8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

1/32

Vol -VII January, 2012

Part-I

IMPORTANT CASE LAWSIMPORTANT CASE LAWS

Compiled by

Tamil Nau Stat! Jui"ial A"a!my

C#!nnai $ 2%

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

2/32

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

3/32

INDEXINDEX

S. NO.S. NO. IMPORTANT CASE LAWSIMPORTANT CASE LAWS PAGE NO.PAGE NO.

1 Supreme Court - Civil Cases 01

2 Supreme Court - Criminal Cases 07

3 High Court - Civil Cases 13

4 High Court - Criminal Cases 22

i

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

4/32

TABLE OF CASES WITH CITATIONTABLE OF CASES WITH CITATION

SUPREME COURT CITATION OF CIVIL CASES

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE CITATION PAGE NO.

1 Mangluram Dewangan Vs Surendra Singh !rs 2011 "#$ C%C 214 1

2 &ana' Dulari Devi (nr Vs )apildeo *ai (nr 2011 C+& 33# *,& 2

3 *amrameshwari Devi and !rs Vs irmala Devi and !rs 2011 C+& 4#1 (.& 3

4 ational +nsuran/e Co .td Vs Sham Singh and !rs "2011$ M.& 1 "SC$ 4

Sua Singh (nr Vs Davinder )aur (nr 2011-4-.5 #10

# Mathai M 6ai'eda Vs C) (nton 2011-4-.5 #1

7Ven'ata/halam C Vs (it'umar C Shah and !rs (nd 8ar Coun/il o9 +ndia VsSana * )othari and !rs

2011 "#$ C%C 771 #

Himani (llos .td Vs %ata Steel .td "2011$ 7 M.& 43 "SC$ #

:Sumatien Maganlal Manani V "dead$ .*s Vs ;ttam/hand )ashiprasadShah and (nr

"2011$ 7 M.& 1432 "SC$ #

ii

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

5/32

SUPREME COURT CITATION OF CRIMINAL CASES

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE CITATION PAGE NO.

1 *aghuvansh Dewan/hand 8hasin Vs State o9 Maharashtra (nr 2011 "#$ C%C 22 7

2 +nderit Singh

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

6/32

HIGH COURT CITATION OF CIVIL CASES

S.NO CAUSE TITLE CITATION PAGE N1 Magaraan C Vs %he Distri/t Colle/tor= Vellore Distri/t= Vellore and (nr 2011 "#$ C%C 140 13

2 C*6 "6D$ o 32 o9 2011 >- S Srinivasan Vs - *

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

7/32

HIGH COURT CITATION OF CRIMINAL CASES

SL.NO.

CAUSE TITLE CITATION PAGE NO.

1Mahala'shmi Vs State o9 %amilnadu rep Deput Superintendent o96oli/e= Maduranthagam and !rs

"2011$ 4 M.& "Crl$ 2 22

2Via and !rs Vs State represented +nspe/tor o9 6oli/e= (ll 5omen 6oli/eStation= %amaram= Chennai and (nr

"2011$ 4 M.& "Crl$ #0: 22

3 *amaee and (nr Vs

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

8/32

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

9/32

2011 (6) CTC 214

Ma!"#$a% D&'a!a

VS#$&$a S*!+ , O$

C-& - C*/*" P$-$& 103 ( - 103) S&5*- 104 O$&$ 22 R#"& , (2) O$&$ 4 R#"& 1(7) 8A9a5&%&5 8 W+&5+&$ a -$&$ - T$*a" C-#$5 $&:&5*! a A;;"*a5*- *"& #&$ O$&$ 22 R#"& 9< ;&$-"a*%*! 5- 9& "&!a5&& #&$ W*"" - P"a*5* a -&=#&5"< *%**! S#*5 * a9&& - a< "&!a" +&*$ *a;;&a"a9"& &$&& -$ -5 8 H&" - A;;&a" * ;$-/*& a!a*5 -$&$ #&$ O$&$ 22 R#"& , &*5+&$ #&$S&5*- 104 -$ O$&$ 4 R#"& 1 8 W+& a -$&$ * ;a& #&$ O$&$ 22 R#"& , *%**! a A;;"*a5*-9< a ;&$- "a*%*! 5- 9& L&!a" R&;$&&5a5*/& - !$-# 5+a5 +& * -5 L&!a" R&;$&&5a5*/& a -&=#&5"a& - 5+& -%;"a*5 a *#& #%%- +#9a -#!+5 -$ =#a+*! 5+& -%;"a*5a a a9#& - 5+& ;$-& - 5+& C-#$5 '+*+ 'a $&*5& 9< 5+& '*& 8 W+& 5+& H*!+ C-#$5 *%*& 5+&;&5*5*- +#9a *"& SLP 8 Pa$5*& 5-- 9< 5+&*$ 5a 8 H&" '+& a -%;&5&5 D*5$*5 C-#$5 +a !$a5& a&$&& - */-$& 5+& Ma!*5$a5& '+*+ 'a "-'&$ * $a7 -#" -5 *!-$& 5+& a%& a 5a7& -!*>a& - 5+&-%;"a*5 8 W+*"& $a# /*5*a5& 5+& -$&$ -95a*& $-% 5+& C-#$5 5+& ;a$5< '+- 'a *5$#%&5a" -$ a9&55& 5+&$a# -#" -5 !&5 $&"*& $-% 5+& C-#$5 9< a""&!*! #+ $a# 8 A 5+& D*5$*5 #!& +a a"$&a< !$a5& */-$&a *5 $&%a*& * -$& '*5+-#5 &55*! a*& 5+& a%& 9< a;;$-;$*a5& ;$-&&*! ;a$5< -#" -5 "-!& a-%;"a*5 9< *!-$*! *5 8 O$&$ - a -%;&5&5 C-#$5 -#" -5 9& &5 a*& a /-* * -""a5&$a" ;$-&&*! 8C-%;"a*5 'a +&" a a a9#& - 5+& ;$-& - 5+& C-#$5 a 'a &5 a*& '*5+ "*9&$5< 5- 5+& '*& 5- +a""&!&5+& &$&& - */-$& * a;;$-;$*a5& ;$-&&*! 8 A;;&a" 'a a""-'&.

A%**5$a5*- - #5*& 8 F$a# 8 O$&$ 8 O*& 8 E&5 8 W+&$& a ;&$- !&5 a -$&$ -*& 9&55& N-5**a5*- * a%**9"& * &/*&& 8 Ga>&55&N-5**a5*- * ;#9"* -#%&5 a a%& a 9& 5a7& :#**a" -5*& a5 a< 5*%& 9< C-#$5 -&$&.

2011 () CTC 623

Ma$a;;a G-#&$ a O$V

C+&*%a"a* G-#&$ (D*&) a O$

T$a&$ - P$-;&$5< A5 1332 (4 - 1332) S&5*- 2 8 D-5$*& - L* P&& 8 C P"a*5* ;#$+a& 1+a$& * #*5 ;$-;&$5< $-% N , ;&*! S#*5 -$ S;&** P&$-$%a& *"& 9< M D&&a5 * $&;&5 - #*5;$-;&$5< 8 S#*5 *"& 9< M 'a *%*& 8 P&*! F*$5 A;;&a" N , a!a* -" 5+&*$ 1 +a$& * a/-#$ - M

8 N , *"& C-%;$-%*& M&%- a"-!'*5+ M a A;;&a" 'a *%*& a a!a*5 N , 8 C P"a*5* 'a-5 ;a$5< 5- C-%;$-%*& M&%- a -;;-& C-%;$-%*& M&%- &5&$& 9&5'&& +* /&-$ a M a -""#*/&

8 C ;"a*5* *"& S#*5 -$ Pa$5*5*- "a*%*! 1 +a$& - P"a*5* a!a*5 D&&a5 8 W+&5+&$ -%;$-%*& &$&&

;a& 9&5'&& ;a$5*& '*5+-#5 -&5 - 5$a&$&& ;&&&5& "*5& '*"" 9* - 5$a&$&& ;&&5 &"*5& '+&5$a&$&& ;&&&5& "*5& * a"- ;a$5< 5- S#*5 8 W+&5+&$ ;#$+a& 9< C P"a*5* ;&*! S#*5 -$ S;&**P&$-$%a& '-#" +*5 9< D-5$*& - "* ;&& -$ -5 8 H&" * 5$a&$&& ;&&5 &"*5& * -5 ;a$5< 5- S#*5 * a+*H*# A-;5*- a Ma*5&a& A5 (3 - 16) S&5*- 13() 8 S#*5 -$ %a*5&a& 8 W*& !#*"5< -

*&$5*- a $#&"5< 8 Ma*5&a& a'a$& 9< "-'&$ C-#$5 8 A'a$ - %a*5&a& 9< C-#$5 9&"-' a-5 9&-# a#"5 '*5+ 8 S&- a;;&a" *%*&.

RATIO DECIDENDI@ A '*& '+- * !#*"5< - &&$5*- -$ $#&"5< +-#" -5 9& %a& 5- #&$ -$ 'a5 - %a*5&a& * +& * -5 +a/*! &-#!+ '+&$&'*5+a" 5- %&&5 +&$ $&a5#$& -%-$5.

2011 (6) CTC 4

Ma

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

29/32

9&*! $&5-$& #"& 5+&$& * -%&5+*! - $&-$ 5- +-' -5$a$< 8 W+& %a* RCOP * $&5-$& 5- *"& S&5*-11 (4) P&5*5*- a"- 5a $&5-$&.

Ta%*" Na# B#*"*! (L&a& , R&5 C-5$-") A5 160 (T.N. A5 13 - 160) S&5*- 11(4) 8 P$-&&*!9&-$& 5+& A;;&""a5& A#5+-$*5< 8 S5a< !$a5& 9< A;;&""a5& A#5+-$*5< a a"- %a& a9-"#5& '-#" -5 9a$ 5+&A;;&""a5& A#5+-$*5< $-% &5&$5a**! a A;;"*a5*- #&$ S&5*- 11(4).

Ta%*" Na# B#*"*! (L&a& , R&5 C-5$-") A5 160 (T.N. A5 13 - 160) 8 E*- 8 P$a5*& aP$-$& 8 A -$&$ ;a& a a -&=#&& 5- a*"#$& - T&a5 5- -%;"< '*5+ -*5*-a" -$&$ #&$ S&5*-

11() * a -5&5& -$&$ a -5 a &;a$5& -$&$ 8 E*! C-#$5 &5*5"& 5- ;$-&& '*5+-#5 -$&$*! -5*&a -5&%;"a5& #&$ O$&$ 21 R#"& 22(1) CPC a a%&& 9< Ma$a H*!+ C-#$5 A%&%&5.

La' - E*- 8 D&"*/&$< - %-/a9"& **& 5&a5& ;$&%*& 9< 9a*"* 5- La"-$ a 7&;5 #&$"-7 a 7&< * a $--% a5&$ &*- - a 9- 9< La"-$ 8 W-#" -5 $&&$ -&"*/&$< - /aa5 ;-&*-

8 H&" &"*/&$< - ;-&*- ;$-;&$.

FFFFFFFFFFFFFF

21

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

30/32

(2011) 4 ML (C$") 32

Ma+a"a7+%*

VS5a5& - Ta%*"a# $&;. 9< D&;#5< S#;&$*5&&5 - P-"*& Ma#$a5+a!a% a O$

I*a P&a" C-& (4 - 1360) S&5*- 02 43A 8 D-'$< P$-+*9*5*- A5 (23 - 161) S&5*- 4 8 C-&- C$*%*a" P$-$& 1 (2 - 14) S&5*- 401 8 R&/**- a!a*5 a=#*55a" 8 S-;& - 8 D&a5+ - '*& *%a5$*%-*a" +-%& '*5+* %-5+ - %a$$*a!& 8 O# 5- &;"a* a#& - &a5+ - &&a& #;- +#9a15A#& 8 D&&& &;"aa5*- - &a5+ 9< #**& #& 5- $-'*! * '&"" a"**& 9< %&*a" &/*&& 8 P-5M-$5&% &$5**a5& $&/&a" &&a& *& - a;+

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

31/32

*"& 21 - C-5*5#5*- - I*a (10) 8 A #+ a;;"*a5*- #&$ S&5*- 432 - C-& %a*5a*a9"& 8 I%;#!&:#!%&5 &5 a*& 8 Ca& 5$a&$$& 5- -%& -5+&$ C-#$5.

RATIO DECIDENDI@ I /*&' - S&5*- 14 - C$.P.C. 5+& -$a" a$!#%&5 a$& %aa5-$< a 5+& '$*55& a$!#%&5-#" 9& *"& * #;;-$5 - 5+& -$a" a$!#%&5 9&-$& -"#*! *5 a *5 * 5+& #5< - 5+& C-#$5 -5 +&a$ 5+& -$a"a$!#%&5 - 5+& a#&.

2011 () CTC 626

Ra%a

8/11/2019 Digest of Case Laws TN Judicial Academy

32/32

(2011) ML (C$") 30

L*!a% L*!a#$a*V

I;&5-$ - P-"*& S#&$a% P-"*& S5a5*- a