All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Fabrizio Fabrizi, ENEA
CSP development in Italy
Workshop
“Solar Energy (Concentrated Solar Power)” on the occasion of EASAC’s 10th anniversary.
Main Hall of the Academy of Athens
28, Panepistimiou Ave, Athens
14:00-17:20 on Friday, December 9, 2011
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
A new approach to concentrating
solar plant (CSP) by ENEA
� ENEA objective
� Economic element of solar plant
� ENEA technology innovations
� Emerging concepts for CSP
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
ENEA Roadmap: by labs to industrial demonstration (10 years)
5
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Molten salt as process fluid and thermal storage
Advantages:
� High working temperature (oil 380 °C - molten salt 550 °C)
� Atmospheric pressure in the thermal storage
� Lower volume and cost for thermal storage
Molten salt is fertilizer
(60% NaNO3 40% KNO3)
Molten salt at 450 °C
6
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Reflecting surface and tracking system
7
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Reflecting panel manufacturing
(Ronda factory)
8
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Receiver tube factory
(Archimede Solar Energy)
Angelantoni Group - Siemens
•Existing factory capacity 25.000 unit/y
•New factory redy at 2011 end
•Foreseen capacity 140.000 unit/y
9
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Demonstration facility
(ISCC Archimede plant by ENEL)
10
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Archimedeproject is the integration of
solar plant with gas combined plant5
11
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Thermal storage tanks and Steam Generator
(under constrution)
12
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Solar collectors of the Archimede plant
13
Solar fuels – Hydrogen production
• METISOL [ MIN. AMB. ]
COMETHY [ H2 JTD – FP7]
• TEPSI [ FISR ]
• HYCYCLES [ FP7]
• (HIMET) [ H2 JTD – FP7]
Ongoing RTD Projects
National and International
Components for CSP plants ( collectors, receiver tubes, HTFs, HSMs, et. )
• ELIOSLAB (Campania) [ FAR ]
• TUBOSOL [ INDUSTRIA 2015 ]
• ESFR (alt. coolant) [ FP7]
• EERA CSP [ FP7]
• SFERA [ FP7]
• RONDA HT Solar Collector
• D.D. Solar Collector
RTD contracts
• Industrial application of molten salts technologies [ ENI ]
• RTD on solar collector with gas as HTF [CRS4]
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Scheduled Italian Activities in EERA cooperation frame
(relations to F.P. VII (F.P. VIII))
EERA - CSP - TES (Thermal Energy Storage)(F.P. VII call on TES Thermal Energy Storage, 2nd stage OPTS)
(F.P. VII call on HTF Heat thermal fluids, 2nd stage MIMOSA)
EERA – CSP – Desalination
EERA – CSP – Thermo-chemistry and solar fuels
EERA – CSP – Aging
EERA
EUROPEAN ENERGY RESEARCH ALLIANCE
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Strategic vision for CSP exploitation in Italy
Medium/small size plants, up to 30÷50 MW, fed by solar and biomass,
multifunctional and suited to requirements and vocations of the territory:
• EE generation
• Tri-generation of electricity, heat and cool
• EE generation and desalination
• EE generation and H2 production (steam-CH4 reforming)
• EE generation and solar fuels production (gaseous and liquid)
• EE generation and residual biomass treatment for solar fuels production.
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Ongoing Demonstration Projects
(and foreseen activities to finance)
Archimede Chain for power large plants
• ARCHIMEDE 5 MWe demonstration project in operation (ENEL)
• ARCHETYPE550+ 25 MWe project (ongoing) (FP7 ENEL+ENEA+Others)
• (ARCHETYPE30+ 30 MWe project ) (NER300 ENEL+ENEA)
(TREBIOS Chain for cogenerative multipurpose plants by solar and biomass)
• Confindustria Lazio (20 MWe + 30 Gg Ethanol)
• Comune di Roma (1 MWe + 5 Gg Ethanol)
• CISA Appennino (1 MWe + District heating)
• Comune di Montale (1 MWe + cellulose production)
•MATS (ongoing) (1 MWe+m.p+desalination) (Egypt) [ FP7]
•OPTS (ongoing) (12 MWth TES_SG demonstration) (Spain) [ FP7]
EPC stakeholders : already operating: ENEL, TECNIMONT, TECHINT
int. agreements being defined: ACS-COBRA, ABENGOA, SIEMENS, CHYODA,
SKYFUEL
Components stakeholders: RONDA, ASE, others
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Direct Mollten Salts CSP system
(i.e. Archimede plant)
24
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Direct MS CSP system with stratifying TES
with integrated SG
25
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Test section for small scale simulation of
stratifying TES_SG concept
Schematic of a TES-SG model: the scaled down (300 kW)
SG is inserted in the storage tank of the PCS facility (it
shows also indications related to stratification phenomena )
Experimental data of a stratification test carried out in the tank
of the PCS facility
26
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
ROAD MAP TOWARDS HYDROGEN PRODUCTION
27
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Sulfur-Iodine thermochemical cycle
2H2O+SO2+xI2 →→→→ H2SO4+2HIx (20÷÷÷÷120°C)
H2SO4 →→→→ H2O + SO2 + ½O2 (800÷÷÷÷900°C)
2HI →→→→ H2 + I2 (300÷÷÷÷500°C)
BunsenBunsen
sectionsection
HH22SOSO44
concconc.&.& decdec..
sectionsection
HIHI
concconc.&.& decdec..
sectionsection
HH22OO
½ O½ O22
HH22
HH22SOSO44
(H(H22O)O)SOSO22
HH22OO
HI (IHI (I22))
(H(H22O)O)II22(H(H22O)O)
BunsenBunsen
sectionsection
BunsenBunsen
sectionsection
HH22SOSO44
concconc.&.& decdec..
sectionsection
HH22SOSO44
concconc.&.& decdec..
sectionsection
HIHI
concconc.&.& decdec..
sectionsection
HIHI
concconc.&.& decdec..
sectionsection
HH22OO
½ O½ O22
HH22
HH22SOSO44
(H(H22O)O)SOSO22
HH22OO
HI (IHI (I22))
(H(H22O)O)II22(H(H22O)O)
Activities on thermochemical cycles
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
HHTEPSI project
S-I cycle laboratory plant
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Solar plant
Molten salt
hot storageca. 550°C
Molten salt
cold
storage< 500°C
H.E.
reforming plantCH4
H20
H2
CO2
H2 production from solar steam-CH4 reforming
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
WHIICH KIND OF BIOMASS?
SHORT ROTATION FOESTRY OR ONLY SPECIALISED AGRO-ENERGETIC CULTIVATIONS?
Any kind of biomass, with ligno-cellulosic content is eligible: stocks from mais, fruments,
threes cuts and vegetable wastes from forestal activities, ecc.
31
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
STEAM EXPLOSION PROCESS AND FERMENTATION
32
CSP Applications & Potential
TR.E.BIO.S. project /1
• multifunctional Combined Heat and Power plants in modular small/medium size for distributed energy applications
in civil and industrial sectors, that
• significant innovations in the respect of Archimede project, including:
• a single thermal stratifying storage tank integrated with a "once-through" steam generator (expected more 50%
cost reduction),,
• a molten salts backup auxiliary heater, fed by biomass (or other renewable/fossil fuels), that allows operation all
over the year also in average sunny climates,
• optional special unit for:
• production of fresh water by a desalination unit for sea water,
• production of hydrogen (mixed in 5-10 % to methane) by a CH4-steam reforming unit at 550 °C.
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
MATS: Multipurpose Applications by Thermodynamic Solar
List of the Project Partners
1- Italian National Agency for New Technologies, Energy and the Sustainable Economic Development – ENEA (Italy)
2- TECNIMONT KT (Italy)
3- Academy of Scientific Research and Technology, ASRT (Egypt)
4- New & Renewable Energy Authority, NREA (Egypt)
5- Delft Environment (Egypt)
6- Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Förderung d. Angewandten Forschung e.V. (ISE) (Germany)
7- University of Cranfield (UK)
8- Orascom Construction Industries, OCI (Egypt)
9- RONDA Group (Italy)
10- French Atomic Energy Commission (Commissariat à l'énergie atomique, CEA) (France)
11- Archimede Solar Energy, ASE (Italy)
and CLP Project as external Sponsor
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi35
MATS Project
Proposed sites just investigated
1. Borg Al-Arab (N. Coast)
(City for Science and
Technology)
Proposed sites investigated by
Egyptian Partners:
•Borg Al-Arab (N. Coast)
•Al-Arish (N. Coast)
•Zafrana (E. Coast)
•Hurgada (E. Coast)
•Marsa Alam (E. Coast)
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Pictures of the site
MATS Project
Selected site
City for Science and Technology
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Project deliverables and impact
Deliverables:
• Complete Solar Field working with – HTF (Molten Salts) Collection System.
• Heat & Cold Cogeneration/distribution Subsystem.
• Desalination unit type MED.
• Electrical generation Power block 1 Mw
• Backup unit fed by gas (R and NR) provided also for connection to a biomass gassifier
Impact:
• Lowering the costs of renewable energy and demonstrating solar power application’s
scalability
• Contributing to the use and development of renewable energies
• Placing EU research organizations and industries in the leading position in low carbon
technologies
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Contribution to energy production by solar source and biomass (rif. Hurgada EG)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Ago Sep Oct Nov Dec
SOLAR BIOMASS
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Hourly pick 1 409 W/m2 Solar Rate
Yearly total 2 308 kWh/m2
Unit Length 100 m
Unit Area 540 m2
Optical Efficiency 75 % Solar Collectors
Thermal Efficiency 83 %
No Collectors 18
Total Collector Length 1800 m
Total Collector Area 9 720 m2 Solar Field
Site Area 22 000 m2
Electric Energy 3 010 MWh Annual Production
Thermal Energy 8 900 MWh
Electric Power 1,0 MW el
Outlet Thermal Power 4,0 MW th
Inlet Thermal Power 5,7 MW th
Type MED Desalting Unit
Capacity 250 m3 per day
MATS Project
Main characteristics
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Elementi di progetto sul territorio
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Posizionamento campo solare e impianti
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
La piattaforma del cippato
Piattaforma
logistico
commerciale in
Stiria - Austria
Capannone esistente
idoneo alla
trasformazione
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
NEED OF LAND FOR 1 GWe BY CSP+BIOMASS
44
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi45
NEED OF LAND FOR 1 GWe BY CSP+BIOMASS
1 Gwe
CSP
5 x 4 km =
= 20 km2
BIOMASSE
40 x 40 km =
= 1600 km2
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Roma Capitale – ENEL Green Power – ENEA Agreement
for a demonstration plant with CSP hybridized by biomass
46
Uses of resources from territory of Roma Capitale for
the susteinable production in CSP-Biomass hybrid
plant of electric power and the transformation of ligno-
cellulosic wastes (from gardens and trees cuts of the
town) in solar fuels, i.e bio-ethanol or other
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
OPTS: OPtimization of a Thermal energy Storage system with integrated steam
generator
List of the Project’s Partners
1 AGENZIA PER LE NUOVE TECNOLOGIE, L’ENERGIA E LO SVILUPPO ECONOMICO SOSTENIBILE - ENEA IT
2 COMMISSARIAT A L'ENERGIE ATOMIQUE ET AUX ENERGIES ALTERNATIVES - CEA FR
3 CENTRE NATIONAL DE LA RECHERCHE SCIENTIFIQUE - CNRS FR
4 FRAUNHOFER-GESELLSCHAFT ZUR FOERDERUNG DER ANGEWANDTEN FORSCHUNG E.V – Fraunhofer GE
5 THE WEIZMANN INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE - Weizmann IS
6 THE CYPRUS RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION - CREF-CyI CY
7 ANSALDO NUCLEARE S.P.A.- ANSALDO IT
8 CENTRO DE INVESTIGACIONES ENERGETICAS, MEDIOAMBIENTALES Y TECNOLOGICAS - CIEMAT ES
9 COBRA INSTALACIONES Y SERVICIOS, S.A - COBRA ES
10 LABORATORIO NACIONAL DE ENERGIA E GEOLOGIA, IP - LNEG PT
11 TECNIMONT KT- KINETICS TECHNOLOGY SPA - TKT IT
Resources for the Project
Total costs: 13,726,083.80 € EU contribution 8,649,499.50 €
Total efforts: 781.50 PM
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
OPTS project aims at developing a new Thermal Energy
Storage (TES) system based on single tank configuration
using stratifying Molten Salts as heat storage medium at
550°C, integrated with a Steam Generator (SG), to provide
efficient, reliable and economic for the next generation of
CSP trough and tower plants.
The three-year experimental program will be focused to the
full development of the integrated system (TES-SG) up to
demonstration level.
Since the objective is to develop a new TES-SG concept for
large-scale CSP plants, i.e. 50 MWe, the experimental
concept has to be verified in a relevant scale (at least 12.5
MWth), maintaining the same main thermo-fluid-dynamic
parameters as the full scale system.
Reference design of TES_SG system for 50 MWe CSP plant,
i.e 5x10 MWe SGs immersed in a large tank
Influence zone of one SG
Schematic of reference 50 MWe TES_SG
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Reference CSP plant for installation of the OPTS Test Section
Basic experimental, modelling and engineering
activities will be carried out to support the
design and optimization of the proposed
technology. These activities include
assessment of MS heat transport properties
under relevant representative conditions for the
TES-SG system.
This test section will be designed, built, and tested
at an existing CSP plant owned by ACS Cobra in
Spain. The plant will be arranged for integrating the
OPTS test section, without affecting the normal
operation but rather enhancing the condition of the
steam at the turbine’s inlet.
All rights reserved EASAC Workshop on CSP Athens 09_12_2011 F. Fabrizi
Direct MS CSP system implementing a stratifying TES
with integrated SG
Design, optimization and cost-benefit assessment for a full-scale TES-SG system (12.5 MWth/50MWe) will be done in the framework of the OPTS project coupled with a CSP
(tower or trough) plant.
Schematic of a MS CSP plant with stratifying TES_SG system
(including MS backup gas fired heater)