+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis...

Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis...

Date post: 30-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
75
The National Ribat University Faculty of Graduate Studies and Scientific Research Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis Patients, in Ibn-sina Hospital, Khartoum. A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment for the Requirements of M. Sc. In Human Nutrition and Dietetics By: Nafisa Abdurahman Mohammed Zain Ahmed Supervisor: Dr. Nadia Abdalrahiam khogaly December 2015
Transcript
Page 1: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

The National Ribat University

Faculty of Graduate Studies and Scientific Research

Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in

Liver Cirrhosis Patients, in Ibn-sina Hospital,

Khartoum.

A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment for the Requirements of M.

Sc. In Human Nutrition and Dietetics

By: Nafisa Abdurahman Mohammed Zain Ahmed

Supervisor: Dr. Nadia Abdalrahiam khogaly

December 2015

Page 2: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

اآلية

قال تعالى

الذين ضل سعيهم (301قل هل ننبئكم باألخسرين أعماال ) )

نيا وهم يحسبون أنهم يحسنون صنعا )في ( 301الحياة الد

الذين كفروا بآيات ربهم ولقائه فحبطت أعمالهم فال أولئك

( ذلك جزاؤهم جهنم بما 301نقيم لهم يوم القيامة وزنا )

((301كفروا واتخذوا آياتي ورسلي هزوا )

صدق هللا العظيم

الكهف سورة 301-301اآليات

Page 3: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

3

Dedication

It is a source of pride and pleasure for me to dedicate the

outcome of my continuous hard work to

My Lovely parents

Who taught me the meaning of forgiveness…and to

be there when one needs us …

I wish them health, happiness and peace

Beloved my sister and brothers

To my husband

My lovely teacher Uz.Safa Almusharf

My lovely friend Rania

All those helped and supported me.

Nafisa

Page 4: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

I

Acknowledgements

My gratitude first and last goes to Allah for accompanying and

supporting me throughout this research.

There is no single word that is enough to express my appreciation and

gratefulness to my supervisor Dr. Nadia Abdalrahiam khogaly for the

continuous support of my study and research, for her patience,

motivation, enthusiasm, and immense knowledge. Her guidance helped

me at all the time of research and writing of this thesis. I could not have

imagined having a better advisor and mentor for my thesis. My sincere thanks also go to the staff of IBN-SINA Hospital in

Khartoum State, for offering me the opportunity to collect the required

data for my thesis. Last but not the least; I would like to thank my

family: my parents, husband, brothers and sisters, for supporting me

spiritually throughout my life.

Page 5: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

II

Abstract Objectives: This study aimed to determine the dietary management of liver

cirrhosis patient in IBN-SINA hospital. Methods: Descriptive, cross – sectional Hospital based study, conducted in IBN-

SINA hospital during the period from September to November 2015. Thirty

patients were case –findings as sampling technique from medical wards. Primary

data was obtained using questionnaire. Weights and heights were measured to

calculate the BMI. The food intake data were collected by 24 hour record method.

Hb, albumin, ALP, ALT and AST were taken from patients' files. Data were

analyzed using statistical packages for sciences (SPSS) version 20, significant

considered at P. value less than (0.05). Results: Males were 20(66.7%), females 10(33.3%). Seven (23.3%) of the patients

received dietary advises in the hospital. Most of the patients in this study regarded

the food services provided to them in the hospital as good in terms of taste and

flavor, variety, temperature, and portion size, cleanness and quality of food

services. The majority of the patients 19(63.3%) consumed hospital diet and

11(36.7%) consumed liquid diet. The majority of patients 21(70%) agreed that the

hospital food quality is better than other states hospitals. Underweight BMI (< 18.5)

was reported in 18(60%) of the patients and normal BMI (18.5 – 24.9) was reported

in 12(40%) of the patients. Significant differences were found between the four age

groups (P < 0.05). Significant differences in the values of BMI, ALP and AST were

found between males and females (P < 0.05) and no significant differences between

the two groups in Hb, albumin and ALT values (P > 0.05). There were no

significant differences between males and females in 24 hour recall of total energy,

carbohydrate, protein and fat intake (P > 0.05) (both males and female intake fall

with limits of intake lower than recommended). Conclusion: Patients satisfaction towards meal services in the hospital was found

to be relatively good; in addition dietary change caused improvement in health for

most of the patients. Patients should be advised to increase their intake of energy,

protein, carbohydrate and fat to recommended levels suitable for liver cirrhosis.

Page 6: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

III

ة البحثخالص

لمرضى تليف الكبد في الرضاء في الخدمات هدفت هذه الدراسة الى تحديداألهداف:

مستشفى ابن سينا.

وهي دراسة وصفية عبر دراسة مقطعية في مستشفى ابن سينا ، والتي اجريت :األساليب

. وقد كانوا ثالثين 5102في نفس المستشفى خالل الفتره من سبتمبر الى نوفمبر عام

مريضا أخذت من عنابر المستشفى . وتم الحصول على البيانات األولية بإستخدام اإلستبيان

( وقد تم جمع IMB) ساب مؤشر كتلة الجسم . وكذالك تم أخذ الوزن والطول لح

(52الطعام )الوجبات( التي يتناولها المرضى خالل معدل التناول الغذائى اليومى )

أخذت من Pia,PLa,PLA,TLH,TSA(، bHى. اما بالنسبة للهيموقلوبين )للمرض

علوم والتي تعرف ب ) ملفات المرضى .وتم تحليل البيانات بإستخدام الحزمة األحصائيه لل

iAii )

( من %5363)6(. و%3363) 01( و اإلناث %66..) 51كانت نسبة الذكورالنتائج :

المرضى تلقوا ارشادات غذائية في المستشفى. معظم المرضى في هذه الدراسة اعتبروا

الخدمات الغذائية المقدمة لهم في المستشفى بأنها جيدة من حيث الطعم والنكهة ودرجة

( يتناولون %363.)01العظمى من المرضى الحرارة والنظافة وجودة الخدمات. الغالبية

( بان جودة الغذاء المقدم %61)50عن طريق تعديل النظام الغذائى .ووافقت غالبيه الرضى

لهم من قبل المستشفى، هو افضل مقارنه بمستشفيات اخرى .ونقص الوزن لمؤشر كتله

الجسم

(IMB لوحظ او اظهر عن اقل من )وأفادة التقارير (من المرضى .% 1.) .0فى 0.62

( من المرضى ووجدت %21) 05( في 5261 – 0.62الطبيعي كان ) IMBبأن

) جموعات الألربعه المذكورة اعالهفروقات ذات دالئل احصائية بين الم

1612>Aروق ذات دالالت احصائية في كل من(.وتم العثور على ف IMB وPLA

( ولم توجد فروق ذات دالالت احصائية بين A<1612واإلناث )بين الذكور Piaو

كانت PLa( وقيمة الPLH,TSA(و الزالل )bHالمجموعتين في الهيموقلوبين )

(1612<A وام يكن هناك فرق كبير بين الذكور و اإلناث خالل معدل التناول الغذائى . )

(.) لوحظ في A>1612ات والدهون )لكل من الطاقة والكربوهيرات والبروتين (52اليومى )

كل من الذكور واإلناث انخفاض كمية الوجبات التي تم تناولها اقل من الموصى بها.(

وجد رضا المرضى نحو خدمات الوجبات الغذائية في المستشفى ان تكون جيدة الخاتمة :

معظم نسبيا ، باإلضافة الى ذالك تسبب تغير النظام الغذائي تحسين الصحة بالنسبة ل

للطاقة والكربوهيدرات والبروتينات ’المرضى. ينبغي ارشاد المرضى الى زيادة تناولهم لل

.الى المستويات المطلوبة أو الموصى بها لتليف الكبد

Page 7: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

IV

Table of Contents

Content Page

Dedication I

Acknowledgements II

Abstract III

IV خالصه البحث

Table of Contents V

List of Tables VII

List of Figures IX

List of Abbreviations X

Chapter One

1. Introduction

1.1 Introduction 1

1.2 Statement 0f problem 1

1.3 Justification 2

1.4 Objectives 2

Chapter Two

2. Literature Review

2.1 The liver 3

2.2 Liver cirrhosis 4

2.3 Complications of liver cirrhosis 7

2.4 Treatment of liver cirrhosis 10

2.5 Nutritional support 10

2.6 Nutrition of liver cirrhosis patients 11

2.7 Nutritional assessment of patients with liver cirrhosis 12

2.8 Dietary modification in patients with liver cirrhosis 13

2.9 Medical management 15

2.10 Meal satisfaction 15

Page 8: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

V

2.11 Previous studies 16

Chapter Three

3. Subjects and Methods

3.1 Type of research 18

3.2 Study area 18

3.3 Sample population 18

3.4 Study Sample and method of selection 18

3.5 Data collection 18

3.6 Data analysis 19

Chapter Four

4. Results 20

Chapter Five

5. Discussion 38

Chapter Six

6. Conclusion and Recommendations

6.1 Conclusion 41

6.2 Recommendations 42

References 43

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Page 9: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

VI

List of Tables

No Table Page

1 General information of patients 20

2 Distribution of patients according to other chronic diseases 21

3 Distribution of the patients according to presenting 21

symptoms of liver cirrhosis

4 Distribution of the patients according to number of meal per 22

Day

5

Distribution of the patients according to type food cooking at

home 22

6 Distribution of the patients according to reception of dietary 23

Advices

7 Distribution of the patients according to drinking of alcohol 23

8 Distribution of the patients according to smoking 24

9 Distribution of the patients according to eating served meals 24

10 Distribution of the patients according to satisfaction towards 25

meal services provided in the hospital

11 Distribution of the patients according to consumption of 26

hospital diet

12 Distribution of the patients according to meeting his/her 26

Cultural food preferences by the hospital

13 Distribution of the patients according to frequency of visits 26

by dietitian in the hospital

Page 10: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

VII

14 Distribution of the patients according to their opinions 27

towards the quality of food services compared to other t

States Hospitals

15 Distribution of the patients according to improvement in 27

health due to change in diet

16 Distribution of the patients according to BMI and nutritional 28

Status

17 Differences between males and females in BMI and 29

nutritional status

18 Differences in nutritional status and BMI according to age 31

19 Differences of mean values in BMI, HB, albumin and liver 33

enzyme according to gender of the patients

20 Differences of mean values of 24 hour intake according to 34

gender patients

21 Differences in mean values in BMI and HB according to age 35

of the patient

22 Differences in mean values in albumin and liver enzyme 36

according to age of the patient

23 Differences in mean values in of 24 hour intake of patients 37

according to age of the patient

Page 11: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

VIII

List of Figures

No Figure Page

1 Differences between males and females in BMI 29

2 Differences between males and females in nutritional status 30

3 Differences in BMI of the patients according to age group 31

4 Differences in nutritional status of the patients according to 32

age group

Page 12: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

IX

List of Abbreviations

ALD: Alcoholic Liver Disease

ALP: Alkaline Phosphatase

ALT: Alanine Aminotransferase

AST: Aspartate Aminotransferase

BMI: Body Mass Index

DNA: Deoxyribonucleic Acid

EIA: Enzyme Immunoassay

HFE: Human Hemochromatosis Protein (High Iron Fe)

HIV: Human Immunovirus

IBD: Inflammatory Bowel Disease

IR: Insulin Resistance

IU: International Unit

MAMA: Mid arm muscle area

NAFLD: Non –alcoholic fatty liver disease NCTs: Number

Connection tests

n-3 PUFAs: Omega-3 Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids

NASH: Non-Alcoholic Steatohepatitis

PCM: Protein-Calorie Malnutrition

PPAR: Peroxisome Proliferator-Activated Receptor

QUOTE: Quality of Care Through the Patient's Eyes

RNA: Ribonucleic Acid

SPSS: Statistical Packages for social Sciences

TIPS: Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Shunting

TSF: Triceps Skin Fold Thickness

NCTs: number connection tests

Page 13: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Chapter One

Introduction

Page 14: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

1

Chapter One

1. Introduction

1.1 Introduction

The liver weighs about 3 pounds and is the largest solid organ in the

body. It performs many important functions, such as: manufacturing

blood proteins that aid in clotting, oxygen transport, and immune

system function; storing excess nutrients and returning some of the

nutrients to the bloodstream; manufacturing bile, a substance needed to

help digest fats; helping the body store sugar (glucose) in the form of

glycogen; ridding the body of harmful substances in the bloodstream,

including drugs and alcohol; and breaking down saturated fat and

producing cholesterol (WebMD, 2015).

Cirrhosis is a slowly progressing disease in which healthy liver tissue is

replaced with scar tissue, eventually preventing the liver from

functioning properly. The scar tissue blocks the flow of blood through

the liver and slows the processing of nutrients, hormones, drugs, and

naturally produced toxins. It also slows the production of proteins and

other substances made by the liver (WebMD, 2015).

1.2 Statement 0f problem

In the private clinic of the physician, name Abdelrahaman AL sheikh

(1/1/2014 to 30/8/2014) have seen 24 patients liver cirrhosis and the

most common causes of liver cirrhosis were: Hepatitis C, alcohol abuse,

and parasitic (Schistosomosis) personal communication.

Page 15: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

2

1.3 Justification

Statistics of IBN-SINA (2014) showed that in the year 2014 the

total patient with liver cirrhosis was 189 with 61 deaths .On the

other hand statistics in same hospital (2013) reported that the

total number of patients with liver cirrhosis was155 with 45

deaths .

This research focuses on the dietary management at IBN-SINA

hospital for patients with liver cirrhosis.

1.4 Objectives:

1.4.1 General objectives:

To assess the dietary management of liver cirrhosis patient in

IBN-SINA hospital.

1.4.2 Specific objectives:

To assess nutrition status, biochemical data.

To assess patient meal satisfaction.

To evaluate their dietary intake, using 24-hr recall.

To design educational pamphlets from local or staple diets.

Page 16: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Chapter Two

Literature Review

Page 17: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

3

Chapter Two

2. Literature Review

2.1 The liver

The liver is a vital organ of vertebrates and some other animals. In

the human it is located in the upper right quadrant of the abdomen, below

the diaphragm. The liver has a wide range of functions,

including detoxification of various metabolites, protein synthesis, and the

production of biochemical, necessary for digestion. The liver is

a gland and plays a major role in metabolism with numerous functions in

the human body. Estimates regarding the organ's total number of functions

vary, but textbooks generally cite it being around 500 (Abdel-Misih and

Bloomston, 2010).

Diseases that interfere with liver function will lead to derangement

of these processes. However, the liver has a great capacity

to regenerate and has a large reserve capacity. In most cases, the liver

only produces symptoms after extensive damage.

Hepatomegaly refers to an enlarged liver and can be due to many

causes. It can be palpated in a liver span measurement. Liver

diseases may be diagnosed by liver function tests–blood tests that can

identify various markers. For example, acute-phase reactants are

produced by the liver in response to injury or inflammation

(Hirschfield and Gershwin, 2013).

Primary biliary cirrhosis is an autoimmune disease of the liver. It is

marked by slow progressive destruction of the small bile ducts of the

liver, with the intralobular ducts (Canals of Hering) affected early in

the disease. When these ducts are damaged, bile and other toxins

build up in the liver (cholestasis) and over time damages the liver

tissue in combination with ongoing immune related damage.

Page 18: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

4

This can lead to scarring (fibrosis) and cirrhosis. (Rajani, et al.

2009).

2.2 Liver cirrhosis

Cirrhosis is a chronic disease of the liver in which diffuse destruction and

regeneration of hepatic parenchymal cells has occurred, in which diffuse

increase in connective tissue has resulted in disorganization of the lobular

architecture. The triad of parenchymal necrosis, regeneration and scarring

is always present regardless of individual clinical manifestations. In the

evolution of many chronic liver diseases cirrhosis is a stage that is

considered to be irreversible. Cirrhosis can be stabilized by controlling the

primary disease but its presence implies consequences such as portal

hypertension, intrahepatic shunting of blood, impaired parenchymal

function affecting protein synthesis, hormone metabolism and excretion of

bile. The most common complications are: gastrointestinal hemorrhage,

ascites, encephalopathy, bacterial infections, renal failure, hepatocellular

carcinoma and hepatic failure. Certain reversible components of cirrhosis

have been indicated where significant histological improvement have

occurred with regression of cirrhosis but complete resolution with a return

to normal architecture seems unlikely. The underlying immunological

response has usually been acting for months or years where inflammation

and tissue repairing are in progress simultaneously which leads in the end

to fibrosis and cirrhosis (Iredale and Guha, 2007). 2.2.1 Causes of liver cirrhosis

It has many possible causes; sometimes more than one cause is present in

the same person. Globally, 57% of cirrhosis is attributable to either hepatitis

B (30%) or hepatitis C (27%). Alcohol consumption is another important

cause, accounting for about 20% of the cases (Perz, et al. 2006).

Page 19: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

5

Alcoholic liver disease (ALD). Alcoholic cirrhosis develops for 10–

20% of individuals who drink heavily for a decade or more. Alcohol

seems to injure the liverby blocking the normal metabolism of protein,

fats, and carbohydrates. This injury happens through the formation of

acetaldehyde from alcohol which itself is reactive, but also leads to the

accumulation of products in the liver. Patients may also have concurrent

alcoholic hepatitis with fever, hepatomegaly, jaundice, and anorexia.

AST and ALT are both elevated but less than 300 IU/ liter with an AST:

ALT ratio > 2.0, a value rarely seen in other liver diseases. In the United

States, 2/5 of cirrhosis related deaths are due to alcohol (Dan, 2012).

Non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH). In NASH, fat builds up in the

liver and eventually causes scar tissue. This type of hepatitis appears to

be associated with obesity (40% of NASH patients) diabetes, protein

malnutrition, coronary artery disease, and treatment with corticosteroid

medications. This disorder is similar to that of alcoholic liver disease but

patient does not have an alcohol history. Biopsy is needed for diagnosis

(Friedman, 2014).

Chronic hepatitis C. Infection with the hepatitis C virus causes

inflammation of the liver and a variable grade of damage to the organ.

Over several decades this inflammation and grade change can lead to

cirrhosis. Among patients with chronic hepatitis C 20-30% will develop

cirrhosis. Cirrhosis caused by hepatitis C and alcoholic liver disease are

the most common reasons for liver transplant. (Friedman, 2014).

Chronic hepatitis B. The hepatitis B virus causes liver inflammation and

injury that over several decades can lead to cirrhosis. Hepatitis D is

dependent on the presence of hepatitis B and accelerates cirrhosis in co-

infection. Chronic hepatitis B can be diagnosed with detection of

HBsAG > 6 months after initial infection. HBeAG and HBV DNA are

determined to assess whether patient needs antiviral therapy (Dan,

Page 20: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

6

2012).

Primary biliary cirrhosis. Damage of the bile ducts leading to secondary

liver damage. May be asymptomatic or complain of fatigue, pruritus,

and non-jaundice skin hyperpigmentation with hepatomegaly. There is

prominent alkaline phosphatase elevation as well as elevations in

cholesterol and bilirubin. Gold standard diagnosis is antimitochondrial

antibodies (positive in 90% of PBC patients). Liver biopsy if done

shows bile duct lesions. It is more common in women (Dan, 2012).

Autoimmune hepatitis. This disease is caused by the immunologic

damage to the liver causing inflammation and eventually scarring and

cirrhosis. Findings include elevations in serum globulins, especially

gamma globulins. Therapy with prednisone and/or azathioprine is

beneficial. Cirrhosis due to autoimmune hepatitis still has 10-year

survival of 80+ % (Dan, 2012). Hereditary hemochromatosis. Usually presents with family history of

cirrhosis, skin hyperpigmentation, diabetes mellitus, pseudogout, and/or

cardiomyopathy, all due to signs of iron overload. Labs show

fasting transferrin saturation of > 60% and ferritin >

300 ng/ml. Treatment is with phlebotomy to lower total body iron

levels (Dan, 2012).

Infection by a parasite common in developing countries

(schistosomiasis). Over a period of three years 410in-patients

harbouring Schistosoma mansoni were under the authors’ care in a

hospital in the Sudan. All had been infected for some times. The ratio of

males to females was 10:1; this was largely owing to the reluctance of

the women to enter hospital. Many of the patients were found only by

chance to be infected. In those with clinical manifestations of the disease

a dysenteric diarrhea with abdominal discomfort, anorexia and lack of

Page 21: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

7

energy were the usual complains. Liver enlargement, in the Aljazeera

Hospital, is usually due to Schistosomiasis mansion infection and but

rarely to other causes. The cirrhotic changes in the liver may be due

either to the Schistosomiasis or to malnutrition, but the standard of

nutrition in the area is good.

2.2.2 Clinical features of liver cirrhosis

Fatigue and malaise are common in all forms of cirrhosis, but these

nonspecific symptoms are found in almost all acute and chronic liver

diseases. Characteristic but nondiagnostic physical findings of cirrhosis

include palmar erythema and spider nevi. Other typical findings include

gynecomastia, testicular atrophy, and evidence of portal hypertension

(splenomegaly, ascites, and prominence of the veins of the abdominal wall).

Other physical abnormalities, such as Dupuytren contracture, xanthelasma,

xanthomas, Kayser-Fleischer rings, a bronze discoloration of the skin, and

hyperpigmentation, are found in specific forms of cirrhosis. The cirrhotic

liver is usually large, and the left lobe is often palpable below the xiphoid

process. Only a patient in the advanced inactive stage of disease exhibits a

small and shrunken liver (Colledge, et al. 2010). 2.3 Complications of liver cirrhosis

2.3.1 Ascites

Ascites: ascites usually occurs when the liver stops working properly .fluid

fills the space between the lining of the abdomen and the organs. Ascites is

most often caused by liver scarring .this increases pressure inside the liver

blood vessels .the increased pressure can force fluid into the abdominal

cavity, causing ascites .liver damage is the single biggest risk factor for

ascites .some causes of liver damage include : cirrhosis, hepatitis B or C

and history of alcohol use .

Other conditions that may increase your risk of ascites include:

Page 22: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

8

Ovarian,pancreatic,liver,or endometrial cancer

Heart or kidney failure

Pancreatitis

Tuberculosis

Hypothyroidism

Salt restriction is often necessary, as cirrhosis leads to accumulation of salt

(sodium retention). Traditionally, three fourths of spontaneous bacterial

peritonitis infections have been caused by aerobic gram-negative organisms

(50% of these being Escherichia coli). The remainder has been due to

aerobic gram-positive organisms (19% streptococcal species). Diuretics

may be necessary to suppress ascites. Diuretic options for inpatient

treatment include aldosterone antagonists (spironolactone) and loop

diuretics. Aldosterone antagonists are preferred for people who can take

oral medications and are not in need of an urgent volume reduction. Loop

diuretics can be added as additional therapy (Moore and Aithal, 2006). If a rapid reduction of volume is required, paracentesis is the preferred

option. This procedure requires the insertion of a plastic tube into the

peritoneal cavity. Human albumin solution is usually given to prevent

complications from the rapid reduction. In addition to being more rapid

than diuretics, 4–5 liters of paracentesis is more successful in comparison to

diuretic therapy (Moore and Aithal, 2006). 2.3.2 Esophageal variceal bleeding

Esophageal varices sometimes form when blood flow to your liver is

obstructed; most often by scar tissue in the liver caused by liver disease.

The blood flow to your liver begins to back up, increasing pressure within

the large vein (portal vein) that carries blood to your liver.

This pressure (portal hypertension) forces the blood to seek alternate

pathways through smaller veins, such as those in the lowest part of the

esophagus. These thin –walled veins balloon with the added blood.

Sometimes the veins can rupture and bleed.

Page 23: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

9

Causes of esophageal varices include:

Severe liver scarring (cirrhosis)

Blood clot (thrombosis)

A parasitic infection

For portal hypertension, propranolol is a commonly used agent to lower

blood pressure over the portal system. In severe complications from portal

hypertension, transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunting (TIPS) is

occasionally indicated to relieve pressure on the portal vein. As this

shunting can worsen encephalopathy, it is reserved for those patients at low

risk of encephalopathy. TIPS is generally regarded only as a bridge to liver

transplantation or as a palliative measure (Moore and Aithal, 2006). 2.3.3 Hepatic encephalopathy

High-protein food increases the nitrogen balance, and would theoretically

increase encephalopathy; in the past, this was therefore eliminated as much

as possible from the diet. Recent studies show that this assumption was

incorrect, and high-protein foods are even encouraged to maintain adequate

nutrition (Sundaram and Shaikh, 2009). 2.3.4 Hepatorenal syndrome

The hepatorenal syndrome is defined as a urine sodium less than

10 mmol/L and a serum creatinine > 1.5 mg/dl (or 24 hour creatinine

clearance less than 40 ml/min) after a trial of volume expansion without

diuretics (Sundaram and Shaikh, 2009). 2.3.5 Spontaneous bacterial peritonitis

People with ascites due to cirrhosis are at risk of spontaneous bacterial

peritonitis (Sundaram and Shaikh, 2009).

2.3.6 Portal hypertensive gastropathy

Which refers to changes in the mucosa of the stomach in people with portal

hypertension, and is associated with cirrhosis severity (Kim, et al.

2010).

Page 24: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

10

2.3.7 Infection

Cirrhosis can cause immune system dysfunction, leading to infection. Signs

and symptoms of infection may be aspecific and are more difficult to

recognize (for example, worsening encephalopathy but no fever) (Kim, et

al. 2010). 2.3.8 Hepatocellular carcinoma

Hepatocellular carcinoma is a primary liver cancer that is more common in

people with cirrhosis. People with known cirrhosis are often screened

intermittently for early signs of this tumor, and screening has been shown

to improve outcomes (Singal, et al. 2014). 2.4 Treatment of liver cirrhosis

The only established therapy for patients with alcoholic liver disease is to

stop drinking alcohol. Patients with alcoholic cirrhosis who continue to

drink seem to have a poorer prognosis than those who stop. The 5-year

survival rate for patients who drink is less than 40% but may reach 60% to

70% if abstinence is maintained. Although pessimism abounds, as many as

30% of patients with alcoholic liver disease may succeed in abstaining

completely. Thus, the emphasis in treatment should be to support patients’

efforts to stop drinking. Various rehabilitation units, peer support groups,

and psychotherapeutic techniques are available (Dan, 2012). 2.5 Nutritional support

The marked nutritional deficiencies noted in many patients with alcoholic

cirrhosis have led most physicians to recommend nutritional support during

the acute illness. A large cooperative study evaluated the role of

an enteral food supplement in decompensated alcoholic liver disease.

The investigators demonstrated a direct relation between caloric

intake and survival and found that vigorous nutritional support

enhanced survival, particularly in severely malnourished patients

Page 25: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

11

(Colledge, et al. 2010).

2.6 Nutrition of liver cirrhosis patients

Together with the consequences described above deterioration in liver

function also have various nutritional consequences upon, for example on

protein, carbohydrate and lipid metabolism as they all are partly controlled

by the liver. Additionally, levels of neurotransmitters are affected by the

inflammatory state further affecting the risk of malnutrition. Frequent

finding in patients with liver cirrhosis is protein-calorie malnutrition

(PCM), leading to severe consequences to the general state and clinical

evaluation of the patient. It had been demonstrated that PCM is an

independent risk factor for death among patients with chronic hepatic

disease, contributing to the emergence of more severe complications in

cirrhotic patients, such as ascites, hepatic encephalopathy and infections.

Multiple factors which are common to the underlying disease directly

contribute to malnutrition, among them; anorexia, nausea, deficient food

intake and absorption and catabolic state (Singal, et al. 2014). In addition,

the many dietary restrictions used to control symptoms and specific

complications, such as ascites and hepatic encephalopathy, aggravate the

nutritional status, predisposing the patients to infections and worsening of

the functional hepatic status (Olde-Damink, et al. 2009). 2.6.1 Inadequate food intake

Ascites adds pressure in the abdomen reducing the space for the gastric

space to expand. Research investigating the effect of ascites has shown a

direct link to decreased gastric volume with increasing ascites, this will lead

to early loss of appetite (Aqel, et al, 2005)

2.6.2 Altered levels of Leptin and Ghrelin

High levels of TNF-α increase the levels of the satiety hormone Leptin.

Also reduced levels of Ghrelin further slows down appetite. Lack of

appetite and early satiety increases risk of malnutrition (Kalaitzakis, et al.,

Page 26: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

12

2007) 2.6.3 Reduced production of bile

Bile is produced by the liver and a reduction in production is correlated

with disease of the liver. A reduction in bile production affects the

absorption of fat-soluble vitamins such as A, D, E and K. Malabsorption of

fat and fat-soluble vitamins (Juakiem, et al., 2014). 2.6.4 Altered metabolism

By-pass of nutrient rich blood due to portal vein hypertension without

appropriate metabolism. Reduced storage capacity of glycogen results in

early fasting metabolism converting body proteins to glucose via

glyconeogenese. All liver cirrhosis patients develop insulin resistance (IR)

and IR can be used as a marker for early diagnosis. IR will over time lead to

Hepatogenous Diabetes in the a majority of liver cirrhosis patients (Juakiem

et al., 2014) 2.7 Nutritional assessment of patients with liver cirrhosis

2.7.1 Food intake

Methods of evaluating food intake in this patient population does not differ

from other patients and are based on the preference of the professional who

performs the evaluation as well as the literacy level of the patient. Some of

these methods include 24- hour food recalls, food frequency questionnaires,

calorie counts, and food diaries (Johnson, et al. 2013). The 24-hour re- call is perhaps the most rapid, low cost method, al-though it

relies on the patient’s memory and may be difficult to obtain in patients

with encephalopathy or Alzheimer’s disease. (Johnson, et al. 2013).

Serum levels of albumin, one of the most abundant hepatic proteins, have

long been used as a marker of nutrition status and malnutrition. More

recently, prealbumin levels that have a shorter half- life and are able to

Page 27: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

13

show changes more rapidly than albumin levels have been considered as the

nutrition marker of choice by many practitioners. How- ever albumin,

prealbumin, and many of the other hepatic proteins such as transferrin are

affected by numerous factors other than nutrition status. They are negative

acute-phase proteins, which means their levels decrease in response to

infection/inflammation, injury, or trauma (Johnson, et al. 2013).

Patients at risk for malnutrition should receive aggressive nutrition therapy.

Another use for these hepatic proteins is to evaluate the effectiveness of

nutrition therapy as one study by Casati et al. (1998) has reported that

prealbumin and retinol-binding protein levels correlate positively with

nitrogen balance of patients who receive parenteral nutrition. 2.7.2 Dietary management of liver cirrhosis

In general, patients with cirrhosis are advised to consume 4-6 small

frequent meals through- out the day to be able to meet their higher needs.

Researchers have recommended that the simple addition of a carbohydrate

and protein-rich evening snack may also help nitrogen balance, improve

muscle cramps and prevent muscle breakdown by supplying the body with

overnight carbohydrate energy, and preventing gluconeogenesis. (Zillikens,

et al. 2003).

2.8 Dietary modification in patients with liver cirrhosis

Energy: The primary goal for a patient suffering from liver cirrhosis should

be to avoid by all means possible intentional or unintentional weight loss

and sustain a diet rich in nutrients. It has been suggested that patients with

liver cirrhosis should receive 35–40 kcal/kg per day (Plauth, et al. 2006). Protein: The consensus of opinion nowadays is that protein restriction be

avoided in all but a small number of patients with severe protein intolerance

and that protein be maintained between 1.2 and 1.5gm of proteins per kg of

Page 28: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

14

body weight per day. In severely protein intolerant patients, particularly in

patients in grades III-IV HE, protein may be reduced for short periods of

time (Merli and Riggio, 2009). Carbohydrate: An intake of 4-6 gm/kg carbohydrate ensures adequate

glycogen reserves needed for the maintenance of liver function for

protection against further injury to the liver and for its protein sparing

action (Plauth, et al. 2006). Fats: Mortality from cirrhosis in many countries is greater than what per

capita alcohol consumption would predict. Several investigations have

concluded that excess dietary fat may encourage cirrhosis progression. High

intakes of total fat, saturated fat, and polyunsaturated fat have been

implicated (Plauth, et al. 2006). Antioxidants and B-vitamins: Due to a reduction in food intake and

documented deficiencies of several nutrients in cirrhosis, patients should

take at least a multiple vitamin with minerals that meets 100% of the dietary

allowance for all vitamins and minerals (Leevy and Moroianu, 2005). Sodium: A sodium-restricted diet is standard treatment. A 2000 mg

sodium-restricted diet is effective, when combined with diuretic therapy, for

controlling fluid overload in 90% of patients with cirrhosis and ascites.

Evidence also indicates that sodium-restricted diets improve survival

(Leevy and Moroianu, 2005).

Branched-chain amino acids: In a multicenter randomized trial of 646

patients with decompensated cirrhosis, the ingestion of 12 g/day of

branched-chain amino acids over 2 years was associated with decreased

mortality of roughly 35%, compared with nutrition support from diet alone.

(Muto, et al. 2005).

Omega-3: Use of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (n-3 PUFAs) as a

potential treatment of NAFLD have been described. n-3 PUFAs, besides

having a beneficial impact on most of the cardio-metabolic risk factors

Page 29: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

15

(hypertension, hyperlipidemia, endothelial dysfunction and atherosclerosis)

by regulating gene transcription factors, carbohydrate responsive element-

binding protein], impacts both lipid metabolism and on insulin sensitivity.

In addition to an enhancement of hepatic beta oxidation and a decrease of

the endogenous lipid production, n-3 PUFAs are able to determine a

significant reduction of the expression of pro-inflammatory molecules

(tumor necrosis factor-α and interleukin-6) and of oxygen reactive species

(Di Minno et al. 2012). 2.9 Medical management

2.9.1 Medications

A healthy diet is encouraged, as cirrhosis may be an energy-consuming

process. Close follow-up is often necessary. Antibiotics are prescribed for

infections, and various medications can help with itching. Laxatives, such

as lactulose, decrease risk of constipation; their role in preventing

encephalopathy is limited (Iredale and Guha, 2007). 2.10 Meal satisfaction

As liver disease is often chronic and progressive, frequent monitoring of

medication and progression of the disease is necessary. Therefore, besides

the quality of the medical therapy, good quality of care is important to these

patients as they frequently interact with their physicians. Besides good

medical therapy, good quality of care determines patient satisfaction.

Patient satisfaction, in turn, has proven to be important in compliance with

treatment, seeking medical advice and maintenance of a continuous

relationship with a physician. Also, patient satisfaction and quality of care

are increasingly of interest to health insurance companies or health

maintenance organizations that wish to negotiate prices when purchasing

health care (Weaver, et al. 2003). Murray (2001) has developed a methodology protocol to develop a

standardized series of questionnaires measuring Quality of Care Through

Page 30: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

16

the Patient's Eyes (QUOTE), based on market research theory, which

asserts that client satisfaction should be measured by looking at the

discrepancy between what clients need/expect and what they actually

receive. QUOTE instruments consist of two parts: the weight (importance)

patients assign to different aspects of health care, second, patients'

experiences with health care (performance). From the combined effect of

importance and performance, the quality index can be obtained. One study found that aspects of care such as accessibility, cooperation with

other health care workers, and accommodation are of lesser importance to

patients with chronic liver disease. In another study the researcher found

dissatisfaction on items pertaining to accessibility (by telephone), doctors'

and nurses' psychosocial approach, information, cooperation with other

health care workers, privacy, and patient authority, rather than medical

competence, contact, and communication, with the exception of

'information' (Hekkink, et al. 2003). A study was done by Sahin, et al. (2006) to determine the factors affecting

general satisfaction level of patients with the food services in a military

hospital in Turkey. Results showed that patient-specific demographic

characteristics were insignificant in explaining satisfaction level with food

services, but the variables of taste and appearance of the food were

statistically significant and important determinants of patient satisfaction

with the foods served at the hospital. 2.11 Previous studies

According to Greenberger et al., (2007) in a case studies of three patients

with HE treated with vegetable and animal protein diets revealed that

vegetable protein diets resulted in lower HE index scores as well as

decreased serum ammonia levels. The patients who received animal

proteins in this study had higher fetor hepaticus, which was also parallel to

their mental status deterioration. In another study, Uribe et al. (2009) also

Page 31: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

17

compared the effects of 40g and 80 g vegetable protein diets, along with a

40g animal protein diet. They found improved patient performance on both

vegetable diets. However, patients on the 80g vegetable diet complained of

the volume of food they need to consume for 80g of protein, since many

vegetable protein sources are also rich sources of fiber and lead to increased

fullness. Although a bit harder and bulkier to eat, the high fiber content of

vegetable protein sources seems to have its own benefits on patients with

cirrhosis, by decreasing ammonia levels.

Page 32: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the
Page 33: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Chapter Three

Subjects and Methods

Page 34: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

18

Chapter Three

3. Subjects and Methods

3.1 Type of research:

Descriptive, cross – sectional Hospital based study.

3.2 Study area:

Ibn –Sina Specialized Hospital was built in early 80th in previous century

and it located in Khartoum Sudan, south Khartoum Mohamed Nagib

street and between 17th and 21th street.

Ibn – Sina have three major departments:

- Gastroenterology (GIT).

- Nephrology.

- ENT.

3.3 Study population:

All patients admitted to hospital with liver cirrhosis and who agreed to

participate in the study during the study period from September to

November 2015. Exclusion end stage and severe complication.

3.4 Study sample and method of selection:

30 patients were case –findings as sampling technique from medical

wards in IBN-SINA hospital.

3.5 Data collection:

3.5.1 Primary data:

By questionnaire including Socio economic, demographic, medical

and diet histories.

Weights and heights were measured to calculate the BMI.

The food intake data were collected by 24 hour record method.

HB, albumin, ALP, ALT and AST were taken from patients files.

Page 35: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

19

3.5.2 Secondary data:

Website, books, journals, previous studies.

3.6 Data analysis:

Data were analyzed using statistical packages for social sciences (SPSS)

version 20, significant considered at P. value less than (0.05).

Page 36: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

20

Page 37: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Chapter Four

Results

Page 38: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

20

Chapter Four

4. Results

Table (1) General information of patients

Parameters N %

Gender Male 20 66.7

Female 10 33.3

Total 30 100.0

20-40 years 8 26.7

Age group 41 - 60 years 9 30.0

61-80 years 10 33.3

> 80 years 3 10.0

Total 30 100.0

Illiterate 9 30.0

Level of education Primary 5 16.7

Secondary 7 23.3

University 9 30.0

Total 30 100.0

Marital status Single 7 23.3

Married 23 76.7

Total 30 100.0

Omdurman 3 20.0

Bahri 3 10.0

Khartoum 1 3.3

Algaziera 8 26.7

Residence Northern State 4 13.3

Kassala 2 6.7

Port Sudan 3 3.3

White Nile 3 6.7

Halfa 3 10.0

Total 30 100.0

Unemployed 15 50.0

Worker 4 13.3

Occupation Employee 5 16.7

Farmer 2 6.7

Free business 4 13.3

Total 30 100.0

Table (1) shows the general information of the patients. Males were

20(66.7%), females 10(33.3%). The highest percentage 10(33.3%) in the

age group 61-80 years and the lowest percentage 3(10%) in the age group

above 80 years. Nine (30%) were illiterate and the same percentage have

university level of education. Married patients were 23(76.7%) and single

Page 39: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

21

patients were 7(23.3%). Most of the patients 8(26.7%) were resident in

Algaziara area, only 1(3.3%) in Port Sudan. Half of the patients (50%)

were unemployed and 2(6.7%) were farmers.

Table (2) Distribution of patients according to other chronic diseases

N %

Other diseases Yes 17 56.7

No 13 43.3

Total 30 100.0

DM 3 17.6

HTN 4 23.5

Diseases Renal Disease 1 5.9

DM+HTN 7 41.2

DM+HTN + Renal Disease 2 11.8

Total 17 100.0

Other chronic diseases among patients in this study are shown in Table

(2). The majority 17(56.7%) were suffering from other chronic disease,

which include diabetes mellitus and hypertension 7(41.2%), hypertension

4(23.5%), diabetes mellitus 3(17.6%), diabetes mellitus, hypertension and

renal disease 2(11.8%) and renal disease 1(5.9%).

Tables (3) Distribution of the patients according to presenting

symptoms of liver cirrhosis (N=30)*

Symptoms N %

Fatigue 7 23.3

Bleeding easily 4 13.3

Bruising easily 0 0.0

Itchy skin 9 30.0

Jaundice 19 63.3

Ascites 15 50.0

Loss of appetite 22 73.3

Nausea 15 50.0

Swelling of legs 17 56.7

Weight loss 27 90.0

Hepatic encephalopathy 7 23.3

Page 40: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

22

Table (3) shows the common symptoms of liver cirrhosis among the

patients which were weight loss 27(90%), loss of appetite 22(73.3%)

jaundice 19(63.3%), swelling of legs 17(56.7%), nausea 15(50%) and

ascites 15(50%). On the other the less common symptoms were itchy skin

9(30%), fatigue 7(23.3%), hepatic encephalopathy 7(23.3%), and

bleeding easily 4(13.3%).

Table (4) Distribution of the patients according to number of meal

consumed per day

N %

One 0 0.0

Number of meals per day Two 3 10.0

Three 27 90.0

Total 30 100.0

Table (4) shows that the majority of patients 17(90%) eat three meals per

day, and 3(10%) eat two meals per day.

Table (5) Distribution of the patients according to type food cooking

at home

N %

Frying 0 0.0

Boiling 0 0.0

Type of food cooking Grilled 0 0.0

Salty 2 6.7

Stew 28 93.3

Total 30 100.0

Table (5) shows that the majority of the patients 28(93.3%) their food

cooking was stew and 2(6.7%) salty cooking method.

Page 41: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

23

Table (6) Distribution of the patients according to reception of

dietary advices

N %

Yes 7 23.3 Received dietary advises

No 23 76.7

Total 30 100.0

Doctor 0 0.0

Source of advises Nurse 0 0.0

Dietitian 7 100.0

Total 7 100.0

Table (6) shows that 7(23.3%) of the patients received dietary advises in

the hospital and all of them received these advises from dietitian.

Table (7) Distribution of the patients according to consumption of

alcohol

N %

Yes 8 26.7 Drinking alcohol

No 22 73.3

Total 30 100.0

< 5 years 2 25.0

Duration 5-10 years 3 37.5

> 10 years 3 37.5

Total 8 100.0

Page 42: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

24

Table (7) shows that drinking alcohol was found in 8(26.7%) of the

patients, of them 3(37.5%) for more than 10 years, 3(37.5%) for 5-10

years and 2(25%) less than 5 years.

Table (8) Distribution of the patients according to smoking

N %

Yes 6 20.0 Smoking

No 24 80.0

Total 30 100.0

< 5 years 1 16.7

Duration 5-10 years 1 16.7

> 10 years 4 66.6

Total 6 100.0

Table (8) shows that smoking cigarette was found in 6(20%) of the

patients, of them 4(66.6%) for more than 10 years, 1(16.7%) for 5-10

years and 1(16.7%) less than 5 years.

Table (9) Distribution of the patients according to eating served

meals

N %

Yes 25 83.3 Eating served meal

No 5 16.7

Total 30 100.0

Quantity of meal 2 40.0

Causes behind no eating served meals Can't eat, need fluid 2 40.0

Nausea, eat, but not all 1 20.0

Total 5 100.0

Page 43: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

25

Table (9) shows that the majority of patients 25(83.3%) eating several

meals, and 5(16.7%) did not. Two (40%) of those who did not eat

several meals said that it was due to the quality of meal, 2(40%)

because they can't eat and need fluids, and 1(20%) due to nausea did

not eat all types of meals.

Table (10) Distribution of the patients according to satisfaction

towards meal services provided in the hospital

Very Good Satisfactory

Needs

good Improvement

N % N % N % N %

Taste/flavor 1

3.3 9 30.0 18 60.0 2 6.7

of food

The variety of 0

0.0 18 60.0 9 30.0 3 10.0

received food

The temperature 12

40.0 15 50.0 0 0.0 3 10.0

of hot food

Cold food 12 40.0 15 50.0 2 6.7 1 3.3

Friendless and

services from 3 10.0 25 83.3 1 3.3 1 3.3

the staff

The size of portion 7 23.3 14 46.7 7 23.3 2 6.7

Time of food 12

40.0 17 56.7 0 0.0 1 3.3

Distribution

Cleanness of forks, 15

50.0 13 43.3 0 0.0 2 6.7

spoons and dishes served

Quality of food services 5

16.7 20 66.7 2 6.7 3 10.0

in the hospital

Table (10) shows that most of the patients in this study regarded the

food services provided to them in the hospital as good in terms of taste

and flavor, variety, temperature, size and portion, cleanliness and

quality of food services.

Page 44: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

26

Table (11) Distribution of the patients according to consumption

of hospital diet

N %

consumption of hospital diet Yes 19 63.3

No 11 36.7

Total 30 100.0

Table (11) shows that the majority of the patients 19(63.3%) consumed

hospital diet and 11(36.7%) consumed liquid diet.

Table (12) Distribution of the patients according to meeting his/her

cultural food preferences by the hospital

N %

The hospital meeting patients' cultural food preferences Yes 9 30.0

No 21 70.0

Total 30 100.0

Table (12) shows that the majority of the patients 21(70%) claimed that

the hospital did not meet their cultural food preferences and 9(30%)

said it met their preferences.

Table (13) Distribution of the patients according to frequency of

visits by dietitian in the hospital

N %

Frequency of dietitian visits Do not visit 13 43.3

One time 17 56.7

Total 30 100.0

Table (13) shows that 17(56.7%) of the patients visited one time by

dietitian in the hospital and 13(43.3%) were not visited at all.

Page 45: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

27

Table (14) Distribution of the patients according to their opinions

towards the quality of food services compared to other states

hospitals

Total N %

Yes 21 70.0 The hospital food quality is better than other states hospitals

No 9 30.0

Total 30 100.0

As shown in Table (14) the majority of patients 21(70%) agreed that the

hospital food quality is better than that of the other hospitals and

9(30%) did not agree on that.

Table (15) Distribution of the patients according to improvement in

health due to change in diet

N %

Improved 19 63.3 Improvement in health due to change in diet

No change 11 36.7

Total 30 100.0

Table (15) showed that 19(63.3%) of the patients health status was

improved due to change in diet, and 11(36.7%) did not.

Page 46: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

28

Table (16) Distribution of the patients according to BMI and

nutritional status

N %

Underweight (< 18.5) 18 60.0 BMI range

Normal (18.5-24.9) 12 40.0

Total 30 100.0

Weight Loss 6 20.0

Edema 4 13.3

Anemia 3 10.0

Nutritional status Loss of weight + anemia 6 20.0

No change in nutrition status 7 23.3

Loss weight, edema, anemia 2 6.7

Loss weight + edema 2 6.7

Total 30 100.0

Table (16) shows that underweight BMI (< 18.5) was reported in

18(60%) of the patients and normal BMI (18.5 – 24.9) was reported in

12(40%) of the patients. On the other hand no change in nutritional

status was found in 7(23.3%), loss of weight 6(20%), loss of weight in

combination with anemia 6(20%), edema 4(13.3%), anemia 3(10%),

loss of weight, edema, anemia 2(6.7%), loss of weight and edema

2(6.7%).

Page 47: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

29

Table (17) Differences between males and females in BMI and nutritional status

Male Female Chi P

N % N % squire value

BMI range Underweight (< 18.5) 11 36.7 7 23.3

Normal (18.5-24.9) 9 30.0 3 10.0 0.62 0.35*

Total 20 66.7 10 33.3

Loss weight 5 16.7 1 3.3

Edema 3 10.0 1 3.3

Anemia 1 3.3 2 6.7

Nutritional status Loss of weight + anemia 1 3.3 5 16.7 12.3 0.04**

Normal 6 20.0 1 3.3

Loss weight, edema, anemia 2 6.7 0 0.0

Loss weight + edema 2 6.7 0 0.0

Total 20 66.7 10 33.3

* No significant differences (P > 0.05)

** Significant differences (P < 0.05)

Figure (1) Differences between males and females in BMI

Gender

FemaleMale

Co

un

t

12

10

8

6

4

2

BMI range

Underw eight (< 18.5)

Normal (18.5-24.9)

Figure (2) Differences between males and females in nutritional status

Page 48: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

30

Gender

FemaleMale

Co

un

t

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

0

Nutritional status

Loss w eight

Edema

Anemia

Loss of w eight + ane

mia

Normal

Loss w eight, edema,

anemia

Loss w eight + edema

As shown in Table (17) and Figures (1 and 2), no significant differences

in BMI were found between males and fame patients (P > 0.05), where the

prevalence of underweight among males was 11(36.7%) and females

7(23.3%). On the other hand significant differences were found between

males and females in nutritional status (P < 0.05), where loss of weight in

combination was found in only 1(3.3%) of the male patients compared to

5(16.7%) of female patients and males of normal nutritional status were

6(20%) compared to only 1(3.3%) female has the same nutritional status.

Page 49: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

31

Table (18) Differences in nutritional status and BMI according to age

(N=30)

20-40 years 41 - 60 years 61-80 years > 80 years Chi

Squire P value N % N % N % N %

BMI range Underweight (< 18.5) 3 10.0 5 16.7 7 23.3 3 10.0

4.17 0.24 Normal (18.5-24.9) 5 16.7 4 13.3 3 10.0 0 0.0

Total 8 26.7 9 30.0 10 33.3 3 10.0

Nutritional status

Loss weight 1 3.3 1 3.3 3 10.0 1 3.3

14.05 0.02

Edema 2 6.7 1 3.3 1 3.3 0 0.0

Anemia 0 0.0 2 6.7 1 3.3 0 0.0 Loss of weight + anemia 1 3.3 1 3.3 2 6.7 2 6.7

Normal 3 10.0 3 10.0 1 3.3 0 0.0 Loss weight, edema, anemia 1 3.3 0 0.0 1 3.3 0 0.0 Loss weight + edema 0 0.0 1 3.3 1 3.3 0 0.0

Total 8 26.7 9 30.0 10 33.3 3 10.0

Figure (3) Differences in BMI of the patients according to age group

Age group

> 80 years

61-80 years

41 - 60 years

20-40 years

Co

un

t

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

BMI range

Underw eight (< 18.5)

Normal (18.5-24.9)

Figure (4) Differences in nutritional status of the patients according

to age group

Page 50: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

32

Age group

> 80 years

61-80 years

41 - 60 years

20-40 years

Co

un

t

3.5

3.0

2.5

2.0

1.5

1.0

.5

Nutritional status

Loss w eight

Edema

Anemia

Loss of w eight + ane

mia

Normal

Loss w eight, edema,

anemia

Loss w eight + edema

Table (18) shows that no significant differences in BMI of the patients

according to age group (P > 0.05), where 3(10%), 5(16.7%), 7(23.3%) and

3(10%) of the patients in age groups (20-40 years), 41-60 years, 61-80

years and > 80 years respectively fall in the range of underweight BMI.

Concerning nutritional status significant differences were found between

the four age groups (P < 0.05), where loss of weight with anemia found in

1(3.3%), 1(3.3%), 2(6.7%) and 2(6.7%) of the patients in the age groups

(20-40 years), 41-60 years, 61-80 years and > 80 years respectively.

Page 51: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

33

Table (19) Differences of mean values in BMI, HB, albumin and liver

enzyme according to gender of the patients

Gender Mean±SD P value

Male 18.9±3.18

BMI 0.02* Female 16.6±3.06

Male 11.2±2.27

Hb (g/dl) 0.07** Female 8.8±1.86

Male 2.7±0.87

Albumin (g/dl) 0.18** Female 2.2±0.69

Male 139.6±144.55

ALP (U/L) 0.03* Female 73.7±31.29

Male 41.8±28.46

ALT (U/L) 0.31** Female 31.4±18.22

Male 74.8±83.86

AST (U/L) 0.04* Female 35.6±16.44

* Significant differences (P < 0.05)

** No significant differences (P > 0.05)

Table (19) shows the mean differences in BMI, Hb (g/dl), albumin

(g/dl), ALP (U/L), ALT (U/L), and AST (U/L) between males and

females. The mean values of in BMI, Hb (g/dl), albumin (g/dl), ALP

(U/L), ALT (U/L), and AST (U/L) in males were (18.9±3.18),

(11.2±2.27), (2.7±0.87), (139.6±144.55), (41.8±28.46) and

(74.8±83.86) respectively, while in females were (16.6±3.06),

(8.8±1.86), (2.2±0.69), (73.7±31.29), (31.4±18.22), and (35.6±16.44)

respectively. Significant differences the values of BMI, ALP and AST

were found between males and females (P < 0.05) and no significant

differences between the two groups in Hb, albumin and ALT values (P

> 0.05).

Page 52: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

34

Table (20) Differences of mean values of 24 hour intake according to

gender patients

Gender Mean±SD P value

Male 1092.6±428.49

Energy (kcal) 0.83* Female 1126.7±336.46

Male 159.8±62.09

CHO (g) 0.39* Female 181.8±73.25

Male 61.4±25.74

Protein (g) 0.97* Female 61.7±18.29

Male 28.2±15.37

Fat (g) 0.39* Female 23.4±9.39

* No significant differences (P > 0.05)

Table (20) shows that the mean values of total 24 intake of energy

(kcal), carbohydrate (g), protein (g) and fat (g) for males were

(1092.6±428.49), (159.8±62.09), (61.4±25.74) and (28.2±15.37) respectively, and

for females were (1126.7±336.46), (181.8±73.25), (61.7±18.29) and (23.4±9.39)

respectively. There were no significant differences between males and

females in 24 hour recall of total energy, carbohydrate, protein and fat

intake (P > 0.05) (both males and female intake fall with limits of intake

lower than recommended).

Page 53: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

35

Table (21) Differences in mean values in BMI and HB according to

age of the patient

Age group N BMI P value

> 80 years 3 14.67

61-80 years 10 17.65

0.04 * 41 - 60 years 9 18.95

20-40 years 8 19.09

Age group N HB g/dl P value

61-80 years 10 9.9

20-40 years 8 10.3

0.87** > 80 years 3 10.3

41 - 60 years 9 11.0

* Significant differences (P < 0.05)

** No significant differences (P > 0.05)

Table (21) shows that the mean values of BMI were 14.67, 17.65, 18.95

and 19.09 for the age groups > 80 years, 61-80 years, 41-60 years and

20-40 years respectively. There are significant differences in BMI

between the four age groups in the study group (P < 0.05). The mean

values of Hb (g/dl) were 9.9, 10.3, 10.3 and 11.0 for the age groups 81-

80 years, 20-40 years, > 80 years and 41-60 years respectively. No

significant differences found in Hb (g/dl) level among the study group

due to age group (P > 0.05).

Page 54: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

36

Table (22) Differences in mean values in albumin and liver enzyme

according to age of the patient

Age group N Albumin (g/dl) P value

41 - 60 years 9 2.09

> 80 years 3 2.27

0.18* 61-80 years 10 2.53

20-40 years 8 3.04

Age group N ALP (U/L P value

61-80 years 10 92.30

20-40 years 8 109.11

0.23* 41 - 60 years 9 115.56

> 80 years 3 231.37

Age group N ALT (U/L) P value

61-80 years 10 33.41

41 - 60 years 9 38.71

0.89* 20-40 years 8 41.74

> 80 years 3 44.33

Age group N AST (U/L) P value

61-80 years 10 41.16

41 - 60 years 9 47.19

0.18* 20-40 years 8 80.11

> 80 years 3 124.97

* No significant differences (P > 0.05)

Table (22) shows that the mean values of albumin, ALP, ALT and AST

among the study group were not significantly different according to age

(P > 0.05).

Page 55: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

37

Table (23) Differences in mean values in of 24 hour intake of patients

according to age of the patient

Age group N Energy (Kcal) P value

> 80 years 3 803.17

61-80 years 10 899.99 0.08 41 - 60 years 9 1232.36

20-40 years 8 1327.25 Age group N CHO (g) P value

> 80 years 3 130.90

61-80 years 10 141.00 0.36 41 - 60 years 9 185.68

20-40 years 8 192.41 Age group N Protein (g) P value

> 80 years 3 26.77

61-80 years 10 53.97 0.03 41 - 60 years 9 71.28

20-40 years 8 72.85 Age group N Fat (g) P value

> 80 years 3 14.63

61-80 years 10 23.48 0.07 41 - 60 years 9 27.27

20-40 years 8 34.24

As shown in Table (23) no significant differences found in the values of

total energy, carbohydrate and fat intake by the study group according

to age (P > 0.05), but significant difference was found in their total

protein intake.

Page 56: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the
Page 57: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Chapter Five

Discussion

Page 58: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

38

Chapter Five

5. Discussion

This study aimed to assess the dietary management of liver cirrhosis

patients and their satisfaction towards meal services in IBN-SINA hospital.

Thirty patients diagnosed with liver cirrhosis participated in this study, of

them males were (66.7%), females (33.3%). The highest percentage

(33.3%) in the age group 61-80 years and the lowest percentage (10%) in

the age group above 80 years.

In this study, Table (10) shows that most of the patients regarded the food

services provided to them in the hospital as good in terms of taste and

flavor, variety, temperature, size and portion, cleanliness and quality of

food services, moreover Table (14) shows that the majority of patients

(70%) agreed that the hospital food quality is better than that of the other

hospitals. This reflects relatively acceptable level satisfaction among the

study group regarding meal services, due to their demographic

characteristics, where Nine (30%) were of the patients in this study were

illiterates, most of the patients (26.7%) were resident in Algaziara area.

This agreed with study in Turkey by Sahin, et al. (2006) patient-specific

demographic characteristics were insignificant in explaining satisfaction

level with food services, but the variables of taste and appearance of the

food were statistically significant and important determinants of patient

satisfaction with the foods served at the hospital. On the other hand

Hekkink, et al. (2003) found that aspects of care such as accessibility,

cooperation with other health care workers, and accommodation are of

lesser importance to patients with chronic liver disease. In another study

the researcher found dissatisfaction on items pertaining to accessibility (by

telephone), doctors' and nurses' psychosocial approach, information,

cooperation with other health care workers, privacy, and patient authority,

Page 59: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

39

rather than medical competence, contact, and communication, with the

exception of 'information'.

Concerning dietary management of the patients, Table (15) showed that

(63.3%) of the patients’ their health status improved due to change in diet,

and (36.7%) did not. Table (11) shows that the majority of the patients

(63.3%) consumed hospital diet. This indicates positive role of dietary

modification and special in management of liver cirrhosis. Zillikens, et al.

(2003) stated that patients with cirrhosis are advised to consume 4-6 small

frequent meals through- out the day to be able to meet their higher needs.

Researchers have recommended that the simple addition of a carbohydrate

and protein-rich evening snack may also help nitrogen balance, improve

muscle cramps and prevent muscle breakdown by supplying the body with

overnight carbohydrate energy, and preventing gluconeogenesis. As with

the amount, the source and quality of protein consumed by patients with

cirrhosis has also been the subject of numerous research studies.

As for nutrition status of patients in this study, the underweight on BMI (<

18.5) was reported in (60%) of the patients and normal on BMI (18.5 –

24.9) was reported in (40%) of the patients.

On the other hand no change in nutritional status was found in (23.3%),

loss of weight (20%), loss of weight in combination with anemia (20%),

edema (13.3%), anemia (10%), loss of weight, edema, anemia (6.7%), loss

of weight and edema (6.7%). This indicates liver cirrhosis significantly

affect the nutritional status of the patients. Moreover, significant

differences the values of BMI, ALP and AST were found between males

and females (P < 0.05) and no significant differences between the two

groups in Hb, albumin and ALT values (P > 0.05), in addition, no

significant differences were found in Hb (g/dl) level among the study

group due to age group (P > 0.05). Anthropometric measurements

Page 60: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

40

correlated significantly with measurements of albumin concentration but

not with liver function tests. These data suggested that malnutrition is

common in patients with alcoholic and nonalcoholic liver disease

(Thuluvath and Triger, 2009).

Concerning 24 hour recall intake by the patients in this study, Table (20)

shows that the mean values of total 24 intake of energy (kcal), carbohydrate

(g), protein (g) and fat (g) for males were (1092.6±428.49), (159.8±62.09),

(61.4±25.74) and (28.2±15.37) respectively, and for females were

(1126.7±336.46), (181.8±73.25), (61.7±18.29) and (23.4±9.39)

respectively. There were no significant differences between males and

females in 24 hour recall of total energy, carbohydrate, protein and fat

intake (P > 0.05) (both males and female intake fall with limits of intake

lower than recommended). In addition, Table (23) no significant

differences were found in the values of total energy, carbohydrate and fat

intake by the study group according to age (P > 0.05), but significant

difference was found in their total protein intake. Uribe et al. (2009) also

compared the effects of 40g and 80 g plant protein diets, along with a 40g

animal protein diet. They found improved patient performance on NCTs

while on both vegetable diets. So, the quality of protein and all

macronutrients affects the malnourished patient situation as by as the

quantities Casati et al. (1998).

Page 61: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Chapter Six

Conclusion and

Recommendations

Page 62: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

41

Chapter Six

6. Conclusion and Recommendations

6.1 Conclusion

- The majority of the patients with liver cirrhosis in this study were

males, most of them in older ages (61-80 years), the majority from

outside Khartoum State and half of them unemployed.

- Most of the patients in this study regarded the food services

provided to them in the hospital as good in terms of taste and

flavor, variety, temperature, size and portion, cleanliness and

quality of food services.

- The majority of the patients’ health status improved due to change

in diet. High proportion of the patients consumed modified diet,

which indicates positive role of dietary modification and special in

management of liver cirrhosis.

- Low BMI was found among high proportion of the patients in this

study, in addition to high prevalence of loss of weight and anemia.

Significant differences were found between males and females in

BMI, but no significant differences found due to age.

- All patients reported abnormal levels of albumin, ALT, and AST.

Significant differences in the values of BMI, ALP and AST were

found between males and females and no significant differences

between the two groups in Hb, albumin and ALT values, in

addition, no significant differences were found in Hb (g/dl) level

among the study group due to age group.

- All patients’ 24 hour recall intake was found to be lower than

recommended in energy, carbohydrates, protein and fat. There were

no significant differences between males and females as well as

between different age groups of patients in 24 hour recall of total

Page 63: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

42

energy, carbohydrate, protein and fat intake.

6.2 Recommendations

- The healthcare providers should provide liver cirrhosis patients

with the best and most appropriate nutrition intervention beneficial

to patient according to their needs, clinical status, and disease stage.

- Nutritional care by dietitian of the nutritional regimen should be

undertaken for all cirrhotic patients to reduce occurrence of

complications of malnutrition and improve clinical outcome.

- A high protein diet is important for people with chronic liver

disease as the protein is used to maintain muscles and body tissues

(including the liver) and to keep the body working normally.

- Sodium restriction and other modifications should be considered in

patient meal.

- Local or stable diet should be high- lighted in the patient’s meals.

- Patients should be advised to modify their intake of energy, protein,

carbohydrate and fat according to their nutritional status.

- Small, frequent meals 4-7 times a day, including an evening snack

are recommended.

- Meal services, as well as follow up by nutritionists and dietitians

with patients of liver cirrhosis should be improved.

Page 64: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

References

Page 65: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

43

References - Abdel-Misih, S. R. Z. and Bloomston, M. (2010). Liver Anatomy.

Surgical Clinics of North America 90 (4): 643–53. - Aqel, B. a, Scolapio, J. S., Dickson, R. C., Burton, D. D., & Bouras, E.

P. (2005). Contribution of ascites to impaired gastric function and

nutritional intake in patients with cirrhosis and ascites. Clinical

Gastroenterology and Hepatology: The Official Clinical Practice

Journal of the American Gastroenterological Association, 3(11),

1095–100. - Casati A, Muttini S, Leggieri C, Colombo S, Giorgi E, Torri G.

(1998). Rapid turnover proteins in critically ill ICU patients. Negative

acute phase proteins as nutritional indicators? Mi-nerva

Anestesiol. 64:345-50.

- Colledge, N. R. Walker, B. R. and Ralston, S. H. (2010). Davidson's

Principles and Practice of Medicine. 1st

Edition. Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone, p 1376.

- Cotran, R. S.; Kumar, V. Fausto, N. Nelso F. Robbins, S. L. Abbas, A.

K. (2005). Robbins and Cotran pathologic basis of disease (7th ed.).

St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders. p. 878. ISBN 0-7216-0187-1. - Dan L. L. (2012). Harrison's principles of internal medicine. (18th

ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill. pp. Chapter 308. Cirrhosis and Its

Complications. ISBN 9780071748896. - Di Minno, M. N. D., Russolillo, A., Lupoli, R., Ambrosino, P., Di Minno, A.,

and Tarantino, G. (2012). Omega-3 fatty acids for the treatment of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. World Journal of Gastroenterology : WJG, 18(41), 5839–5847.

- Friedman LS (2014). Current medical diagnosis and treatment.

Mcgraw-Hill. pp. Chapter 16. Liver, Biliary Tract, & Pancreas

Disorders.ISBN 978-0071806336. - Greenberger N. J, Carley J., Schenker S., Bettinger I., Stamnes C.,

Page 66: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

44

Beyer P. (2007). Effect of vegetable and animal protein diets in

chronic hepatic encephalopathy. Am J Dig Dis. 22:845–55. - Hekkink C. F., Sixma H. J., Wigersma L., Yzermans C. J., Van Der

Meer J. T., Bindels P. J., Brinkman K., Danner S. A. (2003). QUOTE-

HIV: an instrument for assessing quality of HIV care from the patients'

perspective. Qual Saf Health Care, 12:188-193.

- Hirschfield, G. M. and Gershwin, M. E. (2013). The

immunobiology and pathophysiology of primary biliary

cirrhosis. Annual review of pathology 8: 303–30.

- Iredale J. P., and Guha I. N. (2007). The evolution of cirrhosis. In:

Textbook of hepatology from basic science to clinical practice. 3rd

edition. Edited by Rodés J, Benhamou J-P, Blei A, Reichen J, Rizzetto

M. Oxford, Blackwell Publishing; 583-589. - Johnson TM, Overgard EB, Cohen AE, DiBaise JK. (2013). Nutrition

Assessment and Management in Advanced Liver Dis ease. Nutr Clin

Pract. 28:15-29. - Juakiem, W., Torres, D. M., & Harrison, S. a. (2014). Nutrition in

cirrhosis and chronic liver disease. Clinics in Liver Disease, 18(1),

179–90. - Kalaitzakis, E., Bosaeus, I., Ohman, L., & Björnsson, E. (2007).

Altered postprandial glucose, insulin, leptin, and ghrelin in liver

cirrhosis: correlations with energy intake and resting energy

expenditure. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 85(3), 808–

15. - Kim MY, Choi H, Baik SK; (2010). "Portal Hypertensive Gastropathy:

Correlation with Portal Hypertension and Prognosis in Cirrhosis". Dig

Dis Sci 55(12): 3561–7. - Leevy C. M., and Moroianu S. A. (2005). Nutritional aspects of

Page 67: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

45

alcoholic liver disease. Clin Liver Dis. 9:67–81. - Merli M. and Riggio O. (2009). Dietary and nutritional indications in

hepatic encephalopathy, Metabolic Brain Disease, 24(1): 211– 221. - Moore KP, and Aithal GP (2006). Guidelines on the management of

ascites in cirrhosis. Gut. 55 Suppl 6 (Suppl 6): vi1–12. - Murray C. J, Kawabata K., Valentine N. (2001). People's experience

versus people's expectations. Health Aff (Millwood), 20:21-24 - Muto Y, Sato S, Watanabe A, (2005). Effects of oral branched– chain

amino acid granules on event–free survival in patients with liver

cirrhosis. Clin GastroenterolHepatol. 3:705–713. - Olde-Damink S.W., Dejong C. H. and Jalan R., (2009).

Hyperammoneamic and catabolic consequences of upper

gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhosis, Alimantary Pharmacology and

Therapeutic, 29(8): 801:810. - Perz J. F., Armstrong G. L., Farrington L. A., Hutin Y. J, Bell B. P.

(2006). The contributions of hepatitis B virus and hepatitis C virus

infections to cirrhosis and primary liver cancer worldwide. J. Hepatol.

45 (4): 529–38. - Plauth, M. Cabré, E. and Riggio O. (2006). ESPEN Guidelines on

Enteral Nutrition: liver disease, Clinical Nutrition, 25(2): 285–294.

- Rajani R., Melin T., Björnsson E., Broomé U., Sangfelt P., Danielsson

A., Gustavsson A., Grip O., Svensson H., Lööf L.,

Wallerstedt S., Almer S. H. (2009). "Budd-Chiari syndrome in

Sweden: epidemiology, clinical characteristics and survival - an 18-

year experience". Liver International 29 (2): 253–9. - Sahin, B. Demir, C. Celik, Y. Teke, A. K. (2006). Factors Affecting

Satisfaction Level with the Food Services in a Military Hospital.

Journal of Medical Systems, 30(5): 381-387.

Page 68: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

46

- Singal AG, Pillai A, Tiro J (2014). "Early detection, curative

treatment, and survival rates for hepatocellular carcinoma

surveillance in patients with cirrhosis: a meta-analysis". PLoS

Med 11 (4): e1001624.

- Sundaram V, and Shaikh OS (2009). Hepatic encephalopathy:

pathophysiology and emerging therapies. Med. Clin. North

Am. 93 (4): 819–36.

- Uribe M, Marquez MA, Garcia Ramos G, Ramos-Uribe MH, Vargas

F, Villalobos A, (2009). Treatment of chronic portal-- systemic

encephalopathy with vegetable and ani- mal protein diets. A controlled

crossover study. Dig Dis Sci. 27:1109-16. - Weaver M. J., Ow C. L., Walker D. J., Degenhardt E. F (2003). A

questionnaire for patients' evaluations of their physicians' humanistic

behaviors. J Gen Intern Med, 8:135-139. - WebMD (2015). Cirrhosis of the Liver, www.m.webmd.com/,

accessed November 21st

2015. - Zakim, D. B., and Thomas D. (2002). Hepatology: A Textbook of Liver

Disease (4th ed). ISBN 9780721690513. - Zillikens MC, van den Berg JW, Wattimena JL, Rietveld T, Swart GR.

(2003). Nocturnal oral glucose supplementation. The effects on protein

metabolism in cirrhotic patients and in healthy controls. J Hepatol.

17:377-83.

Page 69: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

Appendixes

Page 70: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

A

Appendix 1

Questionnaire Form

Questionnaire about;

Dietary Management of Liver Cirrhosis in IBN –SINA hospital (in

patient )

1. NO……………………………………………………………… 2. Name…

3. Sex ; Male ( ) Female ( )

4. Age : less than 20 ( ) 20-29 ( ) 30-39 ( ) 40- 49 ( )

50-59 ( ) 60-69( ) 70and more ( )

5. Level of education?

Illiterates ( ) Primary ( ) Secondary ( ) University ( ) Postgraduate ( )

6. Marital Status:

Single ( ) Married ( ) Divorced ( ) Widow ( )

7. Residence……………….. 8. Occupation?............................................................. 9. Did you suffer from any other disease? Yes ( ) No ( ) ,

If yes what?

DM ( ) HTN ( ) Heart disease ( ) Renal disease ( ) 10. The type of food cooking at home:

Frying ( ) Boiling ( ) Grilled ( ) Salty ( ) Stow ( ) 11. Number of meals per

day in hospital?

One ( ) Two ( ) Three

( ) 12. Dietary advised? Yes ( ) No ( )

If yes by whom : Doctor ( ) Nurse ( ) Dietitian ( )

13. The symptom of liver cirrhosis:

a) Fatigue( )

b) Bleeding easily ( )

c) Bruising easily( )

d) Itchy skin ( )

e) Yellow discoloration in the skin and eyes (jaundice) ( )

Page 71: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

B

f) Fluid accumulation in your abdomen (ascites) ( )

g) Loss of appetite ( )

h) Nausea ( )

i) Swelling in your legs ( )

j) Weight loss ( )

k) Confusion, drowsiness and slurred speech (hepatic encephalopathy)

( )

14. Are you drinking alcohol? Yes ( ) No ( )

If yes, for how long?

……………………………………………………………………………

…...

15. Are you smoking? Yes ( ) No ( )

If yes for how long....................................................................... 16. Do you eat served meal in hospital?

Yes ( ) No( )

17. If you don't eat served meal, what is the cause?

1- quantity of meal 2- quality of meal

3- time of meal 4- appearance of meal

18. The taste/flavor of your food was:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

19. The variety of foods you received was:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

20. The temperature of your hot food was

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

21. cold food was

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

Page 72: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

C

22. Friendliness and service from staff was:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

23. The size of portions were:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

24. Time of food distribution of your food was:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

25. The cleanness of fork, spoons and dishes served was:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

26. Quality of foods services in this hospital was:

1- Very good 2- Good 3- Satisfactory 4- Needs improvement

27. Are you on a special diet? Yes ( ) No ()

28. Have we met your cultural food preferences? Yes( ) No ( )

29. Dietitian visit for you was:

1- daily 2- per 3 days 3- per5 days 4-weekly 5- do not visit

30. Can you say that this hospital serves more quality foods services compared to other

States

Hospital? 1- Yes 2- No

31. What improvement have you noticed concerning your health after the change in diet?

Improved ( ) No change ( ) 32. Weight ( ) 33. Height ( ) 34. BMI ( )

35. Nutritional status; loss weight ( ) edema ( ) anemia ( ) 36. 24 hr recall

Break fast ……………………………………………………………………………………

Page 73: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

D

…………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………

Snacks………………………………………………………………………… …………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………

Lunch…………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

Snacks……………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

Dinner…………………………………………………………………………

…………………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

Snacks…………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

……………………………………………………………………………………

Total energy (kacl) ………… CHO (g) ………., Protein (g) …….. Fat (g)

………….

Hb (g/dl) ………… Albumin (g/dl) ………. ALP (U/L) ……….. ALT (U/L)

………

AST (U/L) ………………….. (All these measures from the record)

Page 74: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

E

Appendix 2

General instructions given to the patients

. A diet most suitable for liver cirrhosis patients would be:

high in carbohydrate and proteins, low in fat and fortified with

B-complex vitamins and fat soluble vitamins.

1. Increased energy at 50-75% above usual

requirements if malabsorption is present.

2. Diet should provide 1-1.5 g of high quality protein /kg body

weight the protein found in lean meat, poultry (chicken no

skin), or fish , Egg whites , low fat yogurt and skimmed milk

cheese , salmon and tuna.

3. Methods of cooking are: either boiling, grilling or use oven.

4. If steatorrhea is present should restrict fat, if sever steatorrhea

add fat - soluble vitamin, omega 3 fatty acids should be

included such as fish and fish oil.

5. Supplement diet with complex vitamin ,vitamins C and K

,zinc ,and magnesium through foods or supplement .Food rich

in vitamin C sweet red papers and sweet green papers guavas ,

dark green leafy vegetable (Swiss chard),Kiwifruit, broccoli,

strawberry, orange , lemon , grapefruit, green peas, Tebaldi,

Vitamin K reach in fresh and dry parsley, beet, olive oil, pear.

Zinc reach in sea food, beef and lamb wheat germ beans.

6. Adequate Carbohydrates: to spare protein

Carbohydrates are found in breads, cereals, grains (rice, oats),

starchy vegetables (potatoes, corn, peas), and biscuit

7. Reduce salt and avoid salty food , such as canned food , table

salt , chips , pickles , olives and white chees as much to

protect

Page 75: Dietary Adequacy and Patient Meal Satisfaction in Liver Cirrhosis …repository.ribat.edu.sd/public/uploads/upload/repository... · 2016-04-23 · 1.2 Statement 0f problem In the

F

yourself from body fluid retention , low sodium intake 2-4 g is

recommended with ascites .

8. You can use lemon and spices to add taste to your food 9. Small frequent meals and snack 3 time per day.

10. If esophageal avarices, use soft, low fiber.

11. Stop alcohol.


Recommended