RTCA SC-214 / EUROCAE WG-78
Advanced Data Communication
Baseline 2 Standards
ICAO NAT – PBCS Workshop, Feb 2013
Presented by Jerome CONDIS
RTCA SC-214 / EUROCAE WG-78 Co-chair
1 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013
Overall context
2
SC214/WG78 mission
Deliver Safety Performance Requirements (SPR) and Interoperability requirements (Interop) for Advanced Data Link Air Traffic Services (ATS) to support
NextGen
SESAR
Future oceanic/remote operations
ICAO GANP (Baseline 2 pertains to ICAO Block 1 for B1-15 Improved airport operations & B1-40 improved traffic synchronization and TBO)
Define data link services and applications independent, to the maximum extent practical, from the underlying network technology
Support implementation of aircraft data comm systems that will operate in both continental and oceanic environments (i.e. convergent SPR/Interop Standards), for all types of airspaces (Airport, TMA, domestic en-route & oceanic en-route)
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
Scope (services)
3
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
FIS
AD
S-C
CP
DL
CC
MA
DLIC
ACM
AMC
CRD
DCL
D-TAXI
4DTRAD
D-OTIS
IER
Convergent SPR
Baseline 2
Current Oceanic SPR
ED122/D0306
FIS
AD
S-C
CP
DL
CA
FN
DLIC
CE, CT, TC
PR
Current Domestic SPR
ED120/D0290
FIS
AD
S-C
CP
DL
CC
MA
DLIC
ACM
AMC
ACL
DCL
FLIPINT
D-ATIS
Exclu
de
dfro
mA
TN
B1
(SE
S D
LS
IR)
D-HZWX
D-RVR
CPDLC for ITP
CPDLC for FIM & ITP
CRD
OCL
PR IER
Deliverables (1/2)
4
Supporting current operations
Change 1 to ED122/DO306 (Oceanic SPR)
ITP messages and procedures
Rev A of ED154/DO305 (Mixed Interop ATN & FANS-1/A) and
Change 1 to ED110B/DO280B (ATN B1 Interop)
Seamless transfers between FANS 1/A and ATN B1 airspaces
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
2010 2011 2012 2013
Change 1 to ED122/DO306
Dec 2010
Rev A of ED154/DO305
Jun 2012
Change 1 to ED110B/DO280B
Jun 2013
Deliverables (2/2)
5
Baseline 2 standards
Advanced ATS Data Communication SPR
Safety and Performance Requirements independent from technology
Advanced ATS Data Communication Interop Via ATN
Interoperability Requirements (including backwards compatibility with B1)
Advanced ATS Data Communication Interop Via a Mix of ATN and FANS-1/A
Interoperability Requirements supporting FANS 1/A aircraft in B2 airspace and seamless transfers between FANS 1/A & ATN ATC Centers
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
2010 2011 2012 2013
Draft V0.H (Baseline for Validation)
Feb 2010
Draft v0.I (updated version)
Feb 2012
v1
Mar 2014
CPDLC Msg Set
6
Starting from PANS ATM (ICAO Doc 4444) Ed 15th
New CPDLC message elements created and some existing CPDLC message elements modified to support new ATS Data Link services, e.g.
4DTRAD (4D Trajectory exchanges)
D-TAXI (Taxi route clearances and information)
Departure Clearance (DCL)
Oceanic Clearance (OCL)
CPDLC for In Trail Procedure (ITP)
CPDLC for Flight Interval Management (FIM)
Message set enriched to encompass lessons learnt from current operations (e.g. new message elements defined as standardize Free Text or deletion of unused messages as in GOLD v1)
To ensure that Baseline 2 CPDLC Message Set will fulfill the operational needs and support worldwide ATS Datalink operations
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
CPDLC Msg Set
7
WG78/SC214 effort for rationalization
Prompted by OPLINKP in 2010, assessment of the operational need for each message, leading to message deletions, revisions and additions
Relying on an operational assessment
Analysis coordinated by WG78/SC214 with wide inputs from
Pilots
Human factors specialists
Controllers (Eurocontrol, FAA, ISAVIA acting as NAT representative, NATS, Nav Canada, Airways New Zealand, Air Service Australia…)
ANSPs representatives (taking credit from both FANS 1/A and ATN B1 operations)
Ground systems specialists, and
Aircraft manufacturers
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
CPDLC Msg Set
8
WG78 / SC214 closely coordinated with ICAO OPLINKP Initiated at OPLINKP-WG/WHL 1 in October 2010
Iterative exchanges have occurred to support validation and rationalization of the CPDLC message set
OPLINKP-WG/WHL 2 (May 2011) and WHL 3 (Oct 2011) Initial coordination about the CPDLC message set assessment
OPLINKP-WG/WHL 4 (Mar 2012) Full review of a “redline” version of the message set
Apr 2012 - May 2012 1st review of proposed CPDLC message set by ICAO OPLINKP member states and their representatives
Comments received from AENA (Spain), ENAV (Italy), Federal Aviation Administration (USA), NavCanada (Canada), Naviair (Denmark) and industry (e.g., SESAR, Airbus, Boeing)
ATNS (South Africa) and DECEA (Brazil) responded without recommending any changes
OPLINKP-WG/WHL 5 (Sep 2012) Further updates of CPDLC message set according to comments.
Nov 2012 – Jan 2013 2nd review of updated CPDLC message set by ICAO OPLINKP member states and their representatives
Comments received from NATS (UK), ATNS (South Africa), NavCanada (Canada) and industry
OPLINKP-WG/WHL 6 (Mar 2013) Consolidation of CPDLC message set according to comments
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
CPDLC Msg Set
9 ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
227 UM ----------------
245 UM
Including
18 Reserved
117 DM -----------------
118 DM
Including
1 Reserved
271 UM --------------------
56 New messages
PANS ATM Messages
40 modified
12 Not required
18 Reserved
135 DM --------------------
PANS ATM Messages
18 Replaced
7 not required
1 Reserved
255 UM ---------------------
90 New Messages
PANS ATM Messages
77 replaced
59 not required
19 Reserved
114 DM ---------------------
40 New Messages
PANS ATM Messages
33 replaced
39 not required
1 Reserved
Latest draft (Jan 2013) Draft v0.H (Feb 2010) Doc 4444 Ed. 15th
With about the
same total
number of
messages, the
proposed
CPDLC message
set maintains the
current
capabilities and
supports new
ones
ADS-C definition
10
WG78/SC214 effort for convergence
Maintaining services offered by FANS 1/A ADS-C, while
considering lessons learnt
Introducing new capabilities to support
advanced Trajectory Based Operations
ADS-C Extended Projected Profile
ETAmin-max
New ADS-C events
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
• Containing FMS active Flight
Plan data
• 1 to 128 waypoints with
predictions, and
• Some aircraft information
(gross weight, speed
schedule…)
• Replacing FANS 1/A
Intermediate Projected
Intent report
• Provides early and latest
ETA on a given waypoint
• Changes relative to last
downlinked value • Waypoint change
• Speed change
• EPP change
• FOM change
• Level change
• Changes relative to fixed
threshold(s) • Lateral deviation
• Vertical rate deviation
• Level range deviation
• Vertical clearance deviation
• Aircraft out of vertical
boundaries
• Speed range deviation
RCP/RSP
in Baseline 2
11
SC214/WG78 Operational Performance Assessment (OPA) RCP for CPDLC, RSP for ADS-C and RIP for FIS
Communication Transaction Time Maximum transaction time
Nominal transaction time (95%)
Continuity, Availability and Integrity
Allocations to human and technical ATM/CNS elements (i.e. the aircraft system, aircraft operator, ATS Provider and Air-Ground Communications Service Provider), statistically for Transaction Time
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
CPDLC
RCP120 and RCP-DCL
RCP 240 and RCP400
ADS-C
RSP120
RSP180 and RSP400
FIS
RIP-OTR, RIP180 and
RIP400
New
Reused or
derived from
DO306/ED12
2
RCP/RSP
in Baseline 2
12 ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
RCP communication Transaction Time,
99.9% Continuity and 95% Probability
RCP Specification RCP120 RCP-DCL
Transaction Time
Parameter
ET (sec)
C=99.9%
TT (sec)
P=95%
ET (sec)
C=99.9%
TT (sec)
P=95%
Transaction Time 120 57 See Note See Note
RCP Time Allocations
Initiator 30 13 See Note See Note
TRN 100 48 See Note See Note
TRN Time Allocations
Responder 88 38 See Note See Note
RCTP 32 18 See Note See Note
RCTP Allocations
ATSP 23 12 See Note See Note
ATSU 14 6 See Note See Note
ACSP 18 8 See Note See Note
Aircraft 23 10 See Note See Note
Notes
Note: Values are to be specified by each State
RCP/RSP
in Baseline 2
13 ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
RSP Specification RSP120
Single/1st Periodic/Baseline report
Transaction Time
Parameter
OT (sec)
C=99.9%
DT (sec)
P=95%
Transaction Time 120 52
RSP Time Allocations
Initiator (Controller) 30 13
TRN = RSTP 100 47
TRN = RSTP Time Allocations
ATSP 23 12
ATSU 14 6
ACSP 18 8
Aircraft 95 41
RCP/RSP
in Baseline 2
14 ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
RSP communication Transaction Time and Continuity
RSP Specification RSP180D
Next Periodic/Event report
RSP400D
Next Periodic/ Event report
Transaction Time
Parameter
OT (sec)
C=99.9%
DT (sec)
P=95%
OT (sec)
C=99.9%
DT (sec)
P=95%
Transaction Time 180 89 400 185
RSTP 180 89 400 185
RSP (RSTP) Time Allocations
ATSU 7 3 35 15
ACSP 157 68 378 164
Aircraft 95 41 95 41
Notes
Note 1.— For the RSP180D/400D specifications (next Periodic/Event report), the
Initiator time has been apportioned to the FMS.
Note 2.— For the RSP180D/400D specifications (Next Periodic/Event report), the
recipient is the controller.
Note 3: The bolded values represent the constraining points in the assumed statistical
distribution. The remaining points are allocated to fit the assumed distribution.
RCP/RSP
in Baseline 2
15 ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
RIP communication Transaction Time,
99.9% Continuity and 95% Probability
RIP Specification RIP180
(Single/1st update report)
RIP400
(Single/1st update report)
Transaction Time
Parameter
TTmax (sec)
C=99.9%
TT95 (sec)
P=95%
TTmax (sec)
C=99.9%
TT (sec)
P=95%
Transaction Time 180 57 400 199
RIP Time Allocations
Initiator (Flight crew) 30 13 30 13
TRN = RITP 175 85 395 195
TRN = RITP Time Allocations
D-HZWX Provider 155 67 155 67
ACSP 32 14 353 153
Aircraft 74 32 74 32
Baseline 2 standards
timeline
16
Next Steps
After 5 years of work, WG78/SC214 on the finish line …
targeting release of Baseline 2 standards by Mar 2014
Two remaining opportunities to provide feedback on the proposed
standards
Apr-May 2013: WG78/SC214 review, based on a consolidated draft of SPR
& Interop documents
Sep-Oct 2013: WG78/SC214 Final Review (FRAC/Open Consultation)
Comments from ALL are more than welcomed !!!
WG78/SC214 website: http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ato/service_units/techops/atc_comms_services/sc214/
Documents to review can be found under the “Current documents” section
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards
CPDLC Msg Set
17
QUESTIONS ?
ICAO NAT - PBCS Feb 2013 WG78/SC214 Baseline 2 Standards