+ All Categories
Home > Documents > D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the...

D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the...

Date post: 10-Sep-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
21
Transcript
Page 1: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key
Page 2: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

D.SarahHadden,Ph.D.AmyE.Mountz,M.Ed.RecommendationsforUsingtheCLASSinInclusiveEarlyChildhoodPrograms,

Birth-Age8ThispaperexamineskeyissuesthatmayarisewhentheCLASStoolisusedtoobserveinclassroomswithchildrenwhoarereceivingspecialeducationservices.WhiletheinitialworkdonewiththeCLASSwasconductedinclassroomsthatprimarilyservedtypicallydevelopingchildren,theCLASSiscurrentlybeingusedinavarietyofsettings:stateandlocallyfundedpre-schoolclassroomsthatenrolltypicallydevelopingchildrenand/orchildrenwhoareconsideredtobeat-riskforschoolfailure,HeadStart&EarlyHeadStartprograms,andcommunity-basedchildcareprograms.ItislikelythatanyoftheseprogramsmayincludechildrenwhohaveIEPs,individualizededucationprograms,orIFSPs,IndividualizedFamilyServicePlans,designedtomeettheuniquelearningneedsofchildrenwithdisabilities.Inaddition,theCLASStoolisalsobeingusedinsomeself-containedclassroomsorchildcaresettingsinwhich,mostifnotallofthechildrenhaveanIEPorIFSP.AstheuseoftheCLASSexpands,peoplehavequestionsaboutusingtheCLASSinsettingsthatincludeadiversepopulationofchildren.HereweaddresssomeofthekeyissuesrelatedtousingtheCLASStoolinclassroomsthatenrollchildrenwithdisabilities.First,wediscusshowtheinteractionsdescribedbytheCLASSareapplicabletoallchildren.ThenwediscusscodinginearlychildhoodsettingsthatincludesomechildrenwithIEPsorIFSPs.Next,wewilldescribecodinginclassroomswherethemajority,ifnotall,ofthechildrenreceivespecialeducationservices(self-containedclassroomsthatgenerallyservechildrenwithmoresignificantneeds).Finally,weposesomerecommendationsforusingtheCLASSinself-containedspecialeducationsettings.InteractionsMatterThetypesofeffectiveteacher-childinteractionsdelineatedintheCLASSareimportantforallchildren.Regardlessofability,allchildrenbenefitfrombeinginwarm,supportiveenvironmentswheretheycandevelopstrongrelationshipswiththeirteachersandpeers.Similarly,allchildrenhaveincreasedopportunitiestolearninwell-managedclassroomswhereteachersprovideinterestingandengaginginstructionthatincreaseschildren’sknowledgeandskills.

Page 3: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

WhatisthePurposeoftheObservation?CLASSobservationsmaybeconductedforavarietyofreasons.WhilesomedistrictsusetheCLASSasapartoftheirteacherevaluationprocess,othersmayconductobservationstoevaluatetheoverallefficacyofteacher-childinteractionsacrosstheprogramandtargetprogram-levelprofessionaldevelopmentonareasforgrowth.Insomecases,programsuseprogram-leveldatatomakehigh-stakesdecisions(e.g.,NationalOfficeofHeadStartandsomeQualityRating&ImprovementSystems).Finally,manyprogramsusetheCLASSasaninformalmeasureofquality.Administratorsorcoachestaketheinformationthey’velearnedfromobservationsanduseitasaspringboardforgoalsettingandongoingteacher-levelprofessionaldevelopment.Regardlessofthepurposeoftheobservation,theCLASSobservermustalwaysfollowtheprotocoldescribedinthemanual.RecallthattheCLASSistheonlyvalidatedtoolthatspecificallyaddressesteacher-childinteractions,whichhaveconsistentlybeenidentifiedasakeyleverofchangeinclassrooms.WhethertheCLASSisusedforinformaldatagatheringorhigh-stakesevaluations,thedatashouldbeutilizedtohelpprogramsidentifyareaswhereclassroominteractionsareeffectiveinordertohelpteachersincreasetheirintentionalityaroundthesetypesofinteractions,aswellasidentifyareasforprofessionalgrowth.UsingtheCLASStoObserveinClassroomsthatIncludeChildrenwithDisabilitiesToobtainvalidinformationabouttheefficacyoftheteacher-childinteractions,theobservermustfollowtheprotocoloutlinedintheCLASSmanualandlookforevidenceofalloftheCLASSdimensionsduringtheobservation,regardlessofthecompositionoftheclassroom.Anobserverwhoknowsthattheclassroomincludeschildrenwhoreceivespecialeducationservicescannotdecidetoskipcertaindimensionsorindicatorsbecausehefeelsthatthosedimensionsorindicators“donotpertaintotheclassroom.”Asstatedpreviously,thetypesofinteractionsdescribedbytheCLASSareimportantforalllearners,regardlessofability.Furthermore,CLASSobserverswhoarecollectingdatainclassroomsthatincludechildrenwhohaveIEPsorIFSPsshouldnotknowwhichchildrenhavetheseplansorthereasonforthem.Anobservermaysuspectthatachildmayhavealearningdifferencebasedonsomeobservedbehaviors,butmaynotasktheteacherifthisisthecase.Doingsowouldbeabreachofthechild’s

Page 4: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

confidentiality.Furthermore,regardlessofthedevelopmentallevelsofthestudents,theobserversimplyobservesandrecordstheinteractionsthatrelatetotheindicatorsandbehavioralmarkersintheCLASS.Insomecases,itisobviousthatachildhasadisability(e.g.,childcommunicatesviaAmericanSignLanguage,childusesawheelchairformobilityandcommunicatesviaanaugmentativecommunicationsystem).However,thisinformationmustnotimpacthowtheobserverassignscodes.CLASSobserversmustremainobjectiveatalltimes.EachversionoftheCLASSmanualincludesinformationontheimportanceofremainingobjective.Forexample,Chapter2inthePre-KCLASSManualstates,“Whenassigningscores,itisimperativetobasecodesonthewrittendescriptionsofthedimensions.Observersshouldnotadjusttheircodesupwardordownwardbasedonanyinformationotherthanwhattheyobservedintheclassroom”(pg.12).Similarly,Chapter2intheToddlerCLASSManualindicatesthat,“observersmustguardagainstinjectingexternalexplanationsforwhattheyseetakingplaceintheclassroom.Theobservermustremaintruetotheindividualdimensions”(pg.11).Makingallowancesorexceptionsincodingbecausechildrenhavespecialneedswillresultindatathatisnotreliable.Chapter2alsostatesthatobserversneedtoattendtoboththeteacher’sandthechildren’sbehaviors.ThesameistruewhencodingclassroomsthatincludechildrenwithIEPsorIFSPs.Childrenwhorequirethisadditionallevelofsupportmayhavedifferentwaysofcommunicatingwiththeteacherortheymayrespondtostimuliinadifferentmannerthantheirtypicallydevelopingpeers.Therefore,itisimperativethattheobserverattendstosubtlecuesornuancesinachild’sbehaviorandwatchtoseehowtheteacherresponds.Forexample,atypicallydevelopingchildwhoishavingaconflictwithapeermayapproachtheteacherandsay,“He’sbuggingme.”Theteachermayrespondbysaying,“Youhavealotofwords.Whydon’tyougotalktohimaboutthat?”therebyeffectivelyaddressingthechild’sconcern.Incontrast,achildwholackswell-developedlanguagemayrespondtotheconflictbywhining,gentlyrockingbackandforth,orshowingothersignsofagitation.Anobserverwhoseesthesebehaviorsshouldwatchfortheteacher’sresponse.Doestheteachersay,“Bequiet”or“Stoprocking”andthenkeepdoingwhatevershewasdoing?Ordoestheteachersay,“What’sgoingon?Youdon’tseemhappy”andthenfollowthechild’scuesinordertodeterminewhythechildisupset?Observingthechild’sreactionstotheteacher’sactionsiskeytodeterminingtheeffectivenessoftheinteractions.Inthefirstexample,ifthechildgoesoverandtalkstohispeerandtheyreengageinplay,thenitisclearthattheproblemhasbeenaddressedsuccessfully.Inthesecondcase,doesthechildwhowastoldtobequietshowsignsofincreasedagitation?Doesthechildwhoseteacheraskedwhatwasgoingonrespondtotheteacherinways

Page 5: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

thathelptheteacheraddresstheproblem?Carefullynotingthesubtletiesoftheseexchangesisvitaltodeterminingtheefficacyoftheseinteractions.Childrenwhoreceivespecialeducationservicesaremoreliketheirtypicallydevelopingpeersthantheyaredifferent.Mostyoungchildrenwhoreceivespecialeducationservicesreceivethemduetoaspeechorlanguagedelayandareoftenindistinguishablefromtheotherchildrenintheclass.Furthermore,typecastingchildrenbasedonadisabilitylabelisnothelpful,asthesamediagnosismaymanifestitselfindifferentwaysindifferentchildren.Forexample,achildwithamildformofcerebralpalsymayhaveweaknessononesideofhisbodyandhavesomedifficultywitharticulation,whileanotherchildwhohasthesamediagnosismayuseawheelchairandhavesignificantcognitivedelays.Similarly,twochildrenwithAutismSpectrumDisordermaybeverydifferent.Achildatthelowendofthespectrummayonlyhavedifficultywithsocialskills,whileachildattheoppositeendmayhavedifficultywithsocialskills,language,cognition,andbehavior.Thatsaid,onthewhole,childrenwithIEPsorIFSPsareverymuchliketheirpeerswithoutdisabilities.Theyarecuriousandactiveexplorersoftheirworldwhowanttohavefunandplay.IstheCLASSApplicableforStudentsReceivingSpecialEducationServices?ObserverswhoquestiontheapplicabilityoftheCLASSinsettingsthatincludestudentswithdisabilitiesmayhavetheirconcernsallayedwhentheyrealizethatmanyoftheinteractionsdescribedintheCLASSarefundamentalaspectsofspecialeducation.Eachchild’sIndividualizedEducationProgramorIndividualizedFamilyServicePlanoutlinesindetailtheindividualizedgoalsandobjectivesforthatchild.Thesedocumentsalsolistspecificadaptationsandaccommodationsthatachildneedsinordertoparticipateandprogressinclassroomactivities.Teachersroutinelymonitorhowwellchildrenprogressandadjustinstructionaccordingly,allofwhichareaspectsofTeacherSensitivity.Justasteachersmayneedtoindividualizeinstructionforstudentswithspeciallearningneeds,theyoftenneedtoindividualizehowtheyfacilitateinstructiontomeetthediverseneedsofthechildrenintheclass.Somechildrenmayneedtohaveinstructionsforanactivitybrokendownintoitscomponentparts,whileothersmaysimplyneedmorepracticetomasteraskill.Otherchildrenmayneedadditionaltimetoprocessinformation.Likewise,ateachermayneedtoacceptalternatemodesofrespondingonthepartofthechild,(e.g.,pointing,signlanguage,and/orpicturecards).

Page 6: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

Similarly,youngchildrenwhohaveIEPsorIFSPstendtoengageinchallengingbehaviorsathigherratesthantheirpeers.Therefore,teachersneedtoclearlycommunicateexpectations,beproactive,redirectmisbehavior,andconsistentlyreinforcerules.Ateachermayrelyonsignsorpicturecuesratherthanvocalspeechtocommunicateexpectations,yettheintentoftheinteractionsisthesame.Insum,thetypesofeffectiveteacher-childinteractionsdescribedbytheCLASSarerelevantforallchildren.However,theinteractionsmaylooksomewhatdifferentbasedonthechild’sindividualizedneedsandmethodofcommunicating,aswellasthenatureofthechild’sdisability.Becausebehavioralcuesoftendifferfromchildtochild,theobservermustcloselywatchtoseehowteachersinterpretandrespondtochildren.Thenextsectionoutlinesthingstotakeintoaccountwhencollectingdatainclassroomsthatincludechildrenwhoreceivespecialeducationservices.DimensionLevelConsiderationsThissectionprovidessuggestionsforthingsthatobserversmayseerelatedtothedifferentdimensionsoftheCLASS.Theinformationprovidedisnotmeanttobeexhaustive,butrathertoserveasastartingpointtohelpobserverspickuponsomeofthewaysthatchildrenwithdisabilitiesmaybehaveandcommunicate.PositiveClimate:Allchildren,regardlessofability,benefitfromwarmandsupportivelearningenvironments.Achildwithautismmaynotmakeeyecontactwithhisteacherorgiveherhugs,butinsteadmaystroketheteacher’sarmorstandveryclosetoher.Whenbehaviorsliketheseoccur,theteachermightsay,“I’msogladyoucametoschooltoday!”orgentlytouchthechildontheshouldertodemonstratetheconnectionbetweenthetwoofthem.TeacherSensitivity:Beingawareofandresponsivetochildren’sindividualizedlearningneedsisakeycomponentofTeacherSensitivityandanintegralpartofeducatingchildrenwhohaveIEPsorIFSPs.TeacherSensitivitytowardschildrenwithdisabilitiesisdemonstratedintwodifferentways.First,teachersplanlessonsthatprovideappropriatemodificationsandsupportstoensurethatallchildrenhavetheopportunitytoparticipateinclassroomactivities.Second,teacherscloselyattendandrespondtochildren’sbehavioralcues.Achildwithalanguagedelaymaynotapproachtheteacherandsay,“Ineedhelp,”butinsteadthechildmaysigntheword“help”orgivetheteacherapicturecardwithasymbolforhelp.Theteacherthennoticesthechild’srequestandprovidesassistance.Similarly,ateachermaynotethatachildwithafinemotordelaystrugglingtowritehernameonthe

Page 7: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

morningsign-insheetandprovideadaptivematerialsthatallowthechildtobesuccessful(e.g.,largermarker,pencilgrips,etc.).Becausechildrenwithspeciallearningneedsmaytakelongertoprocessinformationanddeveloparesponsetoaquestion,teachersmaydemonstratesensitivitybyprovidingadditionalwaittime.RegardforStudent/ChildPerspectives:Teacherscanshowregardforchildrenwithdisabilitiesinthesamewaysthattheydemonstrateregardforallchildren.Ifthechildismovingamarblealongthemarblerunoverandoveragain,ateachermayfollowtheirleadbyperformingthesameactiononadifferenttrack.Achildmaynotvocalizethattheywanttoreadaspecificbook,buttheteachermayseethechildholdingthebookandoffertoreadittoher.Teacherscanofferachildwithspecialneedsthesamekindsofchoicestheyprovideothers,butrecognizethattheymayneedtolimitthenumberofchoicestheyofferandallowthechildtorespondbyvocalizing,pointing,touching,usingeyegaze,orphysicallymoving.Likewise,achildmayexpresshimselfwithwords,pictures,signs,oranaugmentativecommunicationdevice.Restrictionofmovementmaymeanallowingachildtostandduringstory,holdsomethingduringcircle,ortakeanactivitybreakasnecessary.BehaviorManagement/BehaviorGuidance:Clear,consistentexpectationswithreliablefollowthroughareparticularlyimportantforyoungchildrenwithdisabilities.Teachersmaydisplayrulesinpicturesandpointtothesepicturestoremindchildrenofbehavioralexpectations.Teachersmustcloselymonitorchildren’sbehaviorforsubtlesignsoftroubleandredirectbeforethebehavioroccurs.Somechildrenmayrequirehigherratesofpraiseinordertointernalizetheclassroomrules.Productivity:Likeallchildren,childrenwithIEPsorIFSPsbenefitfrombeinginwell-managedclassroomswhereactivitiesareprovidedandroutinesareclear.Childrenwithaspeechorlanguagedelaymayindicatechoiceviaheadnods,eyegaze,orpointingtoapicture.Teachersmayusepictureschedulesandreferbacktothemifchildrenhavedifficultyrememberingtheroutines.Teachersmayalsousepicturesorsignstocommunicateactivityinstructions.Somechildrenmayneedmore1:1assistancetosuccessfullytransitionfromoneactivitytoanother.Forexample,theteachermayneedtoprovideverbalremindersaboutthestepstocleaningupaftercenters.Similarly,teachersmayprovidemoreexplicitfollow-throughbyrefocusingachild’sattentiontothetaskashand(“Remember,it’snottimetolookatbooks;it’stimetogetreadyforsnack.”)

Page 8: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

InstructionalLearningFormats:Tomeetthediverseneedsofthechildrenintheirclassrooms,teachersmustplanlessonsandactivitiesinwaysthatengagethechildrenandallowforeachchild,regardlessofabilitylevel,tobeactivemembersoftheclassroomlearningcommunity.Teachersmayneedtouseadditionallevelsoffacilitationtoengagechildrenwithdisabilities.Insomeinstances,anobservermayseeteacherstaskanalyzeanactivity(e.g.,breakitdownintosteps–aprocesscalledtaskanalysis)andsystematicallyteachchildreneachpartofthetask.Thisresearch-basedmethodhasproventobequiteeffectiveinteachingchildrenwithmoresignificantneeds(Cooper,Heron,&Heward,2007).Someactivitiesthatteachersmaytaskanalyzeinclude:handwashing,completingapuzzle,orcuttingoutPlay-Dohshapeswithcookie-cutters.Likeallchildren,childrenwhohaveIEPsorIFSPsmaybenefitfromhavinginformationpresentedinmultiplemodalities.Forexample,ateachermayteachalphabetlettersbyusingabrightlycoloredletterchart,alphabetshapedpuzzlepieces,magneticalphabetletters,andsandpaperletters.Theteachermayfollowupbyhavingthechildrenmakelettersinsandorshavingcream.Usingthisvarietyofmodalitiesandmaterialsnotonlyheightenschildren’sinterest,butmayalsobebeneficialforchildrenwithvisualimpairments.Becausesomechildrenwithdisabilitiesmayhaveshorterattentionspansorfocusonextraneousstimuli,theteachermayneedtohavelongerconversationsaboutwhatthechildrenaredoingandaskevenmorequestionstoensurethatchildrenfocustheirattentiononthelearningobjectives.Finally,studentinterestmaylooksomewhatdifferentwhenachildhasadisability.Asanexample,achildmaynotlookattheteacher,yetstillbemanipulatingmaterialsand/ordirectingherattentiontothetaskathand.ConceptDevelopment:TeachersembedConceptDevelopmentbyintentionallyprovidingchildrenwithlearningopportunitiesthatareadaptedtothechildren’sskilllevel.Theseopportunitiesshouldbechallengingenoughtopromotegrowth,butnotsochallengingthatthechildrengiveup;thinkoftheRussianpsychologistLevVygotskywhodevelopedtheconceptofandthe“zoneofproximaldevelopment,”whichstatesthatchildrenlearnnewskillswhenteachersadaptthelevelsofsupporttheyprovideinordertohelpthechildrenmasternewskills(Vygotksy,1978).Allchildrencanengageinanalysisandreasoning:thekeyistopresenttheinformationattheappropriatelevel.Forexample,achildwithadevelopmentaldelaymaynothavetheprerequisiteknowledgetoexplainwhyplacingthewoodenblockononeendmakesthebalancescalegodownwhilethefeatherontheotherendgoesup,butthechildcanproblemsolvewhattodowhentheareawhereshewantstoplayisfull.Bothoftheseexamplesaddressanalysisandreasoning,butatadifferentlevel.Teachersshouldalwaysbeexplicitwhenthey

Page 9: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

integrateknowledgeorconnectnewinformationtothechildren’srealworld;however,theyneedtobeevenmoreintentionalandexplicitifchildrenhaveIEPsorIFSPs.QualityofFeedback:Effectivefeedbackisgoodforalllearners.Rememberthatscaffoldingoccurswhenateachertakesthestudentfromwheretheyareandprovidesthesupportthatthechildneedstobesuccessful.Forachildwithamoresignificantdisability,thiscouldbeassimpleaspointingtoapictureofsoapbythesinktoremindthechildtousesoapwhilewashinghishandsorascomplexasusingahandoverhandprompttohelpthechildpickupthesoapandrubitbetweenhishands.Thesystemofleastprompts,anotherresearch-basedstrategyusedinspecialeducation,isdesignedtoscaffoldchildren’slearningbystartingwiththeleastintrusiveprompt(hint)andsystematicallymovingtomoreintrusiveprompts(e.g.handoverhandguidance)untilthechildarrivesatthecorrectresponse(Wolery,Ault,&Doyle,1992).Anobservershouldnotassumethattheywouldneverseeafeedbackloopbetweenateacherandachildwithlimitedlanguage.Teachersmayuseacombinationofgestures,signs,orpicturestoengageachildinaback-and-forthexchangethathelpsthechildcompleteataskorcometoahigherlevelofunderstanding.Becausesomechildrenmayhyper-focusonextraneousstimuli,theprovisionofexplicitfeedbackisoftennecessary.Finally,teachersmayposequestionsthatencouragethought,butthechildmayrespondnonverbally.LanguageModeling:Teacherspromotelanguageinavarietyofways.Teachersmayobserveplayandcommentaboutwhatthechildrenaredoing.Thesecommentsmayturnintoconversationalexchangesorserveasparalleltalkdependingonwhetherornotthechildresponds.Whenteacherscontingentlyrespondtochildren’scommunicativeattempts,includingnonverbalattempts,theyletthechildknowthattheyvaluethechildasacommunicativepartner,therebyincreasingtheoddsthatthechildwillinitiatemorecommunication.Alongthesamelines,ateachermaymapthechildren’sactionsandencouragechildrentousewhatevervocalspeechtheyhaveandthenexpandontheirattempts.Forexample,ifachildlooksataballonashelfandsays“ba,”theteacherwouldsay,“Ball.Youwanttheball”andtheneithergettheballforthechildorgivethechildpermissiontogoandgetit.Similarly,achildmaypointtothebowlofpeasonthelunchtableandtheteachermaysay,“Oh,youwantpeas?”andpassthebowltothechild.Inbothoftheseexamples,theteacherreadsthechildren’scuesandrespondscontingently.

Page 10: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

HowDoesThisLookinPractice?ThefollowingexampleshowsateacherinteractingwithachildatthewatertablewhileaddressingindicatorsintheInstructionalSupportdomain.NoticethattheteacherembedsinteractionsinInstructionalSupporteventhoughthechildusesverylittleorallanguage.

Andreaisatthewatertablepouringwaterfromaone-cupcontainertoothercontainersofdifferingsizes.Theteacherusesparalleltalksaying,“Iseeyouarepouringwater.”Shethenasks,“Whichcontainerdoyouthinkwillholdmorewater?”(AnalysisandReasoning).Andreapointstothesmallercontainerandtheteachersays,“Let’sseewhathappens.”Andreapoursthewaterintothecontaineranditoverflows.Theteachersays,“Hmm,therewastoomuchwater.Itoverflowed.Thatmeansthatthewaterspilledoverthetopofthecontainer(AdvancedLanguage).Whatdoyouthinkwillhappenifyoupouritintotheothercontainer?”(PromptingThoughtProcessesandPrediction).Andreascoopsthewaterintotheothercontainerandexcitedlypointstoshowthatthereisroomatthetopformorewater.Theteachersays,“Sothisoneholdsmorewaterthantheotherone.Iwonderwhy?”(AnalysisandReasoning).Andreaholdsupthetwodifferentcontainersandsays,“B.”Theteachersays,“Yes.Thesecondcontainerisbigger.That’swhyitholdsmorewater.Goodthinking.”(RepetitionandExtension,ProvidingInformation).

Being“Penalized”BecauseofChildren’sBehaviorSometeachersareconcernedthatthebehaviorsofstudentswithIEPs,IFSPs,orBehavioralInterventionPlans(BIPs)maybringdowntheCLASSscores.However,inmostcasesthesebehaviorswillnotimpactthescorebecausetheCLASSmeasurestheaverageexperienceoftheaveragechildintheclassroom.Ifoneortwochildrenactuporaredefiant,itisunlikelytoinfluencethescore.Ontheotherhand,ifthebehaviordisruptsclassroomactivitiesandupsetstheotherchildren,itmayinfluencethescore.Iftheteachertakesalotoftimeawayfrominstructiontoaddressthesebehaviors,itwillimpactthecodeforBehaviorManagement.HighlevelsofproblembehaviormayaffectInstructionalLearningFormatsaswellasProductivity.Ateacherwhospendsasignificantamountoftimedealingwithmisbehaviorhaslesstimetofacilitateactivitiesandmaynotalwaysprovidechildrenwithsomethingtodo.Itisimportanttorecognizethattypicallydevelopingchildrenandchildrenwhoareat-riskforschoolfailuremayalsoengageindisruptivebehavior.

Page 11: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

KeepinmindthattheCLASStoolprovidesanobjectivemeasureofwhatishappeninginaclassroomduringtheobservationperiod;itisnotintendedtoblameteachersforchildren’sbehaviors.Onthecontrary,observerscanusethedatacollectedduringanobservationasaguideforplanningprofessionaldevelopmenttosupportteachers’workwithallchildren.TheCLASSManualrecommendsfourconsecutiveobservationcyclesbecauseobservingmultiplecyclesallowstheobservertohavearepresentativesnapshotofinteractionsintheclassroom.Anobservermayseesomeproblembehaviorduringthefirstcycle,butseenoevidenceinsubsequentcycles.CantheCLASSBeUsedtoCodeSelf-ContainedSpecialEducationClassrooms?Differentlocalitiesprovidespecialeducationservicesindifferentways.Somelocalitiesimplementfullinclusion,whichmeansthatallchildren,regardlessoftheirdisability,receivealloftheirspecialeducationservicesinthegeneraleducationsetting.Whereasotherlocalitiesimplementacontinuumofserviceoptionsrangingfromfullinclusionatoneendofthecontinuumtoeducationinself-containedspecialeducationclassroomsattheotherendofthecontinuum.TheIndividualswithDisabilitiesEducationAct(IDEA)doesnotincludealegaldefinitionofself-containedclassrooms,callinginsteadforeducatingstudentswithdisabilitiesintheLeastRestrictiveEnvironment(LRE)(IDEA,2004).Thelackofafederaldefinitionleavesstatestodeterminetheirowndefinition,resultinginvariationsinhowthistermisapplied.Inmanystates,aclassroomisconsideredtobeself-containedifallofthechildrenintheroomhaveanIEPorIFSP.However,otherstatesandlocalitieshavedifferentinterpretations.Forexample,theStateofArizonadescribesaself-containedclassroomasone“inwhichmorethan50%ofthechildrenhaveidentifiedspecialneedsandarereceivingservicesthroughanIEP/IFSP.”Duetothesetypesofdifferences,thefocusshouldbeonhowtheCLASScanbestbeusedinclassroomsthatcontainalargepercentageofchildrenwithIEPSorIFSPs,ratherthanfocusontheterminologyusedtodescribetheclassrooms.Thenextsectioncontainsasetofrecommendationsforcodinginthesetypesofsettings.RecommendationsforCodinginClassroomsthatContainaLargePercentageofStudentswithIEPsorIFSPs

1. Observersshouldhaveabackgroundinspecialeducation.

Page 12: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

2. Observersshouldbrieflytalkwiththeteacheroradministratortolearnaboutanyspecialcircumstancestheyshouldtakeinaccountwhencoding(e.g.typesofdisabilities,alternativeoraugmentativecommunicationsystemsinuse,behaviorinterventionplans).Thesecircumstanceswouldnotaltercodes,butratherwouldprovidecontexttohelptheobserverunderstandthenuancesofthebehaviorstheyobserve.

3. FollowtheCLASSprotocolasdescribedinthemanual;donotmakeexceptionsbecausechildrenhaveIEPsorIFSPs.

4. UsetheCLASStoolthatcorrespondstothechronologicalageofthemajorityofthechildrenintheclassroom.Thereissomethoughtthattheobservershouldusetheagelevelthatcorrespondstothechildren’sdevelopmentallevel.However,thisisnotourrecommendation.Observersarenotprivytoinformationaboutchildren’sdevelopmentallevels,soitwouldnotbefeasibletomakeadjustments.Furthermore,justasweseeawidevariationinskilllevelamongchildrenwhodon’treceivespecialeducationservices,wealsoseeawidevariationinskilllevelamongchildreninself-containedclassrooms.Forexample,aclassroommayserveachildwithautismwhohasgoodcognition,yethassignificantneedsinsocialskillsandlanguage.Thischildmayplaysidebysidewithapeerwhohasseverephysicallimitations,butwhoselanguageskillsaredevelopmentallyappropriate.

SummaryThetypesofteacher-childinteractionsmeasuredbytheCLASSarecriticalforallchildren.Indeed,werespectfullysuggestthattheCLASSdescribeswhateffectivespecialeducationteachersroutinelydointheirclassrooms.Indeed,preliminarydatafromtheStateofArizonasuggeststhattheCLASStoolmaybeusedinself-containedpreschoolclassroomsthatservealargepercentageofchildrenwhohaveIEPsorIFSPs(Thisdatawillbesharedattheendofthispaper.)Werecommendthatanobserverwhoiscollectingdatainaclassroomthatservesalargepercentageofchildrenwithdisabilitieshaveabackgroundinspecialeducationinordertounderstandthecontextinwhichtheinteractionstakeplace.JustasaCLASSobserverwhoiscollectingdatainaclassroomforduallanguagelearnersmustunderstandthelanguagesbeingspoken,theobserverinthistypeofclassroomshouldunderstandhowtointerpretandcodethetypesofinteractionsthatmayoccurduringtheobservationperiod.WerecommendthatanobserverwhoknowsthatthemajorityofchildrenintheclassroomhaveanIEPorIFSPgatherinformationabouttheneedsofthechildren;

Page 13: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

learningaboutadaptationssuchasalternativemodesofcommunicationandbehaviorsthatmayinterferewithlearning.Ideally,theobservershouldspendaseveralminutespriorintheroompriortotheformalstartoftheobservationtoallowthechildrentogetusedtotheirpresence.Somestudentswithdisabilitiesmaybeundulydistractedbyunfamiliaradultsintheclassroomandtherebypreventtheobserverfromseeingtypicalinteractions.Duringthistime,theobservermaywatchhowthechildreninteractwitheachotherandcommunicatetheirneeds.Theobservershouldalsonotechildbehaviorsthatsuggesttheyfeelcomfortable.CantheCLASSBeUsedtoCodeClassroomsthatIncludeofChildrenwithLimitedVerbalCommunication?ItisimportanttorecognizethattheCLASSmeasurestheefficacyofteacher-studentinteractions,includingbothverbalandnonverbalbehaviors.Observersmayhavequestionsabouthowtocodeinteractionsbetweenadultsandchildrenwhenchildrenhavelimitedornovocalspeech.Thefollowingsectionincludesinformationaboutthekindsofnonverbalinteractionsanobservermayseeforeachdimension.Asalways,observersshouldnotechildren’sresponsestoteachers,factoringinverbalandnon-verbalexchanges.PositiveClimateAlloftheindicatorsforPositiveClimatemaybenotedbyobservingnon-verbalinteractions.Withtheexceptionofthebehavioralmarkersofsocialconversation(Relationships)andrespectfullanguage(Respect),alloftheotherbehavioralmarkersmaybenotedintheabsenceofvocalspeechonthepartofthechild.Anobservermayseeateacherandchildsittingonthefloorplayingwithoneanother(closephysicalproximityandsharedactivities).Inadditiontolaughingorsmiling,childrenwithwell-developedspeechmayanimatedlytalkwiththeteacheraboutwhattheyaredoingasawayofdemonstratingtheconnectionbetweenthetwo.Incontrast,achildwithlimitedspeechismorelikelytosimplysmile,laughorshowenthusiasmviafacialexpressionandgestures.NegativeClimateWhilemanyoftheindicatorsandbehavioralmarkersthatdefineNegativeClimateareexhibitedbyverbalspeech(harshvoice,yelling,threats,sarcastictoneofvoice),NegativeClimatemaybeconveyedthoughnon-verbalinteractions.Forexample,peeraggression(negativeaffect)mayormaynotbeaccompaniedbyverbalizations,

Page 14: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

asachildmaypinchorshoveanotherchildwithoutsayinganything.Similarly,achildmaytaketoysawayfromanotherchild(disrespect/teasing).Finally,afightbetweenpeersmayalsooccurwithoutchildrensayinganything.TeacherSensitivityBydefinition,TeacherSensitivitylooksathowteachersrespondtochildren’sverbalandnonverbalcues.Teacherswhoareawareofchildren’sneedsnoticewhenachildhasnotstartedworkingonanactivityorappearstobeupset.Ateachermayseeachildlookawayorpullathissleevewhenaskedaquestionthatistoodifficultandofferadditionalsupporttohelpthechildbesuccessful.Typicallydevelopingchildrenmayshowthattheyarecomfortablewiththeirteacherbycallingtheteacher’sname,askingtheteacherto“Watchme!”orvolunteeringtoanswerquestionsduringclassactivities.Achildwithoutvocalspeechmaydisplaythislevelofcomfortbyapproachingtheteacher,gettingtheteacher’sattentionbytouchingtheteacheronthearmorgentlypullingontheteacher’ssleeve.Insteadofcallingouttheanswertoaquestion,thechildmaysign,pointtoaphysicalobjectintheclassroomorapictureontheirpicturecommunicationsystem.RegardforStudentPerspectivesAlthoughthefirstthreeindicatorsinthisdimension(e.g.,Flexibility&StudentFocus,SupportforAutonomy&Leadership,andStudentExpression)directlymeasurethethingsthatteachersdotopromotechildren’sinterests,motivations,andpointsofview,observersshouldstillbeonthelookoutforwaysthattheteacheracknowledgesandbuildsonchildren’sinterests.Forexample,ateachermaynoticeseveralchildrenwatchingladybugsflyingaroundtheplaygroundanddecidetoreadEricCarle’sTheGrouchyLadybugwhentheygoinsideinsteadofthebookshehadplannedtoread.Alongthesamelines,theteacherasksthechildrentodecidewheretheywillplayduringcentersandacceptseyegazeorpointingtopicturecardstoindicatepreference.Ateachermayalsogivechildrenmoretimetoformulateresponsesorhavethempointtopicturevocabularycardstosharetheirideas.Forexample,afterfinishingastoryaboutalittlegirlwholostherpuppy,ateachermayask,“Howdidthegirlfeelwhenshecouldn’tfindherpuppy?”andwaitwhileachildwhousesanaugmentativecommunicationdevicelocatesthepictureof“sad.”Shemightthenfollowupbysaying,“Yes,shefeltsad.Whatmakesyoufeelsad?”andagainwaitforthechildtoformulateresponse.”

Page 15: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

BehaviorManagementAsnotedintheearliersectiononDimensionLevelConsiderations,effectiveteachersmonitorthebehaviorofallofthechildrenintheclassroom.Teachersmustbeparticularlyawareofindicationsthatachildwithlimitedcommunicationskillsishavingdifficultyandrespondquicklytoavertescalationofproblembehavior.Teachersneedtounderstandthatchildrenwhohavedifficultycommunicatingtheirwantsandneedsmayexhibitchallengingbehaviors.Ratherthanoverreactingtothesebehaviors,teachersneedtoidentifytheunderlyingfunctionofthebehaviorandrespondaccordingly.Forexample,achildmayhavedifficultycompletingapuzzleandthrowapieceoutoffrustration.Theteachermayrespondbysaying,“Thatisaprettyhardpuzzle.Wouldyoulikemetohelpyouwithit?”andthenteachthechildamoreappropriatewaytoexpresshisfrustrationbyteachingthechildthesignforhelp.ProductivityProductivitymeasureshowwellteachersmanageinstructionaltimeandroutinesintheclassroom.TheindicatorsofMaximizingLearningTimeandPreparationlookatwhetherornotteachersplanactivitiesandprovideinstructionforthechildren.Theextenttowhichchildrenunderstandtheroutinesintheclassroommaybeobservedthroughtheirnon-verbalinteractions.Forexample,duringmealtime,dothechildrenservethemselvesfoodandthenpassthebowltothechildnexttothemordotheyleavethebowlsittingonthetable?Similarly,attheendofthemeal,dothechildrenautomaticallycleanuptheirplaceatthetableandgotothesinktobrushtheirteethordotheywaitfortheteachertotellthemwhattodo?InstructionalLearningFormatsThedimensionofInstructionalLearningFormatslooksatwhatteachersdotodrawchildrenintoactivitiesandhelpthemlearn.Whencodingthisdimensionwhileobservingchildrenwhohavelimitedvocalspeech,theobservershouldaccountforhowthechildrendisplayinterestandwhetherornottheteacherattendstothesecommunications.Whenateacherasksaquestiontoexpandthechildren’sinvolvement,doestheteachernoteachild’snonverbalcommunicationandbuilduponthechild’scommunicationtokeepthechild’sinterest?Ordoestheteacheracknowledgethecommunicationandthenmoveontosomethingelse?Similarly,doesateacherusealternatemodesofcommunicationsuchassign,picturesortangiblematerialstoengagethechildren?

Page 16: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

ConceptDevelopmentSomeobserversbelievethatitisnotpossibletomeasureConceptDevelopmentinclassroomswherechildrenwithlittletonoverbalcommunication.However,thedefinitionofthisdimensionstatesthatConceptDevelopment“measurestheteacher’suseofinstructionaldiscussionsandactivitiestopromotestudents’higher-orderthinkingskillsandcognition.”Thismeansthattheobserverfocuseshisorherattentiononwhattheteacherdoestopromotehigherorderthinkingandthennoteshowthechildrenrespond.Teacherscanengagethechildrenininteractionsthatexemplifyeachoftheindicatorsofthisdimension(e.g.,AnalysisandReasoning,Creating,Integration,andConnectionstotheRealWorld).However,thechildren’sresponsesmaylookdifferentbasedontheirmodesofcommunication.Ateachermayaskchildrentoclassifypicturesoffruitsandvegetables,butinsteadofhavingthechildrenverballytellherwhatcategoryeachpicturefallsinto,askthechildrentosortthepicturesontoalargepieceofpaper,placingfruitsononesideandvegetablesontheother.Childrenmayalsousealternativemodesofcommunicatingsuchaspointingorcomputergeneratedvoiceoutputtoindicatetheirresponse.Itshouldbenotedthattheactivitymightbemodifiedtomeetachild’sdevelopmentallevel.QualityofFeedbackJustasConceptDevelopmentfocusesontheteacher’sinteractionswiththechildren,sotoo,doesQualityofFeedback.AsnotedinthesectiononDimensionLevelConsiderations,someresearch-basedstrategiesdesignedspecificallyforusewithchildrenwithdisabilities(e.g.,thesystemofleastprompts;Woleryetal.,1992)utilizescaffoldingasaprimarymeansofinstruction.AlthoughweoftenthinkaboutFeedbackLoopsasoccurringwithinthecontextofaconversation,FeedbackLoopscanoccurwithoutachildvocalizing.Anexampleofanon-verbalFeedbackLoopfollows:

Antonioisworkingonapuzzlethatdisplaysapictureofthebeach.Thepuzzleshowsthesand,thewater,andthebluesky.Antoniopicksupalightbluepuzzlepiecethatcontainsabitofcloudonitandtriesseveraltimestofigureoutwhereitfits.Histeachernoticeshiseffortsandsays,“That’satrickyone.Wouldyoulikemetohelpyou?”Antonionodshisheadtoindicateyes.Teacher:“Lookatthecolorofyourpuzzlepiece?Whatcolorisit?”Antoniosignsthecolorblue.

Page 17: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

Teacher:“That’sright.Itisblue.Wheredoyouseeblueonthispuzzle?”Antoniopointstotheoceanandthentriestoplacethepieceinthatsectionofthepuzzle.Teacher:“Theoceanisblue,sothat’sagoodtry.Butlookagaintoseeiftheblueinyourpiecematchestheblueoftheocean.”Antonioputsthepiecenexttotheoceanandshakeshishead“No.”Teacher:“Goodobservation.Yourblueislighterthantheblueocean.Canyoufindsomeplacewithalighterblue?”Antonioscansthepuzzleandplacesthepieceatthetopofthepuzzle,butlooksfrustratedwhenitdoesn’tfit.Teacher:“Youareclose,butlookatyourpieceagain.Whatisdifferentaboutit?”Antonioshrugshisshoulderstoindicatehedoesn’tknow.Teacher:“Lookatthatwhite.It’sapartofacloud.Doyouseetherestofacloud?”Antonioscansthetoppartofthepuzzleandplaceshispiecewhereitbelongs.Teacher:“Nicework,Antonio.Youmatchedthelightblueskywiththecloud.Youreallyworkedhardonthat!

Teacherscanprovideinformationandofferencouragementandaffirmationregardlessofachild’slinguisticcapabilities.TheindicatorinthisdimensionthatisprobablymostdifficulttomeasureisthatofPromptingThoughtProcesses.Again,theobservershouldrecordhowthechildrenrespond.Forexample,duringcalendartime,theteachermayaskachildtolookattheweatherchartandtelltheclasswhethertherehavebeenmoresunnydaysormorecloudydaysthatmonth.Thechildmayscanthechartandpointtothepictureofthesun.Theteachermayask,“Howdoyouknowthattherehavebeenmoresunnydays?”Thechildmaypointtothecolumnofthesunnydaysandrunhishandupthecolumntoshowthattherearemoreentriesonthesunnycolumnthanthereareonthecloudycolumnonthechart.LanguageModelingThefirsttwoindicators,FrequentConversationandOpen-endedQuestions,focusonverbalinteractions.Nonetheless,itisimportanttorecognizethatateacherandchildmayhavebackandforthexchangesinwhichtheteacherusesvocalspeechandthechildusesanalternativeoraugmentativecommunicationsystem.Inaddition,theymayengageinbackandforthexchangesusingAmericanSignLanguage.Teacherswhorespondtochildren’scommunicativeattemptsbetheyvocal,gestural,usingpictures,pointing,orsign,validatechildren’scommunication,therebysupporting

Page 18: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

childrenintheireffortstoeitherinitiateorrespondtocommunicationinthefuture.Considerthefollowingillustration:

Theteacheraskswhowouldliketopickoutthenextsongtheywillsingduringmorninggreeting.Kylieraisesherhandandherteachersays,“Whichsongwouldyoulikeustosing?”ShewaitswhileKyliepausesandsaysthe/t/sound.Herteachersays,“Oh,wouldyoulikeustosignTwinkle-twinkleLittleStar?”Kylienodshappily.TheteacheracknowledgesheraffirmationandleadstheclassinarousingrenditionofTwinkle-twinkleLittleStar.

Kylienodshappilyandtheclassstartstosing.

Theremainingindicators,RepetitionandExtension,SelfandParallelTalk,andAdvancedLanguageareappropriateforallchildren.RepetitionandExtensioncanbeparticularlysalientforchildrenwithlimitedspeechastheteacheracknowledgestheirutterancesandrecaststhemintoexpandedforms.Ateachermaytellachildwhomakesa“vroom-vroom”kindofnoisetorequesttoplaywithatruck,mightsay,“That’satruck.Theymakea“vroom”sound,buttheyarecalledtrucks.”Observersshouldbeawarethatadvancedlanguageforachildwithlimitedtonovocalspeechmightbedifferentfromthatforchildrenwithmoreadvancedcommunicativeskills.Forexample,achildwithacognitivedisabilitymaybelearningbasiccolors(red,blue,green)whileherpeersarelearningmoreadvancedcolors(lavender,turquoise,coral).AreThereClassroomsthatShouldNotBeObservedwiththeCLASS?SomeobserversaskwhetherornottheCLASSisappropriateforuseinself-containedspecialeducationclassroomswhereallofthechildrenhaveIEPsorIFSPs.However,abetterquestionmaybe,"Whatkindsoflearning/developmentalneedsdothechildrenintheclassroomhave?"Basedonthestatedefinitionofself-contained,aclassroommayenrollasufficientnumberofchildrenwithspeechandlanguagedelaysthatitisconsideredtobeaself-containedclassroom.Notobservinginthissituationwouldbeamisstepbecausemanyofthesechildrenareconsideredtobeatriskforschoolfailure.Childrenwhofitthislabelareoftenthechildrenwhobenefitthemostfrombeinginwarm,supportive,structuredenvironmentswhereteachershaveclearandconsistentbehavioralexpectations.Incontrast,aclassroommayenrollafewchildrenwithsignificantdisabilities(e.g.,severecognitivedisabilitiesorsevereautism).IfonlyafewchildrenwithIEPsofIFSPshavesignificantneeds,thentheCLASSisstillappropriatebecausetheCLASSmeasures

Page 19: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

theaverageexperienceoftheaveragechild.However,insituationswherealargenumberofchildrenhavemoresignificantneedsthatimpactcognitionandcommunication(bothverbalandnonverbal),thantheCLASSmaynotbetheappropriatetoolforevaluation,butisstillappropriateasatoolforprofessionaldevelopment.DatafromSpecialEducationClassroomsTogaininsightontheuseoftheCLASSinself-containedclassrooms,wepresentdatacollectedbyArizona’sQualityFirstprogram,whichpartnerswithearlycareprovidersthroughoutthestatetoimprovethequalityofearlyeducation.TheycollectedPre-KCLASSdatainclassroomswheremorethan50%ofthestudentsareonanIEP/IFSP,whichconformstoArizona’sdefinitionofaself-containedclassroom.Thechildrenintheseclassroomshaveawiderangeofdisabilities.Althoughthenumberofclassroomswherethedatawascollectedissmall(n=81),thetrendsnoteddemonstratethatthetoolaccuratelycapturesclassroominteractionsatorabovethelevelsofclassroomswithamajorityoftypicallydevelopingchildren.WewouldliketothankourcolleaguesattheArizonaDepartmentofEducationandSouthwestHumanDevelopmentforsharingthisinformationwithusandfortheirthoughtfulcontributionstothispaper.Arizona’sQualityFirstprogramhascollectedpre-KCLASS®datafromclassroomswheremorethan50%ofthestudentsareonanIEP/IFSP,whichareconsidered“self-contained.”Althoughthenumberofclassroomswherethedatawascollectedissmall(n=81),thetrendsnoteddemonstratethatthetoolaccuratelycapturesclassroominteractionsatorabovethelevelsofclassroomswithamajorityoftypicallydevelopingstudents.

CLASSDomainAverageScoresbyProgramSites

AverageEmotionalSupport

AverageClassroom

Organization

AverageInstructional

SupportSelf---ContainedClassrooms 6.3 6.1 2.0NValue(TotalNumberofSelf---ContainedClassroomsoutof41ProgramSites)

81

81

81

Non---Self---ContainedClassrooms 6.4 6.0 2.1

NValue(TotalNumberofNon---Self---ContainedClassroomsoutof190ProgramSites)

302

302

302

Page 20: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

CLASSDimensionsAverageScoresbyProgramSites

AveragePositiveClimate

AverageNegativeClimate

AverageTeacherSensitivity

AverageRegardfor

StudentPerspectives

AverageBehaviorManagement

AverageProductivity

Average

InstructionalLearningFormats

AverageConceptDevelopment

AverageQualityofFeedback

AverageLanguageModeling

Self---ContainedClassroomsCLASSAveragesbyProgramSites

6.3

1.1

6.4

5.7

6.4

6.4

5.5

1.7

1.7

2.5

NValue(TotalNumberofSelf---ContainedClassroomsoutof41ProgramSites)

81

81

81

81

81

81

81

81

81

81

Non---Self---ContainedClassroomsCLASSAveragesbyProgramSites

6.3

1.1

6.4

5.9

6.2

6.3

5.5

1.9

1.7

2.7

NValue(TotalNumberofNon---Self---ContainedClassroomsoutof190ProgramSites)

302

302

302

302

302

302

302

302

302

302

ProgramTypesandNumberofChildrenEnrolledwithIEP’sandIFSP’satAssessment

NumberofChildrenEnrolledwithIndividualEducationPlansatAssessment

NumberofChildrenEnrolledwithIndividualFamilyServicePlansatAssessment

Self---ContainedClassrooms

701

19

NValue(TotalNumberofSelf---ContainedClassroomsoutof41ProgramSites)

81

81

Non---Self---ContainedClassrooms

772

2

NValue(TotalNumberofNon---Self---ContainedClassroomsoutof190ProgramSites)

302

302

Cooper,J.O.,Heron,T.E.,&Heward,W.L.(2007).Appliedbehavioranalysis(2nd

Edition).UpperSaddleRiver,N.J.:PearsonMerrillPrenticeHall.

Page 21: D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D....D. Sarah Hadden, Ph.D. Amy E. Mountz, M.Ed. Recommendations for Using the CLASS in Inclusive Early Childhood Programs, Birth-Age 8 This paper examines key

Vygotsky,L.S.(1978).Themindinsociety:Thedevelopmentofhigherpsychologicalprocesses.Cambridge,MA.HarvardUniversityPress.

Wolery,M.,Ault,M.J.,&Doyle,P.M.(1992)Teachingstudentswithmoderatetoseveredisabilities:Useofresponsepromptingstrategies.NewYork:Longman.


Recommended