+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and...

Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and...

Date post: 15-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
61
www.rcaonline.org Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner, Sidley Austin LLP Guest Lecturers: Nathan A. Howell, JD, Partner, Sidley Austin LLP Steven M. Felsenthal, JD, LLM, GC & CCO, Milburn Ridgefield Corporation Kara J. Brown, JD, SVP, GC & Compliance Officer, Cabot Properties L.P. Verity A. Van Tassel Richards, JD, Associate, Sidley Austin LLP Cynthia L. Wells, JD, Staff Attorney, Sidley Austin LLP
Transcript
Page 1: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

www.rcaonline.org

Custody Rule Basics and

Conundrums

November 13, 2018Senior Practice Fellow:Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner, Sidley Austin LLP

Guest Lecturers:Nathan A. Howell, JD, Partner, Sidley Austin LLPSteven M. Felsenthal, JD, LLM, GC & CCO, Milburn Ridgefield CorporationKara J. Brown, JD, SVP, GC & Compliance Officer, Cabot Properties L.P.Verity A. Van Tassel Richards, JD, Associate, Sidley Austin LLPCynthia L. Wells, JD, Staff Attorney, Sidley Austin LLP

Page 2: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

2

RCA Mission & Community

NORTH AMERICA

EUROPEASIAAFRICASOUTH AMERICAAUSTRALIA

Exclusive Global Authority for Compliance ContinuingEducation (CCE®); Talent Assessment & Development;Professional Exams; Executive Degree Programs.

RCA Global Metrics

Supporting over 80,000:• Individuals in Career

TransitionVeteransSingle Parents

• Regulators• Financial Execs• Professionals • Jobseekers• Millennials

Recognized by over 30,000 senior level Regulators, Lawyers, CPAs, Investors and Financial Institution Executives

Page 3: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

3

Core Verticals

Compliance Continuing Education

Professional Exams &

Certifications

Executive Masters Degree

Programs

Talent Assessment and

Development

Recognized & Used by over 30,000 Regulators, Institutional Investors, Compliance Officers, Legal & Operations Executives

Governing, Regulating & Administrating the Professional Examination of Regulatory Counsel, Regulatory Analysts & Compliance Officers.

• Executive MS (Master of Science) in Compliance

• Executive LLM (Master of Law) in Regulation

Invest in Your Future…Position Yourself for SuccessTM

• Certifying Regulators• RTAC – Assessment of

Compliance Knowledge & Skills

• RTEDS - Talent Management and Development

RCA Mandate

Page 4: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

4

Curriculum Development

RCA’s CCE® (Continuing Compliance Education) Accreditation requires all course materials to satisfy graduate level criteria within each phase of the academic process: Curriculum Development, Instructional Design & Peer Review.

Instructional Design

Peer Review Accreditation

• Course Materials (Textbook, Instructional Aides, etc.)

• Lectures• Examinations

• Syllabus and detailed outline

• Entire course offering• Mandatory annual review

and accreditation of Course Materials.

• CPE (Continuing Professional Education).

• CLE (Continuing Legal Education).

• CCE® (Continuing Compliance Education®)

RCA CCE® Accreditation – Refined Over 20 Years

• Independent assessments of course subject matter.

• Faculty drafted syllabus & corresponding outline.

• Faculty prepared course materials.

• Proprietary work product (forms, policies/procedures, contractual language, etc.)

© RCA, 2000-2018, All rights reserved

RCA CCE® Accreditation

Page 5: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

5

Firms Using RCA Accredited CCE®

Page 6: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

6

Regulators & Industry Executives Using CCE ®

Page 7: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

7

RCA for EmployersExclusive Global Authority for Compliance Continuing Education (CCE®); Talent Assessment & Development; Professional Exams; Executive Degree Programs. Optimize Your Firm

RTAC™ – RCA’s Talent Assessment Center

RTEDS™ – RCA’s Talent Enhancement& Development System

REIS™ – RCA’s Regulatory ExamInterview System

RTAC™ + RTEDS™ + REIS™ = RCA Validated Talent Optimization

Page 8: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

8

RCA Talent Assessment Center (RTAC)Fortify Your Firms Human Capital – Its Greatest AssetTM

Page 9: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

9

RCA Talent Enhancement and Development System (RTEDS)

Law & Practice Law

Practice

Operational Process

Cybersecurity

Due Dilligence

Risk Management

Fund Goverance

Valuation

Accounting

Taxation

FACTA

BEPS

Compliance Process Surveillance Supervision Analytics Case Management Risk Assessments Forensic Testing Reviews Remediation Reporting Marketing Disclosure Practices Client/Customer/IR Fiduciary Duty AML Social Media Code of Ethics Trading & Markets Conflicts

Exams & Enforcement

Inspections

Examinations

Enforcement

Civil Discovery

Civil Litigation

Investigatory Practice

Criminal Prosecution

Regulation 33 & 34 Act IA Act 1940 IC Act of 1940 Crypto Currencies Digital Assets CTA Regulation CPO Regulation AIFMD UCITS MiFIDs EMIR DOL / ERISA AML / KYC Trading & Markets Insider Trading Market Manipulation Systemic Risk Political Contributions Whistleblower FCPA Anti-Bribery Sanctions Anti Trust HSR

Fortifying Human Capital – Your Firms Greatest AssetTM

Page 10: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

10

Automated Regulatory Examination Interview System™(REIS™) SEC Examiners NOW interview your personnel to find deficiencies in their core

competencies and skill sets. RCA’s Examination Interview System (REIS) simulates the interview process to identify and resolve knowledge gaps by assigning accredited, up-to-date, relevant, targeted, talent development.

Design & Deploy

Configures mock exam interviews by subject or topic for a division, department, group or particular employee.

The cloud-based system simulates the interview process with a database of over 15,000 queries spanning 4500 topics using a “self-paced” environment.

Automatically identifies, assesses and evaluates each employee’s gaps in core competencies skill sets and knowledge.

Page 11: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

11

RCA for Career Advancement

Invest in Your Future… Position Yourself for SuccessTM

Professional Exams and

Certifications

• CRC (Chartered Regulatory Council)

• CRA (Chartered Regulatory Analyst)

• Surpass JD & MBA Graduates

RCA SymposiaExecutive Degree Programs

Compliance Continuing Education

• Timely, Relevant Commentary

• Comprehensive, Up-to-Date, Practice Guides

• Over 800 Topics

• Executive MS (Master of Science) in Compliance

• Executive LLM (Master of Law) in Regulation

• Accredited, Authoritative Faculty

• Network with Industry Leaders and Senior Regulators

Page 12: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

12

Regulatory Leaders Endorse RCA

®

®

Page 13: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

13

Regulatory Leaders Endorse RCA

®

®®

®

Page 14: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

14

Industry Leaders Endorse RCA

®

®

®

®

Page 15: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

15

Overview of the Topics To Be Covered

Custody 101: Custody Rule Basics and Practical Compliance Advice

Custody 201: General Compliance Issues under the Custody Rule

Extra Credit: Custody Conundrums

Page 16: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

16

Custody 101: Custody Rule Basics

Page 17: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

17

What is “Custody”?

The SEC staff interprets “custody” broadly, including where the RIA or its related person holds, directly or indirectly, the assets – i.e., the RIA or its related person either possesses or has the authority to obtain the assets, even if access to those assets is temporary and/or never used.

The Custody Rule includes a myriad of technical requirements, not all of which make sense in the context of safekeeping of assets.

An RIA or its related person generally have custody where the adviser:

• Has possession of client funds or securities (unless they were received inadvertently and the adviser returns them to the client within three business days of receipt);

• Has a general power of attorney under which the adviser is authorized or permitted to withdraw client funds or securities;

• Is a GP of a limited partnership, a managing member of an LLC, a trustee of a trust, or a person with similar legal ownership of or access to client funds or securities;

• Receives proceeds from the redemption of client securities; • Can write checks or withdraw funds from its client’s account; or • Has authority to dispose of client funds or securities for any purpose other than “authorized

trading,” can deduct fees or other expenses from a client’s account or can direct cash flows from the client’s account.

Page 18: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

18

What is “Custody”?

According to the SEC staff, an adviser can have custody where the custodial agreement binds the custodian to act on instructions of the adviser, even if the advisory agreement restricts the adviser (so-called “inadvertent custody”).

SEC staff has also indicated that an adviser may have custody where it has entered into a standing letter of instruction or similar asset transfer authorization (“SLOA”).

The staff has indicated that under certain circumstances adviser authorization to transfer assets between a client’s own accounts will not constitute custody.

Page 19: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

19

What is a “Client” under the Custody Rule?

• Any person or entity receiving investment advice, including accounts that pay no fees (e.g., family members).

• An adviser may not have to comply with the custody rule, however, with respect to assets in private funds owned solely by the adviser’s principals, their family members and/or their family trusts.

• Includes pooled investment vehicles (PIVs) or separately managed accounts (SMAs).

Page 20: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

20

What are “Funds and Securities”?

“Funds” include cash or cash equivalents.

“Security” is defined broadly under the Advisers Act and

includes bonds, notes, stocks, security futures, evidence of

indebtedness (e.g., loans and mortgages), options on

securities and security-based swaps.

“Security” definition under Advisers Act and Investment Company Act is broader than

under the Securities Act or Securities Exchange Act, which

causes considerable confusion.

The Custody Rule does not apply to assets that are neither “funds” nor “securities,” such

as commodities and real estate that is directly owned.

Page 21: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

21

Practical Compliance Advice

Page 22: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

22

Custody 201: General Compliance Issues

Page 23: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

23

Extra Credit : Custody Conundrums

Page 24: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

24

Real Estate

Page 25: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

25

Digital Assets

Page 26: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

26

Additional Materials

Page 27: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

27

“Maintained” with a “Qualified Custodian”

With limited exceptions for mutual fund shares and certain privately offered securities, the Custody Rule requires an RIA with custody to maintain client funds and/or securities with a “qualified custodian.”

Generally, a “qualified custodian” must be a bank, broker-dealer or registered FCM.

Funds and securities must be kept in a separate account for each client under that client’s name or in accounts that contain only clients’ funds and securities, under the adviser’s name as agent or trustee for the clients. Client assets may not be commingled with the adviser’s assets.

Page 28: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

28

“Maintained” with a “Qualified Custodian”

It is not always clear how precisely to “maintain” certain securities – e.g., loans or swaps – with the qualified custodian.

“Self-custody” – an RIA or its related person that meets the “qualified custodian” definition may “self-custody.” The RIA must obtain an internal control report prepared by an independent public accountant overseen by the PCAOB and must undergo an annual “surprise” verification of assets (unless the RIA has custody solely because the related qualified custodian has custody of the RIA’s client assets and the related qualified custodian is “operationally independent” from the RIA).

“Privately offered securities.” An adviser is not required to maintain securities with a qualified custodian if they are privately offered, uncertificated and transferable only with prior consent of the issuer or outstanding holders. Under certain circumstances, private stock certificates are not required to be maintained with a qualified custodian.

Page 29: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

29

Reporting Requirements

Quarterly statements + surprise audit. The adviser must have a reasonable basis, after due inquiry, for believing that the qualified custodian sends an account statement, at least quarterly,

directly to each client and pooled vehicle investor for which the custodian

maintains funds and/or securities, identifying the amount of funds and of each security in the account at the end

of the period and setting forth all transactions in the account during the period and must undergo a “surprise

examination” by an independent auditor at least once per year.

Audit exemption for pooled vehicles. The adviser will be

deemed to have complied with the Custody Rule if it prepares audited financial statements in accordance

with GAAP and GAAS and delivers to the fund investors within 120 days of the fund’s fiscal year end for a direct

trading private fund or within 180 days of the fund’s fiscal year end for a fund of funds. In addition, the fund

must conduct a final audit and distribute to the investors “promptly”

upon liquidation of the pool.

Page 30: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

30

“Qualified Custodian”

“Qualified Custodian”Includes:

Banks

(as defined in the Advisers Act and clarified in SEC staff guidance—what is/is not a “bank” is NOT as obvious as it seems)

Savings & Loans

Registered Broker-Dealers

Futures commission merchants registered

with the CFTC

Exception for mutual fund transfer agents who may be used in lieu of a

Qualified Custodian

Page 31: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

31

“Qualified Custodian”

RIA must maintain Client assets with a Qualified Custodian either in:

A separate account for each Client under that Client’s name

Accounts that contain only Clients’ Funds & Securities, under the RIA’s name as agent or trustee for the Clients.

Page 32: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

32

“Qualified Custodian”

What about the RIA who acts as the Qualified Custodian or uses a related Qualified Custodian?

Needs at occupational level

Needs at individual level

• SEC staff perceives the arrangement as a higher risk to Clients.

• To address the risk, the RIA must (1) obtain or receive from its related custodian, as applicable, an internal control report from an independent accountant and (2) arrange for a surprise verification of assets (except where the RIA has Custody due solely to the related Qualified Custodian’s custody of the assets and related Qualified Custodian is “operationally independent” from RIA).

Page 33: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

33

Special Treatment for “Privately Offered Securities”

Generally, RIAs need not, however, maintain “privately offered securities” with a Qualified Custodian.

• Acquired from the issuer in a transaction or chain of transactions that do not involve a public offering;

• Uncertificated, and ownership thereof is recorded only on the books of the issuer or its transfer agent in the name of the Client; and

• Transferable only with prior consent of the issuer or holders of the outstanding securities of the issuer.

“Privately offered securities” are securities that are:

The exception, which is available to both SMAs and PIVs, is available to PIVs only if the PIV is audited and the financials are distributed, all in accordance with the requirements of the “Audit Exemption.”

A security must satisfy each of the three prongs above to be considered a “privately offered security,” and there are some troubling conundrums…

Page 34: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

34

Basic Custody Rule Compliance - Notice, Reporting, Surprise Exam

• RIA must notify Clients and fund investors (unless fund is subject to Audit Exemption) promptly in writing of the Qualified Custodian’s name and address and how the Funds and/or Securities are maintained by that custodian at the time the account is opened and upon any changes to the information in the prior notice.

• RIA must have a reasonable basis after due inquiry for believing that the Qualified Custodian sends an account statement (1) at least quarterly, (2) directly to each Client and fund investor (but delivery requirement is not satisfied if the fund investor is also a fund and are the RIA’s related persons), (3) identifying the amount of Funds and of each Security in the account at the end of the period along with all transactions in the account during the period.

• Must be undertaken by an independent public accountant that meets additional requirements;

• Must be conducted once during each calendar year (generally, within the first within six months of the RIA becoming subject to the requirement) to (1) verify that the Client assets exist, (2) reconcile all such assets to the RIA’s books and records of its client accounts, (3) confirm such information with the RIA’s Clients;

• Are subject to a number of other requirements.

Notice

Reports

Surprise Exam

Page 35: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

35

The “Audit Exemption” for PIVs

Providing to the PIV investors audited financial statements prepared and delivered as specified in the Custody Rule.

Maintaining the Client’s Funds and/or Securities with a Qualified Custodian, if and as required

Regarding PIVs, including a single investor fund, an RIA may comply with the Custody Rule (and not be subject to the Notice and Reporting requirements and be deemed to have complied with the Surprise Exam requirements) by:

Page 36: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

36

The “Audit Exemption” for PIVsNotable requirements of the Audit Exemption:

PIV must be audited in accordance with GAAS at least annually and upon liquidation.

Auditor must be registered with, and subject to inspection by, the PCAOB.

PIV must distribute the audited financial statements, prepared in accordance with GAAP to investors within 120 days following the PIV’s fiscal year end (with extensions for FOFs) and “promptly” upon liquidation of the pool.

Financials must be distributed to the PIV investors that are not funds related to the RIA.

PIVs wholly owned by other funds advised by the RIA may be included in the scope of the pertinent upper tier fund.

Page 37: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

37

“Authorized Trading” is not “Custody”

• BUT WHAT IS “AUTHORIZED TRADING”?

• Famous Footnotes from the 2003 Adopting Release:

Footnote 5 states that “Custody” is “control of client funds or securities for purposes other than authorized trading.”

Footnote 10

Describes “authorized trading” as “the authority to issue instructions to a

broker-dealer or custodian to effect or to settle trades”; and

Provides a brief description of the “delivery v. payment” system as an

example, noting that “Clients’ custodians are generally under instructions

to transfer funds (or securities) out of a client’s account only upon

corresponding transfer of securities (or funds) into the account. This

delivery versus payment arrangement minimizes the risk an adviser could

withdraw or misappropriate the funds or securities in its client’s custodial

account.”

Page 38: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

38

Recent Tri-Part Custody Guidance Regarding “Custody” and SMAs

FAQ 11.4 – RIA’s restricted authority to transfer assets between or among Client’s own accounts held with Qualified Custodians (first-party transfers)is not Custody.

IAA N-AL – A standing letter of authorization (“SLOA”) authorizing a Qualified Custodian to transfer assets upon the RIA’s instruction to a third party for purposes other than Authorized Trading IS Custody, but there will be no enforcement recommendation under certain conditions, even if no surprise exam.

IM Guidance Inadvertent Custody – a nightmare of troubling conundrums…

Client must authorize RIA in a signed writing to make such transfers.

Generally, a copy of the authorization must be provided to the sending custodian, specifying the Client accounts – i.e., name and account numbers on sending and receiving accounts (including ABA routing number(s) or name(s) of receiving custodian).

Page 39: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

39

“Inadvertent Custody” and FAQ Modifications -The Nightmare

• The RIA is not a party and

• The authority in the custodial agreement conflicts with the

RIAs agreement with the Client.

IM Guidance –Inadvertent Custody may be imputed to an RIA when the

custodial agreement between the Qualified Custodian and

the Client permits the Qualified Custodian to accept

instructions from the RIA to transfer assets from the

account for any purpose other than authorized trading even if

• FAQ II.11—no enforcement if an RIA who does not have the custodial agreement, does not have reason to know its provisions and did not recommend the Qualified Custodian neither complies with the Custody Rule requirements nor reports Custody on its Form ADV

• FAQ II.12—an RIA as described in FAQ II.12 must still comply with applicable Custody Rule requirements if, e.g., it separately has authority to deduct fees and write checks

New FAQs

substantially modify the IM Guidance

Page 40: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

40

“Privately Offered Securities”

What securities qualify as “uncertificated securities”?

• Per SEC staff guidance, partnership agreements, subscription agreements, LLC agreements and ISDA master agreements are not certificated securities and even some privately offered certificated equity securities enjoy relief under certain circumstances.

• In the absence of additional specific guidance, we would expect other examples to include debt or equity interests in a private company and other types of customized agreements (e.g., assignments and customized agreements that are not negotiable instruments).

What securities are “transferable only with prior consent of the issuer or

holders” – do bank loans, mortgage loans & other types of loans satisfy

this prong?• To the extent such loans are not vulnerable to misuse or misappropriation by

the RIA and therefore do not require the protection of a Qualified Custodian, it is reasonable to take the position that privately negotiated debt securities that are not readily negotiable and meet the other prongs also should qualify for the exception.

Page 41: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

41

Liquidation Audit

YES! The liquidation audit is a fundamental condition of the Audit Exemption designed to assure liquidation proceeds are appropriately accounted for and provide investors an opportunity to take timely steps to protect their rights.

Answer 1

Page 42: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

42

Liquidation Audit

The SEC staff has not provided guidance as to the definition of “upon liquidation,” but the American Institute of CPAs (“AICPA”) has commented that the financial statements (1) should be dated as of or near the final distribution date (and generally would not be distributed prior to the final fund distribution to investors) and (2) can cover more than a 12 month period if they are delivered to investors within the 120 days of the PIV’s FYE, provided they include two balance sheets, two income statements, two statements of changes in partners’ capital and two statements of cast flows, as applicable, one of each as of the FYE and one for the period from the FYE to the liquidation date.

Answer 2

Page 43: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

43

Liquidation Audit

There is no SEC comfort for omitting the liquidation audit! And it is important to wrap up well, especially where the adviser is ceasing operations and the employees want to move on.

Answer 3

Page 44: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

44

Special Purpose Vehicles (“SPVs”)

Provided an SPV has no owners other than the RIA, its related persons

and/or their PIVs, an RIA relying on the Audit Exemption has the

option to treat:

• The SPV as a separate Client and

separately audit the SPV or

• The SPV’s assets as assets of the

fund and consider those assets

“within the scope” of the fund’s

audited financials.

Page 45: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

45

Dreaded Scenario 4

If an investment vehicle has owners other than those

described above, the vehicle may share characteristics

with an SPV, but it is not an SPV—it is an investment

fund that should be treated as a separate Client for

purposes of the Custody Rule, and the RIA must comply

separately with the Custody Rule’s audit and audited

financial statement distribution requirements with

respect to such investment fund.

Page 46: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

46

SMAs, IMAs and the Custody Rule

• NOT INCLUDE language that could be construed to confer authority that constitutes Custody and

• INCLUDE clear language indicating the RIA does not have Custody

Where an RIA does not accept Custody, it is important the SMA IMA

• Client grants RIA authority to act as Client’s agent and attorney-in-fact to issue instructions to a broker-dealer or a custodian to effect or to settle trades for and on behalf of Client with respect to the account

• Assets will be held by a custodian selected by the Client in an account opened by the Client and notified by the Client to the RIA

• Client acknowledges that RIA will at no time have “custody” of the assets in the account as that term is defined in Rule 206(4)-2 under the Advisers Act

Assuming the RIA has discretionary authority, the IMA terms should indicate, at a minimum, that:

The facts must support the provisions indicating the RIA does not have Custody

Page 47: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

47

The Custody Rule—Perennial Compliance Issue

Noted widespread deficiencies in compliance due to, e.g.,

• Unsurprising “surprise” exams and • Failure to recognize “Custody,” e.g., where RIA

o Has personnel or a related person who serves as trustee or has POA for Client accounts

o Provides bill-paying services for Clientso Had online access to, and ability to withdraw from,

Client accountso Received checks for Clients and failed to return

promptly to sender

2013 Risk Alert

2017 Risk Alert

Page 48: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

48

Audit-Related Deficiencies in the 2013 Risk Alert

Accountant was not “independent” as required by the Custody Rule.

Audited financial statements were not prepared in accordance with GAAP (e.g., organizational expenses were improperly amortized rather than expensed as incurred resulting in a qualified audit opinion…).

Adviser failed to demonstrate that the audited financials were distributed to all fund investors—instead it appeared the statements were made available “upon request”

Audited financials were not sent to investors within the required time frame (120, 180, 240 days, as applicable).

4

3

2

1

Page 49: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

49

Audit-Related Deficiencies in the 2013 Risk Alert

Auditor was not PCAOB-registered and subject to PCAOB inspection.

Final audit was not performed on liquidated PIVs.

Adviser requested investor approval to waive the annual financial audit of a fund—but did not obtain a surprise examination thereby failing to either undergo a surprise exam or comply with the Audit Exception.

Some PIVs were using financial statements that were not prepared in accordance with GAAP or audited in accordance with GAAS without satisfying the conditions set out in the guidance.8

7

6

5

Page 50: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

50

Auditor Independence Rule—Enforcement In Re Holthouse Carlin & Van Trigt LLP (“HCVT”) (September 13, 2018)

In 2012 HCVT began auditing private funds managed by RIAs.

HCVT conducted 57 audits for four RIAs between 2012 and 2016.

Under the Auditor Independence Rule (Regulation S-X), an auditor is not independent if the accountant provides certain bookkeeping or other services related to the accounting records or

financial statements, unless it is reasonable to conclude that the results of those services will not be subject to audit procedures during the audit of the audit client’s financial statements.

HCVT’s P&P, controls and training (1) incorrectly referenced the independence standards issued by the AICPA, which allow auditors to prepare their clients’ financial statements and still maintain

their independence as long as the client assumes responsibility for the financial statements, rather than Regulation S-X’s independence standards and (2) failed to make clear that the

independence standards of Regulation S-X govern audits under the Custody Rule.

HCVT thereby caused the RIAs to violate the Custody Rule.

Page 51: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

51

Recordkeeping and CustodyAdvisers Act Rule 204-2—the Books and Records Rule:

A journal or other record showing all purchases, sales, receipts and deliveries of securities (including certificate numbers) for such accounts and all other debits and credits to such accounts.

A memorandum describing the basis upon which you have determined that the presumption that any related person is not operationally independent under §275.206(4)-2(d)(5) has been overcome.

A separate ledger account for each such client showing all purchases, sales, receipts and deliveries of securities, the date and price of each purchase and sale, and all debits and credits.

Copies of confirmations of all transactions effected by or for the account of any such client.

A record for each security in which any such client has a position, which record shall show the name of each such client having any interest in such security, the amount or interest of each such client, and the location of each such security.

1

2

3

4

5

If an investment adviser subject to paragraph (a) of this section has custody or possession of securities or funds of any client, the records required to be made and kept under paragraph (a) of this section shall include:

b

Page 52: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

52

Digital Assets

• Are Bitcoin, Ethereum or other digital assets “Funds” or “Securities”?

• Dalia Blass, Director of Division of Investment Management to the Investment Company Institute and the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, Staff Letter: Engaging on Fund Innovation and Cryptocurrency-related Holdings, January 18, 2018:

o Cryptocurrency related holdings raise “significant outstanding questions concerning how funds holding substantial amounts of cryptocurrencies and related products would satisfy the requirements of the 1940 Act and its rules”, including custody and safekeeping.

Page 53: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

53

Digital Assets

SEC Chairman Jay Clayton, CNBC, June 6, 2018:

o When asked about Ethereum, he would not comment on specific

digital assets, but he stated that cryptocurrencies that are a

replacement for sovereign currencies are “not securities”.

o A digital asset used to raise money for a venture in exchange for

a return from the venture or on the secondary market is a

security.

• Tokens as securities vs. tokens as “investment contract” securities under certain circumstances

Page 54: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

54

Digital Assets

o “Applying the disclosure regime of the federal securities laws to the offer and resale of Bitcoin would seem to add little value.”

o “And putting aside the fundraising that accompanied the creation of Ether, based on my understanding of the present state of Ether, the Ethereum network and its decentralized structure, current offers and sales of Ether are not securities transactions.”

o “If a promoter were to place Bitcoin in a fund or trust and sell interests, it would create a new security. Similarly, investment contracts can be made out of virtually any asset (including virtual assets), provided the investor is reasonably expecting profits from the promoter’s efforts.”

William Hinman, Director, Division of Corporation Finance, Digital Asset Transactions: When Howey Met Gary (Plastic), June 14, 2018:

Page 55: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

55

Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner, Sidley Austin LLP

LAURIE KLEIMAN is a global co-leader of Sidley’s Investment Funds, Advisers and Derivatives practice team. She represents a wide range of domestic and international investment funds and managers and is also a leader of the securities and derivatives enforcement and regulatory practice. Laurie is a frequent speaker on investment manager and fund regulation and compliance as well as on issues relating to the advancement of women in law.

Strong advocacy on behalf of her clients has earned Laurie acknowledgment in numerous industry publications, including Chambers USA, The Legal 500 and U.S. News & World Report. She is recognized in the area of Mutual Funds Law by The Best Lawyers in America®, with sources telling the publication: “Ms. Kleiman has been extremely professional and knowledgeable in her service to our firm. We trust her advice explicitly,” and “[Laurie] is a true expert in her area, and remarkably commercial and practical.” Laurie has also been included in articles in mainstream publications including Crain’s New York Business. She has been named to Crain’s New York Business’ inaugural “Leading Women Lawyers in New York City” list, where she was lauded as being among the 100 “trailblazing women” who have “found multiple paths to excellence” and have displayed “fierce determination, passion for the law, keen intelligence, and inspiring achievement.” Laurie has also been named one of the “50 Leading Women in Hedge Funds 2017” by the Hedge Fund Journal.

Page 56: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

56

Nathan A. Howell, JD, Partner, Sidley Austin LLP

NATE HOWELL is a partner in Sidley’s Chicago office in the Investment Funds, Advisers and Derivatives practice group. He also serves as a member of Sidley’s End-User Derivatives team and the Securities & Derivatives Enforcement and Regulatory practice group.

Nate’s practice focuses on futures and derivatives regulation, transactions and compliance, with a core focus on Commodity Exchange Act, Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and Dodd-Frank Act matters. He also frequently advises clients on issues related to cryptocurrency, blockchain and distributed ledger technology, and tokenized assets. He understands the complexities of the current legislative and regulatory environment in the United States in light of the disruption caused by technology. Nate’s clients rely on him to understand all of this complexity, while providing practical and straightforward solutions.

Nate’s clients include clearing organizations, derivatives exchanges and other trading facilities, self-regulatory organizations, commodity pool operators, commodity trading advisors, futures commission merchants, introducing brokers, swap dealers, banks, hedge funds, commercial end-users of derivatives (including manufacturing and energy companies) and companies that are actively engaged in the cryptocurrency and digital assets space. Nate also advises a number of non-U.S. financial institutions on the cross-border aspects of U.S. derivatives regulations.

Page 57: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

57

Steven M. Felsenthal, JD, LLM, GC & CCO, Millburn Ridgefield CorporationSteven Felsenthal is a General Counsel and Chief Compliance Officers of MillburnRidgefield Corporation, a Registered Investment Adviser, Commodity Pool Operator and Commodity Trading Advisor and its US and international affiliates. He focuses on all legal and compliance issues relating to the firm’s operations.

Prior to joining Millburn in January 2004, Mr. Felsenthal was a senior associate in the investment management group at Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP, where he represented and advised hedge funds, registered investment companies, investment advisers, broker-dealers and banks in connection with all facets of their asset management businesses, and a member of the tax department of Kramer, Levin, Naftalis & Frankel LLP.

He graduated cum laude from Yeshiva University in 1991 with a bachelor of arts degree in political science and order of the coif from Fordham University School of Law in 1996, where he also served as an editor of the Fordham Environmental Law Journal. Mr. Felsenthal received an LL.M degree in taxation from New York University School of Law in 2001 and has written and been quoted in numerous published articles and spoken at conferences, on various topics related to investment management.

Mr. Felsenthal is a member of the New York State Bar, serves on National Futures Association’s Compliance and Risk Committee, is a past member of the Steering Committee of the Managed Funds Association’s CCO Forum, past Co-Chairman of the Managed Funds Association CPO/CTA Advisory Committee and a past member of its Steering Committee, a Faculty Member and Lecturer for the Regulatory Compliance Association and a member of the Editorial Board of the Journal of Securities Operations & Custody (formerly, the Journal of Securities Regulation and Compliance). He was also recognized by Institutional Investor as one of its 20 Rising Stars in September 2006.

Page 58: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

58

Kara J. Brown, JD, SVP, GC & Compliance Officer, Cabot Properties L.P.

Kara J. Brown has 13 years of legal experience focused primarily on regulatory compliance. Ms. Brown joined Cabot in September 2018 and is responsible for overseeing all legal support for Cabot and assisting the Chief Compliance Officer with implementation of Cabot’s compliance program.

Prior to joining Cabot, Ms. Brown was Counsel in Sidley Austin LLP’s Boston office and a member of the Securities and Derivatives Enforcement and Regulatory practice groups, providing legal advice to investment advisers offering real estate, credit, private equity and public equity strategies and funds. Ms. Brown previously served as in-house counsel and compliance officer for investment advisers including Glenview Capital Management and Neuberger Berman.

Ms. Brown hold a Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, with honors and a Juris Doctor from Brooklyn Law School.

Page 59: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

59

Verity A. Van Tassel Richards, JD, Associate, Sidley Austin LLPVERITY VAN TASSEL RICHARDS focuses her practice on representing digital asset trading platforms, blockchain technology companies, U.S. and non-U.S. broker-dealers, financial services firms and cryptocurrency funds. Verity advises technology companies on blockchain token offerings, including so-called ICOs. She also counsels financial institutions and digital asset exchanges with day-to-day securities issues, private placement agent requirements, custody rule requirements, cross-border regulatory issues, money services business registration requirements and FINRA and SEC regulatory inquiries.

Verity works with transactional lawyers on structuring deals involving financial services and technology companies, digital asset exchanges and blockchain tokens. Verity advises blockchain entrepreneurs in the formation of nonprofit organizations and benefit corporations. She is an adjunct professor of law at the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law where she teaches The Law of Nonprofit Organizations.

Verity is a frequent speaker and writer on various topics in FinTech, with a particular focus on distributed ledger technology and blockchain tokens.

Prior to joining Sidley, Verity worked as an associate at another New York law firm. She was a judicial intern for the Honorable Dickinson R. Debevoise of the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey.

While in law school, Verity was an associate editor of the Cardozo Law Review and a Dean’s Distinguished Fellow.

Page 60: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

60

Cynthia L. Wells, JD, Staff Attorney, Sidley Austin LLP

CYNTHIA L. WELLS is a member of the firm’s Investment Funds, Advisers and Derivatives group. Her practice focuses on the representation of domestic and international investment funds and advisers. She is a member of the Sidley’s Associates Committee. Cynthia’s practice encompasses:

• Advice to both U.S. and non-U.S. managers to investment products of all types –including hedge funds, mutual funds, private equity funds, real estate funds, collateral managers and managed accounts – with respect to both U.S. federal and state investment adviser registration, regulation and compliance.

• Advice to financial institutions with respect to investment fund compliance and governance issues.

• Organization and registration of U.S. registered investment companies, including mutual funds, money market funds and closed-end funds.

Cynthia also has general corporate finance experience, particularly in investment grade debt securities and medium-term note programs.

Page 61: Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums - rcaonline.org...2018/11/13  · Custody Rule Basics and Conundrums November 13, 2018 Senior Practice Fellow: Laurin Blumenthal Kleiman, JD, Partner,

61© RCA, 2000-2018, All rights reserved

PracticEdgeTM Disclaimer


Recommended