Decision Making, Problem-Solving and
TeamworkEnterprise & Project Management
Please note that these slides are not intended as a substitute
to reading the recommended text for this course.
Decision making process in an organizational context
Rational model of decision making
Psychological barriers
Management skills / knowledge
Factors that contribute to effective teamwork
How do teams behave
Objectives
1
Decision = choice made from available alternatives
Decision Making = process of identifying problems and opportunities and resolving them
Decisions and Decision Making
2
Increase Your Knowledge
– Ask questions.
– Get experience.
– Use consultants.
– Do your research.
– Force yourself to recognize the facts when you see them (maintain your objectivity).
Use Your Intuition
– A cognitive process whereby a person instinctively makes a decision based on his or her accumulated knowledge and experience.
How To Make Better Decisions
3
Rationality - a logical, step-by-step approach to decision making, with a thorough analysis of alternatives and their consequences
The decision maker uses a consistent system of preferences to choose the best alternative
The decision maker can calculate the probability of success for each alternative
Usually focuses on means—how best to achieve one or more goals
Rational Model
4
Rational Decision-Making Model
5
Incremental model - major decisions arise through a series of smaller decisions
– piecemeal approach to larger solutions
Focus on structured sequence of activities from discovery to solution
Large decisions are a collection of small choices
Organizational Decision Making
6
Incremental Decision Model
7
Choices based on the discovery, identification, and diagnosis of unusual and ambiguous problems and/or the development of unique or creative alternative solutions
Three forms of innovation for economic progress:
– Institutional innovation: includes the legal and institutional framework for business, such as deregulation
– Technological innovation: creates the possibility of new products, services, and production methods
– Management innovation: major changes in the way organizations are structured and how managers perform their functions
Innovation Decisions
8
Is it legal?
– Does it violate law
– Does it violate company policy
Is it balanced?
– Is it fair to all
– Does it promote win–win relationships
How will it make me feel about myself?
Ethics Check
9
Some Barriers to Decision Making - Perception
10
People may assume that everyone sees things the way they do.
– They think if something is clear to them it is also clear to everyone else.
– Decision makers must find out what other people are thinking and take those views into account.
Personal perspective
11
Imaginative Barriers
– Premature criticism
– Lack of creativity
Emotional Barriers
– Feeling inferior
– Insecurity
Perceptual Barriers
– Stereotyping
– Self-fulfilling prophecies
– Culture
Intellectual Barriers
– Insufficient data
– Not looking for feedback
Some Barriers to Decision Making
12
Task Based Approach - changing employee responsibilities and tasks
People Oriented includes activities intended to improve individual competencies and performance levels
Task / People Based Management Approach
13
The multi-dimensional and thus multi-discipline nature of many problems requires a team approach.
– It encourages staff with complementary skills and competencies, to coordinate their efforts.
By establishing priorities, concentrating financial resources, and combining knowledge and expertise, you can have greater impact on serious problems through your program
– Such efforts can serve to:
• 1) lighten individual work load,
• 2) reduce duplication of efforts, and
• 3) produce a result greater than all of separate efforts.
Teamwork…..Why?
14
Group
IndividualTeam
Usefulness of teams:
– More resources for problem solving.
– Improved creativity and innovation.
– Improved quality of decision making.
– Greater commitments to tasks.
– Higher motivation through collective action.
– Better control and work discipline.
– More individual need satisfaction.
How do teams contribute to organizations?
15
Common problems in teams:
– Personality conflicts.
– Individual differences in work styles.
– Ambiguous agendas.
– Ill-defined problems.
– Poor readiness to work.
• Lack of motivation.
• Conflicts with other deadlines or priorities.
• Lack of team organization or progress.
• Meetings that lack purpose or structure.
• Members coming to meetings unprepared.
How do teams contribute to organizations?
16
Projects teams or task forces.
– People from various parts of an organization work together on common problems, but on a temporary basis.
– Official tasks are very specific and time defined.
– Disbands after task is completed.
What are the current trends in the use of teams?
17
What are the current trends in the use of teams?
Guidelines for managing projects and task forces:
– Select appropriate team members.
– Clearly define the purpose of the team.
– Carefully select a team leader.
– Periodically review progress.
What are the current trends in the use of teams?
19
Effective teams …
– Achieve and maintain high levels of task performance.
– Achieve and maintain high levels of member satisfaction.
– Retain viability for the future.
How do teams work?
20
Group
IndividualTeam
Group process:
– The way the members of any team work together as they transform inputs into outputs :
– Also known as group dynamics.
– Includes communications, decision making, norms, cohesion, and conflict, among others.
How do teams work?
21
Group
IndividualTeam
An open-systems model of work team effectiveness.
– Forming — initial orientation and interpersonal testing.
– Storming — conflict over tasks and ways of working as a team.
– Norming —consolidation around task and operating agendas.
– Performing —teamwork and focused task performance.
– Adjourning — task accomplishment and eventual disengagement.
Stages of team development
23
The Five-Stage Team Development Model
24
1. Ten or fewer team members
2. Voluntary team membership
3. Continuous service on the team
4. Full-time assignment to the team
5. An organization culture of cooperation and trust
6. Members report only to the project manager
7. All relevant functional areas are represented on the team
8. The project has a compelling objective
9. Members are in speaking distance of each other
Conditions Favoring Development of High Performance Project Teams
25
Creating a High-Performance Project Team
26
Maintenance activities
– Support emotional life of a team as an ongoing social system.
– Include:
• Gatekeeping
• Encouraging
• Following
• Harmonizing
• Reducing tension
How do teams work?
27
Teams help businesses increase customer satisfaction in several ways.
– One way is to create work teams that are trained to meet the needs of specific customer groups.
Teams also help firms improve product and service quality in several ways.
– teams take direct responsibility for the quality of the products and service they produce.
Teams are increasingly popular is the need for speed and efficiency when designing and manufacturing products.
– Traditional product design proceeds sequentially, meaning that one department has to finish its work on the design of a product before the next department can start. Unfortunately, this is not only slow, but it also encourages departments to work in isolation from one another.
The Advantages of Teams
High turnover.
– Teams aren't for everyone, and some workers will balk at the responsibility, effort, and learning required in team settings. Social loafing / Slackers occurs when workers withhold their efforts and fail to perform their share of the work.
Groupthink
– where members of cohesive groups feel pressure not to disagree with each other
Team decision making takes considerable time and team members may be unproductive and inefficient.
Another pitfall is that one or two people may dominate team discussions, restricting consideration of problems and solutions.
The Disadvantages of Teams
29
The presence of someone with expertise
The presentation of a compelling argument
Lacking confidence in one’s ability to contribute
An unimportant or meaningless decision
A dysfunctional decision-making climate
Factors that Encourage People to Withhold Effort in Teams
30
Project teams are created to complete specific, one-time projects or tasks within a limited time.
– Project teams are often used to develop new products, to significantly improve existing products, to roll out new information systems, or to build new factories or offices.
– The project team is typically led by a project manager, who has the overall responsibility for planning, staffing, and managing the team.
– Can reduce or eliminate communication barriers and speed up the design process
– Promote flexibility
Special Kinds of Teams
31
Credibility of the project leader
Unclear project objectives
Changing goals and priorities
Lack of team definition and structure
Confusion about roles and responsibilities
Performance appraisals that fail to recognize teamwork
Excessive team size
Barriers to team building
32
Goals, direction and leadership
Roles, responsibilities and skills
Climate and interpersonal skills
Methods and operating procedures
All integrated through effective communication
The effective team
33
Individual members whose loyalty rests elsewhere.
Where goals are not clarified or understood.
Where the aims of the team are seen to be in conflict with other teams to which the members belong.
Members treat each other with suspicion and distrust.
Ideas and contributions are devalued and “rubbished” by other members.
Members are allowed to switch off and opt out.
Cliques form for their own protection.
Barriers to effective teamworking
34