+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost...

Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost...

Date post: 01-Feb-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 9 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
49
Cost and Financial Analysis August 2010 WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION
Transcript
Page 1: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

Cost and Financial Analysis

August 2010

WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION

Page 2: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August
Page 3: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

FLMWP ZQ 7ZY_PY_^

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP T

FLMWP ZQ 7ZY_PY_^ .+- AFLJG<M;LAGF ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ .*.

/+- ;GKL =KLAE9L= E=L@G<GDG?Q +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*. /+. ;RaZeR] ;‘de EVeY‘U‘]‘Xj +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*. /+/ ;RaZeR] ;‘de ;ReVX‘cZVd +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*.

/+/+. K;; .-n?fZUVhRj R_U LcRT\ =]V^V_ed +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*. /+/+/ K;; /-nKeReZ‘_d) Ke‘ad) LVc^Z_R]d) A_eVc^‘UR] ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*/ /+/+0 K;; 0-nKfaa‘ce >RTZ]ZeZVd7 QRcUd) KY‘ad) 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ :fZ]UZ_Xd ++++++++++++ /*0 /+/+1 K;; 1-nKZeVh‘c\ R_U KaVTZR] ;‘_UZeZ‘_d ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*0 /+/+2 K;; 2-nKjdeV^d +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*1 /+/+3 K;; 3-nJZXYe*‘W*ORj) DR_U) =iZdeZ_X A^ac‘gV^V_ed ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*1 /+/+4 K;; 4-nNVYZT]Vd +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*2 /+/+5 K;; 5-nHc‘WVddZ‘_R] KVcgZTVd ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*2 /+/+6 K;; 6-nM_R]]‘TReVU ;‘_eZ_XV_Tj ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*2 /+/+.- K;; .--n>Z_R_TV ;YRcXVd +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*2

/+0 GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;‘ded EVeY‘U‘]‘Xj ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /*3

0+- ;9HAL9D HD9F +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*. 0+. ;RaZeR] ;‘ded++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*. 0+/ Hc‘a‘dVU ;RaZeR] >f_UZ_X K‘fcTVd +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*1

0+/+. >VUVcR] ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*1 0+/+/ D‘TR] ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*2

0+0 =gR]fReZ‘_ ‘W >Z_R_TZR] ;RaRTZej +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*2 0+1 ;‘_decfTeZ‘_ HYRdZ_X++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*4 0+2 >f_UZ_X K‘fcTVd W‘c G_X‘Z_X ;RaZeR] H]R_ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*5

1+- GH=J9LAF? 9F< E9AFL=F9F;= HD9F +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*. 1+. GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;‘ded ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*. 1+/ GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV >f_UZ_X K‘fcTVd +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*0

1+/+. D‘TR],KeReV ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*0 1+/+/ >VUVcR] ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*0

1+0 GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV =iaV_UZefcV ;RdY >]‘h +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*0

2+- JAKCK 9F< MF;=JL9AFLA=K ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*. 2+. Hc‘[VTe ;‘de M_TVceRZ_eZVd ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*.

2+.+. ;YR_XVd Z_ Hc‘[VTe KT‘aV +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*. 2+.+/ ;YR_XVd Z_ Hc‘[VTe KTYVUf]V ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*.

2+/ >f_UZ_X M_TVceRZ_eZVd ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*. 2+/+. >L9 FVh KeRced >f_UZ_X ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*. 2+/+/ D‘TR] >f_UZ_X JZd\d +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2*/

3+- J=>=J=F;=K ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3*.

9HH=F<AP 9 J=NAK=< DGF? J9F?= LJ9FKHGJL9LAGF HD9F /-..m/-.6) E9J;@ /2) /-.-

Page 4: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

FLMWP ZQ 7ZY_PY_^

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP TT

?T^_ ZQ FLMWP^ LRS]V 0*.7 ;RaZeR] ;‘de =deZ^ReVd W‘c LKE R_U :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd Sj K;; ;ReVX‘cj Z_ ;fccV_e

QVRc <‘]]Rcd ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*/

LRS]V 0*/7 ;RaZeR] ;‘de =deZ^ReVd W‘c KeReZ‘_ R_U 9]ZX_^V_e 9]eVc_ReZgVd Z_ ;fccV_e QVRc <‘]]Rcd ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*0

LRS]V 0*07 L‘eR] 9]]‘TReVU R_U M_R]]‘TReVU ;‘_eZ_XV_Tj W‘c LKE R_U :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd Z_ /--6 <‘]]Rcd ’EZ]]Z‘_d(++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*1

LRS]V 0*17 ;RaZeR] >f_UZ_X JVbfZcV^V_ed W‘c LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ KjdeV^ ER_RXV^V_e R_U :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd Z_ /--6 <‘]]Rcd ’EZ]]Z‘_d(+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*4

LRS]V 0*27 ;RaZeR] ;‘de =deZ^ReVd W‘c EZ_Z^f^ GaVcReZ_X KVX^V_ed Sj KeR_URcUZkVU ;‘de ;ReVX‘cj Z_ /--6 <‘]]Rcd ’EZ]]Z‘_d(++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*5

LRS]V 0*37 D‘_X LVc^ ;RaZeR] >f_UZ_X W‘c EVec‘ JRZ] KjdeV^) /-.-m/-1- ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0*.-

LRS]V 1*.7 9__fR] GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;‘ded W‘c QVRc /-02 W‘c LKE R_U :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd Z_ QVRc ‘W =iaV_UZefcV <‘]]Rcd ’^Z]]Z‘_d( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*/

LRS]V 1*/7 QVRc /-02 G%E ;‘ded W‘c 9]eVc_ReZgVd ‘gVc EVec‘ DJLH 9^‘f_e W‘c OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1*0

LRS]V 1*07 GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;RdY >]‘h W‘c eYV EVec‘ JRZ] KjdeV^) /-.-m/-.6) QG= ++++++ 1*2

LRS]V 1*17 GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;RdY >]‘h W‘c eYV EVec‘ JRZ] KjdeV^) /-/-m/-03 ++++++++++++++++ 1*4

Page 5: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5N]ZYdX^ LYO 5MM]PaTL_TZY^

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP TTT

5N]ZYdX^ LYO 5MM]PaTL_TZY^ 99 9]eVc_ReZgVd 9_R]jdZd

9;= RUgR_TVU T‘_TVaefR] V_XZ_VVcZ_X

::: KR_eR E‘_ZTR :ZX :]fV :fd

;E9I ;‘_XVdeZ‘_ ER_RXV^V_e R_U 9Zc IfR]Zej

=AK,=AJ V_gZc‘_^V_eR] Z aRTe deReV^V_e,V_gZc‘_^V_eR] Z^aRTe cVa‘ce

>>?9 >f]] >f_UZ_X ?cR_U 9XcVV^V_e

>L9 >VUVcR] LcR_dZe 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_

>Q WZdTR] jVRc

@JL YVRgj cRZ] ecR_dZe

@JN YVRgj cRZ] gVYZT]V

DJLH D‘_X JR_XV LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ H]R_

DJN ]ZXYe cRZ] gVYZT]V

EGK ^Z_Z^f^ ‘aVcRS]V dVX^V_ed

G%E ‘aVcReZ_X R_U RZ_eV_R_TV

H= acV]Z^Z_Rcj V_XZ_VVcZ_X

JAH JVXZ‘_R] A^ac‘gV^V_e Hc‘XcR^

K;; deR_URcUZkVU T‘de TReVX‘cZVd

L:E ef__V] S‘cZ_X ^RTYZ_V

L<9 LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ <VgV]‘a^V_e 9Te

LKE LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ KjdeV^d ER_RXV^V_e

M;D9 M_ZgVcdZej ‘W ;R]ZW‘c_ZR) D‘d 9_XV]Vd

N9 <VaRce^V_e ‘W NVeVcR_d 9WWRZcd

QG= jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV

Page 6: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August
Page 7: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

+(*g=Y_]ZO‘N_TZY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP +’+

+(* =AFDB8G7F=BA

LYZd cVa‘ce acVdV_ed eYV TRaZeR] R_U ‘aVcReZ_X T‘de VdeZ^ReVd R_U eYV WZ_R_TZR] R_R]jdZd W‘c eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd SVZ_X T‘_dZUVcVU W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ Z_ D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej+ LYV ac‘[VTe Zd TfccV_e]j Z_ eYV <cRWe =_gZc‘_^V_eR] A^aRTe KeReV^V_e, =_gZc‘_^V_eR] A^aRTe JVa‘ce ’=AK,=AJ( aYRdV+ LYV <cRWe =AK,=AJ VWW‘ce T‘_eZ_fVd h‘c\ eYRe SVXR_ Z_ acVgZ‘fd a]R__Z_X defUZVd daVTZWZTR]]j eYV 9]eVc_ReZgVd 9_R]jdZd ’99( aYRdV+ LYV 99 aYRdV hRd T‘^a]VeVU Z_ BR_fRcj /--6 hYV_ eYV EVec‘ :‘RcU RU‘aeVU YVRgj cRZ] ecR_dZe ’@JL( Rd eYV acVWVccVU ^‘UV e‘ VieV_U eYV ViZdeZ_X EVec‘ JRZ] @JL hVde e‘hRcU eYV HRTZWZT GTVR_ R_U eYV ;Zej ‘W KR_eR E‘_ZTR+

LYV <cRWe =AK,=AJ hZ]] R_R]jkV R F‘ :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgV) R LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ KjdeV^ ER_RXV^V_e ’LKE( 9]eVc_ReZgV) R_U WZgV @JL R]eVc_ReZgVd7

n 9]eVc_ReZgV .nOVdeh‘‘U,M_ZgVcdZej ‘W ;R]ZW‘c_ZR D‘d 9_XV]Vd ’M;D9( =ieV_dZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV /nOVdeh‘‘U,NVeVcR_d 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ ’N9( @‘daZeR] =ieV_dZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV 0nKR_eR E‘_ZTR =ieV_dZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV 1nOVdeh‘‘U,N9 @‘daZeR] =ieV_dZ‘_ a]fd OVde @‘]]jh‘‘U =ieV_dZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV 2nKR_eR E‘_ZTR a]fd OVde @‘]]jh‘‘U =ieV_dZ‘_

LYV WZ_R_TZR] R_R]jdZd acVdV_eVU Z_ eYZd eVTY_ZTR] cVa‘ce Zd SRdVU ‘_ eYV TRaZeR] R_U ‘aVcReZ_X R_U ^RZ_eV_R_TV ’G%E( T‘ded VdeZ^ReVd acVaRcVU W‘c VRTY ‘W eYV WZgV SfZ]U R]eVc_ReZgVd acVdV_eVU RS‘gV+

LYZd eVTY_ZTR] cVa‘ce R]d‘ acVdV_ed eYV TRaZeR] R_U ‘aVcReZ_X T‘ded W‘c dVgVcR] deReZ‘_ R_U R]ZX_^V_e ‘aeZ‘_d7

n 9]eVc_ReZgV . RS‘gV hZeY‘fe eYV ;cV_dYRh KeReZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV / hZeY‘fe eYV ;cV_dYRh KeReZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV 0 hZeY‘fe eYV ;cV_dYRh KeReZ‘_

n 9]eVc_ReZgV 1 hZeY R ecR_dWVc deReZ‘_ W‘c T‘__VTeZ‘_d SVehVV_ eYV Hfca]V DZ_V R_U eYV OVde @‘]]jh‘‘U DZ_V Re DR ;ZV_VXR

n 9]eVc_ReZgV / hZeY eYV ;V_efcj ;Zej KeReZ‘_ Re ;‘_deV]]ReZ‘_ cReYVc eYR_ KR_eR E‘_ZTR

n 9]eVc_ReZgV / hZeY eYV OVdeh‘‘U D‘‘a

n 9]eVc_ReZgV / hZeY eYV ;V_efcj ;Zej KeReZ‘_ Re ;‘_deV]]ReZ‘_ R_U hZeY‘fe eYV ;cV_dYRh KeReZ‘_+

LYVdV R]eVc_ReZgVd RcV UVdTcZSVU WfceYVc Z_ eYV Hc‘[VTe <VdTcZaeZ‘_ JVa‘ce R_U Z_ ;YRaeVc / ‘W eYV <cRWe =AK,=AJ+

LYZd cVa‘ce R]d‘ RUUcVddVd eh‘ Z^a]V^V_eReZ‘_ ‘aeZ‘_d) hYZTY cVacVdV_e a‘eV_eZR] Z_ZeZR] T‘_decfTeZ‘_ aYRdVd W‘c 9]eVc_ReZgVd . eYc‘fXY 27

n EZ_Z^f^ GaVcRS]V KVX^V_e . ’EGK .(7 >RZcWRi =ieV_dZ‘_

n EZ_Z^f^ GaVcRS]V KVX^V_e / ’EGK /(7 ;V_efcj ;Zej =ieV_dZ‘_

Page 8: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

+(*g=Y_]ZO‘N_TZY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP +’,

LYV WZ_R_TZR] R_R]jdZd Z_ eYV <=AK,=AJ Zd T‘_dZdeV_e hZeY EVec‘od RU‘aeVU D‘_X JR_XV LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ H]R_ ’DJLH( UReVU GTe‘SVc /--6+ EVec‘ ]ReVc faUReVU eYV WZ_R_TZR] a]R_ Z_ ERcTY /-.- e‘ cVW]VTe R acZ‘cZeZkReZ‘_ ‘W TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed+

LYV GTe‘SVc /--6 DJLH R_eZTZaReVd eYRe eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ h‘f]U SV T‘_decfTeVU Z_ eYcVV aYRdVd+ HYRdV . h‘f]U VieV_U Wc‘^ eYV ViZdeZ_X Hfca]V DZ_V ‘W eYV EVec‘ JRZ] @JL djdeV^ Re OZ]dYZcV R_U OVdeVc_ e‘ OZ]dYZcV R_U >RZcWRi+ LYV DJLH Rddf^Vd eYRe T‘_decfTeZ‘_ h‘f]U SVXZ_ Z_ /-./ R_U SV T‘^a]VeVU Sj /-.6+ HYRdV / h‘f]U VieV_U eYV ac‘[VTe R]ZX_^V_ed Wc‘^ >RZcWRi e‘ ;V_efcj ;Zej+ LYZd dVX^V_e h‘f]U SV T‘_decfTeVU Wc‘^ /-.3 e‘ /-/3) R_U SV ‘aVcReZ‘_R] Z_ /-/4+ HYRdV 0 h‘f]U VieV_U eYV djdeV^ Wc‘^ ;V_efcj ;Zej e‘ OVdeh‘‘U+ ;‘_decfTeZ‘_ ‘W eYZd dVX^V_e h‘f]U SVXZ_ Z_ /-/1 R_U SV ‘aVcReZ‘_R] Sj /-03+

EVec‘ Zd ecjZ_X e‘ RTTV]VcReV Zed TRaZeR] ac‘XcR^ hZeY eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV+ LYV T‘_TVae ‘W eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV Zd e‘ fdV eYV ]‘_X*eVc^ cVgV_fV Wc‘^ eYV EVRdfcV J dR]Vd eRi Rd T‘]]ReVcR] W‘c ]‘_X*eVc^ S‘_Ud R_U R WVUVcR] ]‘R_ hYZTY hZ]] R]]‘h EVec‘ e‘ SfZ]U ./ \Vj ^Rdd ecR_dZe ac‘[VTed) Z_T]fUZ_X eYV OVdedZUV ac‘[VTe) Z_ .- jVRcd cReYVc eYR_ 0-+

EVec‘ YRd VdeZ^ReVU eYRe RTTV]VcReZ_X eYV T‘_decfTeZ‘_ ‘W eYVdV ./ \Vj EVec‘ ac‘[VTed hZ]] cVdf]e Z_ T‘de dRgZ_Xd R_U TcVReV VT‘_‘^ZT SV_VWZed+ LYV EVec‘ S‘RcU RU‘aeVU R a‘dZeZ‘_ ‘W dfaa‘ce W‘c eYV 0-,.- T‘_TVae ‘_ 9acZ] .2) /-.-) R_U R]d‘ T‘_WZc^VU eYRe WfefcV S‘RcU RTeZ‘_ h‘f]U SV cVbfZcVU e‘ Raac‘gV R_ RTTV]VcReVU ac‘[VTe UV]ZgVcj dTYVUf]V+

OYZ]V eYVdV a]R_d RcV acV]Z^Z_Rcj) dfTY R UVgV]‘a^V_e h‘f]U Z^aRTe eYV OVdedZUV =ieV_dZ‘_od dTYVUf]V R_U T‘de+ M_UVc eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV) eYV OVdedZUV =ieV_dZ‘_ h‘f]U SV ‘aVcReZ‘_R] Sj /-/.+ AW dfTY a]R_d ^ReVcZR]ZkV) eYV Z^aRTe ‘_ eYV e‘eR] ac‘[VTe T‘de Z_ QG= U‘]]Rcd hZ]] SV ViR^Z_VU WfceYVc+ EVec‘ Zd Z_ eYV ac‘TVdd ‘W faUReZ_X Zed WZ_R_TZR] a]R_) R_U eYZd h‘f]U SV cVW]VTeVU Z_ faUReVU gVcdZ‘_d ‘W eYV DJLH+

EVec‘od WZdTR] jVRc ’>Q( SVXZ_d ‘_ Bf]j . R_U V_Ud ‘_ Bf_V 0-+ >‘c ViR^a]V) >Q/-.. cVWVcd e‘ eYV aVcZ‘U ‘W Bf]j .) /-.-) eYc‘fXY Bf_V 0-) /-..+ 9]] jVRc cVWVcV_TVd Z_ eYZd cVa‘ce RcV e‘ EVec‘od WZdTR] jVRc+ LYZd WZ_R_TZR] R_R]jdZd UZU _‘e T‘_dZUVc T‘ded) cVd‘fcTVd) R_U Wf_UZ_X decReVXZVd Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY Sfd dVcgZTV ac‘gZUVU Sj V_eZeZVd ‘eYVc eYR_ EVec‘+ LYc‘fXY‘fe eYZd cVa‘ce) T‘ded R_U cVgV_fVd RcV acVdV_eVU Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd R_U,‘c jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV ’QG=( U‘]]Rcd hYVcV daVTZWZVU+

Page 9: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’+

,(* 7BEF 9EF=@5F9 @9F<B8B?B;K

,(+ 7L[T_LW 7Z^_ @P_SZOZWZRd

LYV ^VeY‘U‘]‘Xj fdVU W‘c XV_VcReZ_X TRaZeR] T‘de VdeZ^ReVd Zd T‘_dZdeV_e hZeY >L9 XfZUV]Z_Vd W‘c VdeZ^ReZ_X TRaZeR] T‘ded+ >L9 cVbfZcVd ac‘[VTe da‘_d‘cd e‘ fdV deR_URcUZkVU T‘de TReVX‘cZVd ’K;;() hYZTY V_RS]Vd R]] >L9*Wf_UVU ac‘[VTed e‘ UVgV]‘a SfUXVe SRdV]Z_Vd eYRe df^^RcZkV eYV^ Z_ R T‘_dZdeV_e WcR^Vh‘c\+

=deZ^ReVd eYRe dfaa‘ce eYV <cRWe =AK RcV SRdVU ‘_ T‘_TVaefR] UcRhZ_Xd eYRe RcV UVgV]‘aVU e‘ R_ Raac‘iZ^ReV .- aVcTV_e ]VgV] ‘W V_XZ_VVcZ_X T‘^a]VeZ‘_+ OYVcV eYV ]VgV] ‘W UVdZX_ U‘Vd _‘e dfaa‘ce bfR_eZej ^VRdfcV^V_ed) aRcR^VecZT VdeZ^ReZ_X eVTY_ZbfVd hVcV feZ]ZkVU+ ;‘ded hVcV VdeZ^ReVU Z_ QVRc /--6 U‘]]Rcd R_U VdTR]ReVU e‘ jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV U‘]]Rcd+ 9UUZeZ‘_R] UVeRZ] Zd ac‘gZUVU Z_ eYV >Z_R] ;RaZeR] ;‘de =deZ^ReV JVa‘ce) ERj .-) /-.-+

,(, 7L[T_LW 7Z^_ 7L_PRZ]TP^

LYV W‘]]‘hZ_X df^^RcZkVd eYV >L9 K;;d hYZTY RcV fdVU Rd eYV decfTefcV W‘c eYV TRaZeR] T‘de VdeZ^ReV7

n .- ?fZUVhRj R_U LcRT\ =]V^V_ed

n /- KeReZ‘_) Ke‘ad) LVc^Z_R]d) A_eVc*^‘UR]

n 0- Kfaa‘ce >RTZ]ZeZVdnQRcUd) KY‘ad) 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ :fZ]UZ_Xd

n 1- KZeVh‘c\ R_U KaVTZR] ;‘_UZeZ‘_d

n 2- KjdeV^d

n 3- JZXYe*‘W*ORj) DR_U) =iZdeZ_X A^ac‘gV^V_e

n 4- NVYZT]Vd

n 5- Hc‘WVddZ‘_R] KVcgZTVd

n 6- M_R]]‘TReVU ;‘_eZ_XV_Tj

n .-- >Z_R_TV ;YRcXVd

,(,(+ E77 +*g;‘TOPbLd LYO F]LNV 9WPXPY_^

?fZUVhRj R_U ecRT\ V]V^V_ed RcV Rddf^VU e‘ SV pejaZTR]q e‘ eYV Z_Ufdecj+ >‘c afca‘dVd ‘W eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ VdeZ^ReVd) Tc‘dd dVTeZ‘_d RcV Rddf^VU e‘ SV T‘_Xcf‘fd hZeY ViZdeZ_X EVec‘ ‘aVcReZ_X djdeV^d W‘c @JL+

Page 10: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’,

,(,(+(+ ;‘TOPbLd LYV @JL XfZUVhRj T‘de TReVX‘cZVd Z_T]fUV f_UVcXc‘f_U T‘_decfTeZ‘_ W‘c eYV @JL Z_T]fUZ_X eYV ef__V] S‘cZ_X ^RTYZ_V ’L:E() R_U Tfe R_U T‘gVc dVTeZ‘_d+ >‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_) XfZUVhRj T‘ded RcV Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X eYcVV dfS*TReVX‘cZVd7

n .-+-3 ?fZUVhRj7 M_UVcXc‘f_U ;fe R_U ;‘gVc

n .-+-4 ?fZUVhRj7 M_UVcXc‘f_U Lf__V]

n .-+-5 ?fZUVhRj7 JVeRZ_VU ;fe ‘c >Z]]

,(,(+(, F]LNV LcRT\ T‘de TReVX‘cZVd T‘_dZde ‘W cf__Z_X cRZ]d) eZVd) SR]]Rde) UZcVTe WZiReZ‘_ T‘_TcVeV a]Z_eY) V^SVUUVU ecRT\) R_U daVTZR] ecRT\ T‘^a‘_V_ed7

n .-+-6 LcRT\7 <ZcVTe WZiReZ‘_

n .-+.- LcRT\7 =^SVUUVU

n .-+.. LcRT\7 :R]]RdeVU

n .-+./ LcRT\7 KaVTZR] ’dhZeTYVd) efc_‘fed(

n .-+.0 LcRT\7 NZScReZ‘_ R_U F‘ZdV <R^aV_Z_X

LcRT\ f_Ze T‘ded hZ]] SV UZgZUVU Z_e‘ eYcVV ejaVd ‘W T‘_decfTeZ‘_ eYRe Z_T]fUV UZcVTe*WZiReZ‘_ ecRT\) V^SVUUVU ecRT\) R_U SR]]RdeVU ecRT\+ >‘c @JL) eYV acZ^Rcj ecRT\ eVTY_‘]‘Xj Zd <ZcVTe >ZiReZ‘_+ =^SVUUVU R_U SR]]RdeVU ecRT\ ^Rj R]d‘ SV feZ]ZkVU) Sfe ‘_ R ]Z^ZeVU SRdZd) W‘c RTTVdd e‘ jRcUd R_U dY‘ad W‘c ViR^a]V+ >‘c afca‘dVd ‘W eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_) Z_ZeZR] T‘de VdeZ^ReVd hZ]] SV SRdVU ‘_ T‘de*aVc*^Z]V R_U,‘c T‘de*aVc*c‘feV*W‘‘e feZ]ZkZ_X YZde‘cZTR] Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_+ M_Ze T‘ded RcV Rddf^VU e‘ SV R]]*Z_T]fdZgV ‘W cRZ]) eZVd) SR]]Rde) cRZ] hV]UZ_X) WRdeV_Vcd R_U R_TY‘cd+

,(,(, E77 ,*gE_L_TZY^& E_Z[^& FP]XTYLW^& =Y_P]XZOLW

LYV deReZ‘_d T‘de TReVX‘cj Zd ^RUV fa ‘W eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X dfS*TReVX‘cZVd eYRe Z_T]fUV deReZ‘_ decfTefcVd) aRc\Z_X ]‘ed) V]VgRe‘cd) R_U VdTR]Re‘cd+ >‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj VieV_dZ‘_) T‘ded RcV Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X dfS*TReVX‘cZVd7

n /-+-0 M_UVcXc‘f_U KeReZ‘_) Ke‘a) KYV]eVc) ER]]) LVc^Z_R]) H]ReW‘c^

n /-+-2 B‘Z_e <VgV]‘a^V_e

n /-+-3 9fe‘^‘SZ]V HRc\Z_X Ef]eZ*Ke‘cj KecfTefcV

n /-+-4 =]VgRe‘cd) =dTR]Re‘cd

>‘fc ejaVd ‘W deReZ‘_d RcV f_UVc T‘_dZUVcReZ‘_7

n ;V_ecR] EVkkR_Z_V hZeY R_ V_ecR_TV eYc‘fXY eYV TV_eVc ‘W eYV deReZ‘_+

n KZ_X]V*=_U D‘RUVU

n <‘fS]V*=_U D‘RUVU

n <VVa KeReZ‘_ ’‘gVc R_U f_UVc T‘_WZXfcReZ‘_ W‘c _Rcc‘h cZXYe*‘W*hRj ‘c T‘__VTeZ‘_d e‘ ‘eYVc ]Z_Vd(

Page 11: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’-

KeReZ‘_ h‘c\ hZ]] R]d‘ Z_T]fUV RcTYZeVTefcR] ecVRe^V_ed) dZX_RXV) R_U ]ZXYeZ_X) gVceZTR] TZcTf]ReZ‘_ V]V^V_ed dfTY Rd deRZcd R_U V]VgRe‘cd) Rd hV]] Rd VbfZa^V_e c‘‘^d+ HRc\Z_X decfTefcVd Z_T]fUV ecRWWZT T‘_ec‘]) dZeV h‘c\) decfTefcR] ViTRgReZ‘_ R_U SRT\WZ]]) W‘f_UReZ‘_ h‘c\ T‘_TcVeV W‘‘eZ_Xd) deVV] cVZ_W‘cTV^V_e) aVUVdecZR_ RTTVdd R_U ac‘eVTeZ‘_) R_U ]ZXYeZ_X) V]VTecZTR] R_U ^VTYR_ZTR] h‘c\+

?V_VcR]]j) deReZ‘_ T‘ded hZ]] SV SRdVU ‘_ Z_Ufdecj*deR_URcU T‘ded*aVc*dbfRcV W‘‘e8 aRc\Z_X decfTefcV T‘ded hZ]] R]d‘ SV SRdVU ‘_ dbfRcV W‘‘e T‘ded) TYVT\VU Sj T‘de*aVc*daRTV TR]Tf]ReZ‘_d+

,(,(- E77 -*gE‘[[Z]_ :LNTWT_TP^4 KL]O^& ESZ[^& 5OXTYT^_]L_TZY 6‘TWOTYR^

AeV^d Z_ eYZd TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUV ‘WWZTV dfaa‘ce RcVRd) ^RZ_eV_R_TV ‘W hRj WRTZ]ZeZVd) ecRT\h‘c\ W‘c gVYZT]V de‘cRXV) T]VR_Z_X R_U ^RZ_eV_R_TV WRTZ]ZeZVd) R_U de‘cRXV,^RZ_eV_R_TV SfZ]UZ_Xd+ KfS*TReVX‘cZVd RcV ZUV_eZWZVU Rd7

n 0-+-. 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ :fZ]UZ_X7 GWWZTVd) KR]Vd) Ke‘cRXV) VeT

n 0-+-/ @VRgj ERZ_eV_R_TV >RTZ]Zej

LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd T‘ded ‘c R efc_SRT\ WRTZ]Zej Z_ eYV ViZdeZ_X <ZgZdZ‘_ /- ’Hfca]V,JVU DZ_V( ERZ_eV_R_TV >RTZ]Zej e‘ RTT‘^^‘UReV /+2*^Z_feV YVRUhRjd Z_ eYV ^RZ_ dfShRj ecf_\8 R_U A^ac‘gV^V_ed e‘ eYV ViZdeZ_X dY‘a R_U Z_daVTeZ‘_ WRTZ]ZeZVd Re eYV <ZgZdZ‘_ /- jRcU eYRe RcV cVbfZcVU W‘c S‘eY eYV F‘ :fZ]U R_U :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd+

,(,(. E77 .*gET_PbZ]V LYO E[PNTLW 7ZYOT_TZY^

LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd dZeVh‘c\ R_U daVTZR] T‘_UZeZ‘_d eYRe ^Rj SV Z_ RUUZeZ‘_ e‘ dT‘aV T‘gVcVU f_UVc _‘c^R] ac‘WZ]Vd W‘c XfZUVhRj R_U deReZ‘_ T‘_decfTeZ‘_+ LYV T‘de V]V^V_ed Z_T]fUVU Z_ VRTY dfSTReVX‘cj RcV UVdTcZSVU Z_ ^‘cV UVeRZ] SV]‘h+

,(,(.(+ .*(*+ 8PXZWT_TZY LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd T‘ded Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY SfZ]UZ_X R_U ‘eYVc UV^‘]ZeZ‘_) R_U TR_ R]d‘ Z_T]fUV ViZdeZ_X cRZ] decfTefcVd+

,(,(.(, .*(*, G_TWT_d DPWZNL_TZY LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd cV]‘TReZ‘_ ‘W S‘eY afS]ZT R_U acZgReV feZ]ZeZVd) R_U daVTZWZTR]]j ViT]fUVd SVeeVc^V_ed+ >‘c afca‘dVd ‘W eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ ;‘ccZU‘c) feZ]Zej cV]‘TReZ‘_d RcV Z_T]fUVU Rd R_ R]]‘hR_TV) aV_UZ_X R UVeRZ]VU VgR]fReZ‘_ ‘W eYV ViZdeZ_X feZ]ZeZVd R_U UVWZ_ZeZ‘_ ‘W eYV RTefR] feZ]Zej cV]‘TReZ‘_ h‘c\ dT‘aV+ OYVcV \_‘h_ ^R[‘c feZ]Zej Z^aRTed RcV ZUV_eZWZVU) eYV feZ]Zej cV]‘TReZ‘_d ^Rj SV VdeZ^ReVU+

,(,(.(- .*(*- <LeL]OZ‘^ @L_P]TLW LYO 9YaT]ZYXPY_LW @T_TRL_TZY F‘ UVeRZ]VU YRkRcU‘fd ^ReVcZR] ‘c V_gZc‘_^V_eR] ^ZeZXReZ‘_ Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_ hZ]] SV RgRZ]RS]V f_eZ] eYV HcV]Z^Z_Rcj =_XZ_VVcZ_X ’H=( ac‘TVdd YRd SVV_ T‘^a]VeVU R_U R_ =_gZc‘_^V_eR] EZeZXReZ‘_ E‘_Ze‘cZ_X H]R_ UVgV]‘aVU+ LYVcVW‘cV) R pa]fXq _f^SVc SRdVU ‘_ eYV ‘gVcR]] R]ZX_^V_e ]V_XeY hZ]] SV feZ]ZkVU) R_U Zd acZ^RcZ]j Z_eV_UVU e‘ T‘gVc T‘_eR^Z_ReVU d‘Z] R_U Xc‘f_U hReVc cV^VUZReZ‘_+ KY‘f]U eYV RUgR_TVU T‘_TVaefR] V_XZ_VVcZ_X ’9;=( aYRdV . defUZVd ‘c S‘cZ_X UReR cVgVR] T‘_eR^Z_ReZ‘_ cVbfZcZ_X daVTZR] UZda‘dR]) eYZd hZ]] SV Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV T‘de+

Page 12: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’.

,(,(.(. .*(*. ET_P E_]‘N_‘]P^ O‘c\ ZeV^d Z_ eYZd TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUV cVeRZ_Z_X hR]]d) d‘f_U hR]]d) dYRcVU ]‘ed) decfTefcVd hYVcV eYVcV ^ZXYe SV cVeRZ],VT‘_‘^ZT,T‘^^f_Zej RTeZgZeZVd ‘_ eYV Xc‘f_U W]‘‘c) R_U ‘eYVc h‘c\ eYRe Zd RU[RTV_e e‘ eYV RTefR] R]ZX_^V_e+ LYVdV T‘ded hZ]] SV UVcZgVU feZ]ZkZ_X R T‘de*aVc*dbfRcV W‘‘e SRdZd Rd Z_UZTReVU eYc‘fXY YZde‘cZTR] T‘^aRcZd‘_d ‘W dZ^Z]Rc ac‘[VTed+

,(,(.(/ .*(*/ CPOP^_]TLY 5NNP^^& ?LYO^NL[TYR O‘c\ ZeV^d Z_ eYZd TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUV dZUVhR]\d) aReYd) a]RkRd) ]R_UdTRaV) dZeV R_U deReZ‘_ Wfc_ZefcV) dZXYe ]ZXYeZ_X) dZX_RXV) afS]ZT Rceh‘c\) SZ\V WRTZ]ZeZVd R_U WV_TZ_X+ E‘de ‘W eYVdV ZeV^d RcV UVWZ_VU UfcZ_X eYV >Z_R] <VdZX_ aYRdV+ LYVcVW‘cV) R]]‘hR_TVd RcV feZ]ZkVU W‘c acZTZ_X UfcZ_X H=+

,(,(.(0 .*(*0 5‘_ZXZMTWP 5NNP^^bLd^& CL]VTYR ?Z_^ LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd c‘RUhRjd) decVVed) dfcWRTV aRc\Z_X RcVRd) dZUVhR]\d) TfcSd) R_U XfeeVcd+ A_ RUUZeZ‘_) eYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj ZW Raa]ZTRS]V ^Rj Z_T]fUV dYRcVU*]‘ed ‘c decfTefcVd hYVcV eYVcV ^ZXYe SV cVeRZ],VT‘_‘^ZT ‘c T‘^^f_Zej RTeZgZeZVd ‘_ eYV Xc‘f_U W]‘‘c+ ;‘ded hZ]] SV SRdVU ‘_ Z_Ufdecj RgVcRXVd ‘_ R T‘de*aVc*dbfRcV*W‘‘e SRdZd+

,(,(.(1 .*(*1 FPX[Z]L]d :LNTWT_TP^ LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd ^‘SZ]ZkReZ‘_) UV^‘SZ]ZkReZ‘_) eV^a‘cRcj ecRZ]Vcd) VRdV^V_ed) R_U ‘eYVc T‘ded+ LYV T‘ded hZ]] SV UVeVc^Z_VU Rd R aVcTV_eRXV ‘W eYV ‘gVcR]] TRaZeR] T‘_decfTeZ‘_ T‘de+

,(,(/ E77 /*gEd^_PX^

LYV KjdeV^d T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd dVgVcR] cV]VgR_e dfS*TReVX‘cZVd7

n 2-+-. LcRZ_ ;‘_ec‘] R_U KZX_R]d

n 2-+-/ LcRWWZT KZX_R]d R_U ;c‘ddZ_X Hc‘eVTeZ‘_

n 2-+-0 LcRTeZ‘_ H‘hVc Kfaa]j7 KfSdeReZ‘_d

n 2-+-1 LcRTeZ‘_ H‘hVc <ZdecZSfeZ‘_7 ;ReV_Rcj R_U LYZcU JRZ]

n 2-+-2 ;‘^^f_ZTReZ‘_d

n 2-+-3 >RcV ;‘]]VTeZ‘_ KjdeV^ R_U =bfZa^V_e

n 2-+-4 ;V_ecR] ;‘_ec‘]

LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd T‘ded W‘c R_ ViaR_dZ‘_ ‘W eYV ViZdeZ_X JRZ] GaVcReZ‘_d ;V_eVc ]‘TReVU Re A^aVcZR] R_U OZ]]‘hSc‘‘\ 9gV_fV R]‘_X eYV EVec‘ :]fV DZ_V+ ;‘ded W‘c ViaR_dZ‘_ e‘ eYZd ;V_ecR] ;‘_ec‘] SfZ]UZ_X eYRe RcV ReecZSfeVU e‘ ‘eYVc EVRdfcV J ac‘[VTed RcV _‘e Z_T]fUVU) Rd Ze Zd Rddf^VU eYRe eYVj RcV Wf_UVU Sj EVRdfcV J Z_ eYV F‘*:fZ]U dTV_RcZ‘+

,(,(0 E77 0*gDTRS_’ZQ’ILd& ?LYO& 9cT^_TYR =X[]ZaPXPY_^

LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd cVR] VdeReV RTbfZdZeZ‘_ R_U cV]‘TReZ‘_ T‘ded+

n 3-+-. HfcTYRdV ‘c DVRdV ‘W JVR] =deReV

n 3-+-/ JV]‘TReZ‘_ ‘W =iZdeZ_X @‘fdVY‘]Ud R_U :fdZ_VddVd

n 3-+-0 JZXYe ‘W ORj

Page 13: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’/

>VV RTbfZdZeZ‘_d ‘W aVc^R_V_e R_U eV^a‘cRcj VRdV^V_ed) cV]‘TReZ‘_ T‘ded) R_U p]‘dd ‘W SfdZ_Vddq T‘^aV_dReZ‘_ RcV Z_T]fUVU+ JVR] =deReV RTbfZdZeZ‘_ R_U cV]‘TReZ‘_ VdeZ^ReVd hZ]] SV ac‘gZUVU Sj EVec‘ SRdVU ‘_ Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_ ac‘gZUVU Sj eYV EVec‘ JVR] =deReV UVaRce^V_e W‘c dZ^Z]Rc ejaVd ‘W ac‘aVcej+ JVR] =deReV RTbfZdZeZ‘_d,VRdV^V_ed h‘f]U acZ^RcZ]j SV Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY deReZ‘_ V_ecR_TVd) T‘_decfTeZ‘_ deRXZ_X) RTTVdd W‘c ef__V] S‘cZ_X ^RTYZ_Vd) R_U,‘c a‘eV_eZR] dfSdfcWRTV VRdV^V_ed W‘c ef__V]Z_X f_UVc acZgReV ac‘aVcej+ ;‘de VdeZ^ReVd hZ]] SV acVaRcVU Sj EVec‘od JVR] =deReV UVaRce^V_e SRdVU ‘_ cZXYe*‘W*hRj UcRhZ_Xd ac‘gZUVU Sj eYV ;‘_df]eR_e W‘c Z_T]fdZ‘_ Z_ eYV T‘de VdeZ^ReV+

,(,(1 E77 1*gHPSTNWP^

LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj Z_T]fUVd eYV T‘de ‘W cVgV_fV R_U _‘_*cVgV_fV gVYZT]Vd7

n 4-+-. DZXYe JRZ] NVYZT]V ’DJN(nF‘e MdVU

n 4-+-/ @VRgj JRZ] NVYZT]V ’@JN(

n 4-+-0 ;‘^^feVc JRZ]nF‘e MdVU

n 4-+-1 :JLnF‘e MdVU

n 4-+-2 GeYVcd

n 4-+-3 F‘_*JVgV_fV NVYZT]V

n 4-+-4 KaRcV HRced

JVgV_fV gVYZT]V acZTZ_X hZ]] SV SRdVU ‘_ cVTV_e YZde‘cZTR] R_U Z_Ufdecj*deR_URcU f_Ze T‘ded) R_U hZ]] Z_T]fUV UVdZX_ V_XZ_VVcZ_X) ^R_fWRTefcV) eVdeZ_X) R_U daRcV aRced+ LYV VdeZ^ReV hZ]] Rddf^V eYVcV hZ]] SV _‘ _VVU e‘ cVec‘WZe R_j ‘W EVec‘&d ViZdeZ_X W]VVe W‘c T‘_dZde T‘^aReZSZ]Zej hZeY _VhVc eVTY_‘]‘XZVd+

,(,(2 E77 2*gC]ZQP^^TZYLW EP]aTNP^

LYZd T‘de TReVX‘cj T‘gVcd T‘_TVaefR] V_XZ_VVcZ_X R_U R]eVc_ReZgVd R_R]jdZd) H=) WZ_R] UVdZX_) UVdZX_ dfaa‘ce UfcZ_X T‘_decfTeZ‘_) T‘_decfTeZ‘_ ^R_RXV^V_e) EVec‘ RXV_Tj T‘ded) ac‘WVddZ‘_R] Z_dfcR_TV T‘ded) dfcgVjd R_U eVdeZ_X) daVTZR]ej dfS*T‘_df]eR_ed) R_U ]VXR] ViaV_dVd+

,(,(3 E77 3*gGYLWWZNL_PO 7ZY_TYRPYNd

M_R]]‘TReVU T‘_eZ_XV_Tj Zd Z_eV_UVU e‘ T‘gVc SZU cZd\ R_U T‘_decfTeZ‘_ cZd\ eYRe TR__‘e cVRd‘_RS]j SV R]]‘TReVU e‘ daVTZWZT K;; T‘UVd+ Ae Zd Z_eV_UVU e‘ T‘gVc f_\_‘h_d eYRe TR__‘e SV R_eZTZaReVU) Sfe Zd _‘_VeYV]Vdd acfUV_e e‘ Z_T]fUV W‘c a]R__Z_X afca‘dVd+ LYZd Zd TR]Tf]ReVU Rd R aVcTV_eRXV RUU*‘_ SRdVU ‘_ eYV e‘eR] TRaZeR] T‘de VdeZ^ReV) ejaZTR]]j Z_ eYV cR_XV ‘W .- aVcTV_e+ F‘eV eYRe RUUZeZ‘_R] R]]‘TReVU T‘_eZ_XV_TZVd cR_XZ_X Wc‘^ 2 e‘ /2 aVcTV_e RcV R]]‘TReVU e‘ daVTZWZT T‘de TReVX‘cZVd Rd RUUcVddVU Z_ KVTeZ‘_d 1+3 R_U 1+4 ‘W eYV WZ_R] ;RaZeR] ;‘de EVeY‘U‘]‘Xj JVa‘ce+

,(,(+* E77 +**g:TYLYNP 7SL]RP^

>Z_R_TV TYRcXVd RcV _‘e Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV dT‘aV ‘W eYV Z_ZeZR] VdeZ^ReVd SVTRfdV EVec‘ Z_eV_Ud e‘ Wf_U eYV ac‘[VTe hZeY‘fe eYV fdV ‘W ac‘[VTe*daVTZWZT UVSe+

Page 14: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’0

,(- B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7Z^_^ @P_SZOZWZRd

LYZd dVTeZ‘_ ac‘gZUVd eYV SRdZd W‘c eYV G%E T‘de ^VeY‘U‘]‘Xj UVgV]‘aVU W‘c eYV OVdedZUV =ieV_dZ‘_ LcR_dZe ;‘ccZU‘c KefUj+ LYV ^VeY‘U‘]‘Xj W‘c VdeZ^ReZ‘_ ‘W G%E T‘ded Zd UVdZX_VU e‘ dReZdWj >VUVcR] LcR_dZe 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ ’>L9( TcZeVcZR W‘c T‘de ^‘UV]Z_X+

LYV G%E T‘ded hVcV VdeZ^ReVU fdZ_X R cVd‘fcTV T‘de SfZ]U*fa Raac‘RTY+ KVaRcReV G%E T‘de ^‘UV]d hVcV UVgV]‘aVU W‘c VRTY ‘W eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X EVec‘ ecR_dZe ^‘UVd R_U eh‘ ac‘gZdZ‘_d ‘W dVcgZTV ejaVd7

n @VRgj JRZ] LcR_dZe

n DZXYe JRZ] LcR_dZe

n <ZcVTe]j*GaVcReVU D‘TR] R_U =iacVdd :fd) JRaZU :fd) R_U :fd JRaZU LcR_dZe

n HfcTYRdVU LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ D‘TR] R_U =iacVdd :fd

G%E T‘de ^‘UV]d hVcV _‘e UVgV]‘aVU W‘c aRcRecR_dZe R_U TYRceVc dVcgZTVd+ LYVdV ecR_dZe dVcgZTV TReVX‘cZVd RcV Rddf^VU _‘e e‘ SV ^ReVcZR]]j RWWVTeVU Sj eYV ecR_dZe Z^ac‘gV^V_e R]eVc_ReZgVd SVZ_X RUUcVddVU+

>‘c EVec‘ dVcgZTVd R dV]VTeZgV]j*Xc‘faVU cVd‘fcTV ^‘UV] hRd fdVU+ LYZd ^‘UV] cVeRZ_d dfWWZTZV_e UVeRZ] e‘ V_dfcV eYRe dVcgZTV) djdeV^d) R_U WRTZ]ZeZVd UZdeZ_TeZ‘_d Rd hV]] Rd ^R[‘c TReVX‘cZVd ‘W T‘ded eYRe TR_ SV W‘cVTRdeVU R_U eYRe YRgV cVT‘X_ZkRS]j UZWWVcV_e VWWVTed ‘_ G%E T‘de RcV acVdVcgVU Rd dVaRcReV aRced ‘W eYV ‘gVcR]] T‘de ^‘UV]d+ LYZd Raac‘RTY dfaa‘ced Z_UVaV_UV_e R_R]jdZd ‘W G%E T‘de WRTe‘cd ‘c Z_W]fV_TVd dfTY Rd hRXV ]VgV]d) WfV] R_U ‘eYVc V_VcXj acZTVd) gVYZT]V eVTY_‘]‘XZVd) ^ReVcZR]d) R_U dfaa]ZVd+ >‘c eYV EVec‘ Sfd dVcgZTVd ac‘gZUVU Sj ^VR_d ‘W T‘_ecRTed hZeY ecR_dZe ‘aVcReZ_X T‘^aR_ZVd) R dZ^a]Vc T‘deZ_X decfTefcV eYRe Zd T‘_dZdeV_e hZeY eYV T‘_ecRTeZ_X SRdZd R_U T‘_dVbfV_e ]‘hVc ]VgV] ‘W RgRZ]RS]V UVeRZ] hRd fdVU+

A_ RUUZeZ‘_ e‘ EVec‘) ecR_dZe RXV_TZVd hZeYZ_ eYV defUj RcVR ‘W eYV OVdedZUV =ieV_dZ‘_ LcR_dZe ;‘ccZU‘c KefUj Z_T]fUV D9<GL) KR_eR E‘_ZTR :ZX :]fV :fd ’:::() ;f]gVc ;Zej :fd DZ_V) 9_eV]‘aV NR]]Vj) KR_eR ;]RcZeR) R_U OVde @‘]]jh‘‘U+ LYVZc ecR_dZe ‘aVcReZ‘_d) hYZTY ^Rj SV RWWVTeVU Sj eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd f_UVc defUj) hZ]] SV dfS[VTe e‘ R_R]jdZd ‘W cZUVcdYZa R_U T‘de VWWVTed TRfdVU Sj eYV R]eVc_ReZgV ecR_dZe Z^ac‘gV^V_ed+

LYV UZcVTe]j*‘aVcReVU R_U afcTYRdVU ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ ^‘UV] decfTefcVd UVgV]‘aVU W‘c EVec‘ Sfd dVcgZTVd hVcV fdVU W‘c eYV ‘eYVc dVcgZTV ac‘gZUVcd hZeYZ_ eYV defUj RcVR8 d‘^V ‘aVcReV dVcgZTVd UZcVTe]j) hYZ]V ‘eYVcd afcTYRdV eYVZc ecR_dZe dVcgZTVd+ LYVdV ac‘gZUVcdo G%E T‘ded RcV) Z_ e‘eR]) R d^R]] aVcTV_eRXV ‘W eYV ‘gVcR]] ecR_dZe G%E T‘de SVZ_X R_R]jkVU+

LYV ^‘UV]d feZ]ZkV TfccV_e R_U WfefcV dVcgZTV Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_ Wc‘^ ecRgV] UV^R_U W‘cVTRdeZ_X ^‘UV]d R_U eYV ‘aVcReZ_X a]R_+ 9__fR] G%E T‘ded hVcV acVaRcVU Z_ /--5 U‘]]Rcd) R_U eYV_ VdTR]ReVU e‘ jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV+ =dTR]ReZ‘_ ‘W G%E T‘ded e‘ WfefcV acZTV ]VgV]d Zd RTT‘^a]ZdYVU Re eYV Z_UZgZUfR] T‘de T‘^a‘_V_e ]VgV]) R]]‘hZ_X daVTZWZT ZUV_eZWZTReZ‘_ ‘W VdTR]ReZ‘_ cReVd R_eZTZaReVU e‘ Raa]j e‘ eYV UZWWVcV_e T‘de TReVX‘cZVd+ LYZd WVRefcV Zd dVV_ Rd VdaVTZR]]j Z^a‘ceR_e Z_ eYV TRdV ‘W V_VcXj T‘ded) Z_ gZVh ‘W eYV TfccV_e Z_deRSZ]Zej R_U cRaZU Z_TcVRdV Z_ T‘ded dVV_ Z_ cVTV_e jVRcd R_U ^‘_eYd+

Page 15: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^ ,(*g7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P @P_SZOZWZRd

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP ,’1

9UUZeZ‘_R] Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_ RS‘fe eYV ^VeY‘U‘]‘Xj fdVU e‘ W‘cVTRde G%E T‘ded Zd ac‘gZUVU Z_ eYV GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;‘de EVeY‘U‘]‘Xj R_U E‘UV]) 9acZ] .3) /-.-+

Page 16: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August
Page 17: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’+

-(* 75C=F5? C?5A

LYV TRaZeR] a]R_ acVdV_ed R_U T‘^aRcVd eYV TRaZeR] T‘ded Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY Z^a]V^V_eZ_X VRTY ‘W eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd) acVdV_ed eYV ac‘a‘dVU TRaZeR] WZ_R_TZ_X a]R_) R_U eYV_ R_R]jkVd EVec‘od RSZ]Zej e‘ Wf_U eYV SfZ]U R]eVc_ReZgVd+

-(+ 7L[T_LW 7Z^_^

LYV TRaZeR] T‘ded Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY Z^a]V^V_eZ_X VRTY ‘W eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ R]eVc_ReZgVd RcV acVdV_eVU Z_ LRS]V 0*. R_U LRS]V 0*/+ LYV F‘ :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgV U‘Vd _‘e YRgV R_j Rdd‘TZReVU TRaZeR] T‘ded R_U dVcgVd Rd eYV SRdV]Z_V W‘c T‘^aRcZ_X eYV :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd+ EVec‘od RSZ]Zej e‘ Wf_U eYV F‘ :fZ]U Zd RUUcVddVU Z_ KVTeZ‘_ 0+1 ‘_ EVec‘od ;RaZeR] H]R_+

LRS]V 0*. acVdV_ed eYV TRaZeR] T‘ded W‘c eYV LKE R_U :fZ]U 9]eVc_ReZgVd Sj K;; T‘UV) Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd+ LRS]V 0*/ acVdV_ed eYV TRaZeR] T‘ded Sj K;; T‘UV W‘c eYV deReZ‘_ R_U R]ZX_^V_e R]eVc_ReZgVd f_UVc T‘_dZUVcReZ‘_+

LYV TRaZeR] T‘de VdeZ^ReVd Z_T]fUV T‘de T‘_eZ_XV_Tj e‘ T‘gVc f_ViaVTeVU T‘de Z_TcVRdVd) hYZTY Zd T‘_dZdeV_e hZeY >L9 cVT‘^^V_UReZ‘_d W‘c ecR_dZe ac‘[VTed Re eYV .- aVcTV_e ]VgV] ‘W V_XZ_VVcZ_X T‘^a]VeZ‘_+ ;‘_eZ_XV_Tj T‘_dZded ‘W R^‘f_ed R]]‘TReVU Z_ gRcjZ_X R^‘f_ed e‘ VRTY T‘de TReVX‘cj SRdVU ‘_ p\_‘h_ f_\_‘h_dq+ A_ RUUZeZ‘_) R_ RUUZeZ‘_R] R^‘f_e ‘W f_R]]‘TReVU T‘_eZ_XV_Tj YRd SVV_ RUUVU e‘ RUUcVdd pf_\_‘h_ f_\_‘h_d)q ‘c e‘ dZ^a]j cVW]VTe R acfUV_e R^‘f_e e‘ T‘gVc f_R_eZTZaReVU VgV_ed+ L‘XVeYVc) R]]‘TReVU R_U f_R]]‘TReVU R^‘f_ed ^R\V fa eYV e‘eR] T‘_eZ_XV_Tj+ LRS]V 0*0 dY‘hd eYV e‘eR] R^‘f_e ‘W T‘_eZ_XV_Tj eYRe Zd Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV T‘de VdeZ^ReV W‘c VRTY R]eVc_ReZgV+

Page 18: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’,

FLMWP -’+4 7L[T_LW 7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P^ QZ] FE@ LYO 6‘TWO 5W_P]YL_TaP^ Md E77 7L_PRZ]d TY 7‘]]PY_ KPL] 8ZWWL]^

7Z^_ 7L_PRZ]TP^ FE@ 5W_ +g

IP^_bZZO G7?5

5W_ ,gIP^_bZZO)H5

<Z^[T_LW

5W_ -g ELY_L @ZYTNL

9c_PY^TZY

5W_ .gIP^_bZZO)H5 <Z^[T_LW [W‘^

IP^_ <ZWWdbZZO

5W_ /g ELY_L @ZYTNL 9c_PY^TZY [W‘^

IP^_ <ZWWdbZZO

@fZUVhRj R_U LcRT\ >]V^V_ed — 809,966 831,688 1,124,337 1,280,581 1,590,122

KeReZ‘_d) Ke‘ad) LVc^Z_R]d) B_eVc^‘UR] — 910,882 1,009,757 1,518,657 1,723,220 2,232,120

Kfaa‘ce ?RTZ]ZeZVd7 QRcUd) KY‘ad) :U^Z_ ;]UXd 13,000 136,431 136,431 226,392 226,392 226,392

KZeVh‘c\ R_U KaVTZR] <‘_UZeZ‘_d — 293,952 317,178 456,417 506,857 638,476

KjdeV^d 1,920 156,520 166,510 230,871 255,279 321,407

JZXYe*‘W*ORj) DR_U) >iZdeZ_X B^ac‘gV^V_ed — 101,639 159,400 209,954 216,982 325,295

NVYZT]Vd 18,018 498,036 528,528 620,004 823,284 965,580

Hc‘WVddZ‘_R] KVcgZTVd 4,924 761,560 812,315 1,173,702 1,317,468 1,652,811

M_R]]‘TReVU <‘_eZ_XV_Tj 3,786 366,899 396,181 556,033 635,006 795,220

?Z_R_TV <YRcXVd — — — — — —

L‘eR] <‘de &/--6’ =‘]]Rcd 41,648 4,035,885 4,357,988 6,116,367 6,985,069 8,747,423

(:]] <‘ded Z_ /--6 =‘]]Rcd &EZ]]Z‘_d’

Page 19: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’-

FLMWP -’,4 7L[T_LW 7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P^ QZ] E_L_TZY LYO 5WTRYXPY_ 5W_P]YL_TaP^ TY 7‘]]PY_ KPL] 8ZWWL]^

7Z^_ 7L_PRZ]TP^ Alt. 1 less Crenshaw

Alt. 2 less Crenshaw

Alt 3 less Crenshaw

Alt. 4 with Transfer at La Cienega

Alt. 2 with Constellation

Alt. 2 with Westwood

Loop

Alt. 2 with Constellation less Crenshaw

@fZUVhRj R_U LcRT\ >]V^V_ed 822,130 843,853 1,136,499 1,275,679 864,065 918,605 864,870

KeReZ‘_d) Ke‘ad) LVc^Z_R]d) B_eVc^‘UR] 817,132 916,007 1,424,907 1,773,220 1,009,757 1,009,757 886,151

Kfaa‘ce ?RTZ]ZeZVd7 QRcUd) KY‘ad) :U^Z_ ;fZ]UZ_Xd 136,431 136,431 226,392 226,392 136,431 136,431 136,431

KZeVh‘c\ R_U KaVTZR] <‘_UZeZ‘_d 275,367 320,011 437,832 548,114 321,164 327,289 298,108

KjdeV^d 150,949 160,941 225,302 252,627 171,426 174,206 165,240

JZXYe*‘W*ORj) DR_U) >iZdeZ_X B^ac‘gV^V_ed 101,639 101,639 209,954 216,982 178,173 101,639 178,173

NVYZT]Vd 498,036 528,528 620,004 823,284 528,528 569,184 528,528

Hc‘WVddZ‘_R] KVcgZTVd 726,662 784,489 1,138,808 1,345,091 825,937 846,875 775,764

M_R]]‘TReVU <‘_eZ_XV_Tj 352,835 379,190 541,970 646,139 403,548 408,399 383,327

?Z_R_TV <YRcXVd 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

L‘eR] <‘de &/--6’ =‘]]Rcd 3,881,181 4,171,089 5,961,668 7,107,528 4,439,029 4,492,385 4,216,592

(:]] <‘ded Z_ /--6 =‘]]Rcd &EZ]]Z‘_d’

Page 20: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’.

FLMWP -’-4 FZ_LW 5WWZNL_PO LYO GYLWWZNL_PO 7ZY_TYRPYNd QZ] FE@ LYO 6‘TWO 5W_P]YL_TaP^ TY ,**3 8ZWWL]^ $@TWWTZY^%

7Z^_ 7L_PRZ]TP^ $,**3 8ZWWL]^% FE@

5W_P

]YL_

TaP

+gI

P^_b

ZZO)

G

7?5

5W_P

]YL_

TaP

,gI

P^_b

ZZO)

H5

<Z^

[T_L

W

5W_P

]YL_

TaP

-gEL

Y_L

@ZY

TNL

9c_P

Y^TZ

Y

5W_P

]YL_

TaP

.gI

P^_b

ZZO)

H5

<Z^

[T_L

W [W‘

^ I

P^_ <

ZWWd

bZZ

O

5W_P

]YL_

TaP

/gEL

Y_L

@ZY

TNL

9c_P

Y^TZ

Y [W

‘^ I

P^_

<ZW

Wdb

ZZO

:]]‘TReVU <‘_eZ_XV_Tj 62,900 463,578 515,654 720,033 809,990 1,025,187

M_R]]‘TReVU <‘_eZ_XV_Tj 20,000 366,899 396,181 556,033 635,006 795,220

L‘eR] <‘_eZ_XV_Tj 82,900 830,477 911,835 1,276,066 1,444,996 1,820,407

<‘_eZ_XV_Tj Rd HVcTV_e ‘W <RaZeR] <‘de

27.8% 25.9% 26.4% 26.4% 26.1% 26.3%

-(, C]Z[Z^PO 7L[T_LW :‘YOTYR EZ‘]NP^

9d UVdTcZSVU RS‘gV) EVec‘ Zd ecjZ_X e‘ RTTV]VcReV Zed TRaZeR] ac‘XcR^ hZeY eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV+ LYV T‘_TVae ‘W eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV Zd e‘ fdV eYV ]‘_X*eVc^ cVgV_fV Wc‘^ eYV EVRdfcV J dR]Vd eRi Rd T‘]]ReVcR] W‘c ]‘_X*eVc^ S‘_Ud R_U R WVUVcR] ]‘R_ hYZTY hZ]] R]]‘h EVec‘ e‘ SfZ]U ./ \Vj ^Rdd ecR_dZe ac‘[VTed) Z_T]fUZ_X eYV OVdedZUV ac‘[VTe) Z_ .- jVRcd cReYVc eYR_ 0- jVRcd+ EVec‘ YRd VdeZ^ReVU eYRe RTTV]VcReZ_X eYV T‘_decfTeZ‘_ ‘W eYVdV ./ \Vj EVec‘ ac‘[VTed hZ]] cVdf]e Z_ T‘de dRgZ_Xd R_U TcVReV VT‘_‘^ZT SV_VWZed+ LYV EVec‘ S‘RcU RU‘aeVU R a‘dZeZ‘_ ‘W dfaa‘ce W‘c eYV 0-,.- T‘_TVae ‘_ 9acZ] .2) /-.-) R_U R]d‘ T‘_WZc^VU eYRe WfefcV S‘RcU RTeZ‘_ h‘f]U SV cVbfZcVU e‘ Raac‘gV R_ RTTV]VcReVU ac‘[VTe UV]ZgVcj dTYVUf]V+

OYZ]V eYVdV a]R_d RcV acV]Z^Z_Rcj) dfTY R UVgV]‘a^V_e h‘f]U Z^aRTe eYV ac‘[VTe T‘^a]VeZ‘_ dTYVUf]V R_U T‘de+ AW dfTY a]R_d ^ReVcZR]ZkV) eYV Z^aRTe ‘_ eYV e‘eR] ac‘[VTe T‘de Z_ QG= U‘]]Rcd hZ]] SV ViR^Z_VU WfceYVc+

EVec‘ ac‘a‘dVd e‘ fdV R ^Zi ‘W >VUVcR] R_U ]‘TR] Wf_UZ_X e‘ Wf_U eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+ LYV Wf_UZ_X d‘fcTVd eYRe YRgV SVV_ ZUV_eZWZVU Z_ EVec‘od D‘_X*JR_XV LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ H]R_ ’DJLH( Z_T]fUV eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X7

-(,(+ :POP]LW

KVTeZ‘_ 20-6 FVh KeRced >f_Ud7 LYVdV >VUVcR] Wf_Ud RcV RhRcUVU Sj eYV >L9 ‘_ R UZdTcVeZ‘_Rcj SRdZd e‘ _Vh WZiVU XfZUVhRj ac‘[VTed+ A_ eYV DJLH) EVec‘ YRd Z_T]fUVU #.+4 SZ]]Z‘_ ’Z_ jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV U‘]]Rcd( Z_ >L9 KVTeZ‘_ 20-6 FVh KeRced Wf_Ud W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+ LYZd R^‘f_e hRd SRdVU ‘_ 2-$ ‘W eYV VdeZ^ReVU T‘_decfTeZ‘_ T‘de ‘W HYRdV .) 0-$ ‘W eYV VdeZ^ReVU T‘_decfTeZ‘_ T‘de ‘W HYRdV /) R_U -$ ‘W eYV VdeZ^ReVU T‘_decfTeZ‘_ T‘de ‘W HYRdV 0+ LYV WZ_R_TZR] a]R_ Rddf^Vd eYVdV Wf_Ud

Page 21: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’/

h‘f]U SV ac‘gZUVU SVehVV_ /-.. R_U /-/3) acZ^RcZ]j W‘c eYV WZcde eh‘ T‘_decfTeZ‘_ dVX^V_ed+

-(,(, ?ZNLW

n EVRdfcV J) D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ KR]Vd LRi7 LYV ^R[‘cZej ‘W _‘_*>VUVcR] Wf_UZ_X hZ]] SV ac‘gZUVU Sj eYV EVRdfcV J cVgV_fVd+

n D‘TR] 9XV_Tj >f_Ud7 A_ eYV DJLH EVec‘ ac‘XcR^^VU #.35+6 Z]]Z‘_ Z_ ]‘TR] RXV_Tj ecR_dZe T‘_ecZSfeZ‘_d W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+ LYV EVRdfcV J ‘cUZ_R_TV cVbfZcVd eYRe ]‘TR] RXV_TZVd Wf_U Re ]VRde 0 aVcTV_e ‘W e‘eR] ac‘[VTe T‘ded+

n DGFH JVZ^SfcdV^V_e >f_U7 LYV DJLH Z_T]fUVd Raac‘iZ^ReV]j #23+1 Z]]Z‘_ Z_ Wf_Ud UVcZgVU Wc‘^ cVZ^SfcdV^V_ed e‘ EVec‘ Wc‘^ eYV KeReV W‘c DVeeVcd ‘W F‘ HcV[fUZTV RXcVV^V_ed ‘_ gRcZ‘fd TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed) hYZTY EVec‘ Zd WcVV e‘ fdV ‘_ ‘eYVc TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed+ LYVdV Wf_Ud hZ]] SV fdVU e‘ Wf_U V_gZc‘_^V_eR] R_U a]R__Z_X RTeZgZeZVd Wc‘^ /-.- e‘ /-./+

LYV W‘]]‘hZ_X Wf_Ud YRgV SVV_ ViaV_UVU Wc‘^ /--3*/-.-+ LYVdV Wf_Ud RcV _‘e Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV R_R]jdZd ‘W WfefcV Wf_UZ_X cVbfZcV^V_ed) Sfe RcV UVdTcZSVU SV]‘h SVTRfdV eYVj RcV dY‘h_ Z_ eYV DJLH Rd d‘fcTVd ‘W Wf_Ud W‘c eYV ac‘[VTe+

n JVXZ‘_R] A^ac‘gV^V_e >f_Ud7 #/+5 ^Z]]Z‘_ ‘W JVXZ‘_R] A^ac‘gV^V_e >f_Ud W‘c LcR_dZe hVcV feZ]ZkVU W‘c a]R__Z_X R_U V_gZc‘_^V_eR] h‘c\ Z_ /--5+

n DL> ?V_VcR] JVgV_fVd7 EVec‘ feZ]ZkVU Raac‘iZ ReV]j #/+3 ^Z]]Z‘_ Z_ DL> XV_VcR] cVgV_fVd e‘ Wf_U a]R__Z_X R_U V_gZc‘_^V_eR] h‘c\ Z_ /--5+

n LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ <VgV]‘a^V_e 9Te ’L<9( 9ceZT]V 17 L<9 cVgV_fVd RcV R deReVhZUV l TV_e dR]Vd eRi+ EVec‘ feZ]ZkVU Raac‘iZ^ReV]j #0+5 Z]]Z‘_ Z_ L<9 cVgV_fVd W‘c a]R__Z_X R_U V_gZc‘_^V_eR] h‘c\ Wc‘^ /--3*/--5+

-(- 9aLW‘L_TZY ZQ :TYLYNTLW 7L[LNT_d

LRS]V 0*1 df^^RcZkVd eYV TRaZeR] T‘ded R_U cVgV_fVd W‘c eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd f_UVc T‘_dZUVcR*eZ‘_+ >‘c eYV afca‘dV ‘W T‘^aRcZd‘_) eYV cVgV_fVd YRgV SVV_ T‘_gVceVU e‘ /--6 U‘]]Rcd d‘ eYVj TR_ SV T‘^aRcVU e‘ eYV T‘ded) hYZTY RcV R]d‘ Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd+ LYVcVW‘cV) R_j a‘eV_eZR] cVgV_fV XRa Zd R]d‘ dY‘h_ Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd+ LYV e‘eR] R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_Ud Wc‘^ R]] d‘fcTVd) Rd ac‘XcR^^VU Z_ eYV DJLH) Zd #1+/50 SZ]]Z‘_ hYV_ T‘_gVceVU e‘ /--6 U‘]]Rcd+

9d ZUV_eZWZVU Z_ EVec‘od GTe‘SVc /--6 DJLH) EVRdfcV J R_U ‘eYVc cVgV_fVd RcV VdeZ^ReVU e‘ ac‘gZUV eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X cVgV_fVd ’Z_ jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV U‘]]Rcd( W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_7

n >L9 FVh KeRced JVgV_fV7 #.+4-3 SZ]]Z‘_ ’jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV(7 >‘c eYV afca‘dV ‘W eYZd R_R]jdZd) eYV e‘eR] R^‘f_e ‘W FVh KeRced Wf_UZ_X RgRZ]RS]V Zd Rddf^VU e‘ SV WZiVU Re eYV R^‘f_e Rddf^VU Z_ eYV GTe‘SVc /--6 DJLH+ 9d ac‘[VTe UVgV]‘a^V_e T‘_eZ_fVd) EVec‘ hZ]] ]Z\V]j dVV\ RUUZeZ‘_R] FVh KeRced f_UVc eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV+ 9_j RUUZeZ‘_R] WVUVcR] Wf_UZ_X h‘f]U SV Z_T]fUVU Z_ WfefcV faUReVd ‘W eYV DJLH+

n EVRdfcV J JVgV_fVd7 #1+-42 SZ]]Z‘_ ’jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV(7 LYZd R_R]jdZd Rddf^Vd eYRe EVRdfcV J Wf_Ud h‘f]U SV fdVU e‘ Wf_U ac‘[VTe T‘ded _‘e T‘gVcVU Sj >L9 FVh KeRced ‘c

Page 22: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’0

D‘TR] 9XV_Tj Wf_Ud) fa e‘ eYV ^RiZ f^ R^‘f_e RgRZ]RS]V Z_ eYV DJLH W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+

n D‘TR] 9XV_Tj >f_Ud7 #.35+6 ^Z]]Z‘_ ’jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV(7 LYZd WZ_R_TZR] R_R]jdZd Rddf^Vd eYRe eYV ^RiZ^f^ R^‘f_e ‘W ]‘TR] RXV_Tj Wf_UZ_X RgRZ]RS]V W‘c R_j ‘W eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd Zd WZiVU Re eYV R^‘f_e Rddf^VU Z_ eYV DJLH+

n DGFH JVZ SfcdV^V_e >f_U7 LYZd WZ_R_TZR] R_R]jdZd Rddf^Vd eYRe EVec‘ hZ]] daV_U #23+1 ^Z]]Z‘_ ’jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV( Z_ Wf_Ud W‘c R_j ‘W eYV SfZ]U R]eVc_ReZgVd) hZeY eYV ViTVaeZ‘_ ‘W eYV LKE R]eVc_ReZgV) Wc‘^ /-.- e‘ /-./+

LYV RS‘gV ]ZdeVU d‘fcTVd h‘f]U ac‘gZUV R e‘eR] ‘W #3+-.2 SZ]]Z‘_ Z_ cVgV_fV ’jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV() hYV_ T‘^SZ_VU hZeY cVgV_fVd R]cVRUj ViaV_UVU SVehVV_ /--3 R_U /-.-+

>‘c eYV VgR]fReZ‘_ ‘W WZ_R_TZR] TRaRTZej) eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_Ud W‘c VRTY Wf_UZ_X d‘fcTV ac‘XcR^^VU Z_ eYV GTe‘SVc /--6 DJLH YRgV SVV_ UV*VdTR]ReVU e‘ /--6 U‘]]Rcd) d‘ eYRe eYVj TR_ SV T‘^aRcVU e‘ eYV TRaZeR] T‘ded W‘c VRTY SfZ]U R]eVc_ReZgV+

:RdVU ‘_ eYZd T‘^aRcZd‘_ Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd) Rd Z]]fdecReVU Z_ LRS]V 0*1) eYV VdeZ^ReVU TRaZeR] T‘ded ‘W eYV W‘]]‘hZ_X R]eVc_ReZgVd WR]] hZeYZ_ eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_Ud ZUV_eZWZVU Z_ eYV DJLH7

n LKE 9]eVc_ReZgV n 9]eVc_ReZgV .) Z_T]fUZ_X Zed deReZ‘_ R_U R]ZX_^V_e ‘aeZ‘_d

9]eVc_ReZgV / ViTVVUd eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_UZ_X Z_ eYV DJLH Sj #50 ^Z]]Z‘_ Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd) hYZTY Zd ]Vdd eYR_ eh‘ aVcTV_e ‘W eYV e‘eR] T‘de+ :VTRfdV eYZd Zd cV]ReZgV]j T]‘dV e‘ eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_UZ_X eYRe Zd TfccV_e]j ac‘XcR^^VU) Ze Zd Rddf^VU eYRe EVec‘ TR_ ac‘XcR^ RUUZeZ‘_R] EVRdfcV J Wf_UZ_X e‘ YV]a T‘gVc eYZd dY‘ceWR]] Z_ WfefcV faUReVd ‘W eYV DJLH hZeY‘fe dZX_ZWZTR_e]j Z^aRTeZ_X eYV RXV_Tjod RSZ]Zej e‘ T‘^a]VeV ‘eYVc EVRdfcV J ac‘[VTed+ K‘^V ‘W eYV deReZ‘_ R_U R]ZX_^V_e ‘aeZ‘_d acVdV_eVU Z_ ;YRaeVc / h‘f]U UVTcVRdV eYZd Wf_UZ_X XRa) hYZ]V ‘eYVcd h‘f]U Z_TcVRdV eYV XRa R_U cVbfZcV EVec‘ e‘ cVac‘XcR^ RUUZeZ‘_R] EVRdfcV J Wf_UZ_X Z_ WfefcV faUReVd ‘W eYV DJLH+ 9]eVc_ReZgVd 0) 1) R_U 2 RcV _‘e T‘_dZUVcVU e‘ SV WZ_R_TZR]]j WVRdZS]V SVTRfdV eYVZc TRaZeR] T‘ded dZX_ZWZTR_e]j ViTVVU eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_UZ_X RgRZ]RS]V Z_ eYV DJLH+ 9d dY‘h_ Z_ LRS]V 3*0) eYV Wf_UZ_X XRa Zd SVehVV_ .)51/ ^Z]]Z‘_ R_U #1)14/ ^Z]]Z‘_ ’Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd( W‘c eYVdV R]eVc_ReZgVd+ EVec‘ h‘f]U SV f_RS]V e‘ Wf_U eYZd XRa eYc‘fXY EVRdfcV J cVgV_fVd hZeY‘fe Z^aRTeZ_X Zed RSZ]Zej e‘ Wf_U ‘eYVc TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed f_]Vdd eYV RXV_Tj ZUV_eZWZVU R _Vh d‘fcTV ‘W Wf_Ud+

=cc‘c! JVWVcV_TV d‘fcTV _‘e W‘f_U+0*1 dY‘hd eYV Rddf^VU R^‘f_e ‘W >VUVcR] Wf_Ud Rd R aVcTV_eRXV ‘W eYV e‘eR] ac‘[VTe T‘de Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd+

Page 23: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’1

FLMWP -’.4 7L[T_LW :‘YOTYR DP\‘T]PXPY_^ QZ] F]LY^[Z]_L_TZY Ed^_PX @LYLRPXPY_ LYO 6‘TWO 5W_P]YL_TaP^ TY ,**3 8ZWWL]^ $@TWWTZY^%

7Z^_ LYO DPaPY‘P

IP^_^TOP E‘MbLd

:‘YO^g?DFC FE@ 5W_ + 5W_ , 5W_ - 5W_ . 5W_ /

L‘eR] TRaZeR] T‘de 1)/50+1 1.+3 4,035.9 4,358.0 6,116.4 6,985.1 8,747.4

?L: FVh KeRced Wf_Ud .)04.+4 l 1,371.7 1,371.7 1,371.7 1,371.7 1,371.7

EVRdfcV J /)4/4+6 1.+3 2,489.5 2,727.9 2,727.9 2,727.9 2,727.9

D‘TR] ecR_dZe Wf_Ud ..5+4 l 118.7 118.7 118.7 118.7 118.7

DGFH cVZ^SfcdV^V_e 22+6 l 55.9 55.9 55.9 55.9 55.9

GeYVc d‘fcTVd _VVUVU W‘c dY‘ceWR]] l l - 83.7 1,842.1 2,710.8 4,473.2

L‘eR] cVgV_fVd _VVUVU 1)/50+1 1.+3 4,035.9 4,358.0 6,116.4 6,985.1 8,747.4

?L: Wf_Ud Rd aVcTV_e ‘W e‘eR] ac‘[VTe T‘de

0/# -# 34% 31% 22% 20% 16%

1 R]d‘ ac‘gZUVd eYV Rddf^VU R^‘f_e ‘W >VUVcR] Wf_Ud Rd R aVcTV_eRXV ‘W eYV e‘eR] ac‘[VTe T‘ded+ G_V R]eVc_ReZgV W‘c T]‘dZ_X R_j a‘eV_eZR] dY‘ceWR]] Zd W‘c EVec‘ e‘ dVV\ RUUZeZ‘_R] >VUVcR] Wf_Ud W‘c eYV ac‘[VTe+

OYZ]V >VUVcR] ]VXZd]ReZ‘_ aVc^Zed ac‘[VTe da‘_d‘cd e‘ dVV\ fa e‘ 5- aVcTV_e ‘W eYV e‘eR] T‘ded Z_ >VUVcR] Wf_UZ_X+ >L9 XZgVd R YZXYVc WZ_R_TZR] cReZ_X e‘ ac‘[VTed eYRe dVV\ 2- aVcTV_e ‘c ]Vdd+ A_ cVTV_e jVRcd) ac‘[VTed ‘gVc #. SZ]]Z‘_ eYRe YRgV ViVTfeVU >>?9d hZeY >L9) YRgV XV_VcR]]j cVTVZgVU 02 aVcTV_e ‘c ]Vdd Z_ >VUVcR] FVh KeRced Wf_Ud+ @‘hVgVc) dZ_TV eYV DJLH Rddf^aeZ‘_ ‘W #.+4 SZ]]Z‘_ ’jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV U‘]]Rcd( Z_ FVh KeRced Wf_Ud Zd Raac‘iZ^ReV]j 02 aVcTV_e ‘c ]Vdd W‘c VRTY ‘W eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd) EVec‘ ^Rj YRgV eYV RSZ]Zej e‘ cVbfVde RUUZeZ‘_R] Wf_Ud hZeY‘fe Z^aRTeZ_X Zed RSZ]Zej e‘ dVTfcV R_ RXcVV^V_e W‘c >VUVcR] Wf_Ud+ EVec‘ hZ]] T‘‘cUZ_ReV WfceYVc hZeY >L9 ‘_ eYV R^‘f_e ‘W >VUVcR] Wf_Ud Rd eYV WZ_R_TZR] a]R_ W‘c eYV dV]VTeVU R]eVc_ReZgV Zd WZ_R]ZkVU+ LYV cVgZdVU R^‘f_e ‘W cVbfVdeVU FVh KeRced Wf_Ud hZ]] SV cVW]VTeVU Z_ WfefcV faUReVd ‘W EVec‘od DJLH WZ_R_TZR] a]R_+

-(. 7ZY^_]‘N_TZY CSL^TYR

A_ RUUZeZ‘_ e‘ eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd UVdTcZSVU RS‘gV) EVec‘ Zd VgR]fReZ_X eh‘ ^Z_Z^f^ ‘aVcReZ_X dVX^V_ed ’EGK(+ LYV TRaZeR] T‘ded ‘W eYVdV eh‘ dVX^V_ed RcV dY‘h_ Z_ LRS]V 0*2+

Page 24: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’2

FLMWP -’/4 7L[T_LW 7Z^_ 9^_TXL_P^ QZ] @TYTX‘X B[P]L_TYR EPRXPY_^ Md E_LYOL]OTePO 7Z^_ 7L_PRZ]d TY ,**3 8ZWWL]^ $@TWWTZY^%

7Z^_ 7L_PRZ]TP^

@BE +g :LT]QLc IP^_

FP]XTY‘^

@BE , g 7PY_‘]d 7T_dgELY_L @ZYTNL 6Z‘WPaL]O

FP]XTY‘^

@fZUVhRj R_U ecRT\ V]V^V_ed 306,801 607,314

KeReZ‘_d) de‘ad) eVc^Z_R]d) Z_eVc^‘UR] 374,769 817,988

Kfaa‘ce WRTZ]ZeZVdljRcUd) dY‘ad) RU^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ SfZ]UZ_Xd

136,431 136,431

KZeVh‘c\ R_U daVTZR] T‘_UZeZ‘_d 136,186 249,883

KjdeV^d 66,577 126,463

JZXYe*‘W*hRj) ]R_U) ViZdeZ_X Z^ac‘gV^V_ed 72,040 83,361

NVYZT]Vd 254,100 304,920

Hc‘WVddZ‘_R] dVcgZTVd 336,851 639,567

M_R]]‘TReVU T‘_eZ_XV_Tj 168,376 296,593

?Z_R_TV TYRcXVd 0 —

L‘eR] T‘de &/--6 U‘]]Rcd’ 1,852,131 3,262,520

LYV TRaZeR] R_U ‘aVcReZ_X T‘ded W‘c EGK . R_U EGK / S‘eY WR]] hZeYZ_ eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_UZ_X ZUV_eZWZVU Z_ EVec‘od Raac‘gVU DJLH+ LYV UVTZdZ‘_ e‘ fdV T‘_decfTeZ‘_ aYRdVd ^Rj SV RWWVTeVU Sj eYV 0-,.- a]R_ ZW EVec‘ TY‘‘dVd e‘ RTTV]VcReV ac‘[VTe UV]ZgVcj W‘c eYV OVdedZUV VieV_dZ‘_+ 9_j faUReVd e‘ eYV T‘_decfTeZ‘_ aYRdZ_X a]R_ hZ]] SV cVW]VTeVU Z_ WfefcV faUReVd ‘W EVec‘od DJLH WZ_R_TZR] a]R_+

-(/ :‘YOTYR EZ‘]NP^ QZ] BYRZTYR 7L[T_LW CWLY

EVec‘od ]‘_X cR_XV TRaZeR] _VVUd RcV Wf_UVU eYc‘fXY R _f^SVc ‘W ]‘TR]) deReV R_U >VUVcR] Wf_Ud+ LYV Wf_Ud ac‘XcR^^VU e‘ eYV ]‘_X cR_XV TRaZeR] _VVUd W‘c EVec‘ JRZ] Wc‘^ /-.-m/-1- RcV ac‘gZUVU Z_ LRS]V 0*33+

EVRdfcV J Zd eYV YR]W*TV_e dR]Vd eRi W‘c D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej eYRe hZ]] WZ_R_TV _Vh ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ ac‘[VTed R_U ac‘XcR^d) R_U RTTV]VcReV ^R_j ac‘[VTed R]cVRUj Z_ eYV ac‘[VTe UVgV]‘a^V_e aZaV]Z_V) Z_T]fUZ_X _Vh cRZ] R_U,‘c Sfd cRaZU ecR_dZe ac‘[VTed) T‘^^feVc cRZ] Z^ac‘gV^V_ed) EVec‘ JRZ] djdeV^d Z^ac‘gV^V_ed) YZXYhRj ac‘[VTed) Z^ac‘gVU T‘f_ejhZUV R_U ]‘TR] Sfd ‘aVcReZ‘_d) R_U ]‘TR] TZej*da‘_d‘cVU ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ Z^ac‘gV*^V_ed+ EVRdfcV J hRd Raac‘gVU Sj eYV g‘eVcd Z_ F‘gV^SVc /--5) R_U e‘‘\ VWWVTe Z_ Bf]j /--6+

LYV EVec‘ :‘RcU ‘W <ZcVTe‘cd ‘cZXZ_R]]j Raac‘gVU R EVRdfcV J ViaV_UZefcV a]R_ Z_ Bf]j /1) /--5+ LYV /--6 DJLH) hYZTY ‘fe]Z_VU eYV ac‘[VTed e‘ SV Wf_UVU Sj EVRdfcV J Rd hV]] Rd ‘eYVc Wf_UZ_X d‘fcTVd) hRd Raac‘gVU Z_ GTe‘SVc /--6+

A_ cVda‘_dV e‘ TYR_XZ_X VT‘_‘^ZT T‘_UZeZ‘_d) cVUfTVU deReV ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ Wf_UZ_X R_U eYV RgRZ]RSZ]Zej ‘W _Vh WVUVcR] deZ^f]fd Wf_Ud) Z_ ERcTY /-.- eYV EVec‘ :‘RcU ‘W <ZcVTe‘cd Raac‘gVU R cVgZdVU DJLH ViaV_UZefcV a]R_ W‘c ac‘[VTed ‘gVc #4 ^Z]]Z‘_

Page 25: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’3

‘TTfccZ_X SVehVV_ >Q /-..m/-.6+ LYV ViaV_UZefcV a]R_ acZ‘cZeZkVd Zed ^R[‘c TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed Z_e‘ dZi ^R[‘c TReVX‘cZVd) SRdVU ‘_ eYV _VVU e‘ Wf]WZ]] ViZdeZ_X Wf_UZ_X T‘^^Ze^V_ed) ac‘gZUV dRWVej Z^ac‘gV^V_ed) R_U ]VgVcRXV >VUVcR] Wf_Ud+ LYV cVgZdVU ViaV_UZefcV a]R_ W‘c >Q /-..m>Q /-.6 Zd ac‘gZUVU Z_ 9aaV_UZi 9+

GgVcR]]) EVRdfcV J Zd ViaVTeVU e‘ XV_VcReV _VRc]j #03 SZ]]Z‘_ Z_ cVgV_fVd Wc‘^ >Q /-.- e‘ >Q /-1-+ GW eYRe #03 SZ]]Z‘_) Raac‘iZ^ReV]j #./+/ SZ]]Z‘_ ’‘c Raac‘iZ^ReV]j 02$ ‘W e‘eR] cVgV_fVd( Zd ^R_UReVU e‘ SV R]]‘TReVU e‘ eYV ehV]gV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV TRaZeR] ViaR_dZ‘_ ac‘[VTed Sj GcUZ_R_TV "-5*-. ’hZeY daVTZWZT R^‘f_ed e‘ SV R]]‘TReVU e‘ VRTY ac‘[VTe(+ JVgV_fVd Wc‘^ EVRdfcV J TR_ SV ]VgVcRXVU e‘ SfZ]U TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed) Rd Zd a]R__VU Z_ eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV+

LYV ehV]gV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV ac‘[VTed hVcV ‘cZXZ_R]]j ac‘a‘dVU e‘ SV T‘^a]VeVU ‘gVc 0- jVRcd+ M_UVc eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV) eYV ac‘[VTed YRgV SVV_ RTTV]VcReVU e‘ cVRTY dfSdeR_eZR] T‘^a]VeZ‘_ hZeYZ_ .- jVRcd+ LYZd hZ]] cVbfZcV ]VgVcRXZ_X ‘W EVRdfcV J cVgV_fVd e‘ ‘SeRZ_ eYV faWc‘_e Wf_UZ_X _VTVddRcj e‘ T‘^a]VeV eYV ehV]gV TRaZeR] ViaR_dZ‘_ ac‘[VTed+ A_ R ^V^‘ Wc‘^ eYV D9;EL9 :‘RcU UReVU 9acZ] .2) /-.-) a]VUXZ_X dfaa‘ce W‘c eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV) eYV D9;EL9 :‘RcU ‘fe]Z_VU eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV RTTV]VcReZ‘_ dTYVUf]V R_U ‘cUVcVU eYV ac‘[VTed Z_ eVc^d ‘W acZ‘cZej e‘ D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej+

Page 26: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

-(*g7L[T_LW CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP -’+*

FLMWP -’04 ?ZYR FP]X 7L[T_LW :‘YOTYR QZ] @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*+*f,*.*

EZ‘]NP^ ZQ :‘YO^ $XTWWTZY^& KB9%

FZ_LW :K ,*+*f:K,*.*

:K ,*+*f:K,*+3

:K ,*,*f :K ,*,3

:K ,*-*f :K ,*.*

D‘TR]

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ : 02#l=ZcVTe /)0/5+6 0)-14+5 2)/1-+-

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < 1-#l=ZcVTe .)-55+. .)0.1+- /)3.3+2

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < .-#l=ZcVTe 35+2 l l

L=: :ceZT]V 1 l .+4 3+6

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < /2#l=ZcVTe 234+3 l l

D‘TR] :XV_Tj <‘_ecZSfeZ‘_d /-1+- ...+. .61+4

DL? @V_VcR] JVgV_fVd l l l

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < .-# &EVec‘]Z_\’ 0/4+- 065+5 /63+1

DGFH JVZ^SfcdV^V_e ?f_U 023/ /20+5 l l

EVRdfcV J &/#) 0#) 02# ViTVae Sfd TRa+’ 0)-01+2 1)620+0 3)64.+2

KfSe‘eR] D‘TR] 00)-/2+0 4)54/+3 6)5/3+5 .2)0/3+-

KeReV

KL:lH‘af]ReZ‘_ KYRcV l l l

Hc‘a .; KeReV ;‘_Ud .)-14+0 l l

AZXY KaVVU JRZ] ;‘_Ud g‘eVU ..*1*-5 /1-+6 l l

LcRWWZT <‘_XVdeZ‘_ JV]ZVW Hc‘XcR^ .63+- l l

JVXZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_e Hc‘XcR^ &JBH’ ?f_UdlLcR_dZe

136+2 /26+3

KfSe‘eR] KeReV /)/.0+0 .)620+4 l /26+3

?VUVcR]

KVTe+ 20-6 FVh KeRced .)34/+/ 311+- .)614+3

KVTe+ 20-6 ?ZiVU @fZUVhRj E‘U 0.+5 36+3 l

KVTe+ 201- @c‘hZ_X KeReVd $ AZXY =V_d+ l l l

<E:IlLcR_dZe /60+1 l l

JKLHlLcR_dZe 4+4 l l

KVTe+ 20-6 ;fd $ ;fd*JV]ReVU ?RTZ]ZeZVd /+6 l l

:JJ: &20-6) 20-4) 201-) L>’ .62+6 l l

KfSe‘eR] ?VUVcR] 1)532+. /)/-0+6 4.0+3 .)614+3

K‘fcTV7 :aac‘gVU EVec‘ D‘_X JR_XV H]R_) GTe‘SVc /--6

Page 27: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’+

.(* BC9D5F=A; 5A8 @5=AF9A5A79 C?5A

LYZd dVTeZ‘_ RUUcVddVd eYV G%E T‘de VdeZ^ReVd W‘c VRTY R]eVc_ReZgV) eYV cVgV_fVd RgRZ]RS]V e‘ Wf_U eYV Z_TcVRdVU G%E T‘ded W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_) R_U EVec‘od RSZ]Zej e‘ Wf_U eYV Z_TcV^V_eR] G%E T‘ded+

.(+ B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7Z^_^

LYV R__fR] T‘ded ‘W VRTY R]eVc_ReZgV RcV acVdV_eVU W‘c eYV ac‘[VTe Y‘cZk‘_ jVRc ’/-02( Z_ LRS]V 1*.) R]‘_X hZeY eYV UZWWVcV_TV SVehVV_ VRTY ac‘[VTe R]eVc_ReZgV R_U eYV F‘ :fZ]U R]eVc_ReZgV+ LYV G%E T‘ded Z_T]fUV Z_TcV^V_eR] T‘ded W‘c eYV gRcZ‘fd EVec‘ ^‘UVd) Rd hV]] Rd eYV Z_TcV^V_eR] G%E T‘ded W‘c eYV ^f_ZTZaR] ecR_dZe djdeV^d+ 9UUZeZ‘_R] UVeRZ]d ‘_ eYV G%E T‘ded RcV ac‘gZUVU Z_ eYV GaVcReZ_X R_U ERZ_eV_R_TV ;‘de EVeY‘U‘]‘Xj) 9acZ]) .3) /-.-+

LYV DJLH Z_T]fUVd G%E Wf_UZ_X W‘c #15 ^Z]]Z‘_ W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ Z_ /-/2+ 9d dY‘h_ Z_ LRS]V 1*//) eYcVV ‘W eYV SfZ]U R]eVc_ReZgVd YRgV /-02 G%E T‘ded eYRe ViTVVU eYV R^‘f_e ac‘XcR^^VU Z_ eYV DJLH+

9]eVc_ReZgVd 0) 1) R_U 2nR_U eYV deReZ‘_ , UVdZX_ gRcZReZ‘_d ‘_ VRTYnYRgV eYV XcVReVde TYR_XV Z_ G%E T‘ded) T‘^aRcVU e‘ eYV F‘ :fZ]U R_U LKE 9]eVc_ReZgVd+ LYVdV R]eVc_ReZgVd hZ]] T‘de R_ RUUZeZ‘_R] #3. ^Z]]Z‘_ e‘ #..5 ^Z]]Z‘_ R__fR]]j e‘ ‘aVcReV R_U ^RZ_eRZ_ ‘gVc eYV F‘ :fZ]U T‘_UZeZ‘_+ 9]eVc_ReZgVd . R_U /) R_U eYV UVdZX_ gRcZReZ‘_d ‘W VRTY) hZ]] T‘de SVehVV_ #02 ^Z]]Z‘_ R_U #11 ^Z]]Z‘_ R__fR]]j ^‘cV eYR_ eYV F‘ :fZ]U R]eVc_ReZgV+

?ZgV_ eYV _f^SVc ‘W T‘de R_U dVcgZTV gRcZRS]Vd eYRe T‘f]U TYR_XV Z_ eYV _Vie /2 jVRcd) Ze Zd a‘ddZS]V eYRe EVec‘ hZ]] SV RS]V e‘ RSd‘cS R XcVReVc Z_TcV^V_eR] Z_TcVRdV Z_ G%E T‘ded Sj /-02) hYZTY ^Rj ^R\V ‘_V ‘W eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd RS‘gV ^‘cV RWW‘cURS]V+

Page 28: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’,

FLMWP .’+4 5YY‘LW B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7Z^_^ QZ] KPL] ,*-/ QZ] FE@ LYO 6‘TWO 5W_P]YL_TaP^ TY KPL] ZQ 9c[PYOT_‘]P 8ZWWL]^ $XTWWTZY^%

5YY‘LW 5XZ‘Y_^ AZ’6‘TWO FE@ 5W_ + 5W_ , 5W_ - 5W_ . 5W_ /

EVec‘ AVRgj JRZ] ./4+0. ./4+00 .60+43 .65+.0 //-+15 /13+60 /44+22

EVec‘ DZXYe JRZ] 16-+62 16-+62 16-+4- 16-+31 16-+/. 16-+21 16-+.-

EVec‘ =ZcVTe]j*GaVcReVU ;fd 6/.+6/ 6/2+24 56.+// 56.+// 56.+// 56.+// 56.+//

EVec‘ HfcTYRdVU LcR_da+ ;fd 02+.. 02+.. 02+.. 02+.. 02+.. 02+.. 02+..

KfSe‘eR]lEVec‘ L‘eR] KjdeV^ .)242+/6 .)245+62 .)3.-+46 .)3.2+.- .)304+-0 .)330+5- .)360+64

Ef_ZTZaR] KjdeV^d L‘eR] <‘de .34+-/ .34+-- .33+60 .33+61 .33+63 .33+63 .33+66

L‘eR] EVec‘a‘]ZeR_ :cVR <‘de .)41/+0. .)412+62 .)444+4/ .)45/+-1 .)5-0+65 .)50-+43 .)53-+64

=ZWWVcV_TV Wc‘^ F‘ ;fZ]U7 EVec‘ G_]j 0+33 02+2- 06+5/ 3.+41 55+2. ..5+36

=ZWWVcV_TV Wc‘^ F‘ ;fZ]U 0+31 02+1. 06+40 3.+34 55+12 ..5+33

Page 29: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’-

FLMWP .’,4 KPL] ,*-/ B#@ 7Z^_^ QZ] 5W_P]YL_TaP^ ZaP] @P_]Z ?DFC 5XZ‘Y_ QZ] IP^_^TOP E‘MbLd 9c_PY^TZY

5W_P]YL_TaP ,*-/ =YN]PXPY_LW B#@ 7Z^_

$XTWWTZY^& KB9%

5XZ‘Y_ ZaP] ,*-/ IP^_^TOP E‘MbLd B#@ 7Z^_ TY ?DFC

$!.2 XTWWTZY& KB9%

:]eVc_ReZgV 0 3.+41 .0+41

:]eVc_ReZgV 1 55+2. 1-+2.

:]eVc_ReZgV 2 ..5+36 4-+36

.(, B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP :‘YOTYR EZ‘]NP^

EVec‘ fdVd R T‘^SZ_ReZ‘_ ‘W ]‘TR]) deReV R_U >VUVcR] Wf_UZ_X d‘fcTVd e‘ ‘aVcReV R_U ^RZ_eRZ_ eYV EVec‘ cRZ] djdeV^+ LYVdV Wf_UZ_X d‘fcTVd RcV Rd W‘]]‘h7

.(,(+ ?ZNLW)E_L_P

n D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ 9 R_U Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ ; ;‘f_ejhZUV KR]Vd LRi

n L<9 9ceZT]V 1) deReVhZUV l TV_e dR]Vd eRi

n GeYVc7 LYZd Z_T]fUVd ^ZdTV]]R_V‘fd cVgV_fVd dfTY Rd RUgVceZdZ_X+

n D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ KR]Vd LRi) EVRdfcV J

n KeReV LcR_dZe 9ddZdeR_TVnH‘af]ReZ‘_ KYRcV7 EVec‘ R_eZTZaReVd cVTVZgZ_X eYVdV Wf_Ud W‘c G%E RWeVc /-.0

.(,(, :POP]LW

n KVTeZ‘_ 20-6 >ZiVU ?fZUVhRj E‘UVc_ZkReZ‘_

n KVTeZ‘_ 201- ?c‘hZ_X KeReVd R_U @ZXY <V_dZej

n @‘^V]R_U KVTfcZej ?cR_ed

n ;‘_XVdeZ‘_ ER_RXV^V_e R_U 9Zc IfR]Zej ’;E9I( >f_Ud7 W‘c ‘aVcReZ‘_d ‘_ eYV ?‘]U DZ_V) =ia‘ DZ_V) ;cV_dYRh) R_U ‘eYVc _Vh ]Z_Vd+

A_ RUUZeZ‘_ e‘ eYVdV Wf_UZ_X d‘fcTVd) EVec‘ cV]ZVd ‘_ WRcV cVgV_fVd e‘ Wf_U RS‘fe ‘_V eYZcU ‘W Zed ‘aVcReZ_X T‘ded+ :RdVU ‘_ ac‘[VTeZ‘_d Z_ EVec‘od DJLH) EVec‘ ViaVTed e‘ cVT‘gVc Raac‘iZ^ReV]j 01 aVcTV_e ‘W Zed e‘eR] T‘ded SVehVV_ /--2 R_U /-1- W‘c eYV JVU R_U Hfca]V DZ_Vd ’Z_T]fUZ_X eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_() :]fV DZ_V) ?cVV_ DZ_V) ?‘]U DZ_V ’Z_T]fUZ_X eYV =RdedZUV =ieV_dZ‘_ R_U >‘‘eYZ]]d() ;cV_dYRh DZ_V) OVde KR_eR 9_R DZ_V) R_U EVec‘]Z_\+

.(- B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 9c[PYOT_‘]P 7L^S :WZb

LRS]V 1*00 R_U LRS]V 1*11 acVdV_e eYV ‘aVcReZ_X R_U ^RZ_eV_R_TV TRdY W]‘h W‘c eYV V_eZcV EVec‘ djdeV^) Z_T]fUZ_X eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+ LYZd TRdY W]‘h) hYZTY Zd Z_T]fUVU Z_ eYV GTe‘SVc /--6 DJLH) Rddf^Vd eYRe eYV WZcde aYRdV ‘W eYV OVdedZUV

Page 30: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’.

=ieV_dZ‘_ h‘f]U SV ‘aVcReZ‘_R] Z_ /-.68 eYV dVT‘_U aYRdV h‘f]U SV ‘aVcReZ‘_R] Z_ /-/38 R_U eYV eYZcU aYRdV h‘f]U SV ‘aVcReZ‘_R] Z_ /-03+

Page 31: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R^‘_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’/

FLMWP .’-4 B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7L^S :WZb QZ] _SP @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*+*f,*+3& KB9

:‘YO^ $! TY XTWWTZY^%

CWLY "

,**3 ,*+* ,*++ ,*+, ,*+- ,*+. ,*+/ ,*+0 ,*+1 ,*+2 ,*+3

FZ_LW ,*+* ,*++ ,*+, ,*+- ,*+. ,*+/ ,*+0 ,*+1 ,*+2 ,*+3 ,*,*

K‘fcTVd ‘W ?f_Ud

D‘TR]

?RcVdlJVU,Hfca]V DZ_Vd /)/./+4 6+3# /6+- 01+6 02+0 1-+4 1.+/ 11+. 11+3 13+3 14+/ 16+0 22+-

?RcVdl;]fV DZ_V &Z_T]fUZ_X >ia‘ $ JVX%] <‘__+’

.)6.-+/ 5+0# .3+2 /5+2 /6+0 00+5 01+/ 03+3 10+4 12+2 13+. 15+/ 2/+/

?RcVdl@cVV_ DZ_V 2/3+. /+0# 4+/ 5+4 5+5 .-+. .-+0 ..+- ..+. ..+3 ..+5 ./+0 ./+1

?RcVdl@‘]U DZ_V &Z_T]fUZ_X >RdedZUV $ ?‘‘eYZ]]’

404+0 0+/# 5+- 5+4 5+6 .-+/ .-+0 ..+- ..+/ ..+4 .6+- .6+3 .6+6

?RcVdl<cV_dYRh DZ_V 013+0 .+2# l l l l l l l l l ..+3 ..+6

?RcVdlOVde KR_eR :_R DZ_V ./0+6 -+2# l l l l l l l l l l l

?RcVdlEVec‘]Z_\ /)-/4+4 5+5# 1/+- 10+2 12+- 13+3 15+/ 16+6 2.+3 2/+3 20+4 21+5 22+5

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ : 02# 0).62+1 .0+5# /.+4 /1+. /3+/ /6+4 0.+0 /5+1 /5+5 01+/ 16+5 23+- 3.+.

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < 2 # &KVTfcZej’ 203+. /+0# l l l l .+3 /+6 1+/ 2+0 3+1 4+3 5+5

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < 1- # &=ZdTcVeZ‘_Rcj’ /)5-5+3 ./+/# 54+. 13+1 21+- 10+1 -+. 25+4 55+. 15+0 26+/ 15+3 3.+/

L=: :ceZT]V 1 1.-+- .+5# l 02+- 0-+- 1-+- 32+- l l .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+-

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < .-# &EVec‘]Z_\’ /)/04+0 6+4# 02+- 03+1 04+5 06+0 1-+6 1/+2 11+/ 13+- 14+5 16+5 2.+4

GeYVc &:UgVceZdZ_X) @V_VcR]) EZdT’ 45+/ -+0# .+3 .+3 .+4 .+4 .+5 .+5 .+5 .+6 .+6 .+6 /+-

EVRdfcV J KR]Vd LRi .)555+4 5+/# /.+6 0.+3 00+/ 02+2 05+0 1-+3 1/+6 12+- 14+. 16+0 2.+3

KfSe‘eR] D‘TR] .6)-05+2 5/+1# /4-+- /66+1 0.-+/ 00.+- 0/0+- 0/4+2 04/+1 025+4 1--+- 1.6+. 120+3

KeReV

KL:lH‘af]ReZ‘_ KYRcV .)345+- 4+0# l l l l 1.+4 1/+3 10+2 11+1 12+0 13+0 14+0

KfSe‘eR] KeReV .)345+- 4+0# l l l l 1.+4 1/+3 10+2 11+1 12+0 13+0 14+0

?VUVcR]

KVTeZ‘_ 20-6 ?ZiVU @fZUVhRj E‘UVc_ZkReZ‘_

.)26.+1 3+6# 04+6 1-+0 1-+6 1.+1 1/+- 1/+3 10+/ 10+5 .4+5 06+5 02+6

Page 32: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

FLMWP .’-4 B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7L^S :WZb QZ] _SP @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*+*f,*+3& KB9 $NZY_TY‘PO%

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’0

:‘YO^ $! TY XTWWTZY^%

CWLY "

,**3 ,*+* ,*++ ,*+, ,*+- ,*+. ,*+/ ,*+0 ,*+1 ,*+2 ,*+3

FZ_LW ,*+* ,*++ ,*+, ,*+- ,*+. ,*+/ ,*+0 ,*+1 ,*+2 ,*+3 ,*,*

KVTeZ‘_ 201- @c‘hZ_X KeReVd R_U AZXY =V_dZej

/34+0 .+/# 3+1 3+2 3+3 3+4 3+5 3+6 4+- 4+. 4+/ 4+0 4+1

A‘^V]R_U KVTfcZej @cR_ed 0+5 -+-# l l l l l l l l l l l

<E:I &@‘]U,>ia‘,<cV_dYRh,FVh DZ_Vd GaVcReZ‘_d’

2.2+/ /+/# 6+. /5+6 /6+/ .5+3 l l l l /3+0 15+1 32+3

KfSe‘eR] ?VUVcR] /)044+4 .-+0# 20+1 42+4 43+4 33+5 15+5 16+2 2-+/ 2-+6 2.+0 62+2 .-5+6

L‘eR] K‘fcTVd /0)-61+. .--+-# 0/0+1 042+. 053+6 064+5 1.0+3 1.6+3 133+. 121+- 163+3 23-+6 3-6+5

MdVd ‘W ?f_Ud

JVU,Hfca]V DZ_V 0)103+5 .1+6# 4/+- 34+- 35+5 4-+3 4/+4 42+6 45+- 45+1 5-+- 5.+3 50+1

KfShRj >ieV_dZ‘_ KVX^V_ed .) /) R_U 0 5/0+/ 0+3# l l l l l l l l l l .4+-

;]fV DZ_V 0)0-6+2 .1+0# 4.+5 4.+6 41+2 43+5 5-+3 5-+- 52+4 45+6 5-+2 52+/ 54+.

@cVV_ DZ_V .)01.+1 2+5# /2+5 /2+5 /3+3 /4+/ /5+3 /5+0 /6+2 /5+- /5+2 0.+/ 0.+6

@‘]U DZ_VlHRdRUV_R &Z_T]fUZ_X ?‘‘eYZ]]’

.)366+2 4+1# /0+- /1+2 /2+. /2+5 /4+/ /3+6 /4+6 /2+/ 16+2 2-+2 2.+4

@‘]U DZ_Vl>RdedZUV >ieV_dZ‘_ 4.5+- 0+.# .2+1 .2+0 .2+4 .3+/ .4+- .3+6 .4+2 .2+5 .3+. .3+2 .3+6

;]fV DZ_Vl>ia‘dZeZ‘_ HYRdV B .)/5/+/ 2+3# l 00+2 01+/ 02+/ 04+- 03+4 04+6 03+- 03+4 04+1 05+0

;]fV DZ_Vl>ia‘dZeZ‘_ HYRdV BB 4--+2 0+-# l l l l l l /1+5 //+5 /0+/ /0+4 /1+/

<cV_dYRh DZ_V .)-/3+/ 1+1# l l l l l l l l l 05+3 06+2

OVde KR_eR :_R DZ_V 1-2+2 .+5# l l l l l l l l l l l

JVXZ‘_R] <‘__VTe‘c /55+0 .+/# l l l l l l l l l l ..+2

JRZ] KVTfcZejlJVU DZ_V .).36+6 2+.# .5+3 .6+- .6+3 .6+6 /-+0 /-+4 /.+/ /.+2 /.+6 //+1 /4+3

JRZ] KVTfcZejl;]fV DZ_V Z_T]+ >ia‘,JVX%] <‘__+

.)-05+/ 1+2# ./+/ .5+1 .6+- .6+1 .6+4 /-+. /2+1 /3+- /3+2 /4+3 0-+1

JRZ] KVTfcZejl@cVV_ DZ_V 032+6 .+3# 3+2 3+3 3+6 3+6 4+. 4+/ 4+1 4+5 5+- 5+4 5+6

JRZ] KVTfcZejl@‘]U DZ_V Z_T]fUZ_X >RdedZUV

55.+. 0+5# ./+2 .0+1 .0+4 .0+6 .1+/ .1+2 .1+6 .2+. /1+. /1+3 /2+/

JRZ] KVTfcZejl<cV_dYRh DZ_V //2+4 .+-# l l l l l l l l l 5+2 5+4

Page 33: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

FLMWP .’-4 B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7L^S :WZb QZ] _SP @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*+*f,*+3& KB9 $NZY_TY‘PO%

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’1

:‘YO^ $! TY XTWWTZY^%

CWLY "

,**3 ,*+* ,*++ ,*+, ,*+- ,*+. ,*+/ ,*+0 ,*+1 ,*+2 ,*+3

FZ_LW ,*+* ,*++ ,*+, ,*+- ,*+. ,*+/ ,*+0 ,*+1 ,*+2 ,*+3 ,*,*

JRZ] KVTfcZejlOVde KR_eR :_R DZ_V ..2+0 -+2# l l l l l l l l l l l

JVU DZ_V daVTZR] R_eZ*eVcc‘cZd^ RTeZgZeZVd .+5 -+-#

KfSe‘eR] EVec‘ .5)5/6+/ /24+4 /62+1 0-1+. 0..+6 0/1+2 0/4+/ 04-+/ 022+1 062+. 123+1 2-/+/

EVec‘]Z_\ 1)/32+- .5+2# 44+- 46+5 5/+5 52+6 56+. 6/+1 62+6 65+3 .-.+3 .-1+2 .-4+3

L‘eR] MdVd /0)-61+. .--+-# 001+4 042+/ 053+6 064+5 1.0+3 1.6+3 133+. 121+- 163+3 23-+6 3-6+5

.+ LcR_dZe <‘ccZU‘c JVgV_fV GaVcReZ‘_ =ReVd7 >RdedZUVl?Q.-) >ia‘Bl/-.-,*/-..) >ia‘BBl3,.2) @‘]U ?eY]l3,.4) <cV_dYRhl3,.5) JVX%] <‘__l3,.6) KfS >ie KVX Bl3,.6) OVde KR_eR :_Rl3,/4) KfS >ie KVX /l3,/3) KfS >ie KVX 0l3,03) @cVV_ K‘ ;Rjl3,02) @‘]U >Rde >iel3,02 /+ /--6 DJLH ;RdV]Z_V .-,//,-6

FLMWP .’.4 B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7L^S :WZb QZ] _SP @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*,*f,*-0

:‘YO^ $! TY XTWWTZY^%

CWLY

"

,*,* ,*,+ ,*,, ,*,- ,*,. ,*,/ ,*,0 ,*,1 ,*,2 ,*,3 ,*-* ,*-+ ,*-, ,*-- ,*-. ,*-/

FZ_LW ,*,+ ,*,, ,*,- ,*,. ,*,/ ,*,0 ,*,1 ,*,2 ,*,3 ,*-* ,*-+ ,*-, ,*-- ,*-. ,*-/ ,*-0

K‘fcTVd ‘W ?f_Ud

D‘TR]

?RcVdlJVU,Hfca]V DZ_Vd /)/./+4 6+3# 24+. 24+6 3-+- 3-+5 31+3 32+1 42+1 43+1 46+3 5-+3 50+0 51+0 54+1 55+2 6.+5 6/+6

?RcVdl;]fV DZ_V &Z_T]fUZ_X >ia‘ $ JVX%] <‘__+’

.)6.-+/ 5+0# 21+0 22+- 24+- 24+4 3.+0 3/+. 32+2 33+0 36+. 4-+- 4/+0 40+/ 42+5 43+5 46+4 5-+4

?RcVdl@cVV_ DZ_V 2/3+. /+0# .0+- .0+. .0+3 .0+5 .1+3 .1+5 .2+3 .2+5 .4+5 .5+- .5+3 .5+5 .6+2 .6+4 /-+2 /2+.

?RcVdl@‘]U DZ_V &Z_T]fUZ_X >RdedZUV $ ?‘‘eYZ]]’

404+0 0+/# /-+4 /-+6 /.+4 //+- /0+1 /0+4 /2+- /2+0 /3+0 /3+4 /4+2 /4+6 /5+6 /6+0 0-+1 05+2

?RcVdl<cV_dYRh DZ_V 013+0 .+2# ./+0 ./+2 .0+- .0+. .0+6 .1+. .1+6 .2+. .2+4 .2+6 .3+1 .3+3 .4+/ .4+1 .5+. .5+0

?RcVdlOVde KR_eR :_R DZ_V ./0+6 -+2# l l l l l l l 5+1 5+2 5+3 5+6 6+- 6+0 6+1 6+5 6+6

?RcVdlEVec‘]Z_\ /)-/4+4 5+5# 23+6 24+6 25+5 26+4 3-+2 3.+1 3/+1 30+2 31+4 32+6 34+/ 35+1 36+4 4.+- 4/+1 40+5

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ : 02# 0).62+1 .0+5# 31+5 4.+5 .10+6 .1-+. .-.+. .04+4 .00+. .44+5 .10+/ .44+4 ..5+6 .//+/ .-3+. .-.+6 .-3+5 .-0+1

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < 2 # &KVTfcZej’ 203+. /+0# .-+. ..+3 .0+. .1+4 .3+. .4+2 .5+5 /-+/ /.+2 //+5 /1+. /2+1 /3+4 /5+. /6+2 0-+6

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < 1- # &=ZdTcVeZ‘_Rcj’

/)5-5+3 ./+/# .--+6 ..6+/ 2.+5 1/+. 4-+5 01+1 2.+1 //+6 23+6 05+3 ..0+. ..3+1 ./6+- .04+5 .0.+5 .3/+.

Page 34: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

FLMWP .’.4 B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7L^S :WZb QZ] _SP @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*,*f,*-0 $NZY_TY‘PO%

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’2

:‘YO^ $! TY XTWWTZY^%

CWLY

"

,*,* ,*,+ ,*,, ,*,- ,*,. ,*,/ ,*,0 ,*,1 ,*,2 ,*,3 ,*-* ,*-+ ,*-, ,*-- ,*-. ,*-/

FZ_LW ,*,+ ,*,, ,*,- ,*,. ,*,/ ,*,0 ,*,1 ,*,2 ,*,3 ,*-* ,*-+ ,*-, ,*-- ,*-. ,*-/ ,*-0

L=: :ceZT]V 1 1.-+- .+5# .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+- .-+-

Hc‘a‘dZeZ‘_ < .-# &EVec‘]Z_\’ /)/04+0 6+4# 20+5 23+- 25+/ 3-+2 30+- 32+2 35+. 4-+5 40+3 43+3 46+4 5/+5 53+/ 56+3 60+/ 63+6

GeYVc &:UgVceZdZ_X) @V_VcR]) EZdT’

45+/ -+0# /+- /+- /+. /+. /+. /+/ /+/ /+/ /+0 /+0 /+1 /+1 /+2 /+2 /+3 /+3

EVRdfcV J KR]Vd LRi .)555+4 5+/# 21+- 23+2 26+- 3.+2 30+5 33+/ 35+2 4.+- 40+1 43+- 45+1 5-+6 50+1 53+. 55+4 6.+3

KfSe‘eR] D‘TR] .6)-05+2 5/+1# 2-6+6 211+0 23/+0 225+. 232+0 241+6 3.-+6 312+3 33/+5 356+5 4/-+4 405+0 42.+4 435+. 452+. 503+5

KeReV

KL:lH‘af]ReZ‘_ KYRcV .)345+- 4+0# 15+0 16+0 2-+0 2.+1 2/+1 20+2 21+4 22+5 24+- 25+/ 26+1 3-+4 3.+6 30+/ 31+3 32+6

KfSe‘eR] KeReV .)345+- 4+0# 15+0 16+0 2-+0 2.+1 2/+1 20+2 21+4 22+5 24+- 25+/ 26+1 3-+4 3.+6 30+/ 31+3 32+6

?VUVcR]

KVTeZ‘_ 20-6 ?ZiVU @fZUVhRj E‘UVc_ZkReZ‘_

.)26.+1 3+6# /1+4 /0+2 0/+4 15+0 15+6 16+3 2-+0 2.+- 2.+4 2/+2 20+/ 21+- 21+4 22+2 23+/ 24+-

KVTeZ‘_ 201- @c‘hZ_X KeReVd R_U AZXY =V_dZej

/34+0 .+/# 4+2 4+3 4+4 4+5 4+6 5+- 5+/ 5+0 5+1 5+2 5+3 5+4 5+6 6+- 6+. 6+/

A‘^V]R_U KVTfcZej @cR_ed 0+5 -+-# l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l

<E:I &@‘]U,>ia‘, <cV_dYRh,FVh DZ_Vd GaVcReZ‘_d’

2.2+/ /+/# 05+4 .3+2 l l l l ./+- /4+6 /5+0 .3+. l l l l l //+3

KfSe‘eR] ?VUVcR] /)044+4 .-+0# 4-+6 14+3 1-+2 23+. 23+6 24+4 4-+2 54+/ 55+1 44+. 3.+5 3/+4 30+3 31+2 32+1 55+5

L‘eR] K‘fcTVd /0)-61+. .--+-# 3/6+. 31.+/ 320+- 332+2 341+3 353+. 403+. 455+3 5-5+/ 5/2+. 51/+- 53.+4 544+/ 562+5 6.2+. 66.+2

MdVd ‘W ?f_Ud

JVU,Hfca]V DZ_V 0)103+5 .1+6# 6.+0 6/+6 61+1 63+. 64+. 65+2 .-4+6 ..-+/ ...+6 ..1+. ..3+/ ..5+4 ./-+2 .//+6 ./2+/ ./5+.

KfShRj >ieV_dZ‘_ KVX^V_ed .) /) R_U 0

5/0+/ 0+3# .4+0 .4+3 .4+6 .5+/ .5+1 .5+4 1-+1 1.+0 1.+6 1/+4 10+2 11+2 12+/ 13+- 13+6 15+-

;]fV DZ_V 0)0-6+2 .1+0# 55+2 6-+- 6.+2 60+- 61+. 62+1 64+- 66+- .--+3 .-/+2 .-1+1 .-3+3 .-5+0 ..-+1 ../+2 ..2+.

@cVV_ DZ_V .)01.+1 2+5# 0/+1 0/+6 00+2 01+- 01+1 01+6 02+2 03+/ 1.+- 1.+5 1/+3 10+2 11+/ 12+- 12+6 3.+0

@‘]U DZ_VlHRdRUV_R &Z_T]fUZ_X ?‘‘eYZ]]’

.)366+2 4+1# 2/+1 20+0 21+/ 22+/ 22+5 23+3 24+2 25+5 26+3 3-+5 3.+6 30+0 31+/ 32+1 33+4 35+0

@‘]U DZ_Vl>RdedZUV >ieV_dZ‘_ 4.5+- 0+.# .4+. .4+1 .4+4 .5+- .5+/ .5+1 .5+4 .6+/ .6+1 .6+5 /-+/ /-+4 /-+6 /.+0 /.+4 15+/

Page 35: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

.(*gB[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP CWLY

FLMWP .’.4 B[P]L_TYR LYO @LTY_PYLYNP 7L^S :WZb QZ] _SP @P_]Z DLTW Ed^_PX& ,*,*f,*-0 $NZY_TY‘PO%

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP .’3

:‘YO^ $! TY XTWWTZY^%

CWLY

"

,*,* ,*,+ ,*,, ,*,- ,*,. ,*,/ ,*,0 ,*,1 ,*,2 ,*,3 ,*-* ,*-+ ,*-, ,*-- ,*-. ,*-/

FZ_LW ,*,+ ,*,, ,*,- ,*,. ,*,/ ,*,0 ,*,1 ,*,2 ,*,3 ,*-* ,*-+ ,*-, ,*-- ,*-. ,*-/ ,*-0

;]fV DZ_Vl>ia‘dZeZ‘_ HYRdV B .)/5/+/ 2+3# 05+6 06+3 1-+/ 1-+6 1.+0 1.+6 1/+3 10+2 11+/ 12+. 12+6 13+6 14+3 15+2 16+2 2-+3

;]fV DZ_Vl>ia‘dZeZ‘_ HYRdV BB 4--+2 0+-# /1+3 /2+- /2+1 /2+6 /3+/ /3+2 /4+- /4+3 /5+- /5+2 /6+- /6+4 0-+. 0-+4 0.+0 0/+.

<cV_dYRh DZ_V .)-/3+/ 1+1# 1-+. 1-+5 1.+1 1/+/ 1/+3 10+/ 10+6 11+6 12+3 13+1 14+0 15+1 16+. 2-+- 2.+- 2/+/

OVde KR_eR :_R DZ_V 1-2+2 .+5# l l l l l l l /4+6 /5+0 /5+5 /6+0 0-+- 0-+1 0.+- 0.+3 0/+1

JVXZ‘_R] <‘__VTe‘c /55+0 .+/# ..+4 ..+6 ./+. ./+0 ./+1 ./+3 ./+5 .0+. .0+0 .0+3 .0+5 .1+. .1+0 .1+3 .1+6 .2+/

JRZ] KVTfcZejlJVU DZ_V .).36+6 2+.# /6+5 0-+0 0-+5 0.+0 0.+4 0/+/ 1-+4 1.+2 1/+/ 10+- 10+5 11+5 12+2 13+0 14+/ 15+0

JRZ] KVTfcZejl;]fV DZ_V Z_T]+ >ia‘,JVX%] <‘__+

.)-05+/ 1+2# 0-+6 0.+1 0.+6 0/+2 0/+6 00+0 00+6 01+3 02+. 02+5 03+2 04+/ 04+5 05+3 06+0 1-+/

JRZ] KVTfcZejl@cVV_ DZ_V 032+6 .+3# 6+. 6+/ 6+1 6+2 6+3 6+5 6+6 .-+. ..+2 ..+4 ..+6 ./+/ ./+0 ./+3 ./+5 .4+.

JRZ] KVTfcZejl@‘]U DZ_V Z_T]fUZ_X >RdedZUV

55.+. 0+5# /2+2 /3+- /3+1 /3+6 /4+/ /4+3 /5+- /5+4 /6+. /6+3 0-+/ 0-+6 0.+0 0.+6 0/+2 1/+5

JRZ] KVTfcZejl<cV_dYRh DZ_V //2+4 .+-# 5+5 6+- 6+. 6+0 6+1 6+2 6+4 6+6 .-+- .-+/ .-+1 .-+3 .-+5 ..+- ..+/ ..+2

JRZ] KVTfcZejlOVde KR_eR :_R DZ_V

..2+0 -+2# l l l l l l l 4+6 5+. 5+/ 5+1 5+2 5+4 5+5 6+- 6+/

JVU DZ_V daVTZR] R_eZ*eVcc‘cZd^ RTeZgZeZVd

.+5 -+-#

KfSe‘eR] EVec‘ .5)5/6+/ 2.5+0 2/4+0 203+- 212+0 22.+/ 226+0 3-2+3 321+0 336+5 35/+2 362+. 4.-+1 4/.+0 402+/ 416+2 5/-+5

EVec‘]Z_\ 1)/32+- .5+2# ..-+4 ..0+6 ..4+- ./-+/ ./0+2 ./3+6 .0-+2 .01+0 .05+1 .1/+2 .13+5 .2.+/ .22+5 .3-+3 .32+3 .4-+5

L‘eR] MdVd /0)-61+. .--+-# 3/6+. 31.+/ 320+- 332+2 341+3 353+. 403+. 455+3 5-5+/ 5/2+. 51/+- 53.+4 544+/ 562+5 6.2+. 66.+2

.+ LcR_dZe <‘ccZU‘c JVgV_fV GaVcReZ‘_ =ReVd7 >RdedZUVl?Q.-) >ia‘Bl/-.-,*/-..) >ia‘BBl3,.2) @‘]U ?eY]l3,.4) <cV_dYRhl3,.5) JVX%] <‘__l3,.6) KfS >ie KVX Bl3,.6) OVde KR_eR :_Rl3,/4) KfS >ie KVX /l3,/3) KfS >ie KVX 0l3,03) @cVV_ K‘ ;Rjl3,02) @‘]U >Rde >iel3,02 /+ /--6 DJLH ;RdV]Z_V .-,//,-6

Page 36: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August
Page 37: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

/(*gDT^V^ LYO GYNP]_LTY_TP^

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP /’+

/(* D=E>E 5A8 GA79DF5=AF=9E

/(+ C]ZUPN_ 7Z^_ GYNP]_LTY_TP^

9d hZeY R_j ac‘[VTe Z_ eYV a]R__Z_X R_U T‘_TVaefR] V_XZ_VVcZ_X deRXV) eYVcV Zd R UVXcVV ‘W T‘de cZd\d Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY VRTY ‘W eYV R]eVc_ReZgVd f_UVc VgR]fReZ‘_ W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_+ LYZd T‘de cZd\ acZ^RcZ]j Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY eYV UVWZ_ZeZ‘_ ‘W eYV ac‘[VTe dT‘aV) ac‘[VTe dTYVUf]V) R_U ac‘[VTe Wf_UZ_X+

/(+(+ 7SLYRP^ TY C]ZUPN_ ENZ[P

;fccV_e T‘de VdeZ^ReVd RcV SRdVU ‘_ R_ Raac‘iZ^ReV .-*aVcTV_e ]VgV] ‘W V_XZ_VVcZ_X T‘^a]VeZ‘_+ 9d eYV ac‘[VTe ac‘XcVddVd Z_e‘ acV]Z^Z_Rcj V_XZ_VVcZ_X R_U UVdZX_) eYV VdeZ^ReV hZ]] SVT‘^V ^‘cV acVTZdV Rd eYV ac‘[VTe Zd cVWZ_VU+ ;‘de Z_TcVRdVd T‘f]U ‘TTfc Rd R cVdf]e ‘W f_ViaVTeVU d‘Z] T‘_UZeZ‘_d R_U XV‘eVTY_ZTR] ZddfVd) eYV _VVU W‘c f_ViaVTeVU feZ]Zej cV]‘TReZ‘_d) ‘c eYV acVdV_TV ‘W eRc dR_Ud) f_R_eZTZaReVU Xc‘f_UhReVc R_U ‘eYVc V_gZc‘_^V_eR] Z^aRTed R_U ^ZeZXReZ‘_ ^VRdfcVd) aRceZTf]Rc]j Rdd‘TZReVU hZeY eYV f_UVcXc‘f_U R]ZX_^V_e+ AddfVd cV]ReZ_X e‘ ef__V]Z_X eVTY_‘]‘XZVd) W‘c ViR^a]V) TR_ TYR_XV eYV VdeZ^ReVU T‘ded+ LYV TfccV_e T‘de VdeZ^ReV Z_T]fUVd T‘_eZ_XV_TZVd e‘ T‘gVc eYVdV R_U ‘eYVc a‘eV_eZR] TYR_XVd+

EVec‘ YRd R]d‘ ZUV_eZWZVU dVgVcR] dT‘aV V]V^V_ed eYRe hZ]] SV defUZVU WfceYVc UfcZ_X eYV acV]Z^Z_Rcj V_XZ_VVcZ_X aYRdV) Z_T]fUZ_X R ecRT\ T‘__VTeZ‘_ decfTefcV eYRe acVdVcgVd R WfefcV ViaR_dZ‘_ ‘W eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ e‘ OVde @‘]]jh‘‘U8 R_ R]]‘hR_TV W‘c eYV WfefcV ViaR_dZ‘_ ‘W eYV OVdeh‘‘U,N9 @‘daZeR] deReZ‘_ hZeY eh‘ a]ReW‘c^d8 cVa]RTV^V_e aRc\Z_X Re eYV N9 @‘daZeR] deReZ‘_8 R_U RUUZeZ‘_R] V_gZc‘_^V_eR] ^ZeZXReZ‘_ T‘ded e‘ ZUV_eZWj W‘ddZ] cV^RZ_d Z_ eYV ac‘[VTe RcVR+

AW RUUVU e‘ eYV dT‘aV ‘W eYV ac‘[VTe) eYVdV Z^ac‘gV^V_ed h‘f]U cVbfZcV ‘W #.1. ^Z]]Z‘_ e‘ #/34 ^Z]]Z‘_ ‘W RUUZeZ‘_R] Wf_UZ_X) Z_ /--6 U‘]]Rcd+

/(+(, 7SLYRP^ TY C]ZUPN_ ENSPO‘WP

KTYVUf]V UV]Rjd T‘f]U SV cV]ReVU e‘ f_W‘cVdVV_ T‘_decfTeZ‘_ TYR]]V_XVd) ]‘TR] UVTZdZ‘_*^R\Z_X ac‘TVddVd) VbfZa^V_e ^R]Wf_TeZ‘_d) ‘c XV_VcR] T‘_decfTeZ‘_ UV]Rjd+ M_TVceRZ_ej deZ]] ViZded Z_ eYV acVTZdV eZ^Z_X ‘W eYV T‘_decfTeZ‘_ aYRdVd) hYZTY ^Rj SV Z^aRTeVU Sj eYV 0-,.- a]R_) eYV RgRZ]RSZ]Zej ‘W ]‘TR] Wf_UZ_X) R_U eYV eZ^Z_X ‘W >VUVcR] Wf_UZ_X Raac‘gR]d+ @‘hVgVc) S‘eY ‘W EVec‘od acZ‘c >VUVcR] cRZ] ac‘[VTed) Z_T]fUZ_X eYV =RdedZUV ?‘]U DZ_V R_U eYV JVU DZ_V EGK*0) hVcV UV]ZgVcVU ‘_ eYVZc >>?9 dTYVUf]Vd R_U SfUXVed+ A_TcVRdVd Z_ eYV dTYVUf]V UfcReZ‘_ T‘f]U cVdf]e Z_ RUUZeZ‘_R] ac‘XcR^ ^R_RXV^V_e R_U ‘gVcYVRU T‘ded) R_U a‘eV_eZR] Z_TcVRdVd Z_ acZTV VdTR]ReZ‘_+

/(, :‘YOTYR GYNP]_LTY_TP^

/(,(+ :F5 APb E_L]_^ :‘YOTYR

LYV DJLH Rddf^Vd #.+4 SZ]]Z‘_ Z_ >VUVcR] FVh KeRced Wf_Ud ’Z_ jVRc ‘W ViaV_UZefcV U‘]]Rcd() hYZTY cVacVdV_ed Raac‘iZ^ReV]j /5 aVcTV_e ‘W eYV e‘eR] Wf_UZ_X W‘c eYV Hc‘[VTe ac‘XcR^^VU Z_ eYV ]‘_X cR_XV a]R_+ EVec‘ ^Rj cVbfVde RUUZeZ‘_R] FVh KeRced Wf_UZ_X f_UVc eYV eVc^d ‘W eYV 0-,.- A_ZeZReZgV+ LYV eVc^d ‘W eYZd Wf_UZ_X hZ]] SV _VX‘eZReVU R_U

Page 38: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

/(*gDT^V^ LYO GYNP]_LTY_TP^

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP /’,

UVdTcZSVU Z_ eYV >f]] >f_UZ_X ?cR_e 9XcVV^V_e SVehVV_ eYV EVec‘ R_U eYV >L9) hYZTY Zd ViaVTeVU e‘ ‘TTfc UfcZ_X eYV WZ_R] UVdZX_ deRXV ‘W eYV ac‘[VTe a]R__Z_X ac‘TVdd+

LYV TfccV_e >VUVcR] ]VXZd]ReZ‘_ eYRe RfeY‘cZkVd eYV FVh KeRced ac‘XcR^ YRd SVV_ VieV_UVU f_eZ] <VTV^SVc 0.) /-.-+ LYVcV Zd deZ]] T‘_dZUVcRS]V f_TVceRZ_ej RS‘fe hYV_ ;‘_XcVdd hZ]] cVRfeY‘cZkV eYV dfcWRTV ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ ac‘XcR^ R_U eYV R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_UZ_X eYRe hZ]] SV ac‘gZUVU W‘c FVh KeRced ac‘[VTed+ LYZd T‘f]U RWWVTe eYV e‘eR] R^‘f_e ‘W Wf_UZ_X RgRZ]RS]V W‘c FVh KeRced ac‘[VTed Rc‘f_U eYV T‘f_ecj+

;‘^aVeZeZ‘_ W‘c FVh KeRced Wf_Ud Zd dZX_ZWZTR_e) R_U eYRe T‘^aVeZeZ‘_ TR_ Z_TcVRdV ZW Wf_UZ_X Zd ]Z^ZeVU+ 9d ‘W /-.-) eYVcV RcV /2 ac‘[VTed Z_ eYV FVh KeRced ac‘[VTe UVgV]‘a^V_e ac‘TVdd ’.1 ac‘[VTed Z_ acV]Z^Z_Rcj V_XZ_VVcZ_X R_U .. Z_ WZ_R] UVdZX_+( LYVcV RcV 5 ac‘[VTed f_UVc T‘_decfTeZ‘_ hZeY Wf]] Wf_UZ_X XcR_e RXcVV^V_ed Z_ dZi ^Vec‘ RcVRd+ <V]Rjd Z_ WVUVcR] Raac‘gR]d T‘f]U Z^aRTe eYV ac‘[VTe dTYVUf]V) R_U cVUfTeZ‘_d Z_ WVUVcR] Wf_UZ_X T‘f]U Z_TcVRdV eYV R^‘f_e ‘W ]‘TR] Wf_UZ_X cVbfZcVU e‘ T‘^a]VeV eYV ac‘[VTe+ :VTRfdV eYV ^R[‘cZej ‘W _‘_*>VUVcR] Wf_UZ_X W‘c eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ Zd T‘^Z_X Wc‘^ eYV EVRdfcV J ac‘XcR^) R cVUfTeZ‘_ Z_ Wf_UZ_X T‘f]U Z^aRTe EVec‘od RSZ]Zej e‘ T‘^a]VeV eYV V_eZcV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_) ‘c T‘f]U Z^aRTe eYV UV]ZgVcj ‘W ‘eYVc TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed+

/(,(, ?ZNLW :‘YOTYR DT^V^

LYV acZ^Rcj d‘fcTV ‘W _‘_*>VUVcR] Wf_UZ_X Zd eYV EVRdfcV J YR]W*TV_e dR]Vd eRi+ KR]Vd eRi T‘]]VTeZ‘_d RcV dV_dZeZgV e‘ VT‘_‘^ZT T‘_UZeZ‘_d R_U ‘gVcR]] cReVd ‘W T‘_df^aeZ‘_+ 9_j cVUfTeZ‘_ Z_ EVRdfcV J Wf_UZ_X T‘f]U Z^aRTe EVec‘od RSZ]Zej e‘ T‘^a]VeV eYV V_eZcV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ ‘c T‘f]U Z^aRTe eYV UV]ZgVcj ‘W ‘eYVc TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed+

EVec‘ YRd UVgV]‘aVU R_ ViaV_UZefcV a]R_ W‘c /-.. e‘ /-.6 eYRe acZ‘cZeZkVd Zed ^R[‘c Z_gVde^V_ed SRdVU ‘_ R _f^SVc ‘W TcZeVcZR+ Hc‘[VTed eYRe RcV TfccV_e]j f_UVc T‘_decfTeZ‘_ R_U YRgV ViZdeZ_X Wf_UZ_X T‘^^Ze^V_ed RcV eYV YZXYVde acZ‘cZej+ LYV _Vie YZXYVde acZ‘cZej Z_T]fUVd ac‘[VTed eYRe YRgV SVXf_ afcTYRdZ_X cZXYe ‘W hRj R_U ac‘[VTed eYRe cVbfZcV Wf_UZ_X e‘ T‘_eZ_fV ac‘[VTe UVgV]‘a^V_e+

LYV _Vie eZVc ‘W acZ‘cZeZVd cV]ReVd e‘ TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed eYRe RcV dVV\Z_X Raac‘gR] e‘ SVXZ_ T‘_decfTeZ‘_+ >‘c eY‘dV ac‘[VTed) EVec‘ YRd RddZX_VU eYV YZXYVde acZ‘cZej e‘ dRWVej Z^ac‘gV^V_ed R_U FVh KeRced ac‘[VTed+ 9_ Z_ZeZR] aYRdV ‘W eYV OVdedZUV KfShRj =ieV_dZ‘_ WR]]d Z_e‘ eYZd TReVX‘cj) UV^‘_decReZ_X eYV YZXY acZ‘cZej eYRe EVec‘ a]RTVd ‘_ f_UVceR\Z_X eYZd ac‘[VTe Z_ eYV /-.. e‘ /-.6 eZ^VWcR^V+

LYV 0-,.- a]R_ T‘f]U R]d‘ RWWVTe eYV eZ^Z_X R_U RgRZ]RSZ]Zej ‘W ]‘TR] Wf_UZ_X) hYZTY h‘f]U SV ac‘gZUVU eYc‘fXY UVSe eYRe h‘f]U SV cVaRZU Sj EVRdfcV J cVgV_fVd+ K‘^V ‘W eYVdV UVSe Z_decf^V_ed T‘f]U cVbfZcV ]VXZd]ReZgV RTeZ‘_ Sj ;‘_XcVdd+ @‘hVgVc) dZ_TV EVec‘ YRd ZUV_eZWZVU eYV OVdedZUV ac‘[VTe Rd R YZXY acZ‘cZej eYRe hZ]] SV Z^a]V^V_eVU Z_ eYV _Vie UVTRUV) EVec‘ ^Rj cVUfTV eYZd cZd\ Sj fdZ_X ViZdeZ_X UVSe Z_decf^V_ed e‘ deRce T‘_decfTeZ‘_ ‘_ eYZd ac‘[VTe Z_ eYV _VRc eVc^+

Page 39: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

0(*gDPQP]PYNP^

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 0’+

0(* D9:9D9A79E

>L9 /-.- >VUVcR] LcR_dZe 9U^Z_ZdecReZ‘_ ’>L9(+ /-.-+ 9__fR] cVa‘ce ‘_ _Vh deRced W‘c WZdTR] jVRc /-..+

EVec‘ /--6R D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej EVec‘a‘]ZeR_ LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ 9feY‘cZej ’EVec‘(+ /--6+ D‘_X cR_XV ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ a]R_+

EVec‘ /--6S D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej EVec‘a‘]ZeR_ LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ 9feY‘cZej ’EVec‘(+ /--6+ OVdedZUV dfShRj VieV_dZ‘_ UcRWe TRaZeR] T‘de ^VeY‘U‘]‘Xj cVa‘ce+

EVec‘ /-.-R D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej EVec‘a‘]ZeR_ LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ 9feY‘cZej ’EVec‘(+ /-.-+ OVdedZUV dfShRj VieV_dZ‘_ UcRWe ‘aVcReZ_X T‘de ^VeY‘U‘]‘Xj cVa‘ce+

EVec‘ /-.-S D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej EVec‘a‘]ZeR_ LcR_da‘ceReZ‘_ 9feY‘cZej ’EVec‘( :‘RcU ‘W <ZcVTe‘cd EVVeZ_X EReVcZR]d+ /-.-+ 9eeRTY^V_e 6nD‘_X cR_XV ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ a]R_ _VRc*eVc^ decReVXZVd R_U acZ‘cZej dVeeZ_X TcZeVcZR R_U /-.. D‘d 9_XV]Vd ;‘f_ej ecR_da‘ceReZ‘_ Z^ac‘gV^V_e ac‘XcR^) Rd RU‘aeVU ERcTY /2) /-.-+

Page 40: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August
Page 41: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R^‘_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’+

5CC9A8=J 5

DPaT^PO ?ZYR DLYRP F]LY^[Z]_L_TZY CWLY ,*++g,*+3& @L]NS ,/& ,*+*

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

<ReVX‘cj .

>RdedZUV DJL V_YR_TV^V_ed l 22+6 22+6

>ia‘dZeZ‘_ DJL HYRdV B .1+3 /42+. /56+4

DZXYe JRZ] NVYZT]VdlH/22- &_‘e Z_T]fUVU Z_ ecR_dZe ac‘[VTed’

l 2-+/ 2-+/

EL: JRZ] :JJ: Hc‘[VTel;]fV DZ_V ecRTeZ‘_ a‘hVc dfSdeReZ‘_

l 20+3 20+3

KR_ ?Vc_R_U‘ NR]]Vj F*K GcR_XV DZ_V <R_‘XR >ieV_dZ‘_

32+. ../+1 .44+2

<‘_XVdeZ‘_ JVUfTeZ‘_ =V^‘_decReZ‘_ /1-+- /1-+-

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj .lLcR_dZe 46+4 454+/ 533+6

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde HYRdV B l 30+2 30+2

B*.- <Rca‘‘] DR_V Wc‘^ B*3-2 e‘ HfV_eV 6+3 ./2+2 .02+.

B*1-2 <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd Wc‘^ KJ*6- e‘ B*.- -+. /6+. /6+/

B*1-2 F; <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd Wc‘^ B*.- e‘ MK*.-. .5/+. 52.+6 .)-01+-

B*2,KJ*.1 <Rca‘‘] DR_V =ZcVTe <‘__VTe‘c .+6 .-0+1 .-2+0

K‘f_UhR]] ‘_ B*2 <Rca‘‘] DR_V Wc‘^ KJ*..5 e‘ KJ*.1

-+0 44+- 44+0

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXV 1 .+5 3+1 5+/

KJ*3- <Rca‘‘] DR_V Wc‘^ B*3-2 e‘ ;cVR <R_j‘_ JU

-+0 /1+. /1+1

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj .lAZXYhRj .63+. .)/5-+6 .)144+-

L‘eR] <ReVX‘cj . /42+5 /)-35+. /)010+6 /)010+6 /)010+6

<ReVX‘cj /

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&.’7 KJ*.4- e‘ KJ*..5

50+0 .34+3 /2-+6

DZXYe JRZ] NVYZT]VdlH0---( &_‘e Z_ ecR_dZe ac‘[VTed’

l /2-+2 /2-+2

L‘eR] <ReVX‘cj / 50+0 1.5+. 2-.+1 2-.+1 /)512+0

<ReVX‘cj 0

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde @cRUV KVaRcReZ‘_d HYRdV BB

.--+- .--+-

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&/’7 KJ .4- e‘ ;fV_R NZdeR Ke

.4+5 .4+5

Page 42: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TLYW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’,

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd &0’7 KJ*.01 e‘ K‘+ ‘W ;fcSR_\ ;]gU+

/6+. /6+.

B*2 K‘feY&.’7 <Rc^V_ZeR J‘RU B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_e

.54+5 .54+5

B*2 K‘feY&/’7 :]‘_UcR GgVcTc‘ddZ_X /4+0 /4+0

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 0lAZXYhRj 03/+- 03/+-

L‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 0 03/+- 03/+- 03/+- 0)/-4+0

<ReVX‘cj 1

<cV_dYRh,D:P LcR_dZe <‘ccZU‘c /22+0 /22+0

>RdedZUV DZXYe JRZ] :TTVdd 1+- 1+-

>ia‘dZeZ‘_ DJL HYRdV BB /34+- /34+-

@‘]U DZ_V >RdedZUV DJL >ieV_dZ‘_ HYRdV BB V_gZc‘_^V_eR]

2+5 2+5

@‘]U DZ_V W‘fc bfRUcR_e XReVd >BJ,>BK 0+4 0+4

EVec‘]Z_\ TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed $ cV_‘gReZ‘_,cVYRSZ]ZeReZ‘_

0.+6 0.+6

EVec‘]Z_\ H‘dZeZgV LcRZ_ <‘_ec‘] 6+2 6+2

JVXZ‘_R] <‘__VTe‘c .60+. .60+.

KR_ ?Vc_R_U‘ NR]]Vj >Rde F‘ceY*K‘feY JRaZUhRjd

13+6 13+6

OVdedZUV KfShRj >ieV_dZ‘_ KVX^V_e . .4.+5 .4.+5

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 1lLcR_dZe 656+- 656+-

:cc‘j‘ NVcUfX‘ Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(

.4+1 .4+1

;FK? @cRUV KVaRcReZ‘_d Z_ @ReVhRj <ZeZVd( ..+- ..+-

<?H7 @ReVhRj <ZeZVd LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘cc) HY N &?.0./’

-+/ -+/

<?H7 F‘XR]Vd Ke &D: KfSUZg’ @cRUV KVa &?..26’

3+- 3+-

<?H7 KR_ @RScZV] NR]]Vj LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘ccZU‘cd &?.0/.’

-+0 -+0

<?H7 NZTe‘cj ;] OZUV_) L‘aR_XR <j*=V K‘e‘ &?..1.’

.+4 .+4

<?H7 ORdYZ_Xe‘_ ;]+ OZUV_Z_X) JVT‘_de &?..-4’

-+. -+.

<?H7 OZ]^Z_Xe‘_ :gV B_ecTYX E‘UZWZT Re B*1-2 &?..-0’

.+6 .+6

AZXY =VdVce <‘ccZU‘c V_gZc‘_^V_eR] 00+- 00+-

B*.- <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd Wc‘^ <Zecfd e‘ KJ*24 .4+1 .4+1

B*.- <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd Wc‘^ HfV_eV e‘ <Zecfd /4+5 /4+5

Page 43: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R^‘_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’-

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&1’7 ;fcSR_\ ;]gU cVT‘_decfTeZ‘_

10+2 10+2

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&2’7 ;fV_R NZdeR Ke e‘ >^aZcV :g

33+4 33+4

B*2 F‘ceY LcfT\ R_U AGN DR_Vd( 05+- 05+-

B*2 K‘feY&0’7 NR]]Vj NZVh B_eVcTYR_XV /40+5 /40+5

B*2 K‘feY&1’7 KY‘V^R\Vc) J‘dVTcR_d) ;]‘‘^WZV]U ;cZUXVd

30+- 30+-

B*2 K‘feY&2’7 KR_ :_e‘_Z‘) B^aVcZR] Ahj) R_U Gcc R_U =Rj

./6+5 ./6+5

B*2 K‘feY&3’7 ?]‘cV_TV :gV_fV B_eVcTYR_XV 2-+6 2-+6

B*3-2 <‘ccZU‘c !A‘e Ka‘e! B_eVcTYR_XVd Z_ @ReVhRj <ZeZVd(

2-+- 2-+-

B*4.- K‘feY >Rc]j :TeZ‘_ Hc‘[VTed 54+- 54+-

B*4.- K‘feY( .2+- .2+-

DRd NZcXV_Vd,ER]ZSf Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(

/6+5 /6+5

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXV .- .-+- .-+-

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXV .. 5+3 5+3

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXVd ./) .0) $ .1 5+4 5+4

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXVd 2 $ 4 .3+5 .3+5

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXVd 3 $ 5 1+6 1+6

K‘feY ;Rj JR^a R_U B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_ed(

2-+- 2-+-

KJ*.05 OZUV_Z_X $ <RaRTZej >_YR_TV^V_ed 4-+- 4-+-

KJ*4. ?cVVhRj7 B*.- e‘ EZddZ‘_ ;]gU( 6+/ 6+/

KJ*4.- F‘ceY >ieV_dZ‘_ &ef__V]’( 5-+- 5-+-

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 1lAZXYhRj .)///+2 .)///+2

L‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 1 /)/..+2 /)/..+2 /)/..+2 2)1.5+5

<ReVX‘cj 2 &KRWVej $ FVh KeRced’

@‘]U DZ_V W‘fc bfRUcR_e XReVd >BJ,>BK L;= L;=

EVec‘]Z_\ H‘dZeZgV LcRZ_ <‘_ec‘] 53+0 53+0

EVec‘]Z_\ dRWVej ac‘[VTed 06+0 06+0

JVXZ‘_R] <‘__VTe‘c 514+4 514+4

OVdedZUV KfShRj >ieV_dZ‘_ KVX^V_e . .)40.+0 .)40.+0 /)4-1+3 5)./0+1

<ReVX‘cj 2 &Hc‘[VTe JVRUZ_Vdd R_U KfS*JVXZ‘_R] >bfZej’

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde @cRUV KVa HY BBl/2# ‘W EVRdfcV J

42+- 42+-

Page 44: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TLYW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’.

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde @cRUV KVa HY BBl.4# EL: T‘^^Ze^V_e

.-2+6 .-2+6

:cc‘j‘ NVcUfX‘ Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.-+/ .-+/

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&/’7 KJ .4- e‘ ;fV_R NZdeR Ke

6-+- 6-+-

B*2 K‘feY&.’7 <Rc^V_ZeR J‘RU B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_e

.6.+6 .6.+6

DRd NZcXV_Vd,ER]ZSf Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.1+2 .1+2

JRaZU ;fd KZX_R]ZkReZ‘_ R_U KeReZ‘_ KfSdZUj Hc‘[VTed

00+0 00+0

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXVd 2 $ 4 3-+4 3-+4

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXVd 3 $ 5 .4+6 .4+6

K‘feY ;Rj JR^a R_U B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

13+5 13+5

KJ*.05 OZUV_Z_XlHVRcS]‘dd‘^) ./3eY e‘ D‘_X NZVh

/3+- /3+- 34/+. 5)462+2

<ReVX‘cj 2 &LcR_dZe KjdeV^ KeReV ‘W @‘‘U JVaRZc’

;fd <RaZeR] EL: R_U Ef_Zd &EVRdfcV J’( 1-+- 1-+-

EVec‘]Z_\ cV_‘gReZ‘_ R_U cVYRSZ]ZeReZ‘_( 61+- 61+-

EL: ;fd :TbfZdZeZ‘_( &_‘_*?:H’ 00# 02-+- 02-+-

EL: ;fd ?RTZ]Zej ERZ_eV_R_TV &_‘_*?:H’ 00#

2-+- 2-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]l?RTZ]ZeZVd ^RZ_eV_R_TVl2-#

2-+- 2-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]l^ZdT ac‘[VTedl2-# 5-+- 5-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]l^ZdT JVU) ;]fV) @cVV_ Z^ac‘g+l2-#

1-+- 1-+- 4-1+- 6)166+2

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

<?H7 @VcR]U =Vd^‘_U ;cZUXV Hc‘[VTe &?..32 $ ?0./3’

/5+3 /5+3

<?H7 H‘ce LcfT\ LcRWWZT JVUfTe+7 O+ ;RdZ_ JRZ]jU &?0.4-’

5+3 5+3

<?H7 JeV .-.,DZ_UVc‘ <j_ JU B_ecTYX B^ac‘g+ &?..0/’

5+3 5+3

<?H7 KJ*147JVa]RTV AVZ^ ;cUX $ FVh >iacdhj &?0.0/’

6+/ 6+/

B*.- <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd Wc‘^ HfV_eV e‘ <Zecfd .06+- .06+-

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd &0’7 KJ*.01 e‘ K‘+ ‘W ;fcSR_\ ;]gU+

./0+2 ./0+2 0.4+2 6)5.4+-

Page 45: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R^‘_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’/

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

<ReVX‘cj 2 &LcR_dZe Kjd +KeReV ‘W @‘‘U JVaRZc’

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]lKRWVej R_U KVTfcZej ac‘[VTedl2-#

03+3 03+3

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]lNVYZT]V ^RZ_eV_R_TVl2-#

.1+2 .1+2

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]lORjdZUV djdeV^dl2-# .4+4 .4+4

OZ]dYZcV ;fd G_]j DR_V /5+5 /5+5 64+3 6)6.1+2

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde @cRUV KVa HY BBl/2# ‘W EVRdfcV J

42+- 42+-

:cc‘j‘ NVcUfX‘ Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.-+/ .-+/

B*2 F‘ceY LcfT\ R_U AGN DR_Vd( .-.+. .-.+.

B*2 K‘feY&/’7 :]‘_UcR GgVcTc‘ddZ_X 4/+0 4/+0

NR]]Vj NZVh B_eVcTYR_XV .04+3 .04+3

B*3-2 <‘ccZU‘c !A‘e Ka‘e! B_eTYX @ReVhRj <ZeZVd(l2-#

24+2 24+2

DRd NZcXV_Vd,ER]ZSf Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.1+2 .1+2

K‘feY ;Rj JR^a R_U B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

13+5 13+5 2.1+6 .-)1/6+1

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

>RdedZUV DZXYe JRZ] :TTVdd /3+- /3+-

>ia‘dZeZ‘_ DJL HYRdV BB .)/12+- .)/12+-

>ia‘dZeZ‘_ DJL HYRdV BB ;Z\VhRj .-+- .-+-

@‘]U DZ_V ?‘‘eYZ]] >ieV_dZ‘_ 5.-+2 5.-+2

EVec‘]Z_\ TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed( 2/+5 2/+5

LcR_dZe T‘_eZ_XV_Tj,cRZ] jU,TRcd &@‘]U DZ_V ?eY] EL: 42#’

.32+- .32+-

<cV_dYRh,D:P LcR_dZe <‘ccZU‘c .)065+6 .)065+6 0)4-5+/ .1).04+3

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde @cRUV KVa HY BBl/2# ‘W EVRdfcV J

42+- 42+-

:cc‘j‘ NVcUfX‘ Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.-+/ .-+/

;FK? @cRUV KVaRcReZ‘_d Z_ @ReVhRj <ZeZVd( /1+- /1+-

<?H7 F‘XR]Vd Ke &D: KfSUZg’ @cRUV KVa &?..26’

//+5 //+5

Page 46: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TLYW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’0

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

<?H7 K‘feY OZ]^Z_Xe‘_ @cRUV KVaRcReZ‘_ &?..66’

.6+0 .6+0

<?H7 NZTe‘cj ;] OZUV_) L‘aR_XR <j*=V K‘e‘ &?..1.’

2+6 2+6

<?H7 ORdYZ_Xe‘_ ;]+ OZUV_Z_X) JVT‘_de &?..-4’

.0+0 .0+0

<?H7 OZ]^Z_Xe‘_ :gV B_ecTYX E‘UZWZT Re B*1-2 &?..-0’

6+2 6+2

<Zej ‘W D:lEVec‘ JRaZU KeReZ‘_d 1/+- 1/+-

B*.- <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd Wc‘^ <Zecfd e‘ KJ*24 .34+2 .34+2

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&1’7 ;fcSR_\ ;]gU cVT‘_decfTeZ‘_

5-+0 5-+0

DRd NZcXV_Vd,ER]ZSf Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.1+2 .1+2

K‘feY ;Rj JR^a R_U B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

13+5 13+5

KJ*.05 OZUV_Z_Xl.52eY e‘ Cf_TeZ‘_ .5 0-+- 0-+- 23.+- .1)365+4

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej’

EL: ;fd :TbfZdZeZ‘_( &_‘_*?:H’ /-# /--+- /--+-

EL: ;fd ?RTZ]Zej ERZ_eV_R_TV &_‘_*?:H’ /-#

0-+- 0-+- /0-+- .1)6/5+4

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

:]R^VUR <‘ccZU‘c >Rde @cRUV KVa HY BBl/2# ‘W EVRdfcV J

42+- 42+-

:cc‘j‘ NVcUfX‘ Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.-+/ .-+/

<?H7 =V K‘e‘ OZUV_7 JVRXR_ ?hj*=Vg‘_dYZcV &?0.4.’

4+2 4+2

<?H7 ?ZcVde‘_V ;‘f]VgRcU <RaRTZej B^ac‘gV &?0./1’

6+1 6+1

<?H7 B*..-,KJ*14,@ZSd‘_,F; B*..- :TTVdd &?./-5’

4+1 4+1

<?H7 F‘ceY ERZ_ Ke @cRUV KVaRcReZ‘_ &?0.15’

..+. ..+.

<?H7 JR^‘_R <‘ccZU‘c LcR_dZe <V_eVc :TTVdd &?0./2’

4+4 4+4

<?H7 JR_TY‘ NZdeR @cRUV KVa*KZVccR Ahj,JJ &?..-1’

//+6 //+6

<?H7 KR_ ?Vc_R_U‘ JU+ ;Z\V HReY HY+ BBB:,BBB; &?.2/1’’

5+1 5+1

Page 47: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R^‘_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’1

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

<?H7 KR_ ?Vc_R_U‘ JU+ ;Z\V HReY HY+ BBB; <‘_dec &?02.2’

5+3 5+3

<?H7 KJ*24,KJ*3- <‘_W]fV_TV7 O; K]Za G_*cR^a &?0.04’

5+5 5+5

<?H7 LYV G]U J‘RU) ERXZT Ee_ Hhj*Lfc_SVccj D_ ?0.03’

.2+- .2+-

<?H7 LYZcU Ke $ DR NVc_V :g HRc\Z_X KecfTe &?.1.1’

4+. 4+.

<?H7 NZR HcZ_TVdd 9 >ie*@‘]UV_ NR]*JRZ_S‘h @] &?..35’

..+3 ..+3

?fefcV <R]] W‘c Hc‘[VTed( /2-+- /2-+-

B*2 F‘ceY <Rca‘‘] DR_Vd&2’7 ;fV_R NZdeR Ke e‘ >^aZcV :g

/15+5 /15+5

B*2 K‘feY&1’7 KY‘V^R\Vc) J‘dVTcR_d) ;]‘‘^WZV]U ;cZUXVd

.14+- .14+-

DRd NZcXV_Vd,ER]ZSf Ahj GaVcReZ‘_R] B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

.1+2 .1+2

K‘feY ;Rj JR^a R_U B_eVcTYR_XV B^ac‘gV^V_ed(l/2#

13+5 13+5

KJ*.05 OZUV_Z_X*KVX . $ 0 &:g L*3-eY >+8 L*5*44eY Ke >+’

1-+- 1-+- 624+4 .2)553+1

<ReVX‘cj 2 &LcR_dZe KjdeV^ KeReV ‘W @‘‘U JVaRZc’

EL: ;fd :TbfZdZeZ‘_( &_‘_*?:H’ 14# 2--+- 2--+-

EL: ;fd ?RTZ]Zej ERZ_eV_R_TV &_‘_*?:H’ 14#

5-+- 5-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]l?RTZ]ZeZVd ^RZ_eV_R_TVl2-#

2-+- 2-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]l^ZdT ac‘[VTedl2-# 5-+- 5-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]l^ZdT JVU) ;]fV) @cVV_ Z^ac‘g+l2-#

1-+- 1-+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]lKRWVej R_U KVTfcZej ac‘[VTedl2-#

02+- 02+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]lNVYZT]V ^RZ_eV_R_TVl2-#

.2+- .2+-

EL: JRZ] <RaZeR]lORjdZUV djdeV^dl2-# /-+- /-+-

KR_ ?Vc_R_U‘ NR]]Vj >Rde F‘ceY*K‘feY JRaZUhRjd

./0+/ ./0+/ 610+/ .3)5/6+3

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

B*2 K‘feY&2’7 KR_ :_e‘_Z‘) B^aVcZR] Ahj) R_U Gcc R_U =Rj

.3-+0 .3-+0

B*2 K‘feY&3’7 ?]‘cV_TV :gV_fV B_eVcTYR_XV .20+0 .20+0

Page 48: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TLYW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R‘^_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’2

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

B*3-2 <‘ccZU‘c !A‘e Ka‘e! B_eTYX @ReVhRj <ZeZVd(l2-#

24+2 24+2

KJ*.05 OZUV_Z_Xl.-3eY Ke >+ e‘ ./3eY Ke >+8 44eY e‘ 56eY

32+- 32+-

KJ*.05 OZUV_Z_X*+-4 ^Z h ‘W L*5*44eY >8 56eY >+*63eY >+

32+- 32+- 2-.+. .4)00-+4

<ReVX‘cj 2 &LcR_dZe KjdeV^ KeReV ‘W @‘‘U JVaRZc’

EVec‘]Z_\ cV_‘gReZ‘_ R_U cVYRSZ]ZeReZ‘_( 3/+3 3/+3

EL: JRZ] Kjd B^ac‘gV^V_ed*JVU DZ_V gV_eZ]ReZ‘_ F+ A]]jhU

.3-+- .3-+-

EL: JRZ] Kjd B^ac‘gV*JVU DZ_V ecRZ_ T‘_ec‘]*/+2 ^Z_ YUhjd

3-+- 3-+-

EL: JRZ] Kjd B^ac‘g*JVU DZ_V F‘ceY A‘]]jh‘‘U eVc^Z_R]

61+/ 61+/

EL: JRZ] Kjd B^ac‘g*JVU DZ_V ecRTeZ‘_ ahc*dfaa‘ce YUhjd

61+/ 61+/

EL: JRZ] Kjd B^ac‘g*JVU DZ_V M_Z‘_ KeR faXcRUV =Zg /-

..0+3 ..0+3

LcR_dZe T‘_eZ_XV_Tj,cRZ] jU,TRcd &_‘_*@D ?eY] EL: 42#’

3-+- 3-+- 311+3 .4)642+0

<ReVX‘cj 2 &E‘SZ]Zej R_U >T‘_‘^ZT ;V_VWZe’

<?H7 @ReVhRj <ZeZVd LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘cc) HY N &?.0./’

5+. 5+.

<?H7 @ReVhRj <ZeZVd LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘ccZU‘cd) NB &00-6’

.0+1 .0+1

<?H7 F‘ceY <‘f_ej LcRWWZT ?‘cf^ BLK >iaR_dZ‘_ &?.0--’

6+- 6+-

<?H7 KR_ @RScZV] NR]]Vj LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘ccZU‘cd &?00-5’

.6+6 .6+6

<?H7 KR_ @RScZV] NR]]Vj LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘ccZU‘cd &?.0/.’

.-+2 .-+2

<?H7 K‘feY ;Rj LcRWWZT KZX_R] <‘ccZU‘cd Hc‘[VTe &?00.-’

.-+1 .-+1

?fefcV <R]] W‘c Hc‘[VTed( /32+- /32+-

B*1-2,:cS‘c NZeRV B_eVcTYR_XV d‘feY YR]W 30+1 30+1 066+4 .5)042+-

<ReVX‘cj 2

;fd =ZgZdZ‘_ .0 42+0 42+0

EVec‘]Z_\ TRaZeR] ac‘[VTed( 04+3 04+3 ../+6

L‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 2 .0).31+6 .0).31+6 .5)154+6

Page 49: Cost and Financial Analysis - Metrolibraryarchives.metro.net/DPGTL/eirs/Westside... · Final Cost and Financial Analysis 2.0ŠCost Estimate Methodology WESTSIDE SUBWAY EXTENSION August

:TYLW 7Z^_ LYO :TYLYNTLW 5YLWd^T^

5[[PYOTc 5

I 9 E F E = 8 9 E G 6 I 5 K 9 J F 9 A E = B A 5‘R^‘_ ,-& ,*+* CLRP 5’3

C]ZUPN_

C]P’7ZY^_] 7Z^_

$=YNW‘OP^ DBI%

7ZY^_] 7Z^_ $=YNW‘OP^

HPSTNWP^ # 86%

FZ_LW @F5)E_L_P) :PO :‘YO^ E‘M_Z_LW

7‘X‘WL_TaP FZ_LW

<ReVX‘cj 3 &_‘e R T‘^a]VeV ]Zde R_U hZ]] cVbfZcV WfceYVc R_R]jdZd e‘ T‘^a]VeV’

@‘]U DZ_V >RdedZUV DJL >ieV_dZ‘_ HYRdV BB V_gZc‘_^V_eR]

./+3 l ./+3

AVRgj JRZ] NVYZT]Vd l 40+. 40+.

D:P ;fd =ZgZdZ‘_ l .2+- .2+-

EL: JRZ] cVYRS R_U cVa]RTV^V_e l .)14.+5 .)14.+5

H]R__Z_X W‘c LcR_dZe Hc‘[VTed &dY‘ce*eVc^’ /2+- l /2+-

OZ]dYZcV ;‘f]VgRcU ;fd JRaZU LcR_dZehRj l ..2+0 ..2+0

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 3lLcR_dZe 04+3 .)342+/ .)4./+5

B*4.- K‘feY >Rc]j :TeZ‘_ Hc‘[VTed l 1-+- 1-+-

K‘f_UhR]]d &<‘f_ejhZUV Z_T] E‘_eVcVj HRc\,KJ*3-(’

l 63+- 63+-

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXV .- l /6+4 /6+4

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXV .. l 0.+5 0.+5

K‘f_UhR]]d HRT\RXVd ./) .0) $ .1 l /4+1 /4+1

K‘f_UhR]]d HYRdV B) HcZ‘cZej 0 l L;= L;=

KJ*4.- F‘ceY >ieV_dZ‘_ &ef__V]’( l 60+6 60+6

KfSe‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 3lAZXYhRj l 0.5+5 0.5+5

L‘eR] <ReVX‘cj 3 04+3 .)661+- /)-0.+3 /)-0.+3 /-)2.6+2

( <‘ded &Z_ ^Z]]Z‘_d) QG>’ K‘feY ;Rj EVec‘ @cVV_ DZ_V >ieV_dZ‘_) @cVV_ DZ_V >ieV_dZ‘_ e‘ D:P) R_U OVde KR_eR :_R ;cR_TY RcV _‘e dY‘h_ dZ_TV VZeYVc eYV ;‘RcU*Raac‘gVU defUZVd RcV ]Vdd eYR_ "4 ^Z]]Z‘_ ‘c eYV ;‘RcU YRd eR\V_ _‘ RTeZ‘_ ‘_ eYV ac‘[VTed+

OYZ]V eYV WZ_R_TZR] UReR Z_ eYZd U‘Tf^V_e Zd Z_eV_UVU e‘ TRaefcV ‘_]j eY‘dV ac‘[VTe T‘ded eYRe RcV ViaVTeVU SVehVV_ >Q /-.. R_U >Q /-.6) dfSdVbfV_e ac‘[VTe Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_ hV YRgV cVTVZgVU cVgVR]d eYRe eYV Z_W‘c^ReZ‘_ Z_ eYZd cVa‘ce ‘WeV_ Z_T]fUVd S‘eY >Q /-.- R_U acZ‘c Wf_UZ_X R_U,‘c Wf_UZ_X ViaVTeVU Z_ >Q /-/- R_U ]ReVc+ KZ_TV hV ViaVTe eYRe ac‘[VTe TRdY W]‘h _VVUd hZ]] ‘WeV_ TYR_XV Rd eYVj ac‘XcVdd eYc‘fXY eYVZc UVgV]‘a^V_e) hV RcV _‘e faUReZ_X VRTY ac‘[VTe Z_UZgZUfR]]j Re eYZd eZ^V+ OYV_ hV T‘^a]VeV R Wf]] R_R]jdZd ‘W R]] eYV ac‘[VTed) hV hZ]] cV]VRdV R cVgZdVU 9eeRTY^V_e : eYRe TRaefcVd R]] ‘W eYVdV _‘_*dfSdeR_eZgV ac‘[VTe TRdY W]‘h TYR_XVd+


Recommended