Date post: | 16-Feb-2017 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | eugene-pottenger |
View: | 547 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Let’s talk about Culture(A workshop…)
2
►Awareness: Why is culture important in a business context? (where does it come from and how can it impact us?)
►Reflection & sharing: Our experience of cultural similarities / differences (focus today on PH – DK – AU)
High-Level Agenda
The more discussion & input ……the more likely interesting,
memorable & useful !
For a ‘Crash Dialog’ on working across cultures
3
Why is Eugene facilitating a workshop on cross-cultural dialog…?
►MSc in International Business & Culture (and another one in Strategic Mgmt & Finance…)
►Book editor: Cross-cultural business practices (Between Japan & Denmark)
►& my own experiences… (14 years abroad in a handful of countries)
But let’s get to know each other a little….
4
Introductions from a slightly different perspective
►The usual (name, department)
►Experience working with other cultures?
►Anything you’d like to share about your own culture…
5
A few important guidelines
►Mutual respect is absolutely critical (seek first to understand…)
►Beware stereotypes (they’re useful tools, but can also be a trap…)
►No answers, only good questions (and all questions are good ones…)
6
Why talk about Culture…?
7
“The single greatest cause of difficulties in global business transactions
is not a lack of technical expertise, hard work or good intentions –
it is a lack of ‘people skills’ for relating successfully across style differences
attributed to factors such as national culture, organizational culture,
job function, and personality.”
Ernest Gundling, author of Working GlobeSmart & founder of Aperion Global
8
Some say 90% of
culture is below
the surface…
9
In Aware-ness
Surface Culture
Shallow Culture
Deep Culture
Out of Aware-ness
Most easily seen
10
So where does culture come from…?
11
Ethnicity
Language
Class
Nation
12
Religion
Family
Politics
Geography
Region
History
Education
Profession
Gender
Movements 1
Generation
Sexuality
Movements 2
Company
13
What about Organizational Culture?
Source: Johnson, G. (1988)
14
Why talk about Culture…?
So, how do we TALK
about Culture?
15
One ‘answer’ is…
…very carefully!
Damn straight… especially when talking about people or culture…!culture…!
17
‘Best-practice’ on Stereotypes
►Consciously held. Must be aware that they describe a group norm rather than the characteristics of a specific individual.
►Descriptive rather than evaluative. Used to describe what people from this group might be like, and not to evaluate whether they are good or bad.
►Accruate. Should accurately describe the norm.
►First best guess. Information as a guide to what a person might be like before you have direct information.
► Modified. Continuously updated based on further observation and direct experience with actual people and situations.
Source: Adler, N. (2002)
18
Why talk about Culture…?
So, how does Culture impact and influence us?
19
Beliefs & Values
QuestionYou’re in a car with a close fiend and he hits a pedestrian. You know he was going at least 56kph in a 32kph zone. There are no witnesses and his lawyer says that if you testify under oath that he was only driving 32kph it may save him from serious consequences.
What right does has your friend to expect you to protect him?
Source: Trompenaars, F. & Hampden-Turner, C. (1997)
20
Beliefs & Values
QuestionA defect is discovered. It was caused by the negligence of one of the members of a team.
Is it the fault of the individual or should the responsibility be carried by the team?
Source: Trompenaars, F. & Hampden-Turner, C. (1997)
21
Organizational Behavior
QuestionIs it OK to display emotions openly at work?
Source: Trompenaars, F. & Hampden-Turner, C. (1997)
% who would NOT show emotion openly at work
22
Organizational Behavior
StatementThe most important thing in life (and work) is to think and act in the ways that best suit the way you really are, even if you do not get things done.
Source: Trompenaars, F. & Hampden-Turner, C. (1997)
% who disagree (i.e. more important to get things done)
23
Organizational Beliefs & Values
QuestionWhat makes a good manager? A kind of ‘father figure’ or someone who ‘delivers results’?
Source: Trompenaars, F. & Hampden-Turner, C. (1997)
% desiring to be left alone to ‘get the job done’
24
Casual Personal DistanceJapan 90 cm
North America 45 cm
Western Europe 35 – 40 cm
Middle East 20 – 30 cm
Learned BehaviorWhat’s up
with this…?
And we could talk about ‘touching ‘ more generally…
This learned ‘instinctual behavior’ also governs whether it’s OK to be late for a meeting, ask questions in a meeting, speak first when someone more senior is present,
bring up new issues when most things are decided beforehand, etc…
25
Visual inspiration
from Liu Young
26 Source: Young, Liu (unknown)
Handling of
Problems
27 Source: Young, Liu (unknown)
The Boss
28 Source: Young, Liu (unknown)
Expressing Opinions
29 Source: Young, Liu (unknown)
Emotions / ‘No’
30 Source: Young, Liu (unknown)
Punctuality
31 Source: Tang, Annie (Eurasia Resources), from other sources.
Some ‘gross’ generalizations
• A culture of nature• Systems trust• Deal-focused, goal-oriented• Honesty• Egalitarianism, equality• Direct communication (low context)• Informal• Individual / independence• Private life / leisure time • Authority: questioned / earned• Stable• Religious• Guilt
• A culture of people• Personal trust• Relationship focused• Face• Hierarchy, status• Indirect communication (high context)• Formal• Family / interdependence• Work / wealth ethics• Authority: accepted / given• Changing• Superstitious• Shame
32
Why talk about Culture…?
So, how do we WORK
with Culture?
33
One, and by no means the only
way(!), …
…is via ‘cultural dimensions’ that help is to cluster similarities and
differences.
35
Independent Interdependent
Egalitarianism Status
Risk Restraint
Direct Indirect
Task based Relationship based
Short Term Orientation Long Term Orientation
GlobeSmart dimensions
Situational videos (business setting) available on GlobeSmart website
38
High-Level Overview:
A stereotypical baseline for us to reflect on as we discuss how we see ourselves & our cultures…
Key Dimensions of Culture: Independent Interdependent
• Take individual initiative• Prefer quick decision-making• Openly express opinions /
disagreement• Speak openly about personal
achievements
• Group harmony & cooperation important• Prefer group decision-making process • Express disagreement or opinions
cautiously• Have an appreciation for protocol
Independent Interdependent
What is the role of the individual?
Are these traits / stereotypes we recognize?In ourselves, in others?
Independent (Me) or Interdependent (We)?
“The squeaky wheel gets the grease.”
“The nail that sticks up gets hammered down.”
Egalitarianism Status
Key Dimensions of Culture: Egalitarianism Status
• Comfortable challenging the views of superiors
• Equal to others in professional settings (treat everyone much the same)
• Relatively flexible regarding roles (rules / protocol less important)
• Prefer not to challenge those above them
• Have a formal interaction style with more junior staff (different rank)
• Adapt behavior depending on relative status
What is the relation toward hierarchy?
Are these traits / stereotypes we recognize?In ourselves, in others?
Restraint
Key Dimensions of Culture: Risk Restraint
• Prefer rapid decision-making & quick results
• Place great importance on flexibility & initiative
• Value speed over thoroughness
• Spend time on research before making change
• Establish proper processes and procedures before starting a project
• Value thoroughness over speed
Risk
What is the comfort level with risk taking?
Are these traits / stereotypes we recognize?In ourselves, in others?
Viewpoints: Looking Outward
Risk looking at Restraint:
Restraint looking at Risk:
• Not action-oriented, innovative or entrepreneurial
• Inability to make decisions / Waiting for direction
• Avoiding accountability• Not confident / Analysis
paralysis
• Cowboys / Arrogrant / Immature
• Irresponsible / Decisions without real responsibility
• Not considering all issues, people, relationships
• Dangerous
Direct Indirect
Key Dimensions of Culture: Direct Indirect
• Concise, concrete, to the point (quickly)
• Not afraid to “say it like it is”• Prefer to confront difficulties openly /
difficulties not personal• OK to give and receive “constructive”
feedback
• Spend time explaining context before coming to the point
• Preserve harmony in group• Attention to personal dignity /
Express disagreement in subtle ways• Avoid giving feedback publicly
How is information communicated?
Are these traits / stereotypes we recognize?In ourselves, in others?
Task Relationship• Move quickly to business topics in
meetings, etc. (task takes priority)• View reaching goals & objectives on
schedule as highest priority• Being efficient, managing time are
valuable traits
• Take time required to build trust (relationship takes priority)
• View building relationships as key to achieving results
• Trustworthiness, personal / professional network valuable traits
Priority at work?
Key Dimensions of Culture: Task Relationship
Are these traits / stereotypes we recognize?In ourselves, in others?
►Key features►Global business knowledge (~65 countries)
►50 topics available to research within business practices, culture, norms, language, etc.
►Skill building tool ►Case studies, assessment tests, ‘best-practice’ guidelines, etc.
►Personal cultural assessment profile►Self awareness, comparison to other countries / employees
About GlobeSmart
47
Backup slides
48
StereotypesWhat are they? What is our personal experience with them?
How can they be harmful?
How can they be helpful?
Why do we use them?
49
50
Culture……so with everything we’ve talked about
so fardo we dare to define it…?
Yes, but there is no general agreement on the ‘right’
definition.
51
Classical: “Culture ... is that complex whole which includes knowledge, belief, art, law, morals, custom, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of society.” (Edward Tylor, 1871)1952 Academic survey : 164 definitions cited ranging from ‘learned behavior’ to ‘ideas in the mind’, ‘a logical construct’, ‘a statistical fiction’, ‘a psychic defense mechanism’ … ‘an abstraction from behavior’. (Kroeber & Kluckhohn, 1952)Hofstede, G (1984): “Culture is the collective
programming of the mind which distinguishes the members of one category of people from another.” Schein, E (1992): “A pattern of shared basic assumptions that was learned by a group as it solved its problems of external adaptation and internal integration, that has worked well enough to be considered valid and, therefore, to be taught to new members as the correct way you perceive, think, and feel in relation to those problems.”
52
Hall, E (1959): “Culture is communication and communication is culture.”
Foucault, M (1971): “…un système d'exclusion (système historique, modifiable, institutionnellement contraignant.” […a system of exclusion (historical system, modifiable, institutionally binding)]
Geertz, C (1973): “…an historically transmitted pattern of meanings embodied in symbols, a system of inherited conceptions expressed in symbolic forms by means of which men communicate, perpetuate, and develop their knowledge about and their attitudes toward life.” Hall, E. (? paraphrase): “…culture is something obvious
– like breathing. An insider understands everything, but perceives nothing! A stranger perceives everything, but understands nothing!
53
Communication(in all it’s forms…)
Source: Laurent, A. (1981, as adapted by Adler, 2002)
My model here
54
Model here
55
Communication(in all it’s forms…)
High-Context Culture • Meaning often already
internalized• Less stated explicitly in
written or spoken messages• Understanding occurs based
on shared knowledge and assumptions
• Receiver may have to ‘piece together meaning’
Low-Context Culture • Meaning derived from content• Meaning and information
stated explicitly• Understanding occurs based
on information provided• Receiver can ‘decode’
message based on information received
56
Communication(High-context)
Mulan video here at 2m07s
57
Organizational Behavior
QuestionIs it important for a manager to have at hand precise answers to most questions subordinates may raise about their work?
Source: Laurent, A. (1981, as adapted by Adler, 2002)
58 Source: Young, Liu (unknown)
Contacts
Name of presentation59
Theory behind the GlobeSmart
Basis of GlobeSmartStudies carried out by several researchers
Hofstede’s Cultural
Dimensions
Schwartz Value
Orientation
Leung & Bond Social Axioms
Mc Crae’s 5 factor model
of Personality
Inglehart’s Cultural
Dimensions
Name of presentation60
Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions
• Power distance index (PDI)ᅳHigh PDI – Great power & wealth inequalities in the society. This is accepted by the less powerful members of the societyᅳLow PDI - Equal distribution of wealth, power and opportunities for all
• Individualism Versus CollectivismᅳIndividualism – Individual interests & rights are paramountᅳCollectivism – Interests of the community at large are paramount
• Masculinity Versus FeminityᅳMasculinity – Society values masculine traits like aggression & assertivenessᅳFeminity – Society values feminine traits like nurturing & caring
• Uncertainty avoidance index (UAI)ᅳHigh UAI – Low on risk taking behaviorᅳLow on UAI – High on risk taking behavior
• Long-term orientation Versus Short term OrientationᅳLong term orientation – value long term commitment, work hard today for better long term rewardsᅳShort term orientation – Value the present, expectations of short term rewards for their work
Name of presentation61
Schwartz Value Orientation
• EmbeddednessᅳDegree of emphasis on status quo, maintaining social order, respect for tradition, etc
• HierarchyᅳDegree of emphasis on hierarchical allocation of social power, authority, humility or wealth
• MasteryᅳDegree of emphasis on getting ahead through self assertion or by changing & mastering the natural & social
environment
• Intellectual AutonomyᅳDegree of emphasis on protecting independent ideas & individual rights to pursue his/her own intellectual direction –
fostering curiosity, creativity & broadmindedness
• Affective AutonomyᅳDegree of emphasis on promoting & protecting people’s independent pursuit of positive experience – fostering
pleasure & an exciting or varied way of life
• EgalitarianismᅳDegree of emphasis on transcending selfish interests in the favor of voluntary promotion of the welfare of others
• HarmonyᅳDegree of emphasis on fitting in with the environment
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
Name of presentation69
Style Switching tactic
Adapt your style in order to bridge cultural gaps
71
A good chunk of this course
online…
73
74
GlobeSmart Features
Invite colleagues or select countries to
compare.
Select a combination of profiles to view on the
chart. Each screen will display up to 10
profiles.
Read advice on how to bridge style gaps
between colleagues and/or cultures.
GAP
76
What – So What – Now What
What So What Now What
Cultural dimensions impacting issue
Potential issues that could arise
Strategies to minimize the gap
What are the key cultural differences that
may impact your interactions?
What is the potential impact of these
differences to you / your job?
What strategies could you apply to minimize the cultural gap and
achieve better results?
A tool to help you identify the underlying cultural issues, the impact and what to do next
General Advice for Working Globally
Develop a Range of Approaches
Identify ways to “style switch” or use a “Third
Culture” Way
Constantly Seek Advice and Enhance
KnowledgeTalk to a “cultural bridge”,
read, use GlobeSmart
Be Aware of Your Iceberg
Be aware that you may be making judgments that
work in your culture;Consider alternative
interpretations
79 Source: Grundling, E. (2005:30)
80 Source: Grundling, E. (2005:34)
81
Adapting your style to bridge cultural gaps
82
Creating more value out of cultural differences (and diversity in general…)
►Explore differences and disagreements►Acknowledge the other►Stay there…(in the encounter, the relationship, the openness…)► Encourage the other one to stay as well!