+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the...

Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the...

Date post: 21-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
49
NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005 Slide 1 2 nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for research progress. Emerging environmental Emerging environmental contaminants contaminants applications of LC applications of LC - - MS MS Martin Rose Central Science Laboratory Sand Hutton YORK YO41 1LZ [email protected]
Transcript
Page 1: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 1

2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for research progress.

Emerging environmental Emerging environmental contaminantscontaminants –– applications of LCapplications of LC--MSMS

Martin Rose

Central Science LaboratorySand HuttonYORKYO41 1LZ

[email protected]

Page 2: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 2

Outline

Analytical approachesAnalytical approachesBrominated Brominated contaminantscontaminantsPCNs PCNs and and ClCl--PAHsPAHsFluorinated compoundsFluorinated compoundsToxapheneToxaphenePharmaceuticalsPharmaceuticalsOthersOthers

Page 3: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 3

Analytical approaches

LC-MSHBCDTBBAPFOS and relatedPAHs (LC-FD)Pharmaceuticals

All require careful cleanAll require careful clean--upupprior to instrumental analysisprior to instrumental analysis

GC-MSPXDD/FsPCBsPBDEsDeca-BDEPBBsToxapheneCl-PAHsPAHs

Page 4: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 4

Brominated contaminants

6

2

5

3

4

O 2'

6'

3'

5'4'

BrBr

Polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE)

Br = 1 to 10

6

2

5

3

4

2'

6'

3'

5'

4'

BrBrBr = 1 to 10

Polybrominated Biphenyl (PBB)

PBDEs and PBBs –emerged

PBDD/Fs / mixed bromo- chloro- dioxins (PXDD/Fs)

TBBA and HBCDD

Page 5: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 5

Litten, S., Environmental Science & Technology, 37, 5502-5510, 2003Lioy, P.J., et al., Environ. Health Perspect., 110, 703-714, 2002

World Trade Centre

Tonnes of BFRs burntExceptionally high levels of PBDEs detected in dusts and water run off from ground zero Brominated furans detected in many samplesPBBs > PBDEsPBDD/Fs >> PCDD/Fs

Page 6: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

Blend and Freeze Dry

Alumina

H2SO4

Alumina

H2SO4

HRGC-HRMS

NON-PLANAR FRACTION PLANAR FRACTION

Activated carbon fractionation

Ultra-Turrax (Hexane)

Weigh and add 13C Internal Standards

Multi layer silica column1. DCM/Hexane 2. Toluene

PBDEs & PBBs PBDD/Fs

Page 7: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

Freeze dry, extract, purify and concentrate

250ml Milk

(5-50g solids)25µl Extract

Concentration Factor = 10,000

Page 8: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

Instrumental Analysis

HRGC-HRMS, Triple sector, EISelected Ion MonitoringTwo ions monitored for each analyteMass Resolution 10,000 (4 decimal place)Quantification - Isotope dilution methodology60m DB5-MS, thin film (0.1µm) columnPTV injector - 10 µL injections

16.00 18.00 20.00 22.00 24.00 26.00 28.00 30.00 32.00 34.00 36.00 38.00 40.00 42.00 44.00 46.00Time0

100

%

2

13

10

7

8

11

12/13

15

30 3217

25

28

3537

PCB202

75

49

71

47

66

77 100

119

99

116

118

85

155

126

154153

139138

166

183

181

190

Page 9: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 9

Alwyn Fernandes*, Shaun White, Kyle D’Silva and Martin Rose Simultaneous determination of PCDDs, PCDFs, PCBs and PBDEs in food.Talanta 63 (5) 1147-1155 (2004)

Method Performance

0.05 µg/Kg (ppb)50-110%10%PBBs

30–80%

50-110%

Typical Recovery

0.1 - 6.0 ng/Kg (ppt)

0.05 µg/Kg (ppb)

Method LOD (Lipid Weight)

10%PBDD/Fs

11%PBDEs

Method Precision

(RSD)Analyte

Precise, Accurate, RobustPrecise, Accurate, Robust

Page 10: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 10

Meironyte, D., Noren, K., and Bergman, A. J. Toxicol. Environ. Health A 58, 329–341, 1999.

PBDEs in Swedish Human Milk

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

450019

72

1974

1976

1978

1980

1982

1984

1986

1988

1990

1992

1994

1996

Year

PB

DE

s (p

g/g

fat)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

TEQ

(pg/

g fa

t)

PBDEsTotal TEQ (PCDD, PCDF, PCB)

Expon. (Total TEQ (PCDD, PCDF, PCB))Expon. (PBDEs)

Page 11: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 11

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

Rel

ativ

e co

mpo

sitio

n

BD

E-1

5

BD

E-7

BD

E-1

7

BD

E-2

8

BD

E-4

7

BD

E-4

9

BD

E-6

6

BD

E-7

1

BD

E-7

7

BD

E-8

5

BD

E-9

9

BD

E-1

00

BD

E-1

19

BD

E-1

26

BD

E15

3

BD

E13

8

BD

E 1

54

BD

E-1

83

UK Breast Milk Bromkal 70-5DE

PBDE congener profile in UK Human milk

PBDE-153 accumulating?

Page 12: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 12

PBDEs in Human Milk

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005

Sampling Year

Med

ian

valu

e of

Sum

PB

DE

s (n

g/g

lipid

)

Sweden

Germany

Finland

UK

UK (CSL)

Holland

FaroeIslands

Belgium

Japan

UK Breast Milk

Page 13: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 13

PBDEs in Herons (1)

Predatory BirdsFeed on Fish, Amphibians, Small Rodents and MammalsSusceptible to bio-accumulating lipophillic environmental pollutants

Page 14: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 14

PBDEs in Herons (2)

Birds found dead and deformed – BESTHORPETissue samples taken from Juveniles & Adults at site as well as eggs from nests.Eggs and tissue samples taken from two control sites –HERTFRODSHIRE and CHESHIRE

Page 15: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 15

PBDEs in Herons (3)

0

500

1000

1500

2000

ng/g

lipi

d

BD

E-1

7

BD

E-2

8

BD

E-4

7

BD

E-4

9

BD

E-6

6

BD

E-7

1

BD

E-7

7

BD

E-8

5

BD

E-9

9

BD

E-1

00

BD

E-1

19

BD

E-1

26

BD

E15

3

BD

E13

8

BD

E 1

54

BD

E-1

83

Site C (Hertfordshire) Site A (Nottinghamshire) Site B (Cheshire)

Page 16: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 16

PBDEs in Herons (4)

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

BD

E-1

7

BD

E-2

8

BD

E-4

7

BD

E-4

9

BD

E-6

6

BD

E-7

1

BD

E-7

7

BD

E-8

5

BD

E-9

9

BD

E-10

0

BD

E-11

9

BD

E-12

6

BD

E-15

3

BD

E-13

8

BD

E-15

4

BD

E-18

3

ng/g

lipi

d

Eggs Juvenille Fat Adult FatUp to 1 ppm lipid

Page 17: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 17

PBDEs in Herons (5)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

BDE-

10BD

E-7

BDE-

11BD

E-8

BDE-

12BD

E-13

BDE-

15BD

E-30

BDE-

32BD

E-17

BDE-

25BD

E-BD

E-35

BDE-

37BD

E-75

BDE-

49BD

E-71

BDE-

47BD

E-66

BDE-

77BD

E-10

0BD

E-11

9BD

E-99

BDE-

116

BDE-

118

BDE-

85BD

E-12

6BD

E-15

5BD

E-15

4BD

E-15

3BD

E-13

8BD

E-16

6BD

E-18

3BD

E-18

1BD

E-19

0BB

-52

BB-4

9BB

-77

BB-8

0BB

-101

BB-1

53BB

-169

ng/g

wet

wei

ght

PBB-153 Banned for >20 years

Page 18: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 18

PBDEs and PBBs in Polar Bears (2000)

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

BD

E-1

0B

DE

-7B

DE

-11

BD

E-8

BD

E-1

2/13

BD

E-1

5B

DE

-30

BD

E-3

2B

DE

-17

BD

E-2

5B

DE

-28/

33B

DE

-35

BD

E-3

7B

DE

-75

BD

E-4

9B

DE

-71

BD

E-4

7B

DE

-66

BD

E-7

7B

DE

-100

BD

E-1

19B

DE

-99

BD

E-1

16B

DE

-118

BD

E-8

5B

DE

-126

BD

E-1

55B

DE

-154

BD

E-1

53B

DE

-138

BD

E-1

66B

DE

-183

BD

E-1

81B

DE

-190

BB

-52

BB

-49

BB

-80

BB

-77

BB

-101

BB

-153

BB

-169

Mea

n ng

/g li

pid

(n=

4)

x 10

x 10

PBDE-153 appears

resist metabolism PBB-153 Dominant

to bioaccumulate or

Page 19: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+
Page 20: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+
Page 21: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 21

Deca-BDE

Occurrence – database poor – high environmental levelsPhoto-degradation to form PBDD/FsDifficult to measure – thermo-labile, adsorption lossesRisk assessments – ongoing (EFSA)

Page 22: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 22

Deca-BDEHomogenisation of Sample 50gSample

PreparationInternal Standardisation

with 13C-PBDD/F, Deca-BDE

Hexane/Dichloromethane extraction/elution from

Multilayered modified silica column

Fractionation on activated carbon

PBDD/F fraction – purified on activated alumina

Concentration and Sensitivity Standard addition

Analysis by HRGC-HRMS

Deca-BDE

25µl

Extraction andFractionation

Purification

Measurement

50µl

Page 23: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

2 7 . 0 0 2 8 . 0 0 2 9 . 0 0 3 0 . 0 0 3 1 . 0 0 3 2 . 0 0T i m e0

1 0 0

%

0

1 0 0

%

0

1 0 0

%

p b d e A 0 1 2 2 1 7 2 : V o l t a g e S I R 7 C h a n n e l s E I + 8 1 1 . 3 7 3 6

5 . 0 0 e 53 1 . 2 1

2 7 . 8 5

p b d e A 0 1 2 2 1 7 2 : V o l t a g e S I R 7 C h a n n e l s E I + 7 9 7 . 3 3 5 3

1 . 9 6 e 53 1 . 2 1

3 0 . 9 03 0 . 3 22 9 . 2 42 7 . 8 3 3 2 . 2 43 1 . 8 9

p b d e A 0 1 2 2 1 7 2 : V o l t a g e S I R 7 C h a n n e l s E I + 7 8 3 . 3 3 8 4

3 . 1 5 e 42 9 . 1 3

2 8 . 9 92 8 . 1 7

2 7 . 8 92 6 . 9 6

3 1 . 9 43 1 . 0 3

2 9 . 9 92 9 . 6 6 3 0 . 7 5 3 1 . 1 23 1 . 7 7

3 2 . 0 73 2 . 5 3

13C deca-BDE

deca-BDE

deca-BB

Page 24: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 24

Tetrabromobisphenol A: TBBA

CH3

CH3

OH OH

Br

Br

Br

Br

Used to manufacture epoxy resins used in printed circuit boards (up to 34% by weight TBBPA)

High production volume chemical

Reactive flame retardant – bound to matrix

Excess TBBPA can leach out

Page 25: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 25

Hexabromocyclododecane: HBCD

Principal flame retardant used in foams (expanded polystyrene) in furniture and building materials

High production volume chemical

Additive flame retardant – can leach from matrix

3 diastereoisomers – α, β, and γ

Page 26: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 26

Classification as POPs?

Persistent?Bio-accumulative - YesLong range transport - YesToxic • TBBPA – Endocrine disrupting, estrogenic

activity• HBCD – neuro-developmental, hepatotoxic

Very little toxicological or exposure data!

Page 27: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 27

Analytical Methodology - Schematic

Sample homogenisation, Na2SO4 Drying

Internal Standardisation Addition of 13C-HBCD, 13C-TBBPA

Cold Solvent extraction(Hexane:DCM)/acid hydrolysis

Filtration

Sample PreparationSample Preparation

ExtractionExtraction

Solvent exchange Solvent exchange or purificationor purification

MeasurementMeasurement Analysis by HRGC-HRMS (SIM)

Alumina column

Pre-concentration

Solvent exchanged to Methanol:Water

Analysis by HPLC-MS/MS

(MRM)

Page 28: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 28

GC-MS

HBCDOptimum temperatures required – all zones

Speciation not possible

Small increases in zone temperature dramatically reduce sensitivity

TBBPANo derivitisation required

Purification requires optimisation – poor recoveries

BOM(s) 156

19.50 20.00 20.50 21.00 21.50 22.00 22.50 23.00Time0

100

%

51

100

%

bfrA000501 Sm (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+ 560.7279

2.87e621.32

20.65

bfrA000501 Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+ 528.7295

6.22e720.66

Page 29: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 29

GC-MS Sample Analysis02-Feb-2005, 16:56:25Mackerel (SN: 10704) - Extract 12879

19.25 19.50 19.75 20.00 20.25 20.50 20.75 21.00 21.25 21.50 21.75 22.00Time0

100

%

0

100

%

0

100

%

bfrA001705 Voltage SIR 11 Channels EI+ 572.7687

9.06e521.24

20.6619.66

bfrA001705 Voltage SIR 11 Channels EI+ 560.7279

2.00e621.26

bfrA001705 Voltage SIR 11 Channels EI+ 493.7377

5.13e720.95

13C PBDE-139 (Syringe standard)

13C HBCD

HBCD

Native HBCD in Mackerel

Page 30: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 30

HPLC-MS/MS conditions

Column Sunfire C18 150 mm x 2.1 mm, particle size 3.5 µm

Flow rate 0.2 ml/min Mobile phase A = methanol, B = water Gradient t = 0 min, A = 90%; t = 15 min, A = 100%;

t = 16 min, A = 90% Run time 20 min Injection volume 20 µl Column temperature 30 ºC Typical retention time β-HBCD = 6.4 min

γ-HBCD = 7.1 min α-HBCD = 5.5 min TBBPA = 3.0 min

Ionisation mode Electrospray negative ionisation Source temperature 120 ºC De-solvation temperature 300 ºC

Page 31: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 31

Limits of detection – HPLC-MS/MSMRM test16-Dec-200419:16:37

Time1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 13.00 14.00 15.00

%

61

bfr3_161204_2_010 Sm (Mn, 1x2); Sm (Mn, 1x2) 4: MRM of 2 Channels ES- 640.3 > 78.9

1.88e37.12

6.38

5.55

3.001.801.09

0.141.44

2.24 2.79 3.69

5.91

14.66

12.279.228.46 10.24

9.79 11.16 11.73

13.4512.60 13.97

HBCD 0.5 ng/mlα

βγ

Analyte LOD (ng/ml)α-HBCD 0.41β-HBCD 0.49γ -HBCD 0.21

13C α-HBCD 0.33TBBPA 0.77

13C TBBPA 0.40

MRM test16-Dec-200419:16:37

Time1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 13.00 14.00 15.00

%

63

bfr3_161204_2_010 Sm (Mn, 1x2); Sm (Mn, 1x2) 2: MRM of 2 Channels ES- 554.54 > 430.73

1.77e33.06

2.02

0.48 1.591.17

0.96

2.28

10.63

5.54

5.02

3.41 3.824.29

4.50

8.43

6.63

6.04

7.329.168.59

9.56 10.18

13.84

11.36 11.76

12.49

12.09

13.2012.87

13.54

15.1914.65

14.27

TBBPA 0.5 ng/ml

Page 32: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 32

Linearity – 0.5 to 20 ng/ml

Analyte Correlation coefficientα-HBCD 0.9997β-HBCD 0.9988γ -HBCD 0.9996TBBPA 0.9989

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

0.00 2.00 4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

co ncentra tio n / ng/ml

β-HBCD

Page 33: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 33

Other validation data

Precisionα-HBCD β-HBCD γ -HBCD 13C α-HBCD TBBPA 13C TBBPA

Mean 4803 3308 7990 6516 1868 4561Stdev 461 172 332 448 208 178RSD% 9.6 5.2 4.2 6.7 11.2 3.9

Reference Material dataNo HBCD/TBBPA RM

Bx 1 Bx 2 Bx 338.0 34.1 62.4

α-HBCD concentration (ng/g) mean = 44.8 ng/gRSD = 34 %

published value = 39.6 ng/g

Page 34: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 34

Sample chromatograms

1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 13.00 14.00 15.00Time0

100

%

0

100

%

4.63

2.830.11 2.05

1.531.98

2.672.34

2.883.733.21

4.377.356.906.454.89

5.15 5.8614.3514.14

7.68 13.559.018.447.82 11.2310.6110.35

9.60 11.96 12.29 13.14 14.09 14.99

11.95

11.91

11.329.59

11.25

11.15

12.05

α-HBCD 0.49 ng/gβ-HBCD 0.13 ng/gγ -HBCD 0.20 ng/gTBBPA <0.02 ng/g

TDS group 5 - meat products

Page 35: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 35

BFRs form brominated dioxins and furans (PBDD/Fs)

PBDD/Fs210 congenersThermal breakdown products of brominated organicsFormed from burning of BFRs in plasticsHighly toxic and persistentMimic hormones – ThyroxineSome congeners more toxic than 2,3,7,8-substituted chlorinated dioxins

Page 36: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 36

Brominated dioxins and furans:tri – penta BDFs in food extract

2 4 . 0 0 2 6 . 0 0 2 8 . 0 0 3 0 . 0 0 3 2 . 0 0 3 4 . 0 0 3 6 . 0 0 3 8 . 0 0T i m e3

1 0 0

%

b d x c 0 0 1 7 0 8 3 : V o l t a g e S I R 1 7 C h a n n e l s E I + 5 6 1 . 6 0 5 9

6 . 0 0 e 5

3 4 . 6 3

3 4 . 4 6

3 6 . 0 2

3 6 . 2 2

3 6 . 7 03 8 . 3 9

tri tetra penta

Page 37: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 37

Chlorinated napthalenes and Cl-PAHs

PCNsbetter studied, but poor databaseRecognised dioxin-like effects – TEFs ?Documented occurrence – food, environment

Cl-PAHsOccurrence – environmental, food?Toxicity – predicted

Page 38: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 38

Fluorinated contaminants

S

F F

F F

F F

F F

F F

F FFF

FF

F

O

ON

O

OH

S

F F

F F

F F

F F

F F

F FFF

FF

F

O

ON

OH

S

F F

F F

F F

F F

F F

F FFF

FF

F

O

OHN

O

OH

N-EtFOSE

PFOSAA

S

F F

F F

F F

F F

F F

F FFF

FF

F

O

ONH2

PFOSA

S

F F

F F

F F

F F

F F

F FFF

FF

F

O

OOH

PFOS

OH

F F

F F

F F

F F

F F

FF

FF

F

PFOA

O

Oxidation

M556

PFOS and related‘Scotchguard’Teflon

Page 39: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 39

Summary of LC-MS/MS conditions for PFOS and related compounds

Rt [M-H]- Prod Cone V Prod Cone Vn-C3 Acid PFprA 163 119 10n-C4 Acid PFBA 213 169 8n-C5 Acid PFPeA 10.61 263 219 7n-C6 Acid PFHxA 11.37 313 269 6n-C7 Acid PFHpA 12.17 363 319 6n-C8 Acid PFOA 12.98 413 369 7i -C9 Acid PFTMHxA 463 419 4 219 12n- C9 Acid PFNA 13.79 463 419 7n-C10 Acid PFDeA 14.66 513 469 8n-C11 Acid PFUnA 14 563 519 8n-C12 Acid PFDoA 16.45 613 569 8n-C14 Acid PFTdA 18.24 713 669 8n-C16 Acid PFHdA 20.09 813 769 8n-C18 Acid PFOdA 913 869 9

Tetrahydro THPFHxA 241 221 5 177 8

Labelled-C10 13C2-PFDeA 515 470 6

C4 PFBS 299 99 30 80 30C6 PFHxS 399 99 33 80 33i-C8 i-PFOS 499 169 25 80 35n -C8 n -PFOS 499 99 35 80 35Tetrahydro THPFOS 427 407 20 80 35

i-C8 Amide PFOSA 498 169 25 78 25n-C8 Amide PFOSA 498 169 25 78 25

Primary Secondary

Page 40: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 40

Chromatograms

FSQE#2 SunFire C8 2.1x150mm 5 um 20mM AmAcACNgrad

Time4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES-

813.1 > 769.11.26e5

14.07

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 713.1 > 669.1

6.30e413.74

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 613.1 > 569.1

4.82e413.34

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 563.1 > 519.1

9.36e413.03

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 515.1 > 470.1

1.81e36.725.483.06 3.71 14.8212.5910.228.11 8.31 11.32 16.09

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 513.1 > 469.1

1.94e512.61

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 499.1 > 80.1

3.26e312.92

3.902.15 6.835.79 7.91 11.5210.959.75 16.6214.76

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 498.1 > 78.1

1.09e410.62

6.03

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 463.1 > 419.1

2.41e511.88

FSQE#2 SunFire C8 2.1x150mm 5 um 20mM AmAcACNgrad

Time4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100

4.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00

%

0

100FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES-

413.1 > 369.18.34e4

10.24

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 399.1 > 80.1

2.20e411.81

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 363.1 > 319.1

7.97e49.35

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 313.1 > 269.1

2.31e48.76

7.14

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 299.1 > 80.1

3.06e49.27

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 263.1 > 219.1

4.78e48.16

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 241.1 > 221.1

3.46e38.82

3.26 7.984.92 5.26 17.4814.2012.2611.37 15.84

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 213.1 > 169.1

2.64e413.256.78

2.04 12.127.74 8.78 9.31 11.39

13.76 16.02 16.57

FSQE003_Data066 Sm (Mn, 3x1) MRM of 20 Channels ES- 163.1 > 119.1

2.57e43.77

13.017.074.41 8.91 10.15 15.5113.74 16.60

Page 41: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 41

Total ion current

FSQE#2 SunFire C8 2.1x150mm 5 um 20mM AmAcACNgrad

Time3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 13.00 14.00 15.00 16.00 17.00 18.00

%

0

100FSQE003_Data066 MRM of 20 Channels ES-

TIC3.32e5

11.86

9.55

9.35

8.16

3.79 6.768.76

10.31

11.52

12.59

14.09

13.03

13.72

14.43

16.0015.5116.77

Page 42: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 42

Toxaphene

‘Old’ pesticide; never used in UKPOP and global contaminant1216 congeners

(only a few found)

Page 43: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 43

Pharmaceuticals

Veterinary medicinesSulphonamidesTetracyclinesTylosinPenicillins

Dissipation in soilTransport in surface watersDrainflow, sedimentsLeaching

Page 44: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

Reproduced with permission from EMBO Reports, Vol 5(12)

Page 45: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 45

Uptake by organisms?

Controlled experimentsControlled experimentsLettuce and carrotsLettuce and carrotsNine veterinary medicinesNine veterinary medicinesExposed for 2 Exposed for 2 –– 4 months4 monthsAnalysis by LCAnalysis by LC--MSMS--MSMS

SoilSoilPlant materialPlant material

Page 46: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 46

Other emerging environmental contaminants

PAHs – not POPs (no bioaccumulation), ‘emerged’, recent extension to list of significant PAHs, new interest in exposure from food, MRLs etcTrace elements – esp. speciation studies for As and HgNitro-PAHsPBNsPXDD/FsHexachlorobenzene

Page 47: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 47

Dioxin-like toxicity of other compounds

PBDEs? – some early indications but possibly due to PBDD/F contaminationPBDD/Fs? – yes!

[Early studies suggest at least as potent as dioxins]

PXDD/Fs – no tox. data but would seem likelyHexachlorobenzene? Possibly – again possible contamination issuePCNs – very likelyPBNs – very likelyPBBs - very likely

Page 48: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 48

WHO-TEF Review: Geneva, 27-30 June 2005

Published revisions to TEFs likely to be in about a yearTransparency and consistencyMechanism for derivation and communication of processConfidential until published

Page 49: Developments in the measurement of POPs: Implications for ...€¦ · 2nd seminar meeting of the NERC Knowledge Transfer Network on POPs. ... (Mn, 1x1) Voltage SIR 9 Channels EI+

NERC Knowledge Transfer Network, 7 July 2005Slide 49

Acknowledgements

Alwyn FernandesKyle D’SilvaMalcolm DriffieldDon ClarkeShaun WhiteAlistair Boxall

All the Environmental Contaminants team at CSLAll the Environmental Contaminants team at CSL

Thank you for your attention!Thank you for your attention!


Recommended