Debate Project Instruction Booklet (Black and White)...EXED 200 Fall 2017 Debate/Role Play Project...

EXED 200 Fall 2017

Debate/Role Play Project B.Cunningham, M.s.Ed. James Madison University

[1.5” Binder Spine Insert Title]

EXED 200 Fall 2017

XUTgX Heb]XVg ;haa a [T & E(K( =W(

4 | H T X

EXED 200 FALL 2017

IN THIS SECTION:

ü Heb]XVg GiXei Xj TaW bU]XVg iXfnnn+ ,

ü XUTgX L X aX TaW =kcXVgTg bafnn - /

ü XUTgX 9ff a Xag JhUe V4 @bj lbh j UX eTWXW TaW VbagXagf

bY g[X ebhc U aWXennnnnnnnnnnnnn 0 2

ü JXfbheVXf4 ;b ha VTg ba ;XagXe& D UeTel& ;b TUbeTg ba

;b X T glnnnnn 3

LESSON NOTEBOOK

__Overview

EXED 200 Fall 2017


5 | H T X

IN THIS SECTION:

ü AaYbe Tg iX HeXfXagTg ba Ghg aX ?h WX aX nn+* +,

ü ?ebhc HeXfXagTg ba KV[XWh Xnnnnnnn+,

ü Jb X H Tl =kcXVgTg ba ?h WX Ybe g[X WTl bY g[X

XUTgX# nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn+-

ü XUTgX : U b eTc[l ?h WX aXf nnnn(( +.

ü HeX HeXfXagTg ba Kh Tel ! 9Vg i gl nn( +/

ü HXXe =iT hTg ba 9Vg i gl V Tffjbe # nnn((+0

ü Hbfg XUTgX JXY XVg ba fgTgX Xag nnnn +1

LESSON NOTEBOOK

EXED 200 FALL 2017

Required in binder*

EXED 200 Fall 2017


6 | H T X

EXED 200 FALL 2017

LESSON NOTEBOOK

IN THIS SECTION:

• : aWXe VbagXagfnnnnnnnnnnn(+2

• ?ebhc gbc V fheiXl fhU ggXW UXYbeX

WXUTgX#nnnnnnnnnnnnnn(((+3 ,+

• KheiXlf gb UX Vb c XgXW TaW fhU ggXW ba aX4

o HeX XUTgX fheiXl V[XV VTaiTf Ybe a & Vbcl TaW cTfgX

gb UebjfXe#

o Hbfg XUTgX fheiXl V[XV VTaiTf Ybe a & Vbcl TaW cTfgX

gb UebjfXe#

Binder content/ Surveys

EXED 200 Fall 2017


7 | H T X

Tab 4

EXED 200 Fall 2017


8 | H T X

Project Overview and Objectives

Lb l fghWXagf5

How it all began:

A UX Ta g[ f ceb]XVg Whe a g[X Kce a bY ,*+0 a l =P= ,** V Tff( 9YgXe [XTe a TUbhg g[X

iT hX bY hf a XUTgX cXWT b l Whe a T jbe f[bc Tg BT Xf ETW fba Ma iXef gl& A g[bh [g

TUbhg hf a g gb gXTV[ Te h XagTg ba TaW Vb X T gl f f( 9YgXe Kce a fX XfgXe& UTfXW ba

g[X YXXWUTV WTgT Yeb l V Tff& A eXi fXW g[X cebVXWheXf TaW bT f bY g[X ceb]XVg( L[Xa&

Whe a g[X T bY ,*+0& A Tcc XW Ybe T .N9 eTag j g[ l Vb XT hX& HTh ETUeXl5 ;bbeW aTgbe

bY g[X ;b ha VTg baf ;XagXe( Ghe eTag cebcbfT jTf TVVXcgXW TaW jX TeX abj jbe a

j g[ cebYXffbef Yeb ?Xbe X ETfba Ma iXef gl TaW Dba jbbW Ma iXef gl a fhccbeg bY g[X e

eb X c Tl a TaW WXUTgX Tff a Xagf gb UX hfXW a g[X e V TffXf( L[Ta lbh a TWiTaVX Ybe

lbhe fhccbeg bY g[ f T Tm a XaWXTibe

Why do I feel that argumentation strategies are important to understand and use in future work situations?

• 9f YhgheX gXTV[Xef TaW eX TgXW fXei VX cebYXff baT f& lbh j UXaXY g Ul XagXe a g[X

jbe YbeVX j g[ T YbhaWTg ba a Vb TUbeTg iX W fVbhefX TaW cbf g iX Te h Xag( L[ f j

XaTU X lbh gb ceXfXag WXTf V XTe l TaW gb TWibVTgX Ybe lbhe fghWXag)V Xag aXXWf a T

cbf g iX TaaXe(

• Qbh j XTea gb Tcc l Te h Xag f f a g[X VbagXkg bY eXT jbe W cebU X f(

Tab 5

EXED 200 Fall 2017


9 | H T X

• XUTgX cXWT b l f Ta aabiTg iX TccebTV[( Ag [Tf g[X cbgXag T gb gXTV[ fghWXagf bY

Tal T X g[X beT Vb ha VTg ba& Ve g VT g[ a a & Vb TUbeTg ba& TaW fgXa a f f

aXVXffTel gb XagXe g[X jbe YbeVX TaW V i V eXT ( JTb& ,*+*#(

• XUTgX cXWT b l f Ta TVg iX jTl gb Xa T X fghWXagf g[ebh [ eb X c Tl a &

f h Tg baf& TaW WXUTgXf( LXTV[ a g[ebh [ WXUTgX [Tf UXXa WX bafgeTgXW gb [X c

fghWXagf j g[ Vb ha VTg ba f f& cebU X fb i a & ebhc Vb TUbeTg ba& TWibVTVl&

eXfXTeV[& X cTg[l TaW hV[ beX ;T c ! KV[aTWXe& ,*+*#(

What are the goals of this project?

• Lb fgXa gb TaW Xg gb abj lbhe cXXef a beWXe gb Vb c XgX T V Tff ceb]XVg( =dhT

Vbage Uhg ba gb g[X ceb]XVg Ul T X UXef bY g[X ebhc f g[X WXf eXW cebVXff(

• Lb haWXefgTaW g[X WXUTgX cebVXff TaW XTea [bj g VTa UX Tcc XW gb lbhe

cebYXff baT XkcXe XaVXf a g[X YhgheX

• Lb c Tl T iTe Xgl bY eb Xf a T WXUTgX

• b bj g[X eh Xf TaW cebVXWheXf bY T bbW WXUTgX aV hW a ceXfXagTg ba dhT gl#

• BhW X lbhe bja TaW lbhe cXXefr WXUTgX cXeYbe TaVXf

What are your first steps?

• 9f T ebhc& Vb c XgX g[X Lbc V AagXeXfg KheiXl fXX XUTgX Ubb Xg#

• L[ebh [ TVg iX cTeg V cTg ba a g[X V Tff ebhc TVg i g Xf& XTea TUbhg XTV[ X UXe bY

lbhe ebhc(

• =kV[Ta X VbagTVg aYbe Tg ba j g[ lbhe aXj ebhc ?Xg gb abj XTV[ bg[Xe

EXED 200 Fall 2017


10 | H T X

• JGD= 9KKA?FE=FL4 ?b biXe g[X XUTgX ceb]XVg g X aX fgXW UX bj gb Xg[Xe TaW

Tff a gTf f gb XTV[ cXefba(

Debate Assignment Timeline:

First Week:

s ?Xg gb abj lbhe ebhc( ?ebhc X UXef [TiX UXXa Tff aXW eTaWb l( KXX ;TaiTf#

s ;b c XgX g[X WXUTgX gbc V fX XVg ba f[XXg Tf T ebhc( Qbh Tl WXi fX lbhe bja gbc V

TYgXe fV[XWh a T XXg a j g[ X Tf T ebhc( 9g g[ f g X& A j TccebiX lbhe gbc V

be Tf lbh gb eXi fX g( L[X gbc V hfg eX TgX gb g[X VbhefX VbagXag TaW [TiX Ta

TYY e Tg iX TaW T aX Tg iX f WX(#

s 9YgXe Xgg a VbaY e Tg ba bY lbhe ebhc gbc V& eXi Xj g[X gbc V) Tff a Xag gb Xg[Xe

Tf T ebhc(

s KV[XWh X g X Tg g[X ;b ha VTg ba ;XagXe j g[ 9 Xk TaW E V[TX gb jbe ba lbhe

bhg aX TaW lbhe eb X Ybe g[X XUTgX( i eghT bYY VX [bhef Tl UX TiT TU X# Qbh TeX

XaVbheT XW gb fV[XWh X - i f gf j g[ lbhe ebhc j[ V[ j YbVhf ba g[X Yb bj a

gbc Vf5 lbhe eXfXTeV[ TaW Te h XagTg ba eb X& eb X c Tl a g[X WXUTgX& TaW T cbfg

WXUTgX eXY XVg ba gb TaT lmX lbhe XkcXe XaVX(

s K a hc XTe l L X f bgf Xg Y XW hc dh V l( L[ f f cTeg bY lbhe XUTgX Tff a Xag

TaW g f g X fXaf g iX( KXX VTaiTf Ybe fhU ff ba WTgXf(

Second - Third Week:

• XUTgX Tff a Xag ceXfXagTg ba4 E V[TX & 9 Xk& HebYXffbe ;haa a [T

s XV WX g[X ebhc beWXe Ybe lbhe ebhcf eb X c Tl cXeYbe TaVX

s :X a eXfXTeV[5 Y lbh aXXW W eXVg ba Vbafh g :e Ta Kh iTa4 =WhVTg ba D UeTe Ta

s bhg HeX WXUTgX fheiXl fXX ;TaiTf Ybe WXgT f#

Fourth Week:

s a f[ eXfXTeV[

EXED 200 Fall 2017


11 | H T X

s N f g j g[ 9 Xk TaW E V[TX Tg g[X ;b ha VTg ba ;XagXe( Qbh TeX eXdh eXW gb Xg T

f c Yeb g[X ;b ( ;XagXe iXe Yl a XTV[ XXg a j g[ fcXV Y V WTgXf TaW g Xf TaW

abgXf TUbhg lbhe Tccb ag Xag(

s H h g[X eXfXTeV[ lbh [TiX WbaX agb lbhe bhg aX( fXX VTaiTf Ybe g[X gX c TgX#

s a f[ lbhe ebhc U U b eTc[l cT X( Qbh TeX eXdh eXW gb [TiX , be aT fbheVXf

j[ V[ j UX aV hWXW ba g[X : U b eTc[l cT X( 9 Xl j aW VTgX lbhe fbheVXf Ul

Vb be( 9 . cXefba j [TiX 2 fbheVXf TaW T / cXefba ebhc j [TiX +* fbheVXf a T (

Fifth Week:

s ;eXTgX abgX VTeWf

s KgTeg ceTVg V a lbhe eb X& aW i WhT l TaW a cT ef5 TYY e Tg iX f WX TaW aX Tg iX f WX(

s HeTVg VX gb Xg[Xe Tf T j[b X ebhc& Tg XTfg baVX f[bh W UX fgTaW a & abg f gg a #

GUfXeiX g X gf(

s Qbhe ebhc j VeXTgX Ta TVg i gl gb agebWhVX lbhe gbc V gb g[X V Tff( KhU g Tal

fghWXag jbe f[XXgf g[Tg aXXW gb UX Vbc XW ce be gb lbhe fV[XWh XW XUTgX( L[ f

XXg a hfg UX [X W Tg XTfg baX jXX UXYbeX lbhe fV[XWh XW XUTgX eb X c Tl a

V Tff

Sixth Week:

s HeTVg VX gb Xg[Xe beX( bVh Xag T Vb ha VTg ba TaW XXg a f ba Ta Xi WXaVX

WbVh Xag(

s @TiX lbhe fV[XWh XW XXg a Tg g[X ;b ( ;XagXe gb eb X c Tl g[X WXUTgX

TW[Xe a gb g X WXTW aXf(

s HeTVg VX TaW eXVX iX YXXWUTV eXVbeW a f TWX Tg g[X ;b ( ;XagXe j UX hfXW Ybe

afgehVg baT checbfXf ba l( HeX eXVbeW a bY g[X WXUTgX a c TVX bY eb X c Tl a a

V Tff f W fVbheT XW#

Seventh Week:

s HeTVg VX gb Xg[Xe beX( bVh Xag T Vb ha VTg ba TaW XXg a f ba Ta Xi WXaVX

WbVh Xag(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


12 | H T X

s 9ffX U X lbhe XUTgX ebhc [TaWUbb Ybe fhU ff ba TaW eTW a ( H XTfX hfX T

f T U aWXe j g[ gTUf Ybe XTV[ eXdh eX Xag( Qbhe ?ebhc [TaWUbb j UX WhX baX

jXX TYgXe lbhe fV[XWh XW WXUTgX(

s Ga g[X WTl bY g[X XUTgX lbh hfg fhU g Vbc Xf bY g[X Yb bj a WbVh Xagf gb

HebYXffbe ;haa a [T 5 g[X ebhc TVg i gl TaW ]hfg Y VTg ba& g[X aT Xf bY fghWXagf TaW

g[X eb Xf j[ V[ j UX c TlXW a beWXe bY g[X XUTgX fV[XWh X& TaW T ebhc bhg aX

j g[ XTV[ aW i WhT eb X TaW Te h Xag( KXX U aWXe Ybe WXgT f ba cT Xf +2( L[X

be aT f j b agb lbhe ebhc U aWXe(

Eighth Week:

s HeXfXag gb V Tff

s KX Y eXY XVg

s fVhff lbhe eXY XVg ba bY g[X XUTgX XkcXe XaVX j g[ lbhe ebhc X UXef TaW

E V[TX TaW 9 Xk Yeb g[X ;b ( ;XagXe(

s ;b c XgX g[X eXY XVg ba f[XXg TaW c TVX g a lbhe ebhc U aWXe(

s Lhea a g[X ebhc XUTgX U aWXe Ul g[X WTgX aW VTgXW ba ;TaiTf( Fb TgXe g[Ta baX

jXX TYgXe lbhe XUTgX a V Tff#

Ninth Week:

s bhg g[X Hbfg WXUTgX fheiXl( L[ f f cTeg bY lbhe XUTgX Tff a Xag TaW f g X

fXaf g iX( KXX VTaiTf Ybe fhU ff ba WTgXf(

H XTfX abgX4 Qbhe WTgX Ybe lbhe XUTgX)Jb X H Tl j g[ lbhe ebhc

X UXe aT Xf j UX fgXW a g[X XUTgX KV[XWh X WbVh Xag cbfgXW

ba ;TaiTf a g[X XUTgX bWh X(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


13 | H T X

DEBATE ASSIGNMENT Rubric (worth 35 points-10% of your grade)

Point breakdown and steps needed to complete the assignment:

Component Point value 1.Topic assignment survey baX cXe ebhc# + cb ag2. Pre-debate assignment survey Y aW g[ f ba VTaiTf# LbUX fhU ggXW aW i WhT l ba VTaiTf(

, cb agf

3. Collaborative skills aV hWXf XUTgX ebhc fg#& T

b )abgXf)X T f Yeb i f gf gb g[X ;b ha VTg ba ;XagXe TaW

Xi WXaVX be abgXf)X T VbeeXfcbaWXaVX j g[ WTgXf Yeb

ebhc Vb TUbeTg ba a V Tff be bhgf WX bY V Tff# Qbhe VeXTg i gl

ba cebi W a Xi WXaVX Ybe g[ f VTgX bel j UX TcceXV TgXW

KhU g + Vbcl cXe ebhc a lbhe ebhc U aWXe(

L[ f aV hWXf4

JX[XTefT & VbTV[ a & i WXb gTc a Tg g[X GYY VX bY

;b ha VTg baf ce be gb XUTgX c XTfX Xg f cf Yeb g[X

;b bYY VX Ybe iXe Y VTg ba( Qbhe aT X TaW WTgX f[bh W UX

ba XTV[ f c( - fXff baf#

0 cb agf ,

cb agf XTV[ i f g#

4. Group Schedule fV[XWh X Ybe g[X WXUTgX XiXag# KhU g T

Vbcl gb X TaW chg T Vbcl a lbhe ebhc U aWXe(

L[ f j aV hWX g[X aT Xf bY lbhe WXUTgX ebhc TaW g[X

beWXe a j[ V[ g[Xl j ceXfXag g[X e Te h Xagf(

, cb agf

5. Group outline j g[ aW i WhT Te h Xagf aV hW a UTf V

Te h Xagf& agebWhVg ba& UbWl& TaW VbaV hf baf L[ f j UX

ba g[X bb X WbVh Xag#

/ cb agf

EXED 200 Fall 2017


14 | H T X

:Tf VT l& lbh j aV hWX lbhe Te h Xag TaW cb agf TaW j[Tg

lbh j fTl Whe a g[X WXUTgX( KhU g T Vbcl gb X ce be gb

g[X XUTgX TaW chg T Vbcl a lbhe ebhc U aWXe( 6. Bibliography* KXX afgehVg baf ?ebhc U U b eTc[l

aW i WhT eXYXeXaVXf [ [ [gXW j g[ Vb be Xl cebi WXW#

KhU g a ebhc U aWXe(

. cb agf

7. Debate presentation aV hW a Vb cbaXagf Yeb bhg aX5

g X gf& cebcXe Te h XagTg ba& TWibVTVl& chU V fcXT a &

Tgg ghWX TaW Xag[hf Tf (

/ cb agf

8. Reflection interview: Oe gX T eXY XVg ba fXX W eXVg baf#

TUbhg lbhe XkcXe XaVX TaW Xg YXXWUTV Yeb E V[TX )9 Xk(

AaV hWX g[ f ba lbhe eXY XVg ba cT X( =TV[ X UXe bY g[X ebhc j afXeg T [TeW Vbcl bY g[ f

WbVh Xag a g[X U aWXe(

. cb agf

9. Group Binder: L[ f U aWXe hfg [TiX T g[X TUbiX

WbVh Xagf( Ag hfg [TiX T aXTg ceXfXagTg ba j g[ T gTU X bY

VbagXagf TaW W i WXef Ybe XTV[ fXVg ba( H XTfX V[XV VTaiTf Ybe

g[X WTgX bY fhU ff ba( Hb ag cXaT g Xf j UX TffXffXW Ybe TgX

fhU ff ba( Qbhe ebhc U aWXe hfg aV hWX g[X ebhc

fV[XWh X& ebhc TaW aW i WhT aYbe Tg iX bhg aXf& ba baX

bb X WbVh Xag#& , be aT fbheVXf [ [ [gXW Ybe XTV[

X UXe& ba g[X : U b eTc[l cT X

, cb agf

10. Post-debate survey: fXX g[X WXUTgX bWh X ba VTaiTf

Ybe g[X a TaW fhU g j g[ a g[X g X gf cbfgXW( L[ f f

Vb c XgXW aW i WhT l(

, b agf

11. Class Activity: Qbhe WXfVe cg ba TaW eTg baT X& TVg i glf[XXgf TaW jXU a f Y Tcc VTU X(

, cb agf

EXED 200 Fall 2017


15 | H T X

Communication Center, Library, Collaboration-Collegiality Resources

Resource Contact information Communication Center Faculty: Student Success Center:

Michael Clay Communication Role: ?eTWhTgX 9ff fgTagEmail: V Tl j8Wh Xf(] h(XWh Alexandra Conis Communication Center Role: LhgbeEmail: Vba fTk8Wh Xf(] h(XWh Paul Mabrey Communication Center Coordinator Email: TUeXlcX8] h(XWh

El .N9 Vb XT hX# ;b ha VTg ba ;XagXe4 KghWXag KhVVXff ;XagXe ++.-

EK; +**1

@Tee fbaUhe & N e a T ,,2*1

/.*)/02 .2+2

Library Faculty:

Brian Sullivan: Education Librarian Email: fh ,UT8] h(XWh

Phone: /.*# /02 0-0*

Website: jjj( U(] h(XWh

General number: /.*# /02 0+/* Collegiality: 6 Dispositions of Practice gb fge iX gbjTeWf g[ebh [bhg lbhe

cebYXff baT ebjg[ ;b ha g Xf g[Tg DXTea& DXTW& TaW DTfg5 :h W a TaW

fhfgT a a =WhVTg baT =kcXeg fX& Ul ETeg a Ca Xc#

Ø ;b g Xag gb MaWXefgTaW a

Ø AagX XVghT HXefXiXeTaVX

EXED 200 Fall 2017


16 | H T X

Ø ;bheT X TaW Aa g Tg iX

Ø ;b g Xag gb JXY XVg ba

Ø ;b g Xag gb =kcXeg fX

Ø ;b X T gl

Informative Presentation Outline Guideline

I. Introduction (first speaker, only):

9( MfX g[X TggXag ba Xgg a WXi VX gb T a g[X agXeXfg bY lbhe ThW XaVX TaW gbc V bY lbhe

ceXfXagTg ba(

:( =fgTU f[ g[X f a Y VTaVX& eX XiTaVX& TaW cbegTaVX bY lbhe ceXfXagTg ba gbc V(

;( ; XTe l& Vb ha VTgX lbhe checbfX fgTgX Xag(

( HeXi Xj TaW fh Te mX g[X T a cb agf lbh j hg mX gb XfgTU f[ TaW checbfX

fgTgX Xag(

LeTaf g ba Yeb g[X agebWhVg ba gb g[X UbWl TaW lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(

II. Body:

9( AagebWhVX lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(

+( 9 V T gb fhccbeg lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(

T( Khccbeg a TgXe T gb UTV lbhe V T 5 Xi WXaVX& dhbgXf& XkT c Xf&

TaXVWbgXf be aTeeTg iXf TeX ]hfg fb X bY lbhe cbff U g Xf(

U( Khccbeg a TgXe T gb UTV lbhe V T 5 Xi WXaVX& dhbgXf& XkT c Xf&


,( 9 W YYXeXag V T gb fhccbeg lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


17 | H T X





-( 9 W YYXeXag V T gb fhccbeg lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(





LeTaf g ba Yeb lbhe Y efg T a cb ag gb lbhe fXVbaW T a cb ag(

:( AagebWhVX lbhe fXVbaW T a cb ag(

+( 9 V T gb fhccbeg lbhe fXVbaW T a cb ag(





,( 9 W YYXeXag V T gb fhccbeg lbhe fXVbaW T a cb ag(





LeTaf g ba Yeb lbhe fXVbaW T a cb ag gb lbhe g[ eW T a cb ag(

;( AagebWhVX lbhe g[ eW TaW Y aT T a cb ag(

+( 9 V T gb fhccbeg lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


18 | H T X





,( 9 W YYXeXag V T gb fhccbeg lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(





-( 9 W YYXeXag V T gb fhccbeg lbhe Y efg T a cb ag(





LeTaf g ba Yeb g[X UbWl bY ceXfXagTg ba gb lbhe VbaV hf ba(

III. Conclusion (last speaker will sum up):

9( JXYXeXaVX UTV gb lbhe agebWhVg ba TaW TggXag ba Xgg a WXi VX(

:( Kh Te mX lbhe T a cb agf(

;( ;baV hWX j g[ T X beTU X Y a f[(

Bibliography: MfX 9H9 fgl X( L[X a f cebi WXW UX bj( KXX cT X +. Ybe h WX aXf(

[ggcf4))bj (Xa f[(cheWhX(XWh)bj )fXVg ba),)

EXED 200 Fall 2017


19 | H T X

GROUP PRESENTATION Schedule: 9f T cTeg bY lbhe U aWXe& lbh j aV hWX T fg

bY j[b f gT a j[ V[ cbf g ba a g[X Jb X H Tl XUTgX HeXfXagTg ba(

Example: +fg TYY e Tg iX4 KT l& +fg FX Tg iX4 CTl T& ,aW 9YY e Tg iX4 LeXibe& ,aW FX Tg iX4 ; T eX&

aT Kh Tel4 BTV

Role-Play Expectation (Guide for the day of the Debate)

Debate/Role Play Presentation Guideline Area 1st Affirmative

Speech 1st Negative Speech

2nd Affirmative Speech

2nd Negative Speech

Final Summary Speech

Public Speak-ing, Energy Level, Time limit

Kge iX gb VeXTgX T

UT TaVX bY hf a abgX

VTeWf ba l Y aXXWXW#

Uhg fcXT a gb

ThW XaVX TaW T a

XlX VbagTVg

Kge iX gb VeXTgX T

UT TaVX bY hf a

abgX VTeWf ba l Y

aXXWXW# Uhg

fcXT a gb

ThW XaVX TaW

T a XlX

VbagTVg

Kge iX gb VeXTgX T

UT TaVX bY hf a abgX

VTeWf ba l Y aXXWXW#

Uhg fcXT a gb

ThW XaVX TaW T a

XlX VbagTVg

Kge iX gb VeXTgX T

UT TaVX bY hf a

abgX VTeWf ba l Y

aXXWXW# Uhg

fcXT a gb

ThW XaVX TaW

T a XlX

VbagTVg

Kge iX gb VeXTgX T

UT TaVX bY hf a

abgX VTeWf ba l Y

aXXWXW# Uhg

fcXT a gb

ThW XaVX TaW

T a XlX

VbagTVgRole T eXX j g[

cebcbf g ba

W fT eXX j g[ g[X

cebcbf g ba

XkgXaW TaW WXiX bc

be aT TYY e Tg iX

Te h Xagf

XkgXaW TaW

WXiX bc be aT

aX Tg iX

Te h Xagf

flag[Xf mX TaW

eXi Xj T a

biXeT Te h Xagf

Thesis agebWhVX Vb c XgX

Te h Xag a YTibe bY

g[X cebcbf g ba

agebWhVX

Vb c XgX

Te h Xagf

T T afg g[X

cebcbf g ba TaW

eXYhgX TYY e Tg iX

Te h Xagf

eXYhgX aX Tg iX

Te h Xagf

eXYhgX TYY e Tg iX

Te h Xagf

eXfb iX Tal

W fchgXW V T f

TaW Xi WXaVX

Evidence AagX eTgX , be beX

dhT Y XW fbheVXf a

fhccbeg bY lbhe

Te h Xag

AagX eTgX , be

beX dhT Y XW

fbheVXf a

fhccbeg bY lbhe

Te h Xag

AagX eTgX + aXj

dhT Y XW fbheVX a

fhccbeg bY lbhe

Te h Xag

AagX eTgX + aXj

dhT Y XW fbheVX

a fhccbeg bY lbhe

Te h Xag

bVhf ba

VbaV hf ba TaW

j[l baX f WX f

VbeeXVg TaW g[X e

cbf g ba f gehXOutline MfX Vb c XgX

agebWhVg ba

MfX Vb c XgX

agebWhVg ba

IhXfg ba TYY e Tg iX

fbheVXf

IhXfg ba

FX Tg iX fbheVXf

Fb aXj fbheVXf

EXED 200 Fall 2017


20 | H T X

Focus ; XTe Hebcbf g ba ; XTe

Hebcbf g ba

bVhf ba eXYhgTg ba bVhf ba

eXYhgTg ba

Time Constraints:

• O g[ T / cXefba ebhc& XTV[ fcXT Xe [Tf T - ahgX g(

• O g[ T . cXefba ebhc& XTV[ fcXT Xe [Tf T - ahgX g Uhg g[X ,aW FX Tg iX

fcXT Xe [Tf Ta TWW g baT ahgX gb Ue XY l fh Te mX g[X WXUTgX( L[XeXYbeX&

g[X ,aW aX Tg iX fcXT Xe [Tf . ahgXf a T (

Debate Bibliography Guidelines:

Directions: O[Xa eXfXTeV[ a lbhe cbf g ba Ybe Te h XagTg ba& g f cbegTag gb UX

abj XW XTU X TUbhg lbhe gbc V( Qbh j eXfXTeV[ lbhe gbc V ba Ta aW i WhT UTf f TaW g[Xa

hfX g Tf g[X UTf f Ybe W fVhff ba j g[ lbhe Vb XT hXf(O[Xa g f Vb c XgXW& g j UX

agX eTgXW Tf cTeg bY g[X ?ebhc : U b eTc[l cT X bY lbhe ?ebhc XUTgX U aWXe( Qbh j

[ [ [g lbhef a T W YYXeXag Vb be Yeb g[X X UXef bY lbhe ebhc( H XTfX cebi WX T Xl

aW VTg a j[ V[ [ [ [gXW Vb be aW VTgXf g[X be aT fbheVXf bY XTV[ X UXe( H XTfX hfX

9H9 Ybe Tg(

Research Guidelines:

• Fb U b )OXU E( ( f cXe ff U X

• MfX T eXfXTeV[ WTgTUTfX aV hW a Uhg abg eXfge VgXW gb o BEM D UeTel eXfXTeV[ UTfXf4

o L[X XcTeg Xag bY =WhVTg ba

o L[X Ae f ;XagXe Tg NTaWXeU g Ma iXef gl [ggc4)) e f(cXTUbWl(iTaWXeU g(XWh)

o L[X ;bhaV bY =kVXcg baT ;[ WeXa

[ggcf4))jjj(VXV(fcXW(be

o =(J(A(;(

o A=K(XW( bi

L[X ;Tee Xe D UeTel Tg BEM f Ta afg ghg baT fhUfVe UXe gb Ubg[ =kVXcg baT

;[ WeXa TaW L=9;@AF? =kVXcg baT ;[ WeXa& fb lbh f[bh W UX TU X gb TVVXff Teg V Xf

i T g[X fV[bb UeTel cbegT Qbh VTa ce ag Tg j & Ybe XWhVTg baT checbfXf#(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


21 | H T X

• D fg 2 fbheVXf Y lbh TeX T . cXefba ebhc TaW +* Y lbh TeX T / cXefba ebhc( H XTfX

abgX4 Qbh hfg fg g[X , be aT fbheVXf hfXW gb ceXcTeX lbhe XUTgX fcXXV[( H XTfX

[ [ [g lbhe fbheVXf ba g[X U U b eTc[l cT X j g[ T ha dhX Vb be T ba j g[ g[X

eXYXeXaVX fbheVXf hfXW Ul lbhe Vb XT hXf( Hebi WX T Xl gb aW VTgX g[X Vb be Ybe XTV[

gXT X UXe( H XTfX hfX 9H9 Ybe Tg( Lb haWXefgTaW lbhe WXUTgX cbf g ba& lbh aXXW

gb haWXefgTaW Ubg[ g[X TYY e Tg iX TaW g[X aX Tg iX f WX(

• H XTfX hfX 9H9 fgl X

• JXYXe gb HMJ M= GOD4 ; gTg ba ;[Teg Ybe fcXV Y V aYbe Tg ba ba V g a Ubb f& Teg V Xf

TaW ba aX fbheVXf

• H XTfX hfX iTe XW eXYXeXaVX fbheVXf( AaV hWX Ubb f& Teg V Xf& Tf jX Tf ba aX fbheVXf&

fhV[ Tf h g XW T fbheVXf& cbWVTfgf& XgV(

9WW g baT l& jX TeX YbeghaTgX gb [TiX Ta XWhVTg ba UeTe Ta& :e Ta Kh iTa Tf T eXfbheVX Ybe

g[ f Tff a Xag( Qbh Tl eXTV[ [ Tg fh ,UT8] h(XWh Ybe eXfXTeV[ dhXfg baf TaW

VbaVXeaf(

Pre-Presentation Summary: :XYbeX g[X Jb X H Tl XUTgX& lbhe ebhc [Tf Ta

bccbegha gl gb VeXTgX TaW ceXfXag T f[beg TVg i gl gb g[X V Tff( L[X TVg i gl j UX gXW gb /

+* ahgXf( Qbh Tl hfX T i WXb& jbe f[XXg be TVg i gl f[XXg( L[X checbfX bY g[X TVg i gl f gb

agebWhVX lbhe gbc V( H XTfX T X g[X TVg i gl aXhgeT TaW abaU TfXW& Tf Ta TYY e Tg iX TaW

aX Tg iX cbf g ba Ybe lbhe gbc V j UX fgTgXW Whe a g[X Jb X H Tl XUTgX(

H XTfX T X Ta Tccb ag Xag j g[ X gb W fVhff g[ f TVg i gl + , jXX f UXYbeX lbhe

fV[XWh XW WTgX( KhU g T f[beg cTeT eTc[ WXfVe U a g[X TVg i gl TaW lbhe ebhcrf eTg baT X

Ybe hf a g( H XTfX cebi WX T Vbcl bY g[X TVg i gl f[XXg& Y lbh TeX hf a baX j[Xa jX [TiX bhe

W fVhff ba( A j T X Vbc Xf Ybe g[X V Tff# AaV hWX Tal i WXb a f Y Tcc VTU X(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


22 | H T X

Peer Evaluation Activity:

L[ f f iXa gb XTV[ fghWXag ce be gb XTV[ WXUTgX( H XTfX ghea g j[Xa Vb c XgXW(

9f XTV[ WXUTgX Vb XaVXf& fgXa gb g[X Te h Xagf ceXfXagXW Ul Ubg[ g[X TYY e Tg iX TaW g[X

aX Tg iX f WXf bY g[ f eXfb hg ba( 9f lbh fgXa& gT X fb X abgXf ba g[ a f lbh Y aW agXeXfg a &

VbaYhf a & f XTW a & XgV( 9afjXe dhXfg ba + ce be gb g[X WXUTgX& dhXfg baf , TaW - Whe a g[X WXUTgX&

TaW dhXfg ba . TYgXe(

:XYbeX g[X WXUTgX4

+( He be gb g[X WXUTgX& [bj Wb lbh YXX TUbhg g[X eXfb hg ba UX a WXUTgXW7 O[ V[ Wb lbh

UX XiX [Tf g[X UXggXe Te h Xag7 O[l7__________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

he a g[X WXUTgX4

,( O[ V[ fcXT Xe aT X# ba g[X TYY e Tg iX gXT & W W lbh Y aW bfg cXefhTf iX TaW j[l7 O[Tg

jTf g[X cb ag g[Tg TWX g[X e Te h Xag bfg Vbai aV a 7 be XkT c X4 9YY e Tg iX + be

9YY e Tg iX ,#__________________________________________________________________________

EXED 200 Fall 2017


23 | H T X

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

-( O[ V[ fcXT Xe aT X# ba g[X aX Tg iX gXT W W lbh Y aW bfg cXefhTf iX TaW j[l7 O[Tg jTf

g[X cb ag g[Tg TWX g[X e Te h Xag bfg Vbai aV a 7 be XkT c X4 FX Tg iX + be FX Tg iX

,#______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________

9YgXe g[X WXUTgX4

.( @TiX lbhe YXX a f V[Ta XW j g[ eXYXeXaVX gb g[X eXfb hg ba UX a WXUTgXW7 AY g[Xl [TiX& j[l

TaW [bj7 AY g[Xl [TiX abg& j[l W W g[Xl abg V[Ta X7 je gX ba g[X UTV #

Post-Debate Reflection Statement:

eXVg baf4 L[ a TUbhg g[X j[b X cebVXff bY Wb a g[X XUTgX Tff a Xag( O[Tg W W lbh X

TUbhg g7 O[Tg W Warg lbh X TUbhg g7 Qbh j eXi Xj g[X i WXb bY lbhe WXUTgX Whe a lbhe

Tfg XXg a j g[ E V[TX be 9 Xk( L[ a TUbhg lbhe ceXfXagTg ba Whe a g[X Jb X H Tl(

AagXei Xj);b TUbeTgX j g[ lbhe gXT X UXef TUbhg j[Tg lbh g[bh [g jbe XW jX TaW

j[Tg W Warg jbe ( O[Tg Vbh W lbh Wb a T YhgheX f ghTg ba j[Xa Te h XagTg ba f f TeX

aXXWXW7

KcXT gb X& E V[TX TaW 9 Xk TaW eXY XVg ba g[X Yb bj a dhXfg baf( (=(9(D( bWX #( Qbh

Tl hfX g[X ;e g VT L[ a a KgTaWTeWf LTU X Yeb KXei VX DXTea a gb YbVhf lbhe fgTgX Xagf(

+( ;eXTgX lbhe bja ceb cg gb YbVhf lbhe g[bh [gf4

9eXTf lbh Tl YbVhf ba4 H V baX#

9e h XagTg ba) T b f f

JXfXTeV[ f f);bagXag =a[TaVX Xag

;b TUbeTg ba);b X T gl f f

EXED 200 Fall 2017


24 | H T X

,( L[Xa je gX g[X Yb bj a fgTgX Xagf UTfXW ba g[X ceb cg f# lbh [TiX fX XVgXW TUbiX4

A XTeaXW g[Tg

A XTeaXW g[ f j[Xa

L[ f XTea a TggXef

Aa [g bY g[ f XTea a YhgheX agX eTg ba#

L[ f f[bh W UX Vb cbfXW bY . cTeT eTc[f Tg g[X bfg TaW T

Tk h bY + , cT Xf a Xa g[(

Binder Contents:

eXVg baf4 Qbh j fhU g baX XUTgX)Jb X H Tl U aWXe cXe ebhc& VbagT a a g[X Yb bj a

WbVh Xagf( H XTfX be Ta mX Ul VTgX bel(

AgX JXfcbaf U gl Hb agf

AaYbe Tg iX TaW ebhc

ceXfXagTg ba bhg aX TaW

fV[XWh X

AaW i WhT TaW ebhc 1

: U b eTc[l XTV[ X UXe

Vbage UhgXf , be aT

eXYXeXaVXf#

AaW i WhT TaW ebhc .

; Tff 9Vg i gl XfVe cg ba&

TVg i gl f[XXg TaW jXU a f

?ebhc ,

;b TUbeTg iX f f Xi WXaVX

WbVh Xag

?ebhc 0

EXED 200 Fall 2017


25 | H T X

;b ( ;XagXe WTgXf TaW

abgXf ba j[Tg jTf

TVVb c f[XW( AaV hWX g[X

TggXaWTaVX f cf iXa gb lbh

Tg g[X ;b ;XagXe

?ebhc AaV hWX j g[ lbhe

Vb TUbeTg iX f f Xi WXaVX

WbVh Xag

Hbfg XUTgX JXY XVg ba AaW i WhT .

?ebhc : aWXe be Ta mTg ba ?ebhc ,Notes on your overall score:

• Qbhe XUTgX ceXfXagTg ba6 / cb agf TWWXW gb TUbiX

• ;b c Xg ba bY g[X Yb bj a fheiXlf j TWW / cb agf gb g[X TUbiX fVbeX4

Lbc V KX XVg ba fheiXl

KheiXlf gb UX Vb c XgXW ba aX4

HeX XUTgX fheiXl

Hbfg XUTgX fheiXl

Appendix A:

EXED 200 Debate Assignment

Debate topics: SCALE SURVEY

?ebhc EX UXef4

?ebhc Fh UXe4

TgX4

eXVg baf4 be XTV[ gbc V UX bj& fX XVg ah UXe +& ,& - gb eXY XVg lbhe agXeXfg a g[X gbc V(

+ eXceXfXagf T gbc V g[Tg lbh TeX iXel agXeXfgXW a eXfXTeV[ a TaW WXUTg a

EXED 200 Fall 2017


26 | H T X

, eXceXfXagf T gbc V bY fb X agXeXfg TaW T

- eXceXfXagf T gbc V g[Tg lbh [TiX iXel gg X agXeXfg a(

H XTfX UX fheX gb eTgX XiXel gbc V ba g[X fg UX bj Tf XTV[ ebhc a g[X V Tff j UX Tff aXW

T W YYXeXag gbc V( ?b g[ebh [ g[X cebVXff bY eXTV[ a VbafXafhf j g[ lbhe ebhc TaW g[Xa

fhU g baX XUTgX Lbc V fheiXl cXe ebhc( H XTfX eTgX XTV[ gbc V(

H XTfX Vb c XgX g[ f fheiXl Tf T ebhc& WXgTV[ cT Xf ,* ,, TaW ghea a g[X [TeW Vbcl(

Topics by Chapter:

Chapter 1:

9( fTU gl TUX f Wb beX [Te g[Ta bbW Ybe fcXV T XWhVTg ba(

:( ;[ WeXa j g[ XkVXcg baT g Xf TeX beX f Te gb aXhebglc VT V[ WeXa g[Ta W YYXeXag

Yeb aba aXhebglc VT be aXhebW iXefX V[ WeXa(

;( pHXbc X efgq DTa hT X f[bh W UX eXdh eXW a T Vb X X V TffXf(

Chapter 2:

( ?XaXeT =WhVTg ba f T UXggXe TccebTV[ g[Ta fcXV T XWhVTg ba Ybe gXTV[ a fghWXagf

j g[ W fTU g Xf(

=( :TV ebhaW4 Aa g[X VTfX :G= bY g[X @XaWe V @hWfba ;XageT KV[bb fge Vg i( Jbj Xl

+32,#& g[X KhceX X ;bheg VeXTgXW g[X WXY a g ba bY T pYeXX Tccebce TgX chU V

XWhVTg baq Tf XWhVTg ba hfg VbaYXe pfb X XWhVTg baT UXaXY gq( 9VVbeW a gb eXVXag

VTfXf gb UX Te hXW a BTahTel bY ,*+1& g[X Vbheg hfg jX [ a ba j[Tg pfb Xq jbh W

XTa( Qbh WXV WX( eXfXTeV[ =aWeXj ( i( bh Tf ;bhagl KV[bb :bTeW RVTfX +/

2,1S#(

9e h Xag4 KV[bb W fge Vgf TeX ba l eXfcbaf U X g[ebh [ VeXTg ba TaW c X XagTg ba

bY Ta aW i WhT mXW XWhVTg ba ceb eT Ybe cebi W a fb X XWhVTg baT UXaXY g gb

fghWXagf j g[ W fTU g Xf( 9VVbeW a gb g[X Jbj Xl WXV f ba& g[Tg XTaf p XeX l beX

g[Ta WX a fq be pge i T q#(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


27 | H T X

Chapter 3:

( 9 V[ Wrf W fTU gl cTVgf g[X YT l beX cbf g iX l g[Ta aX Tg iX l(

?( AagX XVghT W fTU g Xf aX Tg iX l cTVg baXrf TU gl gb UXVb X fX Y WXgXe aXW( O[Tg

V[TcgXe f g[ f7

Chapter 5:

@( Hbbe afgehVg ba f beX eXfcbaf U X g[Ta aXheb b VT cT e Xag Ybe g[X TV[ XiX Xag

WXY V gf bY bfg fghWXagf( O g[ XTea a W fTU g Xf(

A( 9VVbeW a gb KgXeaUXe TaW ?e beXa b ,**+#& pOX f[bh W XW TgX l fgbc hf a

W fVeXcTaVl fVbeXf gb WXag Yl V[ WeXa j g[ XTea a W fTU g Xf( L[X Xg[bW f

cflV[b b VT l TaW cflV[b Xge VT l aWXYXaf U Xq(

Chapter 6:

B( L[X TVg a bhg V[ W a g[X V Tffebb [Tf T beX fXe bhf cTVg ba g[X V Tffebb TaW

ba g[X V[ W g[Ta g[X Tag fbV T V[ W be g[X j g[WeTja V[ W(

C( pAg [Tf UXXa fh XfgXW g[Tg baX eXTfba fV[bb f Wb abg hfX flfgX Tg V fVeXXa a TaW

WXag Y VTg ba Xg[bWf Ybe fhfcXVgXW X bg baT TaW UX[Ti beT W fbeWXef f g[Tg Tal

beX V[ WeXa jbh W UX WXag Y XW TaW g[Tg g[ f jbh W VeXTgX T Y aTaV T UheWXa gb g[X

fV[bb (q

Chapter 7:

D( AagXeiXag baf a XWhVTg ba g[Tg TeX abg Xi WXaVX UTfXW Wb beX [Te g[Ta bbW a

g[X geXTg Xag bY V[ WeXa j g[ Thg f (

Chapter 8:

E( LXTV[ a V[ WeXa j g[ Vb ha VTg ba W fbeWXef [bj gb hfX T H(=(;(K( flfgX c VgheX

XkV[Ta X flfgX # be 99; 9h XagTg iX TaW 9 gXeaTg iX Vb ha VTg ba fgeTgX l TaW

WXi VX# flfgX j ceXiXag g[X V[ W Yeb WXiX bc a iXeUT Vb ha VTg ba f f(

Chapter 9:

F( HTeXagf f[bh W T X g[X V[b VX Ybe g[X e aYTag gb [TiX T VbV[ XTe c Tag eTg[Xe g[Ta

jT g Ybe g[X V[ W gb T X g[Tg WXV f ba Ybe [ be [XefX Y(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


28 | H T X

G( EX UXef[ c a g[X XTY Vh gheX j aY hXaVX T fghWXagrf TaW [ f YT lrf cXefcXVg iXf

TaW j f[Xf eX TeW a XWhVTg baT c TVX Xag( ;[TcgXe7

Chapter 10:

H( Ag [Tf UXXa fh XfgXW g[Tg V[ WeXa j g[ i fhT cT e Xagf TeX g[X XTf Xfg ebhc bY

fghWXagf j g[ W fTU g Xf gb agX eTgX agb g[X XaXeT XWhVTg ba V Tffebb f( Obh W lbh

T eXX be W fT eXX j g[ g[ f fgTgX Xag7 =kc T a(

I( Aa g[X V Tffebb & fghWXagf j g[ 9 @ aXXW gb UX ba XW VTg ba gb Xg g[X bfg bhg

bY g[X XWhVTg baT bccbegha g Xf TiT TU X( ;[TcgXe7

J( Ag f UXggXe gb YbVhf ba VTeXXe WXiX bc Xag TaW YX f f Ybe fghWXagf j g[ fXiXeX

W fTU g Xf g[Ta YbVhf ba eXTW a TaW Tg[ f f( ;[TcgXe7

K( =Te l AagXeiXag ba f UXggXe Ybe lbha V[ WeXa j g[ W fTU g Xf be g[bfX Tg e f Ybe

W fTU g Xf g[Ta TgXe agXeiXag ba TccebTV[Xf( ;[TcgXe7

Chapter 13:

L( =WhVTgbef [TiX g[X fT X eXfcbaf U gl gb XXg g[X aXXWf bY V[ WeXa j[b TeX YgXW

TaW gT XagXW Tf g[Xl [TiX Ybe V[ WeXa j g[ W fTU g Xf(

M( ? YgXW TaW gT XagXW fghWXagf UXaXY g g[X bfg Ul cTeg V cTg a a TVVX XeTg ba TaW

Xae V[ Xag ceb eT f j g[ cXXef j[b f[bj f Te agX XVghT TU g Xf(

N( L[X eb X bY bhe XWhVTg baT flfgX gf g[X TV[ XiX Xag bY fghWXagf Yeb W iXefX

XWhVTg baT flfgX gf g[X TV[ XiX Xag bY fghWXagf Yeb W iXefX XWhVTg baT TaW

Vh gheT ebhcf( ;[TcgXe7

O( 9 gXTV[Xerf fX Y TjTeXaXff f eX TgXW gb Vh gheT eXfcbaf U gl Ybe baXrf fghWXagf(

;[TcgXe7

P( 9 cTeXagrf bja fV[bb XkcXe XaVXf j aY hXaVX g[X e Tgg ghWX TUbhg agXeTVg a j g[

g[X e V[ Wrf gXTV[Xef( ;[TcgXe7

Chapter 15:

Q( p;b cXg g iX X c bl Xagq cebi WXf T UXggXe geTaf g ba bhgVb X Ybe TWh gf j g[

W fTU g Xf g[Ta pf[X gXeXW X c bl Xagq(

EXED 200 Fall 2017


29 | H T X

Date post:	29-May-2020
Category:	Documents
Upload:	others
View:	3 times
Download:	0 times

Debate Project Instruction Booklet (Black and White)...EXED 200 Fall 2017 Debate/Role Play Project...

Documents