Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015
Simple DecentralisedDrinking Water Treatment:Drinking Water Treatment:
using the Ultra Low Pressure Ultra‐Filtration (ULPUF)(ULPUF) process
Univ.‐Prof. Dr.‐Ing. Franz‐Bernd FrechenUniversität Kassel
Chair IWA Specialist Group
Winner 2011 in thecategory „society“
Chair, IWA Specialist Group“Membrane Technology”
Slid
e 1 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015WASH – water, sanitation & hygiene
With t f t h i i bl tiWithout safe water, hygiene is problematicSanitation only does not avoid diseasesOptimal results are achieved if all three issues are addressed
Safe water is a core target
Transportation of safe water in rural areas is not safe and much too expensive
Decentralized water treatment is the key concern and membrane technology is the key technology
Slid
e 2 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015The MDG concerning drinking water
R d b h lf th ti f l Reduce by half the proportion of people without sustainable access to safe d i ki t til th 2015drinking water … until the year 2015 (based on situation in 1990)
Done: from 24% down to 9%
Not done concerning numbers:from 1270 million down to 663 millionfrom 1270 million down to 663 million
Slid
e 3 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Actual situation
1,000,000
World ‐ rural population: unimproved water source
800,000
600,000pita
400,000000 cap
200 000
400,00010
200,000
Source WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme (JMP) for Water Supply and Sanitation http //www wssinfo org/data estimates/tables/
02000 2005 2010 2015
Slid
e 4 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Source: WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme (JMP) for Water Supply and Sanitation http://www.wssinfo.org/data‐estimates/tables/
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Actual situation
250,000
China ‐ rural population: unimproved water source
200,000
150,000pita
100,000000 cap
50 000
100,00010
50,000
Source WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme (JMP) for Water Supply and Sanitation http //www wssinfo org/data estimates/tables/
02000 2005 2010 2015
Slid
e 5 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Source: WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme (JMP) for Water Supply and Sanitation http://www.wssinfo.org/data‐estimates/tables/
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015which technology to be used?
Table 7.8 Reductions of bacteria, viruses and protozoa achieved by householdTable 7.8 Reductions of bacteria, viruses and protozoa achieved by household water treatment technologies
Slid
e 6 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Priciples of membrane filtration
‐6‐3‐939
3770
1‐
Dead‐end filtration Cross‐flow filtration
men
t ISBN 978
water Treatm
ogy for W
aste
rane
Techn
olo
ource: M
embr
So
Slid
e 7 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015filtration is mostly done by the cake layer
cake layerraw cake layer(filtration active)
rawwater filtrate
1/1 000 of thediameter of a human hairhuman hair
(MWCO 150 kDalton)
Solids (organic anorganicmembrane
typical pore width 20 to 100 nm (0 020 to 0 100 µm)
Solids (organic, anorganic, bacteria, pathogens, …)
Slid
e 8 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
typical pore width 20 to 100 nm (0.020 to 0.100 µm)
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015removal of bacteria, example cholera
© wikipedia
cholera bacteriadiameter 300 to 500 nm length 2 000 nm ( 2 µm)
membranetypical pore width 20 to 100 nm (0 020 to 0 100 µm)
diameter 300 to 500 nm, length 2 000 nm ( 2 µm)
Slid
e 9 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
typical pore width 20 to 100 nm (0.020 to 0.100 µm)
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015WaterBackpack “PAUL” designed by DESEE:
t DESEE t ti 2001 at DESEE, starting 2001, wedesigned the WaterBackpackll d “PAUL” llcalled “PAUL”, a small mem‐
brane ultrafiltration (UF) unit membrane area 9.5 m2
1,200 L/d for 400 people in, / p pemergency and 60 peopleas permanent supply
0,80 mp pp y weight: 23 kg h i ht 1 2
m m
ax.
height: 1.2 m size: 0.4 m x 0.4 m 6 or 12 units fit on a standard
Euro‐palette
Slid
e 10 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
p
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015operation principles PAUL
dead end filtration ultra low pressure: 0.00 to 0.08 bar (0.04 typical) flat sheet verticallymounted
Slid
e 11 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
y
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Flux decay at standard TMP
d d d filt ti dead end filtration according to literature, the permeate flow will come to zero
(with TMP between 0.3 and 10 bar)
feed = raw water decay of filtrate flow rate
membrane
filtrate = permeate
Slid
e 12 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Melin/Rautenbach: Membranverfahren. 3rd edition 2007. ISBN 978‐3‐540‐34327‐1 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Flux stabilization at low TMP
Slid
e 13 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015dead end filtration – no sizing effect
hi h l iti ( f ) l th b f h high velocities (= forces) along the membrane surface have a sizing effect, leaving higher percentages of small particles on the
b f hi h lik li f l imembrane surface: high likeliness of pore clogging With ULPUF in dead end mode, force along (parallel to the)
membrane is closeto Zero!ze
particle si
1 no crossflow (original particledistribution)
ntage of p distribution)
2 … 5 increasing crossflow velocityfrom 0.3 m/s to 1.5 m/s
percen
Rippberger ,S.(1993): Berechnungsansätze zur Crossflow‐Filtration.
Ch I T h 65 N 5 533 540particle size
Slid
e 14 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Chem‐Ing‐Tech. 65, Nr 5, 533‐540particle size
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Membrane resistance and pore blocking
‐6‐3‐939
3770
1‐men
t ISBN 978
water Treatm
ogy for W
aste
rane
Techn
olo
ource: M
embr
So
Slid
e 15 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Low TMP
Th l th TMP th d i i f f ll ti l t b The lower the TMP as the driving force for small particles to be dragged into the pores, the lower the occurrence of pore bl kiblocking
With ultra low TMP, the small particles presumably cannot even pass the cake layer
Slid
e 16 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015cake layer removal
d d d filt ti i l d d ith l dead end filtration is only recommended with very low suspended solids content – as can be found in surface waters(i l d d i i )(in general and during emergencies)
cake layer has to be removed somehow – but if simple operationis essential, this cannot be done by backflush
Slid
e 17 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015models of cake layer with cross flow …
Slid
e 18 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015operation principles PAUL
fl t h t ti ll t d flat sheet vertically mounted forces at a cake layer particle during filtration
Fg force of gravity
feed
permeate
feed
FN filtration force
FF friction force
membrane
Slid
e 19 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
membrane
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015operation principles PAUL
f t k l ti l d i filt ti d filli forces at a cake layer particle during filtration and filling
F? force due to tur‐
Fg force of gravity
?bulence when filling
feed
permeate
feed
FN filtration force
FF friction force
membrane
Slid
e 20 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
membrane
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015operation principles PAUL
f t k l ti l d i filt ti forces at a cake layer particle during filtration pause
Fg force of gravity
FS sticky force
membrane
Slid
e 21 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
membrane
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015operation principles PAUL
f t k l ti l d i filt ti d filli forces at a cake layer particle during filtration pause and filling
F? force due to tur‐
Fg force of gravity
?bulence when filling
FS sticky force
membrane
Slid
e 22 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
membrane
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015operation principles PAUL
f t k l ti l d i t l i forces at a cake layer particle during tap closing
Fg force of gravity
pl s short term s rge hen closing tapplus short term surge when closing tap
FS sticky force
membrane
Slid
e 23 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
membrane
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015how much water is filtered per day?
1 200 L/d (800 bottles 1 5 Liter each) see picture: 1 day1,200 L/d (800 bottles 1.5 Liter each) – see picture: 1 dayproduction (1.2 tons of water)
Slid
e 24 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Bacteria removal
6
7
e LRV
4
5on
‐Value
2
3
Redu
ctio
Fresenius Fresenius Fresenius Fresenius Fresenius Fresenius0
1
Log‐R
e.coli coliforme I.E. e.coli coliforme I.E.
ISO 9308‐1 ISO 9308‐1 ISO 7899‐2 ISO 9308‐1 ISO 9308‐1 ISO 7899‐2
PAUL A PAUL A PAUL A PAUL B PAUL B PAUL B
Min 5,301 5,368 4,444 5,672 5,929 5,041Mittel 5,689 5,704 5,092 6,013 6,144 5,245
minavg , , , , , ,Max 6,362 6,415 5,568 6,380 6,431 5,544max
g
analyzed by Institut Fresenius Göttingen
Slid
e 25 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
analyzed by Institut Fresenius, Göttingen
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Virus removal (Federal Environment Agency UBA)
added virusses
human adenovirusses
analyzed by Federal Environment Agency Dessau/Roßlau
Slid
e 26 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
analyzed by Federal Environment Agency, Dessau/Roßlau
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Virus removal (Federal Environment Agency UBA)
total amount filtered in m³total amount filtered in m³
analyzed by Federal Environment Agency Dessau/Roßlau
feed: drinking water
Slid
e 27 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
analyzed by Federal Environment Agency, Dessau/Roßlau
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015How to use in permanet DW supply?
t i side view
valve closed
top view side viewfront
valve open
tile with valve incl. float, replaces
sieve
Slid
e 28 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015How to use in permanet DW supply?
raw water tank
optional:pre-sieve
detailtile valve closed
optional:valve
t i side viewvalve float
valve openvalve closed
top view side viewfront
tile with valve to be mounted in the
valve open
mounted in the filtered water tank at proper height
filt d
tile with valve incl. float, replaces
sieve
filteredwatertank
Slid
e 29 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015How to use in permanet DW supply?
raw water tank
optional:pre-sieve
detailtile valve closed
optional:valve
t i side viewvalve float
valve openvalve closed
top view side viewfront
tile with valve to be mounted in the
valve open
mounted in the filtered water tank at proper height
filt d
tile with valve incl. float, replaces
sieve
filteredwatertank
Slid
e 30 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015conclusions
d t f th ULPUF i thi li ti advantages of the ULPUF in this application1. the ULPUF process achieves LRV from 3 up to more than 6 for bacteria as
ll f iwell as for viruses2. the membrane more or less only serves as a support for the filtrating cake
layer→ this is also exemplified by the high LRV for viruseslayer→ this is also exemplified by the high LRV for viruses3. no cross flow, thus no sizing effect of the cake layer → low risk of pore
blockingblocking4. TMP is ultra low, this means driving force of small particles through the
cake layer into the pores is very low→ low risk of pore blockingcake layer into the pores is very low → low risk of pore blocking5. if EPS occur, they will be transported down to the bottom volume and not
be recycled to the membrane surfacey6. structure of the cake layer and bacterial activity keep up the cake layer’s
permeabilityp y
Low invest, small area: high maintenance & replacement costs
high invest, large area: low main‐tenance & no replacement costs
Slid
e 31 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
maintenance & replacement costs tenance & no replacement costs
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015… and about cost
Slid
e 32 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015… more very important facts
N t i t t id t t b No spare parts import necessary, as no cartridges etc. must be replaced on a regular basis
No waste of resources concerning firewood, as boiling the water for disinfection is not necessary anymore
Waste minimization, as water will no longer be supplied in plastic bottlesp
Local added value by creation of employment as plant manufacturer/water vendor/plant operator/maintenancemanufacturer/water vendor/plant operator/maintenance worker – perfect for micro financing
D ti ll d d f ill th Dramatically reduced cases of illness, thus less cost due to illness less cost due to inability to work less cost due to inability to work less absence from school = improved educational opportunities
Slid
e 33 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Uganda
Slid
e 34 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Tanzania
© Schaupppp
© Schaupp
installed March 2012 since then no more cases of diarrhea
pp
since then, no more cases of diarrhea, cholera or other waterborne diseases according to locals© S h
Slid
e 35 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
according to locals© Schaupp
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Peru
Slid
e 36 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Ecuador
Slid
e 37 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Ghana
Slid
e 38 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Nepal
Slid
e 39 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015Nepal
Slid
e 40 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015distribution of PAUL
1 822 PAULColombia: 8Comoros: 13
Congo: 17 Malawi: 22
Madagascar: 10 Malaysia: 4Mexico: 2Mongolia: 3Mozambique: 3
Namibia: 1
Niger: 1Nigeria: 5 1,822 PAUL
as of 20.10.2015
Pakistan: 255Cameroon: 9
Kenya: 9
Kenya/Somalia: 31
Colombia: 8Cuba: 12
Myanmar: 160 Nepal: 217
India: 14
Cambodia: 7 Pakistan: 257 Peru: 10
Haiti: 169Indonesia: 12
Philippines: 165
Guatemala: 1R i 1Senegal: 1Vietnam: 118
unknown: 91
France: 1
Ghana: 11United Kingdom: 2 Russia: 1
Sambia: 1Switzerland: 1Zimbabwe: 1Somalia: 11S L i 2
unknown: 91
Afghanistan: 14Egypt: 5
Bénin: 10
Bolivia: 1Bulgaria: 1Chile: 2Dom. Rep.: 1
Ecuador: 5
Eritrea: 5 St. Lucia: 2South Sudan: 7
Swaziland: 1Taiwan: 2Tanzania: 14Togo: 2
Turkey/Syria: 5Uganda: 21
Venezuela: 10
Slid
e 41 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
Bénin: 10Bulgaria: 1 Turkey/Syria: 5Uganda: 21
Decentralized DW Beijing, 02.11.2015thank you very much for your attention !
www uni-kassel de\fb14\siwawiwww.uni-kassel.de\fb14\siwawiwww.waterbackpack.org
Winner 2011 in the categorythe category
„society“
Slid
e 42 Department of Sanitary and Environmental Engineering (DESEE)
Head: Prof. Dr.‐Ing. F.‐B. Frechenwww.uni‐kassel.de/fb14/siwawi
© Humanity Care Foundation