FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSIONWASHbINdC1O9O, 0C A461

THIS ISDTH BGitMI3. JR OF MM

DATE F I LED CNEMA DO.

IV

71

Imiko

lrx fm

TO

OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL

DATE: June 16,

ANALYST:

I. COMMITATEE:

Neil Evm

Alegbuiy Teledyne @11rors &II ftL amCamitee(AT-PAC) (COO14IW?)

Wae G. RAKd Treuumr(Ajvfis 197 -Pfamu&)

Dv# J. OrW(Juanuy 9, 1997 - April 17, 1997)

Riclud R. Roomr(prior to January to 193 m u 8- IUwq

1000 Six PPOF m "

Pibq~aPA 15222

I 1.

The Masyst luaWd1. bWof On" DOps~ I AImI ,od a"$

WW lio" *a4 be wsI h i.0sL(~i~u 4

flu. lieda re tMa M"c 27, 19"7, by cafSsimW199 Yew fMd Ropet a 1uthag paod.O Tb. owwldd 4uud mw~o ofdie odimflung Mhe avulop was posm Arked

adtkws t ftU Fedmi Election conmuio a1325 KStwst, NW, W20643. (Aflacmmat #S)

-to a

Miwmu

1 of IU,

NEZI O

-I .11M~

-~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - Wtt4~wtftmw

-l IEm -0 -MUM KI WI fLE Fr a m 1m: WU 1

13 SIIT 9 ,mT 'AsrINIrI Uf EUD1IUa'EIl~ MIS1'ST OIn nmmli .11

vo3,.MnICEw N ~ROM FLIm srMuM F minmu*11

HIL IEIRY13

Fma 8AU

to "ww =MRni MU

a's3

a's

tmm

wwU -

ling -3

I vi

3 ~3

12U12uK,to-90

" MK/EA

3/31/96 -$0

U-.

V/31/981 As OF

RK 2

- Page l ot 4

YEARsEND

REPORT NOTICEFDERAL ELECTION COM......ON

PA5Z me no Deceme.r See am

m -o nia0ll paitI IeitessdPA"e 46emmected eeiniues OWdseqreqated towins) =at files a :s-S4 Regata

ftmitteees sheeld sfial the peelmeff label fess the AmhA l'dLIAO Alef the Moeto CetrtleaMS huld be aede 00 00ther

Ireossurers of political comittees eve mespessiblerepete moos filre to do so Is subl64t to *Icisitt..e lilies Ill Ible -e-eto Or uslat aemWlgot MC apiproved 00I gewseed teams f ill beref100

*.3 rut sent registered at eetled ml Ido 10rvmise thep *t be meeri

IARTM3 AND PACS

PAM=U AM MM*

0 /f

yer-nd0/1/97 12 10/Z7 01/31AS

kc@Sb 11/7 - W01M97 152 74

Octobe I - 09

'a

$"/4244M

YEAR-END p3a4

REPORT NOTICEFEDEAL ELECTIN COWMSO

PARTISAND PACS I rant orP A10o

PatyciunIes and PACs (NoncnecemomW me amd Sepra SppidF)afl S Yer-End Repor on January 31,1998.

REGXCERT.MAMUNG VA

IEOt REPORTING-PERUOD* DATE** DA&

MASUNG PMREPRTREPORMG PERIOD* DATE* DAIS

Yw.Ead 12Afl197 - 12/31M9 0113/99~ ~ ip

Ceu ibsi dmoud affix the podl-off idWe ftm the enveklo b h I ofo th iM. fSbe no&d on the label.

PARTIES AND PAC$

July Quaflry 04/1/91 - 06/3W91 07/15M9Octobe Quuay 07/01/98 - 09W3"9 10/15M9 lot" ,Pre-Geneal 10001/96 - 10/14191 10/1191 Ilv2IPost-General 10/1Ism - 11/2319 1210)3M 1231WYear-End 11/24M91- 12/31/91 01/31/99 01131l"

EL MONTHLY FILL

JuneJuly

Fm4kualYaw-End

OI1m 01/31M902/01/"9 - 02/2IiM03001M/ - MOM3104/01/91 - 04f3GW5

060019I -6/0W"

071to" - -ai-IIGO I

OMIM~ WWITh

IMM07/2019OWMb

19on

OVA"1i

05~

*UEXRMPWAw PAC. I

REPO[RT

AprilMay

top*

MOW I v isew *W so

CONFIROAT ION OF NARLUMAu it

SIX~ agP3 ITSM"S lots*88

FEDERAL ELECTION CONNISSIONSHAWN WERTH999 a ST. %weVASHNMt DC 2046SO"I

IDENTIFICATION MUNSRS COWS9?

t%,. REFERENCES YEAREM t@T01foutv IM &2151199?I

TZLECON

Neil Evan

AflgbtyTeledyne Ic, oae lu l s

Nos-ILin of the 1997 Year Ead wu

March20, 1998

Dale G. Raid

1 calle Dale Reid and 1.1 a voice mai inbr, n Wo don trIved the 1997 Year End Rapo. I toldWm toi nduytbqw - -

to avat Pow"nia lep uuCO Al

M"ri 239,19"8

id ft~nuniiiby *bS U unPvloTw

M- 1, i,4m, "i4Sp I at I

wOM-ATPMA

Jeuiazy29s 1996

Federal Ziectios CasLOU1325 K Street e N, W.

.Wuhigtom D. C. 20543

Dear~ SIX t

Zuolosed is the 12197 Year ft4 Moeet 9ez the ,uj

Teledyne Corporation ?@lIts"I tmUs caIt*,

the period 07/01/97 th~ 131,?

N

c'.

27 7"1

It

4'

K

~,.4

3a)of 4

Oa isN omawrap

O1Jtiub I kgft~liv M

Qj~Mmum 51 Yawr~

jJ3hiIMs MM~NWM WVO

) M v M

4L 40 i i~i m b

-w" DWs~kD Fsu' 2 DmWUSODM. Dwh20 1 * )OUW13Ad~ OS D OMMuW

Dl Tsw"e a PS ______ ______

Ql Thomh fey iewt Idbof Ow Gow NOm.0

___inO__ ON" _________

- -Afla I

-~i~ R2~

-1

am&

a

'roll

how kt ws rglved

oHwtd Deavero

OFk*s Classl MallMM

rry POSTMAMUD

o0 esv from ft How c" d Pardst

w-4 Ir.ion

Received" frm snOfEt

Was~nto.MC. 20463

VtRTG4UAL COVT.WS WOW

RELEVANT STATUTE:

SOURCE:

INTERNAL REPORTS.CHECKED:

FEDERAL AGENCIES CHECKED:

L 0ZL5jfQQL AZ

2

2 U.S.C. I 434(aX4XAXiv)

INTERNALLY GENERATED

Rdand Mataah

None

- -f,

U. EI~in~in~hEAL

Based on the Factmuan d Lepi AnalysisAtcmn ,ti Ofie coainm- dod

find vra o lo believ dont th lh Teledyn Iuwhu d ed~IA

Commttee(AT-PAC) and Dalec G. Rdv as usmeam vioAwed 2 U.&C. 4 3X A)l.

............

AILPproved ft01AF - l MCI

Lawrence M. NobleGnfa Counsel

BY:

Associate Oeaeral CoMWDate

AUbMm:

Allegheny Teledyne Ic arpa me d Political Action Committee Factmi ad LO Asb

,~,

w

auMvoai Mu nAL w13mw gUNIw22

zu the matter of

Allegheny Teledyne incorporated,Political Action Comnittee (ATOVAC)and Dal* G. Reid, as teare

NW 3efg~sNO##swa

I, Marjorie V. soso screary of the OkeieRsZ e-Coinission, do hereby certify that an July M6 5

Coinission decided by a vote of 5-0 to tohe the S1iili

actions In No Referrals #0M- 07

~W.

.Tly nlots*~

a.Opn a 11U in MAD RegfTl SIW-7. WI# fb. n ""mraa to bl"M that the Mqm

ACttte ()2.PA) 4 deG.3 a---emw~r vtoatei 2 U.3.C.

1 434 (a) (4) (A) (1w).

c WZ@ri~iV the IPetuakl &a Loga"A1~,a. w~einddLa the wl in.

1@tt te July 10., "to .

4. Take -w tuxtwthe 4eiM, mA e

toewma ftowu& M- 161 -I s

Cft tfaye 3ev *I it*$. lU

Comiselamers Aikis. Zlltotto Na 8ad swThem"s voted .5 5 tmatively for the eGisiin.

Attests

Received In the Meortarit$ FrI.,Circulated to the foission s Mmr.,Deadline for votes I uS

July 10.P onIJuly 1),3*#July 16is 9

lId

r~. -

"S.

"we.

Iz.oat*

FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSION

NO"MIm Fi.Cinb(AT-PAC)

low a nPo t"P1ff1uwA PA 1=22

na dw14 t40L do Fdkmi pEusin

July 22, 199S

RE: MUR 4776Allegheny TeledyneInep

Political Action C -p oomS(A?~)pDale 0. Reid, a trw

111,1m, 11- wpu1 ad tlisi Adiom Cominntee (AT-PAC) (*Conuniue') m~yseibud 2 U.S.C # 4)(XAX~) a roisio of the Federal Election C yspAamuaWd (Oft AM) flwwv, afr cnidrig the cirw ae of this missro

aim ~~t dsaim so ki a. bbadon and closed its file. Tie Fata nis L"I

FACTUA N W ANALY=

RESPONDENT: AquyTd4*m0 mwumPoliiclAs C.--s, (AT-PAC) ma

Dale 0. Red uw V

Th& mat&e was generaed bau m anhmto suaas by 6sw Psi3

Co ~~mmissio ~cmsion") in Onhe mmmiio ema of castla t its ~Wv i1

responsbilities. 2 U.S.C. f 437g(aX(2).

The Federal Election Cmuiga, Act of 1971, a uaened, (the "AWt) mobna

calenda Yewrs in whic no geal chalk is ftkdd Ow m~ me a .lpo

politia cmite must file a yma end repmi cowa* th ld sa) Rud

Docembe 31,*to be filed no latedtm Junmy 31 of theiAIlwiqgauihmw. VSC

J 434(aX4XAXiv). The 1997 Yewr Eud Rqgmt was&a Jimmy 3 1 199. li

Teldyn moprte oiia A&"u uiam (AT-PAC) 61.4 ft*I

&useq 16=52 in rc~ 1U

flauore Urn isawmnt elw~ ~~ytld

V

FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSIONWASHINC1ON. DC A43

THIS ISDX EMOt AW# f- .DATE FILMSD

CNEJIA

4kdn CEM ND*V.

FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSIONWASHINCTON. DC. A03

Date: ,0/7/It

Microfilm

Press

THE ATTACHED MATERIAL IS BEING ADDED TO CLOSED FM Li77 .

I .+l

FEDERAL ELECION COMMISSION999 E Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20463

FIRST GENERAL COUNSEL'S REPORT

FEr. C

..UL ,3 ?:.".

RAD REFERRAL: 9NF.01

DATE ACTIVATED: June 18, 1998STAFF MEMBERS:Kamau PhilbertDeborah Rice

RESPONDENTS: TECO Energy Inc. Employees' PAC andRobin J. Hastings, as treasurer

RAD REFERRAL: 9SNF-03

DATE ACTIVATED: June 18, 1998STAFF MEMBERS:Ruth HeilizerDeborah Rice

RESPONDENTS: Hany S. Truman Club - Federal andLinda Tochterman, as treasurer

RAD REFERRAL: 9SN-07

DATE ACTIVATW. JW -%STAFF MMSSusan LebeauEric Brown

RESPONDENTS.-- Allegheny Teledyne IncorpoatedPolitical Action Committee (AT-PAC) ad

Dale G. Reid, as teasurer

RESPONDENTS:

RELEVANT STATUTE:

SOURCE:

INTERNAL REPORTS CHECKED:

RAD REFERRAL: 9SNF-08

VArIi ACTIVATED: June 18,1991SSTAFF MEMBERS:Mary TaksarEric Brown

North Side Good Government Committee and

Michael Hagan, as treasurer

2 U.S.C. § 434(aX4XAXiv)

INTERNALLY GENERATED

Referral MaterialsDisclosure Reports

FEDERAL AGENCIES CHECKED: None

1. GENERATION OF MATTERS

These matters were generated by four referrals that the Office of the General Counsel

received from the Reports Analysis Division ("RAD"). On March 4,1998, RAD refered TECO

Energy Inc. Employees' PAC and its treasurer based on the failure to timely file th 1997 Mid

Year Report On March 6,1998, RAD referred the Harry S. Tnman Club - Federal nd its

teasU baed on the failure to timely file the 1997 Mid-Year Report. Onis 16, 199M D

there y T y incoporated Political Action

Dale G. Reid, as treasme, based on the failure to timely file the 1997 Ya Fad Repst. On

June 16,1998, RAD-referred the North Side Good Government Commine md Mielm*i am,

as treasurer, based on the failure to timely file the 1997 Mid-Year Report.

11. FACTUAL AND LEGAL ANAILYSES

Based on the Factual and Legal Analysis, Attachment 1, this Office recommends that theCommission find reason to believe that TECO Energy Inc. Employees' PAC and Robin J.

Hastings, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. § 434(a)(4)(AXiv).

Based on the Factual and Legal Analysis, Attachment 2, this Office recommends that the

Commission find reason to believe that the Harry S. Truman Club - Federal and Linda

Tochterman, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. § 4 34(a)(4XA)(iv).

Based on the Factual and Legal Analysis, Attachment 3, this Office recommends that the

Commission find reason to believe that the Allegheny Teledyne Incorporated Political Action-, Committee (AT-PAC) and Dale G. Reid, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. § 4 34(aX4XAXiv).

'DBased on the Factual and Legal Analysis, Attachment 4, this Office recolmendr that theCommission find reason to believe North Side Good Government Committee and

Michael Hagan, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. § 434(aX4XAXiv).

III. DISCUSSION OF CONCIIATION AND CAI

S

6

1~

)

"I

IV. RECOMMENDAIONS

1. a. Open a MUR in RAD Referral 9NF-01.

b. Find reason to believe TECO Enmergy Inc. Employees' PAC and Robin J.Hastings, as treasurer, violated 2 US.C. § 434(aX4XA)(v), ad ant oconciliation prior to a finding of probable cause to believe.

c. Approve the attached Factul and Legal Analysis mad onciloi Agreenm.

2. a. Open a MUR in RAD Referral 9NF-03.

b. Find rewn to believe Harry S. Tnmnu Club - Federal and Limb Todifman,as t , violated 2 U.S.C. § 434(aX4XA)(iv).

c. Approve te atached Factual and Le Analysis.

d. Tdam o fad ie u md e the fl.

3. a. Open a MUR in RAD Relal 98NF-07.

b. Find motn to believe th the Allghn Teledyne I p PAct on Ie (AT-PAC) and Dale G. Reid, as UauM , va 2 U.S.C.§ 434(aX4XA)(iv).

c. Approve te tached Factul mad L A Amlyis.

d. Take no further action mad cloe the file.

4. a. Open a MUR iw RAD Refemi 9SNF-O

b. Find ream to believ tha North Side Good Govennm t camis. mdMichael Hagmi, - treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. § 4 3 4(aX4XA)(iv), mad eater intoconciliation prior to a findin8 of probable cause to believe.

c. Approve the allad Fatual and Legal Analysis and C tonclisti Aummmi.

5. Approve the a letter.

Lawrence M. NobleGeneral Counsel

Date BY:Date I' Lois G. Lri

Associate General Counsel

Attachments:S1. TECO Energy Inc. Employees' PAC Factual and Legal Analysis2. Harry S. Truman Club - Federal Factual and Legal Analysis3. Allegheny Teledyne Incororted Political Action Committee Factual and Legal Aalysis4. North Side Good Government Committee Factual and Legal Analysis5. TECO Energy Inc. Employees' PAC Conciliation Agreement6. North Side Good Government Committee Conciliation Agreement

.. .

v I

BEFORE THE FEDERAL ELECTION COOCIBBION

In the Matter of

TECO Energy Inc. Employees$ PAC andRobin J. Hastings, as treasurer;

Harry S. Truman Club - Federal andLinda Tochterman, as treasurer;

Allegheny Teledyne IncorporatedPolitical Action Committee (AT-PAC)and Dale G. Reid, as treasurer;

North Side Good Government Committeeand Michael Hagan, as treasurer.

RAD Referral*98N- 01

RAD Referral098 -03

RAD Referral#98N-07

e(ua ,71

PAD Referral

ERTFICATION

I, Marjorie W. uons, Secretary of the Federal Election

Commission, do hereby certify that on July 16, 1998, the

Commission decided by a vote of 5-0 to take the following

actions in RAD Referrals #98NF-01, 03, 07, 08:

1. a. open a MUR in RAD Referral 98WF-Ol. -\t~ 77b. Find reason to believe TECO Energy Inc.

Employees' PAC and Robin J. Hastings, antreasurer, violated 2 U.S.C.5 434(a) (4) (A)(iv), and enter intoconciliation prior to A finding ofprobable cause to believe.

c. Approve the Factual and Legal Analysisand Conciliation Agreement, asreconended in the General Counsel'sReport dated July 10, 1998.

2. a. Open a I!UR in R&D Referral 9SNF-03. IA\UK 411b. Find reason to believe Harry 8. Tzmn

Club - Federal and Linda Tochterman, astreasurer, violated 2 U.S.C.S 434 (a) (4) (A) (iv).

Federal Ilection Comission Page 2Certification for R&D Referrals #98NF-01, 03, 07, 08July 16, 1998

c. Approve the Factual and Legal Analysis,as recozmended in the General Counsel'sReport dated July 10, 1998.

d. Take no further action and close thefile.

3. a. Open a NOR in RAD Referral 98,-07.

b. Find reason to believe that the Allegheny)Teledyne Incorporated Political ActionCommittee (AT-PAC) and Dale 0. Reid, astreasurer, violated 2 U.S.C.S 434(a) (4) (A) (iv).

c. Approve the Factual and Legal Analysis,as recomended in the General Counsel'sReport dated July 10, 1998.

d. Take no further action and close thefile.

4. a. Open a NOR in R&D Referral 9M-08.j~Ff) b. Find reason to believe that North Side

Good Government Comnittee and MichaelRagan, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C.S 434 (a) (4) (A) (iv), and enter intoconciliation prior to a finding ofprobable cause to believe.

c. Approve the Factual and Legal Analysisand Conciliation Agreement, asrecommended in the General Counsele'Report dated July 10, 1998.

5. Approve the appropriate letters, asrecommiended in the General Counsel's Rqetdated July 10, 1998.

(Contiuug~

Federal Election Commission Page 3Certification for RAD Referrals 98NF-01, 03, 07v 08July 10, 1998

Conimsioneru Aikens, Elliott, McJonald, MoGarry, and

Thomas voted affirmatively for the decision.

Attest:

Datew Marj ioN . zooms80crtar of the Cmission

Received in the Secretariat: Fri., July 10, 1998 12:03 p.m.Circulated to the Commission: Mon., July 13, 1998 11:00 a.m.Deadline for vote: Thurs., July 16, 1998 4:00 p.m.

lrd