MGSE
Design, Analysis, d M f t iand Manufacturing
PAGNOTTA ENGINEERING, INC. COMPANY BACKGROUND
• Incorporated in June of 1996OUR MISSION • Based in Exton, PA
• Company founders have extensive experience in:» Architectural/Civil since 1980
» Aerospace Industry since 1982
OUR MISSION:To provide quality mechanical design and analytical services to our customers. We provide
» Aerospace Industry since 1982
» Vehicle Simulation Structures since 1991
• Since incorporation, PEI has completed over 400 projects in Architectural/Civil, Aerospace, Vehicle
creative solutions to complex problems utilizing both our
unique experience and cutting edge computer technology.
Simulation, Medical and Consumer Products, Power Generation, and other industries
• Please visit www.pageng.com for more information on our services experience and
We strive to exceed our customers expectations in
order to maintain our outstanding reputation. information on our services, experience and
personnel
Slide 2
PAGNOTTA ENGINEERING SERVICES AND CAPABILITIES
• Stress Analysis and Optimization• Dynamic, Fatigue, and Fracture Analysis• Program and Vendor Management• Conceptual and Detailed Design Engineering• CAD Modeling (3-D Parametric Solid, Surface, and Wireframe)• Thermal and Non Linear Structural Analysis• Thermal and Non-Linear Structural Analysis• Mechanism Design and Analysis• Material Process and Testing Coordination• Manufacturing Detail and Assembly DrawingsManufacturing Detail and Assembly Drawings
PRIMARY ENGINEERING SOFTWARE TOOLS:PRIMARY ENGINEERING SOFTWARE TOOLS:Design: Pro/Engineer, SolidWorks, AutoCAD Inventor
Analysis: NASTRAN, FEMAP, NASGRO
Slide 3
PAGNOTTA ENGINEERING: FOUR LEVELS OF SUPPORT
• Short-term overflow support– Allows the customer to avoid severe peaks in manpower needs– No long-term contract requirements as with job shops
• Long-term, fixed-price support– For well-defined scope– PEI takes ownership of the engineering, not just a “task doer”
• Turnkey solutionsD i l i d di ti / t f f t i d– Design, analysis, and coordination / management of manufacturing vendors
– Complete solution and delivery of hardware
• On-site engineering supportOn site engineering support– Allows for regular interaction with customer personnel
Slide 4
PAGNOTTA ENGINEERING: INDUSTRIES SERVICED
Industries Serviced as a Percentage of Total Contract Awards
Industries Serviced: Percentage of Total Number of Contracts
MISC*4%
CIVIL STRUCTURES5%
COMMERCIAL PRODUCTS8%
POWER GENERATION5%
Industries Serviced: Percentage of Total Number of Contracts
MISC*
8%
CONSUMER PRODUCTS3%
DEFENSE HARDWARE2%
DER CONSULTINGMGSE FOR SPACE FLIGHT
SPACE FLIGHT HARDWARE20%
CIVIL STRUCTURES
COMMERCIAL PRODUCTS
CONSUMER PRODUCTS
DEFENSE HARDWARE
DER CONSULTING
FLIGHT SIMULATION
13%
FLIGHT SIMULATION17%
GENERAL AVIATION7%
INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS3%
MGSE FOR SPACE FLIGHT HDWR13%
GENERAL AVIATION
INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS
MGSE FOR SPACE FLIGHT HDWR
SPACE FLIGHT HARDWARE
POWER GENERATION
* MISC = UTILITIES, AUTOMOTIVE, MEDICAL, ENTERTAINMENT, RESEARCH
Slide 5
RECENT CLIENTS
• Lockheed Martin……………………….……..Orlando, FL; Newtown, PA; Valley Forge, PA
• Orbital Sciences Corp……………….....……Dulles, VA; Greenbelt, MD
• Alphaport, Inc………………………………….Cleveland, OH
Si N d C ti• Sierra Nevada Corporation………………….Hagerstown, MD
• Rockwell Collins / STS……………………….Sterling, VA; Binghamton NY
• Boeing…………………………………………..Ridley Park, PA
• Northrop Grumman Baltimore MD• Northrop Grumman……………………..…….Baltimore, MD
• Keystone Helicopters……………………..….Coatesville, PA
• NASA Langley…………………………….……Hampton, VA
• PMC Engineering….….………………….……Pottstown, PAg g ,
• Environmental Tectonics Corp.…………….Southampton, PA
• JRL Ventures………………............................Cape Coral, FL
• J.F. Taylor, Inc………………..………………...Lexington Park, MD
• Eagle-Picher Technologies, LLC……………Joplin, MO
• Flight Safety International……….……..........St. Louis, MO; Austin, TX
• Fibertek, Inc……………………………………..Herndon, VA
Slide 6
ABBREVIATED LIST OF MGSE PROJECTS
• Spacecraft L-Fixture (LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Payload Module Shipping Fixture (OSC)
• Analysis of B-SAT 3B Antenna L-Fixture(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Design and Analysis of AMC-21 Payload Module Shipping Fixture (OSC)
• Analysis of PIM Fixture, South Feed (LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Analysis of Jitter Air Spring Assembly (LOCKHEED MARTIN)(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Analysis of Motorized Spacecraft Pivot Shipping Fixture (OSC)
• Design and Analysis of TVAC Rail System (OSC)
D i d A l i f MUOS M M d l
y p g y ( )
• Analysis of Raymond Platform (LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Structural Analysis of ECHO-X Tooling Fixtures(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Design and Analysis of Single GPHS Test Stand• Design and Analysis of MUOS Mass Model(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Analysis of Range Fixture for JCSAT 12(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
D i d A l i f St 2 4 I t ti D ll
• Design and Analysis of Single GPHS Test Stand(ALPHAPORT)
• Design and Analysis of Motorized Spacecraft Pivot Shipping Structure (OSC)
• Analysis of Lift Beam Extensions (OSC)• Design and Analysis of Star 2.4+ Integration Dolly(OSC)
• Design and Analysis of Falcon MGSE Hardware including Multi-Use Dolly, L-Fixture, and Lifting Beams
• Analysis of Lift Beam Extensions (OSC)
• Analysis of Various Hardware Support Equipment (vibe plates, TVAC Plates, battery handling and shipping fixtures) (LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Analysis of Various Fixtures for GPSIIIBeams (LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Design and Analysis of STAR 2.4+ Core Shipping Fixture (OSC)
• Analysis of Sirius S4 Lifting Fixtures (LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Analysis of Various Fixtures for GPSIII(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
• Design and Fabrication of GPSIII Mass Models(LOCKHEED MARTIN)
Slide 7
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
PEI responsibilities: design analyze fabrication drawings
Satellite L-Fixture for Lockheed Martin
PEI responsibilities: design, analyze, fabrication drawings, manufacture, test, deliver finished product, FFMEA
L-FIXTURE:• 20 FEET LONG• WEIGHT = 3500 LBSWITH PROOF
WEIGHT
WITH SATELLITE
Slide 8
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
S t llit L Fi t f L kh d M ti
HornAbsorber
S/C Mass Element(61.38 in. offset forL-Fixture interface plate)
PID 3 –Vertical I-Beams
Satellite L-Fixture for Lockheed Martin
Mass PID 2 - Lateral I-Beams
Cold PlateMass Elements
PID 11
PID 4 -Horizontal I-Beams PID 11 –
S/C Interface Plate
I-Beams
PID 41 & 42 -Detailed I-Beam mesh
PID 12 & 13PID 12 & 13 -Caster Interface
Constraintat caster axle
PID 21-23 Jack Interface
PID 6 Jack Beam
PID 5 -Diagonal I-Beams
LongitudinalI-Beams
Slide 9
PID 6 Jack Beam P1404-LFrame-CDR-05.MOD
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Satellite L-Fixture for Lockheed Martin
Mike Pagnotta, President Brian Dreibelbis, Staff Engineer
Slide 10
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
• OSC needs to safety ship their AMC-21 S/C Payload Module (PM) t Al t l (E t ) f i t l ti
AMC-21 Payload Module Shipping Fixture for Orbital Sciences Corp. (OSC)
(PM) to Alcatel (European customer) for equipment population.
• The populated PM must then be shipped back to OSC for integration.PEI contracted to develop the shipping fixture• PEI contracted to develop the shipping fixture
Design Requirements:» Fit in standard 747 shipping container» Fit in standard 747 shipping container
» Meeting OSC MGSE strength requirements:- Sine-sweep response analysis
- Random (PSD) spectrum ( ) presponse analysis
- Shock response analysis
- Quasi-static load cases
+ =
Slide 11
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
AMC-21 Payload Module Shipping Fixture for Orbital Sciences Corp.
Sine Response, 1.3GY input, N101 (CG)
4 50
Sine Response, 1.3GY input, N101 (CG)
Fabricated 2 00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50
onse
[g's
]
RSS-magX-magY-magZ-magInput
shipping fixture mounted to shipping container base
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00
Resp
o
PEI
MODE FREQNO. [Hz] T1 T2 T3 R1 R2 R3
1 5 192 0 498 0 014 0 000 0 013 0 514 0 000
MODAL EFFECTIVE MASS FRACTION
base 0 00 5 00 0 00 5 00 0 00 5 00 30 00 35 00 0 00
Frequency [Hz]designed the handling frame too!
1 5.192 0.498 0.014 0.000 0.013 0.514 0.0002 5.349 0.014 0.542 0.000 0.472 0.013 0.0003 10.450 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.9974 10.482 0.000 0.000 0.999 0.000 0.000 0.0005 12.889 0.488 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.472 0.0006 13.221 0.000 0.440 0.000 0.511 0.000 0.000
Sum = 1 000 0 997 1 000 0 997 1 000 0 998
Payload module being lowered over shipping
fixture
Slide 12
Sum 1.000 0.997 1.000 0.997 1.000 0.998
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Handling Frame with Payload Module
Slide 13
Fi it El t A l i f P l d H dli F f OSC
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Finite Element Analysis of Payload Handling Frame for OSC
Detail of stiffening gussetgusset
Rendered FE model of fixtureFE d l f fi t ith l d
Slide 14
FE model of fixture with payload
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Flotron Turnover Configuration
Slide 15
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Handling Frame Supporting Payload Module at OSC Facility
Slide 16
Payload Module Handling Fixture on Flotron
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Payload Module Handling Fixture on Flotron
Slide 17
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Handling Frame Supporting Payload Module During Flotron Turn-over Operations at OSC Facility
Slide 18
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
56 5656 56123456123456123456123456
31
Finite Element Analysis of Payload Handling Frame for OSC, Turn-over Configurations
151” 167”
4564565656
44444444444444444444444444
44444444444444444444444444
Y
X Y
Z
456456456456
12
X
Y
Z
X
Y
Z
Slide 19
L Frame for Orbital Sciences Corporation (OSC)
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-Frame for Orbital Sciences Corporation (OSC)
• PEI developed fixture per OSC internal requirements.
• Created 3D design model and all manufacturing drawingsCreated 3D design model and all manufacturing drawings
• Performed all stress analyses
L-Frame Spacecraft
Fixture
Slide 20
L F W ld d A bl
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-Frame Welded Assembly
Slide 21
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-Frame Turn-over Configuration
Slide 22
L F ith P l d
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-Frame with Payload
Slide 23
Thermal-Vacuum (TVAC) Chamber Rail and Exterior Hoist Structure for Orbital
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Thermal Vacuum (TVAC) Chamber Rail and Exterior Hoist Structure for Orbital Sciences Corporation (OSC)
• Interior rail structure design to accommodate temperature extremes of TVAC chamber using flexible titanium stand-offs
• Created 3D design models and all manufacturing drawings
• Managed fabrication vendors and installation
• Created FE models and performed all stress analysesp y
Thermal-Vacuum Chamber Rail and exterior hoist beam Payload fixture rolling into
C
Slide 24
structureTVAC chamber
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-frame in Thermal-Vacuum Chamber at Lockheed Martin - Newtown, PA
Slide 25
A l i f H i l R Fi f kh d M i N PA
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Analysis of Horizontal Range Fixture for Lockheed Martin, Newtown, PA
Rendered Finite El t d lElement model
shown
Slide 26
Design and Analysis of JCSAT-9 C-Band Support Fixture for
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Design and Analysis of JCSAT 9 C Band Support Fixture for Lockheed Martin, Newtown, PA
First Stage of Assembly
Rendered View of C-band Support Fixture
Finite Element Model Pro-Engineer Model
Slide 27
C Band Assembly Finite Element Model
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
C-Band Assembly Finite Element Model
First Stage
Flotron components prior to attachment of C-Band Assembly
2nd Stage
Slide 28
Stage
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Complete Range Assembly Finite Element Model
Range Fixture Finite Element Model
Slide 29
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Tilt T bl A blReflector
Ka Band Antenna L-Fixture (Lockheed Martin)
Tilt Table Assembly (20121912G1)
Reflector Support Frame
Assembly (20122178G1)PEI responsibilities:
design, analyze,Reflector Interface Fitting Assembly (20122185G1) 3X
design, analyze, fabrication drawings,
manufacture, test, deliver finished product, FFMEA
Ka-Band Antenna L-Fixture Assembly (20121910G1)
Tower Strong Back Assembly (20121911G1) (20121910G1)(20121911G1)
Calculated Weight (less reflector and tower) = 575 lb
Slide 30
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Tower Strong Back/Flotron ConfigurationL-Fixture Lifting Configuration
Plate Assembly,Flotron
Installation Tower Strong Back Lift Beam
A bl
L-Fixture Lift Beam Assembly
Flotron (to be
li d
Assembly
supplied by LMCSS)
Tower Strong Back A blAssembly
Slide 31
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-Fixture Finite Element Model
Horizontal Orientation
Vertical Orientation
Slide 32
Model: P1490-KaLFixture_06.MOD
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
PID 100003 & 100004 –
L-Fixture Finite Element Model
PID 100003 & 100004 Tilt table support block PID 100005 – Inner
I-Beam Support Blocks
PID 100002 – Tilt Table standoff support block
PID 100006 & 100007 - I-Beam
PID 100008 -I t f Ri
standoff support block
Interface Ring
PID 100009 & 100010 - Channel
PID 100001 – I-Beam Support Blocks
Constraint at caster base
PID 100011 –Caster Mount Plate
Slide 33
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L-Fixture Turnover Configurations
45 Turnover Configuration Vertical Turnover Configuration Horizontal Turnover Configuration
Slide 34
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Ka Band Antenna L-Fixture (Lockheed Martin)
Slide 35
Single Advanced Stirling Convertor (ASC) Test Stand for NASA-Glenn
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Single Advanced Stirling Convertor (ASC) Test Stand for NASA Glenn» Design and Analysis Requirements:
- Develop a Test Stand with the required flexure assemblies at the test table to Test Stand and the Test Stand to single ASC interfaces to ensure that the assembly meets the minimum frequency requirements
- Perform Modal Analyses to determine the required stiffness at the interface between the single ASC and the Test St d d th tiff d d i t th i t f b t th T t St d d th t t t blStand and the stiffness and damping at the interface between the Test Stand and the test table
- Run a Disturbance Analysis to predict the forces and accelerations at the load cells (SineVibe)- Provide an acceptance test plan and procedure for the testing and use of the single ASC Test Stand at NASA GRC
Single ASC
Load Cells
Test Stand
Slide 36
Test table interface
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Stress Analysis of the STAR 2.4+ Core Structure transport fixture
For Orbital Sciences Corp. 2008
FE Model
Slide 37
MUOS Reflector Mass Simulators for Lockheed Martin
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
» Design and Analysis Requirements:- The mass simulators (shown below) are designed to comply with the mass properties and interface requirements
provided by LM. The simulators both accurately represent the mass, C.G. and interfaces of the flight hardware.- Installation procedure provided to LM- Static analysis of each simulator performed, as well as bolted joint analyses at every connection
UOS e ecto ass S u ato s o oc eed a t
y p , j y y- Complete a Functional Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FFMEA)
MBA Mass Simulator
Slide 38
Legacy Mass Simulator
Motorized Pivot Structure Shipping Fixture (MPSSF) for STAR 2 7 Spacecraft for OSC
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Motorized Pivot Structure Shipping Fixture (MPSSF) for STAR-2.7 Spacecraft for OSC» Design and Analysis Requirements:
- Designed to meet the OSC MGSE specifications in the General Environmental Requirements and Test (GERT) Document
- Dynamic handling (turnover) loading conditions
Pivot Frame
y g ( ) g- Transportation loading conditions (quasi-static, random, sine sweep, and shock)- Various detailed connection analyses of both welded and bolted joints
Base Frame
Actuators, 2x
Pivot Arm 2xArm
FEM: P1599_Turnover_45-MARS_020110.MODOne isolator shown in MARS and one shown
in ANTONOV fi ti f l it
MARS isolators (interior positions, 8x)
(4x on +Z, 4x on –Z sides)
ANTONOV isolators (exterior
positions, 8x)(4x on +Z,
4x on –Z sides)
Slide 39
configurations for clarity
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
• Lockheed Martin needs to assemble and test components of the
Falcon Hypersonic Vehicle for Lockheed Martin
vehicle as well as the full vehicle assembly.
• The Falcon HVT-2 is a crewless, experimental hypersonic research aircraft.
• PEI contracted to design, analyze, and manufacture several MGSE components for testing of the LMSSC Falcon HTV-2 program.
Design Requirements:Design Requirements:» Meeting MGSE strength requirements:
- Quasi-static and over-the-floor load cases
- Lifting analysisLifting analysis
- MGSE Proof Test Requirements
Slide 40
F l H i V hi l M lti U D ll d L Fi t
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Falcon Hypersonic Vehicle Multi-Use Dolly and L-Fixture
Slide 41
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
F l H i V hi l M lti U D ll d L Fi tFalcon Hypersonic Vehicle Multi-Use Dolly and L-Fixture
Slide 42
F l H i V hi l P f W i ht
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Falcon Hypersonic Vehicle Proof Weights
Slide 43
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
L kh d M ti d t f t t t d t t f th GPS III
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase B
• Lockheed Martin needs to safety transport and support components of the GPS III satellite around the facility for various tests.
• PEI contracted to analyze several ground support and shipping equipment
Analysis Requirements:» Meeting Lockheed Martin CIPS requirements:
- Quasi-static and over-the-floor load casesQuasi static and over the floor load cases
- Acoustic Vibration Testing- Thermal analysis
- Proof Load Testing
Slide 44
NAVSTAR Gl b l P iti i S t (GPS) III Ph B
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Absorber Hat Structure
• Static analysis for transportation on casters, mounted on jack stands, resting on foot plates
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase B
• Analyzed for the thermal environment and T-VAC testing
Constraint Set 1 Constraint Set 35Constraint Set 1 Constraint Set 35
Slide 45
NAVSTAR Gl b l P iti i S t (GPS) III Ph B
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
Antenna Panel Acoustic Test Fixture
• Static analysis for transportation on casters, mounted on jack stands
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase B
• Analyzed for Acoustic Vibration Testing
• Analyzed for the Proof Load Assembly
Front Side of Assembly, Antenna Panel and Antenna
Mass Elements Shown
Back Side of Assembly, View of Antenna Mounting
Plate Support Beams
Slide 46
NAVSTAR Gl b l P iti i S t (GPS) III Ph B
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
V-Sensor Acoustic Vibe Fixture
• Static analysis for transportation on casters, mounted on jack stands
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase B
• Analyzed for Acoustic Vibration Testing
Slide 47
NAVSTAR Gl b l P iti i S t (GPS) III Ph B
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
V-Sensor T-Cycle Configuration• Static analysis for transportation on casters for four configurations
• Analyzed for the thermal environment in each configuration
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase B
Analyzed for the thermal environment in each configuration
• Analyzed for the Proof Load Assembly for tall configurations
Slide 48
EXAMPLES OF MGSE ENGINEERING SERVICES
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase B
• Created 3D design models and manufacturing drawings
• Managed fabrication vendors
NAVSTAR Global Positioning System (GPS) III Phase BElectronics Box Mass Simulators
• Managed fabrication vendors
Slide 49