Page 1
Court of Appeal File No. C65861 (M49615)
Superior Court File Nos: CV-18-00603797-0000
CV-18-00602494-0000
CV-18-00603633-0000
COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO
B E T W E E N :
CITY OF TORONTO
Applicant
(Respondent in appeal - Responding Party)
- and -
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
Respondent
(Appellant - Moving Party)
A N D B E T W E E N :
ROCCO ACHAMPONG
Applicant
(Respondent in appeal - Responding Party)
- and -
ONTARIO (HON. DOUG FORD, PREMIER OF ONTARIO), ONTARIO (ATTORNEY
GENERAL) and CITY OF TORONTO
Respondents
(Appellants - Moving Parties)
(Title of Proceedings Continued on p.2)
RECORD OF THE RESPONDING PARTIES, CHRIS MOISE et al.
(Motion for Stay Pending Appeal)
VOL 3 OF 3
Page 2
A N D B E T W E E N :
CHRIS MOISE, ISH ADERONMU and PRABHA KHOSLA on her own behalf
and on behalf of all members of WOMEN WIN TORONTO
Applicants
(Respondents in appeal - Responding Parties)
- and -
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO and THE CORPORATION OF
THE CITY OF TORONTO
Respondent
(Appellant - Moving Party)
- A N D -
JENNIFER HOLLETT, LILY CHENG, SUSAN DEXTER,
GEOFFREY KETTEL and DYANOOSH YOUSSEFI
Interveners
(Respondents in appeal - Responding Parties)
RECORD OF THE RESPONDING PARTIES, CHRIS MOISE et al.
(Motion for Stay Pending Appeal)
GOLDBLATT PARTNERS LLP
20 Dundas Street West, Suite 1039
Toronto, ON M5G 2C2
Tel: 416-977-6070
Fax: 416-591-7333
Howard Goldblatt LS# 15964M
[email protected]
Daniel Sheppard LS# 59074H
[email protected]
Louis Century LS# 66582C
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Responding Parties
Chris Moise et al.
Page 3
- 3 -
TO: MINISTRY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
Constitutional Law Branch
McMurtry-Scott Building
720 Bay Street
Toronto, ON M7A 2S9
Robin Basu (LSO# 32742K)
[email protected]
Yashoda Ranganathan (LSO# 57236E)
[email protected]
Audra Ranalli (LSO# 72362U)
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Moving Parties
AND TO: CITY OF TORONTO 26 Flr., Metro Hall, Stn. 1260
Legal Services
Toronto, ON M5V 3C6
Glenn Chu (LSO# 40392F)
Tel: 416-397-5407
Fax: 416-397-5624
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Responding Party, The City of Toronto
AND TO: ROCCO K. ACHAMPONG
Barrister & Solicitor
Dundas Street West, Suite 2500
Toronto, ON M5G 1Z3
Rocco Achampong (LSO# 57837J)
[email protected]
Gavin Magrath (LSO# 51553A)
[email protected]
Selwyn Pieters (LSO# 50303Q)
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Responding Party, Rocco K. Achampong
Page 4
- 4 -
AND TO: PALIARE ROLAND ROSENBERG ROTHSTEIN LLP
155 Wellington Street West
35th
Floor
Toronto, ON M5V 3H1
Donald K. Eady (LSO #30635P)
[email protected]
Caroline V. (Nini) Jones (LSO #43956J)
[email protected]
Jodi Martin (LSO# 54966V)
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Intervenors Below, Jennifer Hollett, Lily Cheng, Susan
Dexter, Geoff Kettel, and Dyanoosh Youssefi
AND TO: DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP
Suite 6000, 1 First Canadian Place
PO Box 367, 100 King St W
Toronto, ON M5X 1E2
Derek Bell (LSO # 43420J)
[email protected]
Ashley Boyes (LSO# 74477G)
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Intervener Below, The Canadian Taxpayers Federation
AND TO: TORONTO DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD
Legal Services
5050 Young Street, 5th
Floor
Toronto, ON M2N 5N8
Patrick Cotter (LSO# 40809E)
[email protected]
Lawyer for the Intervener Below, the Toronto District School Board
Page 5
INDEX
Tab Description Page No.
VOLUME I
1 Affidavit of Joshua Mandryk, sworn September 14, 2018 i.
2 Exhibit “A” – Email re: City of Toronto’s statement in response to J.
Belobaba’s decision, dated September 10, 2018
1
3 Exhibit “B” – News release from Premier’s Office dated September 10,
2018: ‘Doug Ford Announces Action to Uphold the Better Local
Government Act’
3
4 Exhibit “C’ – Op-Ed by Premier Ford, published by the Toronto Sun,
dated September 12, 2018, ‘FORD: Priority lies in ending Toronto’s
council gridlock’
5
5 Exhibit “D” – Excerpt from Hansard containing Gilles Bisson’s Notice
to the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly dated September 13, 2018
8
6 Exhibit “E” - Affidavit of Chris Moise sworn August 20, 2018
a. Toronto Ward Boundary Review Map Showing the 44-ward
Model
b. Toronto Ward Boundary Review Map Showing the 47-ward
Model
c. Printouts from campaign website
d. Map of the 25-ward Model imposed by Bill 5
16
30
32
34
42
7 Exhibit “F” - Affidavit of Prabha Khosla sworn August 18, 2018
a. Curriculum vitae
b. TWCA Report entitled ‘Women-friendly policies for Toronto’s
Official Plan’
c. Printouts from WWTO’s website
d. Article from the Toronto Star on WWTO
45
62
70
76
98
8 Exhibit “G” - Affidavit of Myer Siemiatycki sworn August 21, 2018
a. Curriculum vitae
b. Toronto Ward Boundary Review Final Report, May 2016
106
124
146
9 Exhibit “H” - Affidavit of Mariana Valverde sworn August 20, 2018
a. Curriculum vitae
214
10 Exhibit “I” - Affidavit of Moya Beall sworn August 21, 2018 231
11 Exhibit “J” - Affidavit of Megann Willson sworn August 21, 2018
a. City Council Decision MM44.128 dated July 23, 2018
b. City of Toronto’s ‘Use of City Resources during an Election
242
254
271
Page 6
- 2 -
Tab Description Page No.
Period Policy’
12 Exhibit “K” - Affidavit of Chiara Padovani sworn August 21, 2018
a. Curriculum vitae
b. Toronto Star article entitled ‘How a Broken Jury List Makes
Ontario Justice Whiter, Richer and Less Like Your
Community’
282
293
298
13 Exhibit “L” - Affidavit of Jamaal Myers sworn August 21, 2018
a. City of Toronto’s demographic report for Ward 45
b. City of Toronto’s demographic reports for Ward 47
c. Tweets made on Twitter under the hashtag
‘#ScarboroughMoves’
d. ‘Scarborough Moves’ Platform and Information About
Candidates
e. Promotional poster for Lewis-Thurab and Khoshdel’s joint
campaign
310
323
331
339
377
383
14 Exhibit “M” - Affidavit of Cheryl Lewis-Thurab sworn August 21,
2018
385
15 Exhibit “N” - Affidavit of Fiona Murray affirmed August 22, 2018
a. City Clerk’s declarations of results
b. City Clerk’s 2014 election report
c. Work Plan prepared by the City Clerk’s Office
d. Confluence calendar prepared by the City Clerk’s Office
e. The Ontario government’s news release of July 27, 2018
announcing its intention to align Toronto’s wards with the
federal and provincial electoral ridings for the 2018 elections
f. News releases an announcements from the 2018 election
g. Printouts of the Election Services website
h. Printout of the Election Services Twitter page
i. Presentation slides of an information session on becoming a
candidate in the 2018 municipal election held on April 7, 2018
j. Presentation slides of four candidate information sessions held
on June 19, June 28, July 12, and July 19, 2018
392
400
421
471
484
495
498
508
587
627
638
VOLUME II
16 Exhibit “O” - Affidavit of Giuliana Carbone sworn August 22, 2018
a. Information from the City’s public website about the City’s
local government and the Councillor’s role
b. List of some of the committees and boards of the City
c. Toronto-Ontario Cooperation and Consultation Agreement
662
681
311
Page 7
- 3 -
Tab Description Page No.
signed January 15, 2008
d. Toronto-Ontario Cooperation and Consultation Agreement
signed May 10, 2011
e. Toronto-Ontario Cooperation and Consultation Agreement
signed May 12, 2016
f. Printout of Election Services webpage posting financial limits
of candidates
g. List of candidates’ information as of August 10, 2018
h. Printouts of Councillor Candidate Websites as of August 10,
2018
i. Samples of Campaign Pamphlets
j. Council decision of June 11 to 13, 2013 to retain a third party
Consultant to conduct the Toronto Ward Boundary Review
(“TWBR”)
k. Council decision of June 13, 2013 to approve the TWBR work
plan, civic engagement and public consultation strategy,
associated staff reports, appendix and presentation
l. Round 2 Report on Civic Engagement and Public Consultation
m. Executive Committee decision requesting Additional
Information
n. Council decision approving 47-ward structure
o. By-law 267-2017
p. By-law 464-2017
q. Ontario Municipal Board Decision dated December 15, 2017
r. Decision of Divisional Court dated March 6, 2018
692
698
703
708
726
751
1087
1112
1127
1172
1233
1251
1347
1352
1392
VOLUME III
17 Exhibit “P” – Affidavit of Gary Davidson sworn August 27, 2018
a. Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Gary Davidson
b. Schedule of Public Hearings of the Ontario Federal Electoral
Boundaries Commission
c. 2016 Population for Federal Electoral Districts in Toronto
d. Average Ward Size for Ontario Municipalities
e. Article by André Côté entitled “The Maturing Metropolis:
Governance in Toronto a Decade on from Amalgamation” from
the Institute on Municipal Finance and Governance, University
of Toronto, March 2009
f. Excerpt from Meetings Statistics, 2009-2016, City Clerk’s
Office, City of Toronto
1396
1419
1428
1431
1433
1435
1467
Page 8
- 4 -
Tab Description Page No.
18 Exhibit “Q” - Affidavit of Lily Cheng, sworn August 21, 2018
1. Maps Showing Ward 47 Municipal Boundaries and Provincial
Boundaries
1494
1506
19 Exhibit “R” – Affidavit of Dyanoosh Youssefi, sworn August 22, 2018
1. Maps of Ward 14 and new Eglinton-Lawrence Ward
2. Press Release
1509
1522
1525
20 Exhibit “S” – Affidavit of Rocco Achampong, sworn August 22, 2018
a. Candidate List for 2018 Municipal Election
b. 2018 Candidate’s Guide for Ontario municipal council and
school board election
c. City of Toronto BY-LAW 598-2018 To confirm the
composition of council, Map of the City of Toronto’s 47
Electoral Wards
d. Media Report: The Globe and Mail “Doug Ford throws Ontario
elections into turmoil”
e. Ontario, News Release, Office of the Premier: The Better Local
Government Act, July 27, 2018 9:35 A.M.
f. Bill 5 An Act to amend the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the
Municipal Act, 2001 and the Municipal Elections Act, 1996
1528
1538
1540
1582
1585
1595
1600
Page 237
Court of Appeal File No. C65861 (M49615)
ROCCO ACHAMPONG
Applicant
(Respondent in appeal)
and ONTARIO
Respondent (Appellants) and
CITY OF TORONTO
Respondent
(Respondent in Appeal)
Superior Court File No.: CV-18-00602494-0000
THE CITY OF TORONTO
Applicant
(Respondent in appeal)
and ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO
Respondent (Appellant) Superior Court File No.: CV-18-00603797-0000
CHRIS MOISE et al.
Applicants
(Respondent in appeal)
and ATTORNEY GENERAL OF
ONTARIO
Respondent (Appellant) and
CITY OF TORONTO
Respondent
(Respondent in Appeal)
Superior Court File No.: CV-18-00603633-0000
COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO
Proceeding commenced at TORONTO
RECORD OF THE RESPONDING
PARTIES, CHRIS MOISE et al.
(Motion for Stay Pending Appeal)
GOLDBLATT PARTNERS LLP
20 Dundas Street West, Suite 1039
Toronto, ON M5G 2C2
Tel.: 416-977-6070
Fax: 416-591-7333
Howard Goldblatt LS# 15964M
[email protected]
Daniel Sheppard LS# 59074H
[email protected]
Louis Century LS# 66582C
[email protected]
Lawyers for the Responding Parties,
Chris Moise et al.
