+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis - Penn State Engineering · Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis The...

Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis - Penn State Engineering · Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis The...

Date post: 10-Mar-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
Adam Kroll New York Law School Curtain Wall Breadth Page 161 of 236 Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis The clear glass façade is a prominent architectural feature of NYLS’s New Community Facility. The glass curtain wall envelops the building almost entirely along its northwest sides, along West Broadway and Leonard Street. The other sides of the building are pressed against adjacent structures, so the glass façade exists wherever people may look at the building from the exterior. With such a large area of glass, solar heat gain could become an issue. Since the façade is northfacing, direct sunlight is not typically a problem, but the large surface area of glass throughout the building makes the glazing system worth considering. Undesirable solar gain is highest in the summer, due to the high solar angle. In the winter, the solar gain is actually desirable to offset heating loads. The ideal solar glazing will be selected based on several criteria. Fitting with the existing design, a clear glazing will be selected. Introducing tints and colors to the glass would clash with the clean architectural style of the building and the theme of transparency. Particularly in the Student Dining Area, tinting the glass would break the connection to the exterior Roof Terrace. A high visible transmittance (T vis ) is desirable, to allow in diffuse northern daylight. The glazing should also have a low heat gain coefficient (SHGC), which measures the transmittance of solar radiation in all wavelengths of the solar spectrum. A balance between visible transmittance and SHGC needs to be met. The light to solar gain (LSG) ratio describes the overall efficiency of the glazing in terms of maximizing visible transmittance while minimizing SHGC. This study analyzes three types of glazing systems using Carrier’s Hourly Analysis Program (HAP). Glazing data, shown in the table below, comes from PPG. All data is for 1” insulated glass units with ½” airspace and two panes of ¼” glass. PPG Glazing Data Description T vis T total ρ vis u winter u summer SHGC LSG Clear glass, uncoated 0.79 0.61 0.15 0.47 0.50 0.70 1.13 Solarban 60 Clear, lowE coating 0.70 0.33 0.11 0.29 0.27 0.38 1.85 Solarban 70XL Starphire Clear, lowE coating 0.64 0.25 0.12 0.28 0.26 0.28 2.37 This analysis will only look at the Level 5 Student Dining area. This space has a large amount of glass area and is representative of the building as a whole. The space is approximately 5500 ft 2 , with floortoceiling glass walls facing north to northeast. For the HAP analysis, the windows were defined as the entire north wall, which is 11’ by 186’ for a total glass area of 2046 ft 2 . This is a rough approximation, since window frames and some variations due to the stairwell are not taken into account. However, since this analysis is comparative, these variations will not affect the conclusion of the study. The findings of the HAP analysis, which calculates mechanical loads according to annual climate patterns, appears below.
Transcript
Page 1: Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis - Penn State Engineering · Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis The clear glass façade is a prominent architectural feature of NYLS’s New Community

Adam Kroll ‐ New York Law School                                                                                                       Curtain Wall Breadth 

Page 161 of 236 

Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis  

The clear glass façade is a prominent architectural feature of NYLS’s New Community Facility. The glass curtain wall envelops the building almost entirely along its northwest sides, along West Broadway and Leonard Street. The other sides of the building are pressed against adjacent structures, so the glass façade exists wherever people may look at the building from the exterior.   With such a large area of glass, solar heat gain could become an issue. Since the façade is north‐facing, direct sunlight is not typically a problem, but the large surface area of glass throughout the building makes the glazing system worth considering. Undesirable solar gain is highest in the summer, due to the high solar angle. In the winter, the solar gain is actually desirable to offset heating loads.   The ideal solar glazing will be selected based on several criteria. Fitting with the existing design, a clear glazing will be selected. Introducing tints and colors to the glass would clash with the clean architectural style of the building and the theme of transparency. Particularly in the Student Dining Area, tinting the glass would break the connection to the exterior Roof Terrace. A high visible transmittance (Tvis) is desirable, to allow in diffuse northern daylight. The glazing should also have a low heat gain coefficient (SHGC), which measures the transmittance of solar radiation in all wavelengths of the solar spectrum. A balance between visible transmittance and SHGC needs to be met. The light to solar gain (LSG) ratio describes the overall efficiency of the glazing in terms of maximizing visible transmittance while minimizing SHGC.  This study analyzes three types of glazing systems using Carrier’s Hourly Analysis Program (HAP). Glazing data, shown in the table below, comes from PPG. All data is for 1” insulated glass units with ½” airspace and two panes of ¼” glass.  

PPG Glazing Data Description  Tvis  Ttotal  ρvis uwinter  usummer  SHGC  LSG Clear glass, uncoated  0.79  0.61  0.15  0.47  0.50  0.70  1.13Solarban 60 Clear, low‐E coating  0.70  0.33  0.11  0.29  0.27  0.38  1.85Solarban 70XL Starphire Clear, low‐E coating  0.64  0.25  0.12  0.28  0.26  0.28  2.37 This analysis will only look at the Level 5 Student Dining area. This space has a large amount of glass area and is representative of the building as a whole. The space is approximately 5500 ft2, with floor‐to‐ceiling glass walls facing north to northeast. For the HAP analysis, the windows were defined as the entire north wall, which is 11’ by 186’ for a total glass area of 2046 ft2. This is a rough approximation, since window frames and some variations due to the stairwell are not taken into account. However, since this analysis is comparative, these variations will not affect the conclusion of the study. The findings of the HAP analysis, which calculates mechanical loads according to annual climate patterns, appears below. 

Page 2: Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis - Penn State Engineering · Curtain Wall Solar Gain Analysis The clear glass façade is a prominent architectural feature of NYLS’s New Community

Adam Kroll ‐ New York Law School                                                                                                       Curtain Wall Breadth 

Page 162 of 236 

HAP Mechanical Loads Summary 

Glazing System Cooling Load (tons) 

Cooling Load (1000 BTU/h) 

Heating Load (1000 BTU/h) 

Clear glass, uncoated  9.3  112.1  166.6 Solarban 60 Clear, low‐E coating  8.2  97.9  167.3 Solarban 70XL Starphire Clear, low‐E coating  7.7  91.9  168.0  The Solarban 70XL glazing performs the best in terms of minimizing cooling loads. This makes sense, since it has the lowest SHGC of the three glazings. A reduced cooling load will not only save energy, but will possibly allow the mechanical equipment to be reduced in size. The additional heating load (due to reduced solar heat gain during the winter) is minimal compared to the reduced cooling load. The visible transmittance is also reasonably high at 64%. Given these findings, the Solarban 70XL Starphire Clear glazing is recommended for the entire building’s glass facade. Only three glazings were analyzed, but most of the other offerings (from PPG) either have tints, colors, or visible transmittance values too low to fit with the architecture of the building.  

 Above: The area of glass façade is highlighted on Level 5. The amount of glass is typical of all floors above grade. 


Recommended