level from the QOF system; other indicators included data from hospitals about inpatient admissions from the Hospital Episode Statistics.
Different measures are available to consider different parts of service performance. In some areas, there is a lack of data about the quality of the service available.
Diagnosis
Key Performance Measure: FEV1 MeasuredForced expiratory Volume over 1 second is a key test for diagnosis of COPD. It is useful to compare restrictive versus obstructive lung disease, and as a measure of degree of obstruction. Ideally, all patients suspected of, or diagnosed with COPD, should undergo spirometry. Those patients with known disease benefit from monitoring of FEV1, to monitor disease progression.
As the proportion of patients with a diagnosis of COPD with a recent measure of FEV1 is measured routinely in the QOF system, data is available on a practice by practice level.
Figure 18
MIT
CHAM
ROA
D SU
RGER
YFU
RZED
OWN
PRIM
ARY C
ARE C
ENTR
ETH
E GRA
YSW
OOD
PRAC
TICE
THE F
RANC
ISCA
N SU
RGER
YBE
DFOR
D HI
LL FA
MIL
Y PRA
CTIC
EDR
NIC
HOLA
S & P
ARTN
ERS
TOOT
ING
SOUT
H M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
ETO
OTIN
G BE
C SU
RGER
YBA
LHAM
HEA
LTH
CENT
REBA
LHAM
PAR
K SU
RGER
YST
REAT
HAM
PAR
K SU
RGER
YBA
LHAM
HIL
L MED
ICAL
PRA
CTIC
EW
ATER
FALL
HOU
SEOP
EN D
OOR
SURG
ERY
THUR
LEIG
H RO
AD P
RACT
ICE
SAI M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
E
GRAN
VILL
E ROA
D SU
RGER
YEA
RLSF
IELD
SURG
ERY
THE S
URGE
RYTH
E MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
ST. J
OHN'
S HIL
L PRA
CTIC
ESO
UTHF
IELD
S GRO
UP P
RACT
ICE
BROC
KLEB
ANK
HEAL
TH C
ENTR
EEL
BORO
UGH
STRE
ET SU
RGER
YTR
IANG
LE SU
RGER
Y
NORT
HCOT
E ROA
D SU
RGER
YLA
VEND
ER H
ILL S
URGE
RYLA
VEND
ER H
ILL G
ROUP
PRA
CTIC
ECH
ATFI
ELD
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
BATT
ERSE
A FI
ELDS
PRA
CTIC
EQU
EENS
TOW
N RO
AD M
EDIC
AL
PRAC
TICE
BRID
GE LA
NE G
ROUP
PRA
CTIC
EBA
TTER
SEA
RISE
GRO
UP P
RACT
ICE
THE F
ALCO
N RO
AD M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
ETH
E HER
ITAG
E MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
THE R
OEHA
MPT
ON SU
RGER
YTH
E HEA
THBR
IDGE
PRA
CTIC
ECH
ARTF
IELD
SURG
ERY
DANE
BURY
AVE
NUE S
URGE
RYIN
NER
PARK
ROA
D HE
ALTH
CEN
TRE
THE S
URGE
RYPU
TNEY
MEA
D M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
ETH
E ALT
ON P
RACT
ICE
THE P
UTNE
Y SUR
GERY
MAY
FIEL
D SU
RGER
YTU
DOR
LODG
E HEA
LTH
CENT
REST
PAU
L'S C
OTTA
GE P
RACT
ICE
South Central North West
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
% of patients with COPD with a record of FeV1 by GP practice in Wandsworth
EnglandWandsworth
Source: Quality and Outcomes Framework, NHS information Centre, 2008-2009
25
It is also possible to observe an inverse correlation between increasing FEV1 measurement and deprivation index of practices.
Here appetent is observed with central, relatively flat plateau of moderate performance, with a small number of practices that perform very well, and a small number that perform considerably less well.
Figure 19
5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.00%
10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
R² = 0.0576884763315211
The percentage of patients with COPD with a record of FeV1 by deprevation index of practice
Average IMD of GP PracticesThe p
erce
ntag
e of p
atien
ts wi
th CO
PD
with
a re
cord
of F
eV1 i
n th
e pre
vious
15
mon
ths
Source: Quality and Outcomes Framework, NHS information Centre, 2008-2009 and NHS Comparators 2008-9
It is also possible to create a chart of aggregated QOF scores, looking across each of the clinical indicators relate to COPD, and comparing scores. Again a pattern of variation in performance occurs. It is noticeable that while some practices are poor at only one or two indicators, there are a number of practices that are consistently poor performing. These practices are potential areas for concern, and might benefit from target education or audit, to better understand their current practices, and improve the quality of care they provide.
26
Key Performance Measure: Post Bronchodilator spirometryNICE guidance suggests that a diagnosis of COPD would be confirmed by the used off post bronchodilator spirometry, which acts to differentiate reversible from irreversible airway obstruction.
Figure 20 shows the variation in QOF achievement in this area. It is noticeable that in these clinical criteria many practices score 100%, while a number of practices (8) score 0%. It would be useful to investigate this phenomenon, and see if these practices truly are not providing this service, or the service is being provided elsewhere, or the practices are recording what they have done incorrectly.
Figure 20
TOOT
ING BE
C SUR
GERY
FURZ
EDOW
N PRIM
ARY C
ARE C
ENTR
ETH
E FRA
NCISC
AN SU
RGER
YBA
LHAM
HEAL
TH CE
NTRE
SAI M
EDICA
L CEN
TRE
DR NI
CHOL
AS &
PART
NERS
THE G
RAYSW
OOD P
RACT
ICEBA
LHAM
PARK
SURG
ERY
MITC
HAM
ROAD
SURG
ERY
TOOT
ING SO
UTH M
EDICA
L CEN
TRE
BEDF
ORD H
ILL FA
MILY
PRAC
TICE
STREA
THAM
PARK
SURG
ERY
WATER
FALL
HOUS
EBA
LHAM
HILL
MEDIC
AL PR
ACTIC
ETH
URLEI
GH RO
AD PR
ACTIC
EOP
EN DO
OR SU
RGER
Y
GRAN
VILLE
ROAD
SURG
ERY
EARL
SFIELD
SURG
ERY
ST. JO
HN'S H
ILL PR
ACTIC
ESO
UTHF
IELDS
GROU
P PRA
CTICE
THE M
EDICA
L CEN
TRE
THE S
URGE
RYBR
OCKL
EBAN
K HEA
LTH CE
NTRE
ELBOR
OUGH
STRE
ET SU
RGER
YTR
IANGL
E SUR
GERY
NORT
HCOT
E ROA
D SUR
GERY
LAVE
NDER
HILL
SURG
ERY
BRIDG
E LAN
E GRO
UP PR
ACTIC
ELA
VEND
ER HI
LL GR
OUP P
RACT
ICECH
ATFIE
LD M
EDICA
L CEN
TRE
QUEEN
STOWN
ROAD
MED
ICAL
PRAC
TICE
BATTE
RSEA
FIELD
S PRA
CTICE
BATTE
RSEA
RISE
GROU
P PRA
CTICE
THE F
ALCO
N ROA
D MED
ICAL C
ENTR
ETH
E HER
ITAGE
MED
ICAL C
ENTR
E
THE H
EATH
BRIDG
E PRA
CTICE
MAYFI
ELD SU
RGER
YTH
E ROE
HAMP
TON S
URGE
RYDA
NEBU
RY AV
ENUE
SURG
ERY
THE S
URGE
RYPU
TNEYM
EAD M
EDICA
L CEN
TRE
CHAR
TFIELD
SURG
ERY
THE A
LTON P
RACT
ICEINN
ER PA
RK RO
AD HE
ALTH
CENT
RETH
E PUT
NEY S
URGE
RYTU
DOR L
ODGE
HEAL
TH CE
NTRE
ST PA
UL'S C
OTTA
GE PR
ACTIC
E
South Central North West
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
% of patients with COPD with diagnosis confirmed by post bronchodilator spiro-
metry England Wandsworth
Source: Quality and Outcomes Framework, NHS information Centre, 2008-2009
As these interventions are evidence based, it is likely that those scoring higher score on the QOF will provide higher quality care, and lead to better outcomes.
27
Chronic Disease ManagementData on chronic disease management would ideally look at the proportion of patients diagnosed with COPD who are prescribed the appropriate medications. The current data collected by QOF does not measure this, although a useful proxy is STAR-PU (specific therapeutic group age-sex related prescribing units, a standardized measure of prescribing for COPD. An analysis at the practice level shows that there is a correlation between increasing prevalence of disease and increasing use of appropriate medications. There are however some outliers, including one practice which prescribes higher than average amounts of the drug, despite a lower than average prevalence, and two practices which prescribe relatively low levels of the appropriate drugs, despite higher prevalence levels.
Figure 21 Key measure: Prescribing data
0.0% 0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5%0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
f(x) = 26.47496652201 x + 0.571799576436556R² = 0.278821522979054
Graph of STAR-PU for COPD related drugs against prevalence of COPD by practice in
Wandsworth
Prevalence
STAR
-PU
Source: NHS Comparators 2008-9 and QOF 2008-9
28
Key Measure: Inhaler TechniqueThe QOF system measures the percentage of patients in each practice who have their inhaler technique assessed. Figure 22 demonstrates that levels are high in most practices, but does identify 6 practices with levels less than 80%.
Figure 22
TOOT
ING
BEC
SU
RGER
YTH
E FRA
NCI
SCAN
SU
RGER
YFU
RZED
OW
N P
RIM
ARY
CARE
CEN
TRE
DR
NIC
HO
LAS
& P
ARTN
ERS
THE G
RAYS
WO
OD
PRA
CTIC
ETO
OTIN
G S
OUTH
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
STRE
ATH
AM P
ARK
SURG
ERY
BED
FORD
HIL
L FA
MIL
Y PR
ACTI
CEO
PEN
DO
OR
SURG
ERY
BALH
AM P
ARK
SURG
ERY
THUR
LEIG
H R
OAD
PRA
CTIC
EW
ATER
FALL
HO
USE
BALH
AM H
EALT
H C
ENTR
ESA
I MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
MITC
HAM
RO
AD S
URG
ERY
BALH
AM H
ILL
MED
ICAL
PRA
CTIC
E
GRA
NVI
LLE
ROAD
SU
RGER
YEA
RLSF
IELD
SU
RGER
YSO
UTH
FIEL
DS G
ROU
P PR
ACTI
CEBR
OCKL
EBAN
K HE
ALTH
CEN
TRE
THE S
URG
ERY
THE M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
ETR
IAN
GLE
SURG
ERY
ST. J
OHN
'S H
ILL
PRAC
TICE
ELBO
ROU
GH S
TREE
T SU
RGER
Y
BATT
ERSE
A FI
ELD
S PR
ACTI
CELA
VEN
DER
HIL
L GR
OU
P PR
ACTI
CEBR
IDG
E LA
NE
GRO
UP
PRAC
TICE
THE H
ERIT
AGE
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
LAVE
ND
ER H
ILL
SURG
ERY
THE F
ALCO
N RO
AD M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
ECH
ATFI
ELD
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
QU
EEN
STO
WN
ROA
D M
EDIC
AL P
RACT
ICE
BATT
ERSE
A RI
SE G
ROU
P PR
ACTI
CEN
ORT
HCO
TE R
OAD
SU
RGER
Y
DAN
EBU
RY A
VENU
E SU
RGER
YCH
ARTF
IELD
SU
RGER
YTH
E HEA
THBR
IDGE
PRA
CTIC
ETH
E ROE
HAM
PTON
SU
RGER
YTU
DOR
LOD
GE
HEAL
TH C
ENTR
ETH
E ALT
ON
PRA
CTIC
ETH
E SU
RGER
YM
AYFI
ELD
SU
RGER
YTH
E PUT
NEY
SU
RGER
YPU
TNEY
MEA
D M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
EST
PAU
L'S
COTT
AGE
PRAC
TICE
INNE
R PA
RK R
OAD
HEA
LTH
CEN
TRE
South Central North West
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
% of patients with COPD whose inhaler technique has been checked
England Wandsworth
Source: Quality and Outcomes Framework, NHS Information Centre, 2008-2009
29
Key Measure: Influenza immunization ratesPatients with COPD are in a higher risk group for influenza and other communicable disease. Evidence based guidance suggests that patients with COPD should be offered the influenza vaccine. Mortality rates for those with COPD from influenza are higher than those who do not have COPD. Figure 23 demonstrates variation between practices, of which 8 score less than 80% and 3 less than 70%.
Figure 23
TOOT
ING
SO
UTH
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
TOOT
ING
BEC
SUR
GERY
THE F
RAN
CISC
AN S
URG
ERY
FURZ
EDOW
N P
RIM
ARY
CARE
CEN
TRE
DR
NIC
HO
LAS
& P
ARTN
ERS
BALH
AM P
ARK
SURG
ERY
THUR
LEIG
H R
OAD
PRA
CTIC
EST
REAT
HAM
PAR
K SU
RGER
YBE
DFO
RD H
ILL
FAM
ILY
PRAC
TICE
WAT
ERFA
LL H
OU
SEBA
LHAM
HIL
L M
EDIC
AL P
RACT
ICE
THE G
RAYS
WO
OD
PRAC
TICE
OPE
N D
OOR
SURG
ERY
BALH
AM H
EALT
H CE
NTR
ESA
I MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
MITC
HAM
RO
AD S
URG
ERY
THE M
EDIC
AL C
ENTR
EEA
RLSF
IELD
SU
RGER
YTH
E SU
RGER
YST
. JO
HN'
S H
ILL
PRAC
TICE
BROC
KLEB
ANK
HEA
LTH
CEN
TRE
ELBO
ROU
GH
STR
EET S
URG
ERY
TRIA
NG
LE S
URG
ERY
SOUT
HFI
ELD
S G
ROUP
PRA
CTIC
EG
RAN
VILL
E RO
AD S
URG
ERY
NO
RTH
COTE
RO
AD S
URG
ERY
QU
EEN
STO
WN
RO
AD M
EDIC
AL P
RACT
ICE
BRID
GE
LAN
E G
ROU
P PR
ACTI
CECH
ATFI
ELD
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
BATT
ERSE
A FI
ELDS
PRA
CTIC
ELA
VEN
DER
HIL
L SU
RGER
YBA
TTER
SEA
RISE
GRO
UP
PRAC
TICE
LAVE
ND
ER H
ILL
GRO
UP
PRAC
TICE
THE F
ALCO
N R
OAD
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
THE H
ERIT
AGE
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
PUTN
EYM
EAD
MED
ICAL
CEN
TRE
THE S
URG
ERY
THE R
OEH
AMPT
ON
SURG
ERY
MAY
FIEL
D S
URG
ERY
THE A
LTON
PRA
CTIC
ECH
ARTF
IELD
SU
RGER
YD
ANEB
URY
AVE
NU
E SU
RGER
YTU
DOR
LOD
GE
HEA
LTH
CEN
TRE
INNE
R PA
RK R
OAD
HEA
LTH
CEN
TRE
THE H
EATH
BRID
GE
PRAC
TICE
ST P
AUL'
S CO
TTAG
E PR
ACTI
CETH
E PU
TNEY
SU
RGER
Y
South Central North West
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
% of patients with COPD who have had influenza immun-isation
England Wandsworth
Source: Quality and Outcomes Framework, NHS Information Centre, 2008-2009
30
Aggregated measuresA number of different measures can be aggregated together, to provide a snapshot of overall performance at the general practice level. It is noticeable that there are a number of PCTs that perform poorly across a number of indicators. These are practices that might benefit from targeted education around TB diagnosis and management.
TOOT
ING BE
C SUR
GERY
FURZE
DOWN
PRIM
ARY C
ARE
CENTRE
THE F
RANC
ISCAN
SURG
ERYBA
LHAM
HEALT
H CEN
TREDR
NICH
OLAS
& PAR
TNERS
THE G
RAYSW
OOD P
RACTI
CESAI
MED
ICAL C
ENTRE
MITCH
AM RO
AD SU
RGERY
TOOT
ING SO
UTH M
EDICA
L CEN
TREBED
FORD
HILL
FAMILY
PRAC
TICE
BALH
AM PA
RK SU
RGERY
STREAT
HAM
PARK
SURG
ERYWA
TERFAL
L HOU
SEBA
LHAM
HILL
MEDIC
AL PR
ACTIC
ETH
URLEI
GH RO
AD PR
ACTIC
EOP
EN DO
OR SU
RGERY
GRAN
VILLE
ROAD
SURG
ERYEAR
LSFIEL
D SUR
GERY
ST. JO
HN'S H
ILL PR
ACTIC
ESO
UTHF
IELDS
GROU
P PRA
CTICE
THE M
EDICA
L CEN
TRETH
E SUR
GERY
BROC
KLEBA
NK HE
ALTH C
ENTRE
ELBOR
OUGH
STREE
T SUR
GERY
TRIAN
GLE S
URGE
RYNO
RTHCO
TE RO
AD SU
RGERY
LAVEN
DER H
ILL SU
RGERY
BRIDG
E LAN
E GRO
UP PR
ACTIC
ELAV
ENDE
R HILL
GROU
P PRA
CTICE
CHATF
IELD M
EDICA
L CEN
TREQU
EENSTO
WN RO
AD M
EDICA
L PR
ACTIC
EBA
TTERSE
A FIEL
DS PR
ACTIC
EBA
TTERSE
A RISE
GROU
P PRA
CTICE
THE F
ALCON
ROAD
MED
ICAL
CENTRE
THE H
ERITAG
E MED
ICAL C
ENTRE
THE R
OEHA
MPTO
N SUR
GERY
THE H
EATHB
RIDGE
PRAC
TICE
DANE
BURY
AVEN
UE SU
RGERY
MAYFI
ELD SU
RGERY
THE S
URGE
RYPU
TNEYM
EAD M
EDICA
L CEN
TRECH
ARTFI
ELD SU
RGERY
THE A
LTON P
RACTI
CEINN
ER PA
RK RO
AD HE
ALTH
CENTRE
THE P
UTNE
Y SUR
GERY
TUDO
R LOD
GE HE
ALTH C
ENTRE
ST PA
UL'S C
OTTAG
E PRA
CTICE
0%50%
100%150%200%250%300%350%400%
Composite chart of COPD QOF indicators for GP practices in Wandsworth % of pa-
tients with COPD with diagnosis confirmed by post bron-chodilator spirometry
% of pa-tients with COPD whose in-haler technique has been checked
% of pa-tients with COPD with a record of FeV1
Source: QOF data, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
31
Management of Acute Exacerbations
Key measure: Emergency Admissions Emergency admission rates are a useful process measure that reflects the quality of chronic disease management in the community. All patients with COPD are exposed to risk of acute exacerbations, requiring hospital admission, but ideally there should be developed plans in place in the community for when exacerbations takes place, so that patients either have pre-prescribed medication available, or have rapid access to primary care including the support of respiratory specialist nurses. Higher rates of emergency admission suggest poorer management of the disease in the community.
An analysis of emergency admission rates reveals that admissions per 1000 people are higher in Wandsworth (2.3 per 1,000) than the national average (2.0 per 1,000), but lower than the cluster average (2.7 per 1,000).
Figure 24
Kens
ingt
on an
d Che
lsea P
CT
Wes
tmin
ster P
CT
Wan
dswo
rth PC
T
Ham
mer
smith
and F
ulha
m PC
T
Islin
gton
PCT
Cam
den P
CT
Towe
r Ham
lets P
CT
0123456
Emergency Admission rate for COPD in the London Centre Cluster
EnglandCluster average
Age s
tand
arize
d em
erge
ncy A
dmiss
ion ra
te pe
r 1,0
00
Source: NHS comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
Again, there is also a pattern of variation between individual practices. Using data from NHS comparators, six practices can be identified as having emergency admission rates for patients with COPD that are significantly higher than both the Wandsworth and the national average.
32
Figure 25D
r Nic
hola
s &
Par
tner
sSa
i Med
ical
Cen
tre
Wan
dsw
orth
Prim
ary
Extr
a Se
rvic
eO
pen
Doo
r Sur
gery
Wan
dsw
orth
Med
ical C
entr
eN
orth
cote
Roa
d Su
rger
yTh
e Su
rger
y, B
alm
uir G
arde
nsBa
lham
Hea
lth C
entre
Clap
ham
Junc
tion
Med
ical
Pra
ctice
The
Her
itage
Med
ical
Cen
tre
Putn
eym
ead
Med
ical
Cent
reTr
iang
le S
urge
ryPu
tney
mea
d M
edic
al Ce
ntre
Sout
hfiel
ds G
roup
Pra
ctice
St. J
ohn'
s H
ill P
racti
ceBa
tter
sea
Rise
Gro
up P
racti
ceCh
artf
ield
Sur
gery
The
Alto
n Pr
actic
eFu
rzed
own
Prim
ary C
are
Cent
reBa
lham
Hill
Med
ical
Pra
ctice
The
Hea
thbr
idge
Pra
ctice
St P
aul's
Cott
age
Prac
tice
St Jo
hns
Balh
am P
ark
Surg
ery
May
field
Sur
gery
Thur
leig
h Ro
ad P
racti
ceG
ranv
ille
Road
Sur
gery
Bedf
ord
Hill
Fam
ily P
racti
ceTh
e G
reys
woo
d Pr
actic
eSt
reat
ham
Par
k Su
rger
yD
aneb
ury
Aven
ue S
urge
ryD
r Nic
hola
s &
Par
tner
sTh
e Ro
eham
pton
Sur
gery
Chatf
ield
Med
ical
Cen
tre
Tudo
r Lod
ge H
ealth
Cen
tre
Que
enst
own
Road
Med
ical
Pra
ctice
Inne
r Par
k Ro
ad H
ealth
Cen
tre
Lave
nder
Hill
Gro
up P
racti
ceBr
idge
Lan
e G
roup
Pra
ctice
Tooti
ng S
outh
Med
ical C
entr
eBa
tter
sea
Fiel
ds P
racti
ceEa
rlsfie
ld S
urge
ryEl
boro
ugh
Stre
et S
urge
ryBr
ockl
eban
k G
roup
Pra
ctice
The
Falc
on R
oad
Med
ical
Cen
tre
Mitc
ham
Roa
d Su
rger
yW
ater
fall
Hou
seTo
oting
Bec
Sur
gery
The
Fran
cisc
an S
urge
ry
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Emergency Admissions with COPD for GP practices in Wandsworth per 1000 population
England Wandsworth
Age
Stan
dard
ized
Adm
issio
n ra
te p
er 1
,000
Source: NHS comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
There is considerable variation in emergency admission rates between practices across the borough, suggesting that some GPs are managing their patients in the community better that others. It is noticeable that six practices have an admission rate that is significantly higher than the Wandsworth average.
33
Figure 26
Source: NHS Comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
Figure 27
50.0% 100.0% 150.0% 200.0% 250.0% 300.0% 350.0% 400.0%0
2
4
6
8
10
12
QOF achievement against emergency ad-mission rate by GP practice in Wandsworth
Aggregated score of QOF achievement for COPD indicators
Emer
genc
y COP
D ad
miss
ion
rate
per
1,0
00
34
Figure 27 indicates that some of those practices with high emergency admission rates are also those with poor achievement on the QOF score. Conversely, some practices with low admission rates also have low QOF scores, so it is hard to make an association between the two variables.
Those practices with the highest admission rates are also not necessarily the most deprived (as demonstrated in Figure 28). It is hard to see a positive correlation between deprivation and emergency admission.
Figure 28
5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.00
2
4
6
8
10
12
R² = 0.0474120797916923
Deprivation level against emergency admission rates for COPD patients by GP practice in
Wandsworth
Index of Multiple DeprivationEmerg
ency
COPD
admi
ssion
rate
per 1
,000
Source: NHS Comparators 2008-2009, LHO 2009
35
Discharge services
Key measure: Length of Stay
Length of stay in hospital for acute admissions is a useful process measure that reflects on the quality of discharge management in the hospital. Ideally patients would be diagnosed from hospital as soon as possible, but only once the current episode has been adequately treated, and when a robust discharge plan is in place, including appropriate levels of support in the community.
Length of stay in hospital with COPD in Wandsworth does appear to be higher than the London average. The cluster average length of stay is higher than both London and national averages, perhaps reflecting the higher proportion of complex cases and deprivation in the central London cluster, but the Wandsworth average is still just statistically significantly above this.
Newham PCTHillingdon PCTBrent Teaching PCTHounslow PCTEaling PCTHarrow PCTBarnet PCTGreenwich Teachi...Lambeth PCTBarking and Dag...Havering PCTRedbridge PCTBromley PCTRichmond and Tw...Bexley CTHammersmith and...Lewisham PCTW
altham Forest PCTSouthwark PCTKensington and C...Sutton and Merto...W
estminster PCTEnfield PCTCamden PCTIslington PCTCroydon PCTHaringey Teaching...W
andsworth PCTTower Hamlets PCTKingston PCTCity and Hackney ...
6.8
7
7.2
7.4
7.6
7.8
8
Average Length of Stay for Emergency COPD admissions in London PCTs
2008/9
London Av-erage
Mean
Leng
th of
Stay
(day
s)
Source: NHS Comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
Looking at data at the practice level, it possible to see that there are a small number of practices that have a much higher length of stay than the others, including one significant outlier (Northcote Road Surgery). In part this is a reflection of very small numbers of cases,
36
or even individuals, in some places that have spent a prolonged period in hospital. However, in some other practices with long stays there have been a number of different admission, perhaps reflecting a systematic difficulty in arranging discharge to certain locations.
Dr Nicholas & PartnersSai Medical CentreThe Wandle Valley SurgerySt. John's Hill PracticeOpen Door SurgeryWandsworth Medical Ce...Triangle SurgeryThe Surgery, Balmuir Gar...Elborough Street SurgeryBattersea Fields PracticeBalham Park SurgeryFurzedown Primary Care ...Mitcham Road SurgeryPutneymead Medical Ce...The Heathbridge PracticeTooting Bec SurgeryBalham Health CentreQueenstown Road Medica...Earlsfield SurgeryStreatham Park SurgeryBedford Hill Family PracticeChartfield SurgeryPutneymead Medical Ce...Inner Park Road Health C...Granville Road SurgeryThe Greyswood PracticeChatfield Medical CentreThurleigh Road PracticeSt JohnsThe Bec Family PracticeMayfield SurgeryBrocklebank Group Prac...Bridge Lane Group PracticeSt Paul's Cottage PracticeThe Franciscan SurgeryLavender Hill Group Prac...The Falcon Road Medical...Tooting South Medical C...Danebury Avenue SurgeryDr Nicholas & PartnersThe Heritage Medical Ce...The Roehampton SurgeryTudor Lodge Health CentreSouthfields Group PracticeWaterfall HouseThe Alton PracticeBattersea Rise Group Pra...Clapham Junction Medica...Balham Hill Medical Prac...Northcote Road Surgery
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70Average Length of Stay for Emergency COPD
Admissions by practice in Wandsworth 2008/2009 London Av...
Mean
Length
of sta
y (Days
)
Source: NHS Comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
37
Key Measure: Readmission rates
Readmission rates for patients with COPD are a useful process measure of the quality of discharge coordination services, and support in the community. A well coordinated service would aim to keep readmission to a low level, as patients are only diagnosed when their initial symptoms are adequately treated, and they are discharged into a secure community environment, where appropriate levels of care are available.
Figure 27 shows that Wandsworth does well, with readmission rates lower than the London and England Average. This suggests that although our patients are admitted for slightly longer than average, the extra time is hospital is put to good use, as our discharges are better planned and supported, and less discharges fail and require readmission to hospital.
Figure 29
Barnet P
CT
Hillingdon PCT
City and Hack
ney Tea
ching PCT
Barking a
nd Dagenham
PCT
Wandsworth
PCT
Haringey
Teach
ing PCT
Newham
PCT
Croydon PCT
Kensingto
n and Chels
ea PCT
Tower Ham
lets PCT
Hammers
mith an
d Fulham
PCT
Waltham
Fores
t PCT
Enfield PCT
Southwark PCT
Lewish
am PCT
Sutton and M
erton PCT
05
101520253035
Readmissions within 28 days for COPD emergency admissions
LondonEngland
% of
adm
issio
n re
adm
itted
with
in 2
8 da
ys
Source: NHS Comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
38
Pulmonary Rehabilitation
It is thought that it the new national strategy for pulmonary rehabilitation will call for increased availability of pulmonary rehabilitation. A detailed report on this has been done on this by Piers Simey, at St George’s Hospital.
The key findings of this report are that the total current estimated capacity of these services is 168 (134 at St Georges and 34 at Queen Mary’s) people per year, while the total estimated annual need for these services in Wandsworth is at least 666, and possibly up to 1638, people with COPD. This means that there is at least a fourfold gap between service need and service capacity for Wandsworth residents.
This report also states that there is currently a 3 month average waiting list for pulmonary rehabilitation at St George’s (our largest provider), with a similar figure at Queen Mary’s.
The report goes on to recommend that that extra pulmonary rehab capacity is commissioned in Wandsworth from 2010/11 with ongoing service evaluation.
It further states that: Capacity needs to increase during 2010/11 to meet the needs of those already
identified with COPD. Capacity will also need to increase in future years as the case finding interventions in the COPD National Strategy take effect
Local rehabilitation services need to demonstrate that they are effective Services need to be geographically accessible and promoted in primary care Extra capacity should include two new programmes in the community and an extra
class at St George’s.
For further details please refer to the report: Pulmonary Rehabilitation Needs Assessment in Wandsworth, by Piers Simey.
Assisted discharge
The respiratory team at St George’s Hospital endeavour to provide a discharge service to those patients admitted to the hospital with a known diagnosis of COPD. However they are aware that they are not able to identify all such patients admitted. The team is in the process of working towards a structured assisted discharge service working to NICE standards. Further work will need to be undertaken to map the existing service to NICE guidance.
39
Service costs
Exact data on expenditure on COPD is difficult to calculate. It is possible to calculate costs in secondary care associated with COPD related admission from the payments by results tariff. One method which might also an estimation of costing is the use of programme budgets.
Programme budgets are a retrospective analysis of expenditure, which can be used to compare relative expenditure and relative outcomes. In this case, Wandsworth PCT has been compared with the six demographically similar PCTs in its cluster. Using this methodology, it appears that NHS Wandsworth spends less than the national average per head on COPD, but more than the cluster average.
Table 3
Expenditure (£ per person) on respiratory
disease2008/9
Expenditure (£ per person)
on COPD2008/9
Prevalence of COPD2008/9
Mortality from bronchitis,
emphysema and other COPD
2005/7
England 77.97 12.70 1.54 12.17
London 65.61 9.92 0.97 12.40Cluster 64.65 9.60 1.00 14.22
Tower Hamlets 59.27 11.01 1.19 25.49
Hammersmith and Fulham
80.50 4.91 1.02 16.88
Camden 62.02 9.25 0.97 14.82Islington 68.80 11.54 1.25 15.42Kensington and Chelsea
48.19 7.78 0.98 8.37
Westminster 68.86 8.61 0.78 9.95
Wandsworth 66.37 12.42 0.82 13.60
Source: NHS programme Budgeting Tool, 2008/9. Using unified weighted population and total expenditure without DFT adjustment.
Comparative figure on COPD specific spend across the London boroughs, calculated by NHS comparators according to Programme Budgeting codes, demonstrates that the spent on COPD patients per 1,000 people is slightly higher than the London and national average.
40
Figure 30
Bromley PCTRichmond and Twickenh...Harrow PCTKingston PCTBrent Teaching PCTRedbridge PCTBarnet PCTHillingdon PCTLambeth PCTCroydon PCTBexley CTEnfield PCTSutton and Merton PCTHaringey Teaching PCTEaling PCTHavering PCTHounslow PCTKensington and Chelsea...City and Hackney Teachin...W
estminster PCTW
altham Forest PCTLewisham PCTW
andsworth PCTHammersmith and Fulh...Newham PCTGreenwich Teaching PCTSouthwark PCTCamden PCTIslington PCTBarking and Dagenham...Tower Hamlets PCT
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
Pounds spent on COPD admissions per 1,000 patients
National AverageLondon Average
£ spe
nt
Source: NHS Comparators, NHS Information Centre, 2008-9
41
Elements of innovative Service Provision in NHS Wandsworth
Respiratory Nurse Specialist ClinicsAt present the respiratory specialist nurses perform regular COPD clinics at a number of sites around the borough. These sites are:
Queen Mary’s Hospital Brocklebank Surgery St John’s Surgery Balham Health Centre Tudor Lodge
TelehealthNHS Wandsworth has developed a telehealth service for the monitoring of patients with certain sever chronic conditions, allowing their health status at home to be monitored from a distance using new technology. This service is available to a limited number of COPD patients, as well as patients with conditions such as cardiac failure.
At present data on the number of patients treated with the telehealth system ho have COPD as their diagnosis is not available. Anecdotal evidence suggests that the telehealth equipment is underutilized relative to its potential capacity at present. Further work to map the usage of telehealth, and an evaluation of its effectiveness would be useful.
Virtual WardsNHS Wandsworth is currently running an innovative community virtual ward, operated by specifically employed GPs, in close collaboration with community matrons and the wider GP community. This service has been running for less than a year, and currently has 108 patients registered to the service. An early analysis suggests that 27 patient have a diagnosis of COPD, among other co morbidities, representing 25% of patients on the virtual ward.
Patients in the virtual ward are selected by referral, or by predictive risk modelling, and are thought likely to represent those patients most at risk of admission to hospital. A formal evaluation of the effectiveness of this service is ongoing, but preliminary data suggests that the GPs running the virtual wards are currently estimating that they are preventing approximate 5 acute COPD exacerbation admissions each month (November 2008- January 2010).
On call nursing teamIn a recent service innovation, the respiratory specialist nurse team now provides an on call services during the day on Saturdays. This is a new service, and as such data on usage is currently unavailable, but it provides an extra layer of support for out of hours services over the weekend.
42
Views from local stakeholders
Discussions were held with healthcare professionals in Wandsworth, including community respiratory nurses, hospital chest clinic staff and commissioning staff, who work on COPD to gather their views about the services. The following comments were gathered during a series of semi-structured interviews with this group.
Things that are done well:
There is a good level of communication between respiratory specialist nurses, most GPs and the chest clinic.
The current service has proved open to new innovative ideas, such as the use of telehealth and the development of the weekend on call service.
Recruitment and retention of specialist staff has gone well, leading to a group of knowledgeable local respiratory nurses. This is in contrast to several other boroughs that have had problems recruiting sufficient high quality and specialist staff.
Discharge coordination has been improved by the presence of an electronic patient record that can be accessed from the community, but this is only available from some hospital (SGH) but not other (CWM).
Areas that could be improved
More resources to provide an assisted discharge service from the hospital would help to improve care.
Community staff would like to time to be proactive and call the less well patients, rather than reactively waiting for patients to reach crisis point.
There are a small number of general practices that have been resistant or unresponsive to messages about COPD management.
The current staff balance sometimes means highly skilled staff are using their time inefficiently on less skilled tasks. Activities highlighted as inefficient included checking inhaler technique, setting up telehealth system and checking vital signs. The specialist nursing tem might benefit from a HCA/technician, so time could be focused on more specialist skills.
Waiting times for Pulmonary Rehabilitation services are too long at present (sometimes 6-12 weeks).
Staff would like more time to evaluate current work, including the effectiveness of specialist clinics, but do not have time at present due to workload.
43
Local Stakeholders
Local stakeholders in the process of TB diagnosis, treatment and management include:
Patients The community respiratory nurse team General practitioners and practice nurses Respiratory services at local hospitals (significantly at St George’s Hospital, but also
at Chelsea and Westminster, Kingston Hospital, the Royal Brompton, amongst others)
Out of hours GPs NHS Wandsworth, including the Wandsworth “virtual ward” Wandsworth Borough Council (and social services in particular) Pulmonary rehabilitation services Stop smoking services
44
Policy contextIn considering the local health needs in relation to COPD in Wandsworth, it is also important to consider the various frameworks, initiatives and agendas that are also either currently in place or likely to become significant in the future.
High Quality Care for AllLord Darzi’s report “High Quality Care for All” renewed a focus on quality of care in the NHS. It called for improved quality of treatment for long term conditions, with an increased emphasis on personalized care. In also called for innovation of services, and moving services that have previously been provided in hospital to be moved into community settings. Although initial emphasis on moving care in the community has focussed on other long term conditions, including diabetes and cardiovascular care, it is likely that there will be a significant requirement to move a proportion of specialist provision of COPD care into community settings. No target has yet been set for COPD care provision moving closer to home by WPCT.
PolysystemsAs a part of the healthcare for London consultation, there has been a move towards clustering primary care services in functional units larger than traditional GP practices, offering a more diverse range of services including diagnostics, and some services previously provided in hospital settings, such as speciality out-patient appointments.
This has taken the form initially of polyclinics, which have now transformed to polysystems. It is anticipate that NHS Wandsworth will have four polysystems. These will have an impact of COPD services, in that it will be important to consider the epidemiology of COPD within these different polysystems, and ensure that services available are appropriate to these more local populations.
New National Service FrameworkThe forthcoming National Strategy for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease seeks to ensure that everyone diagnosed with COPD receives high quality health and social care services. It is a ten year strategy that will tackle health inequalities by ensuring better prevention strategies and quicker identification of those at risk. The National Strategy will go on to articulate further national cares standards, including in hospital and for rehabilitation services, although the exact nature of this guidance is not known.
45
Analysis and Discussion
The burden of COPD in Wandsworth is not as high as in many other parts of the country. This is driven by the demography of the population of the borough, with large numbers of transient young people, and a much smaller elderly population.
Despite this lower than average prevalence, COPD remains a common disease, affecting a large number of people in the borough (over 2740, and very likely many more), and a disease which accounts for considerable spending by the PCT. Mortality rates for COPD in Wandsworth are similar to the national average.
The services provided by the borough to manage COPD are well developed, with good links between primary and secondary care, a well established community nursing team, and a clearly defined pathway. Significant proportions of care are nurse led, in settings in primary care that are likely to be more convenient to patients than accessing services in hospitals.
NHS Wandsworth has clearly defined standards of care that it hopes to achieve, with established evidence based protocols, which are based on National guidance. In this respect, Wandsworth knows the level of service that it aims to achieve. However it does not have complete systems in place to monitor whether these standards are being met.
When the borough is examined at a smaller geographical unit scale, a number of concerning features arise. There is a mismatch between observed COPD diagnosis, and those predicted from mathematical modelling. Although this is the case in all PCTs nationally, it is noticeable that there is considerable variation on a practice by practice level in Wandsworth. There is a group of practices that are predicted to have high levels of COPD, but in which only low levels are diagnosed. This suggests that there are sporadic areas of under diagnosis of the disease.
Data on service performance is available, but not complete. Data is available from national sources to allow evaluation of some aspects of services at the primary and secondary level, but there are few local mechanisms monitor levels of activity in local services and to audit services.
The QOF data provides useful indicators of a number of areas of performance, although caution must be taken in their interpretation. These data reveal that many practices are performing at a high level. They also however reveal variation in the quality of care provided by individual practices, with some achieving consistently low scores across a number of different indicators. These practices may be a target for closer audit of performance by the PCT, and potential education programmes to ensure that their management of cases is in line with best practice.
Similarly, only a limited number of measures are available from national acute care data sets. The new data provided by NHS comparators provides several interesting streams of data about admission rates, length of stay and readmission rates.
The variation in emergency admission rate observed is a cause for concern. In particular, the six practices with a statistically significantly level of emergency admission compared to the
46
average are candidates for investigation and improvement. The fact that some of the practices with highest emergency admission rates are also some of the practices with the lowest QOF scores is further evidence that some practices are underperforming.
It is interesting to note that while length of stay in hospital in Wandsworth is above average, readmission rates are lower than average, suggesting good and bad points about hospital management and discharge planning. There is potential for the improvement of discharge services.
In both treatment settings there are no systems in place to monitor compliance of treatment practice with the care pathway standards, as defined by NICE and local policy. This might be another potential area for audit.
There is variability on performance across all of the polysystems. The potential South Wandsworth Polysystem is notable in its high levels of variability in performance. This presents a potential target for polysystem/local action to improve areas in what has historically been a poorer and more deprived part of the borough.
Some aspects of the care pathway, although innovative, appear to have not been utilized as much as they potentially could. There is a lack of data about activity, including usage patterns for the nurse led clinics, telehealth and the weekend on call service. It would be sensible to generate data about this activity before making further recommendations about these services.
47
Recommendations to improve services
This report highlights several practices which seem to be performing less well than their peers in the management of COPD across a number of objective indicators. There is a need to understand this variation, and for primary care commissioning to work with the more poorly performing practices to improve performance.
This report has highlighted gaps in the diagnosis of COPD, particularly in the observed versus expected prevalence of COPD in the community. NHS Wandsworth should work with all GPs, but particularly those with a large “diagnostic gap” to ensure that diagnostic processes are strengthened.
Existing practice based commissioning clusters or potential future polysystem should take local action to deal with specific local areas of poor performance. This applies in particular to the South Wandsworth Polysystem, which has higher levels of variability in performance than other areas.
The PCT needs to work with its partners at St George’s Hospital to strengthen the nature of discharge provision, ideally in the form of an assisted discharge service, commissioned to NICE standards. This may lead to shorter stays in hospital, and lower readmission rates.
The PCT needs to consider expanding existing provision of pulmonary rehabilitation services, in order to meet the increasingly unmet need for this service as outlined in the separate needs assessment.
The PCT should work with its community respiratory team to develop systems to generate stronger measures of process and activity around COPD service provision. In particular, it should collect and report data on levels of activity at specialist clinics and during the new weekend on call.
Audits of COPD management should be undertaken in primary and secondary care, to measure compliance with local and NICE guidance.
Given the prevalence of the main risk factor for COPD, smoking, in the borough of Wandsworth, the PCT should place continued emphasis on the development of smoking cessation services at the primary care level, and also aim to improve health promotion activities in hospitals.
48
Appendix 1: Management Protocols NICE
Diagnosis
49
Management of Acute Exacerbations
50
Appendix 2: Management Protocols NHSW
NHSW protocol for the management of stable COPDFigure 31
51
NHSW protocol for the management of exacerbations of COPD
Figure 32
52
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the following who gave their time to contribute towards the production of this report:
Jo Jackson, Head of Urgent Care, Community Services Wandsworth
Julie Mariaki, Community Respiratory Specialist Nurse, NHS Wandsworth
Melissa Cottington, Public Health Research Officer, NHS Wandsworth
Nikki Davies, Community Respiratory Specialist Nurse, NHS Wandsworth
Piers Simey, Public Health Registrar, St George’s Healthcare Trust
Sam Prigmore, Respiratory Nurse Consultant, St George’s Healthcare Trust
Sara Corben, Public Health Consultant, NHS Croydon
Seth Rankin, General Practitioner, Wandsworth Medical Centre
Vanessa Flagg, Long Term Conditions Development Manager, NHS Wandsworth
Wendy Kong, Community Respiratory Specialist Nurse, NHS Wandsworth
53
References
54
1 World Health Organization: COPD Definition (Accessed on 30/10/09:http://www.who.int/respiratory/copd/definition/en/index.html)2 Gruffydd-Jones K. A national strategy for the management of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in England: aiming to improve the quality of care for patients. Prim Care Respir J. 2008 Dec;17 Suppl 1:S1-8.3 Nacul LC, Soljak M, Meade T. Model for estimating the population prevalence of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: cross sectional data from the Health Survey for England. Popul Health Metr. 2007 Sep 26;5:8.4 Corben S. Croydon Primary Care Trust. 5 Nacul LC, Soljak M, Meade T. Model for estimating the population prevalence of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: cross sectional data from the Health Survey for England. Popul Health Metr. 2007 Sep 26;5:8.6 Calverley PM. COPD: what is the unmet need? Br J Pharmacol. 2008 Oct;155(4):487-93. Epub 2008 Sep 15. Review.7 Gruffydd-Jones K. A national strategy for the management of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in England: aiming to improve the quality of care for patients. Prim Care Respir J. 2008 Dec;17 Suppl 1:S1-8.8 Calverley PM. COPD: what is the unmet need? Br J Pharmacol. 2008 Oct;155(4):487-93. Epub 2008 Sep 15. Review.9 Department of Health: Annual Report of the Chief Medical Officer 2004on the state of public health. London ; 2005.10 Mannino DM. COPD: epidemiology, prevalence, morbidity and mortality, and disease heterogeneity. Chest 2002; 121: Suppl. 5, 121S–126S.11 Hansell AL: The epidemiology of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in the UK: spatial and temporal variations. In PhD Thesis Faculty of Medicine of the University of London, Imperial College, St Mary's Campus; 2004.12 Rushton L: Review of the literature on chronic bronchitis and emphysema and occupational exposure Leicester, UK: Institute of Environmental Health; 2004.13 Barnes PJ: Molecular genetics of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Thorax 1999, 54:245-52.14 Chatila WM, Wynkoop WA, Vance G, Criner GJ: Smoking patterns in African Americans and Whites with advanced COPD. Chest 2004, 125:15-21.15 http://www.apho.org.uk/resource/item.aspx?RID=7718016 Nacul LC, Soljak M, Meade T. Model for estimating the population prevalence of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: cross sectional data from the Health Survey for England. Popul Health Metr. 2007 Sep 26;5:8.17 Modelled estimates and projections of COPD for Local Authorities in England Available at http://www.erpho.org.uk/viewResource.aspx?id=1802418Mannino DM. COPD: epidemiology, prevalence, morbidity and mortality, and disease heterogeneity. Chest 2002; 121: Suppl. 5, 121S–126S.19 Feb 2004 Management of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in adults in primary and secondary care. Clinical Guideline 12. Developed by the National Collaborating Centre for Chronic Conditions.20 NICE guidance on commissioning assisted discharge services for COPD. (Accessed at http://www.nice.org.uk/usingguidance/commissioningguides/assdissvcpatientscopd/assisteddischarge_service_for_patients_with_copd.jsp)21 NICE guidance on commisioing pulmonary rehabilitation services. (Accessed at: http://www.nice.org.uk/usingguidance/commissioningguides/pulmonaryrehabilitatio
nserviceforpatientswithcopd/pulmonary_rehabilitation_service_for_patients_with_copd.jsp)