of 30
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
1/30
S D N Te Jewish
Social Contract
Introduction by Gordon Schochet, Rutgers University
W S P M I , J ? W -----q ? I Te Jewish Social Contract,1 D N q --
G . B -- G, I .
W , , , , x, N : -- x D J
, - J C-. T x -- x x; , .
Te Jewish Social Contract j x 2005 A J S, HebraicPolitical Studies P N .
1 D N, Te Jewish Social Contract: An Essay in Political TeologyP:P U P, 2005.
HBRAIC PIICA SUDIS, V. 1, N. 5 (A 2006), PP. 593622, 2006 SHAM PRSS.
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
2/30
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
3/30
-- .
G H , ,
H j.H G , j -. S I G . N , , G H C , M B C; G H --
- G NH B.T political
N H x D , , . I -- . M, , N , --
x ; , contractual.N, C , J . A , j --. T x J x j.
P N x . B , .A , -- . x. J, , ,
. S f , , .
Hebraic Political Studies 595
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
4/30
N , , -- B W, .
Comments by eora Batnitzky, Princeton University
D N Te Jewish Social Contract J -- . B N J -- J - . I N
, , j J , . N J , . S J , --. I , N , J
C . A N . P --, N , J C, H R , -- .
D J
N , :W --, . B , . 18. T f N : J J . J , N , -- , J x
. A N --x M M , I , , j
596 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
5/30
. 169.S , , q
. A N , -- .
I x N J -- C. A N , J C
J J . A , J -- x , . I N ,
J C . C J .T C J J . T , J C
j q , , . 126.
T N -- . T N J-C
--. A N , . S, , , q . 121.A N, J -- , J : T J - , J, J . 18.
Hebraic Political Studies 597
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
6/30
N , C, , , -- J, ,
, . T --, N J , . S, J, f -- . A , , J , J j.
T x, , N , : M M S. T , M J -- q , S J q . A N , J C x. B M I x, S ,
C W, M I . I, N , M S J , q , , , .
W C, N -
. Y, S , -- I J . T , S, [] C, --; J M, , , D fqh. 2 N W , M I x
2 S, Persecution and the Art o Writing C: U CP, 1988, . 19.
598 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
7/30
. H , --.3 N , N , --
, [. 18], M , , N , --. N , M, , ., M Guide, [ ] , [] , 4 : T :
. A , q-- . A , . T . , . 5
S, --- M N j , , N. --
j x N , M din hamalchut -- .6M, M , M -- . M , , A q , ,
.7
B M N Jj J . I , M q
3 M M, Guide o the Perplexed, . S. P C: U C P, 1963, 2:40.
4 I.
5 M, Guide o the Perplexed, 3:27.
6 S, , M, Guide o the Perplexed, 3:34.
7 M , Politics and the Limits o Law: Secularizing the Politicalin Medieval Jewish ToughtS: S U P, 2001, . 66.
Hebraic Political Studies 599
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
8/30
N Jewish Social Contract .H q Guide :
K , , I I . T - . T , x . .8
B - -- , , N , J , , , . C N . A N . B x M ,
J, -- , ?
N J B. A ,C, B . T . N, , R . S, R --
R j, B , B . 113. T q : W N B M? A -- B
? A, N x , , ,
8 M, Guide o the Perplexed, 3:27.
600 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
9/30
, ?
T q N --
J C I. W q--, N : J . I -- N C C J U S. S N
, J C .B , ? I --
? M N C I , C J , j -- C? T . B S ,
-- C S C- J I ,j M, , ? H , C N , ? C, N
, N ?
P, , N . A , J S I. S N C j C U S. I ,
I, , , x J -- .
N . H, , N J-C q ,
Hebraic Political Studies 601
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
10/30
Te Jewish Social Contract : J C . I Te Jewish Social Contract,
, J . B , J C N -- J, C, .S, I , Te Jewish Social Contract --
J . T -- j J J --, N , , .
Comments by Michael Walzer, Institute or Advanced StudyT I I . B , I x -- .
D N , , J, I ; , J
, I . I x J. N , J: , ; , ; , --. B q x . R, x, -- . 27. B peshat
, ; , ?W ? I , I .B I
602 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
11/30
--. A, , ; q.
J , , . A q I -- J , , x -x , J. I ?
S q , , not yet! M xJ -x J , , x --. P - . C I xsiddurim J : M K , , [
] I.T -- , . I . I R C --; , f J . A N , x J --
. 222. D . B .T D B-G, B
1942 1943, J , , . W , x-- . T galut [x] ! H N ? T J
.A ? A : I I
1999, N S . I , J S.
Hebraic Political Studies 603
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
12/30
T NIS 200,000; , NIS 18 . H , j , , ,
- -, -- C M , x . N , x J, - , -- . A, I , . --
, S , .N x ,
J -- J , J . B J , ? I , N , q .
B q , q, - , J -J .A ; . H , . T , , - ; U S . B , x,
, C, J, , , M D , , G A, .I --, , .
D N , , , . 9. B I , , .
I ; x ; ; J
604 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
13/30
; , , , ,
. Y I N .
N J D N -- x , J , -- , ? W ,
, mamlachtiyut q?T N , , , . , ? A , , -- ? S U S H ? J? J B? S? A , , , Mx? I N x,
x? A ?S, q ? S
q , A , ? A j J , N , x J . 221? W
j? A ?T, q
? N : T , , -- J J . 228. T U S I most , I. A, ,
, q . H , q? I
Hebraic Political Studies 605
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
14/30
.N , I .
N, q, , , J N , J ? T J , q, , . M R C J, D N x , J --
?
Response by David Novak, University o oronto
I B M W Te Jewish Social Contract, q . q I .
T , q j -- . A, q, , , .
I. Leora Batnitzky
B J political M , S. H jx M S , ,, S xpolitical-- M , , Leo Strauss and EmmanuelLevinas: Philosophy and the Politics o Revelation. N, M ,
J N G,I A, M M , f, -J A, ,H, R. A, S f I
606 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
15/30
S U C 1960, S -- . B , P B
M, S M. H J . I, M , -- I G B HK B-G U N.
M Te Jewish Social Contract I --
, P B I J C -- . C S, J- I. I J- C I x -- C , , I C M A S.
S, x P B I
M S, J I J C.
P B q M Guide o the Perplexed, 2.40 3.27: , M ; , M , j ,
, G. T W ; . A , --: 1 , 2 G. T Guide ; , -- ,
, S ,M .
M -- humanly limited society divinely directed
Hebraic Political Studies 607
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
16/30
community. T , P B -- , orah shariah, / ,
. T -- , , . M , Mishneh orah. N, .
T . M, ,
haolam haba, , , --. B, Guide , x ; , Mishneh orah, M .
T --. M , namusiyyah, A Gnomos . H, -- ,
. N, M, society --, x, M , . I , , , / , , S, S x, P, S , . T ,
, R . S, M, community -- society, society , community. N x -- . A, , S , .
U , M q I --
, I A S . U ,I M. , M society secularity, P B :
608 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
17/30
B x M , -- J,
, -- ?
, M. IMishneh orah, mipnei hechreh hadaat, , Mishneh orah, K 8:11.A S ractatus Teologico-Politicus,
. 5 M j , , , . M , x --, haolamhaba. N, . A, , , until , M, . I ,
, not yet M haolam haba; Mishneh orah, R 8:8. I, M q -- 1983 , Te Image o the Non-Jew in Judaism, 1998 , Natural Law in Judaism, I , j.
A , , P B --, I M
, I C I?R I M, I
M -- M --, , --
x. I , I M G M A -- praxis theria Nicomachean Ethics. B I /
Hebraic Political Studies 609
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
18/30
- -- J Knesset Yisrael U S C, x
-- . Y , secularism, , --, fdeismles extrmes se touchent! I, I dina demalchuta dina J J S M R, M N R, S A
R, N G R J . A C , C .
T J J C contractual-- C . T C -- / lex naturalis,
ius naturale R f S --. S C J, , J . A, J C de acto C J, S 1492, de jure J q
, q de jure.T J C
-- , C society, . T C community, the church ,
, -C . I, x , C C -- J V C II 1960, covenantal; , , .
610 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
19/30
modern all , , J , x --
. A, , , .N, I , , nowhere. I, ab initio? Ex nihilo nihil ft. I, covenantal , J C,
, -- . I J C , -- J-C , J C A C U S, q .I Te Jewish Social Contract, I x
J , I , C .
U I, , J de acto, , -- de jure, I shariah. A I , J C, I , - dhimmi
I , , M . A , J , ; -- q. A, , -- , M J , J , - J - ger
toshav; Mishneh orah, K6:1, 8:10. H, q -M I ; M . , , M
Hebraic Political Studies 611
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
20/30
q J -J. H M J j
J J J -- M; Mishneh orah, K, . 12..
T I M, I , J -- J -J . A, I
M W M q -M , , .
, J M J M ,, C A q .
J C, , , . T, J C, - C C --- -M J, J C -- C , C J --
. I, x J q C. , , J, J . S, J I J , J J .
I , , I PB q , M S, , J C I. I , , q ,
612 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
21/30
P B , .
II. Michael Walzer
M W q , , Te Jewish Social Contract.H, , -- q. I q , q , --
q , I , q x P W .
T , , q :
1. T --
; , q q .
2. J -- q , J
.3. ,
G B , .
4. J, x J -- J,
J .
I I Te Jewish Social Contract ,I P W 1;
Hebraic Political Studies 613
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
22/30
2; -- 3, ;
x 4 -- x J.N, J . I q J , j I q J J --. I , I q J J, I q . A , I q
. I , --, q J J, I , J J.
A J J x , I , , I j -x/ J
. C, R C J , , R J G B J . Y, , I -- -x J j , x -- , I q
-x J , , , somewhere. T somewhere , -- ; , , , , . I , -x J -- , , ; ,
somewhere -- within - . U, A . N, I J J -x J J.
614 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
23/30
B q, P W x [ N]. S I --
J 1 ,2 , 3 , P W -- x . M, , -- , . T x , , ,
. D ortha doxa q -- pistis credo . A , , :1 G I; 2 J , ; 3 G
j .C, , I belieq
J J. I, J q . x--, J says [ ], T G ein orah min ha-shamayim. M , q J
. x, J q , , , : Y, G, . Y, , q q -- . S, x, that G, q j how G I. A , , AJ H, Heavenly orah, 2005 .
, R H, x how mitzva. ,
Hebraic Political Studies 615
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
24/30
x -- x, kavana q
. , -- , . I, , .
N, , ,
-- x.B B S, x , x , J A -- .
B j what that
. B J -- J q J that , , , apologia what . A , J , -- , , , x f,
, j what . emu--na, ; , , bitahon. H, J q , q that . T, J J , , j j. T - P H: [ ]
[kilu] [ ] . A , , J x . H, x-- , I f 1984
616 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
25/30
C G , Te Nature o Doctrine, f W .
T , , J . H J M , M C, M G, I, J . R, -- J , J . A J --
, Seer Haikkarim, - J A, C Aq, C, B -- . I, J . S, x, M summa legae, , Mishneh orah, Guide o thePerplexed, . T . T
j A J H -. j, 1986 I M K, Dogma in Medieval Jewish Tought. N, , .T J ,
. Y x -- G teshuva .
A P W , , , I .I, J I Te Jewish SocialContract P W I
x -- , , S q , J , C , J .
Hebraic Political Studies 617
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
26/30
W I P W x J , I . N
- J, , , -- J j J . T x x J - , , -x J , -J . S
: , how why , . T , J x J, . D x, W -, D I U S -- x, G ,
C C R R. J . , , , j . Y q f J, , -- J .
P W x -- J x , . J x, I -- , j J x, I D . B I . T , , . I , --
I Te Jewish Social Contract, I J , B, q A C J galut .
618 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
27/30
x , P W , G C
x I , H Mj q I. PW -- . I , x I , , N Ax, !A x I
x . P W q-- . , matbea shel teilla M Avot3:2, . P, I , I q R C
. N, , . M x, , -- J x q . H, -- communal J , , --
. I, j , , , . , I C C . A , A C J -- S I -J , x
Z . A, -- , J Z , -Z J -Z -Z -S.
Hebraic Political Studies 619
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
28/30
, P W [ ] q . I, 1983 , Spheres
o Justice. Y -- [] . A, q xJ . N I . I US, x
T , , J x C. W x J J , x J -- T A. A, , A , x , T J S, G . T, ,
J , -- T , C, H B C . T q x J , . J, -- covenantal.
S - , A --
. M x J j , j . T U S C, x RM R N Y 1859, .Y J q , x S C U S? S, A x J
, I J, , J, ,
620 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
29/30
. H , x J P W I . B, , J --
J, I j J .
G q Te JewishSocial Contract, I I, P W q: [W] q
? A , q: [C] q ? Q , J J . P W --.
D P W ? I , M
- A-A , - , - -- ? W ? -- N Y C j
, , ?A I q , , x J , , . T, , x - - .I , --
.
B M W I
Hebraic Political Studies 621
7/28/2019 David Novak 1
30/30
. A I x j , Hebraic PoliticalStudies.
622 Symposium on he Jewish Social Contract