+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics ,...

Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics ,...

Date post: 31-Mar-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
36
Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts from Binary White Dwarf Mergers Kunihito Ioka (KEK) Kashiyama, KI & Mészáros 13
Transcript
Page 1: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Cosmological ���Fast Radio Bursts from Binary White Dwarf Mergers

Kunihito Ioka (KEK)

Kashiyama, KI & Mészáros 13

Page 2: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

GRB Cosmology Massive star origin ⇒ High redshift GRBs

Larson & Bromm 02 GRB QSO, galaxy

GRBs are useful for probing high-z

Like QSO Like SN Star formation Reionization Metal, Dust Dark energy … z~10-30

? z~8

~10 yr ago

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 2

Page 3: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Radio Dispersion High energy photon

Ionized region Low energy photon

Δt = 4.15 s ν1 GHz

"

#$

%

&'

−2DM

103 pc cm−3

"

#$

%

&'

In a plasma, a light signal is delayed ω 2 = k2c2 +ω p

2

ω p =4πne2

m= 5.63×104n1 2 s−1

plasma frequency

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 3

Luminosity

Time t~Δt

Distortion in light curve ⇒ DM ⇒ Reionization History

Page 4: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Dispersion Measure is the column density of free electrons along light path

Dispersion Measure ↓

Reionization History

Recombined electrons provide no DM

Dispersion Measure

Redshift

Reionization redshift

KI 03, Inoue 04 13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 4

Page 5: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Intergalactic DM ( )( )

( )

( )

2

20

2

2

01 20 3

0

112 1

12

1

1

z p

e

z

m

zdtt dzdz z

em c

z dzcnH z

ν

ν

π ν

Λ

+Δ =

+⎡ ⎤⎣ ⎦

= ×

+

⎡ ⎤Ω + +Ω⎣ ⎦

DMIGP including missing baryon

KI 03

DMGalaxy~30-103 pc cm-3

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 5

Page 6: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

DM from Afterglow Distortion at t~Δt ⇒ DM

Δt∝ν-2

KI 03

Unfortunately radio afterglows are not so bright 13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 6

Page 7: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Fast Radio Bursts Thornton+ 13

F=0.6-8.0 Jy ms !!! Most luminous radio transients if cosmological

64m Parkes radio telescope (New South Wales) High Time Resolution Universe (HTRU) Survey High latitude survey (-70 deg < b < -30 deg) ν=1.382 GHz, Δν=400 MHz/1024, Δθ~14 arcmin

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 7

Page 8: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Dispersion Measure Thornton+ 13

Galactic latitude

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 8

δt∝DM・ν-2

DM=500-1000 cm-3 pc

Lorimer Burst

Page 9: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Summary of FRB Obs. l  DM=500-1000 cm-3 pc (z=0.5-1, dL~2-6Gpc) l  Sν~Jy ⇒ Eiso~1038-40 erg l  δt=5.6ms,<4.3,1.4,1.1ms ���⇒ cδt(1+z)-1 < 1500(1+z)-1 km

l  Rate~(1±0.5)×104/sky/day~10-3/yr/galaxy��� ⇔ Supernova rate 10-2/yr/galaxy

l  No repeated bursts so far l  No counterparts so far

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 9

Page 10: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Expected Rate Hassall+ 13 Lorimer+ 13 Trott+ 13

Low frequency component SKA1 could find an extragalactic burst every hour

1 event/hour

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 10

Page 11: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Possible Origins l  RRAT (Rotating Radio Transient; intermittent

pulsar) l  Giant pulse from a msec/young pulsar l  Evaporation of BH l  SN into a nearby star l  Magnetar giant flare l  Collapse of hypermassive NS l  Binary NS mergers l  Superconducting cosmic strings l  Nearby flaring stars

Colgate+ 71,75; Egorov & Postnov 09

Popov & Postnov 07; Thornton+ 13

Falcke & Rezzolla 13; Zhang 13

Rees 77; Blandford 77; Kavic+ 08; Keane+ 12

Hansen & Lyutikov 01; Totani 13

Cai+ 12

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 11

Loeb+ 12

Page 12: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Binary White Dwarf Mergers?

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 12

Kashiyama, KI & Meszaros 13

l  Massive WD l  SN Ia l  Short GRB���

via →NS l  WD pulsar���

CR e± excess���

l  GW sources

l FRB?

Kashiyama+ 11

Page 13: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Minimum Requirements

l  Energetics l  Timescale l  Event rate 13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 13

Page 14: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Energetics

EB ≈B2

8π×

4πr3

3~ 2×1043erg B9

2r8.73

Magnetic Energy

WD-WD merger ⇒ Differential rotation ⇒ B

Loren-Aguilar+ 09, Ji+ 13

Emax ≈GM 2

r≈1050erg

Ω ≈vr

~ 1 s−1r8.7−3 2

Bobs,max~109G

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 14

Page 15: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Timescale cδt 1+ z( )−1 ≤1.5×108 1+ z( )−1 cm < 108.7cm

rcap ≈ rrΩc

#

$%

&

'(

1 2

~ 6.7×107 cm r8.73 2Ω0

1 2

rcap

c~ 2.3 ms r8.7

3 2Ω01 2

WD radius

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 15

Page 16: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Event Rate WD-WD merger rate

RWD2 ~ 10−2 −10−3 yr−1 galaxy−1

Badenes & Maoz 12

~4000 WDs in SDSS Radial velocity ⇒ Binary fraction & distribution n(a)∝aα

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 16

Page 17: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Binary White Dwarf Mergers?

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 17

Kashiyama, KI & Meszaros 13

l Energetics EB~1040erg l Timescale rcap/c~ms l Event rate ~SN Ia l SN Ia as a counterpart?

Page 18: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Counterparts l  Supernova Ia (Double degenerate model) l  X-ray debris disk

Loren-Aguilar+ 09, recently Beloborodov 13

LX<1047erg/s for ~100sec Swift for nearby FRBs

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 18

Page 19: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

FRB Cosmology l  Reionization l  Missing baryon l  Dark energy, ���

cosmological ���parameters

DMIGP =3cH0Ωb

8πGmp

1+ z( )dz

Ωm 1+ z( )3 +ΩΛ#$

%&1 20

z∫

dL =c 1+ z( )H0

dz

Ωm 1+ z( )3 +ΩΛ#$

%&1 20

z∫

Fast radio bursts as cosmological tools New frontier?

KI 03 McQuinn 13

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 19

Page 20: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

20 U.  Tokyo  Seminar  by  Kunihito  IOKA  (KEK) 21  Nov  2013

? ? ? Gravitational wave X-ray IR-Opt Radio

!!!

? ? Neutrino Gamma-ray Gravitational Wave Sources

Counterparts to GW

Page 21: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Relativistic Shock Breakout RelaHvisHc

Kyutoku, KI & Shibata 12

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 21

Not resolved yet by numerical simulation

Page 22: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Relativistic Shock Acceleration

ρ

r

Γsh ∝ρ−αrela

αrela ≈ 3 − 32

≈ 0.232

Johnson & McKee 71

Γ f ≈ Γsh1+ 3

After breakout, shocked matter accelerates to

by converting heat into motion

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 22

Page 23: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

1044

1045

1046

1047

1048

1049

1050

1 10 100 1000

E(>`

K) (

erg)

`K

escape velocityfor M* = 2.8 Msun and R* = 15 km

n=3, Msh=10-4 Msunn=3, Msh=10-5 Msunn=4, Msh=10-5 Msunn=6, Msh=10-5 Msunn=3, Msh=10-6 Msun

Relativistic Outflow

v>>vesc~0.3c!!!

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 23 Kyutoku, KI & Shibata 12

Page 24: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Early & High-Energy Emission

Radio flare

Macronova

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 24

Page 25: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Summary l  Fast Radio Burst l  Dispersion Measure ⇒ Cosmological? l  Binary White Dwarf Merger –  Energetics ✔, Timescale ✔, Event Rate ✔

–  SN Ia, X-ray debris disk l  FRB Cosmology

l  Ultrarelativistic EM Counterpart to NS2

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 25

Kashiyama, KI & Mészáros 13

KI 03

Thornton+ 13

Kyutoku, KI & Shibata 13

Page 26: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Thank You

Page 27: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

BH-NS Merger

Only Ejecta

x-z plane, only ejecta Full GR Q=5 χ=0.75 H4 EOS

Kyutoku, KI & Shibata 13

©Kyutoku

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 27

Page 28: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Anisotropic Mass Ejection

θej ≈15

Kyutoku, KI & Shibata 13

ϕej ≈ πViewing angle diversity Polarization Proper motion 13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 28

Page 29: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Spin Down Luminosity Lspin ≈

B2r6Ω4

c3 ~ 1.7×1038erg s−1B92r8.7

6 Ω04 <<1043 erg/s

B reconnection ⇒ FRB like solar flares, magnetar flares

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 29

Page 30: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Acceleration

Φmax ≈BΩ2r3

2c2 ~ 2.5×1016 Volt B9Ω02r8.7

3

⇒ e± production ⇒ Coherent radio emission

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 30

Page 31: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Beaming

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 31

Kashiyama, KI & Meszaros 13

Injection ≠ Emission

Page 32: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Brightness Temperature

Fν =πr⊥

2

d 22ν 2

c2kT

T ~ 3×1041K L43remi,10−2

⇒ Coherent emission

P~|E|2~|E1+E2+E3+…+EN|2

~N|E1|2 (incoherent) ~N2|E1|2 (coherent) 13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 32

Page 33: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Curvature Radiation

νc ≈ γ3 3c

4πrc~ 0.72 GHz γ3

3rc,10−1

γ ≥1100ν91 3rc,10

1 3

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 33

Page 34: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Luminosity

Pc ~ 2γ 4e2c3rc

2 ~ 5×10−17 erg s−1 γ34rc,10

−2

Ncoh ≈ ne ×Vcoh ≈ ne ×4γ 2 remi

2 cνc

~ ne ×2×1016 cm3 γ3−5rc,10remi,10

2

Npat ≈Vemi

Vcoh

≈1Vcoh

4π fremi2 δremi ~ 1

Vcoh

×9×1028 cm3 fremi,102 δremi,7.8

Ltot ≈ PcNcoh2( )×Npat

Ltot ~ 4×1042 erg s−1 fne,72 γ3

−1rc,10−1 remi,10

4 δremi,7.813/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 34

Page 35: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Electron Density ne ~ 2×107 cm L43

1 2γ31 2rc,10

1 2 remi,10−2 δremi,7.8

−1 2

κGJ =nenGJ

=ne

BemiΩ 2πce~ 8×103ne,7Bemi,5

−1 Ω0−1

Necessary multiplicity

Plasma frequency limit

νc ≥ν p ≈γ

2π4π #nee

2

me

$

%&

'

()

1 2

, #ne =neγ

ne ≤ 0.6×107 cm−3 γ35rc,10

−213/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 35

Page 36: Cosmological Fast Radio Bursts · 2013. 11. 14. · Binary White Dwarf Merger! – Energetics , Timescale , Event Rate – SN Ia, X-ray debris disk!! FRB Cosmology!! Ultrarelativistic

Induced Compton Melrose 71 Wilson & Rees 78 Lyubarsky 08

Compton scattering is enhanced by photons To evade the induced Compton

γ ≥ 2000 rc,103 14remi,10

3 14 ne,73 14

13/11/14 Fast  Radio  Burst  by  K.  Ioka  (KEK) 36


Recommended