+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Deer Claim Study Counties

Deer Claim Study Counties

Date post: 12-Nov-2014
Category:
Upload: blinsink
View: 267 times
Download: 2 times
Share this document with a friend
Description:
Good review and reminder, look at your area and the areas you regularly travel.
22
ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006 PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005 2005 2005 Deer Claim 5-Year 2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005 Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim Pure State County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity Premium IL Adams 470 7 $14,033 15 24 0 25 $2,005 $30 Alexander 1 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 Bond 340 6 $14,270 18 23 136 25 $2,378 $42 Boone 165 1 $3,270 6 13 0 6 $3,270 $20 Brown 4 1 $1,199 250 0 0 59 $1,199 $300 Bureau 139 2 $9,955 14 14 15 18 $4,977 $72 Calhoun 2 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 Carroll 33 2 $5,485 61 29 0 32 $2,743 $166 Cass 17 - $0 0 50 333 29 $0 $0 Champaign 1,261 2 $2,572 2 4 6 4 $1,286 $2 Christian 277 4 $5,640 14 4 0 9 $1,410 $20 Clark 18 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 Clay 25 1 $3,228 40 0 0 10 $3,228 $129 Clinton 277 1 $2,247 4 11 0 7 $2,247 $8 Coles 878 9 $28,052 10 6 2 8 $3,117 $32 Cook 6,818 9 $15,747 1 1 2 1 $1,750 $2 Crawford 31 - $0 0 0 0 20 $0 $0 Cumberland 51 2 $3,205 39 18 105 39 $1,603 $63 De Kalb 648 1 $3,527 2 3 9 5 $3,527 $5 De Witt 43 1 $3,599 23 20 0 27 $3,599 $84 Douglas 125 1 $2,892 8 8 0 11 $2,892 $23 Du Page 1,396 - $0 0 1 0 1 $0 $0 Edgar 82 1 $4,034 12 18 0 8 $4,034 $49 Edwards 6 1 $1,419 167 0 0 67 $1,419 $237 Effingham 160 2 $4,196 13 14 0 11 $2,098 $26 Fayette 63 1 $2,757 16 14 143 16 $2,757 $44 Ford 45 - $0 0 0 83 13 $0 $0 Franklin 688 16 $41,187 23 30 0 26 $2,574 $60 Fulton 116 3 $7,800 26 19 0 23 $2,600 $67 Gallatin 4 1 $2,675 250 0 0 59 $2,675 $669 Greene 13 - $0 0 0 0 19 $0 $0 Grundy 62 - $0 0 16 0 5 $0 $0 Hamilton 11 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 Hancock 4 - $0 0 0 0 56 $0 $0 Hardin 6 - $0 0 300 0 125 $0 $0 Henderson 7 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 Henry 362 1 $4,117 3 9 0 5 $4,117 $11 Iroquois 201 1 $5,181 5 0 0 5 $5,181 $26 Jackson 63 2 $3,388 32 71 0 51 $1,694 $54 Jasper 212 7 $16,173 33 39 0 34 $2,310 $76 Jefferson 488 19 $40,079 39 25 0 31 $2,109 $82 Jersey 140 2 $1,340 14 8 100 18 $670 $10 Jo Daviess 28 - $0 0 33 0 20 $0 $0 Johnson 9 - $0 0 250 0 80 $0 $0 Kane 746 2 $8,979 3 0 0 2 $4,490 $12 Kankakee 358 2 $2,146 6 8 5 8 $1,073 $6 Kendall 203 - $0 0 0 0 3 $0 $0 Knox 192 2 $3,838 10 21 0 13 $1,919 $20 La Salle 1,481 16 $36,439 11 8 15 13 $2,277 $25 Lake 2,095 5 $18,770 2 1 2 2 $3,754 $9 Lawrence 22 2 $4,792 91 83 0 49 $2,396 $218 Lee 675 11 $26,042 16 10 14 13 $2,367 $39 Livingston 113 3 $5,950 27 0 0 13 $1,983 $53 Logan 486 5 $14,781 10 8 10 10 $2,956 $30 Macon 2,202 24 $64,755 11 8 4 9 $2,698 $29 I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 20
Transcript
Page 1: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumIL Adams 470 7 $14,033 15 24 0 25 $2,005 $30

Alexander 1 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Bond 340 6 $14,270 18 23 136 25 $2,378 $42Boone 165 1 $3,270 6 13 0 6 $3,270 $20Brown 4 1 $1,199 250 0 0 59 $1,199 $300Bureau 139 2 $9,955 14 14 15 18 $4,977 $72Calhoun 2 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Carroll 33 2 $5,485 61 29 0 32 $2,743 $166Cass 17 - $0 0 50 333 29 $0 $0Champaign 1,261 2 $2,572 2 4 6 4 $1,286 $2Christian 277 4 $5,640 14 4 0 9 $1,410 $20Clark 18 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Clay 25 1 $3,228 40 0 0 10 $3,228 $129Clinton 277 1 $2,247 4 11 0 7 $2,247 $8Coles 878 9 $28,052 10 6 2 8 $3,117 $32Cook 6,818 9 $15,747 1 1 2 1 $1,750 $2Crawford 31 - $0 0 0 0 20 $0 $0Cumberland 51 2 $3,205 39 18 105 39 $1,603 $63De Kalb 648 1 $3,527 2 3 9 5 $3,527 $5De Witt 43 1 $3,599 23 20 0 27 $3,599 $84Douglas 125 1 $2,892 8 8 0 11 $2,892 $23Du Page 1,396 - $0 0 1 0 1 $0 $0Edgar 82 1 $4,034 12 18 0 8 $4,034 $49Edwards 6 1 $1,419 167 0 0 67 $1,419 $237Effingham 160 2 $4,196 13 14 0 11 $2,098 $26Fayette 63 1 $2,757 16 14 143 16 $2,757 $44Ford 45 - $0 0 0 83 13 $0 $0Franklin 688 16 $41,187 23 30 0 26 $2,574 $60Fulton 116 3 $7,800 26 19 0 23 $2,600 $67Gallatin 4 1 $2,675 250 0 0 59 $2,675 $669Greene 13 - $0 0 0 0 19 $0 $0Grundy 62 - $0 0 16 0 5 $0 $0Hamilton 11 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Hancock 4 - $0 0 0 0 56 $0 $0Hardin 6 - $0 0 300 0 125 $0 $0Henderson 7 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Henry 362 1 $4,117 3 9 0 5 $4,117 $11Iroquois 201 1 $5,181 5 0 0 5 $5,181 $26Jackson 63 2 $3,388 32 71 0 51 $1,694 $54Jasper 212 7 $16,173 33 39 0 34 $2,310 $76Jefferson 488 19 $40,079 39 25 0 31 $2,109 $82Jersey 140 2 $1,340 14 8 100 18 $670 $10Jo Daviess 28 - $0 0 33 0 20 $0 $0Johnson 9 - $0 0 250 0 80 $0 $0Kane 746 2 $8,979 3 0 0 2 $4,490 $12Kankakee 358 2 $2,146 6 8 5 8 $1,073 $6Kendall 203 - $0 0 0 0 3 $0 $0Knox 192 2 $3,838 10 21 0 13 $1,919 $20La Salle 1,481 16 $36,439 11 8 15 13 $2,277 $25Lake 2,095 5 $18,770 2 1 2 2 $3,754 $9Lawrence 22 2 $4,792 91 83 0 49 $2,396 $218Lee 675 11 $26,042 16 10 14 13 $2,367 $39Livingston 113 3 $5,950 27 0 0 13 $1,983 $53Logan 486 5 $14,781 10 8 10 10 $2,956 $30Macon 2,202 24 $64,755 11 8 4 9 $2,698 $29

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 20

Page 2: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumIL Macoupin 184 1 $189 5 25 19 15 $189 $1

Madison 1,022 4 $8,878 4 5 0 5 $2,219 $9Marion 40 - $0 0 25 333 33 $0 $0Marshall 41 2 $5,923 49 44 2000 54 $2,961 $144Mason 52 1 $1,858 19 54 0 28 $1,858 $36Massac 5 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0McDonough 28 - $0 0 0 0 13 $0 $0McHenry 1,218 4 $8,278 3 3 0 4 $2,069 $7McLean 670 6 $14,302 9 5 0 5 $2,384 $21Menard 150 3 $12,973 20 47 61 36 $4,324 $86Mercer 7 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Monroe 460 5 $15,933 11 6 0 10 $3,187 $35Montgomery 61 - $0 0 28 77 33 $0 $0Morgan 203 - $0 0 5 56 5 $0 $0Moultrie 94 1 $1,444 11 0 0 3 $1,444 $15Ogle 193 4 $8,508 21 16 0 21 $2,127 $44Peoria 1,585 16 $45,846 10 9 6 8 $2,865 $29Perry 72 2 $2,822 28 36 0 28 $1,411 $39Piatt 66 2 $2,858 30 30 0 25 $1,429 $43Pike 14 - $0 0 0 1000 83 $0 $0Pope 2 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Pulaski 4 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Putnam 18 1 $3,763 56 0 0 30 $3,763 $209Randolph 900 23 $59,267 26 34 0 29 $2,577 $66Richland 221 2 $6,882 9 33 0 19 $3,441 $31Rock Island 269 1 $1,825 4 0 0 4 $1,825 $7Saline 16 1 $3,123 63 0 0 16 $3,123 $195Sangamon 2,655 23 $77,337 9 10 9 8 $3,362 $29Schuyler - - $0 N/A N/A 0 N/A $0 $0Scott 5 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Shelby 264 3 $6,502 11 16 19 15 $2,167 $25St. Clair 2,457 11 $35,171 4 7 0 5 $3,197 $14Stark 92 1 $1,027 11 44 0 32 $1,027 $11Stephenson 330 2 $4,559 6 9 0 10 $2,279 $14Tazewell 1,476 9 $17,400 6 9 2 7 $1,933 $12Union 9 2 $3,700 222 111 0 125 $1,850 $411Vermilion 584 6 $16,210 10 13 23 11 $2,702 $28Wabash 35 2 $5,570 57 0 0 23 $2,785 $159Warren 49 1 $3,222 20 31 0 27 $3,222 $66Washington 303 3 $10,588 10 24 0 16 $3,529 $35Wayne 21 2 $3,267 95 111 250 94 $1,634 $156White 6 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Whiteside 1,042 11 $26,053 11 8 13 9 $2,368 $25Will 1,456 1 $1,172 1 3 5 3 $1,172 $1Williamson 67 2 $5,793 30 16 91 19 $2,897 $86Winnebago 1,780 8 $15,331 4 4 15 5 $1,916 $9Woodford 199 2 $4,587 10 18 0 10 $2,293 $23

Total IL 44,787 347 $881,920 8 8 7 8 $2,542 $20

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 21

Page 3: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumIN Adams 1,194 10 $25,232 8 8 6 9 $2,523 $21

Allen 8,712 45 $133,120 5 6 5 5 $2,958 $15Bartholomew 724 8 $22,018 11 10 7 9 $2,752 $30Benton 38 1 $1,069 26 51 0 17 $1,069 $28Blackford 120 1 $971 8 7 22 12 $971 $8Boone 845 3 $14,121 4 6 1 4 $4,707 $17Brown 630 9 $15,678 14 37 12 26 $1,742 $25Carroll 731 12 $22,985 16 13 15 17 $1,915 $31Cass 952 9 $18,637 9 10 18 12 $2,071 $20Clark 466 3 $6,647 6 6 0 3 $2,216 $14Clay 597 9 $21,679 15 11 14 14 $2,409 $36Clinton 146 1 $318 7 17 0 8 $318 $2Crawford 20 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Daviess 516 4 $9,169 8 16 7 16 $2,292 $18De Kalb 763 12 $24,848 16 18 20 17 $2,071 $33Dearborn 1,313 15 $41,647 11 16 8 12 $2,776 $32Decatur 28 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Delaware 2,356 7 $20,911 3 3 4 3 $2,987 $9Dubois 241 4 $10,873 17 20 0 16 $2,718 $45Elkhart 2,379 13 $42,247 5 4 7 6 $3,250 $18Fayette 201 3 $9,385 15 25 0 20 $3,128 $47Floyd 351 1 $2,125 3 3 0 4 $2,125 $6Fountain 40 - $0 0 23 25 18 $0 $0Franklin 140 3 $9,834 21 19 28 16 $3,278 $70Fulton 401 11 $29,355 27 33 28 33 $2,669 $73Gibson 386 - $0 0 10 12 6 $0 $0Grant 641 6 $13,077 9 13 3 9 $2,180 $20Greene 306 4 $8,325 13 20 56 23 $2,081 $27Hamilton 7,963 19 $55,568 2 3 3 3 $2,925 $7Hancock 1,545 8 $21,106 5 5 3 5 $2,638 $14Harrison 129 2 $2,441 16 21 0 15 $1,221 $19Hendricks 4,113 18 $51,910 4 6 5 5 $2,884 $13Henry 881 6 $14,880 7 7 21 9 $2,480 $17Howard 1,744 2 $5,329 1 4 3 3 $2,665 $3Huntington 570 5 $20,042 9 3 11 7 $4,008 $35Jackson 982 9 $26,500 9 12 2 10 $2,944 $27Jasper 203 3 $7,763 15 8 14 23 $2,588 $38Jay 1,969 14 $28,064 7 12 16 11 $2,005 $14Jefferson 52 1 $5,399 19 20 0 15 $5,399 $104Jennings 91 1 $518 11 19 0 9 $518 $6Johnson 2,999 10 $30,378 3 5 3 4 $3,038 $10Knox 81 - $0 0 0 0 5 $0 $0Kosciusko 2,214 33 $63,572 15 17 16 15 $1,926 $29La Porte 188 3 $5,544 16 15 7 12 $1,848 $29Lagrange 845 10 $21,593 12 12 21 15 $2,159 $26

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 23

Page 4: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumIN Lake 963 3 $6,532 3 2 6 3 $2,177 $7

Lawrence 797 15 $25,965 19 18 7 15 $1,731 $33Madison 2,094 10 $28,352 5 5 3 4 $2,835 $14Marion 17,668 31 $90,133 2 2 1 2 $2,908 $5Marshall 180 2 $5,734 11 11 8 19 $2,867 $32Martin 30 1 $919 33 17 0 10 $919 $31Miami 582 5 $6,172 9 7 21 9 $1,234 $11Monroe 630 4 $8,972 6 12 5 11 $2,243 $14Montgomery 375 4 $6,648 11 10 8 13 $1,662 $18Morgan 2,512 14 $37,600 6 8 6 7 $2,686 $15Newton 60 - $0 0 16 0 13 $0 $0Noble 1,667 35 $80,729 21 18 20 21 $2,307 $48Ohio 20 1 $496 50 48 83 44 $496 $25Orange 288 6 $20,802 21 32 10 24 $3,467 $72Owen 160 2 $8,924 13 14 17 18 $4,462 $56Parke 47 3 $4,539 64 19 55 31 $1,513 $97Perry 228 3 $5,548 13 21 23 19 $1,849 $24Pike 22 - $0 0 50 48 40 $0 $0Porter 1,090 8 $12,508 7 4 8 6 $1,564 $11Posey 182 2 $3,468 11 19 11 13 $1,734 $19Pulaski 126 2 $3,698 16 38 0 23 $1,849 $29Putnam 408 7 $19,497 17 15 7 13 $2,785 $48Randolph 306 5 $18,403 16 9 8 11 $3,681 $60Ripley 47 - $0 0 0 19 11 $0 $0Rush 80 - $0 0 34 0 11 $0 $0Scott 96 2 $3,360 21 19 11 12 $1,680 $35Shelby 509 3 $10,610 6 6 2 5 $3,537 $21Spencer 57 - $0 0 0 0 22 $0 $0St. Joseph 4,961 15 $40,906 3 4 4 4 $2,727 $8Starke 360 12 $29,991 33 18 13 26 $2,499 $83Steuben 1,128 28 $73,174 25 19 27 26 $2,613 $65Sullivan 34 3 $5,578 88 26 0 31 $1,859 $164Switzerland 14 1 $2,263 71 100 0 43 $2,263 $162Tippecanoe 1,505 12 $32,354 8 4 5 7 $2,696 $21Tipton 500 1 $4,870 2 5 10 3 $4,870 $10Union 70 1 $914 14 0 16 19 $914 $13Vanderburgh 2,941 15 $50,474 5 5 6 5 $3,365 $17Vermillion 30 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Vigo 577 7 $13,668 12 8 8 10 $1,953 $24Wabash 198 2 $4,767 10 21 20 19 $2,384 $24Warren 31 - $0 0 100 0 29 $0 $0Warrick 973 10 $27,256 10 8 4 8 $2,726 $28Washington 461 4 $11,037 9 17 13 19 $2,759 $24Wayne 2,594 14 $31,527 5 6 4 6 $2,252 $12Wells 1,447 5 $14,529 3 8 11 9 $2,906 $10White 631 5 $8,422 8 13 9 11 $1,684 $13Whitley 1,780 17 $45,057 10 10 13 11 $2,650 $25

Total IN 103,265 658 $1,671,273 6 7 6 7 $2,540 $16

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 24

Page 5: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumMD Allegany 12,569 168 $310,501 13 14 19 16 $1,848 $25

Anne Arundel 28,309 94 $263,970 3 3 4 3 $2,808 $9Baltimore 29,165 95 $243,610 3 5 5 5 $2,564 $8Baltimore City 7,360 9 $19,307 1 2 2 2 $2,145 $3Calvert 5,785 58 $147,168 10 11 12 10 $2,537 $25Caroline 1,662 20 $44,994 12 14 10 14 $2,250 $27Carroll 15,257 146 $358,800 10 11 14 12 $2,458 $24Cecil 8,371 65 $162,011 8 9 9 8 $2,492 $19Charles 6,303 77 $205,802 12 8 12 11 $2,673 $33Dorchester 1,486 15 $32,493 10 9 16 12 $2,166 $22Frederick 22,131 183 $405,553 8 10 12 11 $2,216 $18Garrett 4,982 103 $177,004 21 25 37 29 $1,718 $36Harford 11,701 93 $239,656 8 7 8 8 $2,577 $20Howard 21,100 134 $347,268 6 7 9 7 $2,592 $16Kent 377 7 $18,803 19 17 26 21 $2,686 $50Montgomery 48,051 272 $658,642 6 5 8 6 $2,421 $14Prince Georges 17,011 44 $129,448 3 3 4 3 $2,942 $8Queen Annes 2,936 29 $78,529 10 9 9 10 $2,708 $27Somerset 126 5 $7,712 40 8 34 20 $1,542 $61St. Marys 7,045 89 $213,751 13 13 13 12 $2,402 $30Talbot 2,858 44 $108,829 15 14 15 15 $2,473 $38Washington 14,804 159 $328,535 11 13 17 14 $2,066 $22Wicomico 2,416 28 $78,047 12 8 7 10 $2,787 $32Worcester 1,183 13 $31,230 11 5 4 7 $2,402 $26

Total MD 272,988 1,950 $4,611,662 7 8 10 8 $2,365 $17

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 26

Page 6: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumNY Albany 1,816 12 $19,732 7 7 4 7 $1,644 $11

Allegany 1,439 30 $60,569 21 28 54 32 $2,019 $42Bronx 1 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Broome 2,054 14 $27,934 7 12 12 12 $1,995 $14Cattaraugus 3,581 48 $79,029 13 17 28 21 $1,646 $22Cayuga 698 22 $55,013 32 19 17 21 $2,501 $79Chautauqua 5,417 105 $211,014 19 18 26 22 $2,010 $39Chemung 3,608 36 $72,360 10 9 15 13 $2,010 $20Chenango 155 6 $17,919 39 32 41 41 $2,987 $116Clinton 934 8 $16,974 9 6 11 8 $2,122 $18Columbia 80 3 $7,851 38 23 16 16 $2,617 $98Cortland 538 3 $4,321 6 25 14 13 $1,440 $8Delaware 825 22 $46,935 27 22 39 32 $2,133 $57Dutchess 78 - $0 0 0 0 9 $0 $0Erie 15,610 135 $300,678 9 8 9 9 $2,227 $19Essex 43 - $0 0 0 0 20 $0 $0Franklin 244 5 $13,994 20 12 33 18 $2,799 $57Fulton 633 5 $17,087 8 5 13 8 $3,417 $27Genesee 1,249 18 $40,405 14 15 24 18 $2,245 $32Greene 1,330 29 $61,716 22 20 29 24 $2,128 $46Hamilton 29 - $0 0 34 0 28 $0 $0Herkimer 278 6 $17,771 22 14 6 21 $2,962 $64Jefferson 781 22 $61,069 28 37 25 32 $2,776 $78Kings - - $0 N/A 0 0 0 $0 $0Lewis 91 2 $5,629 22 36 0 24 $2,815 $62Livingston 1,692 30 $65,723 18 21 29 23 $2,191 $39Madison 1,177 35 $78,423 30 19 40 25 $2,241 $67Monroe 6,424 47 $107,430 7 7 10 8 $2,286 $17Montgomery 333 3 $5,483 9 6 25 12 $1,828 $16Nassau 7 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0New York 4 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Niagara 2,288 12 $26,180 5 7 5 6 $2,182 $11Oneida 2,726 36 $62,714 13 9 11 12 $1,742 $23Onondaga 3,123 21 $46,101 7 5 7 6 $2,195 $15Ontario 3,721 51 $106,275 14 17 25 19 $2,084 $29Orange 98 2 $3,719 20 10 29 13 $1,859 $38Orleans 2,286 26 $48,114 11 17 26 18 $1,851 $21Oswego 1,259 11 $25,047 9 10 18 13 $2,277 $20Otsego 490 15 $25,351 31 16 34 26 $1,690 $52Putnam 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Queens 9 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Rensselaer 845 7 $10,901 8 7 9 8 $1,557 $13Richmond 1 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Rockland 17 - $0 0 0 56 29 $0 $0Saratoga 1,547 11 $32,193 7 6 5 6 $2,927 $21

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 28

Page 7: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumNY Schenectady 1,304 5 $13,903 4 7 7 6 $2,781 $11

Schoharie 534 13 $23,483 24 15 24 28 $1,806 $44Schuyler 741 23 $43,827 31 26 42 33 $1,906 $59Seneca 414 9 $26,358 22 8 21 17 $2,929 $64St. Lawrence 257 3 $6,584 12 21 42 25 $2,195 $26Steuben 5,204 117 $238,095 22 20 37 28 $2,035 $46Suffolk 28 - $0 0 0 43 7 $0 $0Sullivan 24 - $0 0 40 143 38 $0 $0Tioga 636 9 $19,864 14 25 48 29 $2,207 $31Tompkins 1,179 33 $65,939 28 22 34 30 $1,998 $56Ulster 85 - $0 0 12 0 3 $0 $0Warren 409 2 $6,262 5 0 14 6 $3,131 $15Washington 730 9 $30,757 12 15 16 14 $3,417 $42Wayne 1,161 19 $33,227 16 19 17 17 $1,749 $29Westchester 52 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Wyoming 1,709 44 $107,750 26 27 30 27 $2,449 $63Yates 461 19 $42,747 41 30 30 39 $2,250 $93

Total NY 84,490 1,143 $2,440,450 14 14 20 16 $2,135 $29

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 29

Page 8: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumNC Alamance 3,321 30 $68,708 9 8 11 9 $2,290 $21

Alexander 1,317 10 $19,059 8 13 7 11 $1,906 $14Alleghany 56 - $0 0 21 0 10 $0 $0Anson 42 1 $1,894 24 68 120 51 $1,894 $45Ashe 961 23 $49,456 24 17 0 20 $2,150 $51Avery 104 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Beaufort 78 1 $1,578 13 0 29 13 $1,578 $20Bertie 5 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Bladen 52 1 $2,753 19 18 29 17 $2,753 $53Brunswick 139 - $0 0 16 0 9 $0 $0Buncombe 3,024 6 $17,989 2 1 1 1 $2,998 $6Burke 1,538 6 $16,092 4 9 5 6 $2,682 $10Cabarrus 2,286 9 $18,712 4 4 2 4 $2,079 $8Caldwell 1,855 12 $18,896 6 3 6 4 $1,575 $10Camden 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Carteret 113 - $0 0 0 14 2 $0 $0Caswell 224 6 $13,803 27 17 27 24 $2,301 $62Catawba 4,534 14 $32,917 3 4 4 4 $2,351 $7Chatham 678 13 $34,158 19 17 14 19 $2,628 $50Cherokee 21 - $0 0 45 0 9 $0 $0Chowan 28 - $0 0 0 0 17 $0 $0Clay 31 - $0 0 0 0 9 $0 $0Cleveland 906 - $0 0 7 6 5 $0 $0Columbus 68 - $0 0 0 36 5 $0 $0Craven 78 - $0 0 0 0 3 $0 $0Cumberland 1,448 4 $8,497 3 4 8 4 $2,124 $6Currituck 33 - $0 0 32 0 7 $0 $0Dare 112 1 $719 9 17 13 8 $719 $6Davidson 3,899 22 $43,081 6 7 7 7 $1,958 $11Davie 848 6 $8,027 7 8 4 10 $1,338 $9Duplin 450 4 $8,109 9 16 57 17 $2,027 $18Durham 4,163 26 $61,494 6 8 9 7 $2,365 $15Edgecombe 1,286 19 $26,952 15 15 9 13 $1,419 $21Forsyth 3,972 23 $54,751 6 4 5 4 $2,380 $14Franklin 1,169 12 $25,631 10 14 14 12 $2,136 $22Gaston 5,168 23 $51,631 4 3 3 4 $2,245 $10Gates 6 1 $2,908 167 0 0 51 $2,908 $485Graham 18 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Granville 717 8 $11,205 11 21 24 16 $1,401 $16Greene 41 - $0 0 26 0 20 $0 $0Guilford 5,798 27 $70,817 5 5 4 4 $2,623 $12Halifax 1,229 12 $26,878 10 12 12 9 $2,240 $22Harnett 1,879 14 $30,553 7 8 8 8 $2,182 $16Haywood 1,053 - $0 0 0 2 0 $0 $0Henderson 2,094 4 $4,951 2 2 3 2 $1,238 $2Hertford 21 - $0 0 40 0 12 $0 $0Hoke 166 2 $3,116 12 0 19 8 $1,558 $19Hyde 13 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Iredell 5,891 35 $78,325 6 6 6 6 $2,238 $13Jackson 1,268 3 $5,625 2 2 0 2 $1,875 $4

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 31

Page 9: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumNC Johnston 3,261 28 $72,630 9 8 6 8 $2,594 $22

Jones 5 1 $2,083 200 0 0 48 $2,083 $417Lee 1,073 12 $34,110 11 11 7 10 $2,843 $32Lenoir 274 1 $5,025 4 8 0 7 $5,025 $18Lincoln 1,452 9 $21,010 6 9 10 7 $2,334 $14Macon 184 - $0 0 0 13 2 $0 $0Madison 127 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Martin 40 1 $1,432 25 0 0 6 $1,432 $36McDowell 1,224 4 $8,752 3 3 7 3 $2,188 $7Mecklenburg 15,349 42 $102,455 3 3 2 2 $2,439 $7Mitchell 65 2 $1,702 31 0 0 12 $851 $26Montgomery 535 14 $25,898 26 14 16 19 $1,850 $48Moore 1,305 12 $20,715 9 7 7 9 $1,726 $16Nash 1,278 13 $26,768 10 7 13 9 $2,059 $21New Hanover 253 2 $5,170 8 0 0 3 $2,585 $20Northampton 119 3 $6,164 25 0 21 18 $2,055 $52Onslow 57 - $0 0 19 0 16 $0 $0Orange 2,566 34 $84,464 13 14 20 14 $2,484 $33Pamlico 14 1 $1,230 71 0 77 29 $1,230 $88Pasquotank 18 - $0 0 0 0 10 $0 $0Pender 36 1 $4,720 28 24 26 26 $4,720 $131Perquimans 2 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Person 823 10 $21,401 12 22 14 16 $2,140 $26Pitt 1,798 18 $31,882 10 9 9 9 $1,771 $18Polk 801 7 $15,505 9 6 0 5 $2,215 $19Randolph 3,571 35 $74,271 10 9 9 9 $2,122 $21Richmond 348 1 $4,576 3 4 0 3 $4,576 $13Robeson 410 3 $5,693 7 8 0 5 $1,898 $14Rockingham 1,016 19 $38,546 19 13 17 15 $2,029 $38Rowan 2,241 7 $14,578 3 6 6 6 $2,083 $7Rutherford 838 10 $27,802 12 5 2 9 $2,780 $33Sampson 417 6 $16,490 14 10 7 8 $2,748 $40Scotland 348 1 $654 3 10 0 6 $654 $2Stanly 536 7 $16,966 13 11 0 11 $2,424 $32Stokes 279 2 $3,842 7 36 17 22 $1,921 $14Surry 640 8 $12,137 13 7 7 11 $1,517 $19Swain 142 - $0 0 8 0 2 $0 $0Transylvania 414 1 $12,885 2 3 11 6 $12,885 $31Tyrrell 2 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Union 3,733 18 $44,665 5 7 5 6 $2,481 $12Vance 462 9 $18,185 19 7 11 14 $2,021 $39Wake 20,612 105 $242,264 5 5 6 5 $2,307 $12Warren 148 1 $883 7 20 32 17 $883 $6Washington 7 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Watauga 737 4 $9,498 5 9 12 8 $2,374 $13Wayne 1,765 7 $17,747 4 4 2 4 $2,535 $10Wilkes 2,097 36 $60,352 17 14 14 16 $1,676 $29Wilson 604 4 $5,726 7 16 6 7 $1,431 $9Yadkin 617 17 $55,835 28 8 0 16 $3,284 $90Yancey 876 4 $6,984 5 17 8 9 $1,746 $8

Total NC 139,723 898 $2,002,987 6 6 7 6 $2,230 $14

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 32

Page 10: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumOH Adams 36 3 $7,144 83 61 0 64 $2,381 $198

Allen 2,679 17 $46,271 6 4 8 6 $2,722 $17Ashland 1,347 17 $46,151 13 14 8 13 $2,715 $34Ashtabula 4,396 53 $143,199 12 13 12 13 $2,702 $33Athens 236 6 $14,569 25 16 23 21 $2,428 $62Auglaize 1,237 16 $36,793 13 6 6 8 $2,300 $30Belmont 1,387 14 $25,708 10 12 15 14 $1,836 $19Brown 97 1 $1,297 10 10 0 15 $1,297 $13Butler 3,855 14 $36,117 4 6 4 4 $2,580 $9Carroll 482 13 $29,738 27 16 15 20 $2,288 $62Champaign 356 7 $19,594 20 28 22 22 $2,799 $55Clark 1,398 13 $27,601 9 4 5 6 $2,123 $20Clermont 1,672 11 $26,639 7 13 10 10 $2,422 $16Clinton 746 9 $14,666 12 11 12 14 $1,630 $20Columbiana 3,777 49 $107,966 13 11 13 11 $2,203 $29Coshocton 187 7 $13,281 37 32 14 32 $1,897 $71Crawford 397 2 $4,856 5 10 11 8 $2,428 $12Cuyahoga 14,184 38 $87,161 3 4 2 3 $2,294 $6Darke 2,187 19 $47,042 9 7 9 8 $2,476 $22Defiance 101 - $0 0 22 8 11 $0 $0Delaware 4,312 36 $95,220 8 6 9 9 $2,645 $22Erie 1,487 8 $18,894 5 4 3 4 $2,362 $13Fairfield 3,159 35 $73,930 11 11 12 11 $2,112 $23Fayette 637 3 $8,088 5 6 9 6 $2,696 $13Franklin 23,343 78 $247,413 3 3 3 3 $3,172 $11Fulton 1,271 7 $17,814 6 13 7 8 $2,545 $14Gallia 199 8 $16,924 40 11 59 31 $2,116 $85Geauga 1,804 18 $41,098 10 8 10 10 $2,283 $23Greene 3,316 18 $44,289 5 4 4 5 $2,461 $13Guernsey 548 8 $14,627 15 30 20 17 $1,828 $27Hamilton 6,290 22 $75,754 3 2 5 3 $3,443 $12Hancock 2,081 9 $22,664 4 8 4 6 $2,518 $11Hardin 774 6 $8,698 8 20 15 14 $1,450 $11Harrison 116 5 $7,321 43 26 52 34 $1,464 $63Henry 127 1 $4,072 8 24 17 12 $4,072 $32Highland 139 1 $2,073 7 13 17 15 $2,073 $15Hocking 184 3 $8,383 16 16 20 18 $2,794 $46Holmes 1,372 32 $68,136 23 30 31 28 $2,129 $50Huron 1,310 15 $42,437 11 7 9 9 $2,829 $32Jackson 47 3 $11,883 64 20 49 38 $3,961 $253Jefferson 1,402 13 $34,375 9 17 24 17 $2,644 $25Knox 946 26 $69,721 27 27 22 27 $2,682 $74Lake 6,856 22 $54,870 3 5 4 4 $2,494 $8Lawrence 1,235 15 $20,885 12 6 9 10 $1,392 $17Licking 3,679 46 $122,799 13 13 15 13 $2,670 $33

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 34

Page 11: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumOH Logan 461 8 $20,733 17 18 6 19 $2,592 $45

Lorain 3,168 9 $20,783 3 5 3 4 $2,309 $7Lucas 5,249 9 $20,496 2 2 4 2 $2,277 $4Madison 800 5 $15,091 6 7 10 7 $3,018 $19Mahoning 4,854 31 $74,086 6 5 5 7 $2,390 $15Marion 805 5 $11,428 6 9 8 8 $2,286 $14Medina 5,893 31 $76,313 5 7 8 6 $2,462 $13Meigs 536 15 $55,221 28 37 43 32 $3,681 $103Mercer 2,425 16 $44,229 7 8 11 9 $2,764 $18Miami 2,597 14 $46,177 5 6 6 5 $3,298 $18Monroe 379 13 $13,884 34 30 29 30 $1,068 $37Montgomery 15,165 44 $113,845 3 2 2 3 $2,587 $8Morgan 140 5 $11,969 36 8 28 21 $2,394 $85Morrow 1,139 17 $34,740 15 15 13 17 $2,044 $31Muskingum 693 8 $26,663 12 20 19 16 $3,333 $38Noble 47 2 $2,106 43 67 25 40 $1,053 $45Ottawa 830 6 $16,382 7 8 10 9 $2,730 $20Paulding 184 4 $7,965 22 6 0 11 $1,991 $43Perry 753 17 $36,382 23 26 25 26 $2,140 $48Pickaway 386 2 $8,250 5 5 7 7 $4,125 $21Pike 43 - $0 0 0 69 16 $0 $0Portage 3,776 22 $40,324 6 8 8 7 $1,833 $11Preble 865 10 $24,724 12 10 13 10 $2,472 $29Putnam 874 11 $24,481 13 10 6 10 $2,226 $28Richland 3,190 32 $74,332 10 12 8 10 $2,323 $23Ross 870 11 $23,218 13 10 8 13 $2,111 $27Sandusky 2,531 18 $40,485 7 6 7 7 $2,249 $16Scioto 242 7 $13,117 29 17 6 13 $1,874 $54Seneca 1,636 14 $38,205 9 10 7 7 $2,729 $23Shelby 1,011 7 $21,284 7 16 8 10 $3,041 $21Stark 15,278 76 $150,086 5 5 4 4 $1,975 $10Summit 13,277 42 $107,186 3 3 4 3 $2,552 $8Trumbull 6,498 57 $169,221 9 9 6 8 $2,969 $26Tuscarawas 1,803 35 $64,304 19 14 12 14 $1,837 $36Union 1,637 15 $37,055 9 9 8 9 $2,470 $23Van Wert 825 8 $11,144 10 7 7 8 $1,393 $14Vinton 29 1 $3,710 34 61 0 30 $3,710 $128Warren 3,515 19 $37,403 5 5 5 5 $1,969 $11Washington 3,274 45 $88,236 14 19 16 17 $1,961 $27Wayne 6,261 91 $190,496 15 10 14 12 $2,093 $30Williams 349 5 $10,910 14 20 4 13 $2,182 $31Wood 1,835 7 $12,777 4 3 4 3 $1,825 $7Wyandot 107 - $0 0 10 13 11 $0 $0

Total OH 223,621 1,541 $3,707,600 7 7 7 7 $2,406 $17

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 35

Page 12: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumPA Adams 8,886 99 $219,102 11 11 15 13 $2,213 $25

Allegheny 149,506 1,051 $2,343,890 7 7 7 7 $2,230 $16Armstrong 9,596 290 $659,067 30 31 32 32 $2,273 $69Beaver 27,032 264 $555,267 10 10 11 10 $2,103 $21Bedford 6,434 160 $326,808 25 33 51 39 $2,043 $51Berks 44,176 340 $780,179 8 9 11 9 $2,295 $18Blair 11,297 93 $233,970 8 10 15 12 $2,516 $21Bradford 10,300 303 $580,443 29 37 41 37 $1,916 $56Bucks 31,623 318 $774,607 10 9 10 10 $2,436 $24Butler 30,097 554 $1,241,623 18 18 23 20 $2,241 $41Cambria 14,375 192 $396,450 13 14 21 17 $2,065 $28Cameron 1,318 40 $73,372 30 35 47 40 $1,834 $56Carbon 8,935 120 $248,791 13 13 14 15 $2,073 $28Centre 11,733 174 $385,881 15 13 21 17 $2,218 $33Chester 25,966 290 $735,709 11 11 10 11 $2,537 $28Clarion 7,842 302 $577,593 39 37 41 39 $1,913 $74Clearfield 10,179 285 $539,904 28 26 34 32 $1,894 $53Clinton 5,595 69 $140,368 12 16 21 17 $2,034 $25Columbia 8,378 118 $262,809 14 18 25 20 $2,227 $31Crawford 15,664 432 $879,202 28 35 35 34 $2,035 $56Cumberland 37,068 233 $530,745 6 7 9 7 $2,278 $14Dauphin 31,623 225 $498,310 7 8 9 8 $2,215 $16Delaware 10,946 38 $99,201 3 5 4 4 $2,611 $9Elk 8,361 131 $291,279 16 14 24 19 $2,224 $35Erie 58,674 512 $1,158,659 9 9 13 11 $2,263 $20Fayette 14,773 214 $446,943 14 17 19 17 $2,089 $30Forest 849 32 $51,937 38 35 66 47 $1,623 $61Franklin 14,687 158 $315,800 11 9 13 11 $1,999 $22Fulton 2,111 77 $163,224 36 38 69 45 $2,120 $77Greene 3,044 81 $162,833 27 30 35 32 $2,010 $53Huntingdon 3,351 99 $188,883 30 29 53 37 $1,908 $56Indiana 10,725 321 $639,984 30 35 40 36 $1,994 $60Jefferson 9,692 309 $612,908 32 35 39 37 $1,984 $63Juniata 1,826 27 $50,799 15 19 22 20 $1,881 $28Lackawanna 19,677 130 $351,873 7 9 10 8 $2,707 $18Lancaster 53,798 195 $488,561 4 5 5 5 $2,505 $9Lawrence 11,091 140 $364,152 13 15 16 15 $2,601 $33Lebanon 19,167 107 $234,617 6 6 7 7 $2,193 $12Lehigh 48,534 298 $700,054 6 7 7 7 $2,349 $14Luzerne 35,176 293 $676,315 8 8 10 9 $2,308 $19Lycoming 14,407 206 $435,268 14 19 19 18 $2,113 $30McKean 6,406 168 $347,228 26 29 44 34 $2,067 $54Mercer 19,738 375 $829,471 19 19 23 21 $2,212 $42Mifflin 3,512 30 $57,818 9 8 10 10 $1,927 $16Monroe 12,347 195 $435,223 16 18 24 20 $2,232 $35

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 38

Page 13: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumPA Montgomery 44,975 337 $881,125 7 7 7 7 $2,615 $20

Montour 2,164 32 $64,215 15 12 17 16 $2,007 $30Northampton 44,407 352 $796,134 8 9 10 9 $2,262 $18Northumberland 13,020 156 $325,667 12 10 14 13 $2,088 $25Perry 6,477 88 $164,865 14 13 25 18 $1,873 $25Philadelphia 10,202 13 $41,365 1 2 0 1 $3,182 $4Pike 2,470 53 $120,853 21 26 40 31 $2,280 $49Potter 3,494 139 $263,154 40 41 68 54 $1,893 $75Schuylkill 16,580 178 $370,252 11 14 19 15 $2,080 $22Snyder 5,948 55 $141,122 9 8 13 11 $2,566 $24Somerset 10,918 190 $386,298 17 20 29 25 $2,033 $35Sullivan 900 49 $125,682 54 56 72 65 $2,565 $140Susquehanna 2,047 77 $155,248 38 36 62 46 $2,016 $76Tioga 9,731 349 $612,591 36 41 50 45 $1,755 $63Union 4,913 56 $131,008 11 11 18 14 $2,339 $27Venango 8,793 251 $532,888 29 31 38 34 $2,123 $61Warren 10,367 296 $582,557 29 31 38 34 $1,968 $56Washington 29,009 530 $1,062,166 18 19 21 19 $2,004 $37Wayne 2,587 55 $105,599 21 23 41 31 $1,920 $41Westmoreland 56,680 776 $1,700,927 14 14 16 15 $2,192 $30Wyoming 2,343 66 $133,587 28 33 40 34 $2,024 $57York 32,988 226 $470,810 7 8 10 9 $2,083 $14

Total PA 1,211,528 14,412 $31,255,234 12 13 16 14 $2,169 $26

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 39

Page 14: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumTN Anderson 178 - $0 0 5 0 3 $0 $0

Bedford 33 - $0 0 32 0 17 $0 $0Benton 6 - $0 0 0 0 34 $0 $0Bledsoe 6 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Blount 734 4 $9,622 5 1 2 3 $2,405 $13Bradley 629 2 $3,130 3 4 2 3 $1,565 $5Campbell 267 - $0 0 3 0 1 $0 $0Cannon 72 - $0 0 16 0 11 $0 $0Carroll 1 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Carter 721 5 $8,387 7 4 6 4 $1,677 $12Cheatham 152 1 $4,263 7 14 0 14 $4,263 $28Chester 2 - $0 0 N/A 0 0 $0 $0Claiborne 87 1 $5,537 11 0 0 4 $5,537 $64Clay 35 - $0 0 23 0 11 $0 $0Cocke 111 2 $3,686 18 7 3 9 $1,843 $33Coffee 169 1 $1,300 6 0 83 9 $1,300 $8Crockett - - $0 N/A N/A 0 N/A $0 $0Cumberland 195 2 $4,247 10 5 16 6 $2,123 $22Davidson 3,018 10 $39,483 3 2 3 2 $3,948 $13De Kalb 15 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Decatur - - $0 N/A 0 0 0 $0 $0Dickson 58 2 $3,523 34 19 0 21 $1,762 $61Dyer - - $0 N/A 0 0 0 $0 $0Fayette - - $0 N/A 1000 0 333 $0 $0Fentress 27 - $0 0 0 0 17 $0 $0Franklin 37 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Gibson 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Giles 58 1 $852 17 38 0 14 $852 $15Grainger 87 1 $1,203 11 0 0 8 $1,203 $14Greene 1,082 7 $13,672 6 4 4 4 $1,953 $13Grundy 3 - $0 0 0 0 42 $0 $0Hamblen 578 2 $2,974 3 0 3 4 $1,487 $5Hamilton 951 1 $929 1 4 4 2 $929 $1Hancock 8 - $0 0 0 83 19 $0 $0Hardeman - - $0 N/A N/A 0 N/A $0 $0Hardin 1 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Hawkins 422 3 $7,751 7 6 2 5 $2,584 $18Haywood - - $0 N/A N/A 0 0 $0 $0Henderson 5 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Henry 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Hickman 22 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Houston 2 - $0 0 N/A 0 0 $0 $0Humphreys 13 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Jackson 22 - $0 0 0 0 10 $0 $0Jefferson 352 - $0 0 0 6 3 $0 $0Johnson 416 6 $8,650 14 13 25 15 $1,442 $21Knox 3,028 4 $6,932 1 1 1 1 $1,733 $2Lake 4 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Lauderdale - - $0 N/A N/A 0 0 $0 $0Lawrence 15 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 41

Page 15: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumTN Lewis 3 - $0 0 N/A 0 0 $0 $0

Lincoln 5 1 $2,560 200 143 0 95 $2,560 $512Loudon 404 2 $5,243 5 6 5 5 $2,622 $13Macon 489 9 $17,078 18 18 0 24 $1,898 $35Madison 34 - $0 0 0 59 7 $0 $0Marion 24 1 $1,760 42 45 0 22 $1,760 $73Marshall 18 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Maury 232 2 $5,770 9 16 0 10 $2,885 $25McMinn 109 - $0 0 0 0 5 $0 $0McNairy 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Meigs 34 - $0 0 0 28 11 $0 $0Monroe 347 3 $8,280 9 0 3 3 $2,760 $24Montgomery 316 2 $4,085 6 15 0 10 $2,043 $13Moore - - $0 N/A N/A 0 N/A $0 $0Morgan 18 - $0 0 0 53 25 $0 $0Obion - - $0 N/A N/A 0 N/A $0 $0Overton 270 6 $8,883 22 3 4 9 $1,481 $33Perry 4 - $0 0 250 0 37 $0 $0Pickett 35 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Polk 36 - $0 0 23 0 5 $0 $0Putnam 480 2 $2,027 4 4 7 5 $1,013 $4Rhea 35 1 $1,144 29 30 0 16 $1,144 $33Roane 472 5 $6,502 11 9 0 6 $1,300 $14Robertson 253 1 $2,900 4 0 40 4 $2,900 $11Rutherford 1,702 5 $14,858 3 5 4 3 $2,972 $9Scott 16 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Sequatchie 9 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Sevier 451 2 $1,231 4 0 0 2 $615 $3Shelby 85 1 $957 12 0 0 3 $957 $11Smith 14 - $0 0 0 0 14 $0 $0Stewart 7 - $0 0 200 0 67 $0 $0Sullivan 3,707 22 $53,113 6 4 4 4 $2,414 $14Sumner 679 2 $4,146 3 6 0 6 $2,073 $6Tipton 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Trousdale 10 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Unicoi 304 1 $3,944 3 12 6 6 $3,944 $13Union 49 - $0 0 0 14 3 $0 $0Van Buren 1 - $0 0 N/A 0 0 $0 $0Warren 48 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Washington 2,234 6 $9,534 3 4 3 3 $1,589 $4Wayne - - $0 N/A N/A 0 0 $0 $0Weakley 1 - $0 0 0 0 200 $0 $0White 39 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Williamson 975 7 $14,679 7 3 6 6 $2,097 $15Wilson 557 1 $158 2 8 0 5 $158 $0

Total TN 28,140 137 $294,993 5 5 4 4 $2,153 $10

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 42

Page 16: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumVA Accomack 71 1 $785 14 0 27 7 $785 $11

Albemarle 2,522 32 $81,303 13 13 13 14 $2,541 $32Alleghany 1,352 15 $25,517 11 13 15 15 $1,701 $19Amelia 791 13 $26,890 16 25 19 22 $2,068 $34Amherst 914 15 $30,010 16 15 13 18 $2,001 $33Appomattox 246 1 $1,496 4 34 43 28 $1,496 $6Arlington 3,177 2 $2,986 1 1 2 1 $1,493 $1Augusta 9,653 98 $179,955 10 11 12 11 $1,836 $19Bath 139 6 $7,037 43 43 65 47 $1,173 $51Bedford 2,293 48 $94,494 21 15 16 19 $1,969 $41Bland 284 3 $3,866 11 29 46 29 $1,289 $14Botetourt 1,112 19 $36,565 17 11 13 12 $1,924 $33Brunswick 301 9 $15,989 30 17 42 26 $1,777 $53Buchanan 321 - $0 0 0 0 1 $0 $0Buckingham 134 1 $3,641 7 29 31 25 $3,641 $27Campbell 1,942 22 $42,742 11 15 22 16 $1,943 $22Caroline 409 6 $9,038 15 15 27 15 $1,506 $22Carroll 2,845 47 $78,743 17 20 21 17 $1,675 $28Charles City 125 4 $8,709 32 16 18 23 $2,177 $70Charlotte 143 6 $8,226 42 57 30 41 $1,371 $58Chesterfield 7,849 26 $56,849 3 5 6 4 $2,187 $7Clarke 549 8 $15,778 15 16 30 18 $1,972 $29Craig 138 5 $10,249 36 30 8 34 $2,050 $74Culpeper 1,737 30 $78,531 17 11 26 16 $2,618 $45Cumberland 143 1 $484 7 43 65 34 $484 $3Dickenson 70 - $0 0 13 17 8 $0 $0Dinwiddie 635 7 $14,579 11 11 9 10 $2,083 $23Essex 84 - $0 0 36 23 15 $0 $0Fairfax 18,554 52 $136,304 3 2 4 3 $2,621 $7Fauquier 2,460 24 $58,513 10 17 19 16 $2,438 $24Floyd 541 21 $37,313 39 18 43 36 $1,777 $69Fluvanna 811 17 $28,216 21 22 19 21 $1,660 $35Franklin 3,019 72 $119,956 24 23 22 21 $1,666 $40Frederick 3,310 53 $102,409 16 14 11 15 $1,932 $31Giles 1,888 21 $33,916 11 13 22 17 $1,615 $18Gloucester 172 - $0 0 6 16 8 $0 $0Goochland 514 10 $31,626 19 6 31 14 $3,163 $62Grayson 1,788 42 $55,040 23 23 23 27 $1,310 $31Greene 541 5 $8,353 9 11 25 14 $1,671 $15Greensville 15 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Halifax 1,231 29 $50,148 24 16 28 26 $1,729 $41Hanover 3,605 21 $56,222 6 4 7 6 $2,677 $16Henrico 6,590 25 $69,697 4 4 4 3 $2,788 $11Henry 3,118 49 $77,611 16 20 21 20 $1,584 $25Highland 98 5 $4,205 51 20 76 51 $841 $43

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 44

Page 17: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumVA Isle of Wight 140 3 $9,355 21 0 57 13 $3,118 $67

James City 473 1 $2,711 2 13 8 8 $2,711 $6King and Queen 138 1 $901 7 15 33 15 $901 $7King George 572 3 $5,828 5 5 5 7 $1,943 $10King William 316 3 $8,431 9 16 5 11 $2,810 $27Lancaster 82 1 $3,125 12 42 18 15 $3,125 $38Lee 60 - $0 0 0 45 10 $0 $0Loudoun 7,041 56 $138,717 8 7 10 9 $2,477 $20Louisa 1,802 15 $32,652 8 19 24 17 $2,177 $18Lunenburg 102 2 $5,106 20 87 75 41 $2,553 $50Madison 246 11 $32,818 45 13 5 23 $2,983 $133Mathews 88 1 $1,539 11 0 0 8 $1,539 $17Mecklenburg 1,859 22 $64,483 12 14 19 15 $2,931 $35Middlesex 146 4 $8,673 27 7 0 15 $2,168 $59Montgomery 3,444 39 $69,729 11 12 15 12 $1,788 $20Nelson 817 16 $33,652 20 28 34 29 $2,103 $41New Kent 479 3 $9,212 6 13 21 14 $3,071 $19Northampton 22 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Northumberland 152 2 $3,726 13 7 0 10 $1,863 $25Nottoway 117 6 $14,406 51 42 0 28 $2,401 $123Orange 1,381 23 $50,778 17 19 23 21 $2,208 $37Page 1,810 17 $38,838 9 12 12 12 $2,285 $21Patrick 2,026 55 $104,181 27 28 24 28 $1,894 $51Pittsylvania 3,340 56 $83,270 17 20 17 18 $1,487 $25Powhatan 918 6 $15,710 7 13 20 14 $2,618 $17Prince Edward 450 14 $22,331 31 28 39 24 $1,595 $50Prince George 590 6 $19,525 10 7 9 9 $3,254 $33Prince William 6,633 28 $92,884 4 3 6 5 $3,317 $14Pulaski 2,877 34 $57,261 12 9 12 13 $1,684 $20Rappahannock 354 11 $21,611 31 25 47 29 $1,965 $61Richmond 99 3 $5,802 30 0 0 6 $1,934 $59Roanoke 5,331 32 $64,916 6 7 10 8 $2,029 $12Rockbridge 930 7 $24,610 8 20 16 17 $3,516 $26Rockingham 7,502 66 $117,594 9 8 11 9 $1,782 $16Russell 1,307 6 $9,289 5 7 7 7 $1,548 $7Scott 952 13 $16,371 14 15 16 17 $1,259 $17Shenandoah 2,582 43 $81,520 17 16 14 15 $1,896 $32Smyth 2,124 11 $18,833 5 9 5 6 $1,712 $9Southampton 50 - $0 0 51 0 10 $0 $0Spotsylvania 3,480 22 $86,385 6 4 8 6 $3,927 $25Stafford 2,608 9 $17,779 3 5 6 5 $1,975 $7Surry 36 1 $2,547 28 53 50 32 $2,547 $71Sussex 39 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Tazewell 1,819 12 $22,573 7 9 12 8 $1,881 $12Warren 2,606 35 $78,034 13 17 14 16 $2,230 $30

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 45

Page 18: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumVA Washington 3,229 18 $19,846 6 5 3 5 $1,103 $6

Westmoreland 251 - $0 0 4 23 12 $0 $0Wise 255 - $0 0 0 0 6 $0 $0Wythe 3,134 34 $67,535 11 12 12 13 $1,986 $22York 356 - $0 0 3 0 2 $0 $0Alexandria 2,901 8 $18,850 3 2 3 2 $2,356 $6Bedford City 278 6 $13,628 22 21 37 26 $2,271 $49Bristol 1,023 2 $1,245 2 3 0 2 $623 $1Buena Vista 375 2 $3,784 5 5 21 10 $1,892 $10Charlottesville 956 8 $16,670 8 14 18 11 $2,084 $17Chesapeake 1,072 1 $2,519 1 2 3 2 $2,519 $2Clifton Forge 125 2 $2,369 16 16 0 11 $1,184 $19Colonial Heights 534 1 $1,565 2 2 10 3 $1,565 $3Covington 212 8 $6,421 38 23 18 27 $803 $30Danville 1,389 15 $33,602 11 12 15 11 $2,240 $24Emporia 18 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Fairfax City 339 1 $2,052 3 3 3 3 $2,052 $6Falls Chruch 276 - $0 0 0 0 1 $0 $0Franklin City 25 - $0 0 0 0 9 $0 $0Fredericksburg 1,028 3 $15,251 3 4 6 4 $5,084 $15Galax 602 8 $13,561 13 11 14 12 $1,695 $23Hampton 450 1 $1,750 2 0 0 1 $1,750 $4Harrisonburg 1,495 10 $18,536 7 5 6 7 $1,854 $12Hopewell 299 1 $1,470 3 7 0 5 $1,470 $5Lexington 63 - $0 0 0 56 14 $0 $0Lynchburg 1,733 12 $21,637 7 11 13 10 $1,803 $12Manassas City 520 7 $17,407 13 0 5 6 $2,487 $33Manassas Park City 70 - $0 0 0 0 3 $0 $0Martinsville 263 2 $3,366 8 21 15 14 $1,683 $13Newport News 827 2 $2,810 2 1 3 3 $1,405 $3Norfolk 341 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Norton 3 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Petersburg 354 - $0 0 5 0 3 $0 $0Poquoson City 90 - $0 0 0 0 0 $0 $0Portsmouth 123 2 $9,697 16 9 0 6 $4,849 $79Radford 746 8 $10,149 11 9 3 10 $1,269 $14Richmond City 2,835 4 $6,196 1 3 1 2 $1,549 $2Roanoke City 1,846 5 $13,835 3 3 7 5 $2,767 $7Salem 1,155 4 $6,202 3 7 3 6 $1,550 $5South Boston 654 8 $15,917 12 15 19 14 $1,990 $24Staunton 1,151 9 $11,850 8 8 2 4 $1,317 $10Suffolk 184 - $0 0 0 9 3 $0 $0Virginia Beach 1,964 1 $2,973 1 1 1 1 $2,973 $2Waynesboro 1,492 13 $23,051 9 5 6 8 $1,773 $15Williamsburg 227 - $0 0 0 0 3 $0 $0Winchester 1,995 21 $44,804 11 9 10 11 $2,134 $22

Total VA 196,778 1,789 $3,616,330 9 10 11 10 $2,021 $18

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 46

Page 19: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumWV Barbour 502 16 $23,433 32 30 47 37 $1,465 $47

Berkeley 6,167 76 $149,858 12 13 14 13 $1,972 $24Boone 2,641 20 $40,454 8 13 13 13 $2,023 $15Braxton 376 13 $19,988 35 20 43 42 $1,538 $53Brooke 787 13 $25,458 17 20 25 20 $1,958 $32Cabell 4,793 39 $108,130 8 9 15 11 $2,773 $23Calhoun 88 6 $8,903 68 33 28 54 $1,484 $101Clay 216 5 $8,897 23 35 26 32 $1,779 $41Doddridge 202 8 $15,126 40 48 63 44 $1,891 $75Fayette 2,578 21 $51,914 8 12 9 11 $2,472 $20Gilmer 47 2 $1,491 43 20 29 63 $745 $32Grant 943 32 $51,918 34 50 54 48 $1,622 $55Greenbrier 2,571 47 $93,125 18 18 26 24 $1,981 $36Hampshire 1,683 56 $93,906 33 24 37 31 $1,677 $56Hancock 2,260 34 $77,991 15 16 19 17 $2,294 $35Hardy 1,199 36 $72,789 30 35 59 40 $2,022 $61Harrison 3,980 59 $130,069 15 15 23 18 $2,205 $33Jackson 2,010 64 $124,832 32 40 51 40 $1,951 $62Jefferson 2,175 52 $114,521 24 26 28 26 $2,202 $53Kanawha 13,292 78 $166,855 6 8 11 8 $2,139 $13Lewis 588 13 $30,662 22 32 24 29 $2,359 $52Lincoln 698 10 $31,425 14 20 20 24 $3,143 $45Logan 382 3 $7,500 8 8 20 12 $2,500 $20Marion 3,426 45 $91,920 13 12 21 16 $2,043 $27Marshall 3,201 46 $91,862 14 16 21 18 $1,997 $29Mason 963 28 $47,658 29 32 42 35 $1,702 $49McDowell 92 2 $4,271 22 10 0 7 $2,135 $46Mercer 2,449 17 $29,433 7 5 7 6 $1,731 $12Mineral 4,706 115 $203,763 24 19 28 23 $1,772 $43Mingo 135 1 $2,085 7 7 22 8 $2,085 $15Monongalia 4,603 63 $157,258 14 12 12 13 $2,496 $34Monroe 495 10 $25,023 20 34 37 31 $2,502 $51Morgan 412 13 $27,894 32 17 45 28 $2,146 $68Nicholas 1,416 27 $44,361 19 18 22 23 $1,643 $31Ohio 4,057 48 $81,676 12 11 19 13 $1,702 $20Pendleton 350 11 $18,717 31 34 67 44 $1,702 $53Pleasants 313 6 $8,389 19 21 38 30 $1,398 $27Pocahontas 134 4 $5,458 30 56 48 60 $1,364 $41Preston 3,279 87 $182,344 27 22 28 28 $2,096 $56Putnam 3,933 50 $112,379 13 12 20 16 $2,248 $29Raleigh 7,097 30 $74,979 4 7 7 7 $2,499 $11Randolph 2,223 44 $86,365 20 21 33 28 $1,963 $39Ritchie 257 5 $6,406 19 26 107 56 $1,281 $25Roane 714 33 $61,119 46 41 38 41 $1,852 $86Summers 294 2 $1,908 7 31 33 24 $954 $6

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 48

Page 20: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumWV Taylor 844 19 $47,178 23 24 16 24 $2,483 $56

Tucker 265 10 $34,078 38 36 53 47 $3,408 $129Tyler 468 17 $28,189 36 48 55 48 $1,658 $60Upshur 827 16 $30,725 19 13 34 23 $1,920 $37Wayne 972 11 $22,243 11 9 20 15 $2,022 $23Webster 174 - $0 0 49 47 40 $0 $0Wetzel 1,222 37 $77,755 30 41 54 43 $2,101 $64Wirt 101 4 $5,975 40 51 116 50 $1,494 $59Wood 6,378 120 $248,814 19 18 22 19 $2,073 $39Wyoming 1,242 15 $25,665 12 8 11 10 $1,711 $21

Total WV 107,220 1,639 $3,335,133 15 16 21 18 $2,035 $31

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 49

Page 21: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumWI Adams 42 1 $3,629 24 29 N/A 19 $3,629 $86

Ashland 7 - $0 0 0 N/A 63 $0 $0Barron 216 2 $7,835 9 15 N/A 22 $3,918 $36Bayfield 16 2 $6,412 125 71 N/A 68 $3,206 $401Brown 1,355 16 $40,075 12 6 0 9 $2,505 $30Buffalo 19 1 $2,981 53 154 N/A 63 $2,981 $157Burnett 6 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Calumet 845 5 $10,668 6 13 0 15 $2,134 $13Chippewa 120 5 $20,421 42 24 N/A 43 $4,084 $170Clark 10 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Columbia 157 1 $2,484 6 34 N/A 14 $2,484 $16Crawford 6 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Dane 3,286 22 $73,708 7 8 29 8 $3,350 $22Dodge 482 10 $26,657 21 12 333 18 $2,666 $55Door 777 17 $35,691 22 27 N/A 26 $2,099 $46Douglas 6 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Dunn 412 10 $30,395 24 22 N/A 23 $3,039 $74Eau Claire 363 4 $11,649 11 24 N/A 14 $2,912 $32Florence 7 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Fond du Lac 126 - $0 0 0 0 9 $0 $0Forest 50 - $0 0 43 N/A 21 $0 $0Grant 186 4 $6,773 22 7 N/A 23 $1,693 $36Green 362 7 $25,948 19 10 0 19 $3,707 $72Green Lake 26 - $0 0 71 0 36 $0 $0Iowa 252 8 $20,576 32 28 N/A 30 $2,572 $82Iron 8 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Jackson 108 2 $3,898 19 61 N/A 28 $1,949 $36Jefferson 393 4 $10,286 10 3 0 8 $2,571 $26Juneau 239 5 $14,322 21 25 0 29 $2,864 $60Kenosha 1,066 6 $28,020 6 3 0 5 $4,670 $26Kewaunee 104 3 $5,671 29 22 N/A 29 $1,890 $55La Crosse 662 9 $24,495 14 9 0 11 $2,722 $37Lafayette 26 1 $940 38 80 N/A 38 $940 $36Langlade 30 1 $770 33 105 N/A 52 $770 $26Lincoln 375 4 $6,753 11 19 N/A 16 $1,688 $18Manitowoc 205 2 $6,274 10 22 N/A 23 $3,137 $31Marathon 612 13 $42,470 21 21 N/A 20 $3,267 $69Marinette 276 6 $14,110 22 25 N/A 23 $2,352 $51Marquette 24 1 $3,008 42 0 N/A 13 $3,008 $125Menominee 27 1 $1,665 37 0 N/A 36 $1,665 $62Milwaukee 4,418 7 $13,130 2 2 0 2 $1,876 $3Monroe 569 9 $15,517 16 23 1000 23 $1,724 $27Oconto 237 5 $16,994 21 18 N/A 29 $3,399 $72Oneida 58 2 $7,369 34 122 N/A 61 $3,684 $127Outagamie 1,363 14 $27,950 10 11 0 12 $1,996 $21

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 51

Page 22: Deer Claim Study Counties

ERIE INSURANCE GROUP 6/13/2006

PRIVATE PASSENGER AUTO

Deer Claim Statistics by State by County - Calendar Year 2005

20052005 Deer Claim 5-Year

2005 2005 Paid Frequency 2004 2001 (01-05) 2005 2005Comprehensive Number Losses (claims per Deer Deer Deer Deer Deer

Earned of Deer for Deer 1,000 Claim Claim Claim Claim PureState County Exposures Claims Claims exposures) Frequency Frequency Frequency Severity PremiumWI Ozaukee 263 2 $6,142 8 10 1000 12 $3,071 $23

Pepin 5 - $0 0 0 N/A 83 $0 $0Pierce 108 3 $8,497 28 0 N/A 24 $2,832 $79Polk 17 1 $3,429 59 0 N/A 50 $3,429 $202Portage 327 3 $6,415 9 12 N/A 12 $2,138 $20Price 6 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Racine 1,662 4 $4,639 2 1 0 3 $1,160 $3Richland 24 - $0 0 50 N/A 16 $0 $0Rock 1,014 3 $10,081 3 11 0 7 $3,360 $10Rusk 8 - $0 0 143 N/A 45 $0 $0St. Croix 54 - $0 0 26 N/A 8 $0 $0Sauk 113 2 $3,848 18 11 N/A 21 $1,924 $34Sawyer 12 - $0 0 250 N/A 115 $0 $0Shawano 468 13 $28,723 28 28 0 26 $2,209 $61Sheboygan 556 4 $6,590 7 13 0 10 $1,648 $12Taylor - - $0 N/A 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Trempealeau 76 3 $6,710 39 0 N/A 21 $2,237 $88Vernon 265 11 $29,757 42 66 0 53 $2,705 $112Vilas 31 - $0 0 0 N/A 0 $0 $0Walworth 336 5 $5,860 15 18 0 15 $1,172 $17Washburn 12 - $0 0 100 N/A 33 $0 $0Washington 395 3 $9,988 8 12 0 8 $3,329 $25Waukesha 2,710 13 $29,319 5 10 0 7 $2,255 $11Waupaca 99 1 $2,236 10 34 1000 37 $2,236 $23Waushara 38 1 $1,121 26 0 N/A 27 $1,121 $29Winnebago 1,079 12 $20,442 11 7 0 10 $1,703 $19Wood 144 1 $2,115 7 14 N/A 17 $2,115 $15

Total WI 29,756 295 $755,454 10 11 29 12 $2,561 $25

I:\PERSONAL\AUTO\DEER\DEER CLAIM STATISTICS BY STATE (98-05).XLS 52


Recommended