Date post: | 26-Mar-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | julia-barry |
View: | 219 times |
Download: | 2 times |
Copyright2013
1
The Supervisor's Dilemma
Roger ClarkeXamax Consultancy, Canberra
Visiting Professor in Computer Science, ANU, CanberraVisiting Professor in Cyberspace Law & Policy, UNSW, Sydney
http://www.rogerclarke.com/SOS/CAHI {.html, .ppt}
26th Bled eConference – 10 June 2013
Copyright2013
2
The Supervisor's DilemmaAgenda
1. General Statement of the Dilemma
2. eInteraction Research Realities
3. Specific Dimensions of the Dilemma
4. Resolution? Reconciliation? Avoidance?
Copyright2013
3
Dilemma
A condition in which the alternatives to be chosen among
are equally unfavourable
resulting in a position of doubt or perplexity
Copyright2013
4
The Supervisor's Dilemma
TheCandidate's
vs. Needs
TheSupervisor
'sIntegrity
Is Reconciliation Possible?
Copyright2013
5
The Supervisor's Dilemma
Contemporary disciplinary norms lead the candidate to adopt a
a research perspective, a theoretical basis for research,
a research design and/or rigour-relevance balance
that may conflict with the supervisor's
academic and professional values and personal integrity
Copyright2013
6
2. Some Research Realities
The Focus of the Bled eConference The eInteraction Research Domain
• Inter-Entity communications facilitated by electronic tools
• Entities may be human or machine
• Purpose is not limited, e.g. economic, social, hedonism
• It is irrelevant whether the communications occur within an organisational context or otherwise
• It encompasses technologies, technologies-in-use, and the politics of technologies and their uses
Copyright2013
7
Key Characteristics ofthe eInteraction Research Domain
• Its Immaturity• The Instability of the Phenomena• Driven by Marketing Hype,
Misinformation• Innovators' 'Casino Mentality'• The Vast Numbers of Confounding
Variables• The Interconnectedness among
Phenomena• The Inadequacies of Available Theories
Copyright2013
8
Approaches to Research
• Pure Research (or 'Basic' Research)'because it’s there'
• Applied ResearchTheory-driven or tool-driven 'normal science'
Copyright2013
9
Approaches to Research
• Pure Research (or 'Basic' Research)'because it’s there'
• Applied ResearchTheory-driven or tool-driven 'normal science' 'With a hammer in your hand, everything looks like a nail'
• Instrumentalist ResearchProblem-driven'I need to firmly connect two pieces of timber, so find out how to do it'
Copyright2013
10
Practical Realities• IS and the eInteraction domain are not 'industrialised'
• Tightly-focussed training in 'normal science' isn't appropriate
• Instead, broad background needs to be developed in:
• the philosophy of research• the full range of research techniques
• Much time and effort are invested in the learning process
• Considerable formalism is involved in satisfying examiners
• The dissertation must make a sufficient 'contribution'
• So the topic is very tightly focussed by the time of submission
Copyright2013
11
The Candidate's Motivations
• Attain education and training relevant to the conduct of research
• Make a contribution to a discipline and/or a research domain
• Gain access to the research profession• Gain a prenominal (Dr) or postnominal (PhD)
as evidence of advanced university education• ...
Copyright2013
12
The Supervisor's Motivations
Develop the next generation of researchers, for reasons ofservice / altruism or deferred and indirect reciprocity
Gain intellectual stimulation
Have a junior colleague undertake work closely related toand contributing to the supervisor's own research
Contribute to the supervisor's broader research program
Project the supervisor's theories or methods to the world
Have a research assistant
Satisfy an expectation of the supervisor's employer or peers
Copyright2013
13
3. Specific Dimensions of the Dilemma
• Researcher Perspective• Theoretical Basis• Empirical Research
Design• Rigour-Relevance
Balance
Copyright2013
14
Unit of Study / Unit of Analysis
A technology, an event, an object, a person, a group, an organisational sub-unit, a legally-defined organisation, a relationship between entities (e.g. a dyad), an aggregation of organisations (e.g. an industry sector), a region, a nation
Copyright2013
15
Unit of Study / Unit of Analysis
A technology, an event, an object, a person, a group, an organisational sub-unit, a legally-defined organisation, a relationship between entities (e.g. a dyad), an aggregation of organisations (e.g. an industry sector), a region, a nation
A technology, an event, an object, a person, a group, an organisational sub-unit, a legally-defined organisation, a relationship between entities (e.g. a dyad), an aggregation of organisations (e.g. an industry sector), a region, a nation
Perspective
Copyright2013
16
The Problem of the Singular Perspective
All observation has to be from a specific point of view
Stakeholders' perspectives are diverse
Stakeholders include:• Customers• Suppliers• Providers of similar goods and services• Providers of substitute goods or services• Employees and contractors• Usees• Regulators
The perspective adopted is usually that of one organisation
Other stakeholder interests are excluded, marginalised, or treated as a constraint rather than an objective
Copyright2013
17
Some Perspectives that are Under-Represented in eInteraction
Research• Individual Employees and Contractors• Usees
Affected individuals (e.g. suppliers, customers, licensees,
other people whose data are handled by an organisation, people adjacent to an organisation's facilities)
• Industry Sectors and Industry Segments• Economies• Societies• Humanity • The Biosphere
Copyright2013
18
Some Indicators of Under-Represented Perspectives
'Public Policy'The AIS Library – the term appears in 18 of 16,000 Abstracts The Bled Proceedings (2001-2013) – in 0 of 600 Abstracts
'Privacy'The AIS Library – appears in 360 of 16,000 Abstracts But from the perspectives of marketers, not of people
'Green' TopicsThe AIS Library – 9 in 1998-2008, 19, 20, 28 and 34 in 2009-12But almost all adopt the corporate viewVery few adopt the perspective of humanity or the biosphere
Copyright2013
19
Alternative Perspectives ==>> Additional Topics
skills formation; employment and other income-distribution mechanisms; the differential needs of, and impacts on, people and communitities in urban, regional, rural and remote areas; impact and implications for cultural and linguistic minorities; technology design for people with physical and cognitive impairments; impacts of data surveillance on users and usees; consumer needs and consumer rights; and consumer marketing philosophies other than conventional, predatory, mass-marketing approaches, e.g. permission-based, consensual, micro-, 1-to-1, and non-mass
Copyright2013
20
The Theoretical Basis for the Research
'Convenience Theories'or 'Fashion Theories'
• Cultural Factors TheoryHofstede 1980; but see McSweeney 2002
• Innovation Diffusion Theory Rogers 1962; but see McMaster & Wastell 2005
• Transaction Cost TheoryWilliamson 1981; but see Ghoshal & Moran 1996
• Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)Davis 1989; but see Benbasat & Barki 2007, Bagozzi 2007
Copyright2013
21
Weak Empirical Research Designs - 1
Cases• Semi-structured interviews aren't case studies• Neither are shallow cases / vignettes• Most cases are unauditable (the source is
undeclared even to examiners / reviewers let alone readers)
Surveys• Of what people say they do, not what they
actually do• Failure to complement with in-depth information• Proxy populations and sampling frames (esp.
students)• Over-surveyed populations, minuscule response
rates
Copyright2013
22
Weak Empirical Research Designs – 2
Convenience Samples'snowball sampling'open invitations to fill in a web-form
Convenience Data• long lists of highly ambiguous questions• forced choice• 5 or 7 highly ambiguous points
• highly ambiguous scales• assumption that the data is on a ratio scale
'Likert scales' are a contrivanceThey produce misleading and even dangerous results
Copyright2013
23
Rigour and IntellectualismDominate Relevance
• Clearly, cet. par., more rigour is to be preferred to less• However, all other things are seldom equal• The eInteraction domain creates enormous challenges
(Slide 6)• High levels of rigour make demands of researchers
that conflict with the need for the results to be useful• A trade-off has to be achieved between rigour and
relevance• But, instead, topics are favoured for their
researchability rather than for the value that they can deliver
Copyright2013
24
TensionsThe Candidate's Interest in the
Mainstreamvs. The Supervisor's Professional
Integrity
• Researcher Perspective• Theoretical Basis• Empirical Research
Design• Rigour-Relevance Balance
Copyright2013
25
4. Conclusions
• Resolution ?• Reconciliation
?• Avoidance ?• …............... ?
Copyright2013
26
'Design Science' + 'Critical Theory'?
• Design Science tries to draw the researcher back into contact with the needs of the real world, ground it, and deny abstract, intellectualist social science
• Critical Theory recognises the political dimension of IT applications – the interests and agendas of the players that exercise institutional and market power, and the tensions and the balances among competing forces in influencing the design of technologies and their applications
Copyright2013
27
The Supervisor's DilemmaAgenda
1. General Statement of the Dilemma
2. eInteraction Research Realities
3. Specific Dimensions of the Dilemma
4. Resolution? Reconciliation? Avoidance?
Copyright2013
28
The Supervisor's Dilemma
Roger ClarkeXamax Consultancy, Canberra
Visiting Professor in Computer Science, ANU, CanberraVisiting Professor in Cyberspace Law & Policy, UNSW, Sydney
http://www.rogerclarke.com/SOS/CAHI {.html, .ppt}
26th Bled eConference10 June 2013