DELIVERABLE
Project Acronym: BeingEnergy
Grant Agreement number: 303476
Project Title: Integrated low temperature methanol steam reforming and high temperature polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
Revision: 1.1
Authors: Alfredo Silva (INOVA+)
Project co-funded by the FCH-JU within the Seventh Framework Programme
Dissemination Level
P Public X
C Confidential, only for members of the consortium and the Commission Services
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 2 of 19
Revision History
Revision Date Author Organisation Description
1.0 22/04/2016 Alfredo Silva INOVA+ First version
1.1 27/04/2016 Adélio Mendes,
Marta Boaventura UPORTO Revision
Statement of originality:
This deliverable contains original unpublished work except where clearly indicated otherwise.
Acknowledgement of previously published material and of the work of others has been made through appropriate citation, quotation or both.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 3 of 19
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
1. Executive Summary ..................................................................................................................................................4
2. Dissemination Objectives and Planning ....................................................................................................................5
2.1 Dissemination objectives ........................................................................................................................................ 5
2.2 Target audience ...................................................................................................................................................... 5
2.3 Methods and tools .................................................................................................................................................. 6
3. Website................................................................................................................................................................7
4. Publications .......................................................................................................................................................8
5. Dissemination Actions .................................................................................................................................9
5.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................ 9
5.2 Dissemination actions per partner .......................................................................................................................... 9
5.3 Hannover Messe Fair participation ....................................................................................................................... 11
5.4 Review Days participation .................................................................................................................................... 12
6. Conferences..................................................................................................................................................... 13
6.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................................................... 13
6.2 Conference selection ............................................................................................................................................. 13
6.3 ICCMR conference series ....................................................................................................................................... 13
6.4 The ICCMR11 event ............................................................................................................................................... 14
6.5 The ICCMR12 event ............................................................................................................................................... 14
7. Conclusions ............................................................................................................................................................ 15
Annex I – Project Flyer and Handout............................................................................................................................ 16
Annex II – ICCMR11 Presentation ................................................................................................................................ 18
Annex III – ICCMR12 Presentation ............................................................................................................................... 19
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 4 of 19
1. Executive Summary
Even though BeingEnergy was a R&D project, part of the work effort was dedicated to
dissemination, as it was considered important to build awareness to the project as to prepare its
future exploitation. This effort was a large part of BeingEnergy’s work package 6.
The detailed planning of the dissemination work took place in the first six months of the project,
and were detailed in deliverable D6.2 – Dissemination Plan. The consortium followed this plan
through the life of the project, adapting it as required based on available resources and
opportunity. By the end of BeingEnergy the dissemination plan had been implemented
successfully, with all of the dissemination objectives having been achieved and even surpassed
in some areas (e.g. the project had planned to participate in one conference, but was able to
participate in two).
The current document details the entire dissemination effort of the project. The deliverable is
structured in successive sections as to follow a logic path, from the dissemination planning to the
various actions done, to the conclusions:
Dissemination Objectives and Planning: what the dissemination effort aimed to
accomplish, and how it would be done through the project’s life;
Website: online presentation of the project;
Publications: scientific papers published as a result of the project’s work;
Dissemination Actions: various dissemination actions done by the consortium partners;
Conferences: conferences were the project presented its results;
Conclusions: analysis and wrap up of the dissemination effort.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 5 of 19
2. Dissemination Objectives and Planning
2.1 Dissemination objectives
The aim of the BeingEnergy project was to develop a fuel cell power supply prototype based on
the synergetic integration of high temperature polymer electrolyte fuel cell (HT-PEMFC) stack and
low temperature methanol steam reforming reactor using a very active new reforming catalyst.
Such a fuel cell had great commercial values, which is why, during the project’s execution, the
consortium considered several options for its future exploitation.
A key part of the preparation of the project’s future exploitation was building awareness to it. As
such BeingEnergy included Work Package 6 (WP6), led by INOVA+, to perform this work. All other
7 project partners (UPORTO, DLR, VTT, SerEnergy, ITM-CNR, UPVLC-ITQ, and Rhodia/Solvay)
also participated in some capacity in the dissemination effort.
The dissemination work had the following objectives:
Create awareness: make the project known to industry and academia across Europe,
through participation in conferences and workshops, and contacts with associates/clients;
Disseminate project results: make the project results known in order to prepare their
future exploitation;
Feedback collection: obtaining responses from dissemination audiences in order to improve
the project’s work, and improve the future exploitation plan.
2.2 Target audience
The dissemination work was aimed at the following primary target audiences:
Scientific community: research centres, universities, and any other organisations
dedicated to R&D in the energy sector that could have an interest in the technology being
developed;
SMEs/large companies: companies of all sizes that could have an interest in the fuel cell
technology as systems integrators, business partners, or end users;
Venture capitalists: entrepreneurs that could be interested in investing in the fuel cell area,
and in the BeingEnergy technology.
Public sector: public sector organisations such as Energy, Technology, or Environment
Ministries that could have an interest in supporting the deployment of new fuel cell
technologies for economic, technological, or environmental reasons.
In addition to the above the consortium also considered a number of secondary target audiences.
These were audiences which will not be specifically targeted, but which could nevertheless be
exposed to the project as a result of other dissemination activities (e.g. the project Web site,
papers publication, participation in event, etc.). Secondary targets included:
Organisations outside the energy sector: entities which were not part of the primary
targets of the dissemination work, but that nevertheless could have an interest in the
results of the project.
General public: all individuals, related or not to the core target audiences that show an
interest will be given information on the project work and the fuel cells sector.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 6 of 19
2.3 Methods and tools
A wide variety of dissemination methods and tools were envisaged to be mobilized and used by
all project partners: project Web site, contact networks, participation in seminars and relevant
events, press releases and publications in media, etc. While these are the planned activities, the
consortium took advantage of other dissemination opportunities that arose during the project’s
duration (e.g. participation in Hannover Mess 2015).
The table below describes the relationship between the target groups and the dissemination
methods and tools.
Table 1 – Relationship between targets and tools of dissemination
Dissemination
activity Target Groups Means and Tools
Local dissemination
of project results
- Private or public organisations
- General public
- Personal contact
- Meetings
- Web site
Dissemination of
general applicability
world wide
- Public sector service
- Companies (system integrators,
end users)
- Venture capitalists,
- Printed materials
- Personal contact
- Web site
Dissemination of
commercial
potentials
- Companies (system integrators,
end users)
- Venture capitalists,
- Public sector service organizers
- Distribution network
of partners
- Personal contact
- Meetings
Dissemination of the
scientific results
- Scientific community
- Companies interested in the
developed products
- Scientific papers
- Event participation
In order to support the dissemination work, the consortium developed several support materials,
including a flyer, a handout, and various PowerPoint presentations (Annex I). The latter were
used during event presentations (such as in the two conferences the project participated in),
being each time adapted to the specific theme of the exhibition.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 7 of 19
3. Website
BeingEnergy’s website (deliverable D6.1), which is located at www.beingenergy.eu, was designed
by partner INOVA+ in the second month of the project. During the project it was used as a central
hub for the dissemination effort, housing all the various dissemination materials, paper
publications, project news, etc. The site was included a private area accessible only to the
consortium, where the partners could find and upload all documents relevant to the project, such
as deliverables, meeting presentations, dissemination materials, etc.
Image 2 – BeingEnergy Website
The website includes several features, which were maintained and updated regularly by INOVA+,
with the support of the other consortium partners:
News: this is the same type of news reports that already exists in many websites, with
relevant developments, both in the project or related to it, being listed in the front page
ordered by date. News content include title, date and description;
Description/fact sheets: a description of the BeingEnergy project, including the context
that led to it, its objectives, and approach;
Partners/Contacts: quick description of the consortium partners;
Publications: list of scientific papers published as a result of research work done in the
project;
Dissemination Materials: PowerPoint presentation, Leaflets, and other promotion material
will be made available for download for any interested parties;
Restricted Area: part of the Web Site that requires a login to access, used by the project
partners for project management. All of the project’s deliverables, partner contacts, work
plan, contract, and other restricted information is available there for the consortium.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 8 of 19
4. Publications
Several of the BeingEnergy partners are organisations that are involved in R&D activities in the
energy area and regularly publish papers on scientific journals (e.g. UPORTO and ITM-CNR). Over
the run of the project several partners published papers that involved results obtained from their
work on BeingEnergy, each with full acknowledgement of the FCH-JU funding. These publications
thus provide an important source of dissemination as they expose the project to both the scientific
community, and the organisations/projects that work on the full cell area.
The papers published were as follows:
Katarzyna Morawa Eblagon, Patricia Heydorn Concepción, Hugo Silva, Adélio Mendes, Ultra
selective low temperature steam reforming of methanol over PdZn/ZnO catalysts –
Influence of support defects on catalytic performance, Applied Catalysis B: environmental,
154 (2014), 316-328;
A. Iulianelli, P. Ribeirinha, A. Mendes, A. Basile, Methanol steam reforming for hydrogen
generation via membrane reactores: a review, Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews
29 (2014), 355-368;
K. Ghasemzadeh, S. Liguori, P. Morrone, A. Iulianelli, V. Piemonte, A.A. Babaluo, A. Basile,
H2 Production by Low Pressure Methanol Steam Reforming in a Dense Pd-Ag Membrane
Reactor in Co-Current Flow Configuration: Experimental and Modelling Analysis,
International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 38 (2013), 16685–16697;
K. Ghasemzadeh, P. Morrone, S. Liguori, A.A. Babaluo, A. Basile, Evaluation of silica
membrane reactor performance for hydrogen production via methanol steam reforming:
Modelling study, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 38 (2013), 16698–16709;
K. Ghasemzadeh, P. Morrone, A. Iulianelli, S. Liguori, A.A. Babaluo, A. Basile, H2
production in silica membrane reactor via methanol steam reforming: Modelling and
HAZOP analysis, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy Volume 38 (2013), 10315–
10326;
Simple Urea-assisted Hydrothermal Synthesis Method for Tailoring the Physicochemical
Properties of ZnO: Morphology, Surface Area and Polarity, published in RSC Advances;
Experimental investigation of a coupled liquid cooled high temperature proton exchange
membrane (HT-PEM) fuel cell with a low temperature methanol steam reformer, submitted
to International Journal of Hydrogen;
Master's thesis on the kinetic modelling of MSR reaction, Francisco de Sales Vidal Vázquez,
Aalto University (2013);
Liguori S., Iulianelli A., Dalena F., Pinacci P., Drago F., Broglia M., Huang Y., Basile A.,
Performance and long-term stability of Pd/PSS and Pd/Al2O3 membranes for hydrogen
separation; Membranes 2014, 4(1), 143-162;
Hugo Silva, Cecilia Mateos-Pedrero, Paulo Ribeirinha, Marta Boaventura, Adelio Mendes,
Low-Temperature Methanol Steam Reforming Kinetics over a novel CuZrDyAl Catalyst -
Reaction Kinetics, Mechanisms and Catalysis June 2015, Volume 115, Issue 1, pp 321-
339;
P. Ribeirinha, M. Boaventura, José Carlos B. Lopes, José M. Sousa, A. Mendes, Study of different designs of methanol steam reformers: Experiment and modeling, Int J Hydrogen Energy. 2014; 39:19970-81.
CuO/ZnO binary catalysts for methanol steam reforming in conventional and membrane
reactors (2013);
The influence of impurities in high temperature polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells
performance, Submitted to International Journal of Hydrogen energy, 2015.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 9 of 19
5. Dissemination Actions
5.1 Introduction
During the execution of the project the consortium presented BeingEnergy at events or meetings.
These dissemination actions were often done as part of a larger action by the partner, such as
they attending a fair to present the company, or in a business meeting related to a theme covered
by BeingEnergy’s work. The amount of dissemination done depended on the specific conditions,
and could encompass anything from distributing flyers to showing a PowerPoint presentation that
included a description of the project.
In addition to the individual partner actions, and besides the two ICCMR participations, the project
has also been able to be present in several events. This participation included displays in a booth,
with a person present to answer questions and present the BeingEnergy initiative.
5.2 Dissemination actions per partner
UPORTO
Action Topic Date
Event
participation
The effect of calcination of ZnO on the catalytic performance of PdZn/ZnO
catalyst in low temperature methanol steam reforming, ISGC2 Congress MAY 2013
Event
participation
Comparison of Different Reactor Designs for Methanol Steam Reforming,
Book of abstracts PP30, HYCELTEC 2013 – IV Iberian Symposium on
Hydrogen, Fuel Cells and advanced Batteries
JUN 2013
Event
participation
The effect of calcination of ZnO on the catalytic performance of PdZn/ZnO
catalyst in low temperature methanol steam reforming, ISGC2 Congress MAR 2015
Event
participation
HYCELTEC- V Iberian Symposium on Hydrogen, Fuel Cells and Advanced
Batteries, oral presentation, “The influence of impurities in high
temperature polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells performance”
JUL 2015
Event
participation
HYCELTEC- V Iberian Symposium on Hydrogen, Fuel Cells and Advanced
Batteries, oral presentation, “Comparative analysis of H2 production by
methanol steam reforming in membrane reactors with CO2 or H2 selective
removal”
JUL 2015
DLR
Action Topic Date
Event
participation 64th Annual Meeting of the International Society of Electrochemistry AUG 2013
Event
participation Display at F-Cell conference OCT 2013
Event
participation Participation in Hannover Fair 2014 APR 2014
Event
participation Participation in Hannover Fair 2015 APR 2015
Client/associate
dissemination
Various contacts and meetings among clients and associates in the
energy industrial area -
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 10 of 19
VTT
Action Topic Date
Event
participation Participation in Hannover Fair 2013 APR 2013
Event
participation
Participation in 11th European Congress on Catalysis (EuropaCat-XI) in
Lyon, France with a presentation about kinetic modelling of MSR reaction SEP 2013
Event
participation
Participation in EFC2013 in Rome with a presentation about the integration
of MSR and HT-PEM DEC 2013
Event
participation
Participation in Chemreactor21, oral presentation about reactor design,
Delft, The Netherlands SEP 2014
Event
participation
Participation in EFCF2015, poster presentation about optimised reformer,
Lucerne, Switzerland JUL 2015
SerEnergy
Action Topic Date
Event participation
Participation in Hannover Mesee Fair 2013 APR 2013
Event participation
Participation in Hannover Messe Fair 2014 APR 2014
Event participation
Seminar with Aalborg University APR 2015
Event participation
Participation in Hannover Messe Fair 2015 APR 2015
Client/associate dissemination
Various contacts and meetings among associates in the energy industrial area -
ITM-CNR
Action Topic Date
Event participation
Participation to ICCMR11 in Porto (Portugal) - 2013 (Poster and oral
presentations about LT-MSR in Pd-based membrane reactors: modelling
and experimental analyses)
JUL 2013
Event participation
Participation to World Hydrogen Conference (China) - 2013 (Poster and oral
presentations about LT-MSR in Pd-based membrane reactors: modelling
and experimental analyses)
SEP 2013
Event participation
Participation to EFC12 in Rome (Italy) - 2013 (Poster and oral presentations
about LT-MSR in silica, FBR and Pd-based membrane reactors: modelling
and experimental analyses)
DEC 2013
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 11 of 19
UPVLC-ITQ
Action Topic Date
Client/associate dissemination
Dissemination in the partners of Felder EU project Train2 at Zaragoza 3
& 4 DEC 2012
Client/associate dissemination
Spanish School of Molecular Material Almagro FEB 2013
Event participation
Spanish-Italia Scholl Como Lake JUN 2013
Client/associate dissemination
Pro-active dissemination at Abengoa Renewables JUL 2013
Client/associate dissemination
Various contacts and meetings among associates in the energy industrial
area -
INOVA+
Action Topic Date
Client/associate dissemination
Dissemination among associates connected to R&D in the energy sector
(Libelium, Labor S.A.) -
Event participation
Researcher’s Night 2013 SEP 2013
Event participation
Researcher’s Night 2014 SEP 2014
Client/associate dissemination
Various contacts and meetings among clients and associates in the
energy industrial area -
Rhodia/Solvay
Action Topic Date
Client/associate dissemination
Various contacts and meetings among clients and associates in the
catalyst industrial area -
5.3 Hannover Messe fair participation
The Hannover Messe, an annual event, is the largest industrial fair in the world. The fair covers a
wider range of themes and exhibits in the areas of R&D, industrial automation and IT, industrial
supply, production engineering and services, as well as energy and environmental technology.
Several partners (DLR, VTT, and SerEnergy) often participate in the Hannover Messe fair, and
during the project years these partners included BeingEnergy references (leaflets, posters, etc.)
in their respective booths. However, in the Hannover Messe 2015, FCH-JU kindly allowed the
BeingEnergy project to have a larger presence in its booth. As such, on 16 of April 2015,
BeingEnergy was able to display at the fair a prototype of the fuel cell developed on the project,
and have several people of the consortium present to describe it and answer questions.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 12 of 19
Image 3 – BeingEnergy presence in the Hannover Messe 2015 fair
5.4 Review Days participation
The BeingEnergy project participated in the various Review Days organised by the FCH-JU. In
each of them the project presented its results up that point, as well as had its information made
available through the associated media. A person from the consortium was present on each
occasion, to describe the project and answer questions.
Image 4 – BeingEnergy presence in the Review Days 2014 (left) and 2015 (right) events
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 13 of 19
6. Conferences
6.1 Introduction
As part of the BeingEnergy’s dissemination effort, it was planned that the project would participate
in one thematically relevant international conference. The goal was to hold an especial section
dedicated to the project in the event, resulting in a high-impact dissemination event to help
support the future exploitation of its results.
The BeingEnergy exceeded this goal and was able to participate in two international conferences:
11th International Conference on Catalysis in Membrane Reactors (ICCMR11), which took
place in Porto, Portugal, from 7 to 11 of July 2013 (month 11 of the project);
12th International Conference on Catalysis in Membrane Reactors (ICCMR12), which took
place in Szczecin, Poland, from 22 to 25 of June 2015 (month 34 of the project).
A more detailed description of BeingEnergy’s participation is given in deliverable D6.3.
6.2 Conference selection
Various options for conference participation were analysed, taken from a list of conferences and
fairs whose focus area matched that of the project (for example the annual European Fuel Cell
Forum). The ICCMR11 event, which took place in July 2013 (month 11 of the project), was
selected in early 2013 to hold a BeingEnergy session due to various reasons. The primary one
was its adequacy to BeingEnergy’s work, as the theme of the conference exactly matched that of
the project. Another reason was the easiness of access to the event, given that the ICCMR11 was
organised by one of the project partners in its home city. The timing was also a factor, as at this
point in the project there were already several research results that merited dissemination.
Given that the ICCMR11 conference took place in the first year of the project, and that the project
had a three-year duration, it was decided that the consortium would look for opportunities to
participate in a second international conference. This event had to take place closer to the end of
the project, in order for the consortium to be able to present the near final results. At the start of
2015 it was decided that the BeingEnergy project would participate in the ICCMR12 event, which
took place in June 2015 (month 34 of the project).
6.3 ICCMR conference series
The International Conferences on Catalysis in Membrane Reactors (ICCMR) started in 1994, in
Lyon - France, and continued as a biannual event organised at different locations around the
globe (Moscow 1996, Copenhagen 1998, Zaragoza 2000, Dalian 2002, Lahnstein 2004, Cetraro
2005, Kolkata 2007, Lyon 2009 and Saint-Petersburg 2011).
On the 7 to 11 of July 2013 the 11th International Conference on Catalysis in Membrane Reactors
(ICCMR11) took place in Porto, Portugal. It was organised by partner UPORTO, specifically by
Prof. Adélio Mendes and Dr. José Sousa. ICCMR12 took place on the 22 to 25 of June 2015 in
Szczecin, Poland, and was organised by the Faculty of Chemical Technology and Engineering,
West Pomeranian University of Technology.
The ICCMR conference series is focused on presenting research and the latest trends on
membrane reactors with an interdisciplinary character: the combination of membranes, catalysis
and reaction engineering, in the perspective of process intensification. All these subjects are
covered in different specific scientific meetings, but the ICCMR conferences cover them as an
overlapping interdisciplinary field. This makes them an ideal match to BeingEnergy’s own work.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 14 of 19
The conferences include an afternoon dedicated to European projects, titled “Session on European
Projects related to the conference topics”. This is a special session dedicated to the presentation
of the main results of some of the main EU projects that are running in the area. BeingEnergy’s
participation in both conferences was held in this session.
6.4 The ICCMR11 event
The goal for the 11th edition of the ICCMR1 was to overview of the most advanced studies and
recent trends in the field of the membrane reactors, including engineering of catalysts and
membranes at the nanoscale and microchannel reactors. Special attention was also paid to new
approaches to the modelling of membrane mass transport and to system integration.
The BeingEnergy presentation took place on July 9th 2013, as part of the “Session on European
Projects related to the conference topics” (see Annex II). Its theme was the description of the
research done in Cu-based catalysts during the first year of the project, i.e. the work done in
work package 2 (as the other work packages at this point in the project has less results to
present).
The presentation described the current state-of-the-art in Cu-based catalyst technology,
BeingEnergy’s aim to improve on it, work approach, and results obtained so far. It concluded with
a roadmap of the work and description of the next steps.
6.5 The ICCMR12 event
The goal for the 12th edition of the ICCMR2 continuous to be the overview the current state-of-
the-art in the field of the membrane reactors, including engineering of catalysts and membranes
at the nanoscale and microchannel reactors.
The BeingEnergy presentation took place on June 23rd 2015, again as part of the “Session on
European Projects related to the conference topics” (see Annex III). Its theme was a general
description of the BeingEnergy project, the work done, and the results achieved during its
execution. As such the presentation was divided in three parts:
Overview of the BeingEnergy project, including objectives, consortium, and structure;
A description of the objectives and results per work package;
General conclusions and analysis of the overall results.
1 iccmr11.eventos.chemistry.pt 2 www.iccmr12.zut.edu.pl
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 15 of 19
7. Conclusions
At the start of the project the consortium defined the objective to undergo a dissemination effort
as to pave the way to the future exploitation of its results. In order to achieve this objective, the
partners developed a detailed dissemination plan in the first six months of the project, which they
then implemented through its lifetime.
The plan originally defined by the BeingEnergy consortium was achieved with remarkable
accuracy, and exceeded in some points. Virtually all of the actions initially planned were
performed, and in addition several others not in the original plan (e.g. the second conference
participation, and the participation in the Hannover Messe 2015) were also performed as the
consortium took advantage from unexpected opportunities.
The dissemination effort the BeingEnergy project performed had a large impact in the building of
awareness to the project and its achievements. This effort will be of particular importance on the
future exploitation of the project results, as it created the initial recognition that the project
consortium can now use in its next steps, namely the further development of the fuel cell
prototype and its commercialization.
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 16 of 19
Annex I – Project Flyer and Handout
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 17 of 19
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 18 of 19
Annex II – ICCMR11 Presentation
D6.4 – Dissemination Report
D6.4_V1.1 © BeingEnergy Page 19 of 19
Annex III – ICCMR12 Presentation