Date post: | 04-Jun-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | mohamed-abdrabo |
View: | 228 times |
Download: | 6 times |
of 74
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
1/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Contents
Introduction
Economic Yardsticks
Economic Analysis Process
Cash Flow Model
Examples Of Exploration /Production Programs
Risk And Uncertainty
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
2/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementIntroduction
The prime objective of petroleum producing operations is not
only to supply the modern world crude oil and natural gas,
but, to make a profit while doing so.
CO2Injection Started
Withoutinfills
With 10-Ac.Infills
With 20-Ac. Infills
40-Ac. SpacingWaterflood peak
20000
16000
12000
8000
4000
0
1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992
BPD
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
3/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
In an any economic evaluation, the key elements are:-
Income
Expenditures
Time
Cash flow (periodic recording of Income and Expenditures)
is the most important tool for:
Evaluating investments.
Choosing among alternatives.
Introduction (contd)
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
4/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
E & P INVESTMENT CYCLE
ANNU
ALINCOMEANDEXPEND
ITURES
CU
MULATIVENETCASHFLOW
YEARS
INVESTMENTS
ABANDONMENT
COST
EC.LIMIT
PV PROFIT
PV CUM. NET CASH FLOW
PROFIT
EXPENSES
CUM. NET CASH FLOW
REVENUE
NETINCOME
EXPLORATION PRODUCTION
+
-
0
+
-
0
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Introduction (contd)
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
5/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementIntroduction (contd)
The reason for doing economic evaluations is to make
investment decisions.
This process involves answering three critical questions:
What will it cost ?
What is it worth ?
Will it earn enough profit ?
The time value of money must be considered when
answering the last question.
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
6/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
All companies have established various economic measures
(YARDSTICKS) for determining the attractiveness of
investments.
No single Yardstick matches the gaols of every organization.
It will be necessary for each organization to select the one orcombination of yardsticks which match their goals.
Economic Yardsticks
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
7/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Payout
The shorter the payout the
more attractive the project.
The time required for the
cumulative cash flow to reachzero.
A common rule of thumb is 2-4Years.
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
PROFIT
PAYOUT
TIME - YEARS
CUM
MULATIVECASHFLO
W
Economic Yardsticks (contd)
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
8/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Yardsticks (contd)
Return on investment (ROI)
ROI is independent of time which limiting its usefulness as
a single criterion for investment decisions.
The higher the ROI the better.
ROI = Cumulative IncomeTotal Investment
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
9/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Cumulative Income - Total InvestmentPIR =Total Investment
PIR =ROI1.0
It is another form for expressing the same Yardstick.
Economic Yardsticks (contd)
Profit to investment Ratio (PIR)
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
10/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Yardsticks (contd)
Payout =2 Years Directlyfrom Graph
Investment $60.000
TotalProfit $ 180.000
payout
2 Years
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
200
150
100
50
0
- 50
TIME - YEARS
C
UMULATIVECASH($1,0
00)
ROI =$ 180,000
$ 60,000
ROI = 3.0
PIR =180,00060,000
60,000
PIR = 2.0
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
11/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
The present value of the
entire cash flow, discounted
at a specified discount rate.
i.e how much a certain
amount of future income is
worth today.
Economic Yardsticks (contd)
Present Worth Net Profit (PWNP)
50
100
150
200 Present Worth
Profile
PW10
PI
-50
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Present worthM$
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
12/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Yardsticks (contd)
YEARS
PRESENT WORTH COMPARISONS
Discount Rate
PresentVa
lue
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
1.00
5 %
10 %
15 %
20 %
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
13/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Yardsticks (contd)
PROFIT
PAYOUT
PV PAYOUT
PV PROFIT
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
TIME - YEARS
CU
MULATIVECASH
FLOW
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
14/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Discounted Cash Flow Return On Investment (DCFROI)
The max. discount rate that needs to be charged for the
investment capital to produce a break-even venture.
i.e PWNP =zero
Present Work Index (PWI)
The total discounted cash flow
The total discounted investment
The value of this parameter in the range of 0.5 to
0.75 considered favourable.
Economic Yardsticks (contd)
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
15/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Hurdle rate
The hurdlerate" discount factor, more properly referred
to as the "guideline discount (or interest) rate" is the
minimum acceptable rate of return on investments
The hurdle rate used is normally intended as the returnwhich the firm has been able to realize on its investments
of a similar nature in previous years.
The hurdle rate should recognize :
1.the acquisition cost of capital,2.suitable return on the investment involved
3.a compensation for Corporate risk, and
4.inflation.
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
16/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Yardsticks (contd)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
HURDLE RATE
15%10%
A
B
C
22% A B
C
INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN
27% 32%
DISCOUNT RATE - PERCENT
NETPRESENTV
ALUE
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
17/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Analysis Process
Set EconomicObjective
FormulateScenario
Collect Data
Make EconomicAnalysis
Make RiskAnalysis
Choose OptimumOperation
PAYOUTPWI
DCFROIPWNP
ProductionInvestmentsOperatingExpenses
Oil/Gas Price
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
18/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Today, economic analyses are being applied throughout the
reservoir-development processes.
Sensitivity to various parameters [e.g. Original oil in place
(OOIP), reserves and production rate forecasts, capital
investment, and operating expense]and other data affecting
these parameters on the project /reservoir performance can
be determined by performing economic analyses with variations
in those parameters, thereby covering a reasonable range of
uncertainty.
Economic Analysis
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
19/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Data
Data Source/Comment
Oil and gas production Reservoir and production engineers
Rates vs. time Unique to each project
Oil and gas prices Finance and economic professionals
Strategic planning interpretation
Capital investment (tangible, intangible) Facilities, operations and engineering
and operating costs professionals
Unique to each project
Royalty/production sharing Unique to each project
Discount and inflation rates Finance and economics professionals
Strategic planning interpretationState and local taxes (production, Accountants
severance, ad valorem, etc.)
Federal income taxes, depletion Accountants
and amortization schedules
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
20/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
West Texas
Intermediate (WTI) 40
North Sea Brent 38
Suez Blend 32
This is a widely used term to refer to an acceptable grade ofcrude oil and used as a standard in trading.
WTRGEconomics - 2006www.wtrg.com(479) 293- 4081
Jan 4, 2005 -Jan 24, 2006
Crude Oil Spot
North Sea Brent
$/Barrel
$ 70
$ 65
$ 60
$ 55
$ 50
$ 45
$ 40
$ 351/3/05
2/2/05
3/4/054/6/05
5/5/05
6/6/05
7/6/05
8/4/05
9/2/0510/4/05
11/3/0512/5/05
1/5/06
$ 66.15
Economic Data
Benchmark Crude
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
21/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
AVERAGE WORLD CRUDE OIL PRICES
1850 1870 1890 1910 1930 1950 1970 1990 2010
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
$/BARREL
NOMINAL OIL PRICE
REAL OIL PRICE 2002$
Economic Data
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
22/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementCash Flow Model
Cash flow for typical Exploration and Production venture can
be determined annually or for the life of a project by the
following model :-
Cash Flow=
Annual Revenue Annual Expenditure
Net Net Net
(NCF BT)
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
23/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementCash Flow Model (contd)
=Net
Annual Revenue
Gross Revenue Royalty
Where :-
Gross Revenue = Produce volume of HC x Price .
Royalty = Fraction x Cross Revenue .
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
24/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
=Net
Annual Expenditure
Capital Expenditure
Operating Expense
Where :-
+
Capital Expenditure:
Investment intended to acquire or Improve properties orassets that will generate revenue over a period of time .
Cash Flow Model (contd)
l i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
25/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
OperatingExpense
(cost of production)
Direct operating Expenses
Indirect Expenses (overhead)
Operating Taxses
Cash Flow Model (contd)
P l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
26/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Direct Operating Expense
Fixed Variable periodic
Fixed Cost are independent of the production rate
such as maintenance, engineering staff, power cost.
Variable Cost are dependant on production levelsuch as chemical treating, some power, some labor.
Periodic do not occure constantly, pump changes,
hot oiling, dewaxing, stimulation.
Cash Flow Model (contd)
P t l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
27/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Indirect Expense (overhead)
All costs which may be incurred at a distant location for a
number of different operations are considered indirect
operation cost or overhaed
These include a prorated portion of supervisory and
administrative expense covering the individual property
The specific method of allocating these expenses is
arbitrary
Cash Flow Model (contd)
P t l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
28/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Office expenses, including rent and utilities
Lease supervision wages, benefits
Engineering salaries, benefits
Clerical, accounting wages, benefits
Toolroom, warehouse, shop wages, benefits
Motor pool expense, not recovered as direct charge,
Management salaries, benefitsServices
Employee relations
Public Affairs
Insurance
Elements
Cash Flow Model (contd)
Indirect Expense (overhead)
P t l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
29/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Overhead can be estimated as a fraction of capital
expenditures plus a fraction of direct operating costs.
A recent study determined that the appropriate fractions
would be 9% of capital and 11 % of DOC.
Cash Flow Model (contd)
INDIRECT OPERATING COST (OVERHEAD) FORECAST
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
30/74
P t l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
31/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Operating Taxes
Wellhead Severance valorm
Cash Flow Model (contd)
P t l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
32/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Cash flow Diagrams
Cash flow Diagram is simply a graphical sketch
representing the timing and direction of montary
transfers
Time$
CASH OUT
$CASH IN
Cash Flow Model (contd)
P t l E i d
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
33/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementCash Flow Model (contd)
Time$
CASH OUT
$CASH IN
Cash flow Diagrams
Petrole m Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
34/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementCash Flow Model (contd)
200
150
100
50
0
-50
CumulativeM$
Cumulative
Cash Flow
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
40
20
0
-20
-40
-50
30
10
-10
-30
-60
15
5
10
0
40
20
30
0
10
Revenue andExpenditure
Rate
M$/Yr.
Revenue
Operating Costs
Investment
RateMB/Yr.
OilB/D
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
35/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Major Assumptions
1.Price Forecast
2.Production Forecast3.Royalties
4.Operating Costs and Future Capital Required
5.Taxes
6.Reserves
The above order is general.
Dec
reasingord
ers
o
fimportance
Cash Flow Model (contd)
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
36/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Spreadsheet Format #2Forecast of Natural Gas Production, By-Products and Net Revenue (Before income Taxes).
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15)
Gross
pipeline Gross Gross Gross Total Net
Gas Gas Gas Liquids Liquids Liquids Gross Operating Expense Cash cum.
Year Investment Sales Price Revenue Prod. Price Revenue Revenue Royalty Wells Plant Compr. Flow NCF
($) (MMCF) ($/MCF) ($) (bbl) ($/bbl) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
Column
(5) = (3)* (4)
(8) = (6)*(7)
(9) = (5)+ (8)
(10) = (9)*(Royalty Fraction)
(14) = (9)-(10)-(11)-(12)-(13)-(2)
Petroleum industry cash flow spreadsheets
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
37/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementPetroleum industry cash flow spreadsheets
Spreadsheet Format #1Forecast of Oil Production and Net Revenue (Before income Taxes).
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11)
Total Total
Annual Annual WI WI Share WI Share WI Share WI Share
WI Share Gross Oil Gross Share WI Net Operating Net cum. Net
Year Investment prod. Price Revenue Revenue Royalty Revenue Expenses Cash Flow Cash Flow
($) (bbls) ($/bbl) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
Column:
(2) = (Total investment)* W.I.(5) = (3)* (4)(6) = (5)*WI.(7) = (6)* (Royalty Fraction)(8) = (6) - (7)(9) = (Total Op. Exp.)* W.I.
(10) = (8) - (9)-(2)
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
38/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Procedure for economic calculation before income
tax (BIT) using spreadsheets is outlined below:
1. Calculate annual revenues using oil and gas sales from
productions and unit sales prices.
2. Calculate year-by-year total costs including capital,
drilling/ completion, operating, and production taxes.
3. Calculate annual undiscounted cash flow by subtracting
total costs from the total revenues.
4. Calculate annual discounted cash flowby multiplying the
undiscounted cash flow by the discount factor at a
specified discount rate.
Economic Analysis
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
39/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Analysis Example
(7)(6)(5)(4 )(3)(2)(I)
TotalRevenue
GasRevenue
Gas PriceGas Prod.RevenueOil PriceOil Prod
($MM)(3) + (6)
($MM)(4) x (5)
100($/MSCF)(MMSCF)
($MM)(2) x (1)
($/STB)(MSTB)Year
0.000.001.5000.0020.0001992
0.000.001.5000.0020.0001993
115.024.911.503276110.1120.005505.31994
21904817.901.5011934201.5820.0010079.11995
130.8019.811.5013208.4110.4820.005524.21996
50.758.771.505848.241.9820.002098.81997
24.864.451.502968.220.4120.00lO20.61998
26.733.051.502081.S23.6920.001184.41999
47.793.271.502178.944.2820.002211.32000
58.275.20l.508468.653.0620.002653.22001
46.677.14L504762.839.5320.001976.42002
24.495.051.503364.219.4420.009722003
15.713.331.50220.312.8820.00619.22004
6.781.631.501087.25.1520.00257.42005
766.5684.5256848.1682.0484101.9Total
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
40/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementEconomic Analysis Example
(20)(14)(13)(12)(11 )(10)(9)(8)
DiscountedCash Flow
DiscountedCash Flow
DiscountFactor
UndiscountedCash Flow
Total CostProd. TaxOperating
CostCapital
Cost
@64.23%,$MM
@12%,$MM
@12%($MM)
(7)-(11)($MM)
(8)+(9)+(10)($MM)($MM)($MM)Year
-4.460-5.4000.9449-5.7155.7150.0000.0005.7151992
-30.732-54.5690.8437-64.68064.6800.0000.00064.6801993
-12.812-33.3580.7533-44.284159.30411.5023.825143.9771994
32.233123.0600.6726182.97136.51221.94810.3594.2051995
11.51564.4620.6005107.34522.95213.0309.9220.0001996
2.33519.1690.536235.75114.9975.0759.9220.0001997
0.4955.9630.478712.45612.4082.4869.9220.0001998
0.3426.0440.427414.13912.5952.6739.9220.0001999
0.48412.5260.381632.82314.6714.7499.9220.0002000
0.38214.4880.340742.51815.7495.8279.9220.0002001
0.1759.7610.304232.08314.5894.6679.9220.0002002
0.0403.2910.271612.11612.3712.4499.9220.0002003
0.0091.0240.24254.22111.4931.5719.9220.0002004
-0.011-1.8610.2165-8.59515.3740.6788.3326.3642005
-0.004164.599353.149413.4176.656111.814224.941Total
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
41/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
$MM
Cost
Captital cost Operating Cost Prod. Tax Total Cost
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
42/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
MMSCFM
STB
Revenue
-2000
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
-2000
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
Oil Prod. Total Revenue Gas Prod.
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
43/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
$MM
Cash Flow
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
200
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Undiscounted Cash Flow Discounted Cash Flow
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
44/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
1-Payout Time= 3.43 years.2-Profit-to-Investment Ratio= 578.09/224.941 = 2.57
(PIR) is the total undiscounted cash flow withoutcapital investment divided by the total investment.
3-Present Worth Net Profit (PWNP)= $ 164.599 MM.
It is the present value of the entire cash flowdiscounted at a specified discount rate.
where:
$ 578.09 MM (353.149 + 224.941)is the total undiscountedcashflow without the total undiscounted investment of$ 224.941.
Economic Analysis Summary
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
45/74
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
46/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
EXAMPLEEVALUATION OF EXPLORATION PROGRAMS
An exploration venture has been proceeding for five years at anannual cash outlay of $10 million per year. A commercialdiscovery has been achieved at the beginning of year 6.
DETERMINE:
Whether the following development of the field would be aprofitable undertaking.
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
47/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
SOLUTION :
The summation of the net cash flows from the true beginningthrough abandonment in year 20 is +$92 million. From
discovery forward it is +$142 million.
To answer the basic question as to whether the development
would be economic, the past would be ignored as "sunk costs,"
and year 6 would be treated as though it were year 1. The $50million of sunk costs would not enter into the decision.
It is well to keep in mind, however, that the venture appears
better than it actually is in its entirety.
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
EXAMPLEEVALUATION OF EXPLORATION PROGRAMS
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
48/74
Petroleum Economic andManagementExamples Of Exploration / Production Programs
SOLUTION :
2019181716151413121110987654321
VentureYear
todayTrue beginning abandonment
past future
NCF, $M -10-10-10-10-10-10 -5 +5+10+20+35+25+20+15+8 +6 +5 +4 +3 +1
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
49/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
ADJUSTMENT OF NET CASH FLOW FOR TIME ZERO RESET ($ millions)PV
NCFAdj.NCF
Adj.PastNCF
Effective10%
Factor*
AnnualNCF
VentureYear
NCF
Year
-15.361.536 FV(5)-101
-13.961.396 FV(4)-102
= -64.03-12.691.269 FV(3)-103
-11.541.154FV(2)-104
-10.491.049 FV(1)-105
-64.03-64.03Time Zero
-9.53-100.953 FV(1)-1061
-4.33-50.867 FV(2)-572
+3.94+50.788 FV(3)+583
+7.16+100.716 FV(4)+1094
+13.03+200.651 FV(5)+20105
+20.72+350.592 FV(6)+35116
+13.46+250.538 FV(7)+25127
+9.79+200.489 FV(8)+20138
+6.67+150.445 FV(9)+15149
+3.24+80.404 FV(10)+81510
+2.21+60.368 FV(11)+61611
+1.67+50.334 FV(12)+51712
+1.21+40.304 FV(13)+41813
+0.83+30.276 FV(14)+31914
+0.25+10.251 FV(15)+12015
92
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
NPV10(FULL Life)+$6.27
NPV10(Forwardfrom time zero)
$70.30
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
50/74
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
51/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
ACCELERATION PROJECT
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
250
200
150
100
50
0
-50
-100
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Base Case
ACCELRATION CASE
DIFFERENTIAL (ACC.-BASE)
DISCOUNT RATE - PERCENT
NETPRESENTVALU
E
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
52/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Since additional money is spent for acceleration than would be
required to recover the same volume of hydrocarbons, there is
no undiscounted payout for the additional expenditure.
However, because the additional expenditure accelerates future
income, the venture should exhibit a greater net present value.
This is the justification for making the added expenditure.
CONCLUSION :
Acceleration Investments
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
53/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Waterflood planning in an economic perspective
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
NPV (t) = N
t=1 (1+r)t
PRICE (t) x Rate (t) CAPEX (t) OPEX (t) TAX (t)oil oil
A
B
C
WFPRIMRY
TIME
WATERINJ
ECTIONRATE
A
B
C
WFPRIMRY
TIME
WATERINJ
ECTIONRATE
A
B
C
WFPRIMRY
TIME
OIL
RATE
TIMING ?
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
54/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Economic yardsticks and present value are used for economic
optimization through the following :-
Reduce capital expenditures
Reduce operating costs
Reduce indirect costs (overhead)
Delay expenditures
Increase income (production rate)
Improve value of product
Accelerate income
Examples Of Exploration / Production Programs
CONCLUSION :
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
55/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
The nature of economic evaluation entails risk taking
and uncertainties involving technical, economic, and
political conditions.
The results of the analysis are subjected to many
restrictive assumptions in forecasting recoveries, oiland gas prices,
investment, operating costs, and inflation rate.
Risk And Uncertainties
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
56/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
Types of risk
Dry holes Inflation Governmental policy
Geological Oil and gas prices Government regulationsEngineering Gambler's ruin Laws
Storm damage Interest rates Nationalization
Earthquake Environmental Environmental
Timing Timing Timing
Exchange rate Exchange rate
Financing / capital Financing / capitalSupply / demand Taxation
Operating costs Export / import
Personnel
TECHNICAL ECONOMIC POLITICAL
Risk And Uncertainties (contd)
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
57/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
When evaluating exploration and production venturesthere are three types of uncertainty which aremost significant. These are;
uncertainty of occurrence,
uncertainty of magnitude and
uncertainty of rate of production.
Risk And Uncertainties (contd)
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
58/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
HOW TO DEAL WITH ?
There are four fundamental approaches to coping with riskand uncertainty:-
Diversification,
Reduction of exposure,
Avoidance, and Insurance.
Risk And Uncertainties (contd)
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
59/74
Petroleum Economic andManagement
EFFECTS OF TIMING RISK
REFERENCE: WILSON & PEARSON, JPT YEARS
O
ILPRODUCT
ION-
BARRELS/D
AY
Risk And Uncertainties (contd)
3.500
3.000
2.500
1.500
1.000
500
0
2.000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 100
PREDICTEDDATE FIRSTINJECTION ACTUAL DATE
FRIET INJECTION
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
60/74
et o eu co o c a dManagement
The analysis shows that DCFROI and PWNP are affected more drasticallyby both oil price and oil production than the operating costs.
DCFROI Sensitivity Analysis NPV Sensitivity Analysis
Risk And Uncertainties (contd)
100
80
60
40
20
000
DCFROL,%
-20-30 -10 +10 +20 +30
Percent of Base Projection
-- Oil Production-- Operating Costs-- oil Price
300
250
200
150
100
50
0-30 -20 -10 00 +10 +20 +30
Net present Value. MM$
Percent of Base Projection-- Oil Production-- Operating Costs-- oil Price
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
61/74
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
62/74
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
63/74
Management
Sensitivity Analysis (Conti)
TORNADO DIAGRAM
NET PRESENT VALUE -$MM
PARAMETER (EV)
NOC SHARE (80%)HURDLE RATE (15%)
EXP.ULT.REC. (58.2 MMB)
OIL PRICE ($24/Bbl)
TAXES (0%)
FROB. SUCCESS (50%)
DEVELOPMENT COSTS
EXPLORATION COSTS
VARIABLE OP. COSTS
EXPLORATION PERIOD
FIXED OP. COSTS
DOUBLE TRIANGULAR DISTRIBUTION
Apply Risk Evaluation Methods
-50 0 50 100 150
EXPECTED VALUE -$19.9MM
10%25%
50%90%
0%50%
70%30%
+25%+25%
-50%+50%
-40%+40%
-40%+40%
2 yrs.3 yrs.
87.8 MMB29.3 MMB
$ 30/Bbl$ 20/Bbl
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
64/74
Management
Sensitivity Analysis
Select one risk element and measure the range of equally
likely values.
Apply the range of values, with appropriately selected
intervals, to the part of the evaluation which is sensitive to that
element; i.e., how is OOIP affected by changing from 18% to
30% at 1% intervals.
Combine compatible risk elements to determine if the
elements offset or enhance each other.
Determine a range of outcomes and analyze statistically to
determine the most likely outcome and range of probabilities.
Apply Risk Evaluation Methods
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
65/74
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
66/74
Management
10% Interest Rate
PresentWorth
20% Interest Rate
PresentWorth
30% Interest Rate
PresentWorthCash Flow
Year Factor($) ($) Factor ($) Factor ($)
0 [100,000] 1.000 [100,000] 1.000 [100,000] 1.000 [100,000]
1 81,934 0.909 74,478 0.833 68,251 0.769 63,007
2 32,106 0.826 76,250 0.694 22,282 0.592 19,007
3 14,848 0.751 11,151 0.569 8,597 0.455 6,756
4 7,452 0.683 5,090 0.482 3,592 0.350 2,608
Following is a tabulation of interest rate versus total present worthcalculated from Example 7 and in the above table.
Total 36,340 17,239 2,722 [8,622 ]
Interest Rate - % Present Worth - $0 36,3406 24,212
10 17,23920 2,72230 [8,622]
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
67/74
Management
Year
Cash Flow$
Factor Factor
10% Interest RatePresent Worth
$
20% Interest RatePresent Worth
$
0 [175,000] 1.000 [175,000] 1.000 [175,000]
1 140,520 0.909 127,487 0.833 116,828
2 59,470 0.826 49,122 0.694 41,272
3 20,010 0.751 15,028 11,586
Total 45,000 16,639 [5,314]
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
68/74
Management
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Drill Two Wells
Drill One Well
Interest Rate Per Cent
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
PresentWorthM$
Comparative Present Value Profiles
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
69/74
Management
Function is to determine how to produce most oil and/or gas reserves in the
most efficient manner and at least cost to optimize the economic return.
Optimize bothProduction Rate
Ultimate Recovery
Since there is little or no control over oil price, minimize production cost
and investment is needed.
The decision should consider :-
- The economic costs ( new capital investment ),
- And benefits ( increase in oil rate or reserves ).
The relation between benefits and cost can be measured in various
ways (Undiscounted net profit, net present value, rate of return, , etc)
In brief
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
70/74
Management
DIVERSIFICATION :
Participating in the drilling of ten wells instead of putting allof one's resources in a single prospect
REDUCTION OF EXPOSURE,
Taking a lesser interest in a greater number of venture.
AVOIDANCE
If the risk is so great , it may be better to avoid theundertaking completely.
INSURANCE.
It does not reduce risk, but distributes it over time and sharesit with others in the same insurance pool.
Risk And Uncertainties (contd)
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
71/74
Management
This method essentially combines the sensitivity analysis
approach with a system of randomly selecting the values tobe used. The method is most effective in analyzing the
interrelation of a large number of variable factors. The
outcomes can be statistically analyzed for assignment of
probabilities.
MONTE CARLO ANALYSIS
Apply Risk Evaluation Methods
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
72/74
Management
Price projection depends on gravity of oil and composition
Operating costs projection depends on gravity and
composition, depth, number of wells, etc.)
Royalty and production taxes.
Required investment.
Cost of capitalIncome tax treatment.
ECONOMIC RISKS:
Define the Risk
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
73/74
Management
GEOLOGIC RISKS :
Does the zone exist?
Field size?
Sufficient recoverable hydrocarbons?
Define the Risk
Petroleum Economic and
8/13/2019 Course Petroleum Economic and Management
74/74
Management
PERFORMANCE RISK :
Rservoir properties (Sw, , K, , etc.)
Zone thickness
Areal extent
Drive mechanism (effects on Rf ).
Decline rate
Depth
Production method needed
Well spacing required
Stimulation needed?
Define the Risk